[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why do so many japanese writers struggle to get incest right?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 156
Thread images: 50
File: 1441237928018.jpg (424 KB, 1031x738) Image search: [Google]
1441237928018.jpg
424 KB, 1031x738
Why do so many japanese writers struggle to get incest right?
>>
they don't care about your shit taste?
>>
Because they don't want to go to jail because of laws. It's like asking: Why do Americans struggle to get pedophilia right?
>>
>>142840047
Why do so many OPs struggle to not shitpost?
>>
>>142840353
Good posters never make threads
>>
>>142840111
>>142840353

Butthurt Oreimofags
>>
>>142840047

>Oreimo: consensual and loving relationship between two equals

>Koi Kaze: MC is a literal pedo child molester

Oreimo is shit but Koi Kaze is pedo propaganda
>>
>>142840047
Incest is just a vehicle for sexual fantasies and self-insertion like Oreimo.
>>
File: Inbreds.jpg-c200.jpg (8 KB, 200x200) Image search: [Google]
Inbreds.jpg-c200.jpg
8 KB, 200x200
>Incest
>Ever right
>>
Yeah Oreimo was pretty fucking garbage.
>>
>>142840047
A lot of them did not actually experience having decent family experiences.
>>
>>142840047
Think new anons know about Koi Kaze?
>>
File: 1443294710641.png (3 MB, 1076x1105) Image search: [Google]
1443294710641.png
3 MB, 1076x1105
>>142840047
Japanese writers often struggle to get anything right. That's why 92.84% of anime is cute girls doing cute things, because it requires no actual writing talent.
>>
>>142840997
>Believing the jews so you will have to spit all your holdings every generations

Pls
>>
>>142842601
While it works for now, without improvement and change, it will only fuck up everything in the long run.
>>
>>142840896
>Koi Kaze: MC is a literal pedo child molester

Right.

The thing that the author was a female surprised me out though.

Unthinkable in the west.
>>
>>142840047
Not everything dealing with certain topic have to be realistic depiction.
Wish fulfillment fantasy is ok too.
>>
>>142842977
>implying it isn't happening since luck star
>>
I've never watched OreImo, but I agree that Koi Kaze is an incest story done right. Too bad we don't see many more like it, however.
>