[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
What is it about France that makes it the only succesful Latin
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /int/ - International

Thread replies: 201
Thread images: 33
File: The-Thinker[1].jpg (381 KB, 1624x1080) Image search: [Google]
The-Thinker[1].jpg
381 KB, 1624x1080
What is it about France that makes it the only succesful Latin nation, whereas the others (Spain, Portugal, Italy) are and to a certain extant always have been widely unsuccesful?

France has given the world some of its finest thinkers, mathematicians, scientists, psychologists, philosophers and artists while Spain and Italy only produced good artists (and a handful of Renaissance thinkers) while Portugal produced nothing of the sort. Scientifically speaking the achievements of the Latins are underwhelming to put it lightly.

Even if we look at history, what we see in Spain and Portugal is incompetent leadership and mismanagement. The rise of these two countries to greatness is accidentily happening upon gold and silver, using it to build up their armies and fleets, dominating Europe for about a century and then quietly fading into the night. What they achieved (or rather found) in 1492 was gone by 1648. Compare France which did not achieve because of its colonies but gained colonies because of its achievements. France had some notoriously incompetent leaders, but many great ones as well and a pretty solid administration overall. As for Italy, it seems like their unification only caused things to go downhill rather than uphill.

What is it about France that puts them in the same league as countries like England, the Netherlands and Germany while the other Latins straggle behind?
>>
>>57864931
They are germans speaking a latin language while we are arabs speaking a latin language.
>>
Simple, we were their neighbours, and their desperation to compete with us spurred them on.
>>
File: jmjnYU9.jpg (100 KB, 1280x730) Image search: [Google]
jmjnYU9.jpg
100 KB, 1280x730
>Spain, Portugal, Italy
>Not successful

lol
>>
>>57864931
>(Spain, Portugal, Italy) are and to a certain extant always have been widely unsuccesful?

ok
>>
DELETE THIS SHIT NOW
>>
>>57864931
spanish people sleep for an hour at noon, that's hardly compatible with the industral revolution

also they didn't really take part in many of the 19th and 20th century wars that killed off all the less innovative and intelligent people in northern europe
>>
Ahahahah nice one pal
>>
>>57866382
>wars kill off less innovative and intelligent people

explain Somalia
>>
I can understand Spain and Portugal but how is Italy unsuccessful?
>>
>>57864931
>France has given the world some of its finest thinkers, mathematicians, scientists, psychologists, philosophers and artists while Spain and Italy only produced good artists
No, you just don't know what you're talking about
>>
>>57866458
Shut the fuck up fucking nigger
>>
>>57866382
>also they didn't really take part in many of the 19th and 20th century wars that killed off all the less innovative and intelligent people in northern europe

Do you realize that we were in a constant civil war from 1800's to 1939 plus the francoist purges and wars in Morocco? In what wars were Norway and Sweden being involved? Even dutch and danes surrendered to Germany without shooting a bullet.
>>
>>57866507
>>57866439
barbaric internal civil wars don't favour innovation and technological advancement.
>>
>>57866507
You're not taking his theory about wars seriously, are you?
>>
>>57866382
>spanish people sleep for an hour at noon, that's hardly compatible with the industral revolution

I know you're memeing, but that's not true. The real reason is that we had fuckton a people during the IR and needed not to modernise our agriculture in order to develop an industry, unlike the English who had to. They also had their empire to sell off their industrial products.

Spain hadn't enough people to begin an industrial revolution without modernising its agriculture first, and the people were not ready yet to modernise. When they could, the world was already dominated by the French, Anglos and Germans.
>>
>>57864931
>What is it about France that makes it the only succesful Latin nation
We are the least latin country, that's why.
>>
File: MDR JPP.jpg (5 KB, 132x132) Image search: [Google]
MDR JPP.jpg
5 KB, 132x132
>>57864931
Woops forgot to read the end haha
>What is it about France that puts them in the same league as countries like England, the Netherlands and Germany
>England, the Netherlands and Germany
>England, the Netherlands
>The Netherlands
>>
>>57866624
It's not the theory but the fact that he believes we didn't have any wars.
>>
>>57866458
Too much clashes between the rich North and the agricultural South, no political unity so no interior market like Germany, no exterior market unlike France and England due to their Empire.

