[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why do we call "Indo-European" languages "European"?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /int/ - International

Thread replies: 67
Thread images: 16
File: IE_expansion.png (151 KB, 450x275) Image search: [Google]
IE_expansion.png
151 KB, 450x275
Why do we call "Indo-European" languages "European"? They weren't native to Europe. They were brought by poo in loo invaders from central Asia. The true European languages were the ones the Basques, Etruscans, Sardinians, etc spoke since they were relatively unaffected by the poo migrations.
>>
>>61345628
>central Asia
That looks like Ukraine to me desu senpai
>>
>>61345628
Neolithic languages might have also originated in Anatolia or even the near east though, I doubt any of the paleolithic languages of Europe survived, even though I think some suggested Basque might even be older than the Neolithic.
>>
File: 1460067030621.png (241 KB, 2100x1525) Image search: [Google]
1460067030621.png
241 KB, 2100x1525
Because the people conquered a land reaching from India to Europe?
>>
>>61345628
I know this is a bait thread but lithuanian is as old as sanskrit
>>
File: MapUkraine.jpg (20 KB, 400x312) Image search: [Google]
MapUkraine.jpg
20 KB, 400x312
>>61345734
That's the pontic steppes. It encompasses part of Ukraine and central Asia.
>>
>>61345628
they weren't indian either. we call them that because that's where we found them. by your logic all languages should be african
>>
>>61345842
>some suggested Basque might even be older than the Neolithic.
Sources or evidence?

I find it unlikely that we will ever know
>>
>>61346277
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasconic_substratum_theory
>>
>>61346417
I knew about this but it has pretty much been debunked. The truth is that we will never know what came before, and even if some very words survived we might not be able to tell that is the case.
>>
>>61346766
Yeah I find the hypothesis a bit stretched as well but as you say it's all very speculative.
>>
File: spurdo just right.png (10 KB, 556x493) Image search: [Google]
spurdo just right.png
10 KB, 556x493
>>61345628
>Tfw you're a superior Turbo-Turanian Sumero-Mongolian and not an Indo-Eurocuck

Mother tongue in:
Sumerian: Eme-Gi
Finnish: Emä kieli
Estonian: Ema keel
Mongolian: Ekh khel
Turkish: Ana dil
Uzbek: Ona tili
Kyrgyz: Ene til
Manchu: Eniyengge gisun

>http://mek.oszk.hu/07200/07288/07288.pdf
>>
File: KHANS.png (358 KB, 714x343) Image search: [Google]
KHANS.png
358 KB, 714x343
>>61347036
>>
>>61347036
Kankermongool
>>
File: PIE.png (53 KB, 653x791) Image search: [Google]
PIE.png
53 KB, 653x791
>>61346086
>lithuanian
nice meme
>>
>>61350232
>PIE
no such thing
>>
>>61350288
Proto Indo Europeans
>>
>>61350309
No such thing
>>
>>61350364
kys autist
>>
>>61345628
could you stop making thread? It's always you sardina bastard or that other tuscan nigger who makes thread about "muh europeanness, muh we are uncucked, muh intolerance".

Cool. You're still a fugly shitskin. Fuck off subhuman.
>>
>>61345628
Original Indo-European were not Poo people but actually Aryan horsemens from Ukraine steppes and north caucasus, they just invaded India and Persia, the poo people of India were actually an inferior caste at the times.
>>
>>61350487
t. pugliese furente
>>
File: 1359681142662.png (65 KB, 393x391) Image search: [Google]
1359681142662.png
65 KB, 393x391
>>61350380
If Poles are Proto-Indo-Europeans Finns, Hungarians and Turks are Sumerians
>>
>>61345628
that's the 'Indo' part you fucking dipshit
>>
>>61350587
Nobody gives a shit about memes people like yours.

the only important ethnicity is the western european, is opinion IS A FAR more important than meme peoples.
>>
>>61350770
omelette au fromage
>>
Feels good man
>>
>>61350232
Nice meme, meme.
>>
>>61345628
>poo in loo invaders
But they invaded poo in loo
>>
>>61345628
I do Europeans orginatef from Samara Russia, that is whithin Europe

Stop being butthurt about your med heritage OP
>>
File: 1456516945933.png (25 KB, 650x650) Image search: [Google]
1456516945933.png
25 KB, 650x650
WE WUZ PROTO-INDO-EUROPEANS AND SHIET
>>
>>61352486
Irish are actually meds who were VIKINGED
or cimmerians like Conan.
>>
>>61350587
Sumerians weren't slanty-eyed and didn't have blue eyes and light blond hair.

