[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Was Hannibal black?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /int/ - International

Thread replies: 70
Thread images: 19
Was Hannibal black?
>>
File: BSang_ss10_037_123_6lo.jpg (121 KB, 626x939) Image search: [Google]
BSang_ss10_037_123_6lo.jpg
121 KB, 626x939
>>60593333
was Jesus east asian?
>>
File: boyfriends61_123_336lo.jpg (612 KB, 1200x1661) Image search: [Google]
boyfriends61_123_336lo.jpg
612 KB, 1200x1661
>>60593363
>>
WE
>>
WUZ
>>
KANGS
>>
>>60593333
According to Barbarians Rising, he was.
>>
>>60593333
Fuck no.
nice quads btw
>>
>>60593333
It doesn't matter anyway, he lost to based Fabian
>>
>>60593333
Was Obama?
>>
>>60593333
No he would have looked Tunisian.

Also this wouldn't be a good character to make black since he eventually loses to the > white man
>>
>>60594252
Are Romans white?
>>
are Egyptian blacks?
>>
>>60593477
>>60593663
>>60593744
le upvote !
>>
>>60594252
>cast a black Hannibal
>people starts whining about white pride propaganda
>cast a white Hannibal
>DUDE WHITEWASHING LMAO XD

The only solution would be casting a black Scipio ("he was called African, he must have been Black!"), or at least casting latinos as romans
>>
File: image.jpg (109 KB, 375x600) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
109 KB, 375x600
>>60594650
No
>>
>>60594805
yes

But what about the Portuguese? Are they black?
>>
>>60593333
>Was Hannibal black?

He was smart and successful. Take a guess.
>>
File: index.jpg (4 KB, 318x159) Image search: [Google]
index.jpg
4 KB, 318x159
did anyone notice blackfish?
>>
>>60593333
No, he was North African, basically a Moor.
>>
>>60596229
The mudslimes didn't invade North Africa until de VII century. The Carthaginians probably looked like darkish Greeks.

>French education
>>
File: Mommsen_p265.jpg (1 MB, 1270x1994) Image search: [Google]
Mommsen_p265.jpg
1 MB, 1270x1994
Yes, look at how negroid he looks here.
>>
File: Idris-Elba-wears-Viking-h-006.jpg (26 KB, 460x276) Image search: [Google]
Idris-Elba-wears-Viking-h-006.jpg
26 KB, 460x276
>>60596193
cracka whitewashed Black fish smdh
>>
>>60596229
Phoenicians came from modern day Lebanon. Carthage was a colony.
>>
Phoenicians were a semitic people. I can half understand their language by knowing Hebrew. HanniBal Barka means Grace of Baal from the house of Lightning.
An equivalent name in Hebrew would be HanYahu Barak (Grace of Yehova from the house of Lightning).
He probably looked like a Christian Lebanese. A Jew, Berber and even Greek and Roman would be closer than Black or Germanic.
>>
>>60595675
A french said le hahaha someone screencap this
>>
>>60596333
That bust was made centuries after Hannibal died.

>>60596373
Phoenicians who settled in North Africa mixed with Berbers. Berbers have sub-Saharan admixture. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berbers
>>
>>60596491
Because they fucked their black slaves and have so black blood. Completly irrelevant to the point.

Like arabs.

Like American.

Like any other civilization.
>>
File: berberchildwh1.jpg (85 KB, 394x380) Image search: [Google]
berberchildwh1.jpg
85 KB, 394x380
>>60596491
Berbers look whiter than modern arabs.
>>
>>60596397
>Phoenicians were a semitic people.
They were originally Semitic but they were influenced by Berbers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punic_language
> At first, there was not much difference between Phoenician and Punic, but as time went on and Carthage and its colonies lost contact with Phoenicia, Punic began to become influenced less by Phoenicia but more by the Berber languages spoken in and around Carthage by the ancient Libyans.

It's similar to Portuguese in Brazil starting out European but later becoming Indo-Negroid.
>>
>>60596620
Berbers skin color isn't different from middle-eastern one.
It's quit commong knowledge for anyone who saw a kabyle or some shit like that.
>>
File: kadaffi.jpg (163 KB, 634x530) Image search: [Google]
kadaffi.jpg
163 KB, 634x530
>>60596592
You know the typical berber looks like this.
>>
File: 5293054_Gaddafi_200_119903b.jpg (57 KB, 780x520) Image search: [Google]
5293054_Gaddafi_200_119903b.jpg
57 KB, 780x520
>>60596667
Yes. Even the inbred version after 1300 years of arab domination looks medditeranian.
>>
>>60596900
Arabs hold libya for like 1 century.

Maybe you confuse with levant/israël where it was arabic for 900 years tho. (600-1500)
>>
>>60596960
>who is aballah ibn saad
>>
>>60597019
The guy who got libya in 640.

