[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why did Japan steal all of China's culture?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /int/ - International

Thread replies: 222
Thread images: 50
File: earlychinesepainting.jpg (3 MB, 1708x1097) Image search: [Google]
earlychinesepainting.jpg
3 MB, 1708x1097
Why did Japan steal all of China's culture?
>>
File: LiuSongnianHouse.jpg (105 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
LiuSongnianHouse.jpg
105 KB, 640x480
>>
the ideological supermarket is fit only for looting
>>
no they gave us tolerantly
>>
File: Temujin.png (507 KB, 490x586) Image search: [Google]
Temujin.png
507 KB, 490x586
>>57516154
I dunno but mongols destroyed some ancient chinese kingdom and their culture completely. Only few relics survived i guess.
>>
>>57516154
nips are too dumb to create anything by themselves.
>>
Even samurai armor is inspired/copied from Chinese armor.
>>
>>57516154
if you paint something with only ink, products become similar things
>>
File: Hokusai.jpg (114 KB, 736x519) Image search: [Google]
Hokusai.jpg
114 KB, 736x519
Did Japan steal the concept of tentacle love from China as well?
>>
At least the Japs didn't cuck themselves with a Jewish commie ideology.
>>
many of them came to Japan and gave us,
and they destroyed their culture before and after that.
>>
>>57516154
Meanwhile, some Japanese people say "China stole Japanese things", "Chinks don't create anything on their own".
Let say my opinion, Japan has imitated some things from China (e,g. Kanji characters), China has imitated from Japan. (e,g. fake goods)
It makes sense that thinking they've been influenced each other.
>>
Ancient China invented gunpowder and compass,
Britain killed them using those.
American glorious Guns are copy of China's.
>>
Ancient Chinese secret.
>>
>>57516546
We have many books about ancient China, modern Chinese can know lots of things from those.
>>
>>57516154
>>57516356
the Chinese paintings and weapons were originally copied from somewhere more or less in the same way.

any cultures and cilvilization can't be spread to other areas without coping and learning originals.
>>
File: wtfjapan.jpg (130 KB, 693x482) Image search: [Google]
wtfjapan.jpg
130 KB, 693x482
Wow, even architectural styles that I thought were characteristically Japanese turned out to be early Chinese in origin
>>
File: 1442852343429.jpg (12 KB, 250x241) Image search: [Google]
1442852343429.jpg
12 KB, 250x241
>>57516483
>>57516387
>>57516526
>>57516712
>>57516804

>maximum damage control
>>
>>57516154
lel are you even trying, chang?
just take a look at their internet, you can't see literally ANY web page without seeing stuff stolen from japanese culture.
emoji, meme, anime, manga, character design, art style, etc, etc, literally EVERYTHING is from japan.

http://tieba.baidu.com/
>>
>>57516154
where can I find these arts in modern china?
>>
>>57517207

Too late, China got cucked by Mongols, then Manchus. Like Britain, you should count yourself lucky to be on an island. Literally saved you from back-to-back civilization-destroying barbarians.
>>
File: 1442853735872.jpg (54 KB, 395x401) Image search: [Google]
1442853735872.jpg
54 KB, 395x401
>>57517057
>"b-but we havu anime! manga!"
>>
>>57517054
you don't know the difference between copy and steal?
>damage control
It's about you.
>>
lets be fair lads

japan is currently more creative than china

japan is an island whereas china is connected to other shit and they got ideas from other shit probably so they got a head start

now china is communist and japan is free which would explain the current situation

so its impossible to put it down to race

what is possible to put down to race is they'll never be as creative as white people
>>
China was the cultural powerhouse of the region forever, Korea, Tibet, Mongolia, and Vietnam were all heavily sinicized taking Chinese script, words, art, clothing, religion, political structures, military innovations, food and technologies from China well into the 19th century
>>
File: 1458291757230s.jpg (6 KB, 249x249) Image search: [Google]
1458291757230s.jpg
6 KB, 249x249
>>57517239
>b-b-but we havu paintings literally nobody would care, had it not been for similar japanese stuff
>>
File: definitionofcuckdom.jpg (188 KB, 1048x810) Image search: [Google]
definitionofcuckdom.jpg
188 KB, 1048x810
>>57517236

desu modern China is the one country that got cucked out of their own culture more than any other country on Earth.
>>
>>57516154
>paper
>gunpowder
>mariner's compass
>printings

Why did your countries steal Chinese inventions?
>>
>>57517377

The kimono, traditional hairstyle, architecture, kanji, bonsai, tea ceremony, etiquette, hierarchical social mores, most of your higher-concept vocabulary, and a million other things all have Chinese origins. I'm struggling to find a single thing that is uniquely and originally Japanese. Maybe shinto, but even that was mostly an invented 19th century concept (not to mention that the word shinto itself is borrowed from Chinese for "path of the gods")
>>
>>57517361
>>57517361
>China was the cultural powerhouse of the region forever
>was
modern china is just a shithole where there are no cultural art and products to contribute others
but working like cattle for massive production in factory.
>>
>>57517640
Fortune Cookies and video gaems
>>
>>57517356
on top of that, ancient china had a massive population of that time as well.
take an example around 1000 BC when they invented chinese characters - china's population was already over 10 million while japan about 100,000. a single large city of china had a larger population than the entire japan's.
>>
File: 1458712944470.jpg (48 KB, 428x413) Image search: [Google]
1458712944470.jpg
48 KB, 428x413
Why did europeans steal all roman culture?
>>
>>57516154
>Confucianism
>copying without improving
>a low standard of living

