What are your 10/10's?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /m/ - Mecha
You are currently reading a thread in /m/ - Mecha
What are your 10/10's?
>>13599465
war in the pocket was pretty average, it just looks good in comparison to the rest of gundam.
0080 transcends its genre.
War in the Pocket is shit. I can suspend my disbelief just fine but to think some retard with the help of a little kid secretly repaired a Gundam is hard to swallow. The girl is barely present so I don't get her popularity and when the retard dies doing something retarded I just don't give a shit. What a terrible OVA with an insufferable cast.
>>13599478
>pretty average
>0080
Cowboy Bebop
Eureka SeveN
GITS: SAC + 2nd Gig
SDF Macross
War In the Pocket
Unicorn
Evangelion
Gurren Lagann
>>13599487
its no 10/10 thats for sure
>>13599484
>a Gundam
I have no 10/10s.
However, I consider 0079, 0080, Zeta, X, SEED, and 00 to be 9/10s.
Do You Remember Love?
Encounters In Space
The Big O season 1
>>13599507
God dammit, a mech, a Zaku. You know what I mean
>>13599465
I can see this thread going places
Not gonna lie, 0080 is one of my favorites. Though, it's one I don't feel like watching again.
>no spic meme pls
Getter Robo manga
Victory Gundam
Rahxephon
Gunbuster/Diebuster
>>13599465
/m/en, we watch this show every Christmas. Of course we love it.
>>13599538
I'm curious as to why you put V. Maybe you see something I don't see.
>>13599490
>Unicorn
That's the wrong way to spell UnicRon anon.
What do you mean by a 10/10? Do you mean a literal 10/10 anime that I consider perfect, or are near-10s, like 9.8s, good enough to be posted in this thread? Because let me tell you, most anime and most mecha anime are not 10/10.
How do you guys judge your anime anyway? On a 100 point scale, do you start by saying all anime is at 100, or a 10, and subtract from it as the series goes on and flaws become apparent? Or do you build up a score, starting at 0 and adding points as it does better and better until you reach a final score?
If you just don't watch the last couple episodes it is a 10/10
SDF Macross
Cowboy Bebop
Gundam 00 S1
Gunbuster
Honorable mentions (aka my 9/10 that I feel guilty about not having above)
G Gundam
Do You Remember Love
Macross 7/Frontier
Gurren Lagann
Gaogaigar
Zeta Gundam
10/10 doesn't mean without flaws. That's assanine. To me, 10/10's are shows that do the most good. These become my favorites and probably speak to me on a conceptual level.
There are a few things that I consider perfect 10/10. There are many that are close though.
>Gundam 00 S1:
This is a 10/10. No doubt about it. Everything, from the OP to the ED to the animation and mecha design is great. I love the way they balance the power of Gundams out with the existing world order, and while the Trinitys are a bit of a disappointment it's not enough to lower my opinion of the series.S2 squandered everything.
>Gundam 00: Awakening of the Trailblazer
A solid 10/10. Aliens in my Gundam? It's more interesting than you think! Aside from some stupid shit like Andrei getting yet more scenes, it really does a good job of going from Invasion of the Body Snatchers horror to an amazing sci-fi battle that makes use of concepts that don't date back to the 1960s like most Gundam series. I love watching it.
>Rebuild of Evangelion 1.11, 2.22:
Has there been a more perfect remake than 1.11? It's beautiful, well-animated, a good plot that doesn't yet drag you down into the madness of later Eva, and is something you can just watch again and again. 2.22 is even better, if that's possible. Rather than rehashing the anime it goes down its own path, while continuing to build on the mythos and themes of Evangelion. Unlike 3.33, it doesn't do things differently for the sake of being different, but brings you to the conclusion and thematic starting point of End of Evangelion. It's only later, with 3.33, that things really start going wrong for Rebuild.
>Planetes:
I love it. I love the plot, I love the characters, I love the artstyle and music. The only negative is ghost Hachimaki.
>Uchuu Kyoudai:
The manga is a 10/10, not the anime.
>Macross Frontier, Itsuwari no Utahime, Sayonara no Tsubasa
If you take the good parts of the movies and add them to the good parts of the series, you'd get a perfect Macross. There's just too many silly or stupid or undeveloped plot points in all three entries for any single entry to be a 10.
