[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Ask a historian anything.
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
The stories and information posted here are artistic works of fiction and falsehood.
Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact.
You are currently reading a thread in /b/ - Random

Thread replies: 177
Thread images: 19
File: image.jpg (29 KB, 360x360) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
29 KB, 360x360
Ask a historian anything.
>>
File: 129958-004-C9B8B89D.jpg (18 KB, 343x450) Image search: [Google]
129958-004-C9B8B89D.jpg
18 KB, 343x450
>>676126738
Which MG-XX is that?
>>
>>676127122
MACHINEGEWEHR - 42
Very easy to spot.
>>
File: A8mSZqfl.jpg (87 KB, 640x638) Image search: [Google]
A8mSZqfl.jpg
87 KB, 640x638
>>676127497
What specifically tells you it's a MG42?
>>
>>676126738
how much do you regret spending on a useless degree
>>
>>676127835
The barrel, the sights, and the cocking handle.
And the overall size of it compared to the MG-34
>>
is any of this accurate?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Sw_lgX1q2w
>>
>>676127955
None.
£200,000 a year, (which is probably around 300,000 dollars)
A great hobby, love every last second of my job.
Teach, research, give tours for museums occasionally.
>>
>>676128075
Disturbing but about 90% accurate.
>>
why are you a faggot?
>>
>>676128507
Do you have a PhD in history?
Well, do you?
>>
>>676126738
What area do you specialise in?
>>
>>676126738
Where does toilet paper originate?
>>
>>676128748
20th century.
Mostly the Second World War.
I also do a bit of 19th century work in my spare time, because reenacting is a hobby of mine outside work.
>>
>>676128882
It was made in the 20's in America I think.
>>
>>676128885
So, do you believe the official story of the Holocaust?
>>
What type of chemical weapon was used in the battle of Verdun?
>>
How old am I?
>>
>>676129370
Elaborate pol fag
>>
>>676129370
I don't believe in the holocaust.
I study the war in general, the detailed stuff.
The uniforms, the equipment, insignia etc. Of soldiers of that period.
I believe the Nazis did exterminate the Jews, but I think the gas chambers was a type propaganda to keep the hatred towards the Nazis.
>>
Do you support Hitlers ideology?
>>
>>676129558
elaborate pol fag
>>
File: 1458731142302-b.jpg (81 KB, 500x539) Image search: [Google]
1458731142302-b.jpg
81 KB, 500x539
>>676126738
>>
>>676129448
I believe it was mostly phosfine gas.
>>
You don't know shit op.
>>
>>676129558
you are not a historian you are a polfag pretending to be one
>>
Did Hitler do something wrong?
>>
>>676129568
Kind of.
Hitler liked the Muslims, and I don't.
But I support his beliefs of a truely European race.
>>
>>676129780
Jew detected get out of here zionist scum
>>
Why would you study to become a historian if you can just go back and look at things when you need to
>>
>>676129780
Fuck off, there are many historians that don't believe in the holocaust.
They study history, and they use history to point out their facts.
>>
As an aspiring young American (22) currently aspiring and studying to be a Historian (I don't give two shits if people say it's a useless degree, human history is rich and intriguing) what advice would you have to offer someone currently studying the field?
>>
Op how many jew were really killed. And with who did the zionist do business a read some were that the zionist actually did know about Hitler plans and did some business with zionist.
>>
>>676126738
would the world be a better place had nazi germany won WWII?
>>
Are you gay?
>>
>>676130039
Research your ass off.
It's what I did in uni, and I never regretted it.
In your own time, you can also try and research English history, art history and possibly geography.
>>
>>676130053
Yes. Yes it would have been.
>>
Why is Jeanne D'Arc so perfect?
>>
Op are you going to answer the fucking questions?
>>
>>676130333
checked
>>
>>676130053
Yes/no
I wrote a book about what Britian would look like if Germany succeeded in operation Sealion.
There where two possibilitys.
Either one, Britian would rejoice because there where many British Fascsts at the time (Oswald Mosley)
Or two, Britain would be a hellhole for decades, if not for century's.
>>
Was there any major post-1942 battle that the Japanese actually won?