Japanese have rejected some of Chinese culture.
>>
>>57516154
Ancient China had been a cultural leader of all Asia, but modern China isn't.
>>
>>57517779

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edo_Neo-Confucianism

latter two the result of political/economic, not cultural factors. Modern Mainland China is as much an exemplar of traditional Chinese culture as North Korea is an exemplar of traditional Korean culture.
>>
>>57517894
I mean influence of Confucianism were rejected from Japan for these 20 years.
>>
>>57517894
>Modern Mainland China is as much an exemplar of traditional Chinese culture as North Korea is an exemplar of traditional Korean culture.

What??
Both of best and worst korea have continued using Chinese culture and both have little original culture.
Are you a follower of Koreans?
>>
>>57517695
Because the Romans stole from Etruscan culture
>>
>>57517640
It's almost like people trade, shares idea, adapt and reinvent...
>>
>>57518100

No, but hilariously, you are.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2001/dec/28/japan.worlddispatch
>>
>>57517464
But the newer one looks better, they were more cucks earlier under Manchurians weren't they?
>>
>>57518185

there's a difference between trading, which is mutual, and taking, which is one-sided. Historically, the cultural movement in East Asia was purely from China to Japan, and China took very little from its Eastern neighbor. Though admittedly, modern Chinese enjoy anime and manga.
>>
>>57517640
u know the differ between word and language?
>>
>>57516154
China was the only relevant country in the far east for millenia. Japs were just a bunch of irrelevant savages up until recently.
It's obvious..
>>
>>57518191
If Japanese were Koreans descendants, why cannot only Koreans get the Nobel prizes except the peace prize?
Is Korean education system so retarded?
>>
>>57517640
>>57517640
u don't know God without words?
shonto is a general term. we always don't use the word, children don't know it but go jinja= shrine.
Kokka Shinto not= Shinto
maybe you want to say about Kokka Shinto in Meiji era, it's also change by era.
>>
>>57517640
In your theory, kimchi is as same as Chinese sauerkraut.
>>
>>57518517

Probably, actually. All rote memorization and training and no time for creative thought is useful for mass-producing efficient workers but ineffective at producing creating thinkers and scientists. Modern communist China has the same problem. The vast majority of ethnic Chinese Nobel laureates are Taiwanese/Hongkongese/oversease Chinese.
>>
>>57518616
>>
>>57516154
t. chang
>>
File: 1438852778655.jpg (18 KB, 213x291) Image search: [Google]
1438852778655.jpg
18 KB, 213x291
>>57518517
>>57518599
>>57518637
>>
I want to say a Jinja in my town is differ from Meiji Jinguu, Izumo, and Ise.
but those all are called shinto.
>>
>>57517640
whenever I see Chinese people persisting in meaningless arguments and being proud of cultural origin, I always get ashamed of being east-Asian..

I have never met even a Greece and Italian anywhere who are proud just of the "origin of European culture".
>>
File: jpp.jpg (12 KB, 300x250) Image search: [Google]
jpp.jpg
12 KB, 300x250
>>57518333
And yet everything that you have cited, are now renowned japanese cultural elements...
>>
>>57518732

You've obviously never met a Greek. Italians != Romans.
>>
>>57518665
Understood.
You mean Japan had stolen Chinese culture for a long time. but now as both Koreans and Modern Chinese culture are retarded, Japan cannot steal anything from them.

Agreed.
>>
File: 1456232928232.jpg (436 KB, 1412x1000) Image search: [Google]
1456232928232.jpg
436 KB, 1412x1000
Why did the west steal japan women
>>
>>57516154
They were Rome or Greek of the east.
>>
>>57518732

also, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_nationalism#1830s_to_1848

Greece, and Italy to an extent, have a right to be proud of their culture. And they have been. Neo-Roman nationalism was a rallying cry for Italians in the 19th century, and modern Greeks will not stop lecturing the Germans about how they are the origin of Western civilization so plz gib debt relief.
>>
>>57516154
People trade culture, especially when one place develops culture first.

Big deal
>>
>>57518765
not only Greek and Italian, but also other European people except stupid nationalist don't care about where is the cultural origin.
because all of the countries in Europa have influenced each other for centuries.

