3 episodes have elapsed for most of the shows, now rate them.
God tier:
>Macross Delta
Good tier:
>Netoge
>Kabane
Meh tier:
>Haifuri
>Kuma Miko
Bad tier:
>Ace Attorney
>Mayoiga
Shit tier:
>Hundred
>Asterisk
![[HorribleSubs] Tanaka-kun wa Itsumo Kedaruge - 02 [1080p].mkv_snapshot_20.17_[2016.04.16_17.34.21].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/O76zLRR.jpg "[HorribleSubs] Tanaka-kun wa Itsumo Kedaruge - 02 [1080p].mkv_snapshot_20.17_[2016.04.16_17.34.21].jpg")
Only the shows that I actually saw three episodes of:
>potential AOTS:
Flying Witch
Tanaka-kun
>Great:
Sansha Sanyou
Kuromukuro
Kuma Miko
Unhappy(only because of the lesbians)
>Good enough:
Pan de Peace
Bungou Stray Dogs
From the staff I haven't yet gotten around to watching three episodes, Haifuri was the best, Kiznaiver and Bakuon tied for most disappointing(though Kiznaiver at least looks decent).
Shit taste and fuck-giving general?
>>140663584
Posts yours faggot.
I'm only watching Boku No Hero Academia this season and it hasn't even gotten to the first real fight yet.
Still want to see if we got BONES' good animators or bad ones like Soul Eater Not's.
>>140663288
>God tier:
>>Macross Delta
>>>/v/
>>140663853
Heh, it's the show I dropped the hardest. Shitty generic predictable boring battle shounen
>>140663875
>/v/
>idols
Kabaneri is /v/. Macross is /c/
>>140663288
>listing
That's belong to >>>/mal/
Now, why don't you tell me, Anon. What makes Macross Delta God tier, and what makes Kabaneri and Netoge a good tier?
>>140663288
fuck you nigger, i like hundred
god teir
>habenero
>re zero
>mayoiga
great tier
>cerberus
>onmyouji
>joker game
>bungo
excellent tier
>hundred
>big order
>jojo
>netoge
Already drop the rest.
Thinking about picking up Sansha, Tanaka, and Haifuri, are they all still good after 3 episodes?
>>140663894
Your loss
>>140664020
Haifuri is good. Episode 3 feels like a cooldown though.
God tier:
>Kuma Miko
>Kiznaiver
Good tier:
>Netoge
>Jojo part 4
>Luluco
>Sansha Sanyou
>Anne Happy
>Flying Witch
Meh tier:
>Mayoiga
>Boku no Hero Academia
Pretty comfy season.
>>140663894
I was tempted to try it out because the Doujins of the frog girl or whatever were pretty good.
But if it's just another bit of Shonen Jump fodder, I'll skip it.
Macross Delta has some pretty decent animation, but I'm not sold on it, either.
Will continue lurking. We'll see if anything better pops up this season. Galko was some good dumb fun, but... ah, who the hell am I kidding. I've long passed the point of "Anime is fun", and gone off the deep end into the "Which of these will get the best doujins at the next comiket". That's usually what ends up selling me on a show.
>Kiznaiver
>Best
Kuma Miko
Great
Kuromokuro
Marcross
Haifuri
Re:zero
Good
Flying Witch
Netogame
Mayoiga
Jokers Game
Habenero
>Meh
BnH (it's only 12 episodes it's been slow and nothing has really happened yet)
Bakuon
Sousei no Onmyouji
Sakamoto desu ga
Dropped
Kiznaiver
Buthole shit dog
Big pile of shit
I'm thinking about dropping Haifuri, there's too many characters and it's a bit confusing, also, should I pick up Netoge?
