Second Thread here Guys, here's the last one:
>>65481604
Rules:
Every "Top 100" list I've come across has been really bad and not nearly as inclusive as it should be, so, how about we make one?
The rules are as follows:
Rule 1) Name a song that you think deserves to be in a list of greatest songs ever.
Rule 2) If you see a song that you agree to be in the Top 100, reply to it with a "1", to confirm your vote for it.
Rule 3) Songs without any replies are a 0 and will not be included in the list, songs with 1 reply have 1 vote, 2 / 2, 3 / 3 and so on.
Rule 4) If a comment includes more than one some, reply to that comment with a 1 and the song that you think deserves to be on the list.
Rule 5) I will be taking the first thousand songs with either 1 vote or more, then I will hold a poll to slim the list down until we eventually get the top 100.
So, /mu/, what is the greatest song of all time?
Animal Collective - Alvin Row
My Bloody Valentine- When You Sleep
>>65486810
1
All Delighted People by Sufjan Stevens
Nick Drake - From the Morning
God only knows - Beach Boys
King Crimson - Exiles
Neutral Milk Hotel - Holland, 1945
>>65486893
>>65486810
1
Joy Division - She's Lost Control
The Beatles - Eleanor Rigby
Madvillian - Accordion
>>65486804
Ultralight Beam by Kanye West
>>65486804
Pink Floyd - Shine on you Crazy Diamond
>>65486804
Kayo Dot - The Manifold Curiosity
Animal Collective -- Penny Dreadfuls
Stop Smoking - Car Seat Headrest
>>65486893
>>65486895
>>65486936
>>65486945
>>65486948
Since I Left You - The Avalanches
>>65487002
1 obvs
New Order – Ceremony
https://youtu.be/9pr6SxJb-Dw
Modest Mouse - Dramamine
>>65486948
1
Ween - Ocean Man
>>65486853
>>65486895
>>65486945
>>65486948
1
Black Tambourine - Throw Aggi Off The Bridge
>>65486804
Just to make it clear - we don't re-'1' songs that we already voted for in the first thread, do we?
>>65486853
>>65486893
>>65486895
>>65486936
>>65486948
>>65487041
>>65487057
>>65487068
1
Red House Painters - Katy Song
maudlin of the Well - Birth Pains Of Astral Projection
>>65486988
1
>>65487074
Also, should we repost songs we posted in the last thread?
>>65486804
Neutral Milk Hotel - Oh Comely
>>65486810
>>65486865
>>65486895
>>65487002
>>65487041
yo, these were in the last thread and got votes so we don't need to relist them i don't think
>>65487076
>>65487057
>>65486996
>>65486973
>>65486948
>>65486936
1
Higgs Boson Blues - Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
>>65487068
1
Bjork - Unravel
Red House Painters - Medicine Bottle
>>65487098
To that I would guess yes, since posting the song doesn't count as a vote, and so that new people can vote for songs in the old thread.
David Bowie - station to station
>>65486948
>>65486936
>>65486990
>>65487027 (>tfw Ian vocals never)
>>65487102
>>65487125
1
The Gun Club - For the Love of Ivy
Once in a Lifetime - Talking Heads
Kanske Är Jag Kär I Dig by Jens Lekman
>>65487131
Only one vote is necessary to get it into the running as long as its before the 1000 cut. repost songs that didnt get any votes, but there is literally no point to reposting, say, Oh Comely. it got a ton of votes in the last thread.
Pixies - Where is my mind
I enter:
Aphex Twin - Rhubarb
Angelo Badalamenti - Laura Palmer's Theme
A Silver Mt. Zion - Could've Moved Mountains
Duster - The Landing
The Microphones - I Want Wind to Blow
Slint - Washer
>>65487076
1
>>65487074
Not OP but I we shouldn't re-1 songs we already voted for in a previous thread. Obviously nobody can control whether all the votes for a song are from different people, but we should just think of it as a moral obligation.
>>65487195
>>65486990
1
Death Grips - Up My Sleeves
>>65487202
yeesh
well i'll 1 i want wind to blow
>>65487107
1
Microphones - I want wind to blow
(I know some anon already posted this grouped in with a bunch of other songs, but I'm posting it separately)
>>65486895
1
LIL UGLY MANE - Uneven Compromise
>>65487202
1, The Landing
>>65487041
>>65487002
>>65486965
1
Hmm..