Do you really mean that china have never been influenced by Japanese at the every points since the founding of china?.
>>
>>57518732

The reason why the disputes between China and Japan are so heated is because there is ongoing political antagonism between the two countries. In better times, conversations about culture would be less heated. The thing is that the Chinese got so gob-smacked and humiliated in the last 200 years that they look to their illustrious past as a way to reclaim their national prestige. Which they should. Two hundred years of humiliation should not overrule 3000+ years of prestige.
>>
>>57519032

Prior to the 19th century, when Japan adopted European culture on a massive scale, name a single Chinese borrowing from Japan.
>>
>>57517640
The only reason Japan is where it's today was entirely due to at first China/Korea and then western civilization. If it weren't for those two Japan would just be like Papua New Guinea.
>>
>>57519032

And I would hardly consider the founders of Italy, like the brilliant Mazzini, to be stupid nationalists.
>>
>>57517640
>The kimono, architecture, kanji, bonsai
very classic, and how much can they compensate for numerous stuff modern china's been stealing from japan?

>traditional hairstyle,
ayy lmao

>tea ceremony,
china's tea ceremony is totally different from japan's

>etiquette, hierarchical social mores,
every society before modern age had hierarchical social mores

>most of your higher-concept vocabulary,
and vice versa that of modern china is full of japanese made kanji-words.
kek, they can't even spell their own current country name without using japanese made words!

>and a million other things all have Chinese origins. I'm struggling to find a single thing that is uniquely and originally Japanese
actually, almost all of stuff like samurai, ninja, sumo, kabuki, nou, jujutsu, judo, sado, katana, ukiyoe, etc. etc., which are frequently cited on pop culture and are familiar to world, were independently developed in japan. certainly china might have their own martial arts, warriors, plays, weapons etc that are similar to japan's but it doesn't mean they weren't originated in japan. by your rationale, i don't see any 'unique' culture on the planet.

>Maybe shinto, but even that was mostly an invented 19th century concept
shinto is a mishmash of indigenous pagan
>(not to mention that the word shinto itself is borrowed from Chinese for "path of the gods")
ayy, lmao

conclusion: you are dumb and delusional
>>
>>57519122
u know script and sound language?
>>
>>57516256
Mongols united china. They made china fit to have culture.
>>
File: 321.jpg (59 KB, 642x434) Image search: [Google]
321.jpg
59 KB, 642x434
>>57516154
In your theory, Did Vincent van Gogh stole ukiyo-e?

Culture should be exchanged.
>>
>>57519032

Furthermore, it's true that the British, for example, borrowed from Roman and Greek culture heavily, but never to the same extent that Japan borrowed from Chinese culture. If you look back at traditional Japanese culture before the 19th century, it is practically indistinguishable from, say, Tang Dynasty China, whereas you can very easily distinguish Britain from Rome.
>>
>>57516154
t. Chang.

A true American wouldn't be talking about culture.
>>
>>57519237

The Qin Dynasty united China under imperial rule. Previous to that, China had previously been under nominally-united feudal rule under the Zhou and Shang dynasties (similar to feudal Japan, although that's more convergent evolution than borrowing).
>>
I'm under the impression that a lot of traditions in Japan were originally "imported" from the mainland but through the ages developed on their own.
>>
lol if China is so great why the fuck did your family leave it?
>>
i really like this thing

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/32/Along_the_River_7-119-3.jpg
>>
>>57519576
Pretty much.


>>57519176
>kek, they can't even spell their own current country name without using japanese made words!
lie
>>
>>57519176

>tea ceremony
nope

>social mores
Japanese social mores are explicitly Confucian-inspired

>higher-concept vocabulary
lol, not even worth responding to because this is so obviously false. The number of Japanese-made kanji borrowed back into Chinese is not very large.

>okay, but even the the Japanese martial arts tradition was inspired by Chinese martial arts, the katana is ultimately derived from the tangdao of the Tang dynasty, and as for ukiyoe... well the Chinese invented woodblock painting, although of course the Japanese created their distinct style. The samurai were originally a rank created by the Taika Reform, an edict that forced the Japanese aristocracy to adopt the Tang dynasty political structure, bureaucracy, culture, religion, and philosophy. Of course Japan later made their own styles and sometimes improved it, in my opinion, but don't be so delusional as to deny that 95% of the culture you anti-Chinese Japanese nationalists are so proud of is of Chinese origin.
>>
>>57519578
I'm white.

Why the fuck are you in Cambodia? Boipucci?
>>
>>57519366
I'm not sure whether you properly understand what 'china" was.

china has not been even a nation but area being equivalent to "Europa"
so there are a lot of cultures, characthers and languages of different tribes and people.
china changed their systems and cultural direction whenever as the dynasties collapsed.

>indistinguishable
I'm not sure why you think so.
but when I heard this word, I get aware of the fact that your perspective to china is very similar to the perspective of current communist party in china.
you can't recognize the concept of cultural diversity.
>>
>>57519769
Sure pal, and I'm the Queen of England.