>>
>>676130414
you wrote a book and you cant spell fascists?
>>
>>676130333
>trips never lie
>>
Did Hitler actually commit suicide?
>>
>>676126738
Who did nine eleven?
>>
>>676130435
Good question.
I could be wrong, but was it the battle of Singapore?
>>
Didnt hitler create isreal or some shit?
>>
File: GOINTOTHEBINGOHAIL.jpg (148 KB, 690x820) Image search: [Google]
GOINTOTHEBINGOHAIL.jpg
148 KB, 690x820
>>676129973
then why is the majority of evidence that supports the holocaust happened is from the Nazi's themselves. We all know the Russians killed millions yet we could not back it up with the evidence because the Russians were terrible record keepers unlike ZEE GERMANS.
fuck off wehraboo your not a historian.
>>
>>676126738

did the holocaust really happen ?
>>
>>676130508
C'mon Anon, he said he was a historian, not an english teacher, ya dimwit. Pay attention to the man.
>>
>>676128991
I think? Fuck you and your thinking.. what kind of degree is that.. useless faggot
>>
>>676130435
Not op but the Japanese were cutting through Asia like a fucking hot knife through butter. They started way before the official war started. They had plans of conquering the whole world.
>>
>>676130643
I'm required to say yes.
But I'll just keep it as a "possibly"
>>
File: 1453124753622s.jpg (6 KB, 250x156) Image search: [Google]
1453124753622s.jpg
6 KB, 250x156
>>676130660
Hes just a wehraboo polfag don't encourage him.
>>
>>676128180
Sounds like what we should all expect if we die and go to hell.
>>
I would actually say the japs were pretty cruel and savage compared to the Germans. Op you faggot why don't you answer my questions? Hitler did business with zionist?
>>
>>676130826
>Wehraboo
Implying that the army in which 100s of thousands of Jews where enlisted has anything to do with Nazi ideology.
It's just the army.
>>
>>676130660
>>676130826
he still said he wrote a book yet cant spell a key word any historian should know, FAGGOTS
>>
>>676130610
Nope, that was fought during February 1942. However you are correct that the Japanese won it.
>>
>>676126738

Can communism ever be practiced without error/fault?
>>
File: Dcu4QBT.png (775 KB, 1500x1500) Image search: [Google]
Dcu4QBT.png
775 KB, 1500x1500
>>
>>676130996
The japs where evil, they starved their POW's to death and the POW's had to pay for their food and heigine.
They where savages, they truly where.
Buts that the dedication they had, and that's why they where such good soldiers.
>>
Op you don't know shit.
>>
>>676131175
No.
Look at every country that once was ruled by the communists, they suffered.
Look at China, and all the other country's that are communist, they work in sweat shops and struggle for food.
>>
File: wehrabooMKII_zps3f9a8d97.jpg (59 KB, 304x452) Image search: [Google]
wehrabooMKII_zps3f9a8d97.jpg
59 KB, 304x452
>>676131255
yeah the Germans were super nice to all american p.o.w's they baked strudel and went for long walks on the atlantic wall with the SS right
>>
How accurate do you consider our understanding of history? For example do various otherwise seemingly reliable historical records often disagree? Do you suspect many past attempts at rewriting history have been successful?
>>
>>676131255
They were indoctrinated that they were superior race. That they had to serve there emperor. He was a God and the life of the japs were only to serve.
>>
>>676131247
>implying that a tiger, the most easiest tank to breakdown would be better then a Sherman.

Unless you where the most prepared man in the world, a tiger tank will fail you.
>>
>>676131478
yeah china is a hell hole alright just look at that communist country on the verge of collapse
>>
>>676126738
By your standpoint, who would logically be the best president out of all the candidates due to issues currently involving the world and our country? Not a biased view, if you can.
>>
File: youdown.jpg (43 KB, 570x587) Image search: [Google]
youdown.jpg
43 KB, 570x587
>>676129558
Go to Austria and Poland and see these death facilities for yourself and say that, stupid.
Historian my fucking anus.
>>
>>676131654
damn dude you couldn't tell what irony was if it broke down in front of you
>>
>>676131516
The German POW camps where the same as us.
