What's the closest I can get to this phone today?
a blackberry phone
>>55253781
you can probably buy this on ebay, should be pretty close.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Nokia-3310-100-Original-Unlocked-Cell-Phone-Refurbished-with-Simple-set-/301767763275
>>55253781
If you don't literally want a 3310, Samsung do simple phones in the same style. E1200-series