[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
S/a/kuga Sunday
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 123
File: 1461421462782.gif (2 MB, 664x374) Image search: [Google]
1461421462782.gif
2 MB, 664x374
S/a/kuga Sunday
>>
File: 1460300236517.webm (2 MB, 852x480) Image search: [Google]
1460300236517.webm
2 MB, 852x480
Re:Zero has really surprised me this season

thought it would be shitty
>>
File: 1460123287287.webm (330 KB, 800x450) Image search: [Google]
1460123287287.webm
330 KB, 800x450
>>
How do you define what is and what isn't a sakuga?
>>
>>141854895
sakuga,yshi.org
http://pastebin.com/bNtCEQBS
>>
File: 1437505257801.png (451 KB, 892x480) Image search: [Google]
1437505257801.png
451 KB, 892x480
>>
>>141854936
kys, and take this twitter circlejerk out of /a/
>>
https://youtu.be/ACCvfcfdoNU
>>
>>141854986
>>>141854936
>kys, and take this twitter circlejerk out of /a/
Nigger what
>>
>>141854872
It's a shame that when it's not going full Sakuga, the rest of Conrevo looks pretty sub-par.
>>
>>141855026
>hey guys these are our blogs and twitters pls subscribe
Fuck
Off
>>
>>141854844
lmao where is the animation
>>
>>141854936
interesting
>>
Can't wait for the Garo movie BDs, the action looks very promising.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iBHb_cNr6BA
>>
>>141854844
This looks like shit
>>
File: MDP.webm (2 MB, 960x540) Image search: [Google]
MDP.webm
2 MB, 960x540
>>
What would anti sakuga be?
>>
>>141854824
There's not much impressive animation lately, but that's typical of the mid-season.
>>
>>141855231
Still frames with no movement made to fill up time cheaply.

Also QUALITY. QUALITY definitely counts.
>>
>>141855231
Toei
>>
guys, adobe after effects is not animation
>>
File: 1452278674261.webm (2 MB, 640x360) Image search: [Google]
1452278674261.webm
2 MB, 640x360
>>
>>141855306
Goddamn I need to watch that show. It's been on my backlog for way too long, and every time I see a scene from it it looks amazing.
>>
>>141855441
i am watching it right now, and though it seems to be pretty big on the moeshit sol, it is actually pretty entertaining still
>>
>>141855306
what show is this?
>>
>>141855485
>moeshit sol
Lurk 2 years before posting
>>
>>141855441
>>141855575
The webms are literally the only good part.
>>
>>141855575
Yozakura Quartet: Hana no Uta

Have a nice day, anon
>>
>>141855628
Nah, the sound design in YZQ is also phenomenal.
>>
File: YZQ.png (169 KB, 600x1000) Image search: [Google]
YZQ.png
169 KB, 600x1000
>>141855628
I dare you to say that again!
They are wasted on this board
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dRUESFPX-a4

>>141855575
>>141855685
See pic
>>
>>141855265
Fucking Glasslip, please stop reminding me.
>>
Hey boorufags can you add a date tag for the season a show is from? Like "Spring 2016".
I'd like to see what's new from the latest season without checking each single show's tag every time, is what I mean. I don't even watch most of them.
Yes of course do it just for me thank you very much.
>>
>>141855831
"no"
>>
File: 9.jpg (31 KB, 539x339) Image search: [Google]
9.jpg
31 KB, 539x339
>KyoAni anime on sakugabooru
>Artist unknown
>Artist unknown
>Artist unknown

Can't those niggers read the credits and tell by the style alone? There's only a handful of KyoAni key animators and they're always the same people anyway. I have a feeling they only know the artist because he/she posts the genga on their personal twitter account.
>>
youtube.com/watch?v=FBcpj-ok1k0

I love this thing.
>>
>>141855265
So any Dezaki anime?
>>
>>141855987
It's hard to tell when the differences are more subtle, the few tagged posts tend to come from staff commentary found in the BDs.
>>
File: ohira.jpg (202 KB, 1328x720) Image search: [Google]
ohira.jpg
202 KB, 1328x720
So I was just watching God Bless Dancouga and noticed an animator wrote his name in the animation.
>>
File: SAKUGA.webm (2 MB, 640x360) Image search: [Google]
SAKUGA.webm
2 MB, 640x360
a strong competitor
>>
>>141856213
It's a wonder how Ohira went from a Kanada/Masahito Yamashita follower to having his own style of realism today.
>>
>>141855066
>>141855138

