you can compare them by influence

Eva caused more damage than Haruhi

Haruhi became boring in the LNs.

Eva ended climactically.

You decide.

>>142370113
NGE.

>>142372059
Disappearance is a much more satisfying ending than both instrumentalities

>>142370113
One's for manchildren
The other is for manchildren who haven't seen NGE yet.

Both are pretty good.

>>142373897
Disappearance is not an ending it's a beginning. It made Kyon accept that he enjoys his adventures with Haruhi and Co. and explores Yukis nature, but it didn't give any conclusion to the actual mysteries of the plot, or Haruhis character.

>>142372059
Only the last LN was kinda bad, the others were great, especially the 7th.

>>142376888
>last LN was kinda bad
>implying

>>142376888
>>142376958
I enjoyed all the major story arcs, only some of the short one-off stories were bad. Especially the one where the American football player has a crush on Nagato. Boring as fuck.

>>142377746
>major development for Nagato and her boss
>bad

>>142373897
Are you retarded? It literally answers no questions towards anything in the entire series.

>>142377828
It could've stopped there