[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Do Japanese people actually believe that Samurai were these medieval
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /int/ - International

Thread replies: 156
Thread images: 43
File: Samurai_with_sword.jpg (430 KB, 1275x1600) Image search: [Google]
Samurai_with_sword.jpg
430 KB, 1275x1600
Do Japanese people actually believe that Samurai were these medieval super-soldiers who could take out 100 of the enemy for every one they lost?
>>
File: Banzai.png (38 KB, 853x543) Image search: [Google]
Banzai.png
38 KB, 853x543
>>
obviously not you autist. it's the west that started the katana meme anyway.
>>
>>59024639
But if you watch anime and Japanese films they push this idea...
>>
>>59024659
wah wah wah....
>>
>>59024659
they were influenced by western ideas around it. through history, the katana was merely a side weapon.
>>
>>59024594
FACT:

Tom Cruise was the BEST and the LAST Samurai
>>
>>59024696
How about Emperor Fu Manchu?

He used it in the Battle of Hirohito Hill.
>>
It's stronger than a 13th century Crusades.
>>
>>59024952
The what now?
>>
>>59024952

LOL no.

Japanese steel was of inferior steel to European steel of that period. Japanese didn't even have proper cavalry during that period, they just rode ponies to battle and got off to fight each other.
>>
File: weebs.gif (2 MB, 387x217) Image search: [Google]
weebs.gif
2 MB, 387x217
>>59024952
"no"
>>
>>59024952
You did it bro , all the cucked western EU swallowed the bite
>>
>>59025041
Sup wannabe Arab.

Grown out that beard yet?
>>
>>59025075
Well you were my idol so i tried hard to be like you i hope you dont mind that
>>
>>59025160
If I'm your idol, you'd better start renouncing Islam asap.
>>
Stop bullying Japan
>>
>>59025366
Sorry sir i might have not recognize you , could you please take your turban off so i try a look agin ?
>>
>>59024952
Absolutely baiting
>>
>>59025025
When does that even happen in a real sword fight? It's mostly deflecting so the blade would hit at an angle, not perpendicularly like that.
>>
>>59025002
considering men on ponies conquered the largest contiguous land empire in history i wouldnt look down on them.
Also depending on the time period the samurai armies would be more than able to stand up to their european countrparts in battle.
Especially around the end of the 16th century.
They did lack in the naval game though, as seen when they fought korea.
>>
File: samurai knight.png (991 KB, 768x1150) Image search: [Google]
samurai knight.png
991 KB, 768x1150
>>59024594
why not?
>>
reminder that rapiers were banned from being taken ashore in Japan because the Portuguese were slaughtering the samurai in duels
>>
>>59025694
Mongolian horses were sturdy as fuck, Japan never had horses as good as that.

>>59025700
The bulk of their force was destroyed by bad weather, hardly a fair comparison.
>>
File: KATANAvsLONGSWORD.jpg (192 KB, 1000x700) Image search: [Google]
KATANAvsLONGSWORD.jpg
192 KB, 1000x700
>>59025025
>a """"test"""" with a kraut made """katana"""
lmao
>>
>>59024594
No, they'r seen as their upper class of the time, that's it.
>>
>>59025700
if samurai had face a regular tumen under tsubudai they would probably also had been slaugthered, he was a beast as a general.
>>59025833
still they did have their share of cavalry, not the proper war horse chargers seen in europe and the steppes though.
>>
File: mongol_kouan-01-01-01.jpg (525 KB, 2267x1829) Image search: [Google]
mongol_kouan-01-01-01.jpg
525 KB, 2267x1829
>>59025833
>The bulk of their force was destroyed by bad weather, hardly a fair comparison.
No
>>
>>59025870
You had a defensible coastline, the Poles did not.
>>
File: yumi.jpg (41 KB, 639x358) Image search: [Google]
yumi.jpg
41 KB, 639x358
>>59025025
you frogs were got raped by shitty brit longbows
>>
>>59025951
Japanese penis can never be 12"
>>
File: NanbanDo.jpg (85 KB, 278x541) Image search: [Google]
NanbanDo.jpg
85 KB, 278x541
>>59025700
The japanese samurai used fucking cheap ass steel on their weapons and armor.When the portuguese brought muskets and steel you guys drooled over that shit.You really think you'd stand a chance on an open field agaisn't mongols?

