[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why are Samurai so rare compared to knights and vikings? Let's
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tg/ - Traditional Games

Thread replies: 157
Thread images: 22
File: samurai.jpg (9 KB, 225x225) Image search: [Google]
samurai.jpg
9 KB, 225x225
Why are Samurai so rare compared to knights and vikings? Let's take a look at them

Knights
>rekt by Mongols
>rekt by sandniggers
>rekt by fucking peasants

Vikings
>killing some unarmed farmers and monks
>?

woah fucking impressive

meanwhile Samurai rekt said Mongols and are pretty much agreed to be the best warriors in history
>>
File: YallN1ggazPostinInATrollThread.jpg (18 KB, 240x249) Image search: [Google]
YallN1ggazPostinInATrollThread.jpg
18 KB, 240x249
Dumb baitposter.
>>
>>47912226
>best

That isn't how you say Apache Helicopters, anon.
>>
File: marines.jpg (72 KB, 473x355) Image search: [Google]
marines.jpg
72 KB, 473x355
>>47912226
Samurai
>rekt by marines
>>
>>47912257
>marines

rekt by gooks
>>
>>47912226
You need to go back to /v/ with the weak baitposting
>>
>>47912226
If samurai were so great why did Japans get cucked for eternity by the west?

Check mate, dummy
>>
>>47912392
Because they got rid of the samurai.
>>
Is this a weak excuse to talk about For Honour? Because I'm actually looking forward to coop the shit out of that.
>>
>>47912288
>gooks
rekt by samurai
>>
>>47912425
And thus the cycle was complete.
>>
>>47912226
Benis
>>
>>47912226
Who are you, that do not know your history?
>>
File: image.jpg (40 KB, 550x400) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
40 KB, 550x400
>>47912226
Vikings where pretty awesome with their long traveling routes with longboats, which combined stretched half the globe, and their business with the Middle East helped bring in new silver into western Europe that lead to a more stabile economy.

Samurais had a bunch of civil wars, a bunch of failed invasions of the mainland and made everyone in the region hate Japan.
>>
>>47912226
Actuarry, the ocean lekt the Mongors fo'a the Japanese
>>
>>47912416
Nigga Ill solo that shit. Ive wanted a game like that for years and hopefully im getting it.

Knights Vikings and Samurai came about under completely different conditions and circumstances. Comparing them directly and completely isnt really fair.

The real question is why samurai made this thread. I suspect to draw away from the fact that asthetically (the only fair metric to quickly compare them by) they lose hardcore to knights.
>>
>>47912425
Remember when Hideyoshi successfully invaded and conquered Korea and then the Ming?

Me neither
>>
File: iWKad22.jpg (90 KB, 1440x1080) Image search: [Google]
iWKad22.jpg
90 KB, 1440x1080
>>47912226
Look, I like the samurai. I love japanese history as a whole, actually. But this is just plain stupidity.

I mena, I get this is bait, but you could have put more effort on this.
>>
>>47912449
Woah so some sea jews should be shilled as great warriors? LMAO
>>
>>47912467
No, but i do remember when Tokugawa did it.

That was a fun game of EU4.
>>
>>47912463
That's subjective.
I think vikings win by a milestone. However, I love mail and shieldwalls, so I'm biased.
>>
>>47912467
To be fair they were doing fine on land
>>
>>47912508
Wow mail and shieldwalls how fucking unique too bad literally everyone including Saxons who rekt them used shieldwalls and fucking mail.
>>
>Samurai:"Rook at these Chinese sword, let us spend thousand years copying it! AYYY Nanban dogs have cowardly superior weaponry, let us spend half a thousand years in isolation licking our wounds"
Is there a worse people?
>>
>>47912535
I didn't say my favourite warriors ever were the vikings. That would be either the Sassanids or the early anglo-saxons. But if I were to choose between knights, vikings and samurai, based only on how they look, I would choose vikings. All three of them are pretty cool, but I prefer the early medieval aesthetic.