Aesop Rock - Gopher Guts
>>65486804
Talking Heads - The Great Curve
>>65487202
1 for I Want Wind to Blow
pyramids - frank ocean
>>65487202
voting 4 Microphones
>>65487195
1
Neutral Milk Hotel - Naomi
rule 3 makes this unnecessarily complicated. lets not worry about vote count and just gather submissions now, then vote when they've all been assembled
Death Grips - Guillotine
Television - Marquee Moon
>>65486853
>>65486895
>>65486945
>>65486948
>>65487068
>>65487134
>>65487190
>>65487195
1
>>65487202
1ing Rhubarb, The Landing, I Want Wind to Blow, and Washer
>>65487027
>>65487076
>>65487125
>>65487202 (laura palmers theme)
1
Lua - Bright Eyes
>>65487345
I agree .Counting how many (you)'s each song gets in these threads silly and biases things too heavily towards songs posted earlier in threads.
>>65487345
yup, and we should limit to one song per post
>>65486895
>>65486945
>>65487068
>>65487076
>>65487134
>>65487202
Washer
>>65487359
1
>Billie Jean - Michael Jackson
Heroin - The Velvet Underground
Nirvana - All Apologies
>>65487322
>>65487359
1
Fugazi - Turnover
IN THE FLOWERS!
>>65486895
1
>>65486948
1
>>65487202
Washer 1
Swans - Oxygen
AnCo Brother Sport
Sonic Youth - Teen Age Riot
Slint - Good Morning Captain
>>65487202
1 for Washer and I want wind to blow
>>65487409
1
>>65487369
wait wait
Lua - Bright eyes or Lua - Conor Oberst & Gillian Welch? I like the latter a little better.
1 either way but yeah
>>65487345
agreed
>>65487107
>>65487076
>>65487057
>>65486996
1
Sodom, South Georgia - Iron & Wine
>>65487565
>>65487300
1
john coltrane & johnny hartman - lush life
kanye west - runaway
Stand by me, ben e king
>>65486853
1
>>65486936
1
>>65487202
1, Washer
>>65487472
1
>>65487516
1
>>65487565
1
Sister Ray by the Velvet Underground.
Reoccurring Dreams by Husker Du
>>65487660
>>65487359
>>65487296
>>65487202
>>65487195
>>65487076
>>65487068
1
Of Montreal - The Past Is A Grotesque Animal
Joanna Newsom - Only Skin
>>65487704
1
>>65487726
1
Fritter by Mercury Rev.
>>65487727
1
Gone by Kanye West
Stressed out by 21 Pilots
Toto - Africa
Skream, Summer Dreams
brian eno third uncle
>>65487897
1
Everything else is shite
Opeth - Blackwater Park (song)
Limousine by Brand New
>>65487565
>>65487598
>>65487660
>>65487704
>>65487763
1
found the right answer for #1 overall
>The Beach Boys - I Get Around
>>65488050
That's a funny way to spell Stressed Out by Twenty One Pilots
>>65487193
What's the point of voting in the first place then? If every song listed only needs one vote to make it into the top 1000 and every vote after is redundant... makes this much less fun if only the poll at the end matters.
>>65488037
0
As in no
As in fuck off
As in not even top 10 Brand New songs
As in leave
>>65488110
cuz there's no way to make it remotely fair otherwise
The Trapeze Swinger - Iron & Wine
>>65488110
No, idiot. Once we reach 1,000, then votes start counting. To be considered, all that is needed is 1 vote.
>>65488141
Am I missing something.. how to the votes make it more fair?
>>65488183
if votes count now then songs mentioned at the beginning of the thread will be automatically more popular. scroll up.
>>65488163
Are you saying that we start voting after we reach 1000, or that votes are retroactively counted after we reach 1000? Assuming the second one, why wouldn't we continue voting for songs posted in the OG thread if they do matter. And if votes don't matter, why vote in the first place?
>>65488228
Agreed... so what's with the 1's in the first place. Anyway sorry for picking the concept apart just bugged me.