Talking about the Industrial Revolution here. The current crisis is mainly the fault of Americans and their subprimes.
>>
>>57866709
correct me if Im wrong , didn't the spaniards BTOFed the netherlands in the past?
>>
>>57864931
I know you evil dutch hates glorious Spain, but this makes you look like americans retarded
>>
>>57866779
Netherlands was a part of the spanish empire for a while iirc
>>
>>57866344
s-source of this pic?
>>
High cast in France : germanics
That's all about this.

France is such a disgusting mix of mediteranean people and germans-nordics-celtics.

It went good for a while, but since a spaniard took the prime minister place you know France isn't a thing anymore. I hope on time it will rise, I hope so much.
>>
>>57864931
What you say about France is nice, and true I guess, but saying that Italy Spain and Portugal are "unsuccesful" nations and don't have contributed to the greatness of Western civilization is... Absolutely FALSE !
Come on , mate... Learn history.
These nations are surely the greatest contribution to the Western world...
Renaissance, great discoveries, European maritime empire ?
>>
>>57867010
Oh come on, you are so pessimistic.
(So actual french then) we have shitty politics, yep. History is a thing in a constant evolution.
And I can't wait for 2017.
>>
>>57867108
Lepen is no more but a kike sucker and freemason sucker, wake up m3c.
>>
As someone directly half-French on my father's side, I respect Spain, Italy, and Portugal more than those other nations you listed.

What the fuck has Germany accomplished? Destroying Europe four fucking times? Spain saved Europe's ass in the Reconquista. That's more important than scientific discoveries.
>>
And to a certain extent Italy never had any colonies
>>
>>57867158
We'll see.
Seriously, Idk what will happen in 2017 but it wouldn't be worse than Holland.
>>
>>57864931
>psychologists, philosophers and artists
Who groups useless shit like psychology and philosophy with science and math?

Portugual, why don't you have any great psychologists? haha what a faggot
>>
>>57867242
>spain saved Europe from islam
>Germany did nothing relevant in humankind's history pf sciences/philosophy/industry

Wew

>>57867267

UPR le seul parti qui vaille pêh
>>
>>57867242
fuck off
>>
>>57867306
>Who groups useless shit like psychology and philosophy with science and math?
Philosophy may be a useless McDonald's degree field nowadays, but it led to many important things back in the day.
>>
File: 1427252238243[1].png (19 KB, 267x302) Image search: [Google]
1427252238243[1].png
19 KB, 267x302
>>57867306
>useless shit like psychology and philosophy
>>
>>57867242
Yes, you need history lessons, lad.
But thank you for the support.
>>
>>57867340
>>57867454
Obviously he was sarcastic
>>
why i still browse this cancer board,fuck my life
>>
File: burnsplague.png (112 KB, 522x381) Image search: [Google]
burnsplague.png
112 KB, 522x381
>>57867590
>
>>
File: 1452810477816.jpg (9 KB, 225x225) Image search: [Google]
1452810477816.jpg
9 KB, 225x225
>>57867657
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
>>
>>57867242
>What the fuck has Germany accomplished? Destroying Europe four fucking times?

Can't you fuck off with the memes for once?
>>
>>57867340
>but it led to many important things back in the day
You're confused. Back in the day science was called philosophy, physics was called natural philosophy. It didn't lead to it, the name changed.
>>57867526
You're an edgy fedora neckbeard along with OP.
>>
>>57867972
>Back in the day science was called philosophy
american education
>>
>>57867701
>>57867657
>>57867590
quality posts
>>
>>57866857
Around 100 years.
>>
>>57866366
Kek. We're proof of that.
>>
>>57867972
>You're an edgy fedora neckbeard along with OP.
Why? He was. Or he's really really stupid.
But he can't be so stupid lad, he was sarcastic...
>>
File: swedes.jpg (80 KB, 569x421) Image search: [Google]
swedes.jpg
80 KB, 569x421
>>57868012
Men are talking. Go back in the cuck shed.
>>
>Italy only produced good artists
Fermi
Majorana
Faggin
Marconi
Volta
Galvani
Meucci
Fibonacci

Literally the guys who invented batteries, consumer CPUs, phones and radio and made breakthroughs in nuclear physics.

