[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Is there any nation that resisted more concerted attempts at
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /his/ - History & Humanities

Thread replies: 113
Thread images: 17
File: Catholicism_in_Ireland.png (540 KB, 784x1023) Image search: [Google]
Catholicism_in_Ireland.png
540 KB, 784x1023
Is there any nation that resisted more concerted attempts at genocide?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I0zBlHlnR4Y
>>
File: aint free salvation.png (68 KB, 853x872) Image search: [Google]
aint free salvation.png
68 KB, 853x872
>more than 80%
>gay marriage by popular vote
Paddies are the worst Catholics
>>
File: SsPUvUz.jpg (17 KB, 306x423) Image search: [Google]
SsPUvUz.jpg
17 KB, 306x423
Is there any thread that has been posted more times?
>>
>>953012
>DUDE GOD LMAO XD
>DUDE ATHEISTS LMAO XD
Two more threads
>>
>>953013
Has nothing to do with whether God really exists or not, which both sides believed in the affirmative.

It has to do with whether any nation endured as much as the Irish and Old English Catholics that became Irish as a result of the Protestant English and Scottish attempts at genocide in Ireland.
>>
>>953020
Reread my post and the one I replied to
>>
>>953007
Serbia maybe?
>>
>>953026
He said real nation, not fan fiction.
>>
>>953013

DUDE RHODESIA
>>
>>953035
DUDE ROME
DUDE HITLER
>>
>>953007
Armenia
Georgia
Serbia
Korea
Poland
Finland.....
>>
>>953042
>Poland
>Finland
>Korea

I don't think you understand the nature of the occupation of Ireland compared to these.

The first three are arguable and you should proceed.
>>
>>953041
DUDE PHILOSOPHY IS OBSOLETE
>>
>>953051
Indeed.
>>
>>953007

I commend the Irish for their resistance but they are heretics and their religion is of scum roots. At least the English rid themselves of this evil catholic cult.

See >>952003
>>
>>953046
Korea's occupation was worse than any extended peacetime occupation of Ireland.

t. Irish Studies major.
>>
Can you please stop meming in my thread.
>>
>>953007

objectively superior version of that song coming through

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rwHm18K3kjs
>>
>>953057
The intensity of the Korean occupation was certainly worse but it was extremely brief compared to Ireland's which I think makes the resistance by Ireland more impressive. Also, Korea cucked out more than Ireland did even though they were only annexed for 30 years.
>>
>>953057
>t. irish studies major (at an anglo university)

fixed
>>
>>953065
Try again.
>>
>>953057

go to bed Colum.
>>
>>953060
>They shout more than they sing.
>Not as melodic
>Objectively better
>>
>>953073

what are you, some kind of nancyboy?

It's called spirit.
>>
File: matejko-battle-of-grunwald.jpg (1 MB, 2560x1087) Image search: [Google]
matejko-battle-of-grunwald.jpg
1 MB, 2560x1087
>>953046
you said:
>resisted more concerted attempts at genocide

Poland have resisted numerous attempts to destroy them...from the Northern Crusades to the Soviet Occupation.

Oh I'd also ad Hungry to that list.
>>
>>953080
The Poles didn't have Penal Laws and they weren't banned from owning land in their own country. Also, a war of conquest does not in itself constitute an attempt at genocide.
>>
>>953064
Ireland wasn't actually occupied for 800 years ya know...
>>
>>953086
Starting with the Tudors it was actively occupied for 400 years.
>>
>>953084
Nazis did both to the Poles...Soviets too.

Also, Mongols dude....Mongols.
>>
>>953094
>comparing like 9 years to 400
>>
File: Armenia History Had Enough.png (408 KB, 648x4040) Image search: [Google]
Armenia History Had Enough.png
408 KB, 648x4040
Armenia. Thousands of years later, and still here.
>>
>>953102
>resisted more concerted
-Germans
-Mongols
-Germans again
-Turks
-Germans and Russians
-Germans yet again
-Russians

vs Ireland

-Protestants from Britain

Poland beats Ireland 8-1
>>
>>953119
Getting conquered is not being genocided you dense fuck, why don't you understand the difference?
>>
>>953115
You should read the rules for this board.
>>
>>953007
forgot about the Czechs....
>>
>>953129
When did the Germans try to kill all the Czechs?
>>
>>953123
Brits never really tried to actively exterminate the Irish...keep them down? yep. reduce their population? yep. not exterminate though.

also resist...the Irish really only successfully resisted the Brits twice...in the early 1600s and then again in the 1920s.