>>13599595
Generally speaking, a 10/10 show is anything I watch that I can immediately recommend to anybody I know even if they don't care for the genre.
9/10 shows are something that really hit home for me on an emotional level, but that I know can/will be a hard sell for others.
>>13599645
>Mobile Suit Gundam Unicorn, Episode 1
This is actually more of a 9.98 than a 10, but it's just on the cusp of being perfect. There's just something lacking and unsubstantive about it that makes it fundamentally unsatisfying to watch. Maybe it's the Audrey shit, or the fact that it just drops you into the story with no real explanations of anything. Whatever the case, the rest of Unicorn doesn't come as close to a 10 and the last episode drags the series overall to an 8.87.
>Cowboy Bebop
Yes. It's perfect. It's something anyone with taste should fall in love with instantly.
>Big Guy and Rusty
Working only off of my memory of the series, which I haven't watched in about twelve years, I think this is one of the few Western animated series to be a 10/10 for me. It's just gorgeous, with fun characters, great battles, and that retro sci-fi look that I adore.
>Ring of Gundam
This is probably the best Gundam anime ever made. It distills Gundam down to its essentials as a franchise;a slavish devotion to the original Gundam, the brownnosing of Amuro and Newtypes in general as the answers to everything, and the really pointless morals that seem to crop in every other spinoff.
>Time of Eve
One of the few series to really explore what it could mean for society to live alongside humanoid androids. Studio Rikka really did some beautiful animation here, and I'm looking forward to a return to the setting in the next twenty years.
>Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex, 2nd Gig
Both SAC series are 10/10s. SAC has a bit more of a coherent story and cyberpunk theme compared to 2nd Gig, but they both do a great job of blending gorgeous TV animation and Yoko Kanno's amazing musical score with well-written plots that keep you on the edge of your seat. The Oshii movies are kind of meh in comparison; too much psychobabble weighs down some great cyberpunk stories and beautiful animation.
>>13599595
going by your rating system i rate you rating sytem as a 7/10 rating system, which as a rating system rated by you rated system must meanits shit
>>13599817
meant for
>>13599647
0/10 posting skills
Giant Robo for me
>>13599549
its the same gundam show since 0079, and this is gonna sound weird but it's crazier yet more down to earth, it sorta feels real-er. Tomino tried to sabotage himself and came up with the best protagonist, the best usage of a mass produced robot, a better Lalah Sune and just a cast of irracional humans unlike those logical redditors fiction tries to instill on you
The only /m/anime that comes close to 10/10 for me is SDF Macross.
>>13599595
I start at 5/10 for mediocrity then move either up or down.
Anything Hackiyuki Tomino didnt touch
>>13599645
Holy shit that's some faggot tier taste anon.
>>13599684
>the fact that it just drops you into the story with no real explanations of anything.
This is why you watch 0079, zeta, ZZ and CCA before Unicorn.
>>13599879
Of all the VF-1s ever released, I find the J variant to be the sexiest.
I don't know why, but it's definitely not because of the Ichijo/Jenius livery.
>>13599465
Uhh MLAIOS, obviously.
>>13600571
>insulting MLaiOS with quantifiable scales
You didn't get MLaiOS at all, kid.
![[OZC]The Big O E04 'Underground Terror'.mkv_snapshot_17.56_[2015.10.31_11.47.06].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/YPK3uxc.jpg "[OZC]The Big O E04 'Underground Terror'.mkv_snapshot_17.56_[2015.10.31_11.47.06].jpg")
>>13600575
sry I meant infinity/10
Toward the Terra
The Day The Earth Stood Still
Planetes
Mobile Suit Gundam The Movie: Encounters in Space
Legend of the Galactic Heroes.
I think thats about it for me on /m/ related 10's.
>>13599478
It's pretty good by normal standards.
But by Gundam standards it's above and beyond anything else in the franchise.
Eureka Seven
Evangelion (TV series)
0080
08th MS Team
Zeta
SDF Macross
Gundam Build Fighters (fuck GBFT)
>>13599599
But those are the best ones.