Also, you're forgetting that the vikings conquered England two times.
>>
>>47912494
I remember when the Qing conquered Japan.

That, too, was a fun game of EUIV. Well, as fun as a game of EUIV can be.
>>
>>47912592
Samurai used the Nanban guns, and adapted their tactics pretty quickly to them. Even during the Tokugawa Shogunate, the japanese kept using guns, just not as much.

Also, the isolation lasted 200 years, more or less.
>>
>>47912622
>two times

aside from the fact that once they conquered most of England and not whole of it what was the second time?
>>
>>47912714
He's probably going to say the Normans.
Yes, they're French, but people keep calling them vikings because they were vikings, before they became Normans.
>>
>>47912714
Actually, they sort of conquered the entire thing the first time. Alfred was forced to retreat to the marshes. But that didn't last long and it's more of a footnote, so you're still correct.

The second time was the invasion of Sweyn Forkbeard, although it was his son Cnut who became king of England. This lasted more or less 26 years. After Cnut's death, the English became independet under his son Harthacnut, and after Harthacnut the crown returned to the house of Wessex.

>>47912784
That would count as a third conquest, if it was,'t for the fact that the normans were a mixture of french and dane with their own language and customs. So no, the normans aren't vikings, just as the carthaginians weren't phoenicians.
>>
>>47912784
And Americans were British before they became Americans so by that logic we might attribute all american achievements to Britain.
>>
>>47912784

This, basically. This isn't really relevant, though, because our whole concept of 'knights' is just as continental as it is British, if not more so. The whole chivalry thing was 300% French. Frankly, our historical concept of knights is about as accurate as our depiction of cowboys: heavily romanticized and invented by a bunch of Italians.
>>
>>47912226

Well, it could be because their primary weapons are kind of underpowered (going by their d20 stats at least?)
>>
>>47912864

No. Stop that. Do not abjure the copypasta. We haven't had that copypasta on /tg/ in like a fucking year. Stop. Why.
>>
>>47912226

Because the Japanese were (and, as much as they can get away with it, still are) deeply isolationist, especially when the samurai were actually relevant.
>>
>>47912901
>We haven't had that copypasta on /tg/ in like a fucking year

If only.
>>
File: letmelaughharder.gif (1 MB, 288x198) Image search: [Google]
letmelaughharder.gif
1 MB, 288x198
>>47912226
>Samurai rekted mongols
Samurai did no such thing. In fact, Japan was certain the mongols would bring about their doom had it not been for a freak storm that wiped out their fleet. Even weebs these days dont know world history.
>>
>>47912955
There were two Mongol invasions of Japan. The second one was the one with the storm. The first one was conventional warfare, and the Japanese repulsed the Mongol army after several battles.
>>
>>47912955
Most people don't know world history.
>>
>>47912226
Is there anything where you can play in ye olde japan other than Legend of the Five Rings?
>>
>>47913071
Sengoku Rance.
>>
>>47913149
I was talking about tabletop RPGs, but I'll go replay that anyway.
>>
File: image.jpg (35 KB, 375x374) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
35 KB, 375x374
>>47912480
Successful business and economy is always more important for a thriving culture than having a class of special snowflake warriors.
>>
>>47913188
Then why the fuck should merchants be even compared to knights and samurai?
>>
File: image.jpg (101 KB, 429x599) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
101 KB, 429x599
>>47912532
Yi Sun-sin op pls nerf
>>
>>47913071

Sengoku.

Or some oriental adventures type of shit.
>>
>>47912456
you sound fun to be around
>>
>>47912226
When you live on an island and a big storm saves you from invasion I don't think you can claim victory through your superiority.

Also mongols rekt by knight, hence why we aren't all mongoloid fucks; sand niggers it was more of a draw knights fucked them, they then fucked the Knights, this goes on for a while.

Also the Vikings didn't just fuck up peasants the also conquered swaths of lands which doesn't happen without fucking up the ruling warrior elite.

