CYOA Discussion
- Home
- Board: /mlp/ - My Little Pony
- Reading: CYOA Discussion
We respect your right to privacy. You can choose not to allow some types of cookies. Your cookie preferences will apply across our website.
Fruit Love Edition
ITT:
>We discuss Current, Finished and Upcoming CYOAs.
>Give advice on CYOAs
>Pitch ideas
>Get critique
>Trade art
>Shitpost
List of stories: http://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/
Read this advice first:
http://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/advice
http://www.tgchan.org/wiki/Advice
>What day is best?
http://strawpoll.me/5151810
>What time is best?
http://strawpoll.me/5151833
>What genre are you interested in?
http://strawpoll.me/5151994
>What if I cannot into art?
http://strawpoll.me/5207921
>What race would you play?
http://strawpoll.me/5498136
Remember: Do the impossible
Last thread: >>25629561
Shade a tricky pony
>>25651377
>all those dead quests.
>>25651181
[Urge to spoil potential future CYOA storylines intensifies]
So I've been wondering
Which mare is the smallest one?
>>25651465
Flo
>>25651465
Kessy or Sako.
>>25651495
Kessy will beat Sako's ass
>>25651495
Which quest are these two from?
>>25651528
Urban and Alchemy
>>25649578
Ending for today, will probably continue tomorrow. Need sleep.
>>25651619
No need to post the end of your sessions in this thread.
Beginnings, yes. Endings, no.
We need a scale of all the mares from smallest to biggest
For science
>>25651637
However, you should post the end of your session in your own CYOA thread.
>>25651398
one
>one
ONEone
(1)
of these isn't dead.
>>25651633
How big are virtual mares? Or do they count?
>>25651633
I can only think of a few right now but I'm sure there are many more from quest I haven't read before
We're gunna need a list of them first
>>25651377
napone looks really trashy in this pic
>>25651633
Sundance is biggest mare!
>>25651697
Why do you hurt me in this way
>>25651745
You sure m8?
>>25651745
no she's not.
>>25651697
How big is a bunch of electrons?
>>25651840
About 7.
>>25651914
Not so fast
>>25651914
>"Don't worry sir."
>>25651840
One electron is 10^-6 angstroms.
>>25651924
>tfw you like Sundance but Sundancefags are annoying as shit.
>>25651914
How will Anonguard remove the horn from a mare that big?
>>25651914
>"I'll protect you, sir!"
>>25651946
>>25652024
>tfw Whispen doesn't have a custom pocket on her armor to carry around Anongaurd in
>>25652046
There's plenty of room in the trunk, anon.
>>25652046
Not to worry Anon, she was born with a custom pocket. She's a mare.Unless those rumors I've been hearing are true...
>>25652069
>Anonguard gets to spend Whispen's entire guard shift tucked away in her codpiece
>>25652011
>Removing the horn of his waifu
You are one sick fucker, anon.
>>25652133
What?
He'll put it back on later!
It's just part of their kinky weekend routine.
Now I wanna see big Whispen hugging Anonguard.
>>25652190
I want her to hold Boulder in her hoof and have him realize he isn't the biggest anymore
>>25652190
I still want to see Anonguard and Whispen watching 'The Joy of Painting' together on the sofa but simply longing for something isn't going to make it happen is it?
>You will never be the big mare.
>>25652305
Hey drawfags, can this happen, please?
>>25652312
Not with that attitude.
>>25652305
I have tomorrow off.No promises though.
>>25652305
I want to see Anonguard watching Bob RossLaying on big Whispen's stomach
>>25651697
>Not posting Brandy Bryte
>>25652330
>Whispen trying to paint with tiny brushes and no depth perception.
>>25652565
>Call Pot for a good time.
>>25652565
>G̶a̶r̶'̶s̶ ̶s̶m̶a̶l̶l̶ ̶w̶h̶e̶r̶e̶ ̶i̶t̶ ̶c̶o̶u̶n̶t̶s̶
>Not anymore!
>>25652565
>Looking for friends
>-Blitz
>>25652565
>Looking for love?
>Call 555678 for a night with a cuddle champion
>(Equestrian citizens only)
How will File deal with the dreaded landlord!?
>>25652871
Let's find out.
Also, Thank you Inept.
I want tofeel how I feel when I'm asleep.
why in the hell would someone bump shitty threads from page 10?
No secret club meetings tonight, it seems.
>>25653501
HAHAI got home kinda late todayhttps://picarto.tv/TheBirdieBin
>last thread
>>25653855
>shit art
>get running
>try bad tracing
>>25653855
>dead enough
>>25654081
>>25654830
Optimistic as fuck.
>>25651953
Is it all the scenarios we keep coming up with involving her?
>>25654867
There needs to be more than just Sundance.
Where's the Diamondfags? The Azurafags?
>>25654936
I like Azura but I would compromise for sundance depending on what people want.
>>25654936
I think its kinda our fault for shipping characters together. Like Belle/D-man, oats/berry. I wonder what the top romances are so far.
>still using the mugshot image despite all that ded
I'm still surprised of how bearable it looks, considering it was one of my very first pony drawings while I was training to start a CYOA.
>>25654958
Those two, "Sunwaltz"/"Hot Buck", and some kind of threesome between Wine, Pot and CutieIf Diamond really is going to become unavailable, there needs to be a new stallion to take his place. Ideas?
>>25654970
Actually, no way to really know for sure without a poll.
>>25655005
I wonder if anyone likes wine besides just an easy lay and sex scene. No one ever talks about her and shes easily forgotten.
>>25655014
Sex scenes are unpure.
>>25655005
I always wondered, had Pot and Diamond worked out, who'd have been the top? Cause both of them seem like tops
>>25655014
I like Wine. I think she's unfairly pigeonholed by a few scenes where she was drunk, hungover, or fucking with Pot for fun.