That breastplate was made with european steel,now compare it with a fucking normal samurai breatplate
>>
The undisputable best wepon is the military sabre, a western wepon
>>
>>59025932
only Hakata bay had, others didn't
>>
>>59026042
i actually would like to nominate the standard spear for that position tbqh
>>
>>59026012
it's just a cuirass for bullets.
>>
File: size.jpg (235 KB, 940x937) Image search: [Google]
size.jpg
235 KB, 940x937
>>59025989
said amerismall
>>
>>59026044
By definition coastline is more defensible than the open plains of Eastern Europe. The North European Plain is some of the flattest land on earth.

Let's see Samurai go toe-to-toe with the greatest cavalry army in history in that geography and withstand them.
>>
>>59026156
Totally a ww2 meme
>>
>>59024659
because it's fiction you fucking idiot
>>
>>59026156
REEEEE I THOUGHT ALL THE BLACKS WE HAD WOULD RAISE OUR AVERAGE
>>
I saw Daimajin man, those fuckers were huge
>>
>>59025951
>thinner arrows goes deeper

who would've thought
>>
>>59026174
I'm pretty sure that's not in the definition of coastline.
And you can't credit just the coastline for the difference in casualties. I do agree however that the outcome of the battles, and most if not all medieval battles for that matter, likely has more to do with strategy and logistics than with small differences in the weapons used by both parties.
>>
Man, humans have invented some weird fucking weapons.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UnZQDN88pbg
>>
File: Correa19.jpg (167 KB, 1040x940) Image search: [Google]
Correa19.jpg
167 KB, 1040x940
>>59026156
Good post
>>
>>59026467
Post pics of your big indio cock
>>
>>59026324
so they had better arrows as well? amazing japs
>>
>>59026381
>And you can't credit just the coastline for the difference in casualties.

Yes you can.

Geography is a massive part of battles, even today, why do you think Russia is so cagey about its western frontier?

It's a simple fact: If you put samurai on the North European plain and had them face off against a Mongolian army, they would have been fucking slaughtered.

Japanese have zero humility.
>>
>>59026515
Those are actually small katanas on the tip of a stick.
>>
>>59026600
So that's why you lost your coastline against the Romans, the Normans and the Norse?
>>
>>59026600
eastern europe had many forests, which are good obstacles to cavalry. why didn't they capitalize on it? tactics is also important qualities of capable warriors.
>>
>>59026693
Because the Mongolians were mobile enough to outmanouevre any attempt to pin them down in a fixed battle at a favorable location. Exception being when they were trying to form beachheads on coastlines, for obvious reasons.

Don't be so arrogant. Japan has nothing to compare to even small European nations in terms of material culture.
>>
>>59026685
Asides from the Normans, Britain wasn't even a polity at those times.
>>
>>59026600
>>59026760
>blaming geographical features only when the outcome of a battle is not in line with your own delusions
>calling others arrogant just for arguing with you
If the coastline is as important as you say, there wouldn't have been a single coastline conquered in all of world history you autist
>>
>>59026856
Maybe because the other occasions didn't feature the best cavalry on earth having to behave as quasi-marines?