Samurai on the other hand got rekt by dirty peasants.
>>
File: image.jpg (78 KB, 476x590) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
78 KB, 476x590
>>47913207
Because knights and samurais are just roadbumps in history. Merchants is always what makes society great and allows knights and samurais to even exist. It's money that makes the world go round. Not muh honor or muh swords.
>>
>>47912508
>milestone
>However, I love mail and shieldwalls

Most pretentious pseudo-intellectual moron post of the year award goes to you, Anon.
>>
>>47912226
probably because they're not part of the european collective that was all dumped together to form tolkien's setting so they do not exist in the current pop culture fantasy canon

also they look dumb
>>
File: Danmarkskort.gif (82 KB, 419x591) Image search: [Google]
Danmarkskort.gif
82 KB, 419x591
Since we're already at it I might as well shitpost too.

>Jutes
>Anglos
>Cimbrians
>Teutons
>Vikings

Imagine trying to build a civilization next to this place, and it just keeps spewing out barbarians to raid and settle your shit.
>>
>>47913900
Okay? It's not like I was trying to, but nice on me, I guess.
>>
File: CG1195.png (13 KB, 320x256) Image search: [Google]
CG1195.png
13 KB, 320x256
>>
>japan literally banned a weapon from the comp scene because it was too powerful and wrecked the balance and fun

What a bunch of scrubs
>>
>>47912666

remember when ghandi nuked the us
>>
>>47913670
Everybody seems to think so
>>
File: chesty-birday-600-10.jpg (49 KB, 600x748) Image search: [Google]
chesty-birday-600-10.jpg
49 KB, 600x748
>>47912288
Orly? They couldn't even keep a measly division surrounded.
>>
File: Drifters.jpg (229 KB, 660x1088) Image search: [Google]
Drifters.jpg
229 KB, 660x1088
>>47913685
>Samurai on the other hand got rekt by dirty peasants.
Based Ashigaru. Staple of the Shimazu Clan in Shogun 2.
>>
>>47915959
Shimazu had katana niggers

Oda was the Ashigaru boss
>>
>>47912226
They're not, go to Japan and Samurai shit is everywhere.
>>
>>47916012
>Not using Ashigaru no matter the army
Pleb, Ashigaru are all you need.
>>
>>47915445
Like the Pope did crossbows?
>>
>>47916040
Tried. He didn't pull it off.
>>
>>47912254
God I want to roll an Apache Attack Helicopter so bad but my DM thinks they're overpowered.
>>
>>47912784
They were Normans because they had the mixed blood of Northmen and they were on the North-ish part of France. And judging by the fact that they spoke French after William's conquest and not some Scandy language for the next few centuries it's more accurate to say that the Normans were French. Otherwise you're just saying that the Vikings conquered other fucking Vikings.
>>
>>47916038
Of course, everyone uses Ashigaru. Oda is just better at it than the other clans. Well and Chosokabe because of their accuracy bonus.
>>
>>47912226
More like
>mongols
>rekt everyone
>literally everyone
They fucked the Middle East so hard something just irreversibly snapped to the point it's still a shithole nowadays. Their few battles with the Japanese completely destroyed their understanding about warfare, and they only were saved by a storm destroying the whole fleet on the way to Japan. The Mongol conquests come second only to WORLD WAR II in death toll, in a time period where the world's population was measured in hundreds of millions rather than several billions
>>
>>47912901
>abjure
Did you perhaps mean "conjure"?
>>
File: BelgiqueAnon.jpg (71 KB, 250x250) Image search: [Google]
BelgiqueAnon.jpg
71 KB, 250x250
>>47913707

This.

Soldiers don't hire - they're hirelings.

>rekt by paymasters

The brainiacs who can generate wealth for an entire region do the hiring - and build the infrastructure to make the distribution of wealth self-sustaining. They are the people who drive industry and social progress. Look at the economic powerhouses of Cuba and Venezuela to see how well strongarm juntas fare.