No white person would go this far for a communist nation
>>
Learn comparative linguistics and comparative mythology.
And Go home, China.
>>
>>57519734
in their current name of 中华人民共和国, only 中华 is chinese origin word.
人民 is a japanese made kanji word that means people and 共和国, meaning republic, as well.
>>
File: a0198131_17184765.jpg (23 KB, 375x243) Image search: [Google]
a0198131_17184765.jpg
23 KB, 375x243
>>57519366
for example, when the Manchu people ruled china, none of us appear like that.
>>
>>57519814

>china has not been even a nation but area being equivalent to "Europa"

The comparison to Europe as a whole is wrong. Europe is a mismatch of people with disparate ethnic and linguistic origins. The differences between a Russian, a Hungarian, and an Englishman are far greater, ethnically, genetically, culturally, and historically, than that between any subgroup of Han Chinese people. China is best compared to Germany, which, although an amalgam of different dialects and often politically fractured, is still composed of people of the same ethnicity, linguistic heritage, and history, and therefore form one national entity.
>>
>>57519985

That's Manchu culture, not Chinese culture. Also, we're strictly discussing historical China, not communist China or even Qing China.
>>
>>57520003
there have been a lot of diverse tribes such as Turkic, Persian and Slav still now in china
>>
>>57520173

Those people aren't Chinese in any significant sense beyond perhaps an artificial political one, whereas Hungarians and Slavs are definitely Europeans. Your comparison is wrong.
>>
>>57516154
Why did Americans steal all of Indian land?
>>
>>57520047
I totally wonder why you can tell Manchu culture from Chinese one,
even though it is impossible for you to distinguish Japanese culture and Chinese one.
>>
>>57520318

Easy, Manchu culture is completely different from traditional Chinese culture, whereas, as I have shown, medieval Japanese culture was practically lifted wholesale from Tang dynasty China.
>>
File: xinsrc_252090217073850054143.jpg (58 KB, 500x371) Image search: [Google]
xinsrc_252090217073850054143.jpg
58 KB, 500x371
>>57520273
Chinese govenment appear to treat them as a kind of Chinese.
>>
>>57518464
Well, they were the exact equality of you in East Asia
>>
File: manchu_chinese_japanese.png (1 MB, 1059x495) Image search: [Google]
manchu_chinese_japanese.png
1 MB, 1059x495
>>57520318

Can you tell which one is the odd-one-out?
>>
>>57520405
I'm not sure why you are persisting in your view.
>>
>>57520436

The current Chinese government is a disgrace to China.
>>
File: image.jpg (139 KB, 900x622) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
139 KB, 900x622
>>57516154
Who cares. everyone was Korean.
>>
>>57520669
>증산도
>Pseudoscientific
>>
File: Ashikaga_Takauji_Jōdo-ji.jpg (2 MB, 1770x1770) Image search: [Google]
Ashikaga_Takauji_Jōdo-ji.jpg
2 MB, 1770x1770
>>57520576
Japanese male aristocrats didn't wear such clothes in medieval era.
>>
File: manchu_chinese_kanji.png (1 MB, 1420x689) Image search: [Google]
manchu_chinese_kanji.png
1 MB, 1420x689
>>57520600

Can you tell which one is the odd one out? Manchu on the left, Chinese in the center, Japanese on the right.
>>
>>57520576
>>57520839
>Wercome ou holseliding overllolds
>>
>>57519985
Any way I see it, that's the shittest hairdo ever conceived by man.
>>
>>57520986

Agreed. I don't understand why more Chinese people aren't redpilled about the Qing Dynasty. Absolutely destroyed Chinese culture.
>>
>>57516154
Because they were unironically stione-tool-using hunter-gatherers before being civilized by the Chinese.
>>
They just forked it on git hub. It's better than what the commies did to it.
>>
>>57520765

alright, you got me. I concede defeat.
>>
>>57516356

Nope, however wretched their current state, the Chinese can still claim the title of one of the few original civilizations in human history. Very little of their culture is borrowed. For example, writing arose independently only three times in the entire history of humanity. Of those three, two, Sumeria and Mesoamerica, are extinct. The Chinese are the only surviving civilization to have invented writing independent of external influence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_writing
>>
>>57521359

meant to reply to the responder.
>>
>>57518732

This is rich, coming from the nation infamous for getting into meaningless, childish, and incoherent arguments with the Koreans
>>
China is good country yeah
>>
>>57522387

Modern communist China is a terrible country. Historical China was one of the great achievements of human civilization, and it is sad that we may never recover it from the ravages of the Manchu yoke and communist banditry.
>>
>>57521165
Japan had a hard on for Middle-Chinese culture. It's influence lasted for generations while the Chinese themselves moved on to edgier stuff like MONGOLS, BUDDHIST FUNDAMENTALISTS, and of course ASIAN DOTHRAKI a.k.a the Manchus
>>
>>57519768
>nope
yes it is

>Japanese social mores are explicitly Confucian-inspired
that's a pretty shallow observation. one of the reasons why only japan managed to modernize in east asia is because they didn't make a commitment to confucianism that much unlike korea.

>The number of Japanese-made kanji borrowed back into Chinese is not very large.
not kanji character itself but words. it's quite massive.

>okay, but even the the Japanese martial arts tradition was inspired by Chinese martial arts,
there is no such fact. martial arts aren't so uncommon thing in the world to begin with. every culture has its own martial arts. jujutsu for example is a close combat skill for samurai in case of losing their weapons, and sumo was a religious ceremony.