>God tier:
Macross Delta
Joker game
JOJO
>Good Tier
Kuromukuro
Sakamoto
Boku no hero academia
>OK Tier
Kiznaiver
Luluco
I'm really surprised about how good Delta,pretty good season overall
God tier:
>Macross Delta
>Good tier:
>kabaneri
>luluco
>jojo
>joker game
Meh tier:
>kiznaiver
>netoge
>boku no hero
Shit tier:
>mayoiga
>>140663288
>rating shows with only 3 episodes worth of content
Is /a/ becoming MAL?
>Fun tier
Luluco
Kuma Miko
>Interesting tier
Kabaneri
>Hilariously bad tier
Mayoiga
>Just plain bad tier
Kiznaiver
>Please do not fuck this up again tier
Jojo
>>140664964
>a good portion of /a/ has similarly low power level to MAL's userbase
Good:
Kabaneri, Re:Zero
Entertaining:
Luluco, boku no hero academia
Still giving a chance but so far it's shit :
Kiznaiver
>>140663988
>big order
>okay
is this bait
>people actually consider netoge to be good
stop watching with your dick
god tier
>asterisk
>kabaneri
>jojo
good tier
>kuromukuro
>netoge
>sousei no omniyouji
>tanaka
big order
bad tier
>sakamoto
>re:zero
shit
everything else (excluding thos i havent watched)
meaning to say almost all main stream/ hyped shows that i dropped
>>140665226
>asterisk
>god tier
Now theres a name i never thought i would ever see higher than shit tier.
>>140665268
What do you expect from someone who thinks Netoge is good?
>>140664964
Based on 3 episode rule, which is an /a/ original standard.
This season has been full of surprises! I wasn't hyped for a single series until I started watching a few of them at random.
>Potential AOTS tier
Re:Zero
Sakamoto desu ga?
>Very good tier
Flying Witch
>Good enough tier
Mayoiga
Luluco
>About to drop tier
Boku no Tearful Academia
Kizunaiba
God:
Macross
Kuromukuro
Kabaneri
Kiznaiver
Good:
Asterisk
Concrete
Mayoiga
Ok
Hundred
Jojo
Netoge
Sakamoto
ReZero
Meh:
Bungou
Big order
Boku hero
Terraformars
Shit:
anything not listed
>>140665309
You mean the Madoka rule?
>God tier
Macross
Kabaneri
>Good tier
Jojo
Kumamiko
Luluco
Haifuri
Mayoiga
>Ok tier
Kuromukuro
Bakuon
Sakamoto
>Dropped tier
Kiznaiver
I really like the animation and art in kiznaiver, but the people rating it God tier also like the story?
It's not even trying to make sense.
>>140663894
It has actual likeable characters though
>>140663988
Some of the moeshit deserves a "great" and Joker Game is complete trash, but apart from that I mostly agree with this.
>Meme tier
Mayoiga
>Great tier
Re:Zero
Kabaneri
Sakamoto
>Enjoyable Tier
Luluco
Kiznaiver
Jojo
Kumamiko
Bacon hero academics
>Probably gonna drop tier
Netoge
Joker Game
>>140665395
>>140665662
Also, my list
>Great
Anne Happy
Luluco
Mayoiga
>Good
Flying Witch
Re:Zero
Kabaneri
>Okay
Bakuon
Sakamoto
Kiznaiver
Boku no Pico Academy
>Dropped
Joker Game
Kumamiko
Considering picking up Haifuri.
>>140665311
add Joker Game to drop-tier
>>140665760
>getting called out for baiting
>>140665794
Well, they did have Kiznaiver as 'god tier' and Asterisk as 'good'. That's a bit of a giveaway.
>>140665435
Is that even a thing?
>>140665843
>they like these shows which i dont like
>they must be baiting
>>140665844
Yes, but it's bullshit. People with actual taste who don't rate anime based on "plot" know what they'll like within a few minutes.
>>140665879
So people with taste have clairvoyance?
God tier
>Macross Delta
Good tier:
>TV Unicorn
>Re:Zero
>Jojo
Meh tier:
>Hundred
Shit tier:
>Every SoLshit this season
Over the top shit tier:
>every moeshit this season
Is Macross basicly symphogear 2016. I only want to pick it up if the livestreams are just as fun. Do I need to see previous macross seasons?
