I'll start (Vic Sage version, of course).
>>77482709
They might be saving him for Gotham.
Which actually might be pretty cool providing that he doesn't pass the torch onto Montoya.
>>77482709
too bad, you'll get a lesbian and you'll like it.
>>77482774
I'd prefer Sage, since he always seems to get the shaft on appearing in anything modern ever, but a Montoya is fine too.
>>77482709
>teenage vic
>>77482767
>renee
Why would you guys want that?
stop teasing me with cameos and give me the real deal already
That tailor who worked for the Rogues (Gambi? I'm not sure about the spelling) so that they can get better costumes.
Abra Kadabra would be neat too.
>>77482826
No, I want adult Vic!
>Renee
I don't want that!
>>77482709
I'd love Renee Question as long as we get Vic first.
>>77482767
Oh God no. Please no. That show is so terrible I really hope they don't waste Question on it.
>>77482919
>implying Vic wouldn't be a teenager in CW
I don't want see Vic ending with some Felicity-like romance also
>>77482869
TV production value, though :^(
>>77483000
AAAAAAAAAAAA STOP IT, now you're making me regret it :(
>>77482767
Knowing Gotham it WILL be Montoya
CW Ollie isn't a socialist, why would you want a CW Vic if he'd be neither a zen follower nor even a conspiracy theorist like in the cartoons
>>77483027
CW and Fox better leave Vic alone.
Also, the only man who can play him is Jeffrey Combs, I would be happy with him making a cameo in the DC Cinematic Universe and that's about it.
>>77483070
>implying he won't have a Bernie Sanders endorsement in the show for his mayoral campaign
>>77483107
Ollie was a revolutionary syndicallist, not a social democrat
>>77483128
It was a joke
>>77483107
but Hal would be more likely to vote for Bernie than Ollie is if we go by the 70s characterizaton from their ongoing
>>77483106
It's a shame he's pushing 60 now or something
>>77483070
>conspiracy theorist like in the cartoons
That was some good fucking shit
>>77483027
>implying Gotham's writers will ever remember Renee and Crispus exist
>>77482709
Vic deserves more nuanced writing than a CW show is able to provide
>>77483757
>>77482980
Gotham kicks ass. You're dumb.
>>77483220
Indeed
>>77483241
Touché
Arrow or Flash plz
Fuck it, make a rival themed episode for Supergirl.
>>77484158
I'm willing to bet you've read little to no Batbooks. Gotham should have been Gotham Central not this aborted fetus with unrecognizable characters with names from Batman's mythos slapped on them.
He needs an HBO show based on ONeil's run. Nothing else will do.
Can they use any characters from Gotham City? I would like to see Tommy in live action before I kill myself
Arrow or Flash in Supergirl
Impluse and XS in Flash
>>77484433
>this show should have catered to my elitist Batman dogma
>REEEEEEEEEE
It's a great elseworlds with wonderful cinematography and interesting characters but into fun and dramatic scenarios. Second season has been blowing all the other current cape shows out of the water.
>>77484158
You might as well just say I'm a huge faggot who knows next to nothing about Batman but I like this show cause it makes me feel like I do.
>>77484719
It's a terrible show with awful acting, terrible plots, forced drama and character assassination. It is not an "elseworld." And Elseworld keeps core aspects of character while slightly changing the situations they are in. That show just slaps names on people and doesn't care at all how they are portrayed.
Just admit you're a stupid cocksucking casual faggot that knows nothing about Batman and has extremely poor taste.
>>77484782
Jesus dude take the bat dildo out of your ass
>>77482869
Which show is that one?
>>77484820
Kek just admit you don't know anything
>>77484826
Arrow. Hal might already be a lantern too! In the Flash they say that ferris air got shut down because one of their test pilots went missing
>>77484867
I'm not the other anon. Stop being a faggot.
>>77484826
It's from Arrow s4e1
Animal man could possibly work. Maybe too similar to Vixen.
>>77484782
I can tell you don't even watch the show or maybe saw the 1st five and quit.
All main characters have their core personas in tact. And even if they didn't, an elseworlds can change them. There are literally dozens of stories where the heroes are villains or cowards or whatever else the author wants them to be because it is an elseworlds. It is by definition a "what-if" story that does not need to bend to any established canon or continuity.
