ITT: opinions that will get you fucking killed on /mu/
- Home
- Board: /mu/ - Music
- Reading: ITT: opinions that will get you fucking killed on /mu/
music is good
any
60-year-old Italians should be forbidden from marrying adolescent girls.
post-nightcore has potential
>>63374292
There is literally no sacred ground on this site. Just fire away desu.
I don't think Momentary Lapse of Reason is irredeemable shit.
undertale was a pretty good game
Blur are cool, Weezer are fucking terrible, Animal Collective members should grow the fuck up, Montie has ok taste, Hampus needs to shitpost more, Abgin was awesome, Kendrick is just ok, Kanye is the most entertaining autist of our generation, The Beatles are great, etc.
radiohead is p good
loveless fucking sucks
>>63374395
>oasis
Memes are bad.
swans are overrated as shit I mean what the fuck I don't understand the hype at all, even after having listened their discography through
>>63374417
Oasis are a good pop band with an entire listenable album. That is more than enough for a radio-pop project.
I didnt like Animals
Spiderland fucking sucks
i enjoy muse
i enjoy radiohead to an extent
sun o isn't music
merzbow isn't music
>>63374444
ps check them
I like metal
>>63374341
not even an edgy opinion
>>63374423
>
woah, back off there
>>63374444
Checked
Based comment
jason aldean is unironically better than weed season
I'm tupac
>>63374341
But this is true. Who would go out of their way to contend this other than bitter vaporwave fans?
>>63374341
The only people who think otherwise are the ones who think it's funny to make meme music.
I have nothing against Reddit.
>>63374360
It's not the absolute butthole of music people make it out to be for sure. I'm pretty sure people hate the concept of it more than anything: the fact that Gilmour hired random people to write songs for them and they didn't really even try to come up with their own concepts. I don't think it's complete garbage but I can see both sides of the argument.
i came here from twitter
you people are horrible, lauren was right
The Killers is the best pop-rock band
Eurodance is amusing
Aaron is obnoxious faggot and makes shit memes
pink floyd sucks
Amlor is pink floyds best album info, though I enjoy all of their stuff.
>>63374523
Honestly if you stay off the default subs you can find really good discussion.
>>63374591
nigga, no
I think the album's decent, but thats just false
>>63374395
I agree with everything but
>blur are cool
>>63374465
This is true. Every time that album comes up I feel like the fucking kid in that one children's novel about the king who gets robes made by some bullshitter who says he uses a magic thread that only smart people can see or something. But he's not making anything at all and everyone pretends to be able to see the clothes because they don't want everyone else to think they're dumbasses. Then the king goes out naked like a fucktard and that one kid in the audience sees through all the bullshit and says he's naked.
It's like that. Just a bunch of fucktards pretending to like that stupid album so everyone else will think they're cool, and there's only a few people willing to say they see through the bullshit.
Blur was one of the best of the nineties, before they turned into Pavement-wannabe
Bernie is a senile old faggot and Trump is the best left of a bad bunch.
>>63374555
Gilmour didn't hire anybody to write songs on the album, they were just hired to play. It's basically a Gilmour solo album featuring Rick and Nick, similar to what the Final Cut was for Roger.
kpop should
>>63374515
>>63374516
back to your containment thread
>>63374292
Radiohead is just despicable
I don't get the appeal of Grimes
I like _____ because it sounds nice.
radiohead makes one whiny album after another
i'm white cis straight male
>>63374633
this analogy is actually pretty good, unless this is some copypasta and I'm being a newfag. but it's accurate anyway
Anything negative regarding pic related
>>63374465
This
>DON LAUGHED AS HE FELL DOWN THE STAIRS
>>63374516
I just re read this. And I would like to say I do not agree with this statement I would like the record to show that I do not support meme post night core bullshit. I made a type.
>>63374319
FUCK YOU, MUSIC SUCKS!
>>63374633
yeah there's always this kind of turd posturing with that tired "the king is naked" analogy, feeling so smug about not empathizing with someone that it's just groanworthy. i'm the only one here that actually THINKS, maaan, all around me are sheeple
I think grimes is the worst thing to happen to this board in years.
>>63374351
This
This thread would've been relevant five years ago but the plebs took over and scared all the elitism away so really no opinion is wrong here anymore.