What does France has to offer?
>>
>>57864931

The Frogs, the Bongs, and the Krauts have fucked up Europe beyond any point of salvation with their constant bickering and fighting among themselves.

The eurozone was a Frog project designed to reign in Germany, and the Frogs managed to fuck it up (again).
>>
>>57868457
>The Frogs, the Bongs, and the Krauts have fucked up Europe beyond any point of salvation with their constant bickering and fighting among themselves.
He's so right.
>The eurozone was a Frog project designed to reign in Germany, and the Frogs managed to fuck it up (again).
F.U.C.K. Y.O.U.
At least, we tried :D
>>
>>57864931
>incompetent leadership and mismanagement.

sounds like France tbqhwyamdaff(to be quite honest with you all my dear and funny friends)
>>
>>57868449
frog legs man, they're pretty good
>>
>>57868449
I don't much about this first thing I can think of is the modern vaccine
>>
>>57868457
>and the Frogs managed to fuck it up (again)

Yep, for some reason they turned into their loyal lapdogs. I wonder what's Merkel secret.
>>
>>57868113

But I thought that Murrica made you first world
>>
File: 1438693003905.jpg (183 KB, 989x1022) Image search: [Google]
1438693003905.jpg
183 KB, 989x1022
>>57867972
All science was called natural philosophy "back in the day".
>implying the scientific method did not stem from rationalism
>>
>>57868449
The funny thing is that whitout Volta there isn't modern world and Tesla would have farmed turnips.
>>
>>57868619
maybe we have the same goals

oooooooooohhhh
>>
>>57868619
Secret sexual skills imo
>>
File: maxresdefault.jpg (38 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
maxresdefault.jpg
38 KB, 1280x720
>>57868449
Descartes -scientific methode

Lavoisier - father of modern chemistry

Pasteur - revolution in medicine and food conservation

Pascal - revolution in probabilistic maths

Foucault - invented gyroscope, the instrument which proved relativity theorie

Poincaré - precursor of the relativity theory (some of scientists say that he is the real father of the theory)

De Broglie - one of the fathers of quantum mechanics

Laplace , La grange....

Or Ampère, one of the fathers of modern physics ?

Even today, France with USA is the first country ranked in mathematics.
>>
>>57864931
When you realize we're literally speaking pidgins/creoles then you'll understand why we're retarded.
>>
>>57868626
Sort of. Until they decided to install a dictator and completely fucked up our country for years to come.
>>
>>57868626
Next time you might want to try building shit for them and more importantly educating them.
>>
>>57868658
those are memes, without someone bla bla bla.

Someone else would have did it . Check those inventions and everytime there are a lot of people who were behind those inventions or at least finding a way to create them, the guy who invented something one week before another person get labelled as the inventor generally.
>>
>>57868687
Then why is your economy shit while they are reducing their public debt and having a record low unemployment rate?
>>
File: image_08.jpg (634 KB, 895x598) Image search: [Google]
image_08.jpg
634 KB, 895x598
>>57868727
We can add metric system, european space program and european nuclear program.


Aaaah the french.
>>
>>57868821
Crisis (thanks to banks/financials/rentiers)
Like in your cunt lad
>>
>>57868889
>european space program

literally a waste of money so frogs can pretend to play in the same league as Russia and America
>>
>>57868913
So crisis affected you like us but instead of teaming with countries in your same situation you just decided to lick Mama Merkel's pussy.
>>
>>57868889
Oh come on, it's ok for the auto-ballsuck lads.
The world already think that we're arrogant and shit
>>
>>57868913
your country is spain 2.0 soon.....
>>
>>57868946
>to lick Mama Merkel's pussy
Absolutely not. Say thanks to our "modern" policians, and wait for 2017.
The people, disagree with them.
Look at "nuit debout" on google
>>
>>57868954
There's no "ball suck" in the truth especially when for some reason everyone seems buttblasted about us ITT
>>
>>57868012
Actually it did
>>
>>57868999
That's what some people think here...
If nothing happen.
So we wait until 2017.
Because NO regular election can happen before
>>
File: bored pepe.jpg (70 KB, 960x960) Image search: [Google]
bored pepe.jpg
70 KB, 960x960
>>57869021
>Look at "nuit debout" on google