Allthough they did send some to consentation camps, and that was evil.
But not as evil as the japs.
>>
>>676131826
don't ever read Kurt Vonnegut then it might shock you to find out that the Germans were barbarians too
>>
>>676131826
elaborate pol fag how were they just like us?
>>
>>676131746
Faggot the Germans did kill some jew scum. But not as many as they say. It was around 2 to 3 million at most. Do some fucking research not every thing they say in school is true. My grandfather fought that war in the US army. And from what he told me I did research and confirmed what he said. The the Jews wanted to be seen as victims. It's like fucking niggers still crying about slavery.
>>
>>676131746
its ok man wehraboos dont listen to facts
>>
>>676132032
There's a keen difference between the German army and the political elite army (Waffen-SS, Einstazgruppen etc.)
The Wehrmacht was just like the American, British army etc. They treated prisoners the same, they had the same "war rules" etc. The only difference was that they where fighting for something wrong, because they where muliulated.
>>
>>676132124
wow kid nice try your grandpa was wrong just like you
>>
Is the sinking of Maine an excuse by americans to attack spanish possessions?
>>
File: 1457953954783.png (140 KB, 1077x964) Image search: [Google]
1457953954783.png
140 KB, 1077x964
This is now a b8 thread, came here asking bout mg42s and now its Shoah denial.
>>
>>676132395
Yep, Jesus.
Let's talk about real history, please?
>>
>>676132265
Yeah sure keep saying that if you repeat many time it will come true. Your probably a fucking jew. Let see your fucking victims and see how they treat Palestinian worst that the fucking German camps. They are the true scum of the world. Your a zionist aren't you. Dint know summer was already here
>>
Hey op. What do you know about the Jewish war on Germany of 1918 before ww2? No one ever hears about it and thought I'd ask
>>
>>676132539
Don't you mean the riots that happened?
>>
File: 1458546686314.png (191 KB, 502x371) Image search: [Google]
1458546686314.png
191 KB, 502x371
>>676132124
If the Jews weren't the victims, who were?
Seriously, please tell me, I want to know exactly how stupid you actually are.
>>
>>676132395
Hey fag it's a history thread. WW2 is part of history
>>
>>676132246
the Wehrmacht was totally complicit in the killings there is shit tons of evidence that the Einsaztgruppen and the ss had to rely heavily on the Wehrmacht and did on several occasions fuck off back to /pol/ revisionist historian cunt
>>
>>676132620
The Slavs.
Lots of them died during the invasion of the east.
>>
>>676132124
Dude, I've never had to say this to anybody before, but you might even be too disgusting for 4chan.
>>
>>676132653
They where chosen.
They where deicated Nazis.
Look it up.
>>
>>676132518
calm down /pol/tard drumpf chump im not a Jew but i guess every time you lose an argument you just calm someone a jew or reddit fag right?
>>
>>676132615
Maybe. I saw a few articles from old papers a while back. I seem to remember it was a thing for communism but it's been a while
>>
>>676126738
How much you earn? any hint to be a good Historian? I'm at 4th semester.
>>
>>676132814
keep up that revisionist history
>>
>>676132857
Oh yeah.
After the Great War, communism became very popular with the German people, that is one of the many reasons why the NSDAP began.
>>
>>676126738
Is history any use in today's society ? I mean apart from being a hobby for priviledged...
>>
>>676132814
ever here of the night and fog decree? i guess that was made up too?
>>
"Ask a piece of shit anything"
>>
>>676132916
£200,000 a year.
Research, a good love for the subject, and more research.
>>
>>676132620
OK I'm the stupid one. Man can you see the fucking pattern here. Jew have always been outcast from the beginning of time. Don't you think there's a reason for that Egypt hated the the same with the Roman's. I could go on. They alway portray themselves if being persuade. I won't say all that died were evil but mist of them were. They weren't the only one being destroyed they cleaning there country in general. It sound crude but it's true with there ideology of nationalism. But I see you avoid remark with the Palestinian.
>>
>>676133007
It's good for politics, it's also good for heritage and interest and all of that.
>>
>>676129850
He lost
>>
>>676133169
And he started WW2..