Are you guys special needs or something?
>>
File: 6a1b66_hq.jpg (43 KB, 1024x576) Image search: [Google]
6a1b66_hq.jpg
43 KB, 1024x576
>>141856262
WIT is truly the best studio of our time.
>>
>>141856262
More speed lines please
>>
>>141856326
>zooming in
>>
>>141856320
how about you learn what animation is
>>
>>141856359

>ignoring the smears and effects work

Try again.
>>
>>141856594
It's a weeb buzzword.
>>
>>141856320
The only part worth a bit of praise is the turn around the antagonist.
And it lasts less than 1 second.
The blond girl acceleration might look neat but if you look closely it's 1 second of a full body shot and 3 of smoke and speed lines. The close up on her face is all speed lines too, and not that impressive since turning from 3/4 face to front face has never been that hard to animate. I'll concede that the intervallists did a pretty good job, but the guy who did the key drawings was pretty damn lazy.
>>
>>141856501
But isn't this a sakuga thread?
For a ufotable thread, this would be relevant.
>>
>>141854872
This season is lacking Fuurota.
>>
>>141855286
Okay, but how is that relevant to this thread?
>>
>>141856674
Not him.

Sakuga =/= good animation.
Sakuga = Improvement in animation for a certain scene.

The scene he posted does this.
>>
>>141856653
>>141856739
Baited for these exact responses
>>
>>141856739
I've always hated this definition. I guess a series with consistently good animation has no sakuga, then.
>>
>>141855058
A pastebin and the sakuga booru?

Neither of them are blogs
>>
>>141856775
You'd have to be retarded to believe this.
>>
>>141856833
That's literally what that shitty definition implies.
>>
>>141856854
>hurr durr this animation is literally perfect and can't be better in any shape, way, or form.
>>
>>141856893
That has nothing to do with what I said.
>>
Not even trying to offend or bait anyone but yozakura quartet didn't interest me. At all. Animation in the webms are mostly from the OVAs from what I'm told on here, I watched the main series (not 2008, the newer one that supposedly follows the source material more accurately) and just wasn't feeling it. Didn't really like any characters so even if something cool happened I barely cared. I didn't get that far in tho so maybe o should try again one day
>>
Does every thread have to turn into shitposting, console/company/studio wars, bait , etc

Can't you people get along for once and post nice animation ? Its really not that hard
>>
File: Sakuga.webm (3 MB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
Sakuga.webm
3 MB, 1920x1080
>>141856921
You're implying that it's literally impossible for the animation to get any better.

Stop being a goddamn retard.
>>
>>141856854
Sakuga =animation
Motion graphics != Sakuga
>>
>>141856739
Sakuga literally means animation, it can be good or bad. Informally it is used to mean good animation.
>>
>>141856990

Sakuga (作画) (lit., "drawing pictures") is a term used in anime to describe moments in a show or movie when the quality of the animation improves drastically, typically for the sake of making a dramatic point or enlivening the action.
>>
>>141856926
The newer TV series has lots of good animation as well, but it's understandable if you didn't like it.
>>
>>141857020
That's an awful definition, where'd you get that?
>>
Sakuga = increased frames out of nowhere

Usually in either fights or character acting
>>
>>141857054
Google.

