[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
What if Great Britain and Ireland weren't islands like in
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /int/ - International

Thread replies: 106
Thread images: 9
What if Great Britain and Ireland weren't islands like in Mesolithic 8,200 years ago?
>>
>>58262269
Ther's some youtube videos of fishing trawlers hauling mammoth tusks out of the English channel. The world was a really different place back then.
>>
>>58262356
Mammoth's rightful clay.
Geez I hate humans now.
>>
>>58262269
We would've lost a lot of oil and gas
>>
Germany would have won WWII
>>
>>58262269
>Brittany
We country nao
>>
> Doggerland
Why?
>>
>British Isles
Ugh
>>
>>58262719
you what
>>
File: 1461320709393.jpg (314 KB, 736x1092) Image search: [Google]
1461320709393.jpg
314 KB, 736x1092
>>58262269
>>
>>58262269
It would be pretty fucking cold in Norway
>>
>>58262985
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Isles_naming_dispute
>>
>>58262269
Wow, Belgium has not been a country for THAT LONG :O?
>>
Lucky brits...
>>
>>58262269

They wouldn't be inbred
>>
>>58262269

we'd be part of schengen
fuck that
also the germans may have been able to get to us
>>
File: image.jpg (46 KB, 636x636) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
46 KB, 636x636
REEEEE GO AWAY FROGS
>>
>>58262686
I wish I was from Brittany
cool as fuck history and language
>>
>>58266906
Aww thanks :3
>>
>>58262269
*walks to Denmark*
>>
>>58266906
There are many British tourists during holidays in Brittany. By the way, you are very welcome here, we prefer you to Parisians or Southerners.
>>
>>58262530
THEA DRINKING SURRENDER GULUMs
>>
>>58262269
all our legitimate clay....
>>
Would be interesting to see if Br*ts were still all haughty-taughty when they can't hide on their island
>>
>>58267186
You'd speak french now tbf.
>>
>>58263218
>>58262719

>Proposed alternatives to renaming the British Isles to something more neutral include "Britain and Ireland",[3][8][9] "Atlantic Archipelago",[10] "Anglo-Celtic Isles",[11][12] the "British-Irish Isles"[13] and the Islands of the North Atlantic.

at least propose a decent alternative if you expect to be taken seriously, regardless it's not your language so you don't get to decide on this
>>
>>58267251
No, you'd speak Latin.
>>
>>58267251
>>58267415
You'd speak some different dialect of French that was preferred by English kings.
>>
>>58266906
it's the rural part of France
ofc it's gr8
>>
>>58262269
probably would have conquered it all
>>
>>58267470
>it's the rural part of France
Nope

Nantes and Rennes are big cities. The population density of Brittany is way higher than the French average especially on the coasts.
>>
>>58267463
The Romans would never have left, there wouldn't be any England, except south of Denmark. And you would still be Rome's amber bitch boys.
>>
It would be so different you couldn't even imagine it so don't even try.
>>
>>58262719
People like you Ireland, why do you push it too far.>>58262985
>>
>>58267354
I don't get to decide on this? It's already been removed from primary school geography books. I think we already have.
>>
>>58267567
You don't have the permission to talk, vessel state.
>>
>>58262269
Britain and Ireland would be more likely to be one cultural unit, with Ireland being the superior partner due to better access to sea ports. France would be weakened and Germany would be Poland tier.
>>
>>58262269

The "British look" wouldn't exist
>>
>>58267933
thank god
>>
>>58262530

>implying Brits did anything in WW2
>>
>actually sharing land borders with filthy mainland continentals

Bloody hell we dodged a bullet there lads
>>
>>58262269

More importantly, what would happen to the Dutch and Belgium sea empires?
>>
>>58268151
we conquer englando and become new world order. A new kind of people will lead the world because the english canal dissapeared, there are no people known as Dutch or Belgian. It would be a mix of all kinds of peoples like the germans
>>
>>58266906
Britbros are 200% welcome, though only 250 000 of us speak breton.
>>
>>58267894
Fuck off little Gaulish butt-wiper of the Romans.