>>140665980
Macross is symphogear for heterosexual people
You can watch it however you like
>>140665951
You're probably talking to one of the Haifuri shitposters and someone who unironically thinks Unhappy is a decent moe show. He doesn't think he's clairvoyant- he just doesn't imagine he could ever be wrong, so he thinks that everything be was excited for is great, and everything he wasn't is shit.
>>140666006
>Macross is symphogear for heterosexual people
I'll take it
Sakamoto a best
>>140663288
>Shit tier:
>Hundred
>Asterisk
everyfuckingtime.
eat shit you little faget
Kiznaiver is tanking fast.
Myoiga is starting to get interesting.
Re:Zero is getting really fucking dark and I love it.
Sakamoto's staying cool.
>>140666104
battle harem 13 year old spotted
>>140665951
People with taste can judge writing, style, and general atmosphere of the anime in less time than an hour.
>>140666022
I've been surprised by anime quite a bit and I've been disappointed by anime quite a bit, but I don't remember ever liking a show when I didn't like the first episode. I've dropped things I liked the first episode of, though.
And I'm curious, what's wrong with Unhappy? I think it's cute.
>>140665844
Yeah because of how ep 3 was people seem to give everything a 3 ep rule nowadays, even though it's only true for that one series.
>>140665662
>moeshit
>>140666136
Evangelion was generic as fuck until the good bits kicked in, if you were being as pretentious as you are now when you watched it you would've skipped it.
>>140666191
Youre not gonna send him to /v/?
>>140666104
>he actually like IS ripoff
>>140665879
>People with actual taste who don't rate anime based on "plot" know what they'll like within a few minutes.
You can't tell ahead of time if a series will follow through and make the most of its good premise, and you can't tell if a series is going to start dropping bombshells of juicy plot that make even the slow start look retroactively great.
>>140666104
Asterisk is a series made to cater to people who will watch literally anything as long as it has bright flashy colours and cute girls. It is a fantastic example of shit tier.
>>140666104
It does not make sense really, only people who like battle harems would watch those shows
But then you have people like OP who obviously doesnt like them but still watches them
But then again, its possible that he did not watch them and just shits on them because he doesnt like the genre
>>140666136
Unhappy is cute, I guess, but is completely outshined in it's genre by Flying Witch, Bakuon, and Haifuri, all of which are significantly better comedy SOL than Unhappy. Unhappy is really just generic moe- not much comedy, just a lot of cute.
>Dropped
Kabaneri
Kiznaiver
Re:zero
Mayoiga
Omyouji
Netoge
Gyakuten Saiban
Big Order
Tanaka-kun
Kuma Miko
>Not Dropped
Anne Happy
Crane game
Academia
Flying Witch
Haifuri
Pan de Peace
Sakamoto
Sansha Sanyou
Usakame
Wagamama
>>140666374
It's definitely on the lower end of cute girls this season, but it's better than Sansha sanyou
>>140666192
>Evangelion was generic as fuck
Not really, but I guess it would be really weird for me to dislike a show through the end after a bad first episode, that sounds really stupid as the other anon suggests.
>>140666400
>Re:zero
I don't know why you dropped this but I'm assuming it's because of the MC, he acts like this to make the shift later on better. I'd recommend picking it back up again.
>>140666400
>dropped
>re:zero
oh shit nigga what you doin
>>140666475
Yeah, If I were to judge Evangelion by its first few episodes I'd assume it were generic monster of the week with a whiney MC, it takes a while to show what makes it so good.
Madoka is similar, it changed massively on the 3rd episode and that's why the "rule" was made.
>Top tier
Kiznaiver
Kabaneri
Jojo
Luluco
>Good tier
Mayoiga
My Hero Academia
>>140666192
I don't think so, but I can't say for sure. I liked NGE from the beginning when I watched it and I still do, but maybe I'm biased.
