Is this accurate?
- Home
- Board: /a/ - Anime & Manga
- Reading: Is this accurate?
Is this accurate?
>2004
>not Enokido's masterpiece
It's wrong.
Looks fine to me.
Mostly, I disagree with GITS, Baccano and Time of Eve. The rest is fine.
Why is Monster above 2nd gig? Is Monster good?
Sure, if the quality of an anime is determined by its pretentiousness
then yeah this list is fine.
Seems pretty normalfag
>>133575943
>gits
kill yourself my man
>>133575982
Nope
>2012
>no mention of Milky Holmes S2
>>133575562
>Aria better than Casshern Sins AND Kaiba
Yeah fuck you
>>133575982
Monster is the worst Anime of all time.
2000: Ippo
2001: Baki
2002: Chobits (not a very good year)
2003: Kino
2004: Major s1
2005: Major s2
2006: Code Geass R1
2007: Kaiji
2008: Clannad AS (Best year)
2009: Tokyo Magnitude 8.0
2010: Rainbow
2011: Steins;Gate
2012: Kids on the Slope
2013: Ippo Rising
2014: Ping Pong
2015: Diamond no Ace
Is that just a rearranged version of this one? Because it's inferior.
>2011 isn't Nichijou or Ano Hana.
>>133576275
Stop liking mediocre sports and mediocre dramas so much, holy shit.
>>133576351
Anohana is definitely the runner up to S;G. 2011 was amazing all around.
>>133576355
But they aren't mediocre, they're full of passion.
>2011
>not Madoka
Heathens, all of you!
>>133575562
No, it's pretentious. This is accurate, official and objective. It even says so in the filename.
>>133576488
They're the type of things middle-aged men would have their kids watch to encourage good values. I really don't understand how you can parade your million favorites lists around so much and act like a critic in all the rating threads with taste that pedestrian.
>>133576275
Such shit taste, I can't believe it.
>not a single person ITT mentioning H&C as even a runner-up for either 2005 or 2006
>>133576275
>The man with no taste.png
Haibane
Planetes
Kino no Tabi
GITS: SAC 2nd Gig
Mushishi
ARIA
Nichijou
Madoka
Hyouka
Non Non Biyori
These are the anime in every image in this thread. I guess this is "/a/-core."
>>133576856
Stop trying to make /a/-core a thing.
>>133576571
Can some explain this Non Non Biyori meme? Was the show actually any good?
>>133576922
It is the best SoL anime since ARIA, but you will only enjoy it if you enjoy iyashikei.
>>133576917
It's always been a thing, how new are you?
02: Haibane Renmei
03: Tex
04: Diebuster
05: Mushishi (honorable mention: Kamichu!)
06: xxxHolic
07: Lucky Star
08: Natsume Yuujinchou
09: K-On!
10: Tamayura
11: Usagi Drop
12: Jinrui wa Suitai Shimashita
13: Tamako Market (honorable mention: NNB)
14: Barakamon (honorable mention: Ping Pong)
15: Ore Monogatari
Avoided sequels. I really need to watch more pre-2007 anime.
>>133576046
The show is average though
The 1995 movie is the only really great thing to come out of the franchise
>>133576994
No, it's some shit that people intent on codifying "/a/'s tastes" have been trying to push for ages. Fuck off.
>>133575562
2011 should be Nichijou
>>133576922
Non Non Biyori? More like Non Non It Bores Me!
>>133575562
After skimming through it I'll have to drop an absolute "no", and I would suggest you leave here and register an account on MyAnimeList, preferably staying there.
>>133575982
yes it is
>always the exact same shit of either:
>pseudo intellectual shit that is "objectively" good and has absolutely no personality/variance meaning you're just sucking /a/'s dick to try to look impressive
>or moe shit being (hopefully) ironic
>>133576922
https://desustorage.org/a/thread/133448265/#q133456789 explained it pretty well recently.
tl;dr: It's essentially a perfectly executed SoL. It's pretty clear that SoL isn't for everyone on /a/ but for those who dig it shows like NNB don't come around often.
why do people like Yamato reboot more than the original
>>133576571
Pretty good up until 2013 desu (to be honest)
>>133576680
I come and say this almost every thread.
I literally don't understand how it's possible when people praise utter shit like shigatsu
>>133577168
>not just linking to the post itself and letting 4chanx do the rest
>>>133456789
Quick guide on how to recognize the original AOTY chart with laurel crown designs:
Is Hyouge Mono AOTY 2011?
Yes: Then it's the original.
No: It's someone else's version using the same design.
Stop being lazy and make up your own designs if you want to make a rec chart.
>>133577376
I'm the OP of this thread and I got banned for shitposting.
I guess talking bad about Non Non Shityori is against the rules here.
>>133576186
s1 is better
>>133575562
>ping pong
This anime is nothing but forgettable
>>133577651
You pick that out for being forgettable and not Planetes or Baccano, really?
>>133577584
>make post with NNB as AOTY
>get banned
>I guess they didn't like me talking about NNB
I don't even get what you're trying to shitpost about here.
>>133576571
You again, obnoxious autistic neet? Do you really need to post this everyday?
>>133576488
You are mediocre. Your life is mediocre.
>>133577651
It's impossible to forget how terrible it looks.
>>133577584
>spammed "moeshit" and accusations that a show which had two fanservice moments (both in the same episode) in two entire seasons is "pedo-pandering"
>directly attacking the NNB fanbase by implying they're all pedophiles
Yep, that's shitposting. Based mods.
>>133577692
I don't think ping pong is forgettable, but how can you say that for Baccano.
>>133576294
>2012
>hyouka
Nah anon you list is shit.
>>133577938
Non-linearity is the only thing it really has going for it.
>>133575562
>cashew sins
Gross.
>>133578009
It literally has the most technically impressive visuals of any anime series, ever.
>b-but muh zzzzzzzzz
No.
>>133577787
I'm not the only one who posts it now. It's taken on a life of it's own; nothing I can do about it now.
2002: GITS: SAC
2003: Fullmetal Alchemist
2004: Monster
2005: Mushishi
2006: Death Note
2007: Baccano!
2008: One Outs
2009: Bakemonogatari
2010: Bakuman
2011: Hunter x Hunter (2011)
2012: JoJo's Bizarre Adventure
2013: Kill La Kill
2014: JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders
thoughts?
>>133576275
>2002
>Not a very good year
>The year of Azumanga Daioh, Haibane Renmei, Abenobashi and Princess Tutu
>One of the greatest anime years ever
Better see a doctor soon, Anon. That bad taste of yours is getting critical.
>>133578234
>the most technically impressive visuals of any anime series
Not enough to compensate for everything wrong with the show as a whole.
>>133578359
>JoJo
No.
>>133578359
>JoJo
>KLK
>>133578359
>jojo
Kill yourself.
>>133575562
>anime tryhard garbage: the list
>>133578453
Better than the regular moeshit you watch.
Fuck no. In fact, half of that is trash.
2002 was .hack//SIGN, no contest, with honorable mentions out to Full Metal Panic and King of Bandits Jing.