Read less turanist crap websites.
>>
>>61353347
No

Very ancient Irish were meds, but they were conquered by an indo european group that we're are all related to now. This indo european group was GAEL'D. then VIKING'D, tean NORMAN'D, then ANGLO'D
>>
>>61353435
>says the guy speaking to skeletons
>>
>>61353834
what did he mean by this
>>
>>61353755
so if you put out the germanic norse shit, Irish are literally like spaniards? mostly northern spaniards?
anyway the peoples of the atlantic coast are all more or less related, they are some breed of dark haired or brown haired white people with fair eyes colours, and mostly tall, with originally some celtic or pre-celtic culture for ancestries.
>>
File: blue eyes Sumerian statues 05.jpg (52 KB, 640x305) Image search: [Google]
blue eyes Sumerian statues 05.jpg
52 KB, 640x305
>>61353435
>didn't have blue eyes
>>
File: Colin_Farrell.jpg (264 KB, 852x1222) Image search: [Google]
Colin_Farrell.jpg
264 KB, 852x1222
>>61354118
Yes, there are plenty of Irish who look exactly like Spaniards.
>>
>>61354118
No, again, we are mostly related to the early bronze age invaders. We certainly have deep a connection with other west european atlantic groups who share ancient med farmers and ancient west european hunter and more recent celtic ancestry but evidence points to us being essentially the same as Bronze age invaders around 2000-1500bc. I'm not denying deep connection with places like Galicia in Spain, but it isn't that significant
>>
>>61354242
Could be just decoration. Egyptians didn't have red skin either.
>>
>>61354277
No read this>>61354313. There is a connection but people exaggerate it. Colin Farrell could look like your typical handsome irishman if he had a lighter phenotype, he just has remnants of a few older genes that give him a swarthier phenotype. Europeans arent very gentically diverse anyway, but we are more related to other north europeans than spanish although we have clear ancient connection to the area
>>
>>61354242
>archeologists find anime
>the Japanese must have had rainbow hair
>>
>>61354392
I dont believe so. Ancient Sumerian statues found in a set both have the blue eye inlays and black ones together. Also, the people who are believed to be higher ranking priests in the set do not necessarily have the blue inlays so it means they were given to some for other reasons than simply aesthetics
>>
>>61354242
OH TTHAT MEANS THEY WERE FINNS XDDDD

Even though Finns are described to not hold any form of civilization by every possible non-turanist crap source.
>>
>>61354569
It's unlikely for them to have had light eyes at a significant rate. The genes for light eyes weren't present in that area.

>Also, the people who are believed to be higher ranking priests in the set do not necessarily have the blue inlays so it means they were given to some for other reasons than simply aesthetics

Why not? The different decoration could be just to denote that they were of a higher rank.
>>
File: 1445898158919.jpg (144 KB, 729x793) Image search: [Google]
1445898158919.jpg
144 KB, 729x793
>>61354657
Nordic sagas tell of Finnish kings from which most Scandinavian royal dynasties descend from.
>>
>>61345628
indo-european languages are adopted by the descendants of incas, aztecs, mayans, australian aborigines, bantus
modern indians are simply adopters of a language group originating somewhere near the caspian.
modern europeans are also adopters of this language.
the people who originated this language were neither indian or european.
>>
>>61350587
Proto-Indo-European exists as a reconstructed language that explains the similarities between a number of European language families. In a sense there's no such thing, but to say that the overwhelming amount of linguistic similarity across such a large area doesn't indicate a large amount of interaction, and therefore fucking, between different early European peoples is pretty stupid.
>>
>>61354880
I just told you the ones of higher rank did not necessarily have blue eyes.

Also if Ancient people from 14,000bc carried the blue eye gene then it's not a far stretch that mid easteners could have had it as well around 3000bc. In fact a study just came out on Mid east genetics and some amateur geneticists are claiming that levantines carried genes for light eyes, some people who were skeptical have recently conceded that it might be true but you can check online genetic forums if you dont believe me
>>
>>61350587
It's funny because Simo Parpola (world renowned assyrologist) is convinced uralic languages and sumerian are related.

Of course assigning any relevancy to finnish or finns is a major taboo that would cause international butthurt so no one pays him attention.

http://users.cwnet.com/millenia/Sumerian-Parpola.htm
>>
>>61355298
>muh victim complex
>muh turan

Huh, now that I think about it maybe you are related to turks
>>
File: 1384995903026.jpg (93 KB, 946x572) Image search: [Google]
1384995903026.jpg
93 KB, 946x572
>>61355150
Sardinians are basically the direct descendants of the farmers of that area and they're very dark when it comes to eye and hair color.
>>
File: PCAtest.png (115 KB, 1218x803) Image search: [Google]
PCAtest.png
115 KB, 1218x803
>>61355150
saw that as well, I'm not aware if they checked for the presence of HERC2, got any link?
>>61355696
Sardinians cluster with euro farmers not with near eastern farmers.
>>
File: 1445918491814.png (199 KB, 423x468) Image search: [Google]
1445918491814.png
199 KB, 423x468
>>61355298
>Implying I didn't know that
>>
>>61355844
>euro farmers

wut.
>>
>>61355934
anatolian farmers further mixed with european hunter gatherer, the ones who drove the expansion in Europe
>>
>>61345628
Indo means Indian
>>
>>61345628
ahhh, a proxy-finn.
>>
>>61355696
>Sardinians are basically the direct descendants of the farmers of that area and they're very dark when it comes to eye and hair color.
No they are not

If you read the new study you would learn that there were genetically distinct groups in the middle east all practicing farming, the Sardinian related people were from Anatolia, the people from the Levant were genetically distinct from them. Also Phenotype is affected by such few genes it wouldn't matter what haphazardly related modern populations looked like, it can change so quickly.

>>61355844
Go to Eupedia, the thread about the genetic structure of the first farmers. A few pages of the discussion there is people arguing over Genetikers findings that a some had light phenotypes
>>
>South West Iran
>Indo-European

kek.
>>
File: 1464983878725.png (56 KB, 1197x133) Image search: [Google]
1464983878725.png
56 KB, 1197x133
>>61355553
>turkey
>victim complex
when have we ever had a victim complex about anything?
>>
>>61355696
Sardinians have 15% light eyes
>>
>>61356406
The routine "why does everyone hate Turkey, we dindu nuffin" posts
>>
File: 1466773541128.jpg (87 KB, 640x640) Image search: [Google]
1466773541128.jpg
87 KB, 640x640
>>61357027
well then don't get baited by the half-kurd called "kamal" who keeps posting dead turkish soldiers on /tr/, dead american soldiers on /pol/ and baits people with such threads
>>
>>61345628
>pasta poo
>>
The eternal "native" dillema, how long people have to be in a place to be native to it? Are modern Europeans not native? Am I not native to my country? Are humans in general only native to the one place where the first human was born?
Thread replies: 67
Thread images: 16

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.