wew
>>
>>57868917
>waste of money

Wew
Gladly you aren't in charge, siesta man

>>57868954

Let's call a dog, a dog
>>
>>57868889
Why does the euro space program look like something out of the 1950's?
>>
>>57867306
>>57867340
The science wars didn't exist back then because there was no distinction between hard and soft sciences as such. One thinker could double as mathematician and philosopher.

Mathematics is a branch of philosophy, if you consider what its aims are. This whole humanities/STEM turf war bullshit would look ridiculous to a French thinker of their golden age.
>>
>>57869040
>when for some reason everyone seems buttblasted about us ITT
(first, sorry for my "rusty" English)
did you see the title of the thread lad?
It's troll friendly
just don't play the game, don't be silly :)
>>
>>57868999
More like Al-Andalus 2.0. Paris looks like what Granada was in 950.
>>
File: 166867066__803159b.jpg (92 KB, 780x520) Image search: [Google]
166867066__803159b.jpg
92 KB, 780x520
>>57869084

Budget things, at least we Land on comets and not moons barely nigger than the average American citizen
>>
france is fucking gay
>>
File: best.png (2 MB, 1836x941) Image search: [Google]
best.png
2 MB, 1836x941
>>57864931
Rivalry
>>
>>57869066
>That's what some people think here...
>If nothing happen.
>So we wait until 2017.
>Because NO regular election can happen before
well,your country is in recession mainwhile spain grows fast
>>
>>57869226
>spain grows fast
2.5-3% per year
exports to latin america
south american companies invest in spain
cheap oil
>>
>>57869145
>troll friendly

Those Spanish genuinely have a problem with us tho
>>
>>57866709
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Dutch_inventions_and_discoveries
>>
>>57869291
growth doesn't really mean that much after years of recession. you're still WAY below 2008 levels
>>
>>57869218
>rivalry
>he doesn't have a rocket with an english name

We are not on the same level my dear
>>
>>57869021
I don't know, what are the chances that they form a party like they did in Spain and get into the parliament? Your political system seems to be very beneifical for the establishment.
>>
File: 1454540042262.jpg (208 KB, 1188x898) Image search: [Google]
1454540042262.jpg
208 KB, 1188x898
>>
>>57869347
look the future, spain has a good future :) only one problem is debt
>>
>>57869352
W-What
>>
>>57869213
>>57869218
>>57869334

