[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Were the Soviets the good guys, /his/?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /his/ - History & Humanities

Thread replies: 146
Thread images: 44
Were the Soviets the good guys, /his/?
>>
File: Nuclear War.jpg (109 KB, 600x833) Image search: [Google]
Nuclear War.jpg
109 KB, 600x833
>>
Nah.
>>
File: 1452065289557.jpg (157 KB, 852x1200) Image search: [Google]
1452065289557.jpg
157 KB, 852x1200
>>
>>850369
no
>>
File: Washington.jpg (251 KB, 854x1200) Image search: [Google]
Washington.jpg
251 KB, 854x1200
>>
>>
Till about 1921.
>>
File: Our Triumph in Space.jpg (116 KB, 1028x665) Image search: [Google]
Our Triumph in Space.jpg
116 KB, 1028x665
>>
File: Literacy and Education.jpg (678 KB, 2186x3309) Image search: [Google]
Literacy and Education.jpg
678 KB, 2186x3309
>>
File: berlin-wall-comes-down-013.jpg (693 KB, 2560x1536) Image search: [Google]
berlin-wall-comes-down-013.jpg
693 KB, 2560x1536
>>
>>
>>850388
>Jewish SJW cuckocracy in the middle of a civil war and famine

Literally the worst Soviet period
>>
File: Evolution.jpg (109 KB, 722x1024) Image search: [Google]
Evolution.jpg
109 KB, 722x1024
>>
>>
File: Anti-Nuclear USSR 1985.jpg (294 KB, 960x1420) Image search: [Google]
Anti-Nuclear USSR 1985.jpg
294 KB, 960x1420
>>
File: 1980 Olympics.jpg (54 KB, 620x620) Image search: [Google]
1980 Olympics.jpg
54 KB, 620x620
>>
File: 1452064907238.jpg (572 KB, 1714x2568) Image search: [Google]
1452064907238.jpg
572 KB, 1714x2568
>>
Tis the final battle, let each stand in their place! The International Soviet shall be the human race!
>>
>>850369
>Claim to promote peace
>Start proxy wars all over the place

It's not even the proxy war part, it's the signature Russian lying and doublethink that seals the deal.
>>
File: hqnQTLe.jpg (90 KB, 550x802) Image search: [Google]
hqnQTLe.jpg
90 KB, 550x802
>>
File: May Day.jpg (166 KB, 578x1024) Image search: [Google]
May Day.jpg
166 KB, 578x1024
>>
File: NATO bombs.jpg (240 KB, 850x1200) Image search: [Google]
NATO bombs.jpg
240 KB, 850x1200
>>
File: revolt of 1956.jpg (99 KB, 940x768) Image search: [Google]
revolt of 1956.jpg
99 KB, 940x768
>>
>>850432
inb4 whataboutism and the Americans lynching niggers
>>
they certainly were not the good guys but the popular perception of the soviets hell bent on world domination through force could not really be farther from the truth - early on after ww2 they were shit scared of western aggression (hence building buffers), later they were all about that ideology and tacitly, not militarily, supporting what their ideology perceived as the oppressed masses in the west (the ironing) and not these james bond tier moustache twirling villains who wanted to bomb washington and invade texas or whatever
>>
>>850427
>Tis
they made it so fedora
>>
File: Prauge spring.jpg (63 KB, 550x407) Image search: [Google]
Prauge spring.jpg
63 KB, 550x407
>>
>>850447
>we were invading other countries because we were scared

Yep and serial killers are also just misunderstood about their tough childhood.
>>
>>850447
They actually were trying to take over the world (or liberate it, depending on your inclinations) up until the 20s.
>>
>>850452
You could say "It's the final battle" but that doesn't flow as well.

Or, "this, the final battle" but that sounds kind of weird.

Anything else has too many syllables.
>>
File: Forest brothers.jpg (200 KB, 700x379) Image search: [Google]
Forest brothers.jpg
200 KB, 700x379
>>
File: John paul.jpg (161 KB, 629x400) Image search: [Google]
John paul.jpg
161 KB, 629x400
>>
>>850473
Fuck that reactionary piece of shit.
>>
>>850432
I kek every time dostoyevsky shits on russian doublethink.