![Megazone 23.II.1986.DVDRip.mkv_snapshot_00.25.04_[2015.07.06_23.18.03].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/dOvmVid.jpg "Megazone 23.II.1986.DVDRip.mkv_snapshot_00.25.04_[2015.07.06_23.18.03].jpg")
Megazone23.
shamblo.
>shamblo.
and ZZ
My personal 10s are all shows that I enjoyed the most. Every show has its flaws, but these are the ones that made me look past them for one reason or another:
Shin Mazinger
Gunbuster
Giant Robo OVA
Dai-Guard
Getter Robo Armageddon
>>13599490
>2nd Gig
I don't think many of what you listed are 10/10s, but 2nd Gig is legitimately awful.
>>13600879
The terrorism parts are what ruined it, it felt forced, like "oh, we need some kind of problem don't we". Until that point it was really a slice of life story, in space, which I found far better and more enjoyable.
The EVA testing for the Von Braun episodes were great though.
>>13601218
I think the terrorism attack at the end was well done actually. Mostly because of the fact that none of the things the main characters do has any effect on its outcome, which isn't something you see very often. Those episodes weren't as good as the rest of the show, but I don't think they ruined the show.
Deeper than Eva.
Patlabor TV
Turn A Gundam
Gasaraki
Maybe Tetsujin 28-Gou (2004)
>>13601112
How is 2nd GIG worse than SAC?
>>13601445
Felt too pretentious and Oshi. I'm probably exagerating though, because I haven't seen it since I was 14.
>ctrl+f
>"escaflowne"
>no results
The FUCK, /m/???
![[QTS] Patlabor On Television ep 10 (BD H264 1280x960 24fps AAC).mp4_snapshot_05.30_[2015.10.29_02.15.05].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/v1boJMq.jpg "[QTS] Patlabor On Television ep 10 (BD H264 1280x960 24fps AAC).mp4_snapshot_05.30_[2015.10.29_02.15.05].jpg")
>>13601419
Why Patlabor TV, not movie?
>>13599465
G-Reco. The best Gundam and one of the best anime I've seen.
I don't really have a 10/10 (for mecha anyway) I'm always at least a little disappointed by what I watch.
>>13600541
I'm just speculating. I really don't know why episode 1 doesn't feel perfect to me, it just doesn't. Like, it's just on the cusp of perfection but it's not there. Maybe it's because the Unicorn doesn't do squat except appear.
>>13601218
The terrorism was an integral part of the plot from episode 9. They didn't come out of nowhere. And it's pretty important in the modern day, where we have terrorists everywhere. Greenpeace and Sea Shepherd are basically the Space Defense Force lite.
>>13601945
I still get that, there was also the oppression of smaller nations (shown with the bulky EVA suit episode) and it added to the setting/backdrop. But I guess at the time of me watching it I just wanted a space SoL so bad that I just rejected the ending. Though I have legitimate problems with some of the character's motivations for their choices to become bad guys and they were just not enough/ not well written.
>>13599465
I've rated only 3 mecha as 10/10 (4 if you count LOGH)
NGE (+EoE)
Turn A
FLCL (it's awesome)
Close but no cigar 9/10
0080 war in the pocket
Gunbuster
0079, Zeta and CCA all fall out because Tomino dialogue, but i rate them in order 8,9,8
this is the 10/10 mobile suit
>>13599465
Patlabor or Dai-Guard. Something about the sheer level of comfy they provide.
>>13602091
>Zeta over MSG
>Eva over Gunbuster
>FLCL
Jesus christ anon.
>>13602105
This an has the right idea.
SDF Macross
Galaxy Express 999
Space Pirate Captain Harlock
Ergo Proxy
Ghost in the Shell
MD Geist
Space Adventure Cobra
Bubblegum CrisisHow's my taste?
>>13602215
Oh fuck forgot Outlaw Star. You just can't find anything bad about that sexy bluray it got. Well maybe that it isn't 1:1 with the manga but it's still really great.
Turn A
0080
Terra e
Gankutsuou
>>13602172
What's wrong with FLCL?
>>13602305
There's nothing terribly wrong about it but i wouldn't call it a 10/10. I wasn't very fond of Naota.