Poles and Hungarians have a much better track record of successful resistance, and against more foes.
>>
>>953138
The 'democratic' wishes of a gerrymandered constituency are irrelevant.
>>
>>953139
They definitely tried to exterminate the Irish. The reason the Irish didn't just fish during the Potato famine? They weren't allowed.
>>
>>953132
by the standards set by the OP:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hussite_Wars

also 30 Years War...and WW2.
>>
>>953152

There were plenty of Catholic Czechs who wanted nothing to do with the Hussite shit. Also the 30 years' war was originally about who had the right to rule Bohemia, and it was Protestants who made it about religion. The Hussites also defeated themselves, lol.
>>
File: I ran Away.jpg (63 KB, 700x915) Image search: [Google]
I ran Away.jpg
63 KB, 700x915
>>953145
Protestants have always made up the majority of Ulster.
Sorry if you don't like that, Taig.
Must really anger you that people want to remain part of Britain rather than joining your Godless heathen shithole.

Ireland will only ever be united under a union jack.
>>
>>953151
The Potato Famine was...AT WORST...an accidental attempt at population reduction. Not an attempt to exterminate the Irish people.

The famine was callous stupidity and cruelty at it's finest, but genocide wasn't the goal.

>the Highland Clearances on the other hand.
>>
>>953161
fine, fine....not the Czechs.
>>
>>953162
>always
>implying
The creation of Northern Ireland was completely damage control. It was created around a majority of Protestants, it didn't happen to have a majority of Protestants.

The Republic doesn't even want Northern Ireland because it's just a shitehole.

No one cares anyway. This is a thread about the pre-1921 history.
>>
>>953169
Northern Ireland has always existed. It's called Ulster.
>>
>>953177
Then why isnt all of Ulster in your gerrymanderd constituency retard?
>>
File: wellington-3-sized.jpg (28 KB, 249x315) Image search: [Google]
wellington-3-sized.jpg
28 KB, 249x315
>>953007
Also the Irish were curiously shit at resistance...I saw curiously because the Irish, both as common soldiers and officers, were great fighters. They served wonderfully in the Spanish, French, American and even British armies.

Their leadership was strangely shit....
>>
>>953177
>>953162
Except you took a large amount of Catholics with you because Northern Ireland is an illegitimate shithole that couldn't survive on it's own
>>
>>953183
Wellington was not Irish or even an old Anglo he was an English planter whose family was part of the original attempts at genocide
>>
File: No Niggers Belfast.jpg (70 KB, 560x342) Image search: [Google]
No Niggers Belfast.jpg
70 KB, 560x342
>>953180
Because Donegal, Monaghan and Cavan are all massive shitholes, even by taig standards, unfit for protestant habitation even 100 years ago.

>>953184
Don't like it, come and take it hard man.
See how long you last before you give up and go back to the republic.
>>
>>953190
so you admitted it was an artificial construct for protestant and english imperial damage control. just wanted to establish that. carry on.
>>
>>953011

>Martin Luther

prove yet again that Germans try to ruin everything for everyone
>>
>>953194
Nothing artificial about it.
The protestants of Ulster wanted to remain British.
They didn't want home rule, they didn't want to be ruled by Rome and they didn't want to join the a republic.

What would you have done?
Forced them out of their homeland?
Murdered them?

It was their democratic right.
>>
>>953202
I suppose it's the democratic right for London to secede and form a Beylik, too.
>>
>>953202
they were the ones who didn't want to be governed in Ireland. Ireland was very fair to Protestants who remained in places like Dublin. The Protestants were the ones making a big stink about their existence there, not the Catholics.
>>
>>953202
>It's their democratic right to have their votes counted separately from the people voting against them in the same place
>>
>>953187
>Wellington was not Irish or even an old Anglo he was an English planter whose family was part of the original attempts at genocide
Wellington's paternal grand-father's surname was Colley
>The Colley or Cowley family had come to Ireland from Rutland about 1500
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Wesley,_1st_Baron_Mornington

His family had lived in Ireland for over 250 years before he was born.

any who...enjoy this pic...another great moment in Irish military history.
>>
>>953057
>t. Irish Studies major.

is this the equivalent to gender studies

I'll take a grande pike place, boyo
>>
>>953204
No.
Muslims are parasites that do nothing but leech.
Protestants built Ulster, brick by brick. It's different.

>>953210
Yeah, because they'd seen catholic barbarism first hand.

The Irish murdered protestant babies during the English Civil war.
They behaved like total apes.

