[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
why are vikings remembered as warriors when they were much better
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /his/ - History & Humanities

Thread replies: 64
Thread images: 15
File: imageGallery_3.jpg (547 KB, 2048x1365) Image search: [Google]
imageGallery_3.jpg
547 KB, 2048x1365
why are vikings remembered as warriors when they were much better sailors and explorers?
>>
>>1394991
Except no, viking literally means someone who goes out and raids towns and shit. It's like using US Marines to refer to everyone in the US of A.
>>
File: lindisfarne.jpg (3 MB, 1690x1812) Image search: [Google]
lindisfarne.jpg
3 MB, 1690x1812
>>1394991

contemporary propaganda
>>
>>1394991

They conquered England

And Norman viking descendants conquered England again

Also the whole looting and burning monestaries and having an economy based on a large part of slaves they brought home or sold off to get steel and luxury goods
>>
>>1394991
Because memes and the Viking Invasion of England.
>>
>>1394991
They are simply glorified assholes that neo pagans love to jerk off to kekerino
>>
>>1394991
Butthurt monks who wrote the History
>>
File: norse.jpg (585 KB, 1280x1718) Image search: [Google]
norse.jpg
585 KB, 1280x1718
>>
>>
they weren't literate so couldn't write about how cool they were while the monks cried into their books about being cucked by them
>>
Because the people who wrote about them were usually people they attacked.
>>
>>1396255
>>1396008
These
if you look in to Russian / Greek / Arab writings about Vikings they tell quite a different story compared to western Latin Monks.

Vikings were scary as shit to coastal Europeans in the west because they tended to appear almost out of nowhere, take your shit and be gone before you could do anything. Ironically the monks who were so pissed and scared of Vikings helped create the myths and legends that still draw norseboos in to the "stronkest warriors ever" meme
>>
>>1394991
Not to get political, but who is more memorable: Omar Mateen, or the cashier from Best Buy?
>>
>>1394991

Because few Scandinavians were actually "vikings" and there were other things. "Viking" is pretty much a meme.
>>
Because vikingr was a profession, not an ethnicity
>>
Also they were probably not great warriors. Somewhere in flanders or somewhere they lost repeatedly to the franks. Mail and helmets were probably rare too since we only have like 1 found helmet (the classical nasal one), and most of them would use spears.

Dunno, then again all of the ulfbehrts were wielded by vikings
>>
>>1396828
The Franks still payed Danegeld to them many times and ended up giving Normandy to them
>>
>>1394991
Because their sailing and exploring had basically zero consequences for the rest of the world. Nobody but scholars should care about them travelling to the Americas, considering it didn't matter and nothing happened when they did.

On the other hand their niggering was remembered because nobody likes to get raided.
>>
>>1396878
Did you expect them to go and burn scandinavia to stop the raids?
>>
>>1394997
The term originates from the 19th century
>>
>>1394997
"to go on viking." Was a saying and it basicly ment someone leaving home with the intent of comming back richer. This doesn't nessacry imply raiding tho, a merchant leaving would also be 'on viking'
>>
>>1396909
Nah, Snorre used the word as a verb for raiding/warring/mercenary. IIRC he used it with Olaf II ("to go viking") before he returned to norway.

I could be wrong
>>
>>1394991
Because they excelled at war alongside these other two features of their lifestyles. Being a Viking was a premise based on violence, and attaining goods through plunder. Heathen pirates of the North Sea, attacking oh so holy Christendom makes for good history. Try reading up on the Great Heathen Army, the Danelaw, and Knut the Great if you're interested. Furthermore with Ireland, the Battle of Clontarf, and the trading port cities like Dublin.
>>
>>1396285
You're forgetting the Varangian guard. The term 'vikings' was not contemporary and is little more than a later construct. There were many different peoples under an umbrella you could call Scandinavian. Most were not raiders, but those that were left an impression.
>>
File: image.jpg (11 KB, 800x146) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
11 KB, 800x146
>>1396828
>all of the ulfberhts were wielded by vikings
That's not true, Stephan I. of Hungary also wielded an Ulfberht in battle.
>>
File: CMON.jpg (247 KB, 324x632) Image search: [Google]
CMON.jpg
247 KB, 324x632
>>1394999
>tfw that farmer about to avenge his confessor with a pitchfork
>>
File: 4JmK2Ub.jpg (66 KB, 691x487) Image search: [Google]
4JmK2Ub.jpg
66 KB, 691x487
>>1394991
Because they excelled at all three
>>
>>1398044
That did actually happen. If the illustration is of Ireland (maybe given the round tower). "Monastic levies" were raised sometimes and defeated the Vikings twice.
>>
>>1398402
Where can I read about this?
>>
>>1394997
>>1396932
The term "viking" comes from the word "vik", meaning "Bay".

The original meaning of the word was someone who went out "doing the bay", e.g fishing, sailing, and trying to find new places to live.