Van Morrison - Madame George
>>65488246
>>65488287
Songs need at least one vote to be counted in the 1000 songs that will be voted on. I agree it's kind of dumb but it's probably the best way to do it
Have a Nice Life - Bloodhail
>>65488337
Fair enough :):
Pink Floyd - Dogs
>>65487057
TAKE ME BY THE HAND
>>65488436
all pink floyd song minus the endless river belong in the top 100
Boris - Flood
It's one big song :)
Radiohead - Fake Plastic Trees
Sigur Rós - Ágætis byrjun
Death Grips - Beware
Add it Up-Violent Femmes
NINA SIMONE - SINNERMAN
>>65488436
>>65487660
>>65487608
>>65487565
>>65487546
>>65487472
>>65487359
>>65487195
>>65487190
>>65487057
>>65486983
>>65486948
>>65486945
>>65486895
>>65486853
1 to all of these
Death Grips - Hacker
>>65486895
>>65486936
>>65486948
>>65486983
>>65487102
>>65487296
>>65487565
>>65487546
1
Fleet Foxes - Helplessness Blues
Big Star - Thirteen
Big Star - I'm In Love With a Girl
Godspeed You! Black Emperor - Sleep
>>65486810
>>65486895
>>65487041
>>65487102
>>65487565
>>65487540
>>65487704
all 1
Yes - Close To The Edge
Twerk by Yung Cheezy
>>65486804
young thug - best friend
>>65488887
>>65488523
>>65488556
>>65486936
>>65487120
>>65487041
>>65488776
1
Strangers - Portishead
Motion Picture Soundtrack - Radiohead
Psyke - Massive Attack
Say it aint so - Weezer
The Good Life - Weezer
Mathematics - Mos Def
Royals - Lorde
Honestly? - American Football
Girl/Boy Song - Aphex Twin
Islands - The XX
Who the fucks are arctic monkeys? - Arctic Monkeys
Tigerlily - La Roux
Midnight City - M83
Spaceship - Kanye West
Doomsday - MF DOOM
>>65486810
>>65486853
>>65486945
>>65486965
>>65487002
>>65487190
>>65487359
>>65487546
>>65488296
big up senpai
The Smiths - How Soon Is Now
Marvin Gaye - What's going on
Pixies - Gigantic
Unrest - Suki
Big Star - Thirteen
Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds - The Weeping Song
Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band - Kany Korn
Amon Tobin - In My Garden
The Beta Band - Inner Meet Me
Big Black - Kerosene
Bob Dylan - Sad-Eyed Lady of the Lowlands
Bran Van 3000 - Drinking In L.A.
Brian Eno - Backwater
Neu - Negativland
Stereolab - Jenny Ondioline
Dead Kennedys - California Uber Alles
this is really hard and we should make it more than 100 but more like 500, akin to rolling stones list or whatever
>>65488957
awful taste, only good one is Portishead. Please leave and go back to llleeeddit & pitchfork.
Peter Sotos - Children
Peter Sotos - McMartin
Peter Sotos - Trash
Peter Sotos - Bundy
Peter Sotos - Victims
Whitehouse - Bird Seed
Whitehouse - Public
Whitehouse - Private
>>65489076
Hi Summer!
>>65489059
or maybe like 10 best song of each year, then 100 best songs of each decade and overall 500 best songs of all-time idk just an idea
>>65489103
quite the opposite if you think i like generic pitchfork music lol. pretty ironic as you are the newfag with entry level mucore taste. please leave
>>65489086
epic
Mr Bungle - Carry Stress In The Jaw
>>65486983
>>65487002
>>65487102
>>65487190
>>65487350
>>65487543
>>65488436
>>65488887
1
>>65488957 (motion picture soundtrack, girl/boy song, and midnight city)
Kate Bush - Night of the Swallow
Frank Sinatra - In the Wee Small Hours of the Morning
>>65489076
>Radiohead
>Aphex Twin
>American Football
>Kanye
>Weezer
>Bad
>>65489196
lmao, yep. fuck off summer fag
here is a better list
>Robert Wyatt
>Autechre
>Unwound
>Dalek
>Jellyfish
swans - failure
>>65487763
1
Led Zeppelin - Stairway To Heaven
>>65489086
1
all of them
>>65489249
>Oh no, you like popular music, that obviously 100% means you're new to the board!
