[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Is Islam at its core really that different from Christianity?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /int/ - International

Thread replies: 71
Thread images: 19
File: beautiful-hijab-muslim-woman.jpg (74 KB, 384x348) Image search: [Google]
beautiful-hijab-muslim-woman.jpg
74 KB, 384x348
Is Islam at its core really that different from Christianity? I've read the Quran a couple times (courted some muslim girls on and off over the years, made attempts to understand and be respectful) and yeah it has similar outdated stuff like the bible but most people on both sides don't pay attention to those parts any more.

They pretty much have the same core beliefs from what I see, just different details
>>
File: 20131129-d500.jpg (75 KB, 600x400) Image search: [Google]
20131129-d500.jpg
75 KB, 600x400
>>52579273
>but most people on both sides don't pay attention to those parts any more.

Except, you know, the ones coming to us.
>>
File: 1420659969733.png (45 KB, 757x629) Image search: [Google]
1420659969733.png
45 KB, 757x629
>>52579273
Shillinger... Just stay in your desert mkay?
>>
>>52579273
Aside from the Quran Islam has the Hadith (Shit Muhammad Says), that's the real cancer.
>>
It's not that different. More codified generally, and they actually care what the text says. There's also a huge amount of "scholarly" work that deals with really mundane issues...this stems from the fact that the Quran is (for them) the literal word of god and therefore everything counts, unlike the bible, which is a mishmash. In the end, islam is like back to the future 3, so it's better than 2, but worse than 1
>>
>>52579353
I'm 3/4 white. None of my family is Muslim
>>
>>52579273
No.

Islam is more comparable to judaism, in that it has specific regulations that you have to follow. Rules on prayer, dietary requirements and legal codes etc. Islam goes beyond what any other religion prescribes in the extent of the Sharia and the legal code that Muslims should live their lives behind. Christendom and Political Christianity was not prescribed in the bible, it arose out of having a common religion. An islamic caliphate is prescribed in the Quran.

Christianity simply has nowhere near the regulations required of its followers. For all the ire Protestantism gets, a similar reform movement would not be possible in islam. Because there are fundamentals to islam that simply have to be followed. You can be a "Bad muslim" and not follow them, but any islamic school that suggests you don't need to pray or eat halal or women do not have to dress conservatively would immediately be disregarded by all other muslims.

Islam is a construct that includes a legal system, a political system, a social organization system and a faith system and these 4 parts cannot be separated from each other, they come as a package.
>>
>>52579413
What's the other 1/4? Sheep?
>>
Islam is quite different because it has a legal and political system that cannot be decoupled from the religion.
>>
>>52579273

There's a lot of violent condemnation in the Qu'ran that is comparable to the old testament but not the new.

I don't think they're similar t bh

Christianity is fundamentally pacifist. Islam is largely instruction for subjugation and conquest.

It also separates peoples whereas the bible does not.
>>
>>52579489
Maori, dickhead.
>>
File: 1446466704200.jpg (346 KB, 586x580) Image search: [Google]
1446466704200.jpg
346 KB, 586x580
>>52579273
>I've read the Quran a couple times (courted some muslim girls on and off over the years, made attempts to understand and be respectful)

This can't be real
>>
>>52579273
>most people on both sides don't pay attention to those parts any more.
except from those people running arab governments and several active international terrorists and people in european countries right now raping white girls because they're not wearing headscarves and teaching their own kids that the west is the devil
>>
>>52579573
this,literally reading the Quran just to court some lebs is pretty fucking pathetic
>>
It has a very large body of hadith and secondary writings, on top of an equally giant pile of jurisprudence, argumentation, and interpretations, and then there's all of the history recorded of all of the sect splits, uprisings, dynastic rebellions, disputes, which often is wishy washy and hard to verify if you want to be historically rigorous with what actually happened and not just what each writer said. And all of that has it's own pile of interpretation and argumentation.

Chaotic clustetfuck with no central authority enables the "extremist" groups, which are born of the political instability to legitimize their authority with might makes right. This is older than the modern blame on western interference fucking up the region, see: First Fitnah.

Also this>>52579492
The religion developed simultaneously as a faith and as a political and legal body to guide Muhammad's group to success.
>>
>>52579573
If you are trying to court a Saudi or Iranian girl who comes from a super-conservative family but is only half conservative herself... you better learn to be respectful.
Like participating in Ramadan just as a cultural/sharing sort of experience. And being honest with them that pork and beer are part of your life but you won't have any on the days you'll be seeing her, and if marriage happens you'll reserve those things for times when you're out without her. And you damn well better learn a few polite phrases in her language. Arabic and Farsi both sound beautiful when a girl is saying sweet things to you
>>
File: 1443734753250.jpg (35 KB, 500x375) Image search: [Google]
1443734753250.jpg
35 KB, 500x375
>be muslim
>"koran is absolute truth"
>"islam encourage science and discoveries, skepticism is absolutely not part of it"
>>
>>52579699
I bet you also say PBUH after referring to Muhammad.
>>
>>52579699
How can you participate in sandnigger fairytale nonsense with a straight face? and why would you ever consider marrying someone who unironically thinks beer and bacon are bad, and who you know will absolutely try and indoctrinate any kids you have to become Muslim?
>>
>>52579273
>Is Islam at its core really that different from Christianity?
yes

