ITT Perfect casting
>>71980920
Wrong pic.
>>71980920
Not quite perfect since based viggo is more impressive irl then fictional aragorn was in universe.
>>71980920
getting this out of the way
>>71980953
Various other actors could have filled several of those roles. I'd actually have liked to have seen a Christopher Lee Gandalf as it was originally intended. Not to say McKellan does a bad job.
>>71981018
MOM'S
>>71980920
that shit blue version
>>71981044
No, you're wrong and suck dicks (in a bad sense).
Lee is inherently better at being a villain.
>>71981044
i have to agree with >>71981114. Lee seems more villainous than McKallen
>>71981114
>Lee is inherently better at being a villain.
And that somehow means he would make a bad Gandalf?
Anyway, I just want to see him playing Gandalf for a few scenes. That's the way Tolkien would have wanted it. I'm fine with the roles they had.
>>71980991
It's easier to point out wrong casting rather than good on GoT most of the time, i even think CIA is good as LF, just his direction and habits are terrible
>>71981114
You sound like a faggot desu
>>71981044
>as it was originally intended.
I do know that lee was a huge fan of tolkien and after spilling his spaghetti all over him tolkien told him he would be a perfect gandalf. I don't know that he was ever going to be gandalf in the jackson trilogy.
Based christopher lee... RIP in peace.
P E R F E C T
>>71981211
I am, senpai.
>>71981209
Do you remember his 'I'm sooo soooorry?' when he first met Sansa after her escape? It jarring how out of place and laughable overacted it was.
>>71981311
>It's
>laughably
Damn.
>>71981114
Gandalf should have been portrayed as a villain. He isn't fighting for what is right- an extremely nebulous notion given the greater story-line- he's fighting an old foe from many wars before, a foe that was once his brother. Gandalf is playing every side to get what he wants. Lee's character is just doing what he always did, trying to maintain the old way of things. That old way being what happened after the really big wars decided a thousand years at least before. Gandalf is a loose cannon. He invented the Time of Men just to spike his old adversaries.
>>71981359
Bill Nighy is perfect in everything he does desu
>>71981359
why did Underworld have to turn into shit after the first movie ? The first one was so comfy, I loved the gothic atmosphere, mixed with with fucked up post soviet eastern europe
without a shadow of a doubt
>>71981450
because all fucking vampire movies drawn inspiration from Vampire the Masquerade, but we will never see a fucking real adaptation because some people hate money
Looked like the real Robert Ford and was perfect at playing a creepy faggot.
Shia Lebouf was actually considered for this role
>>71981450
The first one is kind of shit too though.
>>71980920
>>71980920
>Vin Diesel
>Nicolas Cage
Holy shit. This movie could've turned to utter shit so fast because of one miscast.
Glad Viggo got the role. Perfect for it.
Same for the Matrix with Keanu. Smith would've overacted.
>>71981311
There are several moments where he completely overacts. That doesn't mean that he does not have good scenes though.
I always found pic related far worse.
There was not a single moment where she didn't come off as an annoying cunt with zero talent.
She should have kept doing porn.
>>71981504
I'd pay to see Cage hamming it up and screaming during the Helms Deep charge
>>71981462
Underrated post
>>71981504
>Vin Diesel
Wait, what?
Was he considered for Aragorn?
>>71981450
>>71981450
Michael Sheen's pretty good too
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PgSJ7m1bEHk
TOP FRANK
>>71981606
I kinda liked Rome Lad more
>>71980920
>>71981594
He was reportedly considered and Diesel at the time wasn't famous as XXX or Fast and Furious Torino plus he's a huge fantasy geek. Guy actually read the book but he wouldn't have fit the part.
>>71981515
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9lHe6Oelj4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ScQOrbNbopM
They are so funny exactly because they are true. Some time Littlefinger just strayed from a sneaky scheming guy to a full-blown meme character à la CIA.
>>71981504
I'm pretty sure Vin would have done better than shit. Worse than Viggo, yeah, but not utter shit.
Vin's a huge nerd, so he would probably know enough about Arargorn to pull it off.