Fuck off
>>65489293
dumb ass, all the artists i mentioned are popular as fuck you just happen to have shit taste. fuck off
>>65486936
>>65486983
>>65487057
>>65487068
>>65487190
>>65487359
>>65487546
>>65488436
>>65488500 (if you'll count it. guessing no)
1
The Olivia Tremor Control - I Have Been Floated
>>65486945
>>65486973
>>65487002
>>65487190
>>65487322
>>65487619
>>65488812
>>65489059
>1 for Kerosene
>1 for Negativland
Kendrick Lamar - m.A.A.d City
animal collective - my girls
animal collective - daily routine
animal collective - for reverend green
animal collective - fireworks
animal collective - #1
animal collective - today's supernatural
animal collective - applesauce
animal collective - wide eyed
animal collective - mercury man
animal collective - amanita
animal collective - floridada
animal collective - vertical
animal collective - lying in the grass
animal collective - the burglars
animal collective - on delay
animal collective - did you see the words
animal collective - the purple bottle
animal collective - bees
animal collective - loch raven
>>65489267
It makes me wonder how /mu/ has to be so contrarian to not acknowledge this song so far into the thread.
This is by no doubt one of the top 10 songs of music history, even though it's acknowledged as so by the mainstream.
>>65489346
honestly I missed it
>>65489304
I'm not the anon you were calling a summerfag, and I'm saying you calling him out for being a summerfag just because his music taste is popular is fucking dumb.
New Order - Bizarre Love Triangle
>>65487472
>>65487543
>>65487619
>>65487828
>>65488663 (how the fuck does this have 0?)
>>65488817
>>65488887
>>65489346
Maybe, just maybe, they don't like the song?
>>65489326
fucking shit, put a one after all those votes
>>65489346
Exactly what I was thinking&why I suggested it.
>>65489346
the only good led zeppelin song is whole lotta love. stairway to heaven is boring.
Galaxie 500 - On Fire
The Feelies - Loveless Love
My Bloody Valentine - Sometimes
Slowdive - Dagger
The Soft Boys - Underwater Moonlight
Anyone have any idea what #of songs we're at with >0 votes? would guess 100-150?
>>65489473
*meant to say Strange instead of On Fire
Madvillain - Figaro
The Undertones - Teenage Kicks
>>65488436
1
Radiohead - Let Down
>>65489129
1
Mr Bungle - Pink Cigarette
Frank Zappa - Peaches En Regalia
The mothers of invention - Brown Shoes Don't Make It
Candlemass - Solitude
Mars Volta - Meccamputecture
Feotus - Di-1-9026
Lemon Devon - Touch Tone Telephone
>>65486804
CHICANE - SALTWATER
>>65486804
Burial - Archangel
>>65487125
>>65487190
>>65487068
>>65489597
Foetus - DI 9026
1
Pain Teens - RU 486
Wilco - Poor Places
The Moody Blues - Nights In White Satin
The Flaming Lips - Race For the Prize
this thread is so retarded
>>65488436
>>65488767
voting though
Have a Nice Life - Earthmover
This again, oh god you are fucking retarded. I am not even going to post the pasta about how stupid a top X is for /mu/ let alone talk about how stupid it is to nake a poll in an anonymous board
>>65489324
>>65488776
>>65489059
1 for Pixies
>>65488592
>>65488657
>>65488296
(you)
>>65489836
The point is that it's fun, anon:)
Fetchin Bones - Too Much
Unrest - She Makes Me Shake Like a Soul Machine
Bone Thugs N Harmony - Days of our lives
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7R_-icZpCTs
I Felt My Size by The Microphones
>>65489637
>>65489772
>>65489334 (For Reverend Green)
>>65489324
>>65489054
>>65488957 (Spaceship and Doomsday)
1
>>65489326
>>65489267
1
aphex twin - finger bib
the avalanches - frontier psychiatrist
broads of canada - telephasic workshop
daft punk - one more time
daft punk - around the world
daft punk - robot rock
daft punk - technologic
death grips - takyon
death grips - I want it I need it
death grips - on gp
drake - hotline bling
flying lotus - never catch me
gy!be - storm
gy!be - dead flag blues
gy!be - mladic
gorillaz - empire ants
gorillaz - on melancholy hill
grimes - california
grimes - flesh without blood
grimes - kill v maim
grimes - realiti
jamie xx - i know there's gonna be good times
kanye west - stronger
kanye west - flashing lights
kanye west - dark fantasy
kanye west - all of the lights
kanye west - monster
kanye west - blame game
kanye west - touch the sky
kanye west - gold digger
kanye west - diamonds from sierra leone
kanye west - through the wire
kendrick lamar - swimming pools
kendrick lamar - the blacker the berry
kurt vile - freak train
kurt vile - blackberry song
mgmt - siberian breaks
modest mouse - doin the cockroach
modest mouse - truckers atlas
pink floyd - have a cigar
tame impala - the less I know the better
sufjan stevens - come on! feel the illinoise!