>the katana is ultimately derived from the tangdao of the Tang dynasty,
iron swords are ultimately derived from ancient orient as well then.

>and as for ukiyoe... well the Chinese invented woodblock painting, although of course the Japanese created their distinct style.
so what's the problem here? china invented woodblock painting and japan, europeans, etc, adopted that and developed their own styles independently.

>The samurai were originally a rank created by the Taika Reform,
what's so special about creating a warrior occupation? did china invent government paid warriors?
there have been literally countless warrior occupations in the world.

>but don't be so delusional as to deny that 95% of the culture you anti-Chinese Japanese nationalists are so proud of is of Chinese origin.
i'm not even anti-chinese but just saying facts.
>>
>>57516154
Japan invented modern Chinese words so called 和製漢語, like economy経済, science科学, philosophy哲学, communism共産主義, politics政治, civilization文明, etc. And 5 Chinese characters out of 7 for People's Rebulic China中華人民共和国 are those Japanese invented words (人民 共和国). Without Japan, Chinese people cannot write own their country name in Chinese.
>>
>>57522647
>that's a pretty shallow observation. one of the reasons why only japan managed to modernize in east asia is because they didn't make a commitment to confucianism that much unlike korea.
To be fair on that one you kinda swoop in and fuck them when they were trying to westernized
>>
>>57516483
romans had fake goods
>>
>>57522789

Russia had fake cities
>>
>>57522658
Pretty damn sure they would have called it something else
>>
>>57524814
You are welcome .
But you "emperor" got buthurt about we buying slaves that your nobles sold to us.

Fucking chinks
>>
Surely many systems and cultures were modeled after China till Edo Period.
And Perry Expedition changed this.
After Japan had known western civilization, Japan modeled after western countries.

And then Japan could be a strong country unlike China and Korea.
>>
>>57516154
There is nothing special about China, it's all about that massive population. Civilizations almost automatically rise when a certain region comes to have a large population, which mostly depended on crops in ancient times. If your people are lucky enough to live in a region that has large fertile lands, cultivable crops, proper climate and fair water supplies, then the population increases pretty much and consequently administrative institutions to govern people emerge, in which letters, laws and numerous other stuff known to be the essentials of civilization. The region called as China today, having over 13 million of population in as early as 2200 BC and 60 million in 2 AD, was one of the few places that satisfied the conditions on the planet and was inevitable to have a civilization, from which numerous cultural stuff derived as well. So, it's absurd to ask why the culture spread to Japan, which had barely a hundredth of population of China in ancient age.
>>
>>57524933

It can't be that Westernization alone propelled Japan to the first rank of Asian nations. I think you're not giving your East Asian (read: Sinic) cultural heritage enough credit. Think about it. The /only/ industrialized and developed nations in Asia besides Middle Eastern oil sheikhdoms and the European settler-colony of Israel are: Japan, Taiwan, Hong Kong, South Korea, and Singapore. All of these share a common cultural heritage, which suggests that that culture might be responsible for their success rather than Westernization per se, because if westernization were the key to success, then why isn't India, which was ruled by Englishmen, speaks English, adopted Westminster-style parliamentary democracy, and has Cambridge/Oxford-educated leaders, the greatest superpower in the world?
>>
File: zuera-huehue.jpg (33 KB, 264x227) Image search: [Google]
zuera-huehue.jpg
33 KB, 264x227
>>57517640
you could say the same about Western Civilization and Roman Empire/Ancient Greece 2bh
>>
>>57526827

>citation needed.

Why didn't civilization develop on the fertile banks of the Mississippi or along the great rivers of Europe, where it had to be borrowed from others? And China is hardly the Asian state most conducive to agricultural civilization. The early Chinese had to contend with massive floods and natural disasters that caused immense hardship, forcing them to use their wits to engineer solutions to problems that other people often had the advantage of ignoring.

Furthermore, the earliest recorded civilizations emerged in the Fertile Crescent, which, despite its name, was actually not very conducive to agriculture. The bounty of the Tigris and the Euphrates could only be managed with a massive human effort to dig irrigation canals and construct critical infrastructure.
>>
>>57526827
Indonesia?
>>
>>57518810
>sex with socks on
>>
sigh... Chicomm 50cent party is very active again...
>>
>>57520047
manchus is part of chinese culture and identity whether you like it or not

modern chinese dress for example is basically tight manchu qipao

unless you mean chinese = han then maybe its correct
>>
>>57532949
I think they would be more interested and invested in their own forums and boards not 4chan lol
>>
>>57535968