The biggest reason for Viking expansion was that there wasn't enough arable land left for the whole population of Norway at that time, because most of the country's geography is mountains, and not flat country.

The Viking as warrior is a 19th century fiction, invented by nationalist romantics.
>>
>>1398402
Donnchadh Ó Corráin wrote about it in The Oxford Illustrated History of the Vikings
>>
>>1399018
>The biggest reason for Viking expansion was that there wasn't enough arable land left for the whole population of Norway at that time, because most of the country's geography is mountains, and not flat country.
Funny how virtually all of human history boils down to food. It's almost always about food.
>>
>>1399061
Yeah, and it's also worth noting that any expansion stopped completely after the Black Death and the unification of Denmark-Norway.

I don't think that's a coincidence. When 1 in 4 people in your country die, suddenly there's a alot of arable land that's free.
>>
>>1399060
meant for
>>1398969
>>
>>1399018
>Viking as warrior is a 19th century fiction, invented by nationalist romantics.

What is the Knut the Great's North Sea Empire. What is all of the major port cities of Ireland. What is the Danelaw. What is Normandy's origin.
>>
>>1399096
What an interesting connection, and one I've never made before. Great point.
>>
>>1399754
Canute's mother was fucking polish so he was half slav mutt.
>>
>>1396953
Yeah, but the noun "viking" i.e. a Norseman originates from the early 19th century, before that it was just Norsemen "going on a viking" meaning piracy and raiding settlements, the noun however also refers to any seafaring Norsemen such as traders, colonialists and raiders
>>
>>1399872
Your point being?
>>
>>1399925
That he's not a fucking viking.
>>
>>1398402
They were so shit they couldn't deal with fucking levies?
>>
>>1394991
such good explorers that they got btfo so hard by american natives that they forgot everything about the newlydiscovered land
>>
because vikings are fucking brutal as fuck
>>
>>1399936
His mother being a Pole has nothing to do with him not being a viking. He's not a viking because he was a king whose rule came after the Viking Age.

Remember that viking is just a job description.
>>
>>1400010
Again these are basically farmers forming pirate bands because LOOT and maybe also climate/demographic issues.
>>
>sacked Rome
>sacked Constantinopole
>sacked Paris
>conquered Russia
>conquered England
>conquered Normady

they were great warriors who never lost a battle it's mostly because of their unorthodox fighting style (using axes) and war like religion
>>
>>1400010
You just spent the past few weeks on a boat without room to practice or train (except when you were rowing, but out at sea you're relying more on the sails anyways), and the constant salty sea air is more destructive to your kit than air on land with less time and space to keep it well maintained.

Once the Norsemen get established in an area (such as Dublin, the Danelaw, Normandy, etc.), but the raiders before then would have relied more on trying to get into wealthy areas without strong defences (monasteries and the like), because a land army of the local lords would be able to train and maintain equipment in ways a seaborne raider wouldn't be able to.
>>
>>1400109
*Once the Norsemen get established in an area (such as Dublin, the Danelaw, Normandy, etc.), they were a strong army
>>
>>1400109
Thanks for telling me that vikings were raiders I thought they were doctors.
>>
>>1394991
Because they were also fearless warriors, something I'm sure the people of England remember more than them being explorers and pioneers
>>
>show up
>sack
>runaway

Smart tactics, shit tactics. They weren't that good. Even bogniggers ended up pushing their shit in eventually.
>>
>>1400108
>conquered Russia
>conquered England
>never lost a battle
what?
>>
>>1400706
Delusion and misrepresentation of fact. Whoever wrote that is sincerely stupid.
>>
>>1394999
>not hitting that Northern Barbarian with the fucking cross
>>
>>1400706
>>conquered Russia
>>conquered England
These are correct though
>>
>>1394991
mostly because of historical writings written by the people they raped.
>>
>>
File: crazy swedes.jpg (414 KB, 1248x900) Image search: [Google]
crazy swedes.jpg
414 KB, 1248x900
>>
File: viking-warlord.jpg (786 KB, 2267x3054) Image search: [Google]
viking-warlord.jpg
786 KB, 2267x3054
>>
File: K3.jpg (285 KB, 1528x1115) Image search: [Google]
K3.jpg
285 KB, 1528x1115
>>
File: saxons m2jvImoF1tg8jkro1_1280.jpg (350 KB, 1228x900) Image search: [Google]
saxons m2jvImoF1tg8jkro1_1280.jpg
350 KB, 1228x900
>>
File: thegn.jpg (625 KB, 1005x1330) Image search: [Google]
thegn.jpg
625 KB, 1005x1330
>>
>>1402661
>hrothgar we're going raiding
>k just let me get my chinese dragon puppet
>>
File: spede.jpg (28 KB, 553x637) Image search: [Google]
spede.jpg
28 KB, 553x637
>>1402697
That's a Roman standard
Thread replies: 64
Thread images: 15

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.