>>63374591
I honestly can't understand this opinion. It's completely uninspired imo. What do you see in it?
>>63374813
>he hasn't heard any post-nightcore
>>63374898
I miss elite /mu/ but it's kinda nice to have real discussions about pop with people who understand music.
Muse is one of my favorite bands.
>>63374898
This new /mu is saturated with bullshit.
>>63374633
>WAKE UP SHEEPLE
*tips fedora*
>>63374781
R.I.P. Fandango
>>63374935
There was more discussion of music then then there is now. It's literally all dogshit now
>>63374633
Maybe other people just enjoy the album and you're too autistic to accept that people like something that you don't
i dont like opn at all
Memes have absolutely destroyed this place. You'll find some faggot posting obnd in almost any thread. They're ok when they're organic, but when they're so forced it's not funny and it's not clever
kanye is the best musician of the 21st century
>>63374999
yeah I agree. it's just memes and people like 'look at my taste" so they can get their daily (you)
>>63375075
this isn't a unpopular opinion
it may seem like it is now because of the influx of /v/ members but i think a lot of people know this
Michael Gira os not nearly as talented as some people believe.
Nirvanas In Utero is actually a very good album with material that challenges Pixies, Pavement and so on in quality.
My Bloody Valentine is slightly overrated. Loveless is great, however Kevin Shields was feeding off of late 80's bands and managed to hide it so well that plebs believes he created shoegaze.
Memes can be funny
Black metal is the greatest genre of music, and if you dont like it or dislike it, then you literally just don't understand it. I know it sounds corny but I mean literally f a m you just dont understand it
>>63375106
>obnd
I fucking hate that album so much it's so forced it's like the shrek meme but worst.
The worst part is when you watch people trying to force them.
The only decent meme's like that are ITAOTS
and MPP
decent doesn't mean funny either they just make me smile like an old friend.
>>63375212
>thinking Gira and mbv are overrrated
>thinks Nirvana isn't
literally l m a o i n g
Aaron needs to die
>>63375328
Nevermind is disturbingly overrated considering how shallow it is. In Utero isn't shallow at all. Please keep in mind that people instantly think of Nevermind when they think of Nirvana.
90% of the threads here are trash. I miss having full paragraph arguments about songs on albums. I think anyone who talks about EDM on this board should have their opinion disregard immediately.
If a thread beings with meme bullshit it should be 404'd if a thread is about a female musican and it get's derailed it should be 404'd.
I've had enough of the "ITT" threads with no discussion, and the "what does ___ listen to" threads.
>>63375414
Maybe outside of /mu/, sure
The Foo Fighters are a legitimately good band.
>>63374412
But it is, you fucker!
>>63374633
>using the emperor's new clothes argument
kill yourself
>>63374880
>>63374987
>>63375004
assblasted slint fans reporting in
>>63375617
Don't talk to me or my son ever again
>>63374611
This. Much of the non defaults are shit though too. LetsTalkMusic is fine I just wish they werent so strict about posts.
>>63374746
Fuck you!!! Fuck! YOU!
>he pronounces the O)))
>>63374765
Could you all stop this fucking radiohead hate?? Enough is enough!!!
They're among the greatest!
>>63375617
>go on a board where Slint is very acclaimed
>"lol Slint sucks if you like it you're an idiot, stop liking what I don't like!
>Slint fans reply
>"Oh, here comes the Slint defense force, why can't you guys handle different opinions?
Taylor Swift is good
>>63374633
"The Emperor's New Clothes"
>>63375714
tell me more
>>63375759
thanks thats what i was looking for
hip hop is bad and kanye west is shit
>>63374341
spoonfeed me some post-nightcore?
>>63375783
>thanks thats what i was looking for
I recognized it since it is a famous fairy tale here in Scandinavia.
Here it's called "Keiserens nye klær".
Your analogy is actually spot on to the moral of the story.
>>63374475
Sunn is music and that's not even what I would be if you were who you are
Blur > Oasis
>>63375904
That story is rightful danish clay, keep away
>>63377021
I know that. Relax man. I'm just saying it's famous all around Scandinavia. Not taking any credit dane-bro.
>>63375643
That's my only issue with Reddit
The retards over there love to self censor themselves.
I got banned from /r/NBA for saying nigga because it's "appropriating black culture."