Planetes anime was boring shit, go read the manga. 2003 was clearly Gungrave, with honorable mentions to Fullmetal Alchemist and Scrapped Princess.
I could keep going but that would take too long. OP pic is mostly troll picks.
Why does noone mention Samurai Champloo?
>>133578668
Because it was good but not something I would put up as AOTY
2000: Boogiepop Phantom
2001: Hare+Guu (bad year)
2002: Haibane Renmei (superb year)
2003: Texhnolyze
2004: Paranoia Agent
2005: Mushishi
2006: Haruhi (mediocre year)
2007: Dennou Coil
2008: Aria the Origination (great year)
2009: Eve no Jikan
2010: Tatami Galaxy (good year)
2011: Mawaru Penguindrum (great year)
2012: Hyouka
2013: Non Non Biyori (bad year)
2014: Ping Pong
2015: Yuri Kuma
>>133578921
zzzz
>>133578921
>Tatami Galaxy
>Ping Pong
2000: Boogiepop Phantom
2001: Hare+Guu
2002: Haibane Renmei
2003: Texhnolyze
2004: Paranoia Agent
2005: Mushishi
2006: Haruhi
2007: Dennou Coil
2008: Aria the Origination
2009: Eve no Jikan
2010: Oreimo
2011: Mawaru Penguindrum
2012: Hyouka
2013: Oreimo S2
2014: Ping Pong
2015: Yuri Kuma
>>133578234
>It literally has the most technically impressive visuals of any anime series, ever.
And other than that it was nothing.
>>133575562
Garo was AOTY 2014 and Ping Pong is overrated shit only liked by crossboarders.
>/a/ finally admits that tatami galaxy is good
I thought everyone considered it pretentious hipster shit huh.
>>133579042
>2010: Oreimo
>2013: Oreimo S2
Did you think I wouldn't notice?
>>133579130
>I thought everyone considered it pretentious hipster shit huh.
It is. It could be worse, though: it could look like Parkinson's patients off their meds drew it with their feet, like Ping Pong.
>>133579136
>>133579137
He's right though, Oreimo was anime of the year those years.
>People actually like Paranoia Agent
>>133579130
It is pretentious hipster shit, but it's a good kind of pretentious hipster shit. Like Haruki Murakami novels.
Best chart
>>133575562
This looks like "AOTY: 4chan Contrarian Edition"
>>133575562
>2014
>Not Zankyou no Terror
>>133579269
>Tatami Galaxy
You were SO close to having a good chart there.
>All these chart that start at 2000
Watch more anime
>>133579345
>either 480p content or film grain
>good
>>133579269
Best one so far.
>>133578359
Shit taste
Kill La Yourself
>>133579032
How are C and tsuritama pretentious?
Yuasa's just all about the vivid colors.
>>133579802
What
Tsuritama isn't Yuasa
>>133579432
>being an ignorant moron
Whats with the hate on ping pong's artstyle. I mean sure the characters look ugly as fuck, but they looks more asian than 90% of what anime has to offer.
>>133579802
delusonal yuasafags everyone
>>133579897
>>133579802
Disregard that I confused yuasa with kenji nakamura.
>>133579032
>>133579984
>Yuasa underraters
>>133579032
>>133579984
This meme needs to stop
>>133579977
>Whats with the hate on ping pong's artstyle
>the characters look ugly as fuck
There you go. The ugly visuals feel like an insult to the viewer on the level of Lou Reed's Metal Machine Music.
>>133578359
>GITS
>FMA
>Monster
>DN
>Baccano
>Bakuman
>HxH
>JoJo
>KLK
Hello, my sixteen-year-old friend.
>>133579042
>Penguindumb
>Yuri Kuma
Get some taste my friend.
>>133580214
>Bear telling anyone to get some taste
>>133580214
>shitting on him for Penguins and Kumas
>not incest garbage
really bear?
>>133576603
Bear is middle aged, please do not bully.
>>133580252
But PD is incest garbage.
>>133580262
I'm pretty sure he's eighteen.
>>133580252
Oreimo isn't bad, but I agree it's nowhere near AOTY level. To be fair to S2 though, 2013 is a fucking shit year all around.
>>133580262
You know it babe
>>133579269
>Runner up: Aku no Hana
Your taste is pretty good when this is the only thing I can find to greentext.
>>133575562
Don't tell me people actually thought Ping Pong was good.
>>133580473
>Mom, look how contrarian I am
here is your (You) by the way.
>>133580473
I agree. It's far better than good. It's fantastic.
>>133580557
Nope.
>>133580311
I thought hes been here for 4 years or something though
>>133580473
Not really, but is way better than any moeshit pandering to otakus released in 2014 and we had tons of these.
>>133580473
I'm unsure how many pro-Ping Pong posts are legitimate and how many are the same guy who spammed Ping Pong = AOTY threads on a daily basis for months on end last year. That being said, its story is pedestrian, so I'm convinced what popularity it does have here is largely due to its ugly artstyle and associated anti-moe contrarianism.
>>133580473
It's a 9/10 mate.
>>133580597
>>13358031119 and been on 4chan for almost 6.
>>133580702
>so I'm convinced what popularity it does have here is largely due to its ugly artstyle and associated anti-moe contrarianism.
>>133580682
>>133580597
I started browsing when I was seventeen, and that was only because I was too much of a normalfag to go on the "evil child porn site" before that. There are plenty of underage around.
>>133580624
I apologize, however it is not within my ability to push a nonexistent object inside my anus.
On the other hand, my anus can release better looking content than Ping Pong on a daily basis.
>>133580682
>Not being able to appreciate moe
I'm sorry to say this anon but you're worse than him.
>>133580702
I'm unsure how many anti-Ping Pong posts are legitimate and how many are the same guy who spammed Ping Pong = SHIT threads on a daily basis for months on end last year. That being said, its story is masterful, so I'm convinced what hate it does have here is largely due to its unconventional artstyle and associated contrarianism.
>>133580792
>That being said, its story is masterful, so I'm convinced what hate it does have here is largely due to its unconventional artstyle and associated contrarianism.
>>133580834
>Nisekoi
>>133580792
>spammed Ping Pong = SHIT threads on a daily basis for months on end last year.
I legitimately and honestly don't recall this ever happening.
>its story is masterful
It's just a long string of shonen cliches.
>>133580702
>story is pedestrian
I agree, fellow anime connoisseur. At times it was unclear who the MC was, let alone when his harem was going to be introduced for me to make my mind up on who is 'best girl'.
I had to drop it after 3 episodes when the story got too involved, but before that I had been supplementing the show with clips of Umaru to prevent my moe withdrawl symptoms (clinical mental issues) from kicking in.
>>133580792
>I'm convinced what hate it does have here is largely due to its unconventional artstyle
No sher, Shitlock. When you have something belonging to a primarily visual medium that looks more like a Richter scale reading than animation that's going to turn off a lot of people.
>>133580917
There were a lot of PP threads being spammed, both the Ping Pong = SHIT and the Ping Pong = AOTY threads were annoyinga s hell.
I'd say the characters of PP are what really carry it, every character is lovable and entertaining to watch.
>>133580914
It's a terrible series but it really does have the best reaction faces, especially Shitoge.