sufjan stevens - chicago
sufjan stevens - they are night zombies!!
sufjan stevens - should have known better
swans - mother of the world
swans - the seer
swans - just a little boy
swans - bring the sun/toussaint l'ouverture
>>65487226
>>65487543
>>65489334 (Daily Routine and The Burglars)
1
Animal Collective - Winters Love
Bob Dylan - Hurricane
>>65490284
Whoops I forgot to give this a 1.
1.
>>65490259
>drake - hotline bling
>>65487226
1
underrated!
>>65490259
(Diamonds from Sierra Leone, Through the Wire, Trucker's Atlas and Should Have Known Better)
1
Cowboy Dan and Trailer Trash by Modest Mouse
Hey Ya! Outkast
PHOENIX - LISZTOMANIA
>>65490425
1111111111111111111111111
bbbbbboooootttttthhhhhhh
>>65486893
>>65486895
>>65486948
>>65487002
>>65487134
>>65487472
>>65487546
>>65487619
>>65488296
>>65486948
The Beach Boys - Surfs Up
Don Aman - Slint
>>65490433
We definitely need some Outkast but I don't think that's their best song. How about Elevators, B.O.B. or Aquemini?
>>65489473 (on fire)
>>65489772
>>65490259(should have known better)
>>65490291
1
Beach House - PPP
Robert Plant - Big Log
The Doors - The End
Dire Straits - Brothers In Arms
Candy Claws - White Seal
Bon Iver - For Emma
>>65490259
1 for Fingerbib, One More Time, on gp, never catch me, storm, dead flag blues, realiti, blame game, touch the sky, come on and feel the illinoise and chicago.
>>65487565
>>65488957
Say It Ain't So and Honestly?
>>65486895
>>65486936
1
Hum - I Hate It Too
Kendrick Lamar- Sing about Me/ Dying of Thirst
>>65489794
>>65489597
Brown shoes dont make it
>>65489136
>>65489054
>>65489005
>>65488887
>>65488817
>>65488701
>>65488663
>>65488657
>>65487763
>>65487704
>>65487660
>>65487619
>>65487546
>>65487472
>>65487359
>>65487190
>>65487002
>>65486895
>>65486893
>>65486853
>>65486810
1
Sufjan Stevens, Impossible Soul
>>65486810
>>65486865
>>65486895
>>65486936
>>65487002
>>65487057
>>65487102
>>65487134
>>65487190
>>65487195
>>65487322
>>65487359
>>65487472
>>65487543
>>65487546
>>65487565
>>65487763
>>65488436
>>65488701
>>65488523
>>65488767
>>65489637
1
>>65490259
1 for all the gy!be songs and all the sufjan songs
Boston - More than a Feeling
Long Season (98.12.28 version) by Fishmans
Day of the Baphomets - The Mars Volta
The Trees - Rush
The Mercy Seat - Nick Cave
Below the Salt - Unwound
>>65491234
>not Foreplay/Long Time
>>65489346
Pretentious wank for people who were born in le wrong generation. No one actually likes led Zepplin
>>65489528
damn fucking right you did. 1
>>65486810
>>65486853
>>65486895
>>65486936
>>65486945
>>65486948
>>65486965
>>65486983
>>65487002
>>65487057
>>65487102
>>65487125
>>65487134
>>65487190
>>65487195
>>65487322
>>65487350
>>65487359
>>65487472
>>65487543
>>65487546
>>65487565
>>65487660
>>65487799
>>65487921
>>65488436
>>65488523
>>65488767
>>65488812
>>65488817
>>65488887
>>65489136
>>65489568
>>65489585
>>65489772
>>65489794
1
Deep Purple - Hush
The Pecan Tree - Deafheaven
Bob Dylan- Like A Rolling Stone
>>65489249
>I'm going to post worse and less popular version of artists to get more contrarian points
I mean I like autechre but anyone who thinks Autechre are better then Aphex is clearly just doing it for attention
Also If I was a summerfag how would I listen to /mu/core so much?
Kanye West - Hey Mama
Atmosphere - Yesterday
>>65491375
1
1
1
1
1
1
Grateful Dead- Dark Star