I tried to explain to the mods that I can't do that since I'm black and got blocked.
>>63377217
>I got banned from /r/NBA for saying nigga because it's "appropriating black culture."
Good. I don't agree with the reason but there needs to be at least some places on the internet nowadays that ban wigger speak. More and more places on the internet are starting to look like r/hiphopheads.
>>63374292
This is my new favourite black twitter meme desu.
>>63374339
fucking lol
>>63374579
>The Killers is the best pop-rock band
you're not wrong, tho
>>63375934
this nigga looks wack as fuck
The Avalanches are boring and I do not care if they make another album
metallica is one of the best bands in metal, and have had a consistently stimulating career. st. anger is massively underrated.
I think ICP's first few albums are fantastic
Animal Collective peaked with Strawberry Jam. Their second best release is Danse Manatee. MPP is almost as bad as Painting with and CHz as a full LP. CHz has genius production that redeems it.
The greatest album of 1980 is not remain in light
it is Gary numan's telekon
>>63374663
>pro-Trump on 4chan
>trying to get 4Chan mad
Nigga no
Lulu was great. Junior Dad is Lou's best post VU song ever penned and contains his best vocal performance.
Queercore is a great genre.
This board is full of (but not made completely of) pretentious losers irl who want to feel special and don't enjoy the music they listen to.
>>63374292
Fall Out Boy is a great band, I agree with Lauren Mayberry, Indie Rock is still a good genre.
i can't stop listening to this
>>63378332
what's some good queercore?
Because The Internet was medicore
>>63378332
the only half decent queercore/riot grrl shit i've heard was team dresch and even then the production was awful
>>63378349
>Fall Out Boy is a great band
>is
>Implying their latest album wasn't pure shite
I love me some Fall Out Boy, but albums 1-5 only. I'll even tolerate Save Rock & Roll, but the latest is just....no
dubstep is great right guys?? skrillex is really good
>>63374898
>back when mu was good
>>63378494
Okay 1st off
>I'll tolerate Save Rock & Roll
No conscious human being should ever tolerate that trash and FOB should be ashamed to have there name attached to it
and 2nd
>their latest
They have another one? And it gets worse? You're not talking about that shitty "hardcore punk" EP are you?
This is arguably the greatest and most influential album in the history of music.
>>63378643
>They have another one? And it gets worse?
Look up American Beauty/American Psycho. They've gone completely pop. SR&R was the transitioning.
>You're not talking about that shitty "hardcore punk" EP are you?
That's PAX AM days and I haven't heard it
>>63378682
well go on, then, argue it
>>63378643
Oh god I just googled it and saw that godawful title and cover art. I'm done, not even giving it a curiosity listen. Fall Out Boy's last album was Folie a Deux and unfortunately the band died in a tragic plane crash shortly after
>>63378707
Okay, this is literally the greatest and most influential album in the history of music.
Painting With is AnCo's best album
>>63374633
Do you use this argument for every popular album you don't like?
>>63378738
that's not an argument, that's a statement
Pic related is entirely average
>>63378758
No, it is an argument, see we're arguing now.
>>63374896
THIIIIIIIS. THIS. THIS.
>>63378738
Counterpoint: You're gay
>>63378771
alright
please give me three reasons why you think that album is the greatest and most influential album in the history of music
>>63378686
Its so sad that they're willing to trash their name just to make minimal monetary returns. They clearly don't give a fuck about quality, their fans, or even their group dynamics as a band since I'm pretty sure they all hate each other. It really wouldn't surprise me if Patrick just gets instrumentals sent to him by pop producers to slap some vocals over and put they just put the FOB stamp on it
Rap isn't music; it's spoken word with a loop on top.
>>63378799
1.It's really good.
2.Everything else is really bad.
3.I am the only person in the world who knows what good music is and you'll never understand.
Disturbed's cover of Sound of Silence.
>>63378845
>spoken word
>loop on top
both of those things are music
>>63378845
Spoken word with a loop on top is music.
>>63378544
Who are you quoting? Sorry your reading comprehension is shit
>>63378857
Do you have any evidence to back any of those claims? If not, why not?
>>63378861
Is this loss.jpg
>>63378943
1.Listen to the album, it's really good.
2.Listen to every other album, they're really bad.
3.Listen to me, I know what good music is.