>rekt by pirate radio
>>
>>47914006
Oh no! My pathetic slave-stock might get superior Germanic blood intermingled with it!
>>
>>47912226
Japan is a tiny island who rarely had invaders, they mostly just killed each other it seems
>>
>>47916779

Actually, the Mamluks did win against the mongols.
>>
>>47916040
>>47916078

>Pope says that we need to holy war with those wealthy Arabs in their fertile crescent
DEUS VULT!

>Pope wants to outlaw superior military technology I can use on wealthy Arabs and king Fuckface from the next nation over
I'm not doing what some filthy fucking Spaniard says.
>>
>>47917011
They do seem to enjoy pissing off all their neighbours with invasions and warcrimes that even the Vikings would view as shameful.
>>
File: 1445205392830.jpg (18 KB, 224x225) Image search: [Google]
1445205392830.jpg
18 KB, 224x225
>>47912226
The Crusader Orders were the ALLIES of the Mongols and Hungary stopped the Mongol invasion cold. I also haven't a fucking clue where the peasant bait is from, because peasant rebellions got crushed.

You aren't the kind of retard that actually thinks the English army at Crecy or Agincourt were peasants, are you?
>>
File: 1463366279046.jpg (95 KB, 680x989) Image search: [Google]
1463366279046.jpg
95 KB, 680x989
>>47912226
>>
>>47912257

also

>rekt by peasants with rifles
>rekt by their own government for seeing them as obsolete
>rekt by their own ego just like every class based system
>>
>>47913707

unless you are a merchant/warrior

if there is war you turn into a warrior with the shiniest armor you could buy

if there is peace, you are a badass mafia like business man

but I doubt there was something like that IRL. Most merchants don't like to fight battles and training a competent fighter takes time
>>
>>47916779


FUCK YEAH MONGOLS!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=el93MIxAf-c

jokes aside, the problem with Mongols was themselves. Civil wars and fight for power destroyed the Hordes and divided the Empire.

about the Mongol conquest of EAST EUROPE check Tsubutai article in wikipedia.
>>
the game is good and the trailer is hilarious (but not so accurate):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uj3-VkbRSKQ
>>
>>47912226
>Rekt by Mongols
The Mongols were cucks. They couldn't even take Hungary. Hungary was the baby back bitch of Europe, during the Mongol invasion most of their forts were made out of dirt.

These inbred retards managed to beat up the least developed parts of Europe, but NOT EVEN CONQUER THEM, and then acted like they were tough while getting shitstomped by dune coons in Egypt. The last Mongol King was dragged out of his house crying like a bitch and shot in the mouth by Russians. They raped his wives and then threw his kids off of cliffs for fun. No consequences were suffered--because they did nothing wrong.

Mongols are faggots. I'm so glad the Chinese ethnically cleansed them. Every one of those babies who were thrown into ditches and buried alive deserved to die. No Mongol has ever deserved anything except to have his belly slit open and live rats stuffed into his chest cavity.
>>
>>47912442
Not some brain in a floating robot, that's for sure
>>
>>47917520
Are you okay, Anon? You sound angry.
>>
>>47917520

Muslims, please leave
>>
>>47917164
>peasant rebellions got crushed
Jan Zizka wants a word with you.
>>
>>47917520
Tell that to the Song Dynasty.
>>
>>47912226
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WiPyapp1xlc
>>
>>47912226
Vikings are total faggots. They're basically thieves and bandits. In my country they were punished the same way, it wasn't until like the 1980s that we realized that a bunch of pirates the Genoese cut the hands off of and tortured to death in the 11th century were actually Swedes.

