[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Has a woman ever written a masterpiece?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /lit/ - Literature

Thread replies: 128
Thread images: 18
File: image.jpg (35 KB, 378x274) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
35 KB, 378x274
Has a woman ever written a masterpiece?
>>
The Making of Americans by Gertrude Stein
>>
>>8248595
yes, please stop posting this thread now
>>
File: poswiatowska-halina.jpg (36 KB, 365x500) Image search: [Google]
poswiatowska-halina.jpg
36 KB, 365x500
mój cień jest kobietą
odkryłam to na ścianie
on się uśmiechał falistością linii
i ptak bioder o zwiniętych skrzydłach
na gałęzi uśmiechu śpiewał


drzewo kwitnące
obwieszone zielonymi papugami
poprzez skrzydła
pomarańcza złota dojrzałość
słońce na kroplach połyska
w deszczu
proste i nagie drzewo
moje usta uchylone piersi

wschodzący księżyc rzęs zamigotał
i zgasł
gdy zdmuchnąłeś zapałki płomień
i oparłeś na ramionach moich dłonie
mój cień był kobietą
nim zniknął
>>
>>8248603
name it
>>
>>8248624
>>>/wsr/
>>
>>8248626
so you can't name a single one?
>>
>>8248664
nice meme
>>
>>8248640
update the thread before you reply. you should also read the sticky before making threads.
>>
>>8248671
embarrassing reply
>>
>>8248679
embarrassing newwb thread desu. learn to sage and triforce too babby.
>>
>>8248624
middlemarch
now please stop making the thread
if you haven't actually read it then you wouldn't understand btw
>>
>>8248682
Summer faggot detected
>>
>>8248682
imbecile
>>
middlemarch, now fuck off
>>
>>8248688
>middlemarch
you would call that a masterpiece? just how low is your bar for masterpieces? don't reply to this post.
>>
>>8248692
>>8248689
>luk mom i r trollzer
so desu ne, baka
>>
Miss MacIntosh, My Darling
>>
>>8248696
>you would call that a masterpiece?
yes

just how low is your bar for masterpieces?
i don't really have patience for "masterpieces" but it's an excellent book that you probably haven't read
>>
>>8248608
This.
>>
>>8248681
bait much?
>>
>>8248722
isak dinesen or george sand then
>>
Look at this image and tell me women are good writers.
>>
>>8248739
women are good writers
>>
>>8248722
yeah i was quoting op what w/e
>>
>>8248595
Has OP ever written a passable shitpost?
>>
Mary Shelley
Because... Frankenstein, duh
>>
>>8248608
To the Lighthouse and Mrs Dalloway are masterpieces also.
>>
>>8248608
This. It's beautiful.
>>
Middlemarch was written by a girl named George
>>
Iris Murdoch wrote some great stuff.
>>
>>8248681
t.slugwizard
>>
File: 20160705_195403-1.jpg (3 MB, 1594x2988) Image search: [Google]
20160705_195403-1.jpg
3 MB, 1594x2988
>>
File: Cringe+comp+21_407f34_5651767.jpg (55 KB, 780x430) Image search: [Google]
Cringe+comp+21_407f34_5651767.jpg
55 KB, 780x430
>>8248739
Look at this image and tell me men are good writters.
>>
>>8248600
>>8248608
>>8248688
These, also
>Tale of Genji
>Jane Eyre
>Pride and Prejudice
>O'Connor's complete stories
>My Antonia
>Beloved
>Persepolis
>>
>>8249388
None of those are masterpieces and you know it, try for Ulysses tier.
>>
File: 1460155003119.gif (1 MB, 392x400) Image search: [Google]
1460155003119.gif
1 MB, 392x400
>>8249388
>mfw that list
>>
>>8249507
>tales of genji
>not ulysses tier
try reading either of them before you wreck yourself like this again bro
>>
>>8249388
>no to the lighthouse
ok kid
>>
>>8249507
ulysses has it's own tier, middlemarch is in the same tier as GR or recognitions
>>
Has man?
>>
File: 1428362130151s.jpg (3 KB, 95x125) Image search: [Google]
1428362130151s.jpg
3 KB, 95x125
>>8249767
wew lad
>>
Also gonna say Middlemarch, it really is a very very good novel, one of the best in the English language.
>>
>>8249779
>>8249767