Here he is, the eternal anglo thinking he's relevant

Reminder :
English language : thanks to USA
France has more nukes
France has more EEZ
France worth basically 5 times your island
>>
>>57869326
"/int/ Everybody have a problem with everybody"
This is a good slogan
>>
>>57869352
>we didn't make it
>b-but muh etymology guys
http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/sabre_howworks.html
don't be tsundere
>>57869475
this is what we get for trying to be friendly as always
>>
>>57869533
>>
>>57869382
>very beneifical for the establishment
That's true. But a large majority of the population
hope for a change (and they actually do something) .
I hope it will be enough for the next election.
So pray for us, Lat bros
>>
>>57864931
well proxied frog
>>
>>57869571
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qN80_7rNmcE
>>
>>57869533
Ariane - vulcain
And not rolls"kek"Royce
>>
>>57869582
>Lat bros
we are not your bros , dont forget it
>>
>>57869805
We are not latin neither.
>>
>>57869700
>more hype around React before they've even left the ground (and reached space in the same vehicle)
kek
>>
>>57869021
c'est quoi la « loi Travail », au juste?
>>
>>57869805
You may be edgy here but I've met tons of spaniards and never had any problem with any of them
>>
>>57869805
That's mean, man. You guys are so different IRL and here. I met Spanish people when being in Spain and they were like 100% bros.
Are you hypocrital?
Yeah ok, France isn't 100% Latin, but like 50% Idk, and what, is it so important?
People here are very behind Spain, and share it's struggle, hope you can get out of troubles.
Can't you be the same? Why is it so hard to you?
>>
>>57870076
why do you expect some guy on 4chan to be nice or reasonable?
>>
>>57869938
Une connerie qu'il nous ont sortis pour nous ramener au XIX ème siècle.
>>
File: 1338077786039.jpg (35 KB, 425x301) Image search: [Google]
1338077786039.jpg
35 KB, 425x301
Well done OP.
>>
>>57870173
>tfw this is just how the frogs treat us
>>
>>57864931
>What is it about France that makes it the only succesful Latin nation
The fact that we are not a latin nation.
>>
all memes aside our rivalry with the French helped spur both of our nations on to become great. I think we can both be proud of the fact that no nations on the planet come anywhere near to either of us when it comes to shaping the modern world. we have a love/hate rivalry really we pretend not to get along but we secretly respect the shit out of each other.
>>
>>57869980
Tu viens du sud ( en dessous de la Loire ) toi, non ?

J'étudie en Andalousie, et vraiment on (nord-ouest) a rien à voir avec ces branleurs d'espingoins.. Mais j''ai remarqué que les gens du sud ( ouest particulièrement ) s''acclimatent très bien ici
>>
>>57870173
Yeah, I know, but I have hope you know
>>
>>57870274
Come on, we never treat you like that you shitty rosbif de mes deux balls.
>>
File: 250px-UK_Royal_Coat_of_Arms.0.png (109 KB, 250x247) Image search: [Google]
250px-UK_Royal_Coat_of_Arms.0.png
109 KB, 250x247
>>57870301
Ok I admit it.
>>
>>57870301
Pretty true desu, not many countries came close to our Empires other than Portugal and Spain but they seem to receive a lot of shit ITT
>>
>>57870301
>"I secretly respect the French"
>t. fedora neckbeard
>>
>>57870322
andalusia is a shithole...dude
>>
>>57870438
"our empires"
I've never heard of the great Leaf Empire, please do redpill me on it my lumberjack friend
>>
>>57870465
It's a love-hate relationship, you can't understand desu
>>
>>57864931
because the french had the most contact with the anglos
>>
>>57870504
you see friend, the eu is controlled by the germans, who are controlled by the jews, who are in turn controlled by the leaves.

not even /pol/ can see through our masterful trickery.
>>
>>57870555
>you see friend, the eu is controlled by the germans
sadly but true
>>
>>57866077
We're not Krautz, we're Celts m8
>>
>>57864931
We're not latin to be honest. It's pretty offensive to know that you think we're latin.
>>
>>57870582
of course it's true, everything in that post is true.

are you calling me a liar, jorge?
>>
>>57870582
Not at all.

Maybe for your little shitholes yea but no more for France or UK.
Just look at the migrants crisis where we both shat on Merkel's hand.
>>
>>57870593
"don't feed the troll"
>>
>>57870618
>are you calling me a liar, jorge?
no,of course
>>
File: fhurQjA12xIT0T6viXf.jpg (61 KB, 514x352) Image search: [Google]
fhurQjA12xIT0T6viXf.jpg
61 KB, 514x352
>>57867242

>What the fuck has Germany accomplished?
>>
>>57870480

It's quite a nice shithole though, girls are easy and the beer is cheap. Too bad the girls are ugly and the beer taste like piss..

But still, the weather is nice,people are friendly, and free tapas with your drink is a god-gift
>>
>>57870531
>It's a love-hate relationship
Yes. The English invade you, you love your English masters. The Germans invade you, you love your German masters.
>>
>>57870582
Yes, It's pretty true, currently.
Like all the French people I just whisper : "2017"
>>
File: The_expert_of_the_topic.png (254 KB, 365x316) Image search: [Google]
The_expert_of_the_topic.png
254 KB, 365x316
Italy: City states

Britain: Irrelevant shithole surviving merely on not being landbound, until they industrialized first

Spain: No brains, all wealth, all crash

Sweden: Turns out being a genocidal warmonger is hard when your neighbors is barren Russia, Barren Norway and the baltic frozen states during the Little Ice Age.