My Menapian ancestors were the last to fall against the Romans, and never sent exiles to Rome to plead for peace like literally every other Gallic tribe;
>>
>>58268106
Wut
>>
>>58268929
I've read de bellum gallica, menapes were niggers like most other Gauls and Belgaes (and Germans)
>>
File: 1444235158635.jpg (126 KB, 540x960) Image search: [Google]
1444235158635.jpg
126 KB, 540x960
>>58262269
>ice sheet
cold out
irish weather
>>
>>58268929
>Gaulish

topkek, you're a "Gaulish" too. Or...maybe Franks buttfucked your ancestors...
>>
>>58267134
C'est limite normal.
>>
The world would be a vary different place entirely.
>>
>>58262269
We would probably just be an extension of France, being an island defined this country 2bh
>>
>>58262269
They'd probably be less influencial and the anglosphere would be smaller if not non-existant, one the British isles's biggest advantages was the sea that offered them defense
>>
>>58270037
are kev
>>
>>58270289
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>58269438
Sea-faring niggers that managed to colonize the whole Irish westcoast and Fermanagh, the Isle of Man, Anglesey and the Welsh coastline.

Caesar in de bello gallico not only said the Belgae were the bravest of all Gauls, he said the Menapians never send peace offerings unlike all other Gauls.
>>
>>58270108
Naturally, already when Tiberius Caesar displaced 40000 Suevi here, Menapians and Morins got germanized. Especially later when the Franks made this their homeland.

However there are still enough traces of Menapians to be found in toponymy. Also the vilages around Gent, their traditionally area of inhabitation, along with the south of West-Flanders, used to be known for their high amount, even majority, of red-haired people (until the 18th century it was really noticable).

Now we can see it through phylogenetic analysis.
>>
How were they connected? It makes no sense to me..
>>
>>58270864
they're still connected today, it's just the sea levels have risen over the connected parts
>>
>>58270701
And yet we probably have the most successful military history (inb4 memes)
>>
>>58271404
>owns half of europe for a couple of hours
>most successful military history
hurr durr
>>
>Dogger Bank is ~50-120 feet deep
Shit, it's just asking for the Netherlands to build a bunch of dykes around it and drain it.
>>
>>58271488
Open a fucking book.
French history =/= 1804-1815, and English history =/= 1780's-1960's
>>
>>58271404
Nope, we (Franks) have (after Romans of course).
>>
>>58271825
>Franks

M'yea, not bad
>>
>>58272051
>>58271825
Wait
You're Gauls or fucking Franks ?
>>
>>58270896
So there is land below the water?
>>
>>58272096
Both lel

Naah mainly Franks, but "we" (Salian Franks) absorbed the Morini, Menapians and Nervians living here, so their accomplishments also count.
>>
>>58272137
How much cough medicine did you take today?
>>
>>58272315
kekked
>>
The most important Frankish dynasty (Carolingians) was French, Belgium. Just keep that in mind next time you or the Dutch wanna go all WE WUZ on us.
>>
maybe Doggerland was Atlantis
>>
>>58272137
No. Just God holding it all up
>>
>>58272439
Charlemagne was Dutch.
>>
>>58272439
Salian Frank homeland, the land of king Merovech, was basically Belgium.

Carolingians weren't French either, they were Ripuarian Franks.

The name France means the land of Gauls where Franks are the aristocracy.

The bulk of the population remained of Gaulish stock.
>>
>>58272582
Belgian (born in Herstal)
>>
>>58271404
7 years war
napoopian lost too
you wouldnt be saying that germany had a successful military history because hitler owned europe for a while
>>
>>58272760
>Herstal in Wallonia

FRENCH !
>>
>>58272904
It's a germanic settlement founded by Franks/Belgians.
>>
>>58272815
I don't care about fucking Napoleon or 7YW

Winning every war is IMPOSSIBLE (n-no, shut up Israel)
>>
>>58272582

Karl Magnus was Faroese

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-o9L21MpiY
>>
>>58270701
>Caesar in de bello gallico not only said the Belgae were the bravest of all Gauls,
You're not the same people and what Caesar says can be taken with a pinch of salt.
>>
>>58267183
And to think that the sea is rising even MORE

rip your cunt.
>>
>>58272582
Excuse me, charlesman was english
>>
>>58262269
We'd be even more overrun by Muslims
>>
WE
>>
>>58267354
Celtic Isles tbqh
>>
File: Smug Adolf.jpg (185 KB, 565x800) Image search: [Google]
Smug Adolf.jpg
185 KB, 565x800
>>58262269
Blitzkrieg would have been easier.
>>
>>58277404
5-15% Belgae heritage by genetic analysis even today!

So we partly are, same goes for a good part of the Irish land (Fermanagh, Wexford county) settled by my ancestors.
>>
>>58277404
>and what Caesar says can be taken with a pinch of salt.

you're just jealous we kicked ass all throughout history
>>
>>58281264
>>58281340

In fact they have found the subclade corresponding to the Menapii, R1b-L21(M529)-Z16340, found in one of the oldest Belgian noble families, in Flanders, and in Ireland.