>>141857068
Basically this.
>>
File: definition nonsense.png (7 KB, 578x379) Image search: [Google]
definition nonsense.png
7 KB, 578x379
>>141856971
No, I'm saying that the definition
>Sakuga = Improvement in animation for a certain scene.
implies that a series with consistently good animation has no sakuga. It could be better, but that has nothing to do with this definition.
That is why I subscribe to this definition:
>>141856990
>Sakuga literally means animation, it can be good or bad. Informally it is used to mean good animation.
>>
>>141857085
I looked it up and it looks like it's by some random "anime expert".
>>
>>141857105
I'm convinced I'm being baited.
>>
File: a.png (21 KB, 578x379) Image search: [Google]
a.png
21 KB, 578x379
>>141857105
Is this shit really such a hard concept to grasp?
There's no such thing as "perfect" animation. Everything can always be improved, including the Sakuga itself.
>>
>>141856926
Nah it's boring shit. Would be forgettable Endride tier if it didn't get special attention/effort in production (I think someone being buddy-buddy with the mangaka wasn't it?)
>>
Mob psycho 100 wil probably have good animation this summer.
>>
>>141857252
There doesn't have to be "perfect" animation. That has nothing to do with it. I'm saying that your definition doesn't hold in the case of a show that has consistently the same quality of good animation. In that case those sakuga mounts wouldn't be in the goddamn graph and there would thus be no sakuga.
>>
>>141857302
Too bad it's unlikely to be as well-animated as OPM.
>>
>>141856971
Why is loli giving him a bj in front of other people?
>>
Fuck sakuga, just call it good animation.
>>
File: 1461788935196.webm (2 MB, 720x404) Image search: [Google]
1461788935196.webm
2 MB, 720x404
>>
>>141854824
just think if the godzilla movie wasnt made we could have already watched rebuild 4.44
>>
>>141857307
If a show has consistently good animation, but never tries to do any better at all for their more important scenes this never happens, then correct, no Sakuga.
>>
>>141857581
So even if all of the animation in that show was amazing, we would not be allowed to post it in these threads because the definition of sakuga is retardedly specific?
>>
>>141855150
Why do people keep posting this show? Sometimes even the best clips tend not to look so great.
>>
>>141857615
Yes.
Now try finding me a single example of a show that never does this.
>>
>>141857689
>itano circus
>not good every time

Get out
>>
>>141857330
why? it has a better staff.
>>
>>141856968
>Its really not that hard
Obviously, it is if this is how threads always turn out.
>>
>>141857707
Shinya Ohira's Asura's Wrath OVA.
>>
>>141857707
That's irrelevant. What matters is that the definition is really arbitrary. It could just be "good animation" and have the exact same effect, except it doesn't disqualify scenes because of things that aren't actually relevant to the scene of animation we're looking at.
>>
>>141857689
I would guess that the poster considers that scene to be cool and/or of good enough animation quality to fit the term sakuga=good animation=I liked it very much=some other definition.
>>
Lol what. Sakuga literally translated as animation. In anime sakuga is animated parts, while the rest of the show is typically a moving sprites due to shit budget.
True animation is when each frame is drawn from scratch.
>>
>>141857809
It won't have as many good animators on board as OPM, only a handful have gone over to work on Mob Psycho.
>>
File: 1461699906096.png (797 KB, 812x806) Image search: [Google]
1461699906096.png
797 KB, 812x806
>>141857840
>while the rest of the show is typically a moving sprites
>>
>>141856926
You don't need to write a blog post about your shit taste and the new TV series has tons of animation just as good as the OVAs.
>>
File: Ushiromiya_Battler2.png (623 KB, 921x1219) Image search: [Google]
Ushiromiya_Battler2.png
623 KB, 921x1219
>>141857814

>Good animation.

It's fucking shit most of the time. Skipping through it you can obviously see the scenes that were animated better than others.
>>
>>141854824
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tE7I7ffmIfg
>>
>>141857815
>That's irrelevant.
No it isn't. Since it doesn't exist, it doesn't exclude anything.
>>
File: 1406078623725.webm (3 MB, 800x450) Image search: [Google]
1406078623725.webm
3 MB, 800x450
Don't worry guys I'll save this thread.
>>
>>141858074
>It's fucking shit most of the time
Guess there's no helping your pleb taste in animation then.
>>
>>141858074
Are you fucking serious dude? That whole sequence was fucking gorgeous. I wish there's a way to see it without the big lifebar and QTEs
>>
File: 1344922346240.png (34 KB, 213x292) Image search: [Google]
1344922346240.png
34 KB, 213x292
>>141858129
>Type-shitters in charge of recognizing good animation
It's like SIlver Link wanted to out-CG Ufotable in the composite department.
>>
>>141858197
>>141858164