Russia: Irrelevant shithole until Gobbunism industrialized it, allowing it to utilize its extremely waste resources and lands

Germany: Spread city states is never a super power, which is also why making Germany was a big deal
>>
>>57870702
You have forgotten the part where France created your country, the one which allows you to puke your dumbness on /int/
>>
>>57870702
We Invade them both before. Learn your history from IV to XI Centuries. Europe is a big melting-culture-pot Don't you learn it in school in the US?
>>
>>57870699
>andalusian girls are ugly
>>
File: one kek man.jpg (20 KB, 292x326) Image search: [Google]
one kek man.jpg
20 KB, 292x326
>>57870551
>>57866316
>>
>>57870714
2017 = Free nation
>>
>>57870851

Spanish girls are ugly overall, y'all look fucking inbred to me, what's up with the horsey face ?
And they're vulgar and fat...
>>
>>57870504
Top kek, I wasnt referencing Canada as an Empire, I was talking about France. (Canada being a former French colony if you didnt knew)
>>
>>57870889
Mais bien sûr.

Photo reliée : ambassadeur israélien.
>>
dutch people conquered both britain and france so yeah no thx
>>
>>57871037
>ambassadeur israélien
Il a l'air gay. Mais sympatoche faut l'avouer.
>>
>>57870980
Kek, you didn't get me, did you my moose-lover friend ?
>>
>>57870828
>France created your country
Yes our first president was George DeGaul. It's like you eurofags live in an alternate history.
>>
>>57871144

Ungrateful piece of shit.
>>
>>57871144
>George DeGaul
It would be a damn good name for a president.
>>
>>57871218
nice flag, france
>>
>>57871144
without france you wouldn't fucking exist because you needed their aid vs britain, else they would have overwhelmed you and you would remain under their rule. you're the one with the alternate history where you're so awesome and nobody ever aided you ever.
>>
>>57871093
Thanks for the liberation, fuck Romans, man.
>>
>>57871144
That's exactly one of the reason you're hated throughout the world my burger friend. Being an obnoxious fat cunt proud of being dumb :)
>>
File: oh.png (232 KB, 511x296) Image search: [Google]
oh.png
232 KB, 511x296
>>57871264
>tfw our enemies surrendered to us and our BASED WHITE FLAG, back then
>>
File: rsz_rts6ghf-e1454431911998.jpg (153 KB, 1200x515) Image search: [Google]
rsz_rts6ghf-e1454431911998.jpg
153 KB, 1200x515
>>57871264
nice festivals
>>
>>57870076
Meanwhile IRL you are the same as on /int/.
>>
File: kektop.gif (1 MB, 290x189) Image search: [Google]
kektop.gif
1 MB, 290x189
>>57871264
nice found
>>
>What is it about France that makes it the only succesful Latin nation, whereas the others (Spain, Portugal, Italy) are and to a certain extant always have been widely unsuccesful?

I don't know if we are the most germanic of all latin countries or the most latin of all germanic countries.
>>
File: NatalieHershlagbonnetruiejuive85.jpg (307 KB, 1911x2712) Image search: [Google]
NatalieHershlagbonnetruiejuive85.jpg
307 KB, 1911x2712
>>57866077
C'est malheureusement la vérité...Gerardo Piqué...
>>
France is right next to us and England. Having two rivals close by forces you to get your shit together. Meanwhile, all Spain and Portugal ever do is suck each other off.
>>
>>57867334
>>57870696
>our rivals defending us