Tough luck, faggots. Maybe stay in your shitty frozen piss receptacle and leave real civilizations alone.
>>
>>47917520
So your either a
>Angry Muslim that blames Mongols and Western society for all your problems.
>Angry Chinese/Chineseboo that blames Mongols for all of China's problems.
>You hate nomadic tribes and find the Mongols meme-tier and because this is the internet, you can say whatever you want without consequence.
>>
>>47916909
>Cuba and Venezuela
>strongarm juntas
They aren't even those things you nigger. I get that you're conditioned to hate communism but for fucks sake use the actual terminology. Strongman and junta aren't universal terms for things I don't like.
>>
File: 1460268816362.png (252 KB, 500x453) Image search: [Google]
1460268816362.png
252 KB, 500x453
>>47917644
You mean the rebellion led by a fucking nobleman with an army that wasn't made up of peasants?
>>
File: 3v9bENX.gif (2 MB, 352x217) Image search: [Google]
3v9bENX.gif
2 MB, 352x217
>>47913188
>Successful business and economy is always more important for a thriving culture than having a class of special snowflake warriors.

Remember how the Jews constantly managed to repulse and repel invaders for their entire history with their incredible economic status and wealth?

Oh wait, that didn't happen. They routinely got their shit kicked in by "Army of the Month" because Jerusalem is kind of important, and therefore worth owning.
>>
>>47917462
Their mistake was turning away from sky-worship. The moment they started embracing other faiths and not conquering everything that could be burned/trampled, they were lost.
>>
>>47912784
The Normans were Norman. You'd have to be retarded to think they were French.
>>
>>47918292
Jerusalem was worth notthing. Salahadin wanted it because it was iconic. Richard wanted it back because of christian butthurt.
Millions have died for a useless chunk of land jews can't let go off.
>>
Every country on earth has been rekt by someone at least once except Australia, Canada and New Zealand so who cares.
>>
>>47921050
>Worth nothing
>Everyone wants it
choose one
It was the worthiest city in history faggot
>>
>>47921150
>Australia
>Emu War
>Not getting reked
Try harder
>>
>>47921150
And Serbia
>>
>>47921362
You laugh at the Emu war, but there were no human casualties and over 2500 Emu killed.
>>
>>47917380
The Vikings.
>>
>>47918292
The Jews couldn't stand against superior merchant cultures the likes of the Roman Empire, the expanding Muslims and the terrifying Britains.
>>
>>47912226
Samurai:
>Got rekt by Mongols, who got rekt by a fucking storm
>got rekt by Korean Navy
>got rekt by China
>got rekt by western powers
>got rekt by their own Emperor

Truly amazing.
>>
>>47922700
>Jews
>not the best traders of Rome

Anon your knowledge of history is lacking.
>>
>>47922465
Serbia got rekt hard by the Osmans.
And by each other.
And by the NATO.
And by the third Reich.
>>
>>47917164
Remember, when the Hungarians stopped the mongol invasion so hard, the Hungarian king had to flee on a boat, because that was the only way the mongols wouldn't hunt him down?

>>47917520
The mongols in general didn't want to conquer lands other than massive steppes, they'd rather just sack them and return next year for more of the same.
Also cry some more, faggot.

t. a Hungarian
>>
>>47922776
Only after they became part of the Roman Empire, you silly goose.
>>
>>47922799
They were amazing traders down to the babylonian empire.
Stayed that for the Persians, who they were fanboys for. Old testament trying to make Salomon into a mini-Cyrus is hilarious.
Also great traders under the diadochi.
>>
>>47924175
Well, the Jews are still around today. Unlike those three Roman Empires.
>>
>>47912508
>win by a milestone

So they win by the breadth of a stone of variant size, though usually smaller than a man, used to convey the distance to a particular place?

That doesn't sound very impressive anon.
>>
OP confirmed for not knowing the first thing about history. Kill yourself faggot.
>>
Because whenever they're included people get called weebs?
>>
>>47924886
Fucking this. I hate how Japan, Japanese culture/history, or really anything relating to anything Japanese is instantly dismissed as being "weeb". It's such a meme and I hate it.
>>
>>47917733
> Real Country

> Italy

Pick one, most of the time your were vassal states or . . . Well I guess there was Mussolini. Y'all lost to Ethiopia so hard it knocked you the fuck out of the colonisation game. At least the French have the decency to surrender, Italy just "fights" for every side while jerking itself off about "Muh Rome" which was honestly shit until the Greeks got involved and quickly pretended to be everything the Greeks were afterwards before getting cucked by a carpenter.

