[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Who is the greatest president of all time and why is it inevitably
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /his/ - History & Humanities

Thread replies: 103
Thread images: 14
File: 9780812973464.jpg (41 KB, 296x450) Image search: [Google]
9780812973464.jpg
41 KB, 296x450
Who is the greatest president of all time and why is it inevitably Andrew Jackson?
>>
but m-muh trailmix of tears
>>
Washington. Had any other man been President, the USA would be in the same state as South America is. It was luck or fate whatever that America so early in its history had its Cincinatus.
>>
>>1082472
Eh. You say Washington, but I'd argue that Hamilton was far more instrumental to making the US a successful independent state.

Of course, Washington almost always did what Hamilton suggested, so that worked well.
>>
>>1082486
Hamilton was such a nationalist fuck though.
>>
>>1082502
>implying sectionalism is better than nationalism

Democratic-Republicans please leave.
>>
>>1082486
Washington is generally considered great because he picked really good advisors, and was good at choosing from the set of options they presented to him.

>>1082420
>le ebin badass meme man
Besides creating the department of the Treasury and telling Calhoun and those faggots in SC to fuck off, Jackson had zero good policy initiatives.
>>
>>1082420
John Adams

absolutely refusing to deal with either the britshits' or frogs' agitation and keeping peace with both of them, even to the point of torpedoing his chances of reelection

without neutrality with France Napoopan wouldnt have sold Louisiana
without neutrality with England the British-led Concert of Europe would have pushed America's shit in after the napoleonic wars
>>
>>1083095
>Implying that expelling the savages to Oklahoma was a bad thing
>>
>>1083216
Reminder that Jefferson wanted to ally with France and go to war against the English.

Reminder that Jefferson is a meme.
>>
>>1083227
>making the nullification numb-nuts think that they could get away with it by ignoring a SCOTUS ruling was a good thing

So short sighted.
>>
>>1083234
>Reminder that Jefferson is a meme.
Jefferson bought the world revolution meme pretty hard. His one saving grace was being autistic about central banking.
>>
>>1083216
>John 'Alien and Sedition Acts' Adams
>John 'I ruined the Federalist part by being a paranoid jackass' Adams
>John 'my disrespect for the Constitution resulted in the existence of nullification doctrine' Adams
>best president

What a trash opinion.
>>
>>1083234
At least he's better than those silly Federalists who meant ''oligarchy'' instead of ''republic''.
>>
>>1083216

>British-led Concert of Europe

>
>>
>>1083254
not letting himself be led around by the nose by Hamilton = being paranoid?
>>
>>1082420
I have that book. It is good? Haven't read it yet.
>>
>>1083216
john adams is criminally underrated. seriously, when you compare his legacy with Washington, Jefferson, Hamilton, or even Franklin, people do not give a single fuck.

I'd say Jackson is great for the same reason Washington is great. It's more what he stood for than what he did: Washington stepping down after two terms easily puts him as one of the greatest. such an under appreciated aspect of the man. Jackson, on the other hand, was truly the first commoner president, having never received an education and coming from quite literally nothing. Plus, the democratic party is still one of the major parties.
>>
>>1083413
one of the most readable histories imo, I loved it
>>
File: soldierpic55.jpg (39 KB, 600x403) Image search: [Google]
soldierpic55.jpg
39 KB, 600x403
>Greatest
>Not even mentioning The Velt

Is it because he's a meme?

Is it because Reddit fags like him too?

Because he's the quintessential American, man and commander
>>
>>1083409
No, firing his cabinet members because they liked Hamilton's ideas and then provoking Hamilton at every turn was being paranoid.
>>
>>1083430
He's definitely my favorite
>>
File: Abraham-Lincoln-Quotes-3.jpg (84 KB, 1024x768) Image search: [Google]
Abraham-Lincoln-Quotes-3.jpg
84 KB, 1024x768
>>1082420
Andrew Jackson was our nation's first "small government conservative", who decided that America didn't need high finance and gimped America's economy for about 40 years, delaying the industrial revolution and forcing almost two full generations of Americans into crippling depression. He waged a campaign of genocide against the peaceful, cosmopolitan Cherokee to distract Americans from the fact that his domestic policies were throttling the economy.

The man was a great general, there's no taking that away from him. But as a president Jackson is totally overrated and the only reason right-wingers are flocking to his cause is because Harriet Tubman is replacing him on the 20 dollar bill and that's just too gosh darn politically correct for them. The actual Andrew Jackson would have been horrified to find his face on a bank note, he thought bank notes were "sinful" and would have wanted his face taken off of it, anyway.