>>63378893
Maybe you can call that "music", but if I replayed the first 10 seconds of a rock record over and over, would you call that a song?
>>63374457
TTNG or Pink Floyd?
>>63378999
are you related to the 'in the end' guy
>>63379008
Yes.
>>63378999
Trips speak the truth
>>63378999
Your first two points are useless seeing as 'you're the only person who knows what good music is'. Also your 3rd point isn't relevant.
>>63379041
Very interesting perspective, that's for sure.
>>63374444
I can't get past those shitty album cover designs to even listen to them. Early ones especially are absolute trash. Poorly designed.
>>63379033
You tell me.
Nobody has good taste here.
>>63379129
What would be a good design then, in your opinion?
>>63379148
christ
Turny > Christgau > Scaruffi > Fantano
>>63379089
No, your first two points are useless.
>>63374339
k e k
If you think Yeezus was a hip-hop masterpiece, you're a fucking retard. The album was decent at best, but anyone could look at another genre and use their style. Besides that, there was nothing new Kanye brought up , the production feels rushed, and the lyrics are shit. I hate people on /mu/, KTT, and RapGenius give Kanye too much credit as a rapper instead of just an artist, especially in terms of being a lyricist.
madvillainy is boring and i couldnt even finish it
Burial is overrated and he has run out of ideas. Untrue will age like milk.
>>63379181
alright, you got me
>>63379262
Yeah, I did.
>>63379242
untrue has already aged excellently compared to all the skrillex-type shit from 2011-2012, now THAT's aged like milk
>>63379240
try listening to it in the background, or just a few songs at a time instead of the whole thing.
swans is almost as boring as the people who listen to them
>>63379447
YOU TAKE THAT BACK ABOUT SWANS YOU MOTHER FUCKER.
CAPTCHA: SELECT ALL THE CANDY
TOO BAD I CAN'T SELECT YOUR CANDY ASS BITCH.
>>63374395
>Animal Collective members should grow the fuck up
half of their songs are about growing the fuck up
two of them have kids
noah lives in portugal
>>63374998
wait did fantonga shit on it or somethin?
>>63379559
No, he died.
>>63379573
fuck
>>63379593
yeah
>>63379559
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ioVjY5-yds
i like mac demarco
>>63379593
Yeah, it was a really bad car accident, driving drunk and doing his thing somewhere in the Midwest his car got crushed a bit and rolled when it took the hit.
Rap and hip hop isn't music
Kanye should be brutally murdered on public television
Pitchfork is a hive of idiots who know nothing about music but have a large enough lexicon to confuse the average idiot /mu/ browser that they said something insightful
Etc etc
I like IDM, and have no problem calling it IDM despite the edgelords who use the term.
>>63379645
thanks man
>>63379662
>calling Asobi Seksu Experimental/Rock
Ween and Slowdive are great bands
Speedin' Bullet 2 Heaven is good.
Limp Bizkit is seriously underrated, and yes that is my actual opinion
>>63379726
/mu/ has always liked ween and the slowdive shit is basically just to make montie leave the board
>>63375212
>My Bloody Valentine is slightly overrated. Loveless is great, however Kevin Shields was feeding off of late 80's bands and managed to hide it so well that plebs believes he created shoegaze.
Yiss
>>63379710
I don't know what the fuck you're talking about but if that jap is making rap or hip hop then it's not music.
>>63379936
Shoegaze/Dream Pop, dude, the Patricians music, you obviously wouldn't know because you're an absolute pleb.
>>63379969
>go into thread about extremely unpopular opinions
>criticize said opinions
Your handler took the day off I presume?
>>63380021
Dude, nice projection, haha.
>>63380080
>I don't understand what argument turn arounds are or mean
The word you were looking for is ad hominem.
>>63380127
Sorry dude, cucks need not apply, haha.
>>63374579
>best pop-rock band
Killers are good but that's FoB or MCR
>>63379686
same, though i think of it more as a movement or scene as opposed to an actual genre. similar to krautrock in that way.
>>63374319
>>63374412
edgy radiohead hating stopped being that popiular on /mu/ a while ago
Curve are better than both MBV and Slowdive
Mercury Rev are overrated
>>63374475
why not
what's your definition of music
>>63374579
Im on board with The Killers. Everything up until Day and Age is good shit.