If you can't accept that one of the flattest plains on earth is a less advantageous place to meet Mongolian horseriders than them disembarking from the coast, then I don't know what to say.
>>
>>59026892
also note that most of the army invading apan was probably chinese and korean levies.
>>
>>59026760
>Japan has nothing to compare to even small European nations in terms of material culture.

ror britain
>“In Japan, it was necessary for every man to carry a pistol; but the Japanese [with their swords] invariably got the better of every man carrying one, even when he had it in his hand… …I maintain the great fault in our swords is that they will not cut. Use them as much as you like, unless you have them specially sharpened the night before, they are useless. In the cut, our swords are useless in nine cases out of ten. The Japanese use two-handed swords; if we could use them, I should say cut by all means; for they never want a second cut.” “On Military Equipment,” Journal of the Royal United Service Institution, cited in Swordsmen of the British Empire
>>
>>59026892
Because the Yuan dynasty only employed cavalry, right?
What I'm saying is not that the coastline was unimportant, what I'm saying is that the Japanese tactics and logistics were able to capitalize on the geographic features.
Basically my point is that the swords (that we were originally comparing) are much less important than tactics and logistics.
>>
>>59026856
Calm down, bro. No need to go atomic.
>>
File: welcome-to-estonia-tallinn.jpg (555 KB, 1600x1147) Image search: [Google]
welcome-to-estonia-tallinn.jpg
555 KB, 1600x1147
>>59027056
This is Tallinn, Estonia, a tiny European country.

You're welcome to try and find a single Japanese town with as much and as varied extant historical architecture.

Japan is wonderfully efficient and impressive economically and industrially - and I have great respect for the Japanese in this regard, but its traditional culture isn't hugely impressive to me.

>>59027073
Fair enough.
>>
>>59024594
no one even tries to figure it out. maybe historyfags on 2ch and netouyos do but thats all. basically low-iq faggots tend to get into it.
>>
>>59027194
>comparing estonia and japan
are you fucking baiting us right now?
>>
>>59027250
Architecturally Europe is second-to-none, to the point even insignificant towns and cities like Belgrade have vastly more material culture than the major metropolises of other countries. Have you even been to Japan?
>>
File: dead frog.jpg (14 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
dead frog.jpg
14 KB, 480x360
>>59026208

they did ameribro
>>
>>59027194
european stone architecture might be beautiful, but it wouldn't last for a long time in japan, in which massive earthquakes are rampant.
the buildings are the product of that cold to mild climate of europe, which is in general a geologically very stable land. different climates make different architecture.
>>
Fun fact:

Mongols actually lost a large amount of their horses overseas. They got sick during the ship ride. This was a massive handicap for them after they landed.
>>
>>59024594
But jiujitsu is basically samurai arts and every MMA player is trains samurai martial arts even now.
>>no it's Brazilian one
Bjj is jiujitsu or judo concentrated ground technique and it's ground technique is came from samurai martial arts.
>>
>>59029872
Why Korea hate japan desu?
>>
>>59029872
pay reparations kimchi, koreans were part of the invader
>>
>>59030207
When Japan pay reparations to all of Asia for war crimes.
>>
>>59024594
I have not heard it.
Maybe weeaboo said it to you.
>>
File: reparations.png (141 KB, 591x717) Image search: [Google]
reparations.png
141 KB, 591x717
>>59030240
pay right now then
>>
>>59024594
enemy is also samurai.
>>
>>59030285
It's hypocritical as jap
Money has no meaning important is a
Heart.
But you japs has no heart so no mean to say to you guys
>>
you all japs and gaijins shit should do harakiri, I think
>>
>>59030324
If it has no meaning, Korea might just as well give it back.
>>
>>59030367
No need to do it. But Korea should reminded jap and blame japan to prevent next war criminal which would be do by abe.
Since they just paied and they don't have heart!!
And to be honest that money jap pays were so smoll and cheep compere what Korea lost by jap criminal occupation