It makes his books hard to finish.
>>
File: Baltic way.jpg (31 KB, 469x300) Image search: [Google]
Baltic way.jpg
31 KB, 469x300
>>850478
Whatever
>>
>>850486
Seriously though, what the fuck is up with that ugly Lithuanian flag? It only looks good on jars of spinach they produce.
>>
>>850369
There is not "bad guys" or ''good guys'. All guys could do mistakes. Also, you are should understand, this is the international board, all relative, and every descendant wish remember good things about ancestors and famous rulers even a mongol about Genghis Khan.
Some actions of Soviet were wrong, and some actions were right. For example protection of society from narcotics was good much better than today; Cosmic Championship USA-USSR was profitable for Civilizations of Mankind.
In USSR Was tabac and alcohol monopolies; it is debatable question. For example modern post-USSR countries did not produce tabac at all, ant major part of alcohol market owned by foreign owners.
>>
File: hungary 1989.jpg (30 KB, 450x337) Image search: [Google]
hungary 1989.jpg
30 KB, 450x337
>>850490
Are you from Russia or Poland?
>>
>>850517
Neither. Yellow and green are bad enough but red and green are the ultimate eyesore. There's a reason Freddy Krueger sports those colors.
>>
>>850511
>Cosmic Championship
Holy shit, can we rename the Space Race to this in English
>>
File: enhanced-19301-1415891409-24.jpg (57 KB, 625x380) Image search: [Google]
enhanced-19301-1415891409-24.jpg
57 KB, 625x380
>still thinking of international relations in terms of good guys vs bad guys
>>
>>850553
I don't know what kind of translator Ivan ran that through but it's called Space Race in Russian too.
>>
File: gommies.png (339 KB, 460x454) Image search: [Google]
gommies.png
339 KB, 460x454
>>850369
no
>>
>>850564
Cosmic Championship sounds way cooler regardless.
>>
>>850596
>communists stand with black nationalists
err what
>>
>>850606
sounds like a sick Mario Kart track desu
>>
>>850610
superliberal omnifaggottery
>>
>>850610
>not knowing about soviet subversion groups
wew
>>
File: engligthement.png (254 KB, 500x406) Image search: [Google]
engligthement.png
254 KB, 500x406
>>850610
CIS SCUM!
>>
>>850625
let me guess

>muh Bezmenov
>>
File: 1409548165859.png (210 KB, 287x304) Image search: [Google]
1409548165859.png
210 KB, 287x304
>>850639
you know it buddy
>>
>>850637
>haha let's laugh at this strawman i made up look how dumb the opposition is haha
>>
>>850650
ADF is a self-made, uh, "thing".
>>
>>850639
Not him, but try Stanislav Lunev or Anatoli Golitsyn.
>>
>>850639
Are you implying that a guy speaking to the fucking John Birch Society might not be pandering to his audience a little?

Are you implying that MAYBE the KGB didn't devote 85% of its budget to cultural subversion, and one must be retarded to believe that?

No way!
>>
>>850650
I actually just wanted to point fun at the radical SJW groups that claim to be communism, not the whole Communist belief, but okay. You didn't need to be so mean.
Feeling really fucking bad here right now.
>>
>>850650
That's actually not a strawman, it's xir real quote.
>>
>>850639
Soviets supported people like Angela Davis openly, then we've got Carlos the Jackal, terrorists like RAF or Red Brigades. It's not too much of a stretch, especially since Russians have always loved using poorly disguised assassinations and terrorism to pursue their goals.
>>
>>850666
Do people not realize that Communists were the radical SJW groups of their day?
>>
>>850673
I don't get what's wrong with the quote if not paired with the ridiculous image.
>>
>>850685
The ridiculous image is the person who said it you mong.

https://encyclopediadramatica.se/Adf-fuensalida
>>
>>850511
>In USSR were tabac and alcohol monopolies; it is debatable question.
Even Tsar Ivan III of Russia (1502 C.E.) had used alcohol monopolies. Seem it was not bad for national treasury, but bad for morale. If country get profit from soldering, it have interest in soldering folk. That like schizophrenia, dualism of interests.
>All guys could do mistakes.
Ban citizens of USSR right to voyages in foreign countries was certainly bad. But I can't find dates of start and end of that action. For example Vladimir Mayakovsky was at Germany and France in 1924 and in La Habana and Mexico City in 1925. Don't know about Soviet voyages ban ukase, maybe Stalin start it.
>>
>>850688
There's also this, that's safe for work.
https://lolcow.wiki/wiki/Ahuviya_Harel