I can agree with these lads, georgey really has some incredible depth, even if some of the things she says are sweeping generalizations at times, it's a beyond impressive novel, if jane austen was at the helm it'd be about half the length and 3/4th the insight.
>>
File: 1467846333481.jpg (10 KB, 181x297) Image search: [Google]
1467846333481.jpg
10 KB, 181x297
>>
Hamlet
>>
>>8249716
>>8249759
Read U, TOG sounds like classic chic lit desu, all about feels and stuff. Probably some bit in it where they all watch anime', no thanks I'm too educated for that.
>>
The Waves
To the Lighthouse
Frankenstein
Middlemarch
Jane Eyre

just to name a few
>>
>>8249388
Read Jane ( good but not Wuthers) and PnP ( fun but a bit frowsy ) + a bunch o flan stories ( real good), thought the film of Persepolis was a ghastly bore. Would you recc me a translation for T o G based on my reactions to above?
>>
File: mm.webm (3 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
mm.webm
3 MB, 1280x720
>>8249916
>Frankenstein
>>
>>8249908
>tale of the genji
>the world's first novel
>first psychological novel
>about tapping the mother because you're in love with the daughter
>it'll be incomprehensible to you because it relies on a well read reader who is au fait with poetry and proverbs of the time
>chic lit
Yeah, all those chicks into Lolita must have really put you off that too.
>>
>>8248813
Eh, personally I think it's good, very good even, but not a masterpiece. I remember having issues with the fact that all the characters seemed to sound the exact same when they talked, and far too many examples of repeatedly using certain words and phrases (one particular example I remember is the word arduous or some form of it appearing on every other page). Not too mention I found it to be much too direct in some of its ideas. I like some subtelty.
>>
File: fish.jpg (8 KB, 268x188) Image search: [Google]
fish.jpg
8 KB, 268x188
>>8249925
THARRRRRRR SHE BITESSSSSSSSSSSSS
>>
>>8249925
2000 pages without names lul good luck though
>>
>>8249037
After leaving the Night's Watch, Jon Snow discovered anime and cheetos.
>>
>>8249986
>>8249988
kek plebs be plebbin
>>
>>8249996
nah
>>
>>8249388
>Tale of Genji

The first chapter was so beautiful, I couldn't believe how it turned into Sex & the City, Ancient Tokyo so fast
>>
File: sheengunship.png (801 KB, 970x547) Image search: [Google]
sheengunship.png
801 KB, 970x547
>>8248608
[spooiler]overrated
and yea i read it and yea i thought it was dried shite and yea i got its importance but its also boring and not half as beautiful as people on here like to meme it is
>>
File: njafkjn.jpg (38 KB, 552x430) Image search: [Google]
njafkjn.jpg
38 KB, 552x430
>>8250016
hey buddy you better shut your mouth
>>
>>8248595
No
>>
>>8249996
Who u callin a pleb PLEB,
> I call people plebs when they don't swallow my nu-male bullshit
> I pretend to have read books by female authors to look feelzy smart
> I have a sex change every day
> I have a friend is a ghost and who is a faggot ghost called may may
> I go on 4 chan cus I am a masssss plob

