[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Argevollen and IBO were the last nails in the coffin for the
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /m/ - Mecha

Thread replies: 85
Thread images: 6
File: i-cant.png (820 KB, 1600x900) Image search: [Google]
i-cant.png
820 KB, 1600x900
Argevollen and IBO were the last nails in the coffin for the real robot genre.

Nip audience doesn't give a fuck about military series anymore.

Super robots are the new hot shit, again.

It's a cycle.
>>
>implying Japan has given a shit about MUH REAL VS SUPER bullshit since the mid 90's
>>
So what are the newest and hottest super robot shows
>>
At least wait until IBO is over before you assume Sunrise will go full-on Kyoryuger.
>>
>>13690797
They don't give a shit because we've only been getting crap series lately, especially Argevollen and IBO.
>>
>argevollen and IBO
>real
>>
>>13690828
>real
>>
Thank God. Maybe we can get some more fun shows and all the tryhard elitist who only watch childrens cartoons for blood and "grit" will fuck off and take their shallow boring characters with them.
>>
>>13690851
Nope. All the kids are going to turn off the TV and start changing their grandparents bedpans.
>>
>>13690797

The are not failing because they are real robot. They are failing because they just are not very good.
>>
Do seinen and mecha really go together? Because I feel like that's the only way to get a good real robot show/manga.
>>
>>13690797
>Nip audience doesn't give a fuck about military series anymore.
Or maybe they are just boring.
Make another VOTOMS or Dougram and maybe people will get interested again in the genre.
>>
Those filthy manchildren REEEEEEEEE
>>
>>13690797
>>Argevollen and IBO were the last nails in the coffin for the real robot genre.

>>Nip audience doesn't give a fuck about military series anymore.

Macross Delta coming out soon.
Gundam having been ranked in the top 10 for decades.

Yeah, tell me again about how they're failing.
The only fail I see here is this troll thread

/thread
>>
>>13690812
every new mecha show is pretty much a super robot show
>>
>>13691053
Only nerds watch Macross for the real robot stuff. Normies watch it because of the music and the romance.
>>
>>13691053
Macross is a super robot series. If it was real robot, it wouldn't have the stupid singing.

>Gundam having been ranked in the top 10 for decades.
Which is hardly a real robot series anymore, since most of its successes were thanks to super robot influences. For example, SEED's director was a great tier super robot director.

IBO is failing because it got that boring military look.
>>
The super robot genre has taken on a new form. It's now the super robot musume like RGZ and Symphogear.

The super robot genre has always been the major robot genre. It got the action, the drama; everything normal human beings care about.

The real robot phenomena was always a counter-culture tacticool alternative to those normal things, focusing on the militaristic applications and technical specs of these robots that appealed mostly to /k/ nerds.

Gundam always straddled the line between the two, having the drams of supers, and the nerdy aspects of reals.
>>
>>13691206
>boring military look.

ha just like real life

no need to prove it with your burger army pictures
>>
>>13691206
The singing has literally nothing to do with the robots themselves, you idiot. No, not even in 7.
>>
>>13691218
Wikipedian pls go.
>>
Fucking Fafner is more realistic than Argevollen and IBO and it's got giant glowing mind reading aliens and all the robots have super powers now
>>
File: vomitthefrog.gif (752 KB, 320x240) Image search: [Google]
vomitthefrog.gif
752 KB, 320x240
>>13691218
>It's now the super robot musume like RGZ and Symphogear.
>>
>>13690797
Does Fafner count as real or super?
>>
>>13690797
>IBO
>real robot
>>
>>13691265
Fafner counts as a SCIENCE-type
>>
>>13691206
>IBO is failing because it got that boring military look
IBO is failing because of many reasons.
>>
>>13691345
No, the kids just don't like my SERIOUS clown colored robots for adults. It has nothing to do with writing or animation quality.
>>
>>13691358
What do the kids like anyway?
>>
>>13691376
Youkai Watch.
>>
>>13691379
Kids suck.
>>
>>13691379
This is basically admitting that mecha shows aren't for kids anymore and that they should not be taken into the equation from the beginning. With one look at IBO, who in their right state of mind would think the show was made to appeal to kids in any way whatsoever?
>>
>>13691400
It doesn't really have anything more objectionable than the average prime time shounen shit. If anything it's a step back from a lot of older Gundam series.

And it's a toy commercial.
>>
>>13691409
>it's a step back from a lot of older Gundam series
this is much happening across the industry though isn't it? at least when it comes to thematic violence
>>
>>13691265
I've felt that it was real, then added a super to the roster once Sein showed up.