>People on 4chan not knowing aout ADF
>>
>>850701
>Samefagging this hard
>>
>>850677
This.
>>
>>850369
What's a good guy? They were just people acting under cultural pressures, nothing good or bad about it.
>>
>>850716
That's not a bad thing though.
>>
>>850733
t. ADF
>>
File: 1458163447233.jpg (58 KB, 572x563) Image search: [Google]
1458163447233.jpg
58 KB, 572x563
>>850733
>>
>>850751
>social justice is bad

How?
>>
File: 1458101825809.jpg (44 KB, 316x533) Image search: [Google]
1458101825809.jpg
44 KB, 316x533
>>850733
>>
>>850564
No, literal translation is Cosmic Championship/Race
>>
>>850753
Muh white genocide or cultural marxism or cucks or something
>>
>>850674
>Soviets supported people like Angela Davis openly
Of course, because she was with cloth political opinions with party at wheel in USSR.
Financing political parties and election campaigns from foreign money is known practice in modern political world. For example Muammar Gaddafi did financing of Nicolas Sarkozy at Presidential of France elections in 2007.
>>
Those are some cool propaganda but even back in time people snickered and found them ironic at best.
>>
>>850369
If you're a big fan of ethnic cleansing, starvation and oppression.
>>
File: 1455671008338.jpg (140 KB, 1035x784) Image search: [Google]
1455671008338.jpg
140 KB, 1035x784
>>850769
Not the guy you're replying to but I genuinely love these posts. Furthermore almos every single thread about Soviet psyops goes like this:

>Soviets paid off armed insurgence and people who wanted to disrupt order in the US
<Proof? Give us some proof because it sounds like you just made it up.
>Sure, look up [name some guy]
<Wow that's fucking nothing, sounds like a /pol/ tinfoil theory
>But here's some more relevant evidence that [accused person] was in fact a Soviet agent
<SO WHAT? EVERYONE DOES IT, AMERICANS HAD PSYOPS TOO!
>>
>>850790
the americans were lynching negroes
>>
>>850405
this is pretty 2001.
>>
>>850797
At least the Amercians had niggers.
>>
>>850803
Russians are niggers of Russia.
>>
>>850797
50 to 60 million lynchings? Linked to just one president?
>>
File: 1417732418805.jpg (8 KB, 216x209) Image search: [Google]
1417732418805.jpg
8 KB, 216x209
>>850753
>>
File: Selfie23.jpg (24 KB, 276x280) Image search: [Google]
Selfie23.jpg
24 KB, 276x280
>>850807
>>
>>850808
>he actually believes that retarded '60 million' figure

If you think it about it for one second, you'll realize Stalin would have had to lose about half the USSR's population and then some thanks to the war, and somehow rebuilt it entirely within some fifteen years.
>>
File: zYb2ez3.jpg (254 KB, 865x1200) Image search: [Google]
zYb2ez3.jpg
254 KB, 865x1200
for all their shortcomings the commies were pretty aesthetic tbqh
>>
>>850753
because the idea that someone is entitled to something based purely on their skin colour, sexuality, gender, etc. is fundamentally wrong in my view. Don't get me wrong, I'm not against social equality, however, the idea of justice bring connotations that involve all white people having to apologise for slavery which they took no part in, all men having to apologise for patriarchy which they took no part in, I could go on. Needless to say, we know slavery is was wrong, however, we don't make black people apologise for the Barbary slave trade, nor do we often talk about the crimes carried out by the Suffragette movement. Instead we learn that 'if you're white you don't know what it's like to be poor' or you can't experience racism. You could call such a system in which white people are now being viewed negatively by people a form of justice, that doesn't mean it's good. Social justice is very much anti-equality.
>>
>>850828
>because the idea that someone is entitled to something based purely on their skin colour, sexuality, gender,

They're entitled to equal rights. There can't be any justice until that point, which is the reasoning behind 'social justice'.
>>
>>850833
I'm not denying people are entitled to equal rights, what I'm saying is the ideology of social justice is the wrong way to achieve this.
>>
>>850828
I think slavery, lynching and segregation were legitimate problems. The thing is, after they got abolished, the lefties kind of ran out of shit to fight against, so they pulled new, artificial problems out of their ass. Now every time anything happens, it's because of white racism.