That's exactly what would have happened to the Ulstermen had we not saved them and delivered them from the jaws of republican peril.
>>
File: cup-of-smug.jpg (8 KB, 235x218) Image search: [Google]
cup-of-smug.jpg
8 KB, 235x218
>>953225
Sure thing buddy
>>
>>953204
No, it's more like the democratic right of the Bogside to secede and form Free Derry.
>>
>reminder that the Battle of the Boyne was actually a battle between the Dutch and French...not the English and Irish.
>>
>>953225
>Bringing up behavior from 1640
>Ignoring Cromwell

Just goes to show the only reason Protestants are so paranoid is that they know they have blood on their hands and are terrified of retribution even if Catholics don't care anymore.
>>
File: maxresdefault.jpg (60 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
maxresdefault.jpg
60 KB, 1280x720
>>953225
>>953243
>triggered by the 17th century.

damn you people can hold a grudge....
>>
>>953255
No one is thicker than an orangeman, they are a complete shit show from one end of the day to the next.
>>
>Anglos try to genocide Irish
>Anglos try to genocide Boers
Why does anyone like these guys again?
>>
>>953215
>Came over with the planters in the 1500s

Yup that's basically what I said.
>>
>>953267
No one loves England, not even the English. If you gave Americans a choice between Ireland and England in a poll they'd get BTFO by their "closest ally," even though Ireland is SJW and neutral.
>>
>>953115
>Christ, my last name's Irish and even I hate those fenian pricks.
Read the rest of the post in an Irish accent after this.
>>
>>953115
The Irish weren't allowed to fish during the famines
>>
>never actually get genocided
>still end up being catholic brits, don't even speak irish
>make yourself look like the biggest victim of them all
i wish the brits actually tried to genocide them
>>
>>953369
The whole point is that they tried to genocide Catholics whether they were native Celts or Anglo-Normans who came over in the 1200s-1400s.
>>
>>953123
>Poles weren't genocided
the teutons literally slaughtered everyone in Gdansk during their takeover, similar with the rest of Polish lands they stole

Germans after unification went ham with shit like prohibiting the language in public, forcing Poles to sell land and sell it back to germans for a fraction of the price, teach everything in german, even prayers and make an unreasonable amount of anti-polish propaganda

russians also taught in russian, destroy the grecocatholic church etc
>>
>>953383
The Teutons slaughtered the Old Prussians on BEHALF of the Poles. All of that shit in the modern era is light-weight compared to the cruelty perpetrated by England.
>>
>>953392
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teutonic_takeover_of_Danzig_(Gda%C5%84sk)
>>
>>953415
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teutonic_takeover_of_Danzig_(Gda%C5%84sk)
>Sacking a city is ethnic genocide

Yeah okay.
>>
>>953162
Wait what? no the protestants did not always make the majority. Before the planter protestants the majority of Ulster was Gaelic Catholic.
>>
>>953183
It's because the chieftains and kings were always bickering with each other which meant there was no coherent leadership among the Irish. The Irish themselves are great soldiers when battles don't involve anything to do with Ireland as the clan mindset takes over.
>>
Lol the Irish aren't even people
>>
>>953007

>""""""" resisted """"""""
>>
File: 1432865393511.jpg (8 KB, 340x508) Image search: [Google]
1432865393511.jpg
8 KB, 340x508
>>953618
>>
I wish the Irish were genocided, they're fucking useless
>>
File: 1439844286024.jpg (21 KB, 360x517) Image search: [Google]
1439844286024.jpg
21 KB, 360x517
>>954237
>>
>>953094
Bismarck's laws did ban Poles from owning land.
>>
>>953053
pay denbts Kostas.

Also Istanbul is Turkish
>>
>>953162
>always
look up what that means

>Ulster.
Look up what that means
>>
>>953190

You realise Northern Ireland only exists because it's funded by Britain? Without British soldiers and British money, Northern Ireland would implode. The Irish Army nearly invaded Northern Ireland three times, only stopping because of Britain.
>>
>>953202

>It's their democratic right to drive the native Irish off their lands and then insist for centuries that Northern Ireland is British
>>
>>953256

An Orangeman is the following:

Muh fleg.
Muh lodge.
Muh parade.

They're an embarrassment.
>>
Northern Irish Unionists are the most easily triggered faggots on the fucking planet. They are a humiliation.

That and they cannot fucking handle the bantz from the IRA.

>reading about the Great Escape in the Troubles

THE BEST
>>
File: vinegar hill.jpg (230 KB, 960x625) Image search: [Google]
vinegar hill.jpg
230 KB, 960x625
what a fucking shitty version of a good song

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bUVSvit98Zw&nohtml5=False

And come tell me Sean O'Farrell, tell me why you hurry so
Hush a bhuachaill, hush and listen and his cheeks were all aflow
I bear orders from the captain, get you ready quick and soon
With your pike upon your shoulder at the rising of the moon
At the rising of the moon, at the rising of the moon
With your pike upon your shoulder at the rising of the moon

And come tell me Sean O'Farrell, where the gathering is to be
At the old spot by the river right well known to you and me
One more word for signal token, whistle up the marching tune
With your pike upon your shoulder at the rising of the moon
At the rising of the moon, at the rising of the moon
With your pike upon your shoulder at the rising of the moon