>>140666191
I like moe, don't be too upset
>>140666285
>You can't tell ahead of time if a series will follow through and make the most of its good premise
Right, as I said in >>140666136 some shows get worse over time.
>You can't tell if a series is going to start dropping bombshells of juicy plot
I can if it's a generic LN adaptation that screams "SAO". Maybe I've missed things because I'm too quick to drop anime, but I think I browse /a/ enough that I'd notice when a seemingly shitty show suddenly becomes good.
>>140666374
>just a lot of cute
Kind of the point of moe. This would be enough for me, but I think it's also pretty funny. Bakuon is neither, in my opinion, but that's just personal taste.
>>140666477
>>140666494
i didn't like time loop bullshit
Good Tier
Hundred
Netoge
Kabane
Bakuon
Shit Tier
everything else
Jesus Christ this is one of the worst anime ever tier
Big Order
>>140666573
What don't you like about the time loop? Too edgy?
>>140663288
God tier
>Luluko
>Kiznaiver
>Jojo
shit tier
>everything else
>>140666593
>netoge
>good tier
Jesus Christ this is one of the worst anime tier list ever
>>140666627
Look, it's the only Big Order fan on /a/
all im watching is kiznaiver and kagewani
>>140666641
I've never watched that, just surprised someone would watch something as bad as Netoge.
>>140666718
>I've never watched that,
Sure BOfag.
>>140666613
>kiznaiver
>>140666779
The only BO here is emanating from the armpits of the braindead Netoge viewers.
>>140663288
>God tier:
Tanaka-kun
Sansha Sanyou
>Great
Anne Happy
Kuromukuro
Re:Zero
Ushio to Tora S2
>Ok tier
Boku no Pico Academia
Bungou gay dogs
>Meh tier
Ace Attorney
Sakamotofucking DEEN
>Fucking dropped tier
Big Order
Netoge
Hundred
Kiznaiver
>Enjoying the most
Kuma Miko
Kiznaiver
Koutetsujou no Kabaneri
Bungou Stray Dogs
Bakuon
>Good
Pan de Peace!
Boku no Hero Academia
flying witch
Haifuri
Tanaka-kun
Luluco
Sakamoto
Joker Game
Re: Zero
>Okay
Ace Attorney
Mayoiga
Shounen Maid
Netoge
Anne Happy
Wagamama
Sansha Sanyou
>Iffy
Tonkatsu DJ Agetarou
Endride
Big Order
Sousei no Onmyouji
Hundred
Seisen Cerberus
>Obligatory sequel watch
Sailor Moon
Ushio
Rinne
Terra Formars
Concrete Revolution
Kagewani
I haven't watched Kuromukuro yet.
>AOTS
Sakamoto
Flying Witch
>Great
Concrete Revolution S2
Mayoiga
Jojo DiU
Kiznaiver
>Enjoyable
Anne Happy
Haifuri
Kabaneri
Shounen Maid
Luluco
Re:Zero
Joker Game
Macross Delta
Everything else was either dropped or didnt grab my attention
>god tier
tonkatsu dj
>will keep watching tier
kiznaiver
joker game
tanaka-kun
sakamoto
kabaneri(ep 3 will decide)
Re:Zero
Mayoiga
Kuma miko(might drop tough, pretty boring)
>dropped
Bungou Stray Dogs
Boku no Hero
Bakuon
Great
>Kuma Miko
>Tanaka-kun
>Hero Academy
>Concrete Revolutio
Good
>Sakamoto
>Kiznaiver (only if it doesn't try to take itself too seriously in the future)
>Shounen Maid
Ok
>Luluco
>Bungou Stray Dogs
Dropped
>Mayoiga
Good season
>>140663288
>God tier:
Kabaneri
Re Zero
>Good tier:
Stray Dogs and Joker game
>Meh tier:
Big Order
Jojo
>Bad tier:
Netoge
Mayoiga
>Shit tier:
Hundred
Asterisk
>>140663288
God-tier:
>Bungou Stray Dogs
>Kuromukoro
>JoJo
Good tier:
>Tanaka-kun
>Kabaneri
>Kiznaiver
Meh tier, still watching:
>Mayoiga
>Joker Game
>Re:Zero
Shit/dropped at first episode tier:
>Seisen Cerberus
>Ace Attorney
Didn't watch tier:
Everything else.