But you already knew that because no one is that retarded.
>>77484782
>being this asspained over a tv show
you're the reason people hate Batfags
>>77484947
She hasnt appeared in live action yet, they could pull it off.
>flight
>super strenght
>comunicating with animals?
>regeneration
It can be done
>>77484947
He's easy enough to make different from Vixen. Buddy's an actor so making Animal Man almost Booster-tier showoff could be a good idea; putting an emphasis on him being an animal right activist in civilian life would help too.
I'd like to see doc Magnus. Hell, maybe even Metal Men too since the horrifying makeup they used for Red Tornado could actually work for them.
>>77482767
montoya has been completely absent from the show since the middle of season 1. hasn't even been brought up by other characters. doubt she'll be back.
Hour-Man
Mirakuru serum reversed-engineered as Miraclo
Vigilante who's a genius chemist that doesn't know where to fit in between Ray's commercialism and Oliver's solidarity when it comes to being a hero
Costume starts out as a single black hoodie during Rex's first escapades, later gets an upgrade to his more modern costume with a yellow mask behind the hood and a red belt for activating the juice
This is the simplest shit, hell this could have been done in Season 1 and still fit in with the grounded themes of the show
>>77485355
Animal Man also usually has a public identity, which none of the other CW heroes do, which could be interesting. Not to mention the fact that he has a family. Although, in order to keep him CW young, I would make him recently married with a baby Cliff.
Ragman would work in current Arrow, since it's the magic season. I just really want more magic guys. I would kill for an Amethyst or Shadowpact show.
>>77484418
>>77484464
Nice ideas
>>77484494
Don't kill yourself, senpai
>>77487233
Post yfw Deadman shows up
>>77483106
Well he was on the island with fish eye Mooney in Gotham. And the he was surgically rearranged with a woman's body.
>>77488188
Huh?
>>77482774
Was this the mentality behind the series finale of Legend of Korra?
They can't use Hal, so why the fuck not.
>>77487233
>. I would kill for an Amethyst or Shadowpact show.
Amethyst is goddamn perfect for a SyFy or CW series. You've got the potential for Game-of-Thrones-level political chicanery and backstabbing, romantic subplots that don't suck, and a strong female protagonist that can kick ass.
>>77490150
No, the mentality behind the series finale of Legend of Korra was "oh fuck, we didn't think to ask Nickelodeon if gays were a-ok so when we asked them at the last minute we could only get in a last minute reveal for the gayness".
>>77488102
>mfw Deadman shows up
>>77484559
Ralph dibny exists in flarrowverse and was mentioned on the flash as having died the night the accelerator blew up
>>77490230
Long story short "We out of money, out of ideas, out of time, and we've written ourselves in a corner plus we've jumped the shark twice already...lets die in a blaze of horrid glory."
A golden age hero in a more pulpy style, like Dan Garret Blue Beetle or Congorilla.
>>77484719
The only thing that overly bugs me is that everyone just stands around shooting at each other instead of taking cover, running, etc.
>>77490711
I've been wanting Wes and Sandy since literally season 1 of Arrow.
Shit they can really go crazy with it now that Arrow is dealing with magical shenanigans in the current storyline.
>>77483165
to be fair, the Question would be the easiest character to have dubbed over with a stunt double as the actual Questin
>>77482709
>>77486474
There was an hourman show in the works but it's been long cancelled
>>77484494
Thomas Elliot?
>>77491045
Hitman.
>>77491045
The better Tommy. You never read Hitman?
>>77491152
How much bleeping words would they have to do to have Tommy on teevee?
>>77491247
I don't know, what words are they allowed to use?
>>77491086
>>77491152
Not in a long time. I'm glad to hear I guessed wrong.
>>77490883
Surprised she hasn't shown up on any of the shows with Johns as a creative.
This asshole doesn't have a shot in the movies, may as well use him for TV lantern. His interactions with Barry and Ollie would be way more entertaining anyway.
>>77491294
>Super-grey morality.
I like. Which comic is this?
Kev was great too.
Question, Booster Gold, or Blue Beetle.