Out from many a mud walled cabin eyes were watching through the night
Many a manly heart was beating for the blessed warning light
Murmurs passed along the valley like the banshee's lonely croon
And a thousand pikes were flashing at the rising of the moon
At the rising of the moon, at the rising of the moon
And a thousand pikes were flashing at the rising of the moon

Well they fought for poor old Ireland, and full bitter was their fate
Oh what glorious pride and passion fills the men of '98
Yet thank God for men who's bleeding hearts
That gather at the moon
We will follow in their footsteps at the rising of the moon
At the rising of the moon, at the rising of the moon
We will follow in their follow in their footsteps at the rising of the moon
At the rising of the moon, at the rising of the moon...
And hurrah me boys for freedom!
'Tis the rising of the moon
>>
>>954249
biscuck policies against poles were garbage
around 100k Germans polonized themselves because they didn't want to become protestant
>>
File: images.jpg (6 KB, 243x207) Image search: [Google]
images.jpg
6 KB, 243x207
>muh poland
>muh shield of europe
>muh martyr of nations

>occupied by Russia for 45 years and didnt do shit

Yeah nah
>>
>>953080
Poles participated in the Northern Crusades you retard
>>
>>953374

you can't genocide a religion, though desu they did attempt to kill of the the native Celts.

The term you're looking for here is "ethnic cleansing".
>>
>>955125
>Genocide is the intent to systematically eliminate a cultural, ethnic, linguistic, national, racial or religious group
>>
>>955134
>Genocide

Genocide literally means "gene killing".

It is a systematic attempt to eradicate a biological structure. Not a cultural one.
>>
>>953026
I don't think anybody has ever tried to genocide the Serbs
>>
>>955141
You're a fucking dumbass.
genocide (n.) Look up genocide at Dictionary.com
1944, apparently coined by Polish-born U.S. jurist Raphael Lemkin (1900-1959) in his work "Axis Rule in Occupied Europe" [p.19], in reference to Nazi extermination of Jews, literally "killing a tribe," from Greek genos "race, kind" (see genus) + -cide. The proper formation would be *genticide.

Generally speaking, genocide does not necessarily mean the immediate destruction of a nation, except when accomplished by mass killings of all members of a nation. It is intended rather to signify a coordinated plan of different actions aimed at the destruction of essential foundations of the life of national groups, with the aim of annihilating the groups themselves. [Lemkin]

Earlier in a similar sense was populicide (1799), from French populicide, by 1792, a word from the Revolution. This was taken into German, as in Völkermeuchelnden "genocidal" (Heine), which was Englished 1893 as folk-murdering. Ethnocide is attested from 1974 in English (1970 in French).
>>
>>955153
>Dictionary.com

lol kid
>>
>>955153
It's not from dictionary.com. Do you recognize copypasta when you see it? You really are stupid.
>>
>>953267
The victor writes history. The Anglos are like the Jews.
>>
>>953007
They're your bionicles and you can do what you want dude but frankly it's a little weird to have them always gang up on po-koro and then post visualizations of the stats on a Californian renewable energy analytics blog
>>
>>953418
Poles are some of the most butthurt people out there and will make up lies to get attention. And i like poles, even married one.
>>
>>956797
Yesterday they were claiming that Ukrainian nazis were taking orders from Stalin in ww2
>>
>>953007
Cromwell should have done a better job desu.
>>953132
The Habsburgs literally destroyed Czech culture after the Thirty Years' War. By the late 18th century, Czech was a language only spoken by some of the peasantry and edgy enlightenment types in Prague. The edgy enlightenment types won the day.
>>
>>957342
Damn
>>
>>953042

>Finland
>Georgia

Since fucking when?
>>
>>953094

Soviets expanded Polish land.

Its the reason Poland looks as it does now.
>>
>>957876
>lose pre-war eastern provinces, a lot of them were unaffected by war
>get smaller provinces raging from piles of bricks to in best case the most undeveloped ex German lands pillaged by red army
gee thanks Stalin
>>
>>953162
>implying unionism isn't fucking dying
>implying every year the mdeia doesn't portray the orange order, the 11th and 12th in a worse light
>implying kids aren't growing up in an environment that teaches them it's cool to be irish and anti-conservative unionist
>implying NI won't have a nationalist majority in our lifetime
>implying britain isn't fucking doomed

GET A LOAD OF THIS KULTURE
>>
>>953225
Why couldn't fucks like u have stayed on the mainland. I have no problem with Protestants, people should be free to live where they want but don't fucking pretend you guys didn't come over here looking for trouble first.
Thread replies: 113
Thread images: 17

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.