She's admitted to being somewhat hedonistic, but she's nowhere near the set of open legs her harshest critics seem to claim she is.
>>25655005
Cutie, obviously.I don't want a manly stallion.
>>25655044
Her hedonistic nature is why I dislike her, I'm looking for a more emotional connection like that time with Belle.
>>25655037
Sundance can takes turns on top with them both.
>>25655053
I mean, Pot and Not-Trixie also had a mini emotional connection that one time.
Speaking of which, we never actually finished that conversation that happened just before they got attacked by the cats with her. I'm curious to see how that was gonna end up.
>>25655014
I think she's nice, but not exactly long-term relationship material. She said so herself, and I don't see her being more than friends with benefits right now.
>>25655037
They'd take turns. Diamond didn't seem to mind Pot being on top when he was dry humping him. Though he WAS kinda drunk...I remember Diamond saying he wouldn't mind hogging Pot all night at the grand opening. Could have went after him then, but everyone wanted to get the canterlot unicorn. And we all know how that turned out...
>>25655044
Ah, but Cutie is already single. The position of manly stallion can't exactly be filled by him.Though Diamond wasn't exactly the manliest around anyway
>>25655091
When we first met Not-Trixie I disliked her, but shes really growing on me. I love the play fighting thing.
>>25655053
I don't see how hedonism would conflict with an emotional connection.
Hell Wine likes us more because we helped out one of her good friends, Cutie, rather than a more traditionally hedonistic reason.
I think Wine's vocal critics are hilariously self-deceptive. From any outside point of view Pot Luck is far closer to a whore than Wine is. But we know and share Pot's motivations, while everyone assumes Wine is just in it for the physical pleasures.
It's the classic judgement of others by actions but ourselves by intent.
>>25655107
>I don't see how hedonism would conflict with an emotional connection.
She must stay pure until marriage anon.
>>25655106
I agree, she's become a lot more interesting with character development. Everyone does.
>>25655107
In the end, some people are going to like particular characters more than others. The reasons sometimes just boil down to "I like this one" and "I don't like that one". All the extra stuff on top is so we can justify our decisions to ourselves.
>>25655106
Yeah, me too. She seems like she'd be harder to get than Wine and Cutie though.
But seeing as she saw Pot and his choice booty in socks, it's only a matter if fine until she'll be begging for some of that Pot Luck action.
>>25655115
Why though?
Pot isn't pure, so that's pretty hypocritical.
If you're joking, then you are demonstrating a clear bias that most anons have. For some reason no one cares that Diamond is just as hedonistic as Wine, but she has to be pure?
>>25655135
Wonder what would happen if she sore us in a skirt
>>25655136
Pot is looking for love, some fun is alright on the road to happiness.
>>25655136
>Pot isn't pure, so that's pretty hypocritical.
We were looking for flaws a day or two ago weren't we? Two birds, one stone and all that.
>>25655169
Pot's flaw is minor sexism?
>>25655180
Sure.
>>25655106
I like Azura too.
>>25655183
Eh, that's not a bad idea. He might be a bit protective of mares that are obviously not in need.
This might make courting Sundance difficult though...
>>25655106
Are Azzy and Sunny the 2 top female romances?
>>25655216
D-man and QT for males
>>25655180
>>25655202
What else did you guys figure out that made JAD not so perfect?
>>25655227
What are you talking about Anon, JAD IS perfect.
>>25655250
That's why your MC is flat as paper right?
>>25655216
>No one wants to fug Not-Pinkie but me
O-oh okay
>>25655260
But he's not. Can't you read? He's apparently a little bit sexist.
>>25655269
Oh, well in that case he's as flat as cardboard.
>>25655275
What if we make him really sexist?
>>25655226
I vote we include Heart as a backup.
>>25655266
>No one has said they want not-pinkie but you
Keep trying, you'll get the hoo-yah in time
>>25655266
>we eventually walk in on not-Rarara and not-Pinkie making out
>"Oh Pot, I got you a present!"
>>25655284
So Gar is the racist
Pot is the sexist
What else?
>>25655294
I was going to say we needed a speciesist but I realized that would just be normal racism in equestria.
So why where and when is Pot sexist?
>>25655339
The future, near Sundance, and because she needs to be shown a mare's proper place: Having and taking care of foals.
>>25655339
>why
Because they finally saw that he needed some character traits.
>when
Now
>>25655339
He's not, but you gotta introduce those character flaws to fight those perfect accusations. Which really just makes JAD more perfect.
>>25655350
God yes.
I rather like the Idea that pot is boring as shit because then it can be explained as him simply being normal.
Leave it to the nomadic adventurers to be moody and troubled, he's just trying to run a business and live a simple life
>>25655416
I feel the same
>>25655416
>only adventurers need personalities and character traits
>>25655416
>>25655421
Being normal is not an excuse to be flat.
>>25655448
This.
>>25655416
It is in the OP every time after all.
>It is an age of knights, adventurers, dark magics, and destined heroes.
>You are none of these things.
> you just want to run your inn
Active threads
Equestrian Psycho: >>25601723
Hijack: >>25591290
Semantic Error: >>25592329
FOE: >>25631472
Sunset: >>25612666
Vampony: >>25568958
Urban Survival: >>25617770
Crystal Warlock: >>25649578
Alchemy: >>25611490
Trottingham: >>25613430
Space: >>25553699
Archipelago: >>25612611
Coltquest: >>25627820
Bank Robber: >>25625429
>>25655768
And that's well and good. You can describe a character's lifestyle as normal, perhaps they even value peace and simplicity. It's especially effective when juxtaposed with the environment and other characters.
But for heaven's sake, you can't have a character's personality or character as normal or plain, especially when that's the protagonist. That doesn't make for an interesting read at all.
Flaws and strengths, personality traits and quirks, what really pushes his buttons, where does he find happiness more than anywhere else, what does he value, what things doesn't he understand, stuff like that.