>>77491407
JLA - Hitman (2007)
>>77491407
>>77491476
forgot pic
>>77491407
Hitman/JLA
I wouldn't say it's morally grey at all. It acknowledges that superheroes are forced to make tough decisions, and sometimes make mistakes, but Ennis also makes the point that superheroes also represent our capability to hold ourselves to a higher standard. When they're forced to compromise on those ideals, which happens because this world isn't perfect and neither are they, it's still a tragedy.
Superman's point is that sometimes there's going to be dilemmas you're faced with where every option causes some evil or harm, so you have to pick which is the least worst action.
>>77491363
>never ever
ITT: I'm barely literate. Please cater to me.
>>77482709
Oh my god. They need to cast Mark Pelligrino since he has a good relationship with CW, looks like Vic and is a diehard Ayn Rand-following objectivist.
>>77491247
Only as much as they bleeped in the original run I would think. So a couple bitches and bastards uncensored and one or two censored fucks
>>77492113
They pretty much turned Star-Lord into Guy. But yeah. He would've been perfect.
>>77484723
You can't like a show even if you don't know much about batman?
>>77491447
Great taste anon!
The Creeper
>wanting CW to ruin another character
>>77494841
>implying CW ruined anyone
>>77493974
Take it easy!
>>77493974
You ever have a threesome, son?
>>77491407
>>77491525
Wow, and here I thought Ennis was all edge.
> People would rather debate and be angry than post actual characters
I shake my head to be honest family
>>77482709
Dick Grayson
>>77490359
So was Atom Smasher, but he was retconned to have survived (only so he could be more recently killed)
>>77490363
Reminds me of those posts about Asami being the true villain because at the end of it all she jailed her dad, took the business, got profits from the war and made the avatar a non factor.
>>77495508
>implying CW ruined anyone
Hey now, I like the shows as much as the next guy, but let's not pretend they haven't wasted some characters.
Kate Spencer and Atom Smasher come to mind.
And it's weird that they introduced Jason Rusch, only to use a near-identical original character for the second Firestorm.
>>77482980
>That show is so terrible
>Gotham
wut. It's the best Cape show on TV
>>77495958
Ah, well, you win. Good examples
>>77482709
>>77484719
>>77484782
It's barely even an Elseworlds. There's only like one or two subtle things that are really changed.
They respect their audience better than any other cape show on TV. I mean, they do shit like making sure characters use things like adding machines and typewriters even though they have cell phones to tie into the "time out of time" thing BTaS had.
Normies keep crying for the Joker, but they've already shown that they're aware that the real Joker isn't about having a backstory.
Music selection, set designs, and everything tie back to the Burton/TaS era.
Gotham is a show made by people who actually understand Batman. I'm sorry you just wanted Arrow again, but I'm happy there's one decent cape show on TV.
>>77495508
Yes, generic drug-dealers Count Vertigo 1 and 2 were excellent characters.
And what fantastic character Ra's al Ghul was.
Huntress was also wonderful.
I can go on and on.
>>77495978
Fuck off with this meme. Gotham is awful and somehow is even worse than CW's mediocre shows.
>>77495958
I'd say dropping Kate Spencer into the CW-verse would be pointless as you'd have to change a lot about the character to make her fit. While it'd be nice to see Manhunter, she's a character so heavily tied up in other elements of the DCU you'd be stuck with a mostly in name only version to fit her in the CW.
Zatanna and Deadman.
Would make a good bff for Supergirl
>>77496224
>Deadman
>Was dieing just as particle accelerator exploded.
A teen clone of Superman would fit right in.
>>77484782
>It is not an "elseworld." And Elseworld keeps core aspects of character while slightly changing the situations they are in
That one elseworld story were batman is a fat mid life crisis dude
>>77490230
The funny part is that Bryke said Nick were uncomfortable with gayness and then Nick came out and said that not only were they okay with it, but Bryke had never actually asked them for their opinion in the first place.
They're just hacks.
>>77483757
>>77483787
String me up, but I thought the Vic Sage run was kinda overrated for how much people on /co/ hype it up.