t-thanks
>>
hi everybody
>>
>>57871701
Come on, Europe has always been a German-franco-britain question, that's really annoying when a foreigner is bullshitting about ennemies
>>
File: Map-Romance_Language_World.png (38 KB, 1357x628) Image search: [Google]
Map-Romance_Language_World.png
38 KB, 1357x628
>"The discovery of America, and that of a passage to the East Indies by the Cape of Good Hope, are the two greatest and most important events recorded in the history of mankind. Their consequences have already been very great: but, in the short period of between two and three centuries which has elapsed since these discoveries were made, it is impossible that the whole extent of their consequences can have been seen. What benefits, or what misfortunes to mankind may hereafter result from those great events, no human wisdom can foresee. By uniting, in some measure, the most distant parts of the world, by enabling them to relieve one another's wants, to increase one another's enjoyments, and to encourage one another's industry, their general tendency would seem to be beneficial." Adam Smith
All the latin countries have beem succesful and some point,and had basically shaped Europe and the world. The same cannot be said about most of Europe
>>
>>57864931
>What is it about France that makes it the only succesful Latin nation, whereas the others (Spain, Portugal, Italy) are and to a certain extant always have been widely unsuccesful?
Not true, all Latin European countries are 1st world developed countries, France is more succesful? Yes. But someone had to be the best.

>France has given the world some of its finest thinkers, mathematicians, scientists, psychologists, philosophers and artists while Spain and Italy only produced good artists (and a handful of Renaissance thinkers) while Portugal produced nothing of the sort. Scientifically speaking the achievements of the Latins are underwhelming to put it lightly.
Not true Italy produced a lot of Mathematicians, Scientists, Philosophers and all kinds of Artists, I consider them superior to France on that area, and I am not just talking about the Renaissace, altough that was their finest hour.
Spain also had a lot of those, just not that many or very famous.
Portugal contributed very little, but for our size and irrelevancy its actually acceptable.

>Even if we look at history, what we see in Spain and Portugal is incompetent leadership and mismanagement. The rise of these two countries to greatness is accidentily happening upon gold and silver, using it to build up their armies and fleets, dominating Europe for about a century and then quietly fading into the night. What they achieved (or rather found) in 1492 was gone by 1648.
The Portuguese Empire lasted from 1415 to 1580 and we only found gold in 1550.

>As for Italy, it seems like their unification only caused things to go downhill rather than uphill.
Italy is doing fine.

>What is it about France that puts them in the same league as countries like England, the Netherlands and Germany while the other Latins straggle behind?
Ha, France is WAY above the Netherlands.
>>
>>57871873
Delusional, particularly on the "Italy > France @ sciences" and "Netherlands >>>>> France"

Since Italy is france's bitch and Netherlands have french national motto...

You know what I mean pissa
>>
>>57867242
The Franks saved Europe. The Spaniards just merged with the Moors.
>>
>>57872011
It depends of the area and the time.
So it's difficult to discuss *seriously* about it on /int/...
But, basically, every west country had its period
(and a lot of other places all other the world).
>>
>>57868222
America, I want to love you, but you make it really hard sometimes
>>
>>57872011
>and Netherlands have french national motto...
all the best countries do
>>
File: 1454143406691.jpg (32 KB, 259x276) Image search: [Google]
1454143406691.jpg
32 KB, 259x276
>>57872305
And a "Dieu et mon Droit" to you too.
>>
>>57866362
All the early movements ( Humanism , Realism , Romanticism ) did start in Italy but the France was the place where they got life
>>
>>57871037
C'est qui le barbu à côté de l'ambassadeur ?
>>
File: turkthread.jpg (84 KB, 500x370) Image search: [Google]
turkthread.jpg
84 KB, 500x370
>>57872921
JUST ROACH MY SHIT UP SENPAI
>>
>>57872834
>"Dieu et mon Droit"
What does it means?
>>
>>57873432
pretty sure it'd be est instead of et if it were written in modern french
>>
>>57873432
Google trans says it means "I'm a virgin."
>>
File: NatalieHershlagbonnetruiejuive79.jpg (878 KB, 2396x1799) Image search: [Google]
NatalieHershlagbonnetruiejuive79.jpg
878 KB, 2396x1799
>>57873485
Non..stupide bloke, ca veut dire:God and my right...
>>
>>57873568
Oh, So it's the modern motto of England.
Expain everything.
>>57873485
no, pretty sure it's the opposite ;)
>>
>>57864931
Interesting.

