ITT: mangas with good comic adaptations
- Home
- Board: /co/ - Comics & Cartoons
- Reading: ITT: mangas with good comic adaptations
ITT: mangas with good comic adaptations
Bump of interest.
post one
the comic adaptation of this was fuckin garbage
>>81491113
>All you need is kil
It was shit, the manga was superior in every possible way .
>>81493861
The movie was better, though.
>>81493962
replied to the wrong comment, i love how the delete feature doesn't work anymore
>>81491113
Can you name more? I only know about Cyborg 009 and All you need is kill. Any other adaptation?
>>81494090
>>81491113
I bet those two are all the fucking adaptations out there, OP shoulg go and fuck himself.
>>81493058
This
>>81493861
>All you need is kil
there was a comic about that?
>>81493427
I wouldn't call the comics adaptation of Cyborg 009 garbage... it was pretty competently executed for what it was. What it was, though, was something that probably wasn't necessary.
I thought it sort of missed the point of the original work. The original was groundbreaking in terms of its cutting edge (at the time) ideas about cybernetics and its multiracial/multicultural cast. The comic adaptation just repeated the same things, but stuff like cybernetics and multiracial hero teams in comics aren't really groundbreaking these days. I was hoping that the comic would push the medium the way the original manga did. It felt like a missed opportunity to do something special or different.
>>81491113
While of course it's drawn well, I can't understand why this was made. Ishinomori's style is quintessential to the series and a lot of it's charm is lost in this more realistic style. Even with someone with a style like... let's say Jeff Smith would have worked better.
not manga but VN:
song of saya/saya no uta
>>81501647
Jesus fuck this VN dude.
The twist about Saya at the end made me want to throw up.
>>81504064
she is your waifu