>>133580948
>everyone who doesn't like what I like belongs to whatever fanbase I want to attack right now
Didn't you get banned for this shit yesterday?
>>133580914
I understand that you don't have an argument that supports Ping Pong other than it being hipster garbage, but you don't need to publicly grasp at straws and embarrass yourself.
![12191396_1676350795935767_537282385245432207_n[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/m74yWuN.png "12191396 1676350795935767 537282385245432207 n[1]")
>>133581089
>anyone here has an argument against ping pong
>everyone isn't just making vague statements and generalizations
>>133581130
I don't get the >weeks 2/3/4 stuff
>>133575562
Almost had me, didn't realize I was being trolled until I read the runner ups.Also ping pong
>>133581008
>I'd say the characters of PP are what really carry it
They're just stereotypes. It's just formulaic garbage with a lolartsy style.
>>133581209
How long it's been on the charge probably.
>>133581136
And now you revert to memetexting, a real /v/ermin.
>>133575562
Assuming this is real and Uchouten Kazuko managed to outrank WA2 in 2013 (my favorite romance), was it really THAT good?
>>133575943
pic related
>>133575562
Honestly the most broken thing about this list is that White Album 2 got an honorable mention. That really undermines credibility.
Also you may as well put Shirobako in for 2015 now. Nothing's gonna surpass it.
>>133577168
>referring to SoL as if it were a genre
This is the problem with plebs.
>>133581472
Shirobako is 2014. Non Non Biyori is 2015.
>>133581310
nice vague statements anon, the anime delved deep into each individual character. You not being able to appreciate such a simple story is truly a testament of you shit taste. If you think Ping Pong is a hipster show you are truly jaded, it's pretty popular and won many awards. Hating Ping Pong is the true contrarian position, the only people who dislike it are bitter hipsters.
>>133581408
>Reverting to go back to /v/ memes
Even worse, I only browse /a/and sometimes /mu/, if you don't like greentext go back to MAL they love hipsters and contrarians like Roriconfag there.
>>133581528
>semantics argument
One of the most insidious, pointless forms of shitposting/thread derailment.
>Assuming this is real
Ahahahaha how new are you?
>>133581581
>Assuming this is real
>Ahahahaha how new are you?
Meant for >>133581469
>>133581548
>it's pretty popular and won many awards.
So did Naruto.
>>133580722
Is it too late to underage b&?
>>133581700
Do you consider people who like Naruto to be hipsters?
>>133581548
How well did Ping Pong sell, anon?
How well did the actual AOTY, Shirobako, sell, anon?
>>133581700
Read the posts you're responding to, faggot.
>>133581934
>>133581934
>How well did the actual AOTY, Shirobako, sell, anon?
A lot worse than the real actual AOTY, Love Live S2, you hipster.
>>133581934
>Thinking sales matter
Shirobako is pretty good though I'll give you that much.
>>133581581
>semantics argument
The problem with your accusation is that you assume I'm trying to engage in an argument. My post is actually why I'm NOT going to engage in an argument. The poster is not worth engaging in an actual argument, because they clearly have no understanding of what they're talking about. They don't deserve an argument, all they deserve is a shitpost, so that's what they got.
>>133577010
You have good taste, Senpai.
>>133582043
Can you honestly call idolshit anime, anon?
>>133582138
He was obviously making a point about sales not mattering.
>>133581934
memebako was a lukewarm succcess at best compared to PA Works magnum opus Angel Beats.
>>133582050
>pretty good
It's pretty damn close to perfectly executed.
>OP makes thread
>Waits for a few genuine replies
>Starts to post >le epic greentext implying /v/ meme hope u dont do this< for random good anime off the list
>Hopefully hooks a fanbase (usually yuasa)
>Does this because he knows people that like good anime have integrity, and people with integrity will sincerely defend the things they like
>Endless supply of funposting to fill the large gaps in his NEET life
When will /a/ stop falling for it, guys?
>>133582312
I had no complaints with any element of shirobako.
>>133582414
I have no complaints with any element of Kanna.
>>133575562
>2009
>Kemono no Souja Erin honorable mention
I like you anon, or whoever the one made this
Also, these charts tend to be so opinionated, but its definitely a better distribution than a 3x3 thread
>>133582492
This is now a Kanna thread.
>>133582525
I'd let her build me a house any day if you know what I mean.
>>133582516
Erin is amazing. It's a shame not more people know about it honestly.
>>133575943
>I disagree with GITS, Baccano
Nigga what? You have shit taste is the problem
>>133579269
>monogatari
I'll never ever understand.
>>133582584
I whole-heartedly agree, the parts toward the ending felt like poetry
Not to mention how comfy and how much it pulled heart strings. I wasn't prepared for it going into it
2002 - Azumanga
2003 - Kino
2004 - I can't remember anything that aired in 2004
2005 - Mushishi
2006 - Welcome to the NHK
2007 - Manabi Straight
2008 - Casshern Sins
2009 - K-On!
2010 - Tatami Galaxy
2011 - Hanasaku
2012 - Hyouka
2013 - nothing, shit year
2014 - Shirobako
2015 - Eupho
>>133582584
>>133582825
Erin is close to perfect, one of the best works in the medium. Both of you should try Anne if you haven't already.
>>133575982
overrated shit
![[HorribleSubs] Mobile Suit Gundam - Iron-Blooded Orphans - 02 [720p].mkv_snapshot_05.07_[2015.10.16_00.44.52].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/y4CsJfC.jpg "[HorribleSubs] Mobile Suit Gundam - Iron-Blooded Orphans - 02 [720p].mkv snapshot 05.07 [2015.10.16 00.44.52]")
>>133582890
>2010 - Tatami Galaxy
>2012 - Hyouka
>2014 - Shirobako
>2015 - Eupho
>>133582899
>Anne
Ill give it a shot, what am I in for?
planetes is my all time favourite anime, tanabe is my ideal anime girl
>>133583074
nice
Is Arya really that good?
I've always avoided it because it was moeshit and those 20 minutes of araaras in Youtube made it look bad.
>>133576922
I only watched S1, but I like how they depicted kids in a mostly aging countryside in Japan, with full of empty landscape and buildings, and how they still have a brimming cheerfulness in an otherwise decaying society. Of course it's not 'deep' or anything, in the sense of overly-preachy and such.
>>133576571
2013 is Kill La Kill.
>>133575562
>hyougo
into the trash
>>133577148
What else is there?
>>133576922
It's a rock-solid slice of life. It's not the hot shit coming of Christ like some anons make it out to be, but if you're into the genre at all then you'll enjoy it. Probably won't change your mind otherwise, though. Very funny, great music, and nice characters and visuals.
>>133583115
Go watch it and form your own opinions.
>>133583251
Kill la Kill was fun because of the hype it caused there where definitely better shows in 2013
>>133583293
say it again and ur ded m8
>>133576922
/a/utist fanbase used proxies to win some AOTY polls and tried to force those shit opinions until it became meme.
So glad the second season bombed and non non it bores me will never be animated again.
>>133583433
Like what?
>>133583433
>caused there where definitely better shows in 2013
Nope, and this is from someone who considers KLK average.