>>25655984
>But for heaven's sake, you can't have a character's personality or character as normal or plain, especially when that's the protagonist.
>That doesn't make for an interesting read at all.
So you're saying that Pot doesn't have a normal or plain personality. Or that he's not he protagonist.
>>25655994
I don't see how that follows.
>>25655984
Meh, I haven't followed it lately, but it seems like some easy traits for Pot would be overprotectiveness, an easily trusting nature and a penchant for lewdness, or more specifically a casual view of sex and a willingness to use it as an ice breaker of sorts.
>>25655994
It really isn't a great read though. Fun to play, but catching up is a bit of a chore.
>>25656049
>catching up is a bit of a chore.
I'm going to agree, I didn't personally find much motivation to keep reading when I did get caught up, and catching back up felt like a slog every time.
>>25656049
Well Innkeeper was planning to work in some flaws and quirks into the story.
So you might see those appear soon enough.within the next century or so...
>>25656120
Yeah, and I'm not really sure why. Maybe it's because Pot is playing the Straight Man in his universe. He's just not a very exciting focal point.
I'd contrast it to M&M. I enjoy playing that too, but the few times I've fell behind I've enjoyed reading it to catch up.
which cyoa pone has style and gracewith a funny face?
>>25656538
Tara has neither of those, but has a stupid face.
Does that count?
Easy is gonna fucking go crazy and start talking to scorpions or something.
>>25656879
Is that a bad thing?
>>25656897
For her mental state yeah.
>>25656879
Why not, The Scorpions?
Then she can follow them on tour and live her dream of becoming the world's best roadie!
>>25656561
Anime, ballet, and homicide. Is there anything this bat can't do?
>>25656919
I think Storm would be better since she canrock you like a hurricane.
>>25656879
I'VE BEEN THROUGH THE DESERT AS A HORSE WITH NO NAME
IT FELT GOOD TO BE OUT OF THE RAIN
IN THE DESERT YOU CAN ESCAPE THE BLAME
'CAUSE THERE'S NO ONE FOR TO MAKE YOU FLAME
Okay, dungeon delver quest guy here, just tallying up results from last thread that I missed due to sleep. Pretty interesting read! I'm always up for a spot of circle jerking, what a fantastic time to spend the afternoon, but I'm new as fuck, and have only read Entrapment, Don't Fuck Up, and chunks of 11-54 and Hijack. I saw a couple of anon's suggesting to have Nadine in the party, which I've humoured. As for the direct suggestions I got Earth Pone dragon-slayer Fighter, Racist Unicorn Wizard, Barbarian/Paladin Hybrid, and the last two were implied Bat pone ranger and ... a fucking luchador. So that's five plus Nadine would make six. Is this fine? Or are there any modifications you guys wanna make?
>>25657178
Sounds good.
>>25657178
Why not have Stars from Heat as a healer?
>>25657195
>needing a healer
We're just going to blow through the dungeon, healer's not needed.
>>25657178
>lucha is go
All to keikaku
>Crystal Warlock
>fanart within the first thread
>>25657231
Shit, the Nine Lands got art before the first story post.
>>25657178
Can't wait to see the unicorn wizard and batpone ranger get into it with each other
>>25657195
I think she deserves some recognition.
Hey Anon, how many roads must a man walk down, before you can call him a man?
>>25657881
At least one, the road to his first horse pussy.
>>25657881
Enough
>>25657881
None. Men invented roads.
>>25657881
I think the answer to that is blowing in the wind. Yeah, definitely blowing in the wind.
>>25658027
Do you know what else would be blowing?My mouth on a horsedick
Running
>>25612611
>>25658353
lel nobody cares
>>25658372
#rude
Trottingham: artificial spiders edition continues:
>>25658395
Who's already pre ordered their ticket to Urban Survival on Ice?
>>25658510
Didn't think she could handle that many ponies.
>>25658416
Bank Robber CYOA is back
>>25658533
She'sgonna carry that weight.
>>25657303
>>25657204
>>25657195
Final decision? You guys wanna drop somebody out for the cleric? Or stick with what we got already?
>>25658602
I'd enjoy dropping a pone for the cleric. Probably the luchador.
>>25658620
>drop the luchador
FUCK
YOU
>>25658646
Now I want to drop the lucha just to spite you.
>>25658602
>>25658620
If we had to I'd drop with the Luchador. I mean I like the idea, but we got three fighters already.
Then again I suppose the Barbaladin could presumably heal too.
Probably by yelling at the others real loud.
>>25658602
I want Stars to be in. She deserves the moment of glory that she sought.
>>25658602
>>25658665
Yeah, let's get Stars in and swap out the lucha for party balance.
>>25658738
why the shit is no one swapping out any other fighter
am I the only one itching to air steiner a fucking dragon
>>25658745
Because I'd rather a knight with a sword than a guy in spandex.
>>25658745
Because luchador doesn't really fit with the setting.
He's really the odd one out.
And yeah, >>25658765 too.
>>25658765
>>25658776
>not wanting to suplex things
Step it up niggas
>>25658792
this desu senpai
>>25658792
>implying a barbarian can't suplex bitches and then rip their spines out for good measure
It's like you can't even team composition.
>>25658792
I do. Just not as much as I want to stab things.
Look, I'm the guy who suggested the Palabarian.
Why don't we just say he fights unarmed, and knows all kinds of holds and grapples? He'll basically be an armored wrestler who literally glows when he elbow drops you.
Why is the dragon knight not a luchadore?
I think this would make a wonderful multiclass.
>>25658738
fuck you
>>25658765
fuck the dragon hunter
>>25658776
fuck your setting
>>25658792
>>25658814
mah niggas
>>25658887
>>25658849
you guys don't get it, do you?
>>25658893
HEY
YOU
YEAH YOUYOU'RE A FUCKING GENIUS, I LOVE IT, AND I WANT TI REAL BAD.