Black people do drugs? Racism.
Black people are poor? Racism.
White people move out of inner city areas? Racism.
White people move back to inner city areas? Racism.
White cop shoots a black criminal? Racism.
A white gay man talks like a black woman? Racism.
A sports team is named the Indians? Racism.
White kid dresses up like a native warrior for Halloween? Racism.
People have preferences when it comes to dating? Racism.

Fighting against fictional problems.
>>
>>850853
>things disappear as soon as legislation is passed against them
>>
>>850860
Give me a single tangible example of a structural racist oppression in the contemporary American society.
>>
File: jews.png (897 KB, 683x811) Image search: [Google]
jews.png
897 KB, 683x811
There is only one bad guy... and they are all of them.

Russians? Americans?

All of them.

Also, the Majestic 12 were mostly made up of these guys.
>>
>>850879
he wasn't alone
>>
File: 1457494876682.jpg (70 KB, 540x960) Image search: [Google]
1457494876682.jpg
70 KB, 540x960
>>850864
>no replies

Yep.
>>
File: Shining.jpg (78 KB, 403x604) Image search: [Google]
Shining.jpg
78 KB, 403x604
>>850893
It has been like ten minutes, shillax.
>>
>>850369
Only to reprobates.
>>
>>850369
The USSR and USA were both fucked up in their own ways

But the Soviets are cooler, so I guess that tips the favors a little
>>
>>851009
>Soviets are cooler

If mass rapes and famines are your idea of cool.
>>
>>851045
>MUH SOVIET RAPES

The Germans raped a shitton of women when they invaded the USSR.

Such a fucking dumb meme.
>>
File: USSU.jpg (105 KB, 1024x699) Image search: [Google]
USSU.jpg
105 KB, 1024x699
>>851045
that does sound pretty cool
>>
>>851045
And?
>>
>>851009
The USA got 4chan.
>>
>>851073
People should stop holding up mass rapes as something unique to the Red Army to prove they were barbarians or whatever.

Doesn't make it okay.
>>
>>851078
Just an English version of a Japanese format
Even got bought out by Japan in the end
Plus everyone on 4chan is a Rusoboo anyway
>>
>>851080
Well the question wasn't USSR vs Nazi Germany but USSR vs USA. Not to mention the Soviet didn't rape just in Germany, they raped in every country they "liberated", from Poland to Romania. It's pretty well documented.
>>
File: 1457966705780.jpg (27 KB, 673x600) Image search: [Google]
1457966705780.jpg
27 KB, 673x600
>>850833
>not realizing that these social justice groups have every right everyone else does in this day and age

Tell me do you enjoy self-flagelation or are you a member of one of these "oppressed" groups?
>>
>>851094
>Rusaboo
Apart from those who actually live in Russia.
And gookmoot don't even know how the place work.
Also, freedom of speech and all that.
>>
File: batesex.jpg (55 KB, 498x500) Image search: [Google]
batesex.jpg
55 KB, 498x500
>>851111
http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/thirteenthamendment.html
>>
>>851138
Shit, I always thought that thing looked like something form a reindeer until now.
Made me think he was fucking a furry or something.
>>
File: Hang In There.jpg (87 KB, 960x960) Image search: [Google]
Hang In There.jpg
87 KB, 960x960
>>850369
The USSR and the USA were (and are still in the USA) just crazed by their scope of power and influence. Yes, the USSR was shit compared to the US, but most people in the USSR didn't think they were poor. Stalin was a bad guy, but like Hitler, did good as well and the whole history of the Soviet Union shouldn't be judged by that more than the US should be blamed for genocide and puppet dictatorships. The US and the USSR suppressed political opinions that didn't suit their society (though the USSR did way worse with this) and they were both propaganda states. Personally, I think socialism is shit but I think if the Soviet Union didn't dissolve but the Gorbachev reforms still passes, with the exception of Moscow's upper class, government (even that's questionable) and Baltic prosperity I don't think those areas would be that different. So in short, the Soviets weren't the good guys, but neither is the US.
>>
>>851073
>ADF

literally who
>>
>>850459
Maybe it's just a stupid fucking phrase and Leftist protest cadences need to go the way of the dinosaur
>>
>>851879
see >>850688 and >>850709