By Chinese, I mean Han. It's laughable to think that the Tibetans or the Mongols have a claim on Chinese culture. I would be in favor of letting them declare independence in order to have, as much as possible, a Han nation state. Japan has shown us that ethno-cultural cohesion and nationalism is a great strength.
>>
File: ChineseSoccer.jpg (21 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
ChineseSoccer.jpg
21 KB, 480x360
the Qing dynasty was established by Joshin tribe in Manchuria, kicking butts of Hans....
>>
>>57516154
Why did America steal all of Europe's culture?
>>
>>57539812
because at the time the earlier american founders by creating a first true democracy were very influenced by early greek culture opposed to modern greek and modern latin culture
>>
File: 1459108695805.png (1 MB, 800x1800) Image search: [Google]
1459108695805.png
1 MB, 800x1800
>>57517464
Chinese history is both the best and the worst of Asia. They prospered the most when times were good, but they also suffered the most when times were bad. They probably got invaded and conquered more than any other country in the world outside of Egypt.
>>
>>57539656
>>57541578
Yeah, but where are they now? Oh that's right. They got cucked by Han Chinese and now they're eternally cucked and irrelevant. Their land is ours now. The only reason why Japan never got invaded was because it was too irrelevant and too far away.
>>
Because it was the cool hotness back then
>>
>>57516154
>Talking about stealing culture
>BURGER
>>
File: 唐閻立本王會圖(倭).jpg (101 KB, 400x602) Image search: [Google]
唐閻立本王會圖(倭).jpg
101 KB, 400x602
This is a Japanese envoy to Tang China in the 7th century. This is how Japanese people dressed before adopting Chinese culture.
>>
File: ChinesePoopAtBurberry.jpg (76 KB, 900x462) Image search: [Google]
ChinesePoopAtBurberry.jpg
76 KB, 900x462
>>57544217
doesn't he look more civilized than Chinese tourists in the 21st century?
>>
File: ChinaToilet.jpg (66 KB, 600x600) Image search: [Google]
ChinaToilet.jpg
66 KB, 600x600
>>57544217
and still you don't wear pants...
>>
>>57544576
>>57544670
Why are you so sensitive?
>>
File: 5921421194.jpg (14 KB, 580x359) Image search: [Google]
5921421194.jpg
14 KB, 580x359
I was about to say the teeth blackening but recalled that we have minorities with similar practice.
>>
>>57516154
so what? culture borrowing happen all the time, are you some butthurt chinese diaspora jealous of japanese culture popularity?
>>
File: PoliceStomping.jpg (9 KB, 222x227) Image search: [Google]
PoliceStomping.jpg
9 KB, 222x227
>>57545823
calm down, at least your CCP invented a cool stomping game

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtzmKa43w1A
>>
>>57547023
Why are you being so offended? I thought this was about Chinese culture, not modern CCP society. I agree that the CCP has problems but things are constantly improving while Japan is going through its second Lost Decade. I just posted a picture of an original Japanese man but you are being an asspained imbecile over it.
>>
>>57517640
weebs BTFO
>>
File: ChineseSexOffendersCalifornia.jpg (66 KB, 986x655) Image search: [Google]
ChineseSexOffendersCalifornia.jpg
66 KB, 986x655
>>57547486
things are improving or degenerating? how many times have you been arrested, Mr.Chang?
>>
File: 8c89a590f56e16d1fc2c01.jpg (739 KB, 911x620) Image search: [Google]
8c89a590f56e16d1fc2c01.jpg
739 KB, 911x620
>>57536779
do you know there's an eccentric movement in china to revive han costume and culture in preference over modern manchu influenced culture?

its called hanfu movement and guess what, it got shunned by most chinese and the government

also han costumes are not exactly the same as japan, they're more colourful and more ornamental
>>
>>57547800
I've never been arrested. But I'm sure you would be if someone saw all the pedo cartoons in your computer.
>>
>>57548598
no one would be arrested for pedo cartoons on their computer in japan, not in most states of the usa, not in germany and similar not in most european countries. not sure about the british they had some weird laws regarding that so maybe.
>>
>>57522474
>the most stable, prosperous, and peaceful time in Chinese history
>horrible
>>
>>57548591
>shunned by the government

Source required
>>
Japanese culture is straight up copy pasta from Tang dynasty
>>
Why did Spain steal all of Italy's culture?
Why did the Netherlands steal all of Italy's culture?
>>
No one can believe the fuct that chinese are bliliant in old days.
>>
>>57547800

At least half the people on this list aren't even Chinese. And this is rich, coming from the nation famous for pedophile porn, bizarre sexual perversions, subway groping, organized rape parties at major universities, etc. If you live in a glass house, don't throw stones at others, Tanaka-san.
>>
>>57530634
>Why didn't civilization develop on the fertile banks of the Mississippi or along the great rivers of Europe, where it had to be borrowed from others?
Because they didn't have proper crops to support a massive population which is crucial for civilizations to emerge. It's no coincidence that civilizations appeared in regions like Mesopotamia, Egypt, Indus and China that lie on the point/proximity of origin of major crops like barley/wheat/rice. The earlier you start the earlier your population reaches the point where you need an administrative system to keep them going - the civilization. As for China, they had a population of over 10 million in 2000 BC while Japan only 100,000 and reached 10 million around barely the 17th century.
>>
>>57551629
Stop grasping at straws, Ken-kun. You already lost. Go watch some hentai to release your pent-up energy.
>>
File: yamato soldier 6AD.jpg (335 KB, 670x957) Image search: [Google]
yamato soldier 6AD.jpg
335 KB, 670x957
>>57544217
That's bullshit though.
An unearthed clay image from 6th century shows how they looked like and it has no such southern asian taste.
>>
File: images.jpg (9 KB, 299x168) Image search: [Google]
images.jpg
9 KB, 299x168
>>57552181
You're quite dumb.