![J.K._Simmons_02_1024_[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/YT82Nwi.jpg "J.K._Simmons_02_1024_[1].jpg")
>>71981843
yes
>>71981801
the only thing that was actually done right in thee Hobbit
How can other actors even compete?Jack Nicholson was also pretty alright in that role.
>>71981801
hes a great actor, loved him in fargo
![ironman1[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/OrLtraI.jpg "ironman1[1].jpg")
>>71981741
lol thanks for those.
I like to imagine that whenever Littlefinger and Varys have one of those "meaningfull" dialogues the actors just wonder what the pretentious shit they were handed that week is even supposed to mean.
MY KING
>>71982006
yes
![Norwood%20Builder%20(16)[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/8C8tTQL.jpg "Norwood%20Builder%20(16)[1].jpg")
My dear Watson
>>71981936
yes
>>71981962
I could have watched him in that role forever
"just as planned" - the character
>>71981044
>Christopher Lee
>As Originally Intended
You mean Sean Connery.
>>71981843
100% perfect.
>>71982178
Tolkien promised Lee the role of Gandalf if he ever allowed a film to be made during his life time.
>>71982013
They know exactly what it means. A good actor is a deeply disturbed individual. Unless he or she is absurdly gifted. I can't name a living one off the top of my head, that's alive I mean. And the dead ones I think of were like that too. James Dean was amazingly gifted.
>>71981009
Viggo maybe, but Movie Aragorn.. not entirely
Movie Aragorn:
>Iduno..
>My path.. its clouded..
>I'm not sure..
>I guess I should be King
>Alright, I am the King
Book Aragorn:
>I'm the King, get the fuck out of my way
>I'm the King, get the fuck out of my way
>I'm the King, get the fuck out of my way
>Stupid fuck didn't you hear me? I'm the fucking KING!
>>71982232
tea-sipping faggots would share such meaningless nothings with each other
>>71982080
The best Sherlock Holmes.
It annoys that normies thinks of Battlefield Counterstrike or Robert Downey JUNIOR when you mention Sherlock Holmes.
>>71982245
Nailed it. Kind of like how they ruined the character of Gandalf.
>>71982294
hehe, is that Frank?
Viggo hold my hand,
He was so good in these movies.
>>71980920
>>71982297
I didn't mind Robert's portrayal, Benedict cabbagepatch's entire show is what was a trainwreck.
>>71982307
That looks like a porn.
>>71982307
I unironically really liked it.
>>71982372
no, wow
>>71981044
Objectively false
>>71980920
WHY IS IT SO BLUE?
>>71982320
>>71982401
No.
>>71982381
porn casting ain't bad either, though I do wonder why Bree Olson couldn't just die her hair for the role
>>71982372
Memes aside, she was a pretty good Wonder Woman. I loved it.
>>71981018
Prince would be a better Joker.
>>71982413
Objectively? Damn this meme gets me every time. Not objectively.
>>71982470
Go home, Asston. Don't you have a Kodak Moment commercial to film or something?
>>71982490
hell yes
>>71981843
god it would be great to get him back in that role.
>>71981936
Love Robert Carlyle, wish he was in more things
>>71982496
I feel rather scummy knowing that name. That said I couldn't pick her out in a crowd. Ya, I could..
>>71982311
How so?
Been a few years since I last read the books.
>>71980920
Along with Captain Picard as Professor X.
>>71982512
Holy shit! That's brilliant.
>>71982540
Nope. Woz threw the crew's cameras out the window. So, here we sit eating tacos with Bruckheimer.
how dare they remake this movie
>>71982409
why?
>>71982502
agree she was the bes part from BVS i was a little bit sceptical when i heard that they are gonna make a ww movie but after i saw BVS i can't wait to see it
>>71982612
I, to my discredit just posted what I thought in another thread. Lemme dig that shit up and paste it- oh it was here what a faggot I am
>>71981351
>>71982307
I always laugh at the thought of Mathew lillard high talking to a green screen pretending it's a cartoon dog.
>>71981311
Again, direction faults, that read is retarded, but his descent into full meme really started S3 where he went from being kinda shady to full blown "evil", aka when the writing/directors started to lose it.