> Genoa

Even Italians think that part is shit. I'm surprised you stopped suckling your uncles cock for bread long enough to post.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mh5LY4Mz15o
This video is related to the thread.
>>
>>47917164
Don't forget for most of the incursion into the middle east and Europe the Mongolians were suffering from black death.
>>
>>47912226
The samurai were so badass that they got btfo by their own culture because they were too old.
Also Katanas were the ultimate honor weapon, made to quickly cut down unarmored targets like farmers and merchants.
>>
>>47925000
I don't mind Japan/eastern flavoured stuff. But the players who want to make a samurai-themed martial character always, without fail, have gone way overboard: Writing down Japanese phrases to stammer out, you know, so that nobody at the table can understand him; chastising other players for not using honourifics, which he applies inconsistently himself; trying to make everything into a soo-goy adventure, asking where the "oni" lives, never shutting up about his "shisho", never shutting up about his quest "to find mazamunay"; harassing female players/characters like in some bad romcom slice of life anime; and never explaining anything helpful about his character, always deflecting by explaining "well you see, in Japan..."

Japanese characters are fine. Japanese monsters are fine. Clogging up my game with weeb shit is not fine. I'm trying to run a game here. I don't speak Japanese--translate those fucking words. I don't know what a shisho is, I don't know what a senpie is, I sure as hell don't know what a mazamuney is, and looking this shit up takes way too long when I can't spell any of it. Don't give me the history of Bushido, tell me what a fucking shisho is. Don't hit on Sarah, she's obviously uncomfortable. Don't bother other players to be more Japanese either. This happens every damn time and I'm sick of it.
>>
>>47925640
Suprise: autists are retarded and ruin games.

This doesn't mean anime or Japanese things are bad though. Some help though.
>shisho
Another word for "master" or "trainer". Samurai usually had a sensei though, not a shisho.
>oni
A type of Japanese demon (yokai). Usually depicted as a troll so I treat them as such.
>senpie
No way you don't know what the real version of this is but I'll tell you just in case. A "superior" basically someone who is above you in terms of social or cultural ranking.

Granted. I run my "weeb" campaigns with my friends who are all Japanese majors so it works out fine for me. Just hate all this Japan hate that comes from /tg/ and in general from the internet.
>>
>>47925851
>Japanese majors
Are you Japanese? My college in Burgerland is crazy expansive, but even then, languages other than English are a minor at best.
>>
>>47926100
I'm a quarter Japanese but I've been into Japanese stuff since middle school. I'm currently in college right now and I'm double majoring in Japanese and Creative Writing
>>
>>47925851
It's a counterculture backlash from the anime boom in the late 90's and early 2000's. Also mindless katana worship.
>>
>>47926724
Katanas are unironically beautiful to look at though.
>>
>>47927047
I'll say it, considering what the Japanese had to work with, it's a good sword.

It's the same line of reasoning I use to defend the 2011 The Thing.
>>
>>47922790
I'm talking about the second war when Bela IV built over five hundred stone castles in a decade or so like he was fucking Rogal Dorn.
>>
>>47927047
WEEB

GET OUT OF MY BOARD

REEEEEEE

Nah, they look nice.
>>
>>47927047
Oh yeah, they are very slick looking without appearing flimsy or short.
>>
>>47927089
You cannot justify that movie's existence, it should have been aborted, its only legacy is that I now have to specify which "The Thing" I am talking about whenever I say I like it.
>>
>>47922539
That's because the Emu's threatened to bring in the wombats into the conflict.
>>
>>47927644
The only legitimately bad part of that movie is the climax on the alien ship.