Average marxist.
>>
>>851897
It's an old song, not a protest cadence. And it pretty much has already gone the way of the dinosaur.
>>
>>850369
They were until Stalin passed.
>>
>>850807
This is actually the case
>>
>>851921
I'm talking about "THIS IS WHAT DEMOCRACY LOOKS LIKE" "BLACK LIVES MATTER" "YOU'RE A FUCKING! WHITE! MALE!"
All retarded shit.
>>
>>851937
>le marx never worked meme
>your personal failings discredit everything you ever say

>Capitalism guarantees your write to choose your exploiter

This is why the Cheka was necessary.
>>
>>851917
I've noticed most people who adhere to radical ideologies, whether right or left wing tend to be socially retarded beta spergs.

Including myself, unfortunately.
>>
>>851945
I unironically agree.
>>
>>850833
they already have equal rights though
>>
>>851994
A few dead peasants are worth the dead Kulaks and aristocrats.

>yes goy

Do /pol/lacks really still think this is funny?
>>
>>850864
funnily enough, one of the most prominent examples of structural racist oppression in contemporary American society is biased against whites

I'm talking about colleges of course - black people are far more likely to be accepted into a college than a white person, despite having the same grades
>>
>>851994
Kulaks weren't average though.
>>
>>852009
>muh reverse racism

wew
>>
>good guys
stop this meme
>>
>>852007
Humor is subjective, goy.
>>
>>852007
"""Kulaks""" are a meme. To be considered a kulak you had to own more than two cows, that's not wealth and position of power, that's just being a regular peasant.

It was always stupid ass urban workers and spoiled ass city salon socialists who pushed this Marxism meme. Rural people, both the peasantry and the aristocracy were having none of that. There's something about living in a city which makes you batshit stupid.

>Do /pol/lacks really still think this is funny?
It's not funny, it's the truth. And I think it's pretty obvious what kind of person would get butthurt about that.
>>
>>850369
Communism and the Soviets had good critiques of the west. They just aren't good systems to live under.
>>
>>852013
Yes they were.
>>
>>852042
No they weren't.
>>
>>852043
See >>852030
>>
>>852030
Kulaks were real. Their influence was exaggerated by the Bolsheviks, but there really were numerous instances of grain-hoarding by wealthy peasants during the Civil War.

>It's not funny, it's the truth.

What's the truth?
>>
>>852030
>Rural people, both the peasantry and the aristocracy were having none of that.
Lol just fuck off fake
>>
>>852046
>To be considered a kulak you had to own more than two cows
You consciously don't know what you're talking about but you chose to pretend that you do. Why is this?
>>
>>852055
They weren't real. Even after the bolsheviks confiscated EVERYTHING they were baffled that they had food shortages and invented a myth of some sneaky kulaks who hid all the grain and meat, in order for the people not to turn on them. It was a good old fashioned witch hunt.

>>852059
What's fake, you dumb cuckold? When bolsheviks came to power the rural people viewed it as serfdom returning.
>>
>>850369
There are no good guys, you dip.
>>
>>850797
Actually.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuskegee_syphilis_experiment
>>
File: OneBurialMan.png (2 MB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
OneBurialMan.png
2 MB, 1920x1080
Yes.
>>
File: image.jpg (98 KB, 660x916) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
98 KB, 660x916
>>
These conversations are all fun and games until someone gets nuked
>>
Nice pics.

BTW, do you gyus know why translating works was the main occupation of most writers in commie countries? Because they could only write about apprvoed topics and in approved style, while translating foreign works was relatively unhindered so they could engage in all kinds of themes, subjects and style.
>>
>>852030
So much this. My ancestors were deemed kulaks, my grandfather told me lot of stories from the time, for example the only people turnt communists in their village were the absolute landless and those of the most sneaky, underhandling character.

Also my great grandfather had a saying he didn't hide even in the harshest 50s times - "communists aren't human but slime and parasites, but you aren't human either since you don't beat down communists".

Then when revolution came they lynched the local commisar lol.
>>
File: 14568369421590.jpg (48 KB, 600x443) Image search: [Google]
14568369421590.jpg
48 KB, 600x443
>>850490
>>850527
Thread replies: 146
Thread images: 44

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.