>>71982818
Ya, but I always imagined Goodman in the role, too. First thing I thought, actually.
>>71982818
He would be a perfect Bloody Baron in the inevitable Witcher movie tbqh familia
>>71981266
Man, what a disappointing movie. So much potential.
>>71982926
>Implying they'll adapt the subplots and not just TW3's garbage main plot
It'll be just like Game of Thrones and have 95% of the dialogue cut. Don't really know why they need a movie adaption anyhoo, the game's enough of a movie already. Not that that's a bad thing, but damn did it play like shit.
>>71981351
So Gandalf is actually the villain IF you count stuff written well after the original material aka he was retconned to be the villain? Fuck that (by that i mean fuck Tolkien)
>>71982524
It's ok anon
>>71982490
>>71982681
Has based Kurt ever been not perfect for a role.
I want a movie where he plays every character.
>>71982989
I played the first two and there isn't enough in those games to make movies on. Though, I really wanted to read the source material novels after even the first one, but they are Polish and never found a translation- yet. The books must be fucking awesome...
>>71982080
That series is so good.
>>71982989
But anon, he's part of the main quest
>>71982413
My wishful thinking was false? Or are you saying everyone in the picture I quoted was absolutely irreplaceable as an actor. Or are you just a fucking aspie memelord?
![black-sails-cast[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/bPWyann.jpg "black-sails-cast[1].jpg")
>>71980920
black sails
>>71983209
what a terrible series literally peter pan t tier
>>71983053
Nope I'm one of those guys who've read everything repeatedly. Have you read The Silmarillion? Gandalf is old school, man. He's seen literally everything happen in that world, he was there before his boss made the world. He's conservative to the utmost. He's a manipulator who's personal agendas couldn't be understood my men, let alone elves. He lies to everyone, manipulates everyone, in order to best his old rival. He doesn't fucking care about shit anymore. Sauromon did though. He had seen a peace in the world, and despite war, was willing to play dirty to maintain that peace. Gandalf didn't fucking care. His way or else. And he got his way.
>>71981977
what I never got was if he made up the whole story by looking at things on the bulletin board wouldn't the detective guy have noticed the discrepancies in his story and the one he told the DA?
>>71983209
>hey this is pretty good, Starz hasn't gone too overboard with this series
>hmmm, focusing a lot on the sex now, but lesbians are pretty okay
>uhhh, so that gay buttfucking came out of nowhere
Never dropped anything so hard in my life.
>>71983209
>>71983209
dont be silly
flint is alri and I enjoy john silver but thats about it
vane is awful
>>71980920
> 135 posts
>>71983123
Barely.
If they had any sense, they'd cut and rework the entire flashback exposition.
One thing I love in my movies is when Act V is tacked on so some random guy can explain the Antagonist's motives in black & white flashbacks.
>>71982080
>>71982297
You niggers obviously did not see the best adaptation.
>>71982602
probably had three other shootings that day for blond bangers or smth
>>71983375
Vatnik detected
>>71983268
Gandalf could have just given the Ring to the elves and let them kill the Enemy, he always knew exactly where it was. But he didn't. He let the weakest of the weak do his dirty work. And in effect, removed the world of the best it had- the elves said fuck this we're going to heaven. And left the world in a mire of shit with people like you and me to sort it all out. Why did he do that? Cause someone told him he couldn't, that it should be done better, for everyone. He resented the elves, resented his maker.
No one else could have pulled it off.
>>71983422
no one else wanted to do it also
>>71983375
Too cliched and slav-oriented. Music is top-tier though
>>71981044
Lee as Gandalf and McKellan as Saruman could have been dope, but what we got was still perfect
>>71983416
If you haven't picked up on what old Tolk was getting at with Gandalf yet, it's this. Gandalf is Lucifer.
>>71983451
The Hound of the Baskervilles is great though.