So meaningless what jap do was
>>
>>59030416
wont defend any kind of jap poster but arent you that korean with a jp proxy?
if you are that proxyfagget this communication is a kinda fun thing to see.
>>
>>59030496
nah, he's just a kenmo loser pretending to be a zainichi
>>
>>59030285
Why is sweden on the list?
>>
>>59030688
Because Sweden says they did fight manly and need pay! Then we say yes sir and pay.
>>
>>59030496
I'm a Japanese who hate japan.
Why is it meaning pretending zainichi?
Is it fucked up jap nationalist logic?
What a loser netuyo are
>>
>>59030823
im not even a netouyo and usually dont give a flying shit about any kind of jap poster.
im still in doubt as to who you really are but will never talk to you again. do whatever you want.
>>
>>59031073
>don't talk to me or my tsuma's musuko ever again
>>
>>59024594
not really.
>>
>>59025025
why he was trying to SMASH with the thin sword. do SLASH. it's not the way to use Katana.
>>
most foot soldiers were impoverished ill-equipped peasants wielding farming tools and wooden spears. Of course a samurai decked out in armor and well crafted sword could kill 100s of peasants over his lifetime. Only when samurai went against each other tales of feats of heroism came into existence
>>
>>59031254
this guy seems reasonable enough
>>
File: neko samurai.png (453 KB, 655x376) Image search: [Google]
neko samurai.png
453 KB, 655x376
>>59024594
it's just a social class, but some of them fought fearlessly.
>>
おい、誰か暴れている日本人を殺せ。体格差があるのにヨーロッパ人を倒せるわけ無いでしょ?

あとアニメは作り話でありその中で侍が強いのはなんの違和感もない。

こんなこと議論するのは時間の無駄だよ。


shine NETOUYO.
>>
File: Korean School in Tokyo.jpg (73 KB, 640x429) Image search: [Google]
Korean School in Tokyo.jpg
73 KB, 640x429
>>59031352
Kim, one-way ticket to ur cunt costs less than 50USD desu.
>>
>>59031979
he's a zainichi japanese. he belongs in your cunt since he's a japo
>>
>>59032017
fuck off. you little proxy shit
>>
File: Screenshot_2016-05-05-07-48-32.png (232 KB, 1080x1920) Image search: [Google]
Screenshot_2016-05-05-07-48-32.png
232 KB, 1080x1920
>>59024594
Samurais were cucks
>>
File: hinawajyuu.jpg (279 KB, 800x1147) Image search: [Google]
hinawajyuu.jpg
279 KB, 800x1147
>>59032017
I thought his nationality is Korean (either North Korean or South).

>>59024594
in reality most useful weapons were long spears and guns instead of Katana swords.
>>
File: uwa.jpg (19 KB, 400x353) Image search: [Google]
uwa.jpg
19 KB, 400x353
>>59030416
Oh, you again.
>>
>>59032202
>Spanish cucked by Japanese

he is a Japanese descendant in Spain.
>>
いやいやいや、何か日本について批判したらすぐに朝鮮人認定とかネトウヨには脳がないのかな?

俺に返事するのに英語を使うとかお前らが日本人じゃないって自ら言っているようなもんだよ?

こんなところで恥を晒すなよネトウヨwwww
>>
File: silvafamiliabuj1.jpg (99 KB, 989x530) Image search: [Google]
silvafamiliabuj1.jpg
99 KB, 989x530
>>59032349
>A Spanish guy fucked a nip woman
>Said kid wins a world cup and 2 Eurocups for Spain
It seems that you got cucked
>>
who would win

ancient Miyamoto Musashi fresh from meditating upon Mt. Fuji with holy Shinto katana and 100% japanese silk kimono