Pic related. The actual greatest president of all time
>This triggers the southerner
>>
>>1082420
M-muh banks muhfugga
>>
>>1083095
>zero good policy initiatives
Service Pension Act and the enforcing of Tenure Office Act
>>
>>1083487
>the only reason right-wingers are flocking to his cause is because Harriet Tubman is replacing him on the 20 dollar bil
Jackson has always been well liked since his election. He consistently ranks well.
>lincoln
>best
>suspends habeus corpus
he's good tho, southern triggering is great, too bad it turned out literal when JWB pulled the trigger
>>
>>1083487
>Lincoln wanted to get rid of negros
Thanks JWB you fucking cuck.
>>
Let's be honest for a second and stop just trying to be contrary.

Washington

Power gap

Lincoln, FDR, and Jefferson, in no particular order.
>>
>>1083430
GOAT president, right above Lincoln or Truman
>>
>>1083552
The only legacy Wash left was that he refused the crown and stepped down after two terms; he was a pretty mediocre president
>>
>>1083564
That's a huge legacy though.

Without a humble, level headed guy to keep all the personalities in check, you end up being France in the 1790s.
>>
File: the struggle.jpg (48 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
the struggle.jpg
48 KB, 1920x1080
>>1083572
>Monarchy lead America

fug, a man can dream
>>
>>1083430
Theodore Roosevelt is my favorite President too, but Panama really blackens his legacy.
>>
>>1083584
>monarchy
>France
>1790s

Think more "lord of the flies."
>>
>>1083606
>civil rights for Jews and blacks established

The French Revolution was a mistake.
>>
>>1083611
Then move to China where they don't do that.
>>
Who is the greatest villain of all time? Who is Nero? Who is Bluebeard? Who is Jack the Ripper?
>>
>>1082502
You say that like it's a bad thing.
>>
File: wtf.gif (997 KB, 500x296) Image search: [Google]
wtf.gif
997 KB, 500x296
>>1083614
But I don't speak Mandarin or Cantonese, anon.
>>1083617
>>
>>1083622
The grammar is easy, the intonation is hard.

Still, it's easier to get into an authoritarian state from a republic than the other way around.

If you defect to North Korea, they probably won't care about the language gap as long as they have that propaganda victory.
>>
>>1083430
Seems like a really cool dude, but a bit too progressive for my taste
>>
>>1083547
>Jackson has always been well liked since his election. He consistently ranks well.
Never the best though. His domestic policy was fucking horrible, which people especially noticed after they started comparing him to the forward thinking Alexander Hamilton on the 10 dollar bill, as most of Hamilton's predictions actually came true.

>>lincoln
>>best
>>suspends habeus corpus
He won the war. Why should I nitpick over his use of emergency war time powers? It's not like Habeus Corpus went away forever. That's what makes him a strong president: he knew how to wield power. Jefferson Davis lamented that it was his lack of executive power that cost the confederacy the war.
>>
>>1083589
>the insanely profitable Canal
>blackens his legacy

How so?
>>
>>1083248
Jefferson was just actually autistic.
>>
>>1083540
>Service Pension act

Was from the Recomstruction era, three decades after Jackson's presidency.

>Tenure in Office Act

Same thing. It was passed over the objections of Andrew Johnson, and was intended to eradicate the Spoils System created by Jackson.

How could you fuck up this badly?
>>
File: 5.png (141 KB, 311x226) Image search: [Google]
5.png
141 KB, 311x226
>>1083227
>muh everything librulls think is rong reactionary fucktard

Are you even capable of empathy for human beings who aren't shitheads like you?
>>
>>1083859
>Was from the Recomstruction era, three decades after Jackson's presidency
Service Pension Act of 1823, it's even on the wikipedia page. It benefited revolutionary war vets as well as widows.
>Same thing
Sorry, meant Tenure of Office Act. Passed by Monroe, supported by Jackson
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenure_of_Office_Act_(1820)
>>
>>1082420
Jackson was a cuck, his wife was banged by his own slave while out on the campaign.
>>
>>1083942
[Citation Needed]
>>
>>1083622
.....
>>
>>1082420
Lets keep in mind that the indian removal was actually very popular at the time. The people of Georgia would probably have attacked the Cherokee there and done it in a disastrous manner had Jackson obeyed Marshall. Really Jackson would have had to ordered the army to protect the Cherokee and as a populist there is no way he would have done that. Most of the bad shit Jackson did was pretty popular and thats why he did it. He represents America and its sins.