>>71981801
for me he made Bilbo too hateable. perfect in Fargo though, where he's using the exact same mannerisms only you're supposed to dislike him
always loved Richard Roxburgh as Dracula
Perfectly nails the dichotomy between Idi Amin:
A constant morph between a big buffoon-like character to a hyper intense and murderous warlord
>>71981462
C L A S S I C
L
A
S
S
I
C
>>71983242
you haven't watched it eh? more like GoT
>>71983318
season 3 had like 1 sexy scene. homo scene in s2 was just implied , never shown as in GoT or Rome or etc
>>71983336
Vane was oke imo
BlackBeard, Woodens, Miranda are great too
>>71983499
you can see the pain in his eyes reading those pottery lines
>>71981801
>>71983620
Martin Freeman was perfect casting. Bilbo always was a bit of a shit, he's an opportunistic thief and coward who is easily bullied into doing shit.
>>71981669
HAAAACKSOOON!
>yfw the perfect Moriarty was not in a Sherlock Holmes adaptation
>>71983766
Good choice
>>71981351
>just to spike his old adversaries.
>>71982080
What is this from, plz
>>71981808
KEEP YOUR HANDS OFF MY FUCKING NECK!
>>71983795
The adventures of Sherlock Holmes,from 1984.
>>71981750
But he's a fucking bald mystery meat mongrel whose name is fucking VIN DIESEL
Stephen Dilane is literally Stannis. Shame they completely butchered the character.
![WP-TheThing-620x400[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/qwJAO3Y.jpg "WP-TheThing-620x400[1].jpg")
>>71981502
DELETE THIS
GABBAAAGOOOL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5LpZoAmWORc
>>71983547
What is this dank new meme?
realer than real life
>>71983832
>responsible for one of the best games in the last 20 years
>tech is a decade ahead of its time
>keeps making shitty movies instead
god damn it vin
>>71984033
It's me baby, all me. It's brand new OC, circa two hours ago.
>>71984006
HE'S A FAAAAG
>>71984286
>Game comes with worst DRM ever made
And dropped
>>71983903
>that fucking retarded editing
Every damn time. Why do people think this shit is well constructed? Who's doing the direction of photography?? Who's editing?!?
>>71981875
>COUNCILOOOOOOR
Oh fuck yes
>>71983672
lol my brother and i had an inside joke about this movie. Basically van helsing was draculas gay lover in the past but he forgot.
It makes this scene hilarious:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVWrVCLs8ms
>>71981018
Am I the only one who thinks this movie is way tryhard and cliché?
>>71984993
Have you seen it?
>>71982034
hes so good in this
>>71985078
nope. Just the trailers
>>71982515
fuck no
>>71982006
upvoted my good sir
>>71982571
;_;
>>71984728
>having gay jokes with your brother
Did you also touch each other's penises?
>>71985476
Nah, GQ was his arguably best dramatic/comedic role.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQG3I5efwWo
>>71985331
So you're a claim with no way to back it up. Bet you hated ghostbusters too.
>>71985484
nope . We just have different sense of humour
>>71983128
Everyone in that picture IS absolutely irreplaceable, anon :^)
>>71985547
>>71984993
When I saw the first one I was incredibly hyped up. But when anon began posting those atrociously terrible promo articles about Leto, my expectations have somewhat dwindled.
Can u imagine guyz!!??? A RAT!! The man is aaahbsolutely fucking craaazy.
http://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/crazy-things-jared-leto-playing-joker.html/?a=viewall
>>71980920
>>71981602
How does a movie have such an innocent enjoyable second act and such a malerkey first and third.
>>71981351
>Le "the hero is actually the villain" may-may
Do you write for Cracked, anon?
>>71982307
Unironically this.
Terrible movie, spot on casting.
>>71985725
yes
>>71980920
>Nicholas Cage was originally going to be Aragorn, but he declined
Can you imagine?
>>71981750
I love vin but in every role he is in you can kind of see his true dorky nature shining through. That is one of the thing I love most about seeing him but just imagine the type of nerdgasm he would have playing a character in lord of the rings much less aragorn.
>>71981297
You're one of those weirdos!
couldn't imagine any other guy
>>71985878
>come back Frodo you fucking midget
>>71981843
Am i the only one that hated this?
>>71986012
Yes and you should feel bad for it.
>>71982307
Prime smg.
>>71981801
This man was born to play George W. Bush.