The scenes were set up great, most of the time the animation itself was shit. It was like watching a slideshow.
>>
>>141858129
Best episode
>>
>>141858197
>>
>>141858241
The OVA is packed with movement, what are you on about?
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zM4dKiF0-I
>>
>>141858301
Anon, I'm complaining about low framerate, not literal sliding pictures.
>>
>>141858129
I feel like that they have been doing the same movements throughout the entire clip. Was this supposed to be irony?
>>
>>141855231
CG mechs
>>
>>141855231
CG
>>
>>141858329
The framerate's par for the course as far as anime goes, if you don't like it there then you'd be annoyed at the vast majority of animation in anime.
>>
File: 1458424857135.webm (3 MB, 960x540) Image search: [Google]
1458424857135.webm
3 MB, 960x540
Henshin sequences are always nice to look at.
>>
>>141858526
>>141858497

CG is still animated by hand.
>>
File: Capture.png (28 KB, 145x118) Image search: [Google]
Capture.png
28 KB, 145x118
>>141858129
No, take your fate chunni garbage somewhere else, maybe /gd/ or /3/
>>
>>141858552
You and I must have watched two completely different things.
>>
File: 1414447044801.jpg (495 KB, 1922x2162) Image search: [Google]
1414447044801.jpg
495 KB, 1922x2162
>>141858606
>>
>>141858606
Yes, it's "animated" by hand, but it's still garbage.
>>
File: suitescale.webm (3 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
suitescale.webm
3 MB, 1280x720
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-9PB0D6_Lc
>>
File: 1456348894666.webm (2 MB, 800x450) Image search: [Google]
1456348894666.webm
2 MB, 800x450
This is what I would consider nega-sakuga.
>>
>>141858681
Subjective.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKGdEHH2WHg
>>
>>141858315
>not even taking the subtitles out
>French and English sub's at the same time
>>
>>141854824
>Gif
>>
>>141858715
Cringed.
>>
>>141858804
>High budget western CG
>Uses excessive shadows and bright lights to hide textures
>"Epic" slow down shots
CG has no business in animation outside of video games, and even then its only strength is that they're literal puppets that respond to directions.
>>
>>141858715
Jesus christ.
>>
>>141858497
>>141858526
That last fight in the tiger and bunny movie was CG and it looked amazing
>>
>>141858715
anyone who storyboards these kinds of scenes should kill themselves. THIS is forced animation, not the shit people are always bitching about on here
>>
File: 1457231587897.webm (2 MB, 960x540) Image search: [Google]
1457231587897.webm
2 MB, 960x540
I do have a sweet spot for Inferno Cop's "fight scenes".
>>
>>141859049
Sure it did.
>>
>>141858917
I also think muting the clip and adding music on top is bad since sakuga moments are much more enjoyable with good sound design and direction.
>>
>>141859082
I usually hate "forced" anything posts, but yeah that's forced animation. The animator has no idea how people move.
>>
File: forced animation.gif (2 MB, 392x294) Image search: [Google]
forced animation.gif
2 MB, 392x294
>>141859082
>>
>>141859020
Congratulations, you've proved yourself to be retarded, as well as the fact that you know fuck-all about CG.
>>
File: 1445964397799.gif (169 KB, 500x380) Image search: [Google]
1445964397799.gif
169 KB, 500x380
>>141859088
>He was a formidable opponent
Everytime.
>>
>>141858804
I---I think I really hate this. It's trying too hard to be a movie, but doesn't realize that the reason scenes are in American action movies look that way is because the actors can't really do really good action scenes. It's all about the beauty of editing.