>>25658893
Because wrestling isn't typically the best for dragon slaying.
>>25658887
>>25658893
I imagine this won't be very practical, and might be difficult to draw in combat, but make it happen.
>>25658887
This is fine.
>>25658893
This one's kind of stupid.
Don't mind me. I'm just watching this unfold.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3l436MSlivQ
>>25658912
>I imagine this won't be very practical
Alright, so imagine a big pone.
Now imagine the big pone in big armor.
Now imagine the big pone in big armor is coming at you.
Now imagine the big pone in big armor coming at you is fucking glowing.
Do you have it yet?
If not, here's a visual aid:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ba50SE8BfZk
>>25658907
Calm down hijumps, you goddamn autist
>>25658893
>>25658907
>>25658912
Under his helm is a mask, and under his armor is a champion's belt. None have seen the pony beneath these, he is shrouded in mystery.
All we know is that he is not content simply being the strongest pony or the bravest of hunters.
>>25655350
I have always wonder how she would feel about another daughter like wispy
>>25658907
>OC
Calm down hijack, your Panzermane is showing.
>>25656120
>>25656049
Gotta read that part with Zuri during the night and when Sundance told us about her life.
>>25658907
>you guys don't get it, do you?
Oh, no, I get it just fine: You made an intentionally stupid, lulrandumb, setting-shattering D&D character because the extent of your creativity is taking something from time period A and sticking it in time period B. That's a very nuanced and totally original idea. The problem is that it's still stupid, randumb, and breaks the setting.
>>25659083
No idea who Zuri is, and from what I've read in this thread, Sundance just turned full edgelord tortured past in the otherwise comedic SoL quest.
>>25659102
Just described Hijacker desu
>>25659102
rekt.
>>25659102
>Hijack
>Creativity
I think I found the problem.
>>25659102
It's funny because that's all he does.
>>25659102
O U C H
>>25659102
>breaks the setting.
>>25659030
She's be much happier once she accepts Whispy as her own. Until of course her trappy son comes to town. Then him and Whispy will arm wrestle for dominance, and she'll probably win because he's only got like two strength.
>>25659102
>Your fun ends where my immersion begins
Cool.
>>25659113
JAD always had some edge moments in it like Belle and dead husband. Hell we found Wispy shitting in a pot and just adopted her.
Her character feels like its meant to open up to the idea of badlands and how bad people are from their.
>>25659102
Do you think that insults Hijacker? He is fully aware of this, and is even proud about it.
>>25659146
Wispys strength is raising by the second, maybe we should ask Azura or Prism to teach her magic.
>>25658907
You see Hijello, this is why you don't argue with anons as yourself.
>>25659102
Someone REALLY didn't want the luchador
I don't know why so many people in here hate fun so much. I for one, fully accept our new luchadore-dragon-knight overlords.
>>25659166
>>25659143
>>25659126
"My idea of humor is different than yours, therefore you have no taste."
kek. The anti-Hijack circlejerk is real.
>>25659226
What the flying fuck are you on about you goddamn autist? Mad bantz isn't a fucking anti-Hijack circlejerk, it's mad bantz.
Why is it always Hijacker though? He gets shit on so much
>>25659226
Do you have any idea where you are?
>>25659226
this guy
>>25659258
Because he posted opinions with a pic of his very recognizable artstyle. Any QM would be shit on for that.
>>25659226
>spurgs out while showing who he is
>gets bantz
>l-leave him alone
Hijoke Defense Force ASSEMBLE!
>>25659253
>>25659266
>>25659273
>>25659275
I'm pretty sure it was Shiny. He used the same buzzwords and terrible logic that he usually does.
>>25659258
Because he's either
A: Shit at GMing or
B: Leaving his name on when giving hot opinions
MAN
THE
FORT
>>25659274
>Text quests win again
I'm a bit too busy to discuss weather or not we should be railing Hijacker for his hot opinions but If we're going to discuss Knights that can wrestle when disarmed you may spark my interest.
>>25659319
Canadian squirt gun?
In other news, Nips might be running PP later today.
>>25659319
>we should be railing Hijacker
>>25659319
GERMAN SUPLEX DESU SENPAI
Wew. You guys are a bit excitable, I guess it has been awhile since our last batch of hot opinions.
>>25659319
reminds me of an idea i had.
>Knights
>In power armor
>Use claymores
>But unarmed, are like pro wrestlers but real
>>25659319
I think that's what we're going with. A wrestling paladin whose suplexes are, quite literally, godly.
>>25659340
>Nips might be running
No.
No, he won't.
>>25659340
pls nops
>>25659351
Yeah that got a little nuclear
>>25659369
So, add the Cleric Stars, and fuse the soul of the luchadore with the Barbarian/Paladin for some righteous smackdowns?
>>25659439
Sounds good.
>>25659439
>fuse the soul of the luchadore with the Barbarian/Paladin for some righteous smackdowns?
I am dangerously erect.
>>25659226
People here are fucking Ass holes I try never to post here.
>>25659517
I feel like it would be rude to let Hijack do it and not give you a slap on the wrist.
At least you're not a complete sperg about it.
>>25659439
That's a dangerously strong fighter
I like it.
>>25659528
Go for it! I'm kind of a stupid prick.
>>25659528
He's not telling anyone to fuck off, and that's fan art of sorts for the agreed upon character anyway.
>>25659528
Yeah but Hijacker was being autistic.
>>25659548
Hijumper got shit for being fucking autistic
BWH is just advocating for his side
>>25659561
That's what I said.
>>25658907
>>25659001
>>25659022
>>25659517
Damn, today I learned artists have a luchador fetish.
>>25659567
fine taste
I want to bully Hijacku
>>25659567
They're the spirit animal of us all. And goddamn has there been some dank art so far.