>>133583061
>what am I in for?
A cute orphan girl growing up, it's a lot like Erin but set in Canada instead of a fantasy world. The first half is extremely cozy and the 2ndwill make you cryin a good way.
>>133583508
Uchouten Kazoku or Kyousougiga maybe? Tamako Market and Non Non Biyori were also really good.
I tried watching Aria, but i stopped midway throguh Season 2, nothing happens and it's really slow paced, I don't see why it is even named anime of the year.
>>133583578
>Uchouten Kazoku
Oh fuck. You're right.
>>133577148
Do you want a hot blooded manime version?
>>133582629
Me neither, friend.
It's your typical haremshit with disgusting SHAFT powerpoint animation and "witty" wordplay.
>>133582629
>>133583870
Add me to this list.
>>133583870
It has some legitimately fantastic moments (pic) at times, but holy shit is it ever a slog to find them. The writing is embarrassingly bad and goes on and on for the sake of going on and on.
>>133575562
No: kino no tabi is a fuckload better than planetes, mushishi is a fuckload better than aria the animation, casshern sins deserves a mention in the worst anime of the year list, SBY is not an original airing, nnb is garbage, mushishi zoku shou is ridiculously better than ping pong the animation and yuyuyu belongs in the trash.
From the list alone, didn't bother to check which other anime aired on each year. Pretty sure 2014 is wrong as fuck, 2009 has better and 2002 and 2005 might be missing titles.
>>133583015
What are your bad-taste alternatives then, bucko?
>>133583687
>>133583870
>>133583993
>>133584124
samefag contrarian, enjoy your (You)
>>133584292
Do you actually like the series' writing, then?
You don't find that it drags to the point of being legitimately irritating?
You don't get tired of the film 101 cinematography?
>>133575562
>Fate/Zero
>Hunter x Hunter
>Madoka
Come to think of it, 2011 was an exceedingly good year. Why Nichijou as a runner up of all things?
>IMDB: 8.4
Well, I guess it's not THAT weird of an opinion.
>>133584292
Don't lump me in with a Non Non hater you faggot.
2000: Hajime no Ippo (Shoubushi Densetsu Tetsuya is a close second though)
2001: Salaryman Kintaro
2002: Twelve Kingdoms (Azumanga Daioh is close)
2003: Sakigake!! Cromartie Koukou (Planetes is close)
2004: Midori Days
2005: Akagi
2006: Black Lagoon (Nana was great also)
2007: Kaiji
2008: One Outs
2009: Aoi Bungaku
2010: Rainbow
2011: Usagi Drop
2012: JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (Nichibros is second.)
2013: Hataraku Maou-Sama! (A pretty boring year.)
2014: Paratsyte / Kiseijuu
>>133584636
Of all the fucking shows in 2014 you pick Parasyte?
>>133577010
>Diebuster
>2004
HA it's the only OVA you mention the only good episode didn't even air that year
>I really need to watch more pre-2007 anime.
Please do
>>133584636
Damn that's some great taste. It's nice to see you include Tetsuya as a runner up
>>133584636
>parashit
And the shit taste award goes to...YOU
>>133584636
>Parasyte / Kiseijuu
>>133575562
>>133576294
>>133579269
>tfw variations of your AOTY shitposting chart are still being posted on /a/ half a decade later
Wish I could make a meme this popular again someday.
>>133584813
>Tatami Galaxy
>>>/trash/
>>133584732
>>133584772
You guys love calling out Parasyte because crossboarders loved it, but some of that other stuff's just as questionable. Midori Days for 2004, really?
>>133575562
2014 should be Shirobako instead of ping pong, those it's by a close margin. The rest of that is pretty spot on. I can forgive the Yuasa faggotry because it deserved aots for most opf those years
>>133575562
no, too much hipstershit not enough moeshit
>>133584862
The thing is, those all really are AOTY to anyone with taste, which I guess is why it became such good shitposting fuel.
>>133584862
nobody unironically dislikes tatami galaxy, stop with the memes
>>133584691
Well I haven't caught up with 2014 too much.
Only saw Sakura Trick, One Week Friends, Persona 4 The Golden Animation, & Parasyte.
So yeah Parasyte was a pretty good adaptation in my honest opinion.
>>133584713
Gee thanks.
>>133584732
>>133584772
Those are some hot opinions there, care to elaborate?
>>133575562
>ping pong
>good
found the yuasafag.
fucking this is a completely shit meme and you lot need to get mass exterminated.
>>133584292
Don't lump me in with a Non Non lover you faggot.
>>133584915
This is correct if we're talking about an accurate representation of /a/'s taste as a whole.
>>133584940
>not liking ping pong
I'll never understand.
Look at all these people trying to force their opinions. Is it good to force your opinion?
>>133584993
>being a fucko
>>133582398
>implying that falling for it isn't how I fill the large gaps in my NEET life
>>133584986
I guess these threads just attract the crossboarding bronies who are into uchouten kazoku or something
>Most of /a/ has seen anime older than 2007-08ish
>00-2006 is almost always crap choices
>>133585041
These statements are actually contradictions. Welcome to neo-/a/ though.
>>133584915
I unironically agree.
>>133585027
What's a "fucko"?
>>133584989
because liking yuasa is a meme, his shit actually does stink and then poes law fell into effect on /a/
>>133585112
look in the mirror, fucko
>>133580473
Easily the best thing of 2014 by far. HOly shit.
>>133584940
>he's never seen ping pong
Literally this is all I hear when people shit talk Ping Pong
>>133585175
It was my favourite, but there's no undermining how good Mushishi, Shirobako, and Space Dandy are. 2014 was sweet.
>>133585172
A human?
>>133585127
Tell me your favorite anime, anon.
>>133585221
and you are quite literally a bandwagonning meme bot riding on overrated shit.
>>133585262
don't get smart with me, fucko
>>133585286
That post literally made me laugh out loud. Holy shit anon, that should be pasta.
>>133585286
Do you enjoy things?
>>133585435
fuck things
>>133585036
Low powerlevel newfags tend to gravitate towards psuedo-intellectual faire until they realize how pretentious it is and that other media do literally everything but cute girls doing cute things better than anime.
>>133585673
Just cause cute girls doing cute things is anime's most stand-out narrative difference, it hardly means that anime intrinsically does it better. Or anything else intrinsically worse, for that matter.
Hell, if you're trying to make a case for anime being better than other mediums in any aspect, it should be visuals (it's animated for christ's sake).
Not that you're wrong about the pretense of newfags though, you're spot on there.
>>133576275
>Diamond no Ace
My nigger
>>133586167
Boring show, dropped it at 11 episodes.
>>133585673
No, people go to cute girls when they give up. When their brain shuts down and they just want thought free amusement.
>>133575562
No, the chart represents the opinion of the individual who created it and nothing more. The only thing /a/ has ever agreed on is that Japan has shit taste.
>>133586356
There are plenty of moe series that are more than mindless amusement.
>>133586380
Is there anyone on /a/ that hates yotsuba?
>>133586416
Like?
>>133586416
This. If I want mindless amusement I'll watch GochiUsa. If I want something that has something profound to say about life I'll watch Non Non Biyori or ARIA.