Then it's like the slow downs don't really make any sense? Like, yeah he's falling off the thing, but I have no sense of danger for the character so it doesn't provide anything for me except that it looks ridiculous.
>>
>>141859082
>>141859142
It's horrible, but "forced" anything still shouldn't be a thing. It's dumb.
>>
>>141859225

>>141859159
>>
>>141855058
I didn't see the 'please subscribe' part
>>
>>141859159
>YOU JUST DON'T KNOW CG
CG are puppets that take commands. Please feel free to actually try to prove me wrong instead of spewing retarded shit to pretend that I simply don't understand your "artform".
>>
>>141858606
No. It's motion is automatically interpolated between keyframes
>>
File: 1459994817240.webm (2 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1459994817240.webm
2 MB, 1280x720
>>
CAN'T HAVE AN ANIMATION THREAD WITHOUT MAH BOY, REDLIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIINE

And Sword of the Stranger, but I don't have webms of those.
>>
>>141855987
You credit them yourself then.
>>
>>141859346
Just go watch any Pixar making of. Seriously you're like those old people that think making games boils down to pushing a magical make game button.
>>
File: stranger.webm (3 MB, 640x360) Image search: [Google]
stranger.webm
3 MB, 640x360
>>141859427
got you covered senpai.
>>
>>141855058
not that anon, but you sure are retarded.
>>
>>141859458
>You just don't understand!
>But I'm not going to actually explain anything
Didn't think so. Good effort on the shitposting.
>>
File: REDLIIIIIIIIIIIIIIINE.webm (2 MB, 855x480) Image search: [Google]
REDLIIIIIIIIIIIIIIINE.webm
2 MB, 855x480
>>141859427
FUCK, I FORGOT TO POST IT. SORRY.
>>
File: 1446336070421.webm (3 MB, 896x504) Image search: [Google]
1446336070421.webm
3 MB, 896x504
I would love to see a Miku animu in that CG style.
>>
>>141859225
I think you're on to something there. The camera work in that scene kinda feels that way to me too, the way it jerks and wobbles that's really handy if you want to conceal what would be awful-looking action if you shot it with a still camera. I'd imagine people will justify this kind of thing with how it "immerses" you or other such vague words, but sometimes I wonder whether they even know why they're doing it.
>>
>>141859346
>CG are puppets that take commands.
What about it? Stop pretending like that's some sort of problem.

>>141859411
Who do you think sets up said keyframes? Do you really think that you set up a pose, and it just magically works?
No, take Guilty Gear for example, each and every single frame of the character had to be edited for hours on end just to get the character to look right.
>>
>>141859528
Why explain when you're already this biased against 3D animation? There's no point on arguing with you when you're so close minded.
>>
>>141859530
If you must post Redline in a sakuga thread, at least post a part where there's animation, not just a zoom-in on a facial shot.
>>
>>141859624
>What about it? Stop pretending like that's some sort of problem.
You're a fucking idiot.

>GG as an example
>Literally drew every frame by hand and went out of their fucking way to make it look like 2D because they know that CG inherently looks like shit
You're a special kind of fucking idiot.

>>141859641
>I don't have to prove me point!
Just keep pretending you have one.
>>
>>141859712
You sound like a 12 year old.
>>
>>141859138
But the dubstep, anon
>>
>>141859648
Nigga, what are you on about? There is so much animation going on in that clip alone. The tears coming out of the eyes, the sweat, the shading, the earrings jingling, the eyes and their red spots. Come on now.
>>
>>141859712
>Literally drew every frame by hand and went out of their fucking way to make it look like 2D because they know that CG inherently looks like shit

I think we're done with this conversation, because that's 100% incorrect.
>>
>>141859770
And you sound like an ill-informed idiot.
>>
File: 1441742043565.webm (2 MB, 720x480) Image search: [Google]
1441742043565.webm
2 MB, 720x480
I really liked that scene from Petite Princess Yucie. The demon realm princess was my favorite character, and her adventures in the demon realm were quite something.
>>
>>141855987
KyoAnifags learn to animate the KyoAni way. Finding a specific animator is difficult.
>>
File: 9xBMngt.jpg (117 KB, 1440x810) Image search: [Google]
9xBMngt.jpg
117 KB, 1440x810
>>141859841
Try harder kid
>>
Should we mount a mutiny against aers and his fag brigade? He is a shitter that can't even name 10 animators, people like him shouldn't be in charge of sakugabooru. Let's just burn sakugabooru to the ground, change the world forever.
>>
>>141859901
Why not make a sakugabooru ourselves?
>>
>>141859831
>because that's 100% incorrect.
Actually they were animated to look like 2D as much as possible with the quote being to "kill everything 3D" and the close ups and cutscenes were all done by hand. Yes, they did their best to make it look 2D because 2D looks like shit.