After Exodus ep. 7 it went full super.
>>
>>13691379
It's just Hino's latest flavor of the month, they'll flock to something else once that cash cow gets milked really fast.
>>
>>13690797
>super robots are the new hot shit again
ok so where the fuck are they then
>>
>>13691576
every mecha show these days (with few exceptions) is a super robot show
>>
>>13691584
yeah ok can we please fuck off with the
>gundam never loses its a super
tier definition
where are the god damn chest lasers
>>
>>13691586
chest lasers don't make a super. you were brainwashed by dynamic robots.
>>
>>13691595
I hope you realize how ridiculous that statement is.
>>
>>13690797
>Argevollen
>Super
We must have seen very different shows.
>>
>>13690797
>Argevollen and IBO were the last nails in the coffin for the real robot genre.
>Argevollen
>real robot genre
We must have read different posts.
>>
>>13691595
>it's ok when AMURO shouts weapon names!
>>
>>13691717
Argevollen's the closest we've had in years,even the main mech isn't too overpowered.
It's only advantages are speed which the pilot trades his sanity for and some psuedo psycommu system to let you remote control drone mechs.
otherwise the mecha in the show we pretty low on the powerscale,the main one would probably have trouble with a few zakus
>>
>>13691717
Argevollen is nearly as real as you can get. Nothing magical about it other than the quasi mindreading interface that only improves reaction time.
>>
>>13691376
Kids : Yokai Watch
Teenager : One Piece
Manchildren : LN adaptations/Idol anime
Middle Aged : Detective Conan and maybe mecha anime
Old men : Sazae-san
>>
>>13691888
Who's watching Gundam then?
>>
>>13691929
Middle aged and certain manchildren. Maybe a few teenagers too.
>>
>>13691936
>Maybe a few teenagers too
Must be those IBOfags posting illegally on 4chan.
>>
>>13691951
Well /v/ average age is 17, so you must be right.
>>
>>13691191
I don't know what Macross Delta is, but it isn't a super robot. I only know about two mecha shows, one is about mecha cops, and the other one seems to be typical "guy gets pulled into a war" scenario. The last super robot show I can think of... is aquarion logos which just finished so that invalidates my point.
>>
>>13692159
> I only know about two upcoming mecha shows
>>
>>13690797
SnK and Fafner were good.
>>
>>13691376
Japan likes cute things. Seriously this has always been the case.

Cute mascots, cute girls, cute mecha.

Everything has to be cute.
>>
File: 1413603687087.png (276 KB, 668x618) Image search: [Google]
1413603687087.png
276 KB, 668x618
>>13692280
G-Self is cute. CUTE.
>>
>>13692232
>SnK
Which one?
>>
File: Dunderbolt.jpg (13 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
Dunderbolt.jpg
13 KB, 480x360
>>13690797
>>
>>13692232
Fafner is Super though, so I'm not quite sure what your point is
>>
>>13691400
Anyone that isn't a delusional manchild, probably.
>>
>>13690797
Fafner made me give a shit about the NUNS pilots, which was basically 5 grunts and a Casval. Also, robots were never real, kek.
>>
>>13691047

I'm actually thinking of watching VOTOMS for the first time soon, because I think the Abnormal Survivor concept is interesting and radical.
>>
>>13694257
You might want to check Gasaraki out as well.
>>
>>13692159
There was Doamaiger, but I dunno if that should be classified as anything other than "CHEF".
>>
>>13690797
>Nip audience doesn't give a fuck about military series anymore.

Dude, Thunderbolt JUST aired.
>>
>>13690797

>>child soldiers getting shot in the head by adults in the first episode

>>still not gritty and "adult" enough for /m/

lol ok
>>
>>13691206
>Macross is a super robot series. If it was real robot, it wouldn't have the stupid singing.

All the mecha in Macross has always been "real", the singing/music element of the series has nothing to do with the robots, it would be the same show even if you removed the mecha entirely.
>>
>>13690797
Thunderbolt will help keep real robot alive.

Argevollen and IBO's problem is THEY'RE KIND OF SHIT.
>>
>>13694606
Violence by itself isn't adult or gritty. Bringing up things like bio-fuels, forced body modification, child soldiers, and private militaries as themes without adequately exploring the subjects or taking a stance on them is shallow.
At least the mecha fights are enjoyable, and that's why we watch Gundam, right?
>>
>>13694606
that's not edgy, that's rude

even fucking MD Geist lets his preys finish their last word
>>
Is the rating really that bad? Even if it was full of cute girls?
>>
>>13695443
For it's timeslot it's pretty bad and the demographics are all over the place. IBO might have been better as a late night show.
>>
I want something like Shin Zambot 3.or any super robot with kids protags.
When will Tomino save mecha anime again?
>>
>>13694802
I think that guy he snuck up on and stabbed in the temple might have had a few more things to say.
>>
>>13690797
>Argevollen
>not Aldnoah Zero.
>>
This thread is gayer than two dudes slapping dicks together.
>>
>>13697688
So its super /m/?
>>
>people still dont know what makes a show super or real
Jesus christ
>>
>>13698861
>People still don't realize that they don't really mean anything definitive and are just terms used to market a robot to different groups.
>>
>>13690797
>again
>>
File: 004.jpg (181 KB, 640x927) Image search: [Google]
004.jpg
181 KB, 640x927
FUMITAN
ThanksOkada
>>
>>13700114
I don't think she's responsible for character designs, is she??
>>
>>13700121
She made the shotas liking Fumitan instead Atra
>>
File: 026.jpg (262 KB, 640x930) Image search: [Google]
026.jpg
262 KB, 640x930
>>13700114
>Shotas fucking Kukdelia and Fumitan
>Ollder guys Fucking Atra and Takaki
>>
>>13700131
ohh right
Thread replies: 85
Thread images: 6

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.