But also get rekt Calhoun. Union 1 South Carolina 0.
>>
Andrew "Injun Incinerator" Jackson
Andrew "Ravage The Savage" Jackson
Andrew "Better Dead Than Red" Jackson
Andrew "A Grave For Every Brave" Jackson
Andrew "A Noose For Every Papoose" Jackson
Andrew "Lay Down The Law For Every Squaw" Jackson
Andrew "If Their God Has A Tail, Put 'Em On The Trail" Jackson
Andrew "If Their Hat's Made Of Feathers, I'll Kick Their Nethers" Jackson
>>
>>1083864
Stop posting this image, it's not funny, and it's turning into your avatar.
>>
>>1084006
Andrew "A Bullet Hole For Every Seminole" Jackson
>>
>>1083864
>le ebin everyone is a Human bean
This is not an argument.
>>
Andrew "don't turn the other cheek to the Creek" Jackson
>>
>>1082420
AJJ is a good band
>>
Andrew "there's only feces in teepees" Jackson
>>
Andrew "bring grief to the chief" Jackson
>>
>>1083216
>British led concert of Europe
LOL niggah you baiting?
Britain wanted NOTHING to do with Metternich's conservative coalition.

The eternal anglo only acts as the stabilizer where he is needed.
>>
>>1084033
that's a good one
>>
>>1083547
>>suspends habeus corpus
Literally the most Constitutionally justified action he ever took.
>>
File: 1420308348940.jpg (32 KB, 458x357) Image search: [Google]
1420308348940.jpg
32 KB, 458x357
>>1084006
>>1084012
>>1084019
>>1084028
>>1084033
Andrew "Tears For He Who Chucks Spears" Jackson
>>
Andrew "Heads Will Roll at the Totem Pole" Jackson
>>
Andrew "Doesn't Vibe With The Tribe" Jackson
>>
Andrew "I Don't Want to See the Cherokee" Jackson
>>
>>1082420
The asshole caused a depression by attacking the second national bank.
>>
>>1084134
The bank set itself up to cause a depression if it was dismantled, don't be fooled by banker trickery anon.
>>
>>1084134
Andrew"short term pain for long term gain"Jackson
>>
>>1084134
Not to mention the genocide he committed.
>>
>>1084379
you mean Jihad
>>
File: images.jpg (9 KB, 225x225) Image search: [Google]
images.jpg
9 KB, 225x225
>>1084410
>>
>>1084379
>genocide
Didn't even fucking happen.
>>
File: hadrian.jpg (372 KB, 1696x872) Image search: [Google]
hadrian.jpg
372 KB, 1696x872
>>1084379
nothing wrong with a cheeky genocide for the greater good
>>
>>1084125
Andrew "I Just Sank the Bank" Jackson
>>
File: I'm_Eggscellent_Hat.jpg (31 KB, 412x338) Image search: [Google]
I'm_Eggscellent_Hat.jpg
31 KB, 412x338
When asked what his most important accomplishment had been, Jackson replied,
>“I killed the Bank.”

Except the bank still exists. What a fuck up. He did kill a lot of natives though.
>>
>>1082420
Fuck you tyrant lover.

>hurr it's ok to destroy the power of the judicial branch because fuck Injuns
>>
Fans of Jackson are redneck monarchists... kind of like Trump supporters.
>>
File: fdr_fdr-P[1].jpg (231 KB, 1038x539) Image search: [Google]
fdr_fdr-P[1].jpg
231 KB, 1038x539
I trust the man that had the strength and purity of will to lead our country through some of the most tumultuous times in our nation's history.

In every measure, he was ambitious and unwilling to settle for mediocrity. He had the foresight to argue for war when the rest of the country wanted to sit cowardly in our little corner. He had the righteousness to pursue tangible steps towards social welfare that would improve the lives of every American.

Yet behind the strength of his spirit he hid a great physical disability and weakness. That's what makes him admirable. Because he knew he had the sense of mind to embody the image he set out to project.