>>133586416
Name one. You can't though.
>>133586506
K-ON!!
>>133586506
Haruhi, Hyouka.
>>133586506
>>133586547
I'm not going to give out recommendations when I know you chuckleheads are just going to greentext at me. All I'm saying is that it's wrong to dismiss something as mindless just because it's cute. You should get a feel for what's out there yourselves, and find something that speaks to you.
>>133586561
>literal brainless amusement: the show is more than mindless amusement
>>133586635
Hyouka isn't cute girls doing cute things. Haruhi arguably qualifies though.
>>133586249
I like it a lot, especially during the nationals game with Yakushi. But It's annoying that they've kinda made the MC into a comic relief character.
>>133576573
>2015
This guy knows.
>>133576573
>>133587035
Your taste has greatly degenerated if it really is Umaru
>>133587455
Umaru wasn't even AOTS but it did have GOTY.
>>133575562
>Ping Pong
I genuinely thought Ping Pong fags were joking with all the AOTY talk at one point
>>133587738
It was legitimately a forced meme for trolling purposes.
>>133576275
>2008
>Best year
>picked Clannad ASayylmao
>>133580214
Get a load of this shit taste faggot
>>133587525
Tachibana can die in a hole for all I care, Ebina was the REAL best gurl. I mean just look at her big ass fucking tits. Tachibana was just a stuck up retarded ass rich girl who had a superiority complex.
>>133586711
Man everybody in this whole thread of conversation is wrong. First of all moe and CGDCT are two different things. Also if you're going to bastardize "moe" to the point of defining a show as a "moe series" then putting either Hyouka or Haruhi on that list is nonsensical. Both just have some arguably moe characters.
I'm just gonna stop there.
![snapshot_21.49_[2015.07.29_01.18.55].png](https://i.imgur.com/R9Huthk.jpg "snapshot 21.49 [2015.07.29 01.18.55]")
>>133575562
>1443560827325.png
>>133587823
Why is Clannad bad?
So can someone explain Hyouge Mono? Its the only one in this thread im surprised i don't know of / haven't heard much about. What makes it good?
>>133588463
I think what >>133586711 was trying to say was that there was more to Hyouka than the air-headed moe female lead. Where as Haruhi was a fucking mess of a story with two of the three main female characters being overly moe.
>>133588576
Aesthetics.
This is literally the biggest meme thread I have ever seen
>2014
>ping pong
nice joke it's fucking shit
>>133577067
The entire first series was an irrefutable masterpiece with side stories building up to a major overarching plot with an intense culmination and very satisfying conclusion.
I'm gonna need you to return your monocle now.
>>133578567
I'm going to make a .hack//SIGN thread one of these days, as soon as I ingest enough stimulants to be able to watch the entire series.
How come people always seem to forget Ergo Proxy?
>>133580792
moe fags are worst fags, literally killing anime.
>>133589067
Because everyone hates it for being pretentious. I've only seen one episode three years ago, so I don't know if they're right.
I think Katanagatari > Tatami but that's just me bro.
>>133588628
I certainly understand what he was trying to say, and I agree about Hyouka. But I definitely disagree with both of you about Haruhi. When you say that two of the three characters are "overly moe" then I'm not sure which ones you mean.
So what is moe? Moe is a state of having romantic feelings for a fictional character. That's all moe meant when it first became a thing. But then once producers started trying to cash in on this by creating characters specifically in order to elicit these feelings, people started using the term "moe character." So saying a character is a "moe character" is saying something about the intent of the author.
Now I would argue that none of the main girls in Haruhi are moe characters. All three of them are parodies of different moe archetypes pushed to such an extreme as to only be off-putting or annoying. Mikuru is so moe it doesn't even ring true, Haruhi is tsundere without the dere, and Nagato is a Rei clone without the hints of underlying humanity. They're archetypes pushed into an extreme their logical extremes to the point where they don't work anymore as moe. And I think this hints at the "overly moe" you were describing.
And what I would call the genius of the series is that these characters still all end up expressing heartfelt feelings for MC but in non-traditional ways and without ever betraying the extreme natures of their characters as described above. Haruhi never becomes dere but it's made clear how much she cares about Kyon through her actions. Even when she wakes up in the hospital room at the end of Disappearance her expression goes from annoyed directly to pissed off. Mikuru never stops being superficially moe, but eventually takes on an air of motherly tenderness with Kyon. And Nagato literally alters reality in the hope that an alternate version of herself can express her feelings.
This is why Someday in The Rain is such a great episode. Because it perfectly lays out the nature of these three characters.
>>133589430
>Moe is a state of having romantic feelings for a fictional character.
I'd say it's more like, a character's traits elicit a very strong positive response, not necessarily, but often romantic.
>>133589504
>a character's traits elicit a very strong positive response
This is way too ambiguous though. I mean, is Han Solo moe? His character traits elicit a very strong positive response. And it's also just not how moe was ever defined. The important thing about moe is that you feel romantically drawn to a fictional character in the same way that you would a real person. That's what defines it, that crossing of the boundary between fiction and reality.
>>133575562
No, Dennou Coil blows Baccano! out of the water.
>>133589430
OK, I see what you're saying but just because a character archetype is satirically pushed to it's logical extreme doesn't mean that it suddenly stops being the thing getting satirized in the first place.
>>133575562
Kemonozume was nice and all, but was there really nothing better that aired that year?
>>133589430
Also, what is moe about a tsundere without the dere? You're just left with someone who may like a character but never lets on and just continues to treat them badly.
>>133575562
TTGL not being on there as even an honourable mention is just straight up bullshit.
>>133589665
>This is way too ambiguous though.
I think it's supposed to be.
>I mean, is Han Solo moe?
He can be. Moe is subjective and personal.
>>133589773
Watch better anime
>It's not Evangelion every year all years.
>>133575562
meme anime list
>>133589773
TTGL was shit.
>>133589873
>he fell for the gurren lagann is bad meme
>>133589873
>>133589965
>probably new to this board and wasn't here when it aired
Sure things guys. Ping Pong GOAT anime amirite?
>>133589695
And I agree with that. Honestly I think that was one of the failings of the series. It starts off with these characters being really obvious parodies, but the parody never really goes anywhere. And at the end of the day all three of them are still just possible romantic interests. The biggest failing is certainly with Mikuru. The line between parody and moe just kinda gets more and more blurred.
>>133589769
That's my whole point. I'm arguing that Haruhi isn't actually moe because she has no dere.
>>133589774
The important point is the distinction between the feeling of "moe" and a "moe character." Everything that you're saying is true for the feeling called "moe." It's just a feeling, and so is completely subjective. But the idea of a "moe character" is more about the intent of the author (otherwise the concept of a "moe character" has no value). It's about whether or not a character was intentionally designed to elicit moe feelings from its audience. So if you're trying to analyze a character and decide whether it's a moe character it's a process of looking at the japanese young adult fiction landscape and deciding if the author has utilized elements that will engender moe feelings. The most obvious way of doing this is figuring out if characters fit into standard moe archetypes, but it can sometimes be more complicated than that.