>>141859885
Why are you posting garbage?
>>
File: zVwGYOL.jpg (36 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
zVwGYOL.jpg
36 KB, 1280x720
>>141859962
Keep trying son
>>
>>
>>141859988
Trying not to post garbage? Ok.
>>
>>141860045

You can do it I believe in you
>>
>>141860060
You forgot your example of CG """animation"""
>>
>>141859530
Should I give Redline another chance? I watched it a couple years ago but I was bored to death by everything besides the animation.
>>
>>141859962
CG isn't an artstyle, anon. It's a method of creation.
>>
>>141860112
Yeah mate. Just do one thing for me when you do watch it. Have fun, that's all I ask. I tell that to everyone when I reccomend it.
>>
>>
>>141854975
Anyone know who actually animated this scene?
>>
>>141860241
hideki hamasu
>>
>>141859847
That episode was done by Imaishi, I do believe.
>>
File: venus1.webm (3 MB, 960x540) Image search: [Google]
venus1.webm
3 MB, 960x540
>>
>>141859312
What does editing, fighting choreography, and direction have to do with not knowing anything about CG though?
>>
>>141860633
Nothing. CGfags are retarded and in denial.
>>
File: 1391823707306.png (160 KB, 620x454) Image search: [Google]
1391823707306.png
160 KB, 620x454
It's like each sakuga thread is worse than the last one.
>>
Star Wars lol

>>141860271
How do you know this kind of stuff, where can I check it?
I while ago I tried to find out who animated >>141860234 but couldn't find out anything.

>>141859225
Thoughts on this?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjXr9Nj5ZbI
>>
>>141860899
sakugabooru, very informative site. just have to be careful of spoilers is all

>>141860830
i really wish it didn't always devolve into "is this actually sakuga though?"
>>
File: 1461285225299.webm (2 MB, 880x480) Image search: [Google]
1461285225299.webm
2 MB, 880x480
That's what i call sakuga
>>
File: 1442953386660.webm (2 MB, 950x530) Image search: [Google]
1442953386660.webm
2 MB, 950x530
DIE QUALITY CABBAGE
>>
>>141860966
There were some absolute gems during that expo, but the staggering amount of CG was depressing, especially during the last one.
>>
>>141860959
What if Sakugabooru doesn't have the information?
Any other way to find out?
>>
>>141856971
>thread full of shitty action scenes
>no character animations

what a cancerous scene.
>>
Will cg ever be good

I can't watch the recent slew of all cg shows
>>
>>141861356
>Will cg ever be good

Yes, it's called Kizumonogatari.
>>
>>141860830
Whoever cropped him really could have done a better job
>>
>>141861356
Disney died, the digital jew took over, and now it's leaked into Japan.
>>
>>141861356
I enjoyed BBK. It wasn't a GOOD show but the CGI was interesting and the plot took a retarded but still very fun direction near the end. Bad walking animation aside, the CGI did some good stuff with the action and the body movements.
>>
>>141860271
Thanks, I couldn't find any info on him, seems like he's either under appreciated or straight up keeps hidden
>>
>>141861356
In anime, not for a long time I think.

All the good CG animators tend to go do vidya or get snatched by high end CG studios like SEVW
>>
>>141860966
Where can I find more of the same?
>>
>>141861255
If sakugabooru doesn't have anything, just make wild guesses and hope nobody calls you out.
>>
File: 1447962926426.webm (2 MB, 1056x1066) Image search: [Google]
1447962926426.webm
2 MB, 1056x1066
The drumming sequences are generally even better.
I guess Ryo Sasacky himself is an avid drummer.
>>
>>141860899
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjXr9Nj5ZbI

It's interesting. It tells a much better story and is way more interesting to watch than the Batman clip, but is it fair to compare? The other one is taken out of context, but it's apart of a larger narrative even if on it's own it doesn't really stand strong.