It had a comparable budget to Carpenter's The Thing, while having to deal with modern realities of movie making (like not having a genius like Bottin work on it). The movie did well with that the crew and actors had to work with. And it's not like the people involved could afford to alienate the studio, as you need to remember that The Thing's(1982) failure practically killed Carpenter's studio career.

The movie was mediocre at worst, and I will defend it to the death.
>>
>>47927709
>Mediocre at worst

What is worse than being mediocre?

Besides, the original was a genuinely well made movie and is considered to be one of the best horror films ever, it was just muscled out of a better release by Bladerunner and ET. The new one traded atmosphere and paranoia and those bitching practical effects for SPOOPY ALIEN JUMPSCARE CGI.
>>
>>47913005
Actually both were wiped out by a freak storm. The second on the anniversary of the first attack.
It's where the Japan's idea of a divine wind comes from.
>>
>>47927810
>What is worse than being mediocre?
>of only moderate quality; not very good.

Trust me, there is a lot worse than that if you've seen hundreds of horror films that are total duds.

>the new one traded atmosphere and paranoia and those bitching practical effects

Bullshit, the 2011 version still had those. Nowhere near as strong as the '82, but it's still there. For example, I would argue that the divide of people who could speak the language of the crazy swedes and those who couldn't added to the sense of division and mistrust. That was done very well in my opinion.

>bitching practical effects for SPOOPY ALIEN JUMPSCARE CGI
>muh practical effects

Even John Carpenter says he would've used CGI if it was available for him. The practical effects of the The Thing were good, but remember it put Rob Bottin in a hospital. And also practical effects have limitations to them, which is why the Blair-Thing was such a dud in the climax of the '82 The Thing. The Thing 2011 didn't have a geniuses like Bottin or Carpenter working on it, despite having a comparable budget (adjusted for inflation). But that doesn't mean Matthijs van Heijningen Jr. is a bad director. With what they were given to work with, the 2011 The Thing was fine in my opinion aside from a few things.

And practical effects aren't an inherent indicator of quality, look at Harbinger Down. And it's also worth noting that John Carpenter's The Thing was not well received at all either when it came out, and not just financially. Sci-fi fans were shitting all over Carpenter for desecrating what they viewed as a classic 1950s sci-fi horror movie.

"I take every failure hard. The one I took the hardest was The Thing. My career would have been different if that had been a big hit...The movie was hated. Even by science-fiction fans. They thought that I had betrayed some kind of trust, and the piling on was insane. Even the original movie's director, Christian Nyby, was dissing me." - John Carpenter
>>
>>47928078
*hundreds of horror movies, among which are total duds

Sorry needed to correct that.

But to finish off, am I saying 2011 The Thing is Carpenter's The Thing tier? No I'm not. The Thing set a very high standard, but that doesn't mean 2011 The Thing is bad because it couldn't reach that standard.
>>
>>47912254
My friend made a character for GURPS who was a were-apache, a native American man who transformed into a helicopter on a full moon. His name was Black-Hawk-Down.
>>
File: 1465413308043.jpg (648 KB, 819x1157) Image search: [Google]
1465413308043.jpg
648 KB, 819x1157
>>47912226
>vikings
>got together to harass and conquer the shit of out of Anglo-Saxon England before in turn getting rekt by Normans
>Samurai
>Couldn't hold Korea for hardly any length of time
>spent the majority of the time fighting each other and playing sudoku
Get out weeb.
>>
>>47912226
Everybody forgets about the Ghulams
>>
>>47928107
If this is going to be a John Carpenter discussion then what really killed his career was Big Trouble in Little China, he had hits after The Thing and was still a respected name in the industry until Big Trouble. (And has now regained his reputation especially due to the reevaluation of The Thing as the masterpiece it is)

I never said practical effects are inherently better, but Bottin's work on The Thing was godlike and the new monster cgi looked like first gen ps3 shit. I understand that the new one was made on practically the same budget but that just goes to show how instrumental Carpenter was to making the whole thing work. The movie never should have been made, it should have been an original movie inspired by John's, not a pre-sequel. Would it have been any better? I honestly don't know, but it would have been far better received than how it was, a near insult to a horror classic. But it was made during the height of the sequel craze where only sequels would get funding. However, you cannot tell me with a straight face that the movie was not a failure.