Can we stop pretending that aria is good just because its boring shit barely anyone actually watched
>>133589999
Lucky Star was better.
>>133589773
2007 was great, anon. I'd have to check a chart, but I doubt TTGL even makes AOTS.
>>133590033
>It's about whether or not a character was intentionally designed to elicit moe feelings from its audience.
I'm not sure I can agree with this. Technically, any female character with an attractive or cute character design is automatically a moe character by this definition, so this would mean that almost all female anime characters are moe characters.
>>133590033
Well in my original post (I post in /pol/ I'm used to ID's I'm >>133588628 btw ) I did say that 2/3 of the female leads were moe. Well, anyway, it looks like we agree after all.
God damn, 2010 was a good year
Why is nobody mentioning Serial Experiments Lain?
This thread is shit.
>>133590522
2/8
I miss Hyouge Mono threads, wish we had more shows like it.
>>133590176
Well, there's certainly a lot of truth in this. At this point moe has permeated the mainstream of anime to such a degree that it has strongly influenced sort of the default style of female character design. There are lots of characters in recent years would can very clearly and easily be classified as "moe characters," but there are plenty of others which could be said to have been designed with moe influences and moe elements while not being totally about engendering moe.
But what it comes down to is that trying to make a character attractive and trying to make a character have moe appeal are two different but related things. So let's look at two examples. We'll look at main girl from Madoka Magica and main girl from Tatami Galaxy. Just two fairly arbitrary examples. Main girl is obviously moe, she has all the obvious moe traits. She's in the correct age range to be entering puberty and thus at least finding out about sexual maturity, she's naive, she's designed so the audience wants to protect her from the evils of this world. She's not rendered super attractively though. She's cute, but it's mostly because they put her in cute dresses all the time.
Then there's Tatami Galaxy chick. I would say her design is more attractive. That's subjective though of course. But I'd also say that she's a less "moe character" in almost every way, including her design. Why? Because Madoka fits more into the japanese idea of what engenders moe. She has the giant disney eyes and the unassuming face. She designed to not be intimidating (a huge factor in moe design) and super inviting. She's short and she wears cute little outfits, even different outfits pretty regularly like a paper doll. Tatami main girl is designed much more realistically, and she's specifically supposed to be intimidating. She's portrayed as starkly superior to MC in just about every way, but without being a *dere. She's drawn as really attractive, but not ostentatiously so.
>>133591014
>But what it comes down to is that trying to make a character attractive and trying to make a character have moe appeal are two different but related things.
They're not, though, according to your definitions:
>Moe is a state of having romantic feelings for a fictional character
>It's about whether or not a character was intentionally designed to elicit moe feelings from its audience.
Let's be real here. Some viewer somewhere is going to have romantic feelings for any female with an attractive or cute character design. The character designers know this. Thus, any attractive or cute character design is intentionally designed to elicit moe feelings from the viewer by your definitions.
>>133591014
So the point here is that it's apparent that Madoka was designed and written more with moe in mind. She's not a super moe character, but if I had to wager whether her creators were thinking about what the japanese otaku crowd would like then I'd definitely have to say it was a factor. I could go further into why, but I hope it's pretty apparent.
So was it a factor in Tatami chick's design? It's certainly possible. But the "moe" feeling is a pretty specific thing, and if you wanted to engender moe then you would have made many choices differently with her design. Like you could say that Madoka is something like 75% moe while Tatami chick is like at most 15% moe. It's obvious that her character is supposed to be appealing, and attractive, especially to certain audiences, but that is not the same thing as saying her character is supposed to make people feel moe.
Now of course looking back on it the reason I chose that Tatami Galaxy chick is because it's so hard to find an example of a female character design that is not very moe, and it's easiest to make the point I'm trying to make about the elements of a character's design.
>>133590839
The manga just started getting translated again so hopefully we'll be able to get the full story.Not that it'll be the same without Rikyu
>>133591256
We are finally getting past chapter 6? Never thought I'd see the day.
>>133591309
The guy translating it hasn't done any past projects and he's starting from the very beginning so don't get your hopes up. If he's dedicated it's gonna take a long time to catch up.
>2009
>not K-On!
>2010
>not K-On!!
>>133591170
There's a gap in your reasoning here. You're saying the following:
1. No matter the character, somebody somewhere is going to have romantic feelings for that character as long as they're somewhat attractive
2. The character designers know this
3. Therefore, any attractive character design is INTENDED to elicit moe feelings
The first two points are true, but the third point is an oversimplification. We can't know the intent of a character designer unless their intent is apparent on screen.
Imagine a hypothetical scenario where some character designer has never heard of moe before. Say it's some guy from the west or something and he doesn't even speak japanese. Or he's like Sudanese or something, doesn't matter. If he's hired to design a female character, then there are still pretty good odds that he will design that character to be attractive, right? But regardless, that is not a moe character. Because the intent wasn't there. Now, there's an even more remote possibility that this designer will design a character who has all of the stereotypical moe design elements, a totally classic moe character design. Small and round, big cartoony face, shiny and shit, all that garbage. If that were to happen I would be in this thread arguing up and down that that's a moe character design. I'd be wrong, but I'd be arguing it anyway because it's simply a statistical impossibility that this hypothetical would ever actually happen.
So the relevant fact is that the deciding factor of whether a character is a "moe character" design is whether the designer said to themselves "I want to hook the moe crowd." Usually it's really obvious whether or not this is the case, as you can safely assume that pretty much every character designer in the industry knows what moe is. Saying that a character is a "moe character" is only indirectly saying that the character is cute or vulnerable or naive or whatever.
cont.
>>133591724
>We can't know the intent of a character designer unless their intent is apparent on screen.
I would content an attractive or cute character design sends a clear message of intent unless the character designer is unrealistically naive.
>>133591724
>>133591785
What it's directly saying is that the character was intended to pander to an audience which is known to be susceptible to moe, and in the medium of japanese anime that audience is very well known and nailed down. It's very clear to say that some set of particular things are clear cut moe character traits (while others are more nebulous of course). Overwhelmingly, when somebody is designing a moe character for anime, they are targeting the otaku audience, and as such they know they want a certain set of traits. It's not just about making it attractive, it's about making it a certain kind of attractive. Some other market may like a different kind of attractive, but they're not the ones we're pandering to. They're not the big fish. We want the hardcore otakus who are all waifu buyfags, because they're a sure thing.
In theory you could target a moe character at another demographic, but in practice it just doesn't happen. A "moe character" is by definition pandering to a specific audience, and the only audience that anime ever bothers to pander to with "moe characters" is the otaku audience, so if a character isn't pandering to the otaku audience then you can safely assume it is not a "moe character," regardless of whether or not it is attractive.
>>133591933
>a "moe character" is a character that panders to the otaku audience
This is a shameful bastardization of the word "moe." This is a bad post and you should feel bad.
>>133591461
K-On is trash, if I wanted tea-and-cake time I would have vacationed in Britain.
>>133591461
my sentiments exactly
>>133592025
This, to be honest.
>>133592025
This opinion is objectively wrong.