This video is an short film though so it needs more otherwise it would be a failure.
>>
>>141856010
Can someone shed some light on the music? It doesn't translate well enough to let me find an artist.
>>
https://youtu.be/TSbSzrLffew
>>
>>141861356
Show By Rock and Etotama have decent CG.
>>
>>141861758
I cannot unsee that nose being a mouth..
>>
>>141862111
Over-saturated colors and spinning shaky cam is what qualifies decent now?
>>
File: 1434310745893.webm (3 MB, 710x400) Image search: [Google]
1434310745893.webm
3 MB, 710x400
>>141862209
Curse you for making me do that again. It took me almost an entire week to mentally dissociate the mouth-noses when watching the Criticristas.
>>
>>141862337
Decent compared to what you usually get in anime.
>>
File: 1435794081591.jpg (627 KB, 1360x1458) Image search: [Google]
1435794081591.jpg
627 KB, 1360x1458
>>141861758
I'll never understand why I loved SHOW BY ROCK! so much. Its really not that great, but I find it so damn charming and enjoyable. I can't wait for the shorts and S2
>>
File: end of the Fumers.webm (3 MB, 640x360) Image search: [Google]
end of the Fumers.webm
3 MB, 640x360
>>141862518
Not at all. An "average" looking anime would be something like Anne Happy airing this season. Pretty standard art with no action shots, but even then it still looks nice and has a few pretty looking scenes. Then the you get things like Concrete Revolution or Hero Academy or Ushio to Tora which have really nice art styles and some good animation, with the occasional sakuga. The only things that CG can even be compared to is the absolute worst each season has to offer.
>>
>>141861383
Kizu's CG is better than normal shows but it's still fucking jarring to see it in those top down shots and Shinobu diving off the roof.
>>
>>141862680
>jarring

No, not really.
>>
I'll save the thread guys.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yllHBYFnGhk
>>
>>141862775
Yes it is. Are CGfags actually blind?
>>
File: 1 (10).png (52 KB, 420x294) Image search: [Google]
1 (10).png
52 KB, 420x294
>CG hate
>>
>>141861383
good stuff

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvPZGSyAUmw
>>
>>141862670
I meant compared to the CG you usually get in anime.
>>
The problem with CG is that TV-tier CG will never, ever look good. There is good-looking CG, like in the Peanuts movie or Zootopia. But TV CG always looks like garbage, just look at the ugly cheap stuff Dreamworks produces for Netflix.
>>
>>141863000
Yes, it looked better than normal anime CG. But the point is why would we want CG at all? It's done nothing good for the industry.
>>
>>141860546

>Crystal suddenly becoming sakuga stock heaven

What the fuck happened?
>>
>>141862337
>Over-saturated colors and spinning shaky cam is what qualifies decent now?

That describes every sakuga webm quite well.
>>
File: no you piece of shit.jpg (274 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
no you piece of shit.jpg
274 KB, 1280x720
>>141863144
>>
File: 1434908056661.webm (2 MB, 900x506) Image search: [Google]
1434908056661.webm
2 MB, 900x506
>>141862633
I guess it would be because it is solid work.
Vibrant colors, attractive character designs, interesting technical backgrounds as designed by Fumihiro Katagai (I really loved Yokai Town with all its cables and cameras), cute characters, the theme about searching for your dreams, growing up, finding love and never giving up, the quirky characters, the quite enthusiastic voice acting, and it being absolutely unknown on 4chan prior to its airing except on the cosplay boards lead it to being that sudden dark horse that does emit a strange fascination. The 2D and 3D animation being of high quality helps too.