>>25659517
BWH! I dunno if you caught the very start of this little discussion, but a bunch of anons were suggesting using characters from other quests as cameo/stand-in controllable characters. Nadine got brought up and I'd like to use her, if you're cool with it?
>>25659548
>>25659560
To be fair to >>25659528 There are things that I should be doing instead that I'm way behind on.
Who do you care about. Who do you want to live the war, who do you want to live, who do you want to 'resurrect'. Should i JUST shoot.
>>25659704
both
>>25659677
Yes I would love some more
>>25659657
Yeah, I was there. And As If said before, yes people can use my characters. Hell, if you've got some way to get her out of (Hell? Tartarus? Double plus Un-good land? Apple customer support?) Then go for it because I've proven that when I'm around, her life get progressively worse.
>>25659677
>Sunedge on top
Bath pls, we already talked about this.
>>25659657
No.She's mine
>>25659645
Get in line, pal
>>25659739
And then I took a pole. And Sundance came out on top and then I posted the results stating that it made sense with the size difference. And then people started argueing with the results of the pole and now... Now I just don't know what to believe. Can someone who's read both 'Entrapment' and 'Just Another Day' Help me out here?
>>25659739
Sunedge is always on top, how else would she crush others with her massive dildo.
> Wish that picture was on the fanart page
>>25659567
I don't.
>>25659782
The only acceptable outcome is for Sunny D to treat Dancy's edge with her patented Sexual Healingâ„¢.
Already proven to work on both slaves and slavers, or your money back.
>>25659782
Big mares pounding little ones is hot regardless of who they are.
>>25649578
Decided to spare some time for a short session!
Tara has a stupid face.
>>25659731
Neat, thanks!
>>25659742
IM NOT SHARING HER, ANON
Now to trawl through the Heat threads to find out more about this cleric.
>>25659976
She only shows up in the last three or four threads.
She likes bowling.
>>25659837
We did all kinds of science and shit!
>>25659991
I keep getting a 504 error. Thanks though, I'll check it out tomorrow.
>>25660024
bath pls
>>25660076
man is cis scum
>>25660076
Water, mostly.
>>25660076
What makes a man?
Is it the power in his hands, or is it his quest for glory?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oECIKVaz5rcNever played Castlevania.
>>25660076
Step one to making something like Halley.
>>25660076
A miserable little pile of secrets.
>>25660076
Dark Metamorphosis
>>25659998
M&M is up
>>25660106
That's a good song.
Do you fap with your left or right hand, /cyoa/?
http://strawpoll.me/6180026
>>25660360
mouse in right hand, dick in left hand.
when I was young, it was remote in right hand, dick in left hand.
>>25660360
>2015
>not going hands free
>>25660374
This
>>25660388
Teach me, master!
>>25659976
I can't find a description but I did find this. We never got too attached since we went on a literal suicide mission. HEAT SPOILERS (should I even put a spoiler warning?)She died in the explosion that destroyed the pyramidHere's some snippets that might be of worth to you:
>"Stars. Specialize as a healer but I can work as an all around magician."
>Well... I'm Stars... I've worked as a doctor all my life, recently started training to be a war medic. Figured this wouldn't be a bad way to get experience, and maybe some glory if I make it out alive... It'd be awesome to be looked up to, a role model for nurses across Canterlot."
"So Stars..."
>"Hm?"
"I want you to tell me a little bit more about yourself, not what you can do, but who you are, what makes you happy, your friends, family, you know?"
>she blushes
>"O-Oh... Well, I have a pretty good and supportive family. My father is a businesspony, and my mother a nurse. I got my love of medicine from her... I have two younger brothers, a bit rough and tumble, but nice guys overall. What I like to do for fun? Well, I party with my friends sometimes, that's always fun. During the day I mostly study and train as a medic, though I get nights and three days of the week off. I also like bowling... I don't know why, just soothing to me."
>>25660529
>She died in the explosion that destroyed the pyramid
>Harvest died in the pyramid
Okay so who actually made it out of there alive?
>>25660388
>Bluetooth fappin
USB is so much more reliable though.
>>25660575
Stars died in the explosion but Harvest (and another guy) drug herself from the rubble and was then shot by a spooked guard.
>>25660360
>>25660388
I just hump pillows
>>25660575
Okay, here's how this worked.
Three people went on the mission, Harvest, Marks, and Stars.
Stars died in the explosion, leaving only Marks and Harvest to run out. Harvest was killed on the way out by a bullet, but was resurrected by Horus a few days later.
Technically, only Marks survived.
>>25660653
Why didn't Star get revived?
>>25660653
Funny because he was the most ok with dying. The whole blaze of glory and whatnot.
>>25660663
She wasn't the champion of a god.
>>25660672
Well was she at least remembered for her sacrifice?
Seems to me she got a shit end.
>>25660653
>most of the squad died
This probably wouldn't have happened if you, I don't know, brought more people.
>>25660685
That might well be why people are requesting her.
>>25660685
Yes.
>>25660687
We specifically told our regular party that we didn't want them to come because it was essentially a suicide mission.
Those two were the only ones who volunteered.
>>25660529
I think Sunrise may need a physical description.
If there is none, then from what I've read in this thread, I'm getting a strong Rebecca Chambers vibe.
>>25660749
A female pony with long hair.
>>25660749
Sunrise? You mean Stars?
>>25660808
Sunrise is the QM.
>>25660808
The QM (Sunrise), probably needs a physical description for the character (Stars).
>>25660828
Oh I see! Totally misunderstood.
>>25660749
I think she was pink or purple, if memory serves. Don't remember mane colors.
>>25658602
>>25657178
I'd prefer it if you dropped Nadine.
She's in hell, it doesn't make sense for her to be alive. She's also from a specific setting and time period, so unless you're basing your quest in Bathwaters world then it wouldn't feel right.
You should do your own thing and use your own characters. Having a single party member be taken from another quest just feels wrong.
Either go full crossover and have every character taken from other quests, or create every character from scratch.