> I've read the Quran a couple times
nerd

the core difference is that the quran is the literal, unquestionable, un-reformable, word of god. whereas christianity is 2000 years of the telephone game converted into written memespeak

t. ex-muslim
>>
File: 1438202918514.jpg (220 KB, 800x771) Image search: [Google]
1438202918514.jpg
220 KB, 800x771
>be muslim
>"koran is absolute truth, you can see it's scientic facts"
>be btfo in one passage
>"b-but if its proven wrong by science its merely a metaphore"
>>
>>52579813
It's all about learning to respect cultural differences. I wouldn't mind if my children chose to be Muslim so long as they are respectful to those with different beliefs

>How can you participate in sandnigger fairytale nonsense with a straight face?
This is silly fedora-tier logic
>>
>be muslim
>"no its, not putting the arabs in special regards. islam is discouraging discrimination"
>btfo by "le arab language" argument
>"arabs is the most degenerate group of people at that time guys! we should uses their language"
>>
>>52579699
If you have to change your culture to date a girl then they're not worth it. If she sees you're willing to forgo pork then she'll be happy to start pushing you to convert.

And let's be honest - muslim girls will not engage in pre marital sex. Their parents will demand that you become a muslim too if you're to marry them. The detriments simply outweigh all the benefits.

Stay away. If you want to date an Arab or Persian girl then find a Christian one.
>>
>>52579909
>I wouldn't mind if my children chose to be Muslim
TOP CVCK.
>>
>>52579699

>be me in high school
>become friends with some syrian girl
>sex with her at forest

lmao @ your life, nigga probably didn't even get laid
>>
>>52579273
>>52579413
>>52579567
Omg, islam shills actually exist.
>>
>>52579909
>unironically falling for cultural relativism

Islam deserves no respect, and your willingness to set aside things that are perfectly fine to please a Muslim reveals you as a spineless cuckold.
>>
>>52580149
t. Racist
>>
File: 1440880825087.png (93 KB, 190x185) Image search: [Google]
1440880825087.png
93 KB, 190x185
>be muslim
>be arguing whether islam given to arabs because they're degenerate or not
>"allah knew that great faithful people will emerge in arab, and arab is not a steady state yet".
>be implying that allah can see the future and since he create the universe its also implied that universe nature is deterministic
>be implying he knew the outcome, allah is being of no mistake
>"we need islam to prevent the ummah from acting contrary to what god want"
>>
>>52580182
Are you the same poster? If so I''m glad to see this was just bait and I don't inhabit the same country as this spineless moron.
>>
>>52579909
>Muslim so long as they are respectful to those with different beliefs

>muslim
>respectful to different beliefs

this is an oxymoron, muhammad literally went into the kaabah and destroyed every religious idol, and also genocided any boy old enough to have pubes from the banu qurayza tribe
>>
File: 20120227Ngelem210910-1.jpg (45 KB, 600x400) Image search: [Google]
20120227Ngelem210910-1.jpg
45 KB, 600x400
>be muslim
>"islam is objectively perfect, it contained every detail essential to human life"
>be clashed with other existing value of "perfect life" while trying to persuade them to accept islam, be shown islam's fault
>"w-well, its perfect for islamic life, its your lifestyle are degenerate, your whole value is wrong"
>>
>>52580406
Won't you get your hands chopped off for these posts or something?
>>
>>52579761
>>52579872
>>52580203
>>52580406
tips songkok
>>
>>52581116
he would've been killed off by the chinks if they took over anyway
>>
>>52580406
>be muslim
>in poland

rip
>>
>>52579273
Christianity is based entirely on the death and resurrection of Jesus. You can claim that the moral basis is similar, but it doesn't matter because Jesus pays for it all. The "outdated" parts are largely clean laws that belong to Judaism, but Jesus rejected.
>>
>>52579273
islam at it's core is christanity
>>
File: what-kind-of-jew-you-are.png (51 KB, 1302x1296) Image search: [Google]
what-kind-of-jew-you-are.png
51 KB, 1302x1296
>>52581522
fuck forgot pic
>>
>>52579983

>>high school
>>syrian
>>sex at forest
Eww nigga!
How the fuck can write that and think is ok? Canadians really are the filthy shit of the civilised world. You people need to be fumigated to death.
>>
>>52579983
Sorry wrong person.

>>52579990
This is for you u filthy cunt.>>52581585
>>
>>52579273
Yes, it's vastly different. Christianity is slave religion and Islam is a conqueror's diktat.

Christianity would be like Islam if Paul had become Caesar.
>>
>>52581675
it's fortunate that it's not up to the impotent christians to stop the mudslime
>>
>>52579413
Maori bro
>>
>>52579567
Yea sorry
>>
File: 1st-Shahada_white[1].jpg (77 KB, 1320x664) Image search: [Google]
1st-Shahada_white[1].jpg
77 KB, 1320x664
>>52581539
This portrayal for Islam has no basis to me. Nestorians retain core features of Cathodox Christianity which completely clash with Muslim theology such as an intricate ecclesiastical hierarchy and the Incarnation of God, & the Vicarious Atonement. I would say to originated more as a Judean Christian (as represented on the chart) phenomenon that substituted Arabic culture for the Hebraic. Grassroots congregational governance, fully human Christ & docetism were widespread doctrines in that milieu that would easily have been passed to Isalam.