I'm a woman btw and you're not even a proper ghost pleb
>>
>>8250088
(you) I guess
>>
>>8250093
I don't understand?
>>
>>8250088
>calling the heian period nu-male bullshit
>i'm a grill btw :3
you do well to retire
>>
File: 1447282554733.gif (929 KB, 264x320) Image search: [Google]
1447282554733.gif
929 KB, 264x320
>buy woman book
>more than half of the book pointing toward internet links
wut
>>
>>8250136
>>more than half of the book pointing toward internet links
is that a thing? title please
>>
>>8248595
to kill a mocking bird
>>
>>8250138
http://www.booktopia.com.au/paranormal-activity-geralyn-st-joseph/prod9781502421944.html this shit
>>
>>8250167
holy fucking shit, i hope you didn't pay money for that
>>
File: 1453740364521.jpg (11 KB, 186x271) Image search: [Google]
1453740364521.jpg
11 KB, 186x271
>>8250183
too late I'm afraid
>>
>>8250217
this meme is so funny lol
>>
THE MOTHERFUCKING FUCKING BOOK FUCK EMMA BY NONE OTHER FUCKER THAN MOTHERFUCKING FAME QUEEN JANE FUCKING AUSTEN FUCKHEAD
>>
No.

Not a single one, nor will they ever. Women simply don't have the emotional profundity or intellectual maturity required to create a truly elevated work of art.
>>
why do you spend you energy perpetuating lazy stereotypes?
Why do you hate women?
>>
>>8249908
>>
>>8250015
Closer to Ancient Kyoto...
but I didn't get any Sex& the City from it...
>>
>>8250499
anon hasn't read it, anon just feels the need to lie about it because anon's an insecure twat
>>
>>8248595
more importantly, why are people so insecure about this that they are actually replying to this thread?
>>
File: he-for-she-logo.jpg (19 KB, 660x660) Image search: [Google]
he-for-she-logo.jpg
19 KB, 660x660
Emma Watson wants to write a novel

I really want to write a novel - Emma Watson

#WhatIReallyReallyWant

Years of art I really do love it, and I'd love to write.
>>
>>8250517
>assuming they're insecure
it's easy pickings, they might just be lazy. it would explain the people who aren't saging their contribution.
>>
>>8250516
it's okay, fyam, I've only read half of it, thought it was about to get bad.
>>
>>8250827
lol, it's not like murasaki bothered to finish it either
>>
Um, what about that little nigger girl who wrote all of Shakespeare's plays? Smdh senpai
>>
>>8248595
Ugh. Why does sexism still exist?
>>
>plebs itt calling fucking middlemarch a masterpiece

Uh huh. How was your first year of literary study, undergraduate?
>>
>>8248608
Lol
>>
>>8248688
Lolol
>>
>>8250837
Didn't mean I wasn't finishing it this week~
Death doesn't count as giving up.
Besides, it was corrupted and rescued a couple time over the centuries, it might've been completed for all we know.
>>
>>8249388
also Wuthering Heights
>>
>>8250912
>tfw grew out of trash like middlemarch
>tfw still enjoy melville and joyce
Feels erudite tbqh
>>
>>8250912
>>8250999
everyone loves feeling superior.
>>
>>8250999
>tfw not a pseud that hates books I haven't even read
>>
>>8251021
Quiet, girl. Men are talking.
>>
>>8248595
Gone with the wind - Margaret Mitchell
>>
>>8251013
Being*
>>8251021
Peasant, go read Landor
>>
>>8250016
Spotted the plen.
>>
>>8248595
Anything by Virginia Woolf
>>
>>8249507
ulysses is hollow. it's not a masterpiece
>>
Apart from the classics,
The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood
The Conservationist by Nadine Gordimer
The God of Small Things by Arundhati Roy
Pat Barker's Regeneration novels
>>
>>8251375
>hollow
mate, it's literally full
>>
>>8251375
kek, the imbeciles on this fucking board
>>
>>8251425
you sound as though you're relying on "but it has to be good because popular sentiment says it is"

be more like >>8251420 who has tried to make a counterargument based in the text, not "people told me so, and people are always right"
>>
>>8248595
You should be more careful with those kinds of threads, lads!
With every post hating on women writers the spirit of Jane Austen gets stronger, until it's finally strong enough to break from its otherworldly sphere and manifest in a spectral form. And then she's going to haunt every shitposter and drive him mad with witty banter.
>>
>>8251432
>be more like
My mistake, I was imitating >>8251375
who "criticizes" one of the greatest writers of all time with a single word and then expects to be taken seriously
>>
>>8251486
my fetish t b h
>>
>>8251489
>people told me he was great so he must be
Even if anon is wrong about Joyce, he's not a fucking echochamber. There're many reasons that spring to mind why anon could be calling the work "hollow". To give only two, but countervailing, points you could take it as critique of: the bathetic style, which is intentional on Joyce's part; the superficial use of foreign terms under the pretense of worldliness, which Joyce attempts to obfuscate.