France is actually germanic while the language is French though, AND;

History is mostly wrong.
France was established before Rome or Greece.
French was invented first among that group, before Italian or Latin (history being wrong see above.)
Spain was not included on maps "the hidden country" no, it was not hidden; it was not there at the time of those maps.
>>
>>57874023
Also, contrary to the popular saying that Rome was not built in a day,
Rome was in fact built in one day.

A bunch of people do not like this so they had the facts changed.
>>
>>57874023
Some regions in France have names that have an adjective->noun Germanic form
France was named after germanic invaders
France had a germanic ruling class but they all disappeared
Other than that the Germanic influence dries up very quickly
Everything else about France which is 99% is mediterranean/latin/brown.
>>
>>57870322
Yeah I'm from Languedoc, I've lived near Spain all my life
>>
>>57864931

why are dutch so butthurt towards spain?
>>
>>57876165
Because evey time they see an "ethnic" dutch that isn't blue eyed and blond they know his bloodline was Fernando Martinez'd.
>>
>>57876165
Because they were our colony :^)
>>
>>57864931
Italy has been very successful since the Middle Ages. Italians have always been awesome artists, scientists and inventors. It is a mistake to class Italy as nonsuccessful.

Maybe your question is why we were not as successful as France *in the 19th century*, and the short answer is population and religion.

During the world empire era, France was a country with a huge population, like 5 times bigger than that of Spain. Portugal always had a small population. This did not help an equal competition with France.

Then there is the fact that the Catholic Church controlled education very tightly in our countries. Memorising the lives of saints was more important than the scientific method in our universities. The French rebelled against that crap, chopped off the heads of reactionary clerics and gave us the metric system and the Encyclopedia.

Nevertheless, Spain and Portugal were still kind of competitive up until Napoleon's empire. Take seismology or urban planning for instance, those were started in the modern sense with Pombal's reconstruction of Lisbon. You can also take the Balmis expedition, the first large-scale vaccination program in the world: undertaken by the Spanish empire when it was unmistakably decaying.

The failure to join the industrial revolution is what screwed up our countries. Not enough people to create any sort of industry, and even less educated people because of the Church's grip on education.
>>
>>57864931
>confusing countries with individuals
also it's because you're talking about countries living in the extremes of a continent who were much more oriented towards mercantilism, and particularly as a nation.
countries like france and england were more connected to the struggles of central europe and thus managed to create more important achievements later on
meanwhile the netherlands and germany as a nation accomplished nothing. private individuals maybe but as nations they were complete failures and clusterfucks.
when the 20th century came about with all its revolutions towards autonomy and individualism came about, the people in these countries did better than the ones in countries that had developed specifically towards nation-building.
so spain and portugal actually have communist parties in the 21st century, because people actually feel united as a nation. which isn't the case at all in a place like germany
>>
Let them have that "diversity" they can keep it
>>
>>57866077
We are rather Celts than Germans.
>>
>>57877893
Celts were genocided by Caesar, my germanic neighbor.
>>
File: 1460576390639.jpg (268 KB, 760x931) Image search: [Google]
1460576390639.jpg
268 KB, 760x931
>>57877975
>Celts were raped by Caesar
>>
File: 1460039784653.jpg (239 KB, 713x659) Image search: [Google]
1460039784653.jpg
239 KB, 713x659
>>57877975
Mostly the males. Roman sandnigs bought Gaulish women.
>>57878553
>Lyon
>Celto-Germanic
haha yeah that picture is bullshit
>>
genetics, france is latin by language only
>>
>>57878692
>Quality post
>USA
AHAHAH yeah your life is a bullshit
>>
>>57864931
Are you kidding ? Spain , Portugal and Italy not successful? We were the most advanced and rich country for almost 100 years, and continued being top 5 for another near 200.
>>
>>57878553
AUVERGNE
U
V
E
R
G
N
E
Thread replies: 201
Thread images: 33

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.