God Tier:
> Mayoiga
> Re:Zero
Good Tier:
> Big Order
> Kabaneri
Meh Tier:
> Kiznaiver
> Asterisk
> Hundred
Shit Tier
> Cerberus
>>140663288
>Using the 3 episode rule
That rule is retarded and anyone who uses it is a giga-faggotron that should have a hydrogen bomb rammed up their asses and detonated the moment it's completely deep.
>high tier
luluco
kabaneri
>meh tier
flying witch
haifuri
>dropped
kiznaiver
hero academia
>>140663288
>watching less than 10 anime
The 20+ master race wants you to leave.
>>140663288
>great tier
JoJo
Flying Witch
Kuma Miko
>good tier
Sansha Sanyou
Mayoiga
Bungou Stray Dogs
Hero Academia
Sakamoto
Haifuri
Luluco
>meh tier
Bakuon
Joker Game
>It's edgy but fun
Habanero
>It's fun despite the shitposting and shitty plot
Kiznaiver
>Haven't watched but want to
Macross
Kuromukuro
Tanaka-kun
I'd say this season is pretty good, but you're going to complain anyway.
>>140665146
It's not good but not so shit. It's okay. This is not bait.
>Great
Joker Game
Kabaneri
Sakamoto
>Good
Bungou Stray Dogs
Gyakuten Saiban
Hero AcademiaSuper Lovers
>Okay
Mayoiga
Kiznaiver
Shounen Maid
>Meh
Endride
>Dropped
Flying Witch
>Still watching tier:
Macross Delta
Kuromukuro
Kabaneri
>>140663288
reminder that re zero is one of the best anime this season, both cinematography wise plotwise and character wise
>God
Luluco
>Great
Netoge
Anne Happy
>Good
Mayoiga
>Meh
Bakuon
>Gonna drop
Sakamoto
Work schedule's squeezing what little time I have left so probably going to drop everything from meh and below. Whoopee.
>>140670201
>netoge
>great
the fact that people like this actually exist on this website is disheartening
>>140663495
>SoLfag
>no one watching Sakamoto
Shit taste literally gay faggots.
>>140670326
it's only on ep 2
>>140670477
>cancelling my anime for earthquakes
Tsunami best day of my life
>>140670326
We already read the manga.
>>140672056
>reading manga
Sorry I'm not a weeb
>>140670307
SoL is a patrician's choice
>>140663288
So is macross delta good enought to watch? I disliked frontier and harem shit is a turn off.
>>140663288
>Macross Delta
Am I the only one rooting for the space Nazi liking classic music over the multicultural kpop loving degenerate ?
>Macross Delta
>Kuromukuro
Only watching Mecha this season. Any other mecha this season besides those two?
>Great:
Concrete Revolutio: Choujin Gensou - The Last Song
>Good:
Koutetsujou no Kabaneri
Macross Δ
Re:Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu
Kuromukuro
Tonkatsu DJ Agetarou
>Decent:
Kiznaiver
Kuma Miko
Hundred
JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken: Diamond wa Kudakenai
>Average:
Gakusen Toshi Asterisk 2nd Season
Bakuon!!
Flying Witch
Anne Happy
>Meh:
Mayoiga
Uchuu Patrol Luluco
>>140673481
If you like break-dancing mechs and combat idorus, go for it. The threads are fun at the very least.
>>140663288
Holy fucking shit, how is Kabaneri so good? I don't have any magor interest in trains, past-future japan and zombies but this fucking show i so good. I was waiting the whole time for something to let me down yet it just kept on delivering.