They're one of the few radio pop outfits that actually seems to love music just like a patrician artist would. It makes a huge difference.
Military marching music is the sign of dangerous beliefs
>>63377331
Hhh used to be pretty decent until they added it to /r/all
I like vaporware unironicly
I like that bigge remix with the thomas the tank engine theme
>>63379488
After you select it, what would you do anon-kun?
>>63374292
Liking anything Alex Turner-related for some bloody reason
led zeppelin is the objectively best rock band ever.
The whole dad rock meme is an argument for autistic plebs.
>>63374584
nothing wrong with that opinion
>>63379008
yes, go listen to daft punks first two albums
>>63379753
Whoa, slow down there kiddo
>>63380851
jimmy page sucked at soloing, i tried watching the song remains the same and was like "could you please hurry the fuck up with the solos already"
>>63380143
haha
>>63380692
I like that biggie thing too
>>63380988
listen to jeff beck if you want to listen to solos
Some Dream Theater albums are pretty decent.
>>63381026
no, what i meant was that they go on way too long
Sub-sub-genres like "chill-x" and post-anything were made up by amateurs who decided to make their own genres instead of learning how to make good music
>>63380988
solos aren't always about speed, listen to the solo of Achilles Last Stand or the solo of Good times bad times.
>>63375288
This only applies to third wave-black metal and prog black metal
First wave and post are basic as shit, for very different reasons, second wave is just kinda meh
>>63375877
Seconding
>>63379129
>literally judging an album based on its cover
Cancer
>>63379008
Why wouldn't you? Ever listened to post-punk or post-rock?
not all pop punk is shit
I unironically like Bring Me The Horizon.
>>63374395
>Blur are cool, Weezer are fucking terrible, Animal Collective members should grow the fuck up
You were right up until this point anon
>>63378368
God is my Copilot
I like /mu/
>>63378845
>loop
I can think of many rap songs where the instrumentals aren't a loop.
also loops are music
spoken word is music too.
your argument has 0 merit whatsoever.
>>63381409
>post-
WHAT
DOES
THIS
MEAN
>>63378682
Blink 182 is literally hot garbage.
music was better in the past century
>>63379240
How the fuck
Do you even like music?
Every single song on that album is completely different and full of charisma.
>>63381872
It's something people add to genre names to imply that it's a newer, more updated version of it, not realizing that said "post-genre" becomes outdated very quickly.
>>63381900
see pic related
>>63380851
>objectively best
By what measures?
Critical reception? Critics hated them
Popular opinion? Back then they weren't all that liked and now maybe, but I think that place belongs to the Beatles or queen
Originality? They stole most of their songs
Virtuosity? Dude. No.
Subjectively best, tho. Yeah, why not.
Paul McCartney & Wings > The Beatles
>>63380851
>objectively
>music
pick one
>>63382074
that's common knowledge
>>63382024
>>63381872
No. It depends on post-what, most times they aren't even all that similar to the original genere
>>63374633
I felt the same way about Unknown Pleasures at first. But after listening to it for sometime I completely get all the hype for it.
Spiderland is a album ahead of its time. They basically created post-rock.
I understand what you're trying to say, but you picked the wrong album.
>>63382105
>most times they aren't even all that similar to the original genere
example?
Pet sounds is pretty shitty. It's got two or three really good songs and the atmosphere is nice but the other songs arent intresting.
>>63374292
Radiohead is shit
Literal radio music
>>63382102
Not in the real world unfortunately.
>>63382122
Well, I mean, take what most people consider "rock music" and compare it to any song by GY! BE
Or see post-black metal wich is pretty much neo classical+black metal vocals
>>63382152
ram > every beatles album
>>63382054
More like 64,694 reasons.
>>63374292
Death Grips is garbage.
>>63382199
Without question
>>63382223
I'm pretty sure /mu/ is neutral overall to DG. It's a good mix of people who love it and people who hate it and it just depends on who sees your post.
U2 are pretty damn good.
While a lot of "geek music" is absolutely cringey, some are legit 8-10/10s for me.
>>63382266
They're popular enough to be considered mucore.
>>63382119
>someone else who felt this way for unkown pleasures
based
how long did closer take to click for you? I'm probably listening to it within the next few days.