This, this is a true American.
>>
>>1084379
did nothing wrong
>>
>>1082420
He did kill the most injuns, banks, and British
>>
>>1084582
>HURRR EVERYONE WHO DISAGREE WITH ME IS A REDNECK DRUMPF XD XD XD

What is a enlighted mind such as yourself doing here?, go ahead and teach those ignorant rednecks whats better for them.
>>
File: bo1zASx.gif (982 KB, 285x171) Image search: [Google]
bo1zASx.gif
982 KB, 285x171
>>1084612
>>
File: 1461820155058.gif (2 MB, 400x304) Image search: [Google]
1461820155058.gif
2 MB, 400x304
BEST PRESIDENTS WHO EVER LED THE REPUBLIC, TOP 10 EDITION:

1. GEORGE WASHINGTON
//TEENY TINY INCREDIBLY SMALL MINOR POWER GAP//
2. TEDDY ROOSEVELT
//MASSIVE POWER GAP//
3. JOHN ADAMS
4. THOMAS JEFFERSON
5. FDR
6. LINCOLN
7. EISENHOWER
//POWER GAP, HONORABLE MENTIONS TIER:
8. JAMES 'FUCK MEXICO, FUCK THE UK TOO' POLK
9. HARRY TRUMAN
10. VACANT

ANTICHRIST TIER:
11. WOODROW 'JUST FUCK THE WORLD UP SENPAI' WILSON
>>
>>1085437
incredibly ironic that #2 on your list is the reason why your antichrist #11 was elected desu
>>
>>1084555
The second bank of the United states does not exist, Wilson.
>>
>>1084612
>true American
>Literally abusing and ignoring all American valued
>selling the country out to the International community and banks
FDR is a crock of shit
>>
>>1084092
Andrew "I killed the bank, I killed the economy" Jackson
>>
>>1085520
Banks =/= Economy.
He broke up inflation.
That helps the economy.
I don't think you understand that Banking and Economics aren't the same and often butt heads.
Banks will steal for short term gain and create back alley deals for long term survival.
This is counter to both game theory and Economics.
>>
>>1085437

Teddy roosevelt is only liked because muh meme badass president
>>
>>1083845

The way he did it.

It's basically how the CIA destabilized Iran in 1975.

TR set the precedent for CIA fuckery around the world. Clandestine black ops shit.

Let's not even talk about the diplomatic skullduggery that was the 1905 Cruise. (And no, whoever says TR should have sided with China at that time is fucking retarded.)

>>1083942
No she did not, and Andrew Jackson will fucking murder you in your dreams for saying that. Oh hell, Davy Crockett's gonna tag team for that too because fuck you.

>>1084006
Andrew "Badmouth my wife, I'll take your life" Jackson

>>1085497
I don't get this. Bill Clinton repealing Stegal-Glass (and NAFTA), Reaganomics and Bush Jr did more to sell America to the banks than what FDR did. How does literally supporting the Allies via Lend Lease become "selling out to the International community and banking"?

>>1083622
Just move to Singapore. It's already close enough to a fascist state.
>>
Andrew "shits on brits" Jackson
>>
Andrew "kill a fool in a duel" Jackson
>>
>>1084006
kek
>>
>>1084006
Andrew "Outline of Chalk for Every Tomahawk" Jackson
>>
>>1084612
>He felt for the meme.
>>
>>1083064
>federalists
>muh "nationalism"
>only support policies that helped the northeast
>threatened secession when they didn't get their way

There's a reason their party imploded after the war of a 1812.
>>
>>1085758
FDR started it Regan sealed the deal.
Both are shit presidents.
>>
That's already been answered several times.

Jefferson was the best president, his only shortcoming was not banning slavery immediately after the Revolutionary War was over.
>>
>>1083864
The alternative was decades of conflict between white settlers and natives, ultimately resulting in the settlers fucking murdering all of them
>>
>>1083272
>plantation owners bitching about oligarchy
O i am laffin
>>
>>1083845
Panama was part of Columbia at that time. When Roosevelt wanted the Canal to be built there instead of Nicaragua, the Panamanians revolted and US aid thanks to TR. His meddling of Latin American affairs was the beginning of later US interventions and regime toppling in that region.

To be fair, Roosevelt was engaged in a pseudo-Cold War with Imperial Germany at the time. The Germans really wanted to expand their influence into Latin America since it was the only place left to control and colonize. There was quite a bit of German settlers so the Kaiser and his cronies wanted to expand spheres of influence. Naturally, the US saw this as an affront to the Monroe Doctrine.
>>
While not amongst the greatest, I think Chester A. Arthur and Grover Cleveland are the most underrated Presidents. Both were good administrators who strove to keep graft and corruption out of office.
Thread replies: 103
Thread images: 14

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.