It really seems like you're just trying to be contrarian to be contrarian. The whole conversation has just been you making excuses as to why it didn't work and attacking the original for no reason.
>>
>>47927810
>What is worse than being mediocre?

The Highlander 2 comes to mind. It was a pretty mediocre movie with a lore raping plot. Then several years later they made Highlander The Source, which is actually a worse movie. It's somehow even more offensive on the lore raping part and it's not even fun to watch as a bad movie. It was so bad that people looked back fondly on the big whoops that was Highlander 2.

Being mediocre isn't that bad when put into the right perspective.
>>
>>47928446
Speak for yourself, The Source is one of my favorite joke movies, especially as someone who really liked the series.
>>
>>47928284
>It really seems like you're just trying to be contrarian to be contrarian.

No I'm not, I legitimately enjoy the movie and think the dislike for it is blowing minor issues out of proportion. It's disingenuous to dismiss my arguments as being as being hipsterish when I went through the trouble of explaining what I thought the movie did right.

> attacking the original for no reason
Except I never did attack Carpenter's version. I still think it's a masterpiece.

>The movie never should have been made
Why shouldn't have been made? By that line of reasoning, why did Carpenter had to re-make a classic sci-fi movie adaptation of a short story published in the 30s?

>But it was made during the height of the sequel craze where only sequels would get funding. However, you cannot tell me with a straight face that the movie was not a failure.

The 80s were also a sequel craze. Look how many Nightmare on Elm Street and Friday the 13 movies there were. And in 2011, for non-sequels you had the Fright Night (remake though, but still good), Apollo 18 (not good, but I liked the concept enough), Grave Encounters, Absentia (very good), and Attack the Block. To say that the only horror movies that came out were "sequels/prequels" is just ignorant.

>However, you cannot tell me with a straight face that the movie was not a failure.

Except it was. It was a financial failure when it came out (it only actually recouped its budget in 2011), it was a critical failure when it came out, and according to Carpenter himself, sci-fi fans hated it when it first came out. The movie didn't find success until after it's theatrical run.
>>
>>47928475
I like Highlander 2 better as the joke movie.
>>
>>47918292
The only time Jerusalem was important was a brief period it was an important hub in the olive oil trade. This was back when the Assyrians were a big thing mind you.
>>
File: ASHIGARU GOZAIMASU.png (116 KB, 189x349) Image search: [Google]
ASHIGARU GOZAIMASU.png
116 KB, 189x349
>>47913685
ASHIGARU GOZAIMASU!
>>
>>47912226
Samurai are fucking lame, desu. So are people who play them.

The best way to play a samurai is not as an amazing warrior but as a barely competent, womanizing joker who's in it for the money. And as a ronin, since working for lords is fucking lame.

Samurai are jokes and should only be played as such.
>>
>>47933344
You are an undeniable faggot.
>>
>>47933359
Okay.
>>
>>47933382
>y-you too...
kek
>>
>>47933344
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ay9ZxsulN2c
>>
>>47934159
holy shit so this is the origin of the shameful display.

this is comedy fucking gold

I guess I will have to buy this memegame and all its DLC.

brb unzipping my wallet.
>>
>>47934212
No it's not and you are a retard for thinking it is.
>>
>>47934261
He is right, you know.
>>
>>47934383
No he literally isn't. Shameful display has been a meme way before Shogun 2
>>
>>47934424
No retard, it started when the game came out, go to /v/ and ask them if you are too retarded to use your own brain.
>>
>>47912226

Your samurai can only look at his weird curved dick.
>>
>>47917520
Go to bed, /pol/.
Thread replies: 157
Thread images: 22

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.