Here's another one of Japanese attire before adopting Chinese culture.
>>
File: shokukouzu.jpg (34 KB, 300x499) Image search: [Google]
shokukouzu.jpg
34 KB, 300x499
I used google to find a better quality picture.
>>
File: auto-fake-HDD-flash-china.jpg (81 KB, 704x856) Image search: [Google]
auto-fake-HDD-flash-china.jpg
81 KB, 704x856
>>57549466
you Chinese are genius in fact
I didn't come up this nice idea
>>
File: anti-Japan-TV-program.png (509 KB, 549x348) Image search: [Google]
anti-Japan-TV-program.png
509 KB, 549x348
>>57551520
Not mainlanders but these sex offenders are Chinese decent.
And here is anti-Japanese drama made by CCP.
Good thing is these porn dramas have been aired on public TV for free!
>>
>>57552905
>Japan talking about nudes on TV
You don't do that anymore?
>>
>>57552171
It's you, my 5 cent party friend. It's nothing but civilization 101.
>>
>>57552905

>Koreans and Hmongs
>Chinese
>>
File: chinese-sex-scandal.jpg (30 KB, 475x389) Image search: [Google]
chinese-sex-scandal.jpg
30 KB, 475x389
>>57553034
On paid channel yes, on public TV no. I missed those good old days...

>>57552542
how many times I have to tell you, even high ranked CCP officials (like a secretary of Anhui Prov., deputy secretary, party leader at Hefei Univ) in the 21st century do not wear pants, the ancient Japanese man looks much more civilized.
>>
>>57552905
That's hot. I freaking love plump Asian booty.

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a23_1434026072
>>
>>57553596
nice Chinese kinky porn, keep posting more!
>>
>>57553851
Someone posted these on /pol/

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=487_1457090676
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=397_1455966786
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a23_1434026072
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=d2b_1444573929
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=368_1442639331
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=531_1413048556
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=727_1411362172
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=d24_1456415250
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=e76_1447389558
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=595_1435388432
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=bba_1331920866
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=335_1445351308
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=e7e_1404016517
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=2e6_1447949923
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=1d3_1442633470
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=6fa_1440229735
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=475_1448182725
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a51_1390302941
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=bc1_1364027775
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=b76_1451316531
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=b5f_1451370182
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=67b_1451390380
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=37d_1452532422
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=826_1450864386
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=649_1449916666
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=03c_1449820926
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=0ff_1436517598
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=eee_1274814827
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=953_1419758703
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=167_1441373833
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=30b_1456211021
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=d0b_1406106784
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=69b_1429912492
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=1a5_1446812830
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=509_1435070718
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=3db_1402495744
>>
>>57543849
>talking about stealing culture
>CANADA
>>
>>57554111
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=f01_1408275521
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=65f_1446300031
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=7d8_1446184202
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=765_1457011029
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=3bd_1443328619
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=eb2_1442830304
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=961_1438418211
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=fdc_1441467293
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=9ea_1340724063
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=04b_1443302525
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=5d1_1448432612
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=2d6_1437924630
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=8c3_1447859005
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=c0a_1444973007
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=0c1_1444888142
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=778_1444827906
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=790_1443690488
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a6b_1443061123
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=944_1443011011
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=307_1440756329
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=d06_1407326488
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=dd0_1383485074
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=590_1435681594
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=458_1424618846
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=282_1435344724
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=fbc_1435028767
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=1b2_1415013477
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=e39_1410271375
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=96e_1400662246
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=753_1399365390
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=bf3_1394602684
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=1ef_1330368283
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=fa8_1456799185
>>
>>57553596
>>57554111
>>57554135

why are the chinese so barbaric?
>>
>>57554111
You're a disgusting piece of shit. Do you even realize how sick and twisted you are to collect and enjoy videos like that? I hope you're not insinuating that this is a normal thing in China, because it's obviously not, retard. Is sticking eels up your ass a normal thing in Japan because some girls do it? Anyway, you are fucked in the head. Go get some help.
>>
>>57554367
Are you dense? That's like claiming Brits and Americans are "barbaric" based solely on the behavior of pikeys or hicks or ghetto thugs.
>>
Why did China steal all of Indian's culture?
>>
WE WUZ QINGS AN SHIIET
>>
>steal