You know, the most destructive war in human history.
>>
>>676132782
leave summer fag I've been here for more time than you. If you find this discussion disgusting go back to Tumblr
>>
YOU CAN ALL FUCK OFF BACK TO /POL/ WE ALL KNOW YOU FAT NECKBEARDS LOVE CP AND NAZI'S WE GET IT
>>
Hey op. Do you know much about the tank battles in Northern Africa in World War Two? My grandpa fought there and was captured by the British and held for 3 years after the war. He had some very interesting story's you don't hear about ever that he went through there
>>
>>676133272
new kid detected!
>>
>>676132312
Nigga answer me
>>
>>676133306
A bit, yep.
What battle did he fight in?
And what division was he?
>>
>>676133257
Well yeah, that too...
>>
>>676133272
its MARCH and hes calling people summerfag kek nice one kid you can go to bed now
>>
>>676132620
Lots of people....gypsies, homosexuals, free-thinking "radicals", Masons, occultists...it's a long list, but you don't hear about any of them.
>>
>>676133434
96th revisionist neckbeards out of /pol/and
>>
>>676133472
It's always summer somewhere
>>
>>676133568
So, your divison is a bunch of racist faggot holocaust deniers?
>>
>>676133344
Sure OK I "lost" the argument how I don't know. And a rarely visit pole. I don't believe in nationalism and fuck trump. Your all to blind to see what the jew are doing to other people is worst and they still play the fucking victim card.
>>
File: descarga (1).jpg (7 KB, 284x177) Image search: [Google]
descarga (1).jpg
7 KB, 284x177
>>676133067
What you think about this phrase of Orwell? Then we are gods?
>>
Why are Serbs hated even though they did nothing bad?
>>
>>676133092
The Jews should have been given part of Germany. Not where they are now. Now they're in a perpetual war with Palestine and basically every other country in the region.
In all fairness, the Jews are sick of Palestine's bullshit. They throw some mortars across the border...then Israel goes fucking crazy and bombs the shit out of them. What the fuck would you do? If your little brother was constantly sneaking up on you and tasering you in the back of the neck, wouldn't you slap the fucking shit out of him?
>>
>>676133655
fuck off back to /pol/ drumpf chump we can enlighten ourselves without your help kid.
>>
>>676133670
I sounds like "if you understand history, then you can learn from our mistakes and good deeds"
>>
>>676126738
what is very intresting history fact most peopol dont now?
>>
>>676133695
Don't worry Serbia, your good.
>>
>>676133792
that OP is a fag
>>
>>676133434
He never told me specifics like that. I was younger and he passed away a while ago. He said the camps they were in they separated the s s and treated them very well, they ate with the British and were well fed. The rest would sort loot, gold silver, gems, etc and be brought around to hand dig wells. He ended up being released weighing 90lbs and went to Egypt for a few years before leaving. He was 5-11" and quite stocky at his normal weight
>>
>>676133792
and hitler did nothing wrong
>>
>>676133792
Did you know we created english about 550-1066 ad?
Did you Anon doesn't speak it?
>>
>>676133915
Yes he did you Cuck.
>>
>>676133857
>that most people don't know

not what I was looking for
>>
>>676133534
Sure you hear about them. I may not be a "historian" like this fucktard, but I'm pretty sure there were enough dead Jews to make all the others combined a minor footnote. At least those murdered under Hitler
>>
>>676134021
no he did not
>>
>>676133816
Thanks mate
>>
>>676134066
Indeed.
Nice dubs.
>>
>>676133706
No I don't believe that. Just go to YouTube and look at the abuse. Those mortars do shit and almost never kill any body. How would you feel if I forced you out of your house right know at gun point. Would you not try to retaliate? I won't get get deep with all the zionist shit. Because there's nothing worst that people ignoring facts. It's like talking to a wall. You'll believe what you want to believe
>>
>>676134090
Sure he didn't kill as much as the Soviets, but he was a filthy murderer and muliulated the German people.
>>
>>676133670
So how about fuck the past and just take common sense on board.. Take control of the present= Control of the Future..=$$$
>>
File: poltards.jpg (38 KB, 320x226) Image search: [Google]
poltards.jpg
38 KB, 320x226
OP IS A FAGGOT NOT A NAZI
>>
>>676126738
how often do you masturbate?
