>'The Wall' isn't their best album
>>64366353
It's not. It's full of so much fucking filler that it kills the groove. Wish You Were Here is an absolute masterpiece that pulls on so many emotional heartstrings that you feel numb by the time it's over.
>>64366353
That is correct, it's not even close.
Obviously, that would be Piper my man
What OP said could be interpreted as.
>I haven't listened to the rest of their albums, at least not more than once or I didn't put enought attnention to them.
>>64366377
>Listening to a Rock Opera
>Claim it's full of filler
I don't think you know what a Rock Opera is.
>>64366389
>probably says that thinking WYWH or DSotM are any better
Sides 2 and 3 actually make a pretty decent cohesive album. There's some great stuff on there, but it's far from their best.
I've always preferred The Final Cut to be honest.
>>64366423
A BLOO BLOO BLOO
>>64366353
Really? Half the tracks could be removed without losing anything. Stop, outside the wall, vera, is there anybody out there, all just taking up space.
>>64366454
>I've always preferred The Final Cut to be honest.
Wow
>>64366467
which leaves the godawful Animals as your most probable favorite.
thanks for the reply btw, dickhead, enjoying it just like you asked me to.
>>64366353
>Not accepting DSOTM is their best just to be a contrarian.
Wish you were here is second best.
Animals a best
>>64366525
>which leaves the godawful Animals as your most probable favorite.
Nice b8 m8
>it's a watersfag thread
>>64366563
Rock Operas BY DEFINITION have music on it that do not belong.
It's a defining factor that separates it from just an Opera.
>>64366353
it is though
>>64366389
I hope you kill yourself
DSotM = Animals > WYWH > The Wall
>>64366563
>>64366377
>filler
Christ, you guys are unbearable
>>64366612
Well then rock operas by definition suck
>>64366632
Piper > DSotM = Animals > WYWH > The Wall
>>64366605
>It's a "lsd user sings about a bike and mouse so it's better than songs about abandonment, abuse, and isolation" episode
>>64366666
confirmed
>>64366491
shut plebeian
>>64366666
Quints never lie.
>>64366666
QUINTS NEVER
EVER
LIE
ITS JUST A PASSING PHASE
>>64366592
i actually do happily admit i made that post just for the purpose of pissing proge off, but that doesn't change the sincerity of its content.
>>64366563
>Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh
>Opera
fuck off
It isn't though.
Animals > Wish You Were Here > Piper > The Wall
They're all 8 or 9/10 imo anyway
Wish You Were Here
>>64366895
Meddle is my favorite album by them, but I don't think it's their best.
>>64366895
Echoes doesn't save Meddle despite being one of their best songs. Not while Seamus still exists.
someone want to think about Ummaguma?
Pink Floyd is a low tier prog rock band
>>64366491
>>64366377
>>64366454
>>64366605
>>64366666
>>64369571
>being this pleb
>>64366423
wtf is a rock opera?