>>133592009
>hey guys i only read the last post in this long-ass chain of posts
>>133592096
I read all of the posts and am able to read between the lines as well. Reading between the lines leads to the conclusion that the poster is attempting to devalue "moe" in an extremely smug, deceptive manner.
>>133592163
As the poster I'm gonna need you to expand on what you mean by "devalue moe."
>>133591461
Thom Yorke is almost as pretentious as Yuasa. Almost.
>>133592244
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbvYeLxMKN8
>>133592084
It is. I mean, he doesn't have to go to Britain for cake and tea time, amirite?
>>133575982
Yeah best anime I have ever seen
>>133592363
Good point. However, where do you think that cultural practice became popular?
>>133592282
>Insults creator for being pretentious
>Posts clip from a Tarantino film
Is automatically shitting on anything that is popular some kind of act everyone in /a/ just follows for fun or do you guys genuinely just happen to not like shows that are popular?
>>133592715
yes
>>133592715
It's almost assuredly a mix of both.
Why are people so crazy about SAC? Sure, I thought it was pretty damn good, but one of the best shows of all time? Probably not.
I felt it got pretty heavy handed at some times pushing the whole stand-alone complex, which definitely is an interesting idea that Kon and Anno included in their work with the whole "collective conscience" aspect. Maybe it just worked better for me on an emotional rather than a purely philosophical level.
The ending in season 1 was also a joke, that's Hollywood-tier cliff-hanger grasping. You can't show characters go offscreen and have gunshots just to show that they already had an agreement figured out. What the fuck where they shooting at then?
Also lol jesus imagery @ season 2 end, which was weaker than season 1 as a whole
>>133592715
>everyone in /a/
/a/ is not a hive mind. It's just the shitposters are more vocal.
>>133592715
The reality is actually more complicated. There's not really a general audience in the anime fanbase, unless you count western weabs, but they're totally insignificant. In most popular mainstream mediums (western television) you have a huge general audience consuming general appeal type shows. Anime fans by and large have niche tastes. Most of them fit into specific niches and consume anime which cater to those niches. Some people like giant robots, some people like ecchi, some people like absurd humor, etc. Anyway, due to this nature basically nothing ever gets close to being universally liked by the anime fanbase. One big problem is that people don't realize they're even in these niches. They just see a show that caters to another niche and they say it's shit. They say "oh non non biyori is boring trash," when they should realize that they're saying more about the particularities of their own taste rather than the show itself. Few people critique anime based on their general artistic merits, and most do so only on the basis of their own taste. This is why you'll always see plenty of people shitting all over stuff like Cowboy Bebop, one of the most universally liked shows in the West. Sure some of them are being contrarian, but plenty of others just have specific tastes.
>>133592988
>Kon and Anno included in their work with the whole "collective conscience" aspect
Opinion discarded.
>>133592715
You're going to have to name a specific show before I can tell you. I don't shit on anything I actually enjoy a lot, but if a bunch of people start calling something I think is average the best anime of all time, I'll be an aggressive faggot about how it's bad and they should feel bad for liking it.
>>133593423
This sums up the nature of all conversation on /a/.
>>133592988
>Why are people so crazy about SAC?
Because they watch police procedurals on murikan TV and wanted something like that out of anime.
>>133593169
>Anime fans by and large have niche tastes. Most of them fit into specific niches and consume anime which cater to those niches. Some people like giant robots, some people like ecchi, some people like absurd humor, etc.
What about, you know, Action. Generic ol' Action.
>>133592988
this
>>133593788
There really isn't a large generic action niche, unless you're really into battle shounen.
>>133594088
Then why do so many action series come out? You know, basically every anime /a/ looks down on and despises?
>>133594248
What, you mean Naruto and Bleach and other, as I said, battle shounen?
>>133593788
>>133594088
Yeah I mean that's why I said etc. hah. I was listing specific niches, and the more niche sounding they were the better they supported my point. But really it's a whole complex and interconnected web of genres and subgenres. If you were gonna map it out the top level nodes would be things like Comedy, Drama, Action, Iyashikei and probably an Other for all the weird shit like whatever that exercising show is. Then you'd have smaller nodes, probably more like themes such as Absurd Comedy, Ecchi Comedy, Light Comedy, Romance, Tragedy, Crime, Psychological, Mecha, Powers, Fighting, Slice of Life, Adventure, Exploration. Maybe some kind of color coding for showing that some stuff is most prominent in shounen / shoujo / seinen or whatever.
>>133577376
>>133456789
>how standard and dull Hidamari is
FINALLY. SOMEONE. SAID. IT.
>>133575562
>monster
>kemonozume
>time of fucking eve
>a few (admittedly good) entry level stuff like Ping Pong and Baccano! to fool casuals
I guarantee you're a cross-boarder from /jp/ you tremendous mongoloid, end your life
>>133588904
>The entire first series was an irrefutable masterpiece
>>133594300
No, I mean stuff like KLK, Guilty Crown, Noir, Ga Rei Zero, Chevalier D'Eon, basically anything that has action incidentally (although I guess KLK is far more action focused than the others here).
>>133594370
Don't be silly. /jp/ has forgotten about anime.
>>133594370
Is Monster really a /jp/ favorite? Seems very westernized
>>133594370
>>133594398
>one sale man
>>133594370
>Ping Pong and Baccano!
>entry level
I don't go on facebook and see people talking about them, how are they entry level?
At what point does Uchouten Kazoku stop being boring?
>>133575562
I didn't really like ping pong and could never understand why people liked it.
Maybe someone can tell the appeal to it ?
>>133594498
Good joke did you come up with it yourself?
The list becomes utter shit at 2010 and after. At least before that it had some resemblance of accuracy.
>>133594526
When you stop watching seasonal battle harem shit and get some taste.
>>133594370
What? You think no one on /a/ likes Eve no Jikan?
>>133594645
I was kind of hoping for an episode number but that works too I guess
>>133579237
>People actually hate Paranoia Agent
2002: FMP
2003: Planetes
2004: Paranoia Agent
2005: Mushishi
2006: NHK
2007: Baccano
2008: Casshern Sins
2009: Redline (fuck you, movies are allowed)
2010: Katanagatari
2011: Penguindrum
2012: Hyouka
2013: Gatchaman Crowds
2014: Shirobako
2015: Euphonium
>>133579340
>Zankyou no Bait
>AOTY
I've never understood why people think Baccano was so great.
>>133595348
>memebako
>hyoukshit
>hibikek
1/10, at least you tried.
>>133595435
>>133595447
>>133595488
If not being a nostalgia-blinded pleb means being a faggot than bring on the dicks
>>133594498
>2.5 million sale man
>>133594525
>using facebook
>>133588904
>The entire first series was an irrefutable masterpiece
Kill yourself. Please.
>>133595348
Having an orbital piece of shit taste such as this is a crime in my country.
>>133594398
>>133596179
Samefag plz
>>133596212
Not really.
>>133595348
what happened 2012 onward anon?
>>133575562
>2nd gig didn't win
>non non biyori didn't win
shit list
>good
>pretty good
>2011 Penguindrum, fucking yes
>2012 didn't watch Hyouka
>2013 onwards, aneurysm maybe?
>>133579042
Your taste is good until 2009. What the hell happened to you anon?