or some smelly inbred eurocuck in shitty armor worth less that the metal used for it with a giant kebab stick of a """sword"""
>>
>>59032467
>>59032202
Samurais were cucks
>>
File: Japanese.jpg (59 KB, 330x417) Image search: [Google]
Japanese.jpg
59 KB, 330x417
>>59032434
Pedro, ur just amazingly ignorant and idiot,. Now I know why ur cunt is shit as the 3rd world.
There were no Japanese women, but there were six Japanese Samurai men sent to Spain as the members of an embassy, and they remained in Coria del Río, near Seville.catholic missionary.
>>
File: muslim_spain_dvd.jpg (16 KB, 170x244) Image search: [Google]
muslim_spain_dvd.jpg
16 KB, 170x244
>>59032493
and Spain has been cucked by sandniggers over centuries!
>>
>>59025700
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1582_Cagayan_battles
>>
File: image.jpg (120 KB, 700x397) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
120 KB, 700x397
>>59031254
But yi killed a lot of japs.
>>
>>59024659
Going by this idea one would assume that america is full of young athletic lads with tight costumes of bright colours with super-powers when in fact you are far more likely to meet with fat sloby people wearing cargo pants.
>>
File: americanarmy.jpg (53 KB, 500x341) Image search: [Google]
americanarmy.jpg
53 KB, 500x341
>>59027243
welcome to 4chan.
You could get a thread going with hundred of answers every single day by just posting this single picture.
>>
File: image.jpg (65 KB, 634x496) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
65 KB, 634x496
>>59034844
>1000 jap pirates
40 dudes with guns and Europeans weapons
>>
File: Japanese poster.jpg (27 KB, 329x509) Image search: [Google]
Japanese poster.jpg
27 KB, 329x509
ITT
>>
>>59024594

I've recently read something about rapiers being banned in Japan because too many samurais died against portuguese in swordfights or something like that.
>>
File: 1403521167658.jpg (703 KB, 2121x2209) Image search: [Google]
1403521167658.jpg
703 KB, 2121x2209
>>59026156
>no finland
Guess our feet long dongs would've intimidated everyone else to the brink of suicide.
>>
>>59032357
Ching chong ping pong kim
>>
File: 1460981098133.gif (2 MB, 427x239) Image search: [Google]
1460981098133.gif
2 MB, 427x239
mongol defeated china and korea
then raped europe
then we defeated them
your shitty knights are just shitty garbage peasants
>>
>>59025700
W-we won once..
>>
>>59035800
In reality that katana would have either shattered or bent completely.
>>
File: LeonardGSiffleet.jpg (12 KB, 200x296) Image search: [Google]
LeonardGSiffleet.jpg
12 KB, 200x296
Guys see This cool picture of a samurai
>>
Zweihanders are cooler than any other weapon.
>>
>>59037201
They must have just thrown away the cut white pork as it was no good for sushi
>>
File: 7f883d0c.jpg (33 KB, 250x414) Image search: [Google]
7f883d0c.jpg
33 KB, 250x414
SAMURAI IS STRONGEST
>>
he is ZENYA KUNII.

he won to American strongest sword man after WW2
>>
File: maeda.jpg (30 KB, 403x403) Image search: [Google]
maeda.jpg
30 KB, 403x403
he is MITSUYO MAEDA.

he never lost battle with western fighter
>>
File: samurai66-1024x568.jpg (81 KB, 1024x568) Image search: [Google]
samurai66-1024x568.jpg
81 KB, 1024x568
SAMURAI has strongest fighting skill.

and they has The strongest sword.
>>
File: five rings.jpg (10 KB, 181x279) Image search: [Google]
five rings.jpg
10 KB, 181x279
Knight is rely on armor so they didn't have fighting skills.

SAMURAI WAS FIGHT WITH OWN FIGHTING SKILLS.
>>
knight is so slow.
>>
File: 1451167128938.jpg (950 KB, 1920x1078) Image search: [Google]
1451167128938.jpg
950 KB, 1920x1078
>tfw playing Shogun 2
Otomo victory soon lads
>>
>>59025700
I had no idea the Mongols had gotten all the way to Poland. Why do Europeans downplay this huge event so much?
>>
>>59025025
Dont forget to include the part where the german sword actually shatters another sword while having nothing but a small crack.
>>
File: Otomo13.jpg (507 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
Otomo13.jpg
507 KB, 1920x1080
>>59041382
I know that feel, Deus Vult brother.
>>
Then why do my armies.of Yari ashigaru and matchlock ashigaru keep losing in Shogun 2?
>>
File: Otomo6.jpg (629 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
Otomo6.jpg
629 KB, 1920x1080
>>59041684
Use better matchlocks.
>>
>>59041382
What software did you use to do this?
>>
SHAMEFUR DISPRAY
>>
>>59041885
He drew it himself you pleb.
>>
>>59042270
Ive always wanted to know this, have Japanese gamers heard of Shogun 2? Do they like it?