>>63382119
you are dumber than two bricks rubbing together
>>63374444
>those fucking quad fours
Swans confirmed trash
>>63382327
because its discussed all the time, whether positively or negatively
>>63382330
way faster. It's better produced, the whole album has a lot more power and diversity.
>>63382335
why?
>>63381838
I'm back. I'd just like to say that spoken word isn't music, it's spoken word. I also disagree with a loop being considered a whole piece of music too. If it was, I don't think we'd call it a loop huh. See my other comment I made >>63379008
And you can't lie that the majority of hip hop is pretty much repetitive structures. If it's not a loop, it's something like it. For example, DMX's songs. They're beats made for the song, but pretty much the whole songs follow a beat that is played over and over.
>>63381443
They're pretty solid as of the last two albums
Oasis better than radio head
Bowie is the greatest songwriter of all time
TLOP was good
>>63374360
Sorrow is so good it validates the whole album's existence.
I like dad rock
This is my favorite album
>>63374896
;_;
Dave Matthews band has better musicians than any shitty indie band you can name.
>>63383905
that's a 2/10
>>63383979
Yes. But Dave Matthews himself is an atrocious musician and abysmal human being.
>>63383989
>select all images with bread
Stop reading Pitchfork
>>63384030
>reading Pitchfork
just look at the scores to be honest
LCD Soundsystem is shit. All My Friends is their (his?) good song
Lemmy was a shit-tier bassist
>>63378368
hunx and his punx
Vaporwave is the most fresh and innovative genre of all time, it's use of sampling as the primary, if not the only, source of sound for an album is an incredible idea and can create space and feeling in a way no other genre can. Its subgenres (mallsoft, future funk, oceangrunge) show that the genre is really open to a lot of extremely varied sounds and isn't bound in the way any other genre is.
>>63374292
Music these days is garbage.
>>63384144
Lemmy, you must find your way out of this imageboard, or you will surely be remembered as a talentless hack. This way has been closed off by the great bearer of hot pockets. To escape the janitor, you must journey up to the dark reaches of /b/ and down to the fourth page. Who am I? Just a friend. Heed my words, Lemmy. Your time is running out. Make for the Good Sleep Chihuahua.
>>63374292
This album is a strong 8 to light 9 and the best deathcore album
>>63384203
they live in denial just to spite reddit, but deep down they know it.
>>63382637
Well but how about almost all pop and rock, its basically three loops played through the song (verse-chorus-verse-bridge-chorus) maybe there are some very small variations but then again, there are so in beats too
>>63384259
I'd look into The Red Chord before you make that your choice
>>63384202
Vaporwave is a subgenre of oceangrunge, not the other way around
>>63378682
This guy must be memeing,but i actually kind of really like this album.
>>63384294
I see why you'd say that The Red Chord is great I just have a lot of good memories with that album I guess. I love the vocals and the mix compared to their other albums also I always loved CGs slow sorta atmospheric leads that other deathcore doesn't seem to do. The album also seems almost slightly black metal influenced even though I doubt any of the members have listened to any
>>63383989
seriously end your life
>>63382335
You're dumber than your mom rubbing two dicks together.
>>63384259
not so fast
>>63375571
Everything the Foos did up until In Your Honor was pretty solid.
>>63374292
Pop punk isn't all bad
>>63378339
Yeah pretty much
Hans Zimmer is actually good
>>63374292
Kanye hasn't released a consistently good album since 808s
>>63374633
>he doesn't get it
Jk, do what you want. But silly to denounce everyone else as fakers though
EWBAITE is a good Weezer album and probably one of their best works in the past 8 years
>>63374591
to each their own, but AMLOR is not their best album imo. Meddle is
Humble Cannons is actually pretty good
All music except classical music is absolute shit
>>63386172
Still shit compared to Pinkerton and Blue though.
>>63375414
On /mu/ Nirvana is just Bleach, no one cares about the rest of their trash.
continued
>>63386487
>>63386487
>>63386487
>>63379385
>The album's only good if you don't really listen to it.
It's hip-hop, not ambient, what are you on about. Even if it was ambient, good ambient can still be actively listened to.
I don't like neutral milk hotel
>>63374319
pleb zone
>>63374395
>Montie has ok taste
Hi, Montie.
>>63374633
isn't that the plot of The Emperor's New Groove or something?