Check out this quote from the Pseudo-Clementines, the historian's go-to guide for Jewish-Christianity:
"God is one and there is no God but Him"
Sound familiar?
>>
>>52582430
well muhhamad the pedo did a number on them and not all at once more like whenever his dick got hard allah spoke to him in his dream told him it's okay cause...
>>
File: 1450132406402.jpg (28 KB, 250x242) Image search: [Google]
1450132406402.jpg
28 KB, 250x242
>>52579273
>I've read the Quran a couple times
>NEW MUSLAND
>>
File: image.jpg (380 KB, 1600x1200) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
380 KB, 1600x1200
>>52579273
God damn those eyes make my dick rock hard.
>tfw no muslim gf
>>
File: 1449225595974.png (333 KB, 729x1416) Image search: [Google]
1449225595974.png
333 KB, 729x1416
>>52579273
Pic related.

Islam is less ambiguous.
>>
All of the Abraham-religions can fuck right off. It's literally like furries that tries to get everyone else to live like furries for the great futa cock in the ground. It's weird, retarded, and if the proof for the futa-cock in the ground for real is "You can't NOT prove that it exist", that does not make it real.

Don't force your flaccid holy little rinkled cock down my throat, thank you very much.
>>
>>52585207
Queue the aussie with the penis down swedish throat - joke.
>>
File: 1448632762004.jpg (9 KB, 308x270) Image search: [Google]
1448632762004.jpg
9 KB, 308x270
>>52579273
>I've read the Quran a couple times (courted some muslim girls on and off over the years, made attempts to understand and be respectful)

TRUE BLUE
>>
>>52585207
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQBgrUObbHw
>>
>>52579273
>yeah it has similar outdated stuff like the bible but most people on both sides don't pay attention to those parts any more.
>>
>>52579273
Islam is more similar to Judaism than Christianity.
>>
>>52579273
future isis extremist detected
>>
>>52579273
Christian kids are taught from a young age the whole If someone slaps you, you turn the other cheek. Muslims are taught to seek out revenge at all costs plus it's the small differences on a persons up bringing that will basically make the most difference on how a person will turn out when he is older.
>>
Most people in the West who claim to have read the Quran, mean that they read a few cherry-picked quotes on some facebook post one time.
>>
File: Screenshot_2015-12-22-16-00-31_1.jpg (218 KB, 1078x1674) Image search: [Google]
Screenshot_2015-12-22-16-00-31_1.jpg
218 KB, 1078x1674
Islam is fundamentally different from both Christianity and Judaism in its moral system, while Judaism and Christianity portray weakness as a virtue, Islam defines virtue as strength and is closer to western pagan religions. No "turn the other cheek", no "love thy neighbour", no "pray for thy enemies", no "the smallest among you is the biggest in God's eye".

The white westerners are still pious Christians who have stripped the faith from its theological aspects and kept only the perverted moral system, and they brand anything resistant to their collective insanity evil.
>>
>>52579273
>Is Islam at its core really that different from Christianity?
Now, they're both bullshit you can believe only if you have to be brainwashed since childhood.
>>
>I've been courting a mislim girl
>I have read the Quran

Read it again. It's against their rules for a girl to date anyone before marriage, and their codex started does not support marrying with non believers. If found out, she will be stoned and you will be killed as part of their honour killing traditions and shit
>>
>>52579273
I just came here to say You dear sir are a fagot. I hope that you get your Muslim gir and you both get Islamed. How horny must one be to be willing to read Qur'an to get some pussy? I am Muslim and I haven't read it. Dude hire a prostitute.
>>
File: boy-rolling-eyes.jpg (45 KB, 196x257) Image search: [Google]
boy-rolling-eyes.jpg
45 KB, 196x257
>>52589699
>I am Muslim
>I haven't read the Qur'an

What the fuck, grow a brain already
>>
File: 1440374493706.jpg (17 KB, 268x284) Image search: [Google]
1440374493706.jpg
17 KB, 268x284
>>52586838
>islam strenght
>go and make babies we cant win in a fight so lets win in birth rates

the most pathetic and weak method of taking over a continent, Islamic man are way too weak .
>>
>>52590295
this desu
islam failed to conquer europe for 1500 years and is only managing it because europe became so successful that birth rates plummeted
>>
>>52579813
Probably similar to how I participate in stupid middle eastern religions like Christianity to get in with church chicks.
>>
>>52585510
i knew the jews were somehow behind 9/11
>>
File: 1409260920001.jpg (43 KB, 469x463) Image search: [Google]
1409260920001.jpg
43 KB, 469x463
>>52591040
>>
>>52579273
Not really, muzzies are just generally shit.
Thread replies: 71
Thread images: 19

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.