>>13601654
Gundam 0080
Cowboy Bebop
FMP Fumoffu
Macross Plus
Area 88 (the original OVAs)
The Big O
Samurai 7
>>13599645
>>13599684
>>13602327
I was just about to shitpost for liking FMP Fumoffu more than first or second season, but
>Area 88
>Big O
Cant hate you
>>13602316
That's fair enough. I wouldn't call it a 10/10 either, although I do get a lot out of it.
>>13602344
Dont get me wrong, I love FMP and TSR but they arent 100% perfect IMO. Fumoffu, even though it might lack much in terms of mecha or action, its comedy is 100% gold to me which is why I give it a slight edge.
I can tell you TSR and FMP while it might not be in that top 1%, its definitely in my top 5-10%.
Macross tv series and dyrl
Gunbuster
Planetes
Cobra
Jin-Roh
Gundam Zeta
Akira manga
Blame! manga
Appleseed manga
![[x4subs] Uchuu Senkan Yamato 2199 - 10v2 [BD Hi10 720p] [DA8C50A0].mkv_snapshot_10.01_[2015.06.27_22.34.28].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/IEHlKhk.jpg "[x4subs] Uchuu Senkan Yamato 2199 - 10v2 [BD Hi10 720p] [DA8C50A0].mkv_snapshot_10.01_[2015.06.27_22.34.28].jpg")
Yamato 2199 was amazing.
>>13601654
this post is 10/10
Now lets stop before the mental ward patients escape their way to an internet cafe and ruin the thread.
>>13599465
gunbuster
tetsujin 28 go
flcl
gundam build fighters
idk...transformers beast wars/tf animated?
>>13599538
>Gunbuster/Diebuster
My dude.
>>13603054
If only the romance had actually been developed instead of shoved in there.Akira best girl.
>>13602036
>motivations for their choices to become bad guys and they were just not enough/ not well written.
But it was mostly the same stuff you see irl,terrorists only ever have a muh ideology excuse when asked how they feel about their actions,no deep thought really goes behind it.
most people aren't that complex especially those who throw away everything to commit such acts
![[x4subs] Uchuu Senkan Yamato 2199 - 07v2 [BD Hi10 720p] [9E6DB444].mkv_snapshot_05.31_[2015.06.25_22.48.13].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/omziqtz.jpg "[x4subs] Uchuu Senkan Yamato 2199 - 07v2 [BD Hi10 720p] [9E6DB444].mkv_snapshot_05.31_[2015.06.25_22.48.13].jpg")
>>13603187
true enough, the ending gambit was easily the worst part of the show and my only real problem with it outside of aliens looking like humans but different colorsakira SECOND best
Zeta Gundam, possibly SDF Macross TV, I'm not sure about Votoms just yet
>>13602316
>There's nothing terribly wrong about it but i wouldn't call it a 10/10
Honestly it's one of the only things I'd rate at a perfect 10. It knows what it wants to be, it executes it perfectly, and it doesn't try to over-achieve.
>>13603054
yes it is totally 10/10
>>13599490
>2nd gig
>eureka seven
>unicorn
>Gurren Lagann
>Cowboy bebop
You're just trying to start arguements aren't you?
>>13603191
I actually haven't watched the last two episodes yet.
>>13603605
He doesn't seem to have done a very good job from the looks of things then.
![[HorribleSubs] Mobile Suit Gundam The Origin - 02 [1080p].mkv_snapshot_33.39_[2015.11.01_17.45.28].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/4QgCKe5.jpg "[HorribleSubs] Mobile Suit Gundam The Origin - 02 [1080p].mkv_snapshot_33.39_[2015.11.01_17.45.28].jpg")
Vision of Escaflowne
Rahxephon
Patlabor 2
GITS: Stand-Alone Complex
NGE
Gunbuster
Eureka Seven
Macross Plus
Skull Man
Cowboy Bebop
![input.m2ts_snapshot_20.04_[2015.12.02_19.25.15].png](https://i.imgur.com/d8Ki61E.jpg "input.m2ts_snapshot_20.04_[2015.12.02_19.25.15].png")
Gunbuster, Shin Getter and Zeta are the only 10/10s in existance
The Edge of Tomorrow.
Memories
Getter Robo Armageddon
Gunbuster
>>13599465
The Big O
Mobile Suit Gundam Movie III: Encounters in Space
Zone of the Enders: 2167 idolo
Turn A Gundam
Those are the only things I've seen that I would give a full 10 to, though I can thing of plenty that just fall short at a 9.