>>71984728
Damn that does improve the movie
>>71981515
I loved that scene, how they literally built A MODERN FUCKING JUSTICE ROOM for a fantasy world to drive the point through for series-peasants
>>71982621
Yes and yes.
>>71983903
>Stephen Dilane
has he ever not perfectly nailed a role though? I was rewatching John Adams recently and could not believe that he was TJ.
>>71982307
>Mathew Lillard
>Shaggy
Fuck yes. The role he was born to play
>>71984286
what game
>>71986830
escape from butcher bay
>>71986830
I guess he's talking about Chronicles of Riddick: Butcher Bay.
>>71985879
Reminds me, this was a perfect casting choice
the entire show's cast is pretty perfect tbhqf
>There will never be a spin off about him fucking with mere mortals for fun
I'd watch it all day, everyday.
>>71987136
agree, except for weiners faggot son playing glen
>>71981602
Daft Punk really splurged the cash on the making of these feature long music video.
>>71983268
>Have you read The Silmarillion?
Gandalf only got a paragraph
>>71982245
Yea, I also thought Vigo's depiction of Aragorn was too wishy washy. He seemed overly distraught and confused most of the time. I get that they were trying to emphasize his character development for the mass audience, but imo it would have been cooler if he just was more kingly from the get-go, as in the books, instead of trying to make him into a more typical protagonist.
>>71982612
Gandalf is portrayed largely portrayed as a kind, benevolent old man most of the time. In the books he was much more of a crabby old fart of a wizard, who had a heart of gold that only shone through from time to time. I prefer the stricter, meaner portrayal of Gandalf. It's just more Wizardly and less grandpa-y.
>>71981843
/thread
>>71981801
But he never tried acting. He was fucking Martin Freeman as a hobbit.
he's ALWAYS acting like martin freeman
>>71981044
>>71981290
Lee would have made a great Gandalf. I think he could have brought a stern, firey, mysterious edge to the character that Ian didn't have.
Of course Lee was a great Saruman too.
Should have cast Lee in both roles
>>71981133
Is that a willy wonka tv suit?
>>71987446
The whole film is god tier, except for maybe Bill Paxton.
>>71982022
The color of his beard always freaked me out.
>>71988031
This is being broadcast right at this very moment.
I still don't understand how he got off scott free with gunning down 4 of the Baxter in the horse sequence, was it self defense?
>>71988969
better pic
>>71981843
I mean, I like Spider-man, but I recently rewatched the whole trilogy just because of J.K. Simmons.
This is why you should never do such a sudden reboot. SP3 was weak but not a horrible movie, just mediocre.
>>71981501
I hated him so fucking much from the first time he opened his mouth in the movie. He did a great job.
>watch the rotoscoped LOTR
>Aragorn is an ugly, blemished, unattractive old man
I literally couldn't keep watching.
>>71990103
well he's definitely not the shampoo model you see in the Jackson films. He's over 80 and even for part-Numenoreans this is after middle age, and most of the time he wanders the wild, eating rabbits and berries. Frodo initially think she's some sort of a thief
Michael Shannon nailed this role.
>>71990656
Tell that to his snapped neck.
>>71982378
Elementary with hacker guy is a better Sherlock show than Sherlock with cumbersuck
>>71982006
I didnt know that 90% of his character is just improvised by RDJ. They give him a basic outline and let him loose. He just is Tony Stark.
>>71983036
So good, ive been around hopheads and he acts just like a fucking addict
>>71983253
>>71980956
Young Ford was always really good at rugged action heroes. it became less believable as he got older
>>71981546
looks like guru larry, but how could that cunt have any time for acting, considering his full time job of posting in every shitty youtube comment sections i see
>>71983268
Have you read the Silmarillion? Mithrandir is only really mentioned and appears like once. A better basis for opinion is in the Unfinished tales where you learn what he was doing before and during The Hobbit
![15-years-later-the-surprisingly-big-named-cast-of-band-of-brothers-326765[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/960LJcS.jpg "15-years-later-the-surprisingly-big-named-cast-of-band-of-brothers-326765[1].jpg")
>>71982515
His face looks so stupid
I actually believe hes autistic