>>
>>676134211
Neo-Nazis a thugs.
The Nazis where thugs.
I'm neither of those people.
So really, all Nazis are faggots.
>>
>>676134271
Once a week.
>>
>>676134187
Hitler was a sensitive man fuck he even painted cant be all bad sheesh!
>>
>>676134316
>did paintings
>definitely not a bad person.
Nazi logic.
>>
>>676134308
favorite fap material?
>>
File: 1458816335107.jpg (140 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
1458816335107.jpg
140 KB, 1920x1080
>>676126738
history the most uncertain "science" there is, because literally nobdy can prove shit went down like that 100%
it's like finding 1000 year old facebook wallposts and taking them for granted
tl;dr
>how doest it feel to be aware your "knowledge" is made up stories 90%
>>
Hitler told the Jews to get out they did not want to leave. They had it coming
>>
>>676126738
Can you do a back flip?
>>
>>676134410
Joi.
>>
>>676133772
>then you can learn from our mistakes and good deeds
>good deeds

Like don't invade Russia at winter?
>>
>>676134287
Your a revisionist historian with Nazi sympathizing tendency's fuck off back to /pol/
>>
>>676134445
No, but I can do a handstand.
>>
File: 1458718416277.jpg (39 KB, 360x480) Image search: [Google]
1458718416277.jpg
39 KB, 360x480
>>676134410
>>
>>676134395
Christ kid cant you identify a joke when you hear it?
>>
>>676134445
>
>>676134516
You disappoint me op
>>
>>676134513
I knew you faggots would call me a Nazi as soon as I mention the holocaust.
Top fucking Kek.
>>
Oh op I have a good one for you. Can you explain why many people in positions of power wear black robes and how it relates to the warship of Saturn. Eg. Judges in court
>>
File: image.jpg (47 KB, 468x527) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
47 KB, 468x527
>>676129646
>tfw the Byzantine Empire is my favorite historical faction of all time, enthralling me since I was a child
Fucking Turks and faggot Crusaders and power hungry civil war causing faggots
It's not fair
>>
>>676134604
That's theoretical nonsense.
Next your going to say that dinosaurs evolved into Reptillian gods.
>>
I don't understand why so many new cunts are. On 4chan crying over Hitler and the Jews. The Jews are fucking evil.
>>
>>676134706
This argument has gone on for almost the dawn of civilisation.
>>
>>676134706
what did a jew do to you today newkid?
>>
>>676134696
I feel you fam
>>
>>676134604
This is interesting. Tell me fag I want to know or give me a link
>>
>>676133695
I don't think serbs are rly hated (not serb here). Albanians and croatians are hated the most
>>
>>676134706
>The Jews are fucking evil.

Then why Jesus die for us?
>>
>>676134807
The same thing they do every day try to take over the world.
>>
>>676126738
Do you think a European coalition would have declared on France again if the Napoleonic dynasty wasn't ended by the Zulus?
>>
>>676134891
Jesus died from Jewish hands.
Jesus tried to make the Jews good.
Christians are "good Jews"
>>
>>676134702
Ok then. Where did that come from? Why do they wear black robes, did someone one day just decide that was cool. Please explain
>>
>>676134891
OK I don't believe in religion. But the same Jews betrayed him. So there fucking evil. Read the Bible godGod danm it.
>>
File: 1458890209461.gif (1 MB, 540x540) Image search: [Google]
1458890209461.gif
1 MB, 540x540
In all seriousness, why did Hitler hate Jews?
>>
>>676134900
So Americans are the ones who are evil then, not Jews. Right?
>>
>>676134942
Probably not.
The British army was very weak during the neopelonic wars, only 200,000 men.
>>
>>676134807
Enslaved me with fiat currency
>>
>>676134900
that's pinky and the brain its was a cartoon within another cartoon called the animaniacs but i often mix that up with the Jewish cabal
>>
>>676134706
Goddamn Jews got Jesus killed too.
Thread replies: 177
Thread images: 19

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.