Legend of the Galactating Homos
Zeta Gaydam
BOTTOMS
Gay Force
Esgayflowne
Super Gaymensional Fortress Fagcross
Gaybuster
Gaysaraki
G(ay) Gundam
Mazingayser
Shin Mazingay
GaoGayGarEvangaylion
G Gundam
Giant robo
Gunbuster
Big O
War in the pocket
Nadesico
Tekkaman Blade
Shin Mazinger
Imagawas t28
Godannar
SDF macross
Gun X sword
Good old incomplete giant robo
![[Spork] Cutie Honey - 04 (DVD) [A9B15F4D].avi_snapshot_05.17_[2015.10.15_03.29.42].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/7DEaXvR.jpg "[Spork] Cutie Honey - 04 (DVD) [A9B15F4D].avi_snapshot_05.17_[2015.10.15_03.29.42].jpg")
>>13599465
Megazone 23
NGE
SDF Macross
Cutey Honey
Mecha sucks. I can't believe I watch this shit
>>13601462
>>13601462
How is it pretentious if the politics is so cartoonish
At least Oshii knows what he's doing, and always thinks that GitS is science fiction wrapped in cop drama, first and foremost. 2nd Gig is all over the place because too much focus on cartoonish politics
Ten outta ten, motherfuckers!
>all these NGEfags
>>13603894
>Oshii knows what he's doing
>Oshii thinks that GitS is science fiction wrapped in cop drama
>not 12th grade philosophy wrapped in science fiction
W E W
L
A
D
Legend of Black Heaven
The Big O season one (season two gets an honourable mention)
Gunbuster
Bubblegum Crisis
Black Jack Dezaki OVA
Area 88 OVA
Key the Metal Idol
Royal Space Force
>>13603619
>that look of Do Not Want on Ral.
What the fuck is she spitting out?
>>13599490
This is the worst bait I have seen on this website so far this year, here's a (You) for the effort.
>>13603894
I loved Oshii's movies and Shirow's manga but desu, SAC is my favorite.
Probably the most entertaining yet still cerebral GiTS installment.
>>13603054
>>13603191
>>13603585
Found the secondary
>>13599465
G Gundam and Outlaw Star
I miss the 90s.
Friendly reminder that Gunbuster and Zeta are shit
>>13605813
>>13602105
Actually I hate how the head tapers off to a teardrop on the back. That, and the brow on the head is too fucking low. It looks downy. It tickles my autism so badly that I actually couldn't picture getting myself the gunpla of it, even though it's totally worth the hype. I've just been thinking about what head I'd kitbash in place...
>>13607000
Give it a gundam head.
>>13605813
Okay kid, whatever you say.
Royal Space Force
Patlabor, all of it I guess
Area 88
Giant Robo
first 2 eps of 0083
Macross DYRL
Also I assume Akira counts, so that too.
>Pic related
>LoGH
>Ideon Be Invoked (only Be Invoked. A Contact and TV Series BTFO)
And the original Fafner comes close but it was somewhat confusing.
VOTOMS TV
Gundam X
Dai-Guard
Zone of the Enders: Idolo
>>13603054
I like what that they made the Gamillans better characters, and overall it's definitely a better show than the original.
However, I do mind that they downplayed Analyzer and threw in a bunch of female characters for the sake of romance and ass shots.
The relationships between Susumu and Juzo, Shima and Mamoru were kind of downplayed as well.
>>13608719
>and overall it's definitely a better show than the original.
Found the secondary
>>13608734
What's a secondary?
>>13601642
1 is good
2 is Oshii/10
3 is very comfy and honestly pretty good although even less Patlabor than 2
>>13599465
Armored Trooper Votoms TV + 80s OVAs
Gundam 0079
Getter Robo Saga
Gaogaigar TV
Space Adventure Cobra
Akira (manga and movie)
Pacific RimKamen Rider Kuuga
>>13602305
There's nothing wrong with FLCL. Idk why Production IG is remaking it. I lpersonally like Gurren Lagann and Kill la Kill more than FLCL.