Also, Cyan is a cutefu.
>>
>>141863091

It's good for after effects, but that's pretty much it.
>>
File: Chuchu-Show-By-Rock.jpg (87 KB, 557x1000) Image search: [Google]
Chuchu-Show-By-Rock.jpg
87 KB, 557x1000
>>141863255
Also because all of Criticrista is god-tier
>>
>>141863257
Are most of those even CG or are they just digital?
>>
I think that CG and hand-drawn animation are both interesting and exciting in their own ways and that the world would be a better place if we could all just learn to get along.
>>
>>141863435
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BPWj_4RtKr0
There's the same scene done with hand drawn and CG. If you still think that after watching the same scene done both ways that CG should be a part of anime, you're beyond help.
>>
>>141863435
It's just one guy
>>
>>141863628
Strange. I thought I saw that sequence for the Macross Pachinko machines.
>>
>>141863764
It is for the pachinko machines, that's not the point.
>>
Anyone got info on Takahiro Kishida?
https://sakuga.yshi.org/post/show/5195/animated-creatures-morphing-serial_experiments_lai


Also, how do you people find wembs that aren't over 4 MB? Almost everything on Sakugabooru is over that, unless it's really short.
>>
>>141863628

The big problem with that is that the CG looks like it was simply used to cut down the cost and production time. In order for it to look good, it needs to be given a large budget and enough time to be polished off. Both of those things are severely lacking with anime.
>>
>>141863918
>it was simply used to cut down the cost and production time
Yes, that's what CG is. If they had time and money, they would pay real animators to make it properly.
>>
What does /a/ think of Michio MIhara?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8aQPVInKdg
>>
>>141861255
Sakugawiki
Guesswork
Twitter

get creative anon
>>
>>141863820
If it's good enough for pachinko where oldfag otaku spend their money to watch those sequences over and over again after getting a CHANCE~u, then it is good enough for all the oldfag otaku who want to own it on BD.

Big West Advertising sure knows how to wring out money from all those guys.
>>
Why didn't the Sakuga Panel have a part dedicated to Toshiyuki Inoue? The guy is incredible.
>>
>>141862838
you can get used to a lot of things.
>>
>>141864058
I ought to watch Paprika.
>>
>>141864016
CGI is more expensive.
>>
>>141865173
CGI has a different cost model. You invest more time up-front but save if you can reuse.
>>
>>141865173
Initially, yes. But the models get reused to the point that it becomes cost effective. It's just laziness used to save time and money.
>>
>>141856775
That's why when Japanese people say "Sakuga sugoi ne". But in the west, people usually say the part when there is a lot of movement and the motion is fluid.

Effects however, is a different ball game.
>>
>>141864570
Wolf Children looked bad, the part in the gif wasn't impressive at all.
>>
>>141865230
A full fledged 3D movie is still more expensive than a 2D one though.

>>141865234
Most 3D in anime is background shit and mechas, because apparently all mechanical animators are fucking dead.
>>
>>141865173
>CGI is more expensive
If that was true, the jews from Disney will never switch from 2D to 3D then
>>
>>141865476
They use 3D because they think it has wider appeal.
>>
>>141865446
>because apparently all mechanical animators are fucking dead.
Are you trying to make me sad? Because it worked.
>>
File: what is that movement.webm (2 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
what is that movement.webm
2 MB, 1280x720
>>141865446
>because apparently all mechanical animators are fucking dead

Don't worry, you can still enjoy superior 2D hand-drawn animation anytime.
>>
>>141865425
You're wrong the guy is a god:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m6Eigpn-fSE
>>
>>141854824
That hardly qualifies as good animation.
>>
>>141865446
>mechanical animators are fucking dead

*Dying.
>>
>>141865476
Lion king had budget of $45mil, Big Hero 6 had 165. The only reason that they're switched to 3d it's because 3d generates more money.
>>
>>141856739
Effects have nothing to do with sakuga.
Sakuga is based on the skill of the animator.
He talked about smear and effect works, neither are relevant.
>>
File: 1458965341470.webm (3 MB, 720x405) Image search: [Google]
1458965341470.webm
3 MB, 720x405
Those dance animation sequences are always nice.
Of course, what makes them even more surprising is the fact that it's actually fucking Pokémon.
Little children anime shows always surprise you with such things.

I really ought to browse the idle activities and precure threads for some nice scenes.
>>
>>141863435
I do think its pretty obvious CG isn't going to go away anytime soon, and might even be more prevalent as time goes on. Not that I want hand-drawn to go away completely, but if there has to be CG, I'd at least want to see them improving their usage of it. The better looking CG studios are at least getting better at using more relevant techniques like deformation and remodeling individual frames, so its a start.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 123

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.