Meanwhile, you expect other people to take you seriously on Joyce when you couldn't work out any potential argument from anon's use of "hollow", or any potential counterargument besides "it must be good because people told me it's good". You think you're defending Joyce but you're proving that anon's point.
>>
File: 5 star.jpg (49 KB, 351x440) Image search: [Google]
5 star.jpg
49 KB, 351x440
>>8248730
This guy gets it, too bad about the venereal disease, Isak was fine as fuck
Too bad she gets neglected because not everyone considers it 'English' literature, and Danes almost exclusively read Dinesen as Blixen, which is just not the same. It's also a shame when people just read the African Farm when they should be reading something like Anecdotes of Destiny.
>>
>>8251375
I feel like this is an easy sentiment to get, if you only read the book once and take it like any other book - it comes off overwritten and pretentious, but you have to read it more carefully, study, get some footnotes or a guide, don't be so shallow.
>>
>>8250991

It's legit the only book I have ever given up on. Once you get bored of all the phoney elegiac nonsense there's just nothing else to like about it.
>>
>>8250912
>>8250999

Middlemarch is the best novel by an English writer. Only Woolf comes anywhere close to being competition.

>>8249507

Comparing everything to literally the second greatest novel in English is fairly pointless.
>>
>>8249920
>good but not Wuthers

I stopped reading Wuthers midway since I kinda lost interest in it.

It's hilarious how the heroine and her love interest are both kinda horrible people. What a damn crazy family they are.
>>
>>8251415
>The Handmaid's Tale

What a fucking SJW book. The lead is such a fucking slut.
>>
File: Dickens_Gurney_head[1].jpg (160 KB, 814x1190) Image search: [Google]
Dickens_Gurney_head[1].jpg
160 KB, 814x1190
>>8251486
Don't worry. I'll summon the spirit of my boy Charles Dickens to repel her. His humor is superior after all.
>>
>>8252928
I wish I can find Dickens' response to Charlotte Bronte calling Esther shit.
>>
Woolf many times
>>
>>8252918

A slut is just a woman with the morals of a man.
>>
>>8253005
you seem extremely triggered
>>
>>8253005

Aha, a fellow enlightened one on the path of the Redpill!

*tips fedora*
>>
>>8252913
I really liked that about it, I thought it was kind of brilliant how much compassion I had for these two twisted fucks, testament to the power of love.
>>
>>8252767
U is the 4th best pleb. Try NU-MALE FEMINIST SCUM

> I took one social studies class now I go on the best lit websites and try and say women can write becuase I hate meritocraceary

> I have never read Ocean's 11 or any real tier shit like Eros and Spoon
>>
>>8253001
Wrong: a slut is a woman with the morals of a woman. Are you a woman? If you are I will fight you and I will win because I am a black belt and I beat up my mom and sister yesterday and now they're dead.
>>
>>8253058

No I'm not a woman but I have a spyderco pocketknife so you better watch out champ.
>>
>>8253051
>meritocraceary
>>
>>8253063
You have a pocket knife? Are you fucking threatening me? You >>8253271
wanna meritocraceary you leave that knife at home and just see what happens I'm serious
>>
>>8253063
>>8253271
I'M SERIOUS
>>
>>8248664
American "education"...
Also, yes, "mémoires d'Hadrien", Marguerite Yourcenar
>>
>>8249991
*sticks fingers in ears*
LALALA we don't know who that is round here LALALA
Thread replies: 128
Thread images: 18

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.