You can't steal culture. But no, Japan copy from Korea and Chinese copy from Korea
>>
>>57520274
Because we can and nobody could stop us
>>
File: KoreanJesus.jpg (86 KB, 500x300) Image search: [Google]
KoreanJesus.jpg
86 KB, 500x300
>>57554789
good point, everything in this universe originates from Korea
>>
File: wahmbulance.png (96 KB, 350x229) Image search: [Google]
wahmbulance.png
96 KB, 350x229
>>57554373
>>
>>57554775
underrated post
>>
File: check this out.jpg (38 KB, 500x500) Image search: [Google]
check this out.jpg
38 KB, 500x500
>>57554478
but people do just that.
>>
>>57554888
checked
>>
>>57554111
>>57554135
>degenerate whores getting what they deserve
Am I supposed to be horrified?
>>
>>57554373
Calm the fuck down, Wilber Chang.
>>
落ち着けよ糞ジャップどもwwwwwww
日本人から見たら違うかもしれないけど白人様から見て一緒だと何の意味もないだろwwwww
>>
>>57555203
Nope, not at all.
>>
I'd post Chinese courtesy webms but they always get deleted

see
>3 year old kid getting head bashed in by retard while at least a dozen people walk by
>that kid getting running over TWICE in a factory
>the guy on the highway getting creamed by two trucks

every time I post one of these I get fucking warned or banned because Zhang Huang Ping can't handle that his country is still, by and large, fucking shit
>>
>>57548591
It did not get shunned but there is not much support for it, one of the reasons being that not many people have heard of it. I think it's good to revive hanfu. When every ethnic minority in China has its own ethnic dress, it is only the Han who have lost ours. Hanfu is beautiful.
>>
>>57516154
Why did western people steal Roman culture? Ancient empires will always spread their culture. China may be poor now, but there have been multiple golden ages in the past like the Han dynasty, the Tang dynasty and the Song dynasty. It is not surprisingly that neighbouring smaller countries have adopted some of China's culture.
>>
Why foreigners are arguing in the East Asia of thing?
>>
>>57548591
That faggot in the center looks like a faggot.
>>
>>57556872
They have nothing better to do with their lives
>>
>>57556872
>why are posters discussing international topics about international cultures on int?

moron
>>
>>57557249
well well well look what country just popped its stinky little head up
>>
>>57557290
gomennasai yurushitekudasai
>>
>>57551629
He has a point though.
There were no real crops north of Mesoamerica for most of this part of the world's history. It was only after corn, beans, and squash were introduced from further south that people living in fertile areas such the Mississipi and Great Lakes began developing more sophisticated societies and semi-permanent structures.
>>
Why are Japanese so defensive towards China?
I mean, collecting all these videos photos and information for the sole purpose of shitting on China, such as they don't need to work or study.
Are they really this insecure of themselves?
>>
>>57558441
you don't have to bother to 'collect' them because you come across those things literally everyday on the internet especially on /int/ :D
>>
>>57558441
Are you kidding me? Which country is it that employs millions of people to post propaganda on the internet? China.
>>
>>57516406
No, that's pure Japanese culture.
>>
>>57558944
Ching chong detected.
>>
File: bait.png (57 KB, 625x656) Image search: [Google]
bait.png
57 KB, 625x656
>>57558441
this thread is just a huge bait! \(^o^)/
>>
steal? even though thinks has repeated to ruin and spoil their own culture completely?
>>
>>57559020
I'm white.
>>
>>57559328
i'm taylor swift tbqh
>>
File: 1459994226959.jpg (274 KB, 721x887) Image search: [Google]
1459994226959.jpg
274 KB, 721x887
>>57559362
I'm a weeaboo as they like to call them.
>>
>>57559328
I bet you have a swarthy complexion.
>>
>>57560089
What would you describe as swarthy? Having black hair?
>>
>>57517640
Not disagreeing, but which dynasty did the kimono come from? I'm having trouble pinpointing one
>>
>>57558738
>implying china gives a shit about what people on /int/ thinks
>implying astroturfing isn't used to spam or slide discussions in chinese forums, which are filled with actual chinese people who live in china and who the ccp actually gives a shit about
>im fucking plying people aren't accusing others of being shills (ad hominem) to silence real discussion

How delusional can you be?
>>
>>57564239
You're nothing but a CCP puppet.
>>
>>57562778
The Maidikku dynasty
>>
>>57562778
Read a book, ugly boy.
>>
>>57566793
Which book has the answer?
>>
>>57566864
History book.
>>
>>57566882
You need to read a dictionary.
>>
>>57566907
Fuck you.
>>
File: 1385205773831.gif (319 KB, 314x314) Image search: [Google]
1385205773831.gif
319 KB, 314x314
>this thread is still up
>the gooks are still mad
>>
File: image.jpg (263 KB, 1000x800) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
263 KB, 1000x800
57558738
Consider this, CCP has a perfectly legit reason to manipulate internet opinion: they need to consolidate their regime. (I'm not saying this is right though)
But why are some Japanese otaku so possionate to talk shit about China on internet?
After all, Japan was the one who invaded China and killed million civilians, and these otaku are now acting like the other way round.
Is this how Japanese treat their old teacher?
It seems quite ungrateful isn't it?
>>
At the past time
Tang and Song were roma of asia
It's obvious. The ancient chinese stuff is awesome as hell. Many asian countries take their way
Thread replies: 222
Thread images: 50

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.