>>25661029
Nah, that's gay
Next Galloping Steel thread will be tomorrow.
>>25661029
You're dumb. Also not paying attention.
>>25661206
Glad to know. I was considering asking.
>>25661206
Bullying
>>25661167
ur gay
>>25661306
no u
>>25661206
Can you either confirm or deny that Treads has cononically been bullied before?
I want to arrest Whispen for treason and send her to the boop gulag.
>>25617770
Shiny's personal hernia factory is good to go
>>25661443
Is this before or after we confiscate her horn?
>>25661384
Of course, but that's not saying much. We've all been bullied at school at some point and every school has its Diamond Tiara equivalent. Treads was always much more effected by the loss of her mother than by the barbs of random foals.
>>25661555
>We've all been bullied at school at some point
Speak for yourself nerd
>>25661587
>a river in Egypt
So, two things.
First, reminder to please vote for the next PQ if you haven't already: http://strawpoll.me/6164609
Second, and marginally more interesting, we apology stream now:https://picarto.tv/FailureCentral
>>25661555
Did they ever smash her box?
>>25661775
>smash her box
Heh. Are we still talking about cardboard?
>>25661674
Since you have guest chat disabled and since I can't be bothered to sign up just for one request I'll just say it here.
Draw me aSandwich___________________
>>25661706
PP is up
>>25661706
Because Nips is a shit
>>25661775
Even now her box isn't safe from bully. She will never know true peace in her delusions.
>>25661813
Heh
Took me a second to get that
>>25661823
>Since you have guest chat disabled
Just put a temp username in the text field and hit enter. Then you can chat to your heart's content.
>>25661555
So when are you going to reveal the huge Shyamalan level twist showing that there are no tanks?
>>25661927
Guest chat is temp username.
>>25661944
Yeah, and one other person and I are already doing it.
>>25661927
What? In that bar under the chat?
That's what I tried at first and it says guest chat is disabled after it asks to confirm the name.
Is there some sort of limitation on the name you pick it's just not telling me about?
>>25661981
That I'm not sure as I rarely use Picarto. Probably not too long and it has to be one word (no spaces) is all I know.
>>25661981
Are you sure you're not just putting in names that are taken?
>>25661029
Or necromancy happens and she has Vietnam style flashbacks of her time in Hell.
>>25661674
Friendship is Tragic: You're a pony who has yet to discover the joys of harmony and the magic of friendship, so Celestia has given you an ultimatum: You have one week to make a friend, or you'll be banished from Equestria. Sounds easy enough, right? Too bad that you hate every pony...
Colossus: One the night of a particularly spectacular meteor shower, a bright-eyed young pony meets a gentle giant from beyond the stars. Can the young pony keep this incredible creature a secret and help it find a way home, or is this unlikely alliance doomed to be uncovered by the Royal Guard, or worse still, the lad's parents?!
Pony's Island: Dragons and ponies don't usually get along very well. But when disaster strikes and sends a newborn wyrm plummeting into a Canterlot citizen's window, the pony takes it upon him/herself to return the hatchling to its parents - by travelling across Equestria and into the heart of the badlands.
Purpose: You've been constructed for a simple reason: Centuries from now, disaster will strike, and you must prevent it. But to ensure your success, you must follow three rules. One, let no harm come to life in Equestria. Two, never stray from your course. Three, you may not rest until your job is done.
Other is for any of my other ideas, or any of the players', if one gets popular enough. I mean a lot of the stuff I come up with is because of you guys anyway
>>25662000
>>25662015
I was just putting in "apl" because that's the only real handle I've ever used here, but I opened the page in firefox and it seems to be working now. Guess it's just some fuckup with IE.
Except now messages are showing twice and I'm not sure what that's about.
>>25662084
>Using IE
>ever
>>25662084
>IE
Lad...
>>25662084
Shit works fine in IE for me. Maybe you're just a failure at life.
>>25662107
>>25662109I know, but I'm used to it and it's never really caused me trouble before.
>PP
>still not finished
>the month of December
>>25660730
I still think Piryte should have come.
>>25662356
>"I have idea but dun wanna skip my other quests"
>"Do idea"
>"Okay"
>Does idea and further pushes quests back
Two new sorting options available for those that care about that sort of thing.
>>25662377
I thought so originally too, but what if he had died?
Miri couldn't live without Piryte, they had a duty to each other.
>>25662408
Is that a euphemism?
>>25662431
Course.
So, if things work out I'm thinking about starting a cyoa on Sunday that I've been planning, but I wanted to kinda pitch the idea first.
The cyoa would be an oceanic adventure located in Baltimare that was loosely based around the attempts of a filly to stop a chaotic and impish sock puppet villain from causing, well, chaos and shenanigans around the coast and islands nearby.
It would be an adventurey and hopefully comedic type of storyline.
Just wanted to see what you guys thought about it so far.
>>25662496
>oceanic adventure
FINALLY
>rest of that sentence
FUCK
>>25662496
>sock puppet villain
A filly is fighting /pol/?
>>25662496
When does Shade swoop in and kill the sock puppet?
>>25662496
Sounds alright.
>>25662551
Cool
>>25662509
Well, the puppet was initially there as a plot device/reason for me to use transformation magic, but I suppose I could just hide artefacts or something that do the same thing if that would work better.
>>25662514
I... huh, hadn't thought of that, heh.
>>25651914
>>25651924
Who keeps making these? How much?
>>25662878
Making what, the individual pones or the images using them?
>>25662878
The actual pixel ponies or the big mare pictures?
>>25662899
Images.
>>25662901
Fuck it, both.
>>25662914
>>25662933
The individual pixel pones are all done by me, and the images like the ones you linked are someone else.
>>25662933
It's more than just one guy making those.