>who is khalid ibn hamid al-zanati

Guy who broke up arabic empire in north africa ~740

Which led to my century
>>
>>60597063
Remarkable defeat.
>>
>>60597063
Anyway I guess that you are Algirian and know your history better than me. The point still stands though, Hanibal was not black or european. He was semitic with possible admixture of other medditeranian peoples, perhaps due to marring local aristocratic families or foreign rulers. But if you would ask him who he is he would tell you Phoenician.
>>
>>60595675
They're fresh off the boat from r/The_Donald. They don't know that's not cool yet.
>>
>>60596122
>Colombia
>>
>>60593333
Was shit posting in /his/ and /tv/ not enough for you? Will you ask this everywhere?
>>
>>60596122

>Hannibal Successful

Yeah, and Carthage went on to rule the Med for another six centuries and influenced every state that came after it.

Fuckin baby killing Punic savages got B U L L E D
>>
File: img-16.png (341 KB, 1580x976) Image search: [Google]
img-16.png
341 KB, 1580x976
>>60597157
- Semitic is a familiy langage, not a "race" or genetic group.
- Pheonician didn't impact the genoma of north african population obvously.

- Hannibal was born like 1000 years after first pheonician came.

If you want to know what "race" Hannibal was, and whay carthagian were, there are a lot of genetic/scientific work.
Pic related show that negroid element was about 8.33% in carthagian grave.

The conclusion is that modern day north african are same as ancient.

>>60597286
Scientific studies debunked > the they killed babies meme.
>>
File: img-21.png (255 KB, 1482x424) Image search: [Google]
img-21.png
255 KB, 1482x424
Carthagian were different from italian, syrian, spaniard etc.
>>
File: img-20.png (303 KB, 1506x483) Image search: [Google]
img-20.png
303 KB, 1506x483
>>60597342
But carthagian have the same statistics as Algerian.
>>
Roman grave in Algeria, Carthagian grave in Algeria, protohistoric grave in Algeria and modern-day Algerian have the same statistics.

Study on > 200 pop.
>>
File: img-12.png (454 KB, 1536x932) Image search: [Google]
img-12.png
454 KB, 1536x932
>>60597385
>>
File: gaddafi.jpg (71 KB, 451x586) Image search: [Google]
gaddafi.jpg
71 KB, 451x586
>>60596667
>>60596900
>gaddafi
>berber
>>
Are there people still speaking phoenician/punic in tunisia?
>>
>>60597286
Any halfway educated person in this world has heard of the Battle of Cannae 2200 years after it happened.
>>
>>60597519
my truck is loaded
>>
File: gaddai.jpg (17 KB, 192x262) Image search: [Google]
gaddai.jpg
17 KB, 192x262
>>60598225
>>
>>60594252
WE WUZ ROMANS N SHIIIIT
>>
>>60597590
No, because it was an Elite language that was replaced by latin, greek and then arabic, some people still talk the berber dialects native to the region (chaoui and jerbian), but they're very few compared to Algeria or Morocco.
>>
>>60598225
RA2 reference right there
>>
File: ChineseJesus[1].jpg (18 KB, 250x334) Image search: [Google]
ChineseJesus[1].jpg
18 KB, 250x334
>>60593363
yes
>>
carthaginians are directly descended of another semitic empire, the phoenicians

so no
>>
>>60593333
and by the way the helmet brush is purely philistine / grecian there is literally 0 percent chance that phoenicians wore it. they would have been wearing the conical bronze pattern helm

so if we are doing fake history might as well make it completely bullshit
>>
http://phys.org/news/2016-05-ancient-dna-phoenician-carthage-european.html

>A research team co-led by a scientist at New Zealand's University of Otago has sequenced the first complete mitochondrial genome of a 2500-year-old Phoenician dubbed the "Young Man of Byrsa" or "Ariche".

>Interestingly, our analysis showed that Ariche's mitochondrial genetic make-up most closely matches that of the sequence of a particular modern day individual from Portugal," Professor Matisoo-Smith says.

CARTHAGE WAS PORTUGUESE CONFIRMED

WE WUZ MERCHANTS N SHIET
>>
>>60593333
He was Phoenician
>>
Everyone knows he was white. His real name was Henry Bartholomew, a white Saxon man.
>>
>>60593333
More like a dark jew.
>>
>>60603725
Nobody wants to have only slaves as his ancestors.
They're sort of inventing a myth to make themselves feel good. It's a usual thing, for example, chechens also had some funny claims in 1990s. If I won't forget it, I can share some quotes from back then.
>>
>>60593333
We wuz Hannibals n shiet!
>>
>>60593333
WE
>>
>>60603838

share them.
>>
>>60604522
Dammit, I'm not at home right now and the book is there.
>>
File: 1439676733206.jpg (78 KB, 641x960) Image search: [Google]
1439676733206.jpg
78 KB, 641x960
Are Romanians Roman?
>>
>>60603838
if Saint Maurice could be the leader of the Roman Theban Legion in the 3rd century why are people still surprised that other blacks could have been part of Roman Society
>>
>>60595763
Or cast Vin Diesel.

[spoiler]OH WAIT[/spoiler]
Thread replies: 70
Thread images: 19

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.