>>133596362
he got some taste
>>133595348
>FMP
>AOTY
kek
>>133579269
>Tatami Galaxy
>Monogatari
Literally "Repetition: The Anime". Someone please explain why these always exist in these charts.
Why is Hyouge Mono always on these stupid lists? Literally nobody on /a/ cared about it when it was airing and literally nobody cares about it now. And out of all the amazing 2011 anime, the honorable mentions are always god awful.
>>133596745
Repetition is a valid storytelling style though
>>133596767
It's a forced meme.
AOTY 2015.
Prove me wrong, I dare you.
>>133596813
It's also a boring storytelling style.
>>133597098
/a/ told me it was chuuni. Care to defend it from this charge?
>>133597102
That's your opinion, though. Boring is a meaningless buzzword.
>>133597141
Everything in entertainment is just opinion.
>>133597152
Not really. There is genuine criticism to be made, for example if a show is paced poorly to the extent where it becomes difficult to follow.
>>133597183
Repeating things often leads me to stop paying attention, making the show difficult to follow. There, now repetition is "bad."
>>133597188
The difference is whether it is just you or if it is a common theme. Considering how well received the shows are basically everywhere, the problem is probably on the user side.
>>133597228
Argumentum ad numerum
>>133597282
Shitposting in latin is still shitposting
The argument isn't "it's good because it's popular" it's "it must work because it's well received"
A small but important difference
>>133597282
fallacy fallacy
>>133597282
hominem ad einstein
>>133578234
>It literally has the most technically impressive visuals of any anime series, ever.
Literally wrong
>>133597309
It's only "well received" because large amounts of people find it to be good, i.e. still argumentum ad numerum
>>133575562
>2003
>not Kino
>2005
>not Mushishi
>2008
>not Kaiba or Michiko
Otherwise, yeah.Why was 2010 so good, Holt shit
>>133579269
I really didn't think taste worse than OP's was possible, but holy shit. The ONLY redeeming factor is Zegapain
>>133597334
It being well received means that the style works as a storytelling medium
>>133597332
What's your pick, then?
>>133583870
>disgusting SHAFT powerpoint animation
B-but muh shading.
The writing was pretty shit.
Literally every single anime mentioned in this thread is good except Non Non Biyori.
>>133597357
It doesn't work for me though. Thus whether it "works" is down to the opinion of the person viewing the work. >>133597152
>>133575562
Can someone explain to me how ping pong is constantly mentioned as the best anime of 2014? I watched that shit and wanted to kill myself every second. It's just so boring with its tacky symbolism and all the bad art. Is this what it's like to watch "art"? Because if it is, I would much rather watch moe-shit than this any day.
>>133580473
Its good, just entry level and highly-overrated
>>133578384
Abenobashi doesn't belong on that list. Still a great year though.
>nobody mentioning fma brotherhood
It's ok to like things if they are popular
>>133592441
>>133592559
>Not liking memes
>>>/reddit/
>>133597457
But is it okay to like Naruto with Alchemy?
>tfw reading Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy for the first time
Comfy feely feels
Shit thread btw 2bh family. At least I posted in it. You got that going for you.
>>133597365
Casshern Sins
>>133597403
There are two options here:
A) Everybody but you is right and Ping Pong was a very good show. You just have shit taste.
B)You're the chosen one, the only person in the world who is right, everyone else is wrong.
Now tell me which one sounds more likely to you.
>>133597525
>Comfy feely feels
That chart is Vogon-tier
>>133597549
Not him but I never saw anyone discuss Ping Pong when it aired
http://myanimelist.net/anime/22135/Ping_Pong_The_Animation
This is a joke right?
>>133597565
Plenty of things weren't discussed much when they first came out though
The Thing did so shit it was almost dropped from theaters, yet few people would claim that makes it a bad film.
>>133597600
But it does mean it isn't really plausible that all these people on /a/ somehow like it when they didn't discuss it when it aired.
>>133597565
Then you're blind, we had several active threads per episode.
>>133597591
>Ping Pong The Animation won the Animation of the Year award in the Television category for the Tokyo Anime Award Festival in 2015.
Oh look, faggots that hate on Ping Pong don't actually know SHIT about animation.
Whoulda THUNK?
>muh symbolism
That what every moepigs said
>>133597622
/a/ is reactionary and often judges things before they even air
>>133597628
And Argo won an Oscar. Your point being?
>>133597563
Ayy! Another well earned (You)
Thank you, partner. I shall repay (You) in kind.
>>133576571
This is the one.
>best anime of they year charts
>without K-On in it
Into the trash it goes.
>>133597698
Fun things are fun.
>>133597628
Fags that hate Ping Pong don't even know who Taiyo Matsumoto is. All they can do is repeat "muh Yuasashit" and "pretentious hipster" again and again.
>>133597628
>unironically using awards as a measure of quality
>>133597525
This is not a 3x3 thread, you underaged shittard.
>>133597916
And yet it is still my personal toilet.
A (You) for a (You). I am generous with my wealth!
The secret to these lists is to put shit on them that nobody watched or cared about so that they don't realize how shitty they actually are.
>ctrl + F "samurai flamenco"
Well at least my choice for 2013 can't be worse than the people saying OreImo.
>>133598162
>Gays can marry
>You can feel superior to /a/ for at least one thread
2015 is a good year for you.
>>133575562
Monster was fucking terrible, planetes was boring.
Baccanno I don't really have an opinion of, didn't really get into it but I'm sure if I did it would have been okay.
Tatami galaxy was really good.
Most of these I've never watched, but considering they put Monster on a list of "good animes" the person who made this is probably either retarded, or really retarded.
>>133598335
>hasn't seen a significant amount of very well received anime from the last 13 years
>uses the term animes
>somehow expects people to pay attention to his opinions
How the fuck do you people think monster is good? Was there really nothing better that year?
I enjoyed fucking ergo proxy more than I enjoyed that edgy piece of shit. FUCKING ERGO PROXY. Why is Ergo Proxy better than your BoY pick for 2004!?
Not every anime can be GTO or Tatami galaxy, but holy fuck you guys can't we get something better than Monster for 2004?
>>133598550
Beck came out in 2004 and was pretty good too
>>133598623
my nigguh, I fucking loved beck and Sakamichi no Apollon
>>133597525
I thought you didn't like Nichijou.
>>133588576
It's hard to explain. Just watch it, prepare to cringe at the subs and to enjoy the show itself more than any other before it.
>>133599645
The long ruse.
Ive got another couple shows I've trolled for 5+ years but I'm not finished with those fanbases yet.
>>133599707
Is there no end to your disregard for human life?
>>133599860
hahahaha.
NO
I step into a new thread
Same bullshit as the old one
Yall angry over every post
But I just have a ton of fun
Every single post i make is gold
because I got the midas touch
Faggots act like they don't care
but they on pooicide watch
Yeah
You can't fuck with me
I'm way above you
Check my 3x3
That's right
You spent your whole life not approaching me
You're close minded. I recommend brain surgery.
Or maybe
Lobotomy
Anything
Just hurry please
You only live once and you're wasting it
Sincerely
Cuppy
,':^)