>tfw honestly considering "shitty translation" mode
>tfw kind of would rather not because making the shitty translated names alone gave me a feeling so complicated
I know that if it becomes an option I will have to do it, but a part of me is thinking that it has to happen.It just has to be thisDUWANG.
If you think you know what I'm doing, then yes, it's gonna be a Crazy Quest. A Strange Journey. A Bizarre Adventure.
>>25662949
What do I have to do to get a pixel pone?
>>25662958
A lotta diversity for some hired drawfags!
>>25662999
Ask you dumdum
>>25662999
Post a ref or description of the pone you want and I'll make it.
>>25662999
I'm glad these pixellated bigmares could give you a boner, anon. Have a rare.Also, baneposting turns 4 in just 8 days.
>>25663031
Would you mind doing best trap pone?
>>25663062
The thought of Pot and Anonguard riding around snug and secure in their big waifu's armor is certainty a pleasing one
>>25663103
>he kept the squad safe
>now she gets to keep him safe
Muh heart
>>25663031
Not that guy, but requesting Carver.
>>25663156
Carver looks like a total semen demon
>>25663156
So is this the combutt I've heard so much about?
Ha, This pinecone pone doesn't look so tough!
Her ass should be far too easy to tame, I'll leave it to a much more inexperienced man as it would hardly be sporting for myself.
>>25663282
2qt
>>25663282
Likin' it..
>>25663282
Delightful Cutie Swirl, thank you.
>>25663282
That epic, don't suppose you could do one of our daughteroo wispy?
>>25663372
While that reference sheet is up, I wonder how Ember would look in his style. Being a demon pony with smoky hair and all.
>>25663282
>>25663062
They don't, sorry. Does this make me a hothead?Was that when the trailer leaked, or something?
>>25663282
Pixelate her, cap'n, but a few edits I gotta request.
Make her wear a black school uniform. A blazer, maybe. Up to you.
The flowers, it'd be cool to have a similar amount to what's shown, but put in at least one in her front mane if you can't do them all. Positioning is up to you.
Keep that mane color but give her a more colorful coat, some light shade of azure? Unless that would like terrible, in which case keep this coat color.
'
Lastly, if the original artist is here, thanks man I love you.
>>25663419
Who even is this character?
>>25663419
No wait idea. Swap the coat and mane colors, make her coat azure, and flowers you can disregard, my previous notes still stand, if applicable. Please.
>>25663397
Ember would look pretty cool
>>25663419
This low quality jpeg is Baneposting's greatest relic.
>>25663431
If you're referring to the one in the picture, and not the additional edits, that would be a character from Persona Q, if I recall correctly.
This one, to be exact.
>>25663431
Oh boy I bet this will get me lynched.
A while ago I had some requests done in Draw Thread, most of them just ponifications because my power level is out of this world. I was thinking of character designs for my quest(it'll happen I swear) and realized I had shit. That's when I noticed I had some ponies already that I could rip off. I mean build off, and make something that is slightly original.
That pony is Rei from Persona Q, by the way.
>>25663470
Oh my god I think I remember seeing that post.
>>25663503
Yep.
Are you gonna bully me now?You can use the whip this time.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>>25663503
>>25663505
I meant the bread trap pone here
>>25663282
But that's my fault for linking to the wrong post.
>>25663156
How's this
>>25663540
das it mang
>>25663540
That looks great! Thanks!
>>25663372
You want the disguised version right?
>>25663538
Oh, that's a character from JAD, Cutie Swirl.
>>25663538
Bread trap is best trap from JAD. Cutie Swirl. We're currently working on getting him addicted to our dick.
>>25663759
ready for bullying
secret club going up
https://picarto.tv/TheBirdieBin
>>25663397
Well, there was an attempt.
I might redo this and put more effort into the smoke hair shit later.
>>25663813
You should invite Inept to multi-stream.
>>25663813
Not much of a secret
>>25663830
She glows when you click her. Was this intentional? That's a pretty good feature
>>25663831
I did it.
>>25663830
Looks a bit to much like scars to me.
>>25663860
What? I don't know what you're talking about so probably not.
>>25663894
I thought the same when I was drawing them.
>>25663907
When you click on the picture it gets slightly bigger and the bright red pixels suddenly appear.
>>25663938
That's just 4chan's thumbnail system hiding details I guess.
>>25663938
That's the difference between a jpg thumbnail and a png full image.
>>25663830
How about Cobalt?
http://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/archive/vex/wVmxjkW.jpg
Description: Dark grey coat with a braided midnight blue mane and amber eyes.
Cutiemark: A box with a pony's shadow behind it.
>>25663813
>nips joins in
>they arrive
everytime
>>25663419
Alright, how's this?
>>25664258
Okay folks, time for some good ol' fashion capitalism!
>>25663969
Is this a batpone? Need to know if I should put wings on him or not. Looks like one, but all I can see is the head in your ref.
>>25664408
Yep.
>>25664234
HOLY SHIT THAT'S GREAT THANKS MAN
Also her name will be Eden Paradox.
>>25663969
>>25664411
Alright, I don't know what kind of clothes he's wearing or what color, so I didn't draw them.
I also wasn't sure what kind of box you wanted, so I drew a cardboard one.
I just did whatever for the tail since it wasn't in the ref either.
Anything need changed or is this satisfactory?
>>25664456
Oh. That's a she. I must have missed that detail.Though conveniently she did just gender-bend.
>>25664456
>>25664464
Everything else is fine.
>>25664484
Looks good, thank you.
>>25664464
Reverse trap?
>>25664495
The MC in the story has a gender changing spell. So it's not a reverse trap, but a genuine gender change.
>>25661674Thanks for the sandwich, bby.
Sorry, wine made me want to draw butts instead of continuing quest. Have consolation drawing.