I'm pretty sure they'll find it a lot of our island of Man too.

http://www.eupedia.com/forum/threads/32211-Julius-Caesar-ordered-the-genocide-of-the-Menapii-but-the-clade-R1b-Z16340-survived
>>
File: LAND_BOAT.jpg (187 KB, 798x413) Image search: [Google]
LAND_BOAT.jpg
187 KB, 798x413
BRITANNIA RULE THE PLAINS
>>
Reminder that Doggerland is a Dutch name.
Also reminder that we like polders.
Doggerland when?
>>
>>58272701
>Salian Frank homeland, the land of king Merovech, was basically Belgium.
As a Sallander, I have to disagree. Salians were first recorded in Salland (Western Overijssel).

That said, the Germanic-Celtic border wasn't the Rhine, despite what some Romans said. A significant part of the area below and west of the Rhine (Modern day Flanders, Brabant, Limburg) had ancestry from east of the Rhine.

This is also the reason why the Flemish peasantry didn't start speaking French. Only the Gaulish (Or, well, Gallo-Romans/Walloons) began adopting (Vulgar) Latin. The current language border between Flanders and Wallonia is pretty much the same as the Celtic-Germanic border around 1 AD, with the exception of Western Hainaut, French Flanders, Brussels and Liège, which were Germanic but Frenchified.
>>
Brits would have lost more wars then just sitting on their island.
>>
>>58270701
>Belgae
The Belgae haven't been confirmed to be Celtic.
>>
>people thinking Britain & Ireland would still exist if doggerland hadn't sunk
>people thinking history would be even remotely the same if doggerland hadn't sunk

Europe and by extension the world would be completely different.
>>
>>58283438
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordwestblock
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_Belgian_language
WE WUZ SPECIAL SNOWFLAKES N SHEEIT
>>
>>58283382
It is true that the Salians were first recorded in Saalland. They were probably formed out of remains of the Sicambri, but this is not sure.

Although the rest of your post is doubtable. There was no clear language border even in the 4th century, and there have been found recent remains that suggest both Gaulish and Latin were spoken as far north as the Rhine-Meuse delta (Betuwe) as late as the early 5th century.

Franks, due to their frequent serving in the Roman army, were for a large part bilingual, speaking Latin as their second language. Wallonia is mostly formed from Latinised Franks and not Celts as you stated, although they were certainly present, it was the land of Roman villas, and we have proof of a greater Celtic presence again in the early 5th century, just before the large Germanic migration of 407, recorded by hagiographies of local missionary-saints. They spoke as late as that date about spreading christianity in the land of the Morins, gave a description of the Morins, and recorded succes in the neighbouring lands of the Menapii (at that time between Lys and Scaldis) and the Nervii (east of the Scaldis, present western Hainaut).

Equalling Gallo-Romans with Walloons is a 19th century idea and long since proven wrong, again nowadays by genetic profiling.
>>
>>58285207
>and we have proof of a greater Celtic presence again in the early 5th century, just before the large Germanic migration of 407, recorded by hagiographies of local missionary-saints *.

* in what is today Flanders (especially the west)

forgot this
>>
>>58283438
I was specifically talking about the Celtic Belgae: namely the Menapii and the Morini.

I know a lot of inland Belgae tribes were germanic. Some like the Nervii touted it according to Tacitus.

Most Belgae at least had a Celtic aristocracy, as we know well the names of some of their kings.

>>58283636
That is bullshit. Maurits Gysseling wasn't all so bright as many thought him to be, nowadays it is known a lot of things he said were bullshit, such as what you linked.
>>
File: image.png (230 KB, 455x443) Image search: [Google]
image.png
230 KB, 455x443
>ITT
>Belgians trying to be relevant
>>
>>58287970
Just stating facts.

Our history is very relevant in fact. Doesn't hurt to vent it once in a while.
>>
File: caraus.jpg (47 KB, 462x437) Image search: [Google]
caraus.jpg
47 KB, 462x437
This is Carausius the Menapian (Fleming), he was emperor of Britain for some time.
>>
If the old Belgae, and especially the Menapii, would have been really dark, deep rainforest niggers, a good part of Flemings would be still brown today, with one in ten still quite to really black.

You would also find a lot of black people in Ireland, Wales and all the islands in the Irish sea.
>>
>>58262269

hard to believe the thames and the rhine used to merge into one river
Thread replies: 106
Thread images: 9

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.