It had some great moments, like those posted, but in the end there's very little in the way of overarching plot. Vic never takes the time to develop a philosophy of his own, and Shiva specifically mentions that he's basically wasting the training he's been given, running around and beating up muggers.
Sure, that's her philosophy, not his, but for someone who calls himself The Question Vic sure likes to pretend he's got some sort of answer, and not a bunch of half-assed ramblings, half of which he ends with his fist.
>>77495958
Except that Jefferson Jackson actually isn't an original character although to my knowledge he was never Firestorm. He was a friend of Ronnie Raymond though.
>>77495958
>implying CW ruined anyone
Arrow, Flash, Atom, black canary and alot of villains
I already got my wish with Hawks joining the team. I don't know if asking for more would seem fair.
I guess we could use Adam & Alanna Strange. Zatanna and other JLD members would be a must if CW considers giving Constantine more spotlight
>>77496033
>There's only like one or two subtle things that are really changed.
>Gotham is a show made by people who actually understand Batman. I'm sorry you just wanted Arrow again, but I'm happy there's one decent cape show on TV.
Who is Barabara Gordon? They completely fucking ruined her for no reason except to get viewers. Fuck off with your shit opinion pleb.
>>77482709
I'd love to see a semi-serious-yet witty Vic Sage become friends with Oliver and company, only for him to become a total Rorschach and to alienate his former friends after a serious case.
his theme
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ozjs2d_xlSI
>>77484577
If Bart and XS show up they could use that as an excuse to bring the Legion into the CWverse. I'm ok with that.also before Wally's actor announced they were asked if they had plans for Wally or Bart and they said yes to both being people they wanted to introduce down the line. I feel like Bart is almost a certainty if the show keep going how it has. Jenny is a bit more unlikely although I don't see why Bart wouldn't at least mention her, and it'd give them a good excuse to introduce the Legion
Also are these people itt saying they like Gotham and hailing it as the best comic book based tv show fucking joking? It's literally the worst the by a wide margin.I say this as someone who gave 8 episodes before I dropped it(which is twice as many as I normally give a show; and one more than Agents of SHIELD which
surprisingly got much better season 2 while Gotham never got better)
>>77487139
I'd probably make Buddy like a year or two older than Barry
>>77495874
To be fair Wellsobard mentioned Ronnie was dead too so it's pretty safe to assume that Atom Smasher was just assumed dead at the time
>>77495958
Jason's actor didn't seem to want to come back, Jax is pretty okay, he's more like the comic Ronnie (Jock, not science smart) so he's already way better than the previous guy.
>>77501812
Gotham is good if you like partial crime investigation shows. And if you like the source material.
>>77502002
Crime Investigation shows are the literal last thing tv needed more of desu
>>77501812
>dropped it after 8 episodes
>it never got better
seems legit
like by no means will i claim it's the best comic book show airing at the moment, but it's fun and has definitely improved. this season has been consistently solid at the very least
>>77502117
I've watched a couple episodes of this season
And yeah that is legit. 8 episodes is more than anyone should reasonably have to dedicate to an hour long show they just don't find that interesting. That's a lot of time, man. People have other things to do including other things they would rather watch. If you like it then that's cool but this is my opinion.
>>77496917
sauce on nick saying anything?
Well, since Warner Bros is being a dick about not letting people use Hal Jordan, how about one of the other three Earth Lanterns? Hell, I'd even take Alan at this point
>>77501812
>people itt saying they like Gotham and hailing it as the best comic book based tv show fucking joking?
Of ocurse
>>77502391
We need more Guy.
Also, Shade.
apache chief and sushi tornado or whatever the japanese guy was named
>they have to be over-the-top ethnic stereotypes or they wont work
>>77502391
Why not?
>>77501812
Are you on crack?
>Arrow is dreary Nolan shit
>Flash is middling at best
>SuperGRRRRRL is a joke
>Agents of SHIELD is fucking unwatchable
Gotham is the best by a long shot. Even if Gotham wasn't good it'd be better than that shitpile.
>>77499367
okay so you do realize that the Barbara in Gotham isn't Batgirl, right?
Blue Devil would kind of make for an interesting addition to TV-Verse
>>77482709
how would the Question work, to get the lack of face because wearing a nylon on your head should still show your eyes?