>>25664657
Sorry I'm BathWater and I suck.
bump
this board is going crazy
>>25663830
>>25663660
Fuck yeah
Pffft.
there's another one I'll make later
>>25665704
2 kawaii
>>25665693
wew
>>25665704
uguu
This is a thing.http://i.imgur.com/BkPP9DH.png
>>25666045When I said ghost rapists, I meant like, either incredibly generic pone, or it's just the dick showing and no body raping him.
>>25666086I like it better this way
>>25663282
Please make Sam
>all these Tarafags getting btfo by a sheep
Sassy Sheep CYOA when?
>>25666196
>inb4 lamb chops and sweater jokes
>>25666252
I'd eat her lamb chops if you know what I mean.
>>25666271
Y-you'd eat her kids?
isn't homonculus quest or something supposed to be running today?
>>25666285
Yesterday, actually.
>>25666281
How can you say you love her, when you don't even eat her kids?
>>25666291
shame desu fa-m
>>25666281
Put some mint sauce on them and you are good to go.
>>25666291
>>25666285
i can do it now i suppose. it wont go on for long though
>>25666291
Wrong sir
>>25666419
yeah but later he said >>25666354
>>25666430
Yeah, later as in when tomorrow came.
>>25651377
does anyone else remember the royal guard cyao?
>>25666449
M8 do you know how stupid that makes you sound?
>>25666449
RGS?
>>25666449
There has never been a royal guard cyoa.
>>25666460
And especially no CYAO.
>>25666453
>>25666454
>>25666460
wow it was so long ago
you guys must not remember
>>25666484
Be more specific. There have been tons of CYOAs before /cyoa/. What exactly was it about? Who wrote it? How long did it last?
>>25666179
I can't remember if rki ever specified what her colour scheme was so I just used what was in the group pic on the fanart page.
>>25666513
I think it's a secret plot point.
>>25666513
Of course her color isn't specified. rki only ever makes thing white.
>>25666513
Fucking nice. Thanks familia
>>25666513
Can I get the main Alchemy party?
>>25666558
What are their names?
>>25666650
(clockwise) Speed Thrust, Platinum Nut, Lanika, Jitterbug, Masquerade. And then the breezie is Sachiko.
There is a Speed Thrust already.
>>25666695
fuck i dunno
>>25666674
>dark souls memes
>>25666674
>moot
Who?
>>25666731
Shit get
>>25666558
What's Masquerade's cutie mark?
>>25666781
Now if I had to guess...
>>25663813
>Wake up
>Catch up on what happened
>No one thought to get her coffee
Seriously? Are you fucking joking?
>>25666797
>I can't into order
Masquerade is the unicorn.
>>25666781
It's a mask.
>>25666797
The changeling is Jitterbug.
>>25666751
>>25666781
I assumed it be something like that but I didn't want to just guess
>>25666744
You seemed to have Grabbed Speed's fur color as her hair color.
>>25666840
Since you have a satyr base can you do Halley? She's wearing shorts by the way.Also do you update the dropbox?
paper pones are for bully
>>25666869
What are the colour of her legs?
>>25667038
Well they're... uh...
>>25667038
Wait nevermind I found something
>>25667038
because nips a shit when it comes to satyrs lmao
>>25667082
>Satyr hips
>Fruity hips
T-that's lewd!
>>25667108
We all know that Fruity has a nice butt and hips.
>>25666493
Only one I know about wasn't really that old. /cyoa/ was around then, so its probably not the same one the other guy is thinking of.
Don't remember the QM, but it started as a royal guard, unicorn I think, who recently finished officer school. Then, he gets assigned to a squad of guards in the castle and before he leaves he jacks off to his commanding officer. When he arrives, he meets his new squad and gets to guard Princess Luna, They flirt some, and I think they end up fucking too.
Other than that, the game didn't have very many players, and some parts were more multiple choice than open questions.
>>25667258
That one died from a lack of activity.
>>25667258
oh that one
>>25667167
>>25666867
>>25666840
>>25666751
Thank you pixel anon.
>>25667258
>he jacks off to his commanding officer. When he arrives, he meets his new squad and gets to guard Princess Luna, They flirt some, and I think they end up fucking too.
That sounds vaguely familiar..
But that one didn't last very long, did it? I don't remember too well.
hey uh im doing that thing. i dont think its ggoing great but i tried at least.
>>25666695
>>25666558
Here's the breezie unless you wanted a large not-to-scale version.
>>25666869
I haven't added any of the new stuff from this thread yet, but everything else should be on there.
How's this?
>>25667466
Why the fuck didn't you post here when you started?
>>25667475
Nope, that's exactly what I wanted. Thank you kindly.
paper sandwich when
>>25667483
i did you silly shit, it jsut wasnt as obvious >>25666700
>>25667482
yee
>>25667491
>Can't even announce a new CYOA
>calls other people shit
>>25667491
You have to do better than that, dude.
>>25667496
ah, im sorry. and i didnt call you shit i called you silly.
>>25667511
you said silly shit you meanie
New thread when?
>>25667534
Aww, come and hug me then.
>>25667546
Never.
>>25667546
now
>>25667546
It's over bud.
Horse
murder
Treads
coltshan
WE DID IT REDDIT
What the fuck is happening in that Homonculus CYOA?
Running Crystal Warlock for a while.
>>25668201
The QM talked too much, made character creation too much of a clusterfuck, and then bailed.
>>25668201
homo stuff
>>25668201
>>25668213
It was so sudden.
Let's create this character and all of a sudden OP is like "NOPE I'm out of here"
>>25668213
Given how he acted here a short while back it's probably best he bails now before he makes himself into a meme.
He was just a rookie QM and he surely shook with fright
He checked all his research and mad sure everything was right
He had to sit and listen to those awful players roaro
You ain't gonna quest no more!
>>25667466
>killing it because the character is carrot colored
>>25668213
It's the first super thread all over again.
New thread >>25668531
![1449231898870[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/1FGq0Hx.png "1449231898870[1]")
![1433968131235[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/fu92fLU.jpg "1433968131235[1]")