or are you an westerner who moved to Japan to teach English and pursue anime.
>>
>>59041885
Dont know, found the pic on /twg/
>>
>>59030075

Brazilian ju jitsu is completely different to what the samurai used - it's more a sport than a martial art

No one in mma uses Japanese ju jitsu - some may have studied it when they were younger or gotten into martial arts through it but it's just not practical for mma
>>
>>59043001
Well japs love the movie "The Last Samurai" for some reason.
>>
File: laughing sluts.png (315 KB, 465x455) Image search: [Google]
laughing sluts.png
315 KB, 465x455
>>59025841
>slashing sword pierces armor
>weebs actually believe this
>>
>>59041627
>those fucking missionaries
They might as well have given the player tactical nukes, those missionaries are that fucking powerful.
>>
an ULFBEHRT sword could cleave through ten gooks at a time

t. historian pro
>>
>>59044759
I destroyed an entire clan by causing all their provinces to rebel. Felt godly.
>>
>>59044990
>>59044759
Whats even funnier is the fact that conquering those rebel provinces doesnt give you that much clan-fame.
With that method you can knock on Kyotos door without the Shogun even noticing.
>>
>>59041503
They got KHAN'D but are quiet about it to avoid the bantz
>>
File: VEGETABLES.jpg (23 KB, 334x354) Image search: [Google]
VEGETABLES.jpg
23 KB, 334x354
>it's a "retards argue about swords even though spears are better" thread
>>
File: 20160328202552_1.jpg (568 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
20160328202552_1.jpg
568 KB, 1920x1080
>>59047174
Nope, it became a SHOGUN 2 thread.
>>
Does no one play nobunaga 14? It's on steam in english

at least you will learn about sengoku more than tw shogun 2
>>
>>59047526
It's not a bad game but the battle system is really bad when compared to Shogun 2. Plus, managing all the officers and towns later into the game can be a real mess. It reminds me of civ 3 in the sense that's it's too detailed to work on a larger scale. I like the soundtrack though, even if it gets repetitive.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rz-0_GLjN50
>>
>>59047647
just yesterday i beat all the scenarios but you are right 95% of the time I am doing town development
>>
>>59047745
Town development takes way too long considering how little variation it actually has. The game works best when you've got a few castles, maybe a dozen at most since in that situation you can still manage things without it becoming too tedious. I love the system of individual officers and how their abilities affect battles but I wish there was a better way to manage things and a robust battle system. The only reason I ever fight the battles myself is because not doing so makes the battles last so long they just turn into attrition. I still had fun becoming shogun after starting with a custom clan that had a single fort. The events you get are nice too, but the translation seems a bit off at times.
>>
>>59048023
you know you can set vassal forces so you don't have to manage so many towns

after i take about 10 castles and surrounding fortresses i set up a force and later another so they can do the rest of the conquering for me

you just have to watch where you drop the best officers and maybe set up another force for your crap officers
>>
>>59048583
Yeah I do that but there's all kinds of problems with the vassals. They can only invade shit they share borders which can fuck things up when you've got allies or vassal clans.
>>
>>59026208

>falling for the bbc meme

all the africans in america are mixed.
>>
File: Otomo12.jpg (657 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
Otomo12.jpg
657 KB, 1920x1080
>>59047340
>being a heathen

YOU CAN RUN BUT YOU CANT ESCAPE HELL
>>
>>59049261
yea they make ally clans on their own but if you make another vassal that vassal will attack the ally of your other vassal, it is hilarious
>>
>>59032434


ESPANHOLADO
Thread replies: 156
Thread images: 43

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.