>>13603605
>SAC > 2nd gig. They're both 10/10's. I'm due for a re-watch of both tho
>I love Eureka 7. It remembers love for a lot of my older favorites like MSG, SDF, and Eva; while also being an enjoyable adventure on it's own.
>Unicorn is an achievement in the Gundam franchise. I'm a huge fan of it's production and score. Unicorn praises the NT theory better than most Gundam.
>I have love for Gurren Lagann much the same as Eureka 7. Plus, I love the sakuga in gainax/trigger shows.
>Cowboy Bebop is one of the best written TV shows ever written. Not ust in anime. I love it.
Neo Ranga is the only /m/-related legit 10/10 I've ever seen, maybe alongside Gankutsuou and LoGH
>>13604920
Please go back to /a/
>>13599465
SDF Macross
Escaflowne
Bebop
Planetes
>>13599465
>0079
>Zeta
>Turn A
>Digimon Adventure
>DYRL
>Digimon Xros Wars
>>13599465
>it's an /m/ series that isn't Patlabor
the only true 10/10 /m/ to me.
Also if 0080 was only 3 episodes long, had a bunch of the music re-tweaked, and some of the logic errors fixed it would be good. But as it stands I honestly think it's painfully overrated.
>>13602105
indeed 10/10....TO BE A SWISS CHEESE!
>>13610183
How do I into Patlabor? I never know where to begin... series, ovas, movies...
![[QTS] Patlabor On Television ep 24 (BD H264 1280x960 24fps AAC).mp4_snapshot_03.43_[2015.11.30_01.12.26].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/vr6Ch58.jpg "[QTS] Patlabor On Television ep 24 (BD H264 1280x960 24fps AAC).mp4_snapshot_03.43_[2015.11.30_01.12.26].jpg")
>>13612079
1. early days ova + 3 movies
2. tv + new files ova
Tetsujin 2004
0080
The first half of 0083
Rinne no Lagrange
Megas XLR
Victory Gundam
Gunbuser
Do you remember love
War in the Pocket
Legend of the Galatic Heroes
Chihayafuru
F91 is 11/10 design.
>>13612159
F91 is star wars.
>>13612170
F91 is the sexiest piece of ass I have ever seen.
Those curves, those grills, those hidden compartments.
>>13612175
>>13612170
The first time I saw the F91's torso, I thought the design team was inspired by a car.
>>13612176
I'd like to know where Okawara came up with that part, it was a pretty big change for Gundam torso design at that time.
>>13612206
Considering the naming convention for the entirely line (Formula series and its Anaheim ripoff, the Silhouette series), I'm willing to bet it's really based off high-performance cars.
Eva and Gurren Lagann. That's it.
No show deserves a 10/10 because everything has at least one flaw
Area 88
>>13599465
Transformers the Movie
SDF Macross
Gundam 0080 War in the Pocket
The Big O
Ghost in the Shell: SACM.D. Geist
Stand aside chumps, none of these can compare to a true masterpiece.
>>13612175
It's so butterfaced though.
>>13612324
True but a 10 gives of a sign. A 10 should be used VERY sporadically though.
LotGH
Escaflowne
Berserk
Haibane Renmei
Seirei no Moribito
>>13612324
You don't truly love something until you can shit on it hard enough to be mistaken for someone who hates it.
>>13599465
Robot Carnival, Genmu Senki Leda, Cyber City Oedo 808, Wings of Honneamise, Urotsukidoji and Angel Cop.
There's many others I enjoy just as much but none of them are quite perfect.
How pleb am I?
The Big O (First Season)
Escaflowne
GaoGaiGar
GaoGaiGar FINAL
GARO (Season 1, The Animation)
Gunbuster
G Gundam
Gundam 0080 War in the Pocket
Super Dimensional Fortress Macross
Macross Plus
Transformers: Beast Wars
Transformers the Movie
Transformers G1: Season 3M.D. Geist
>>13615081
Oh, also Giant Robo. Fucking perfect and I'm usually not into Showa-era artstyle.
>>13615086
Moderately.
>>13615116
I also like VOTOMs, LoGH, and actual Brave series shit, but I probably wouldn't rewatch them unless it was with a group of friends. Most of the ones on the list I made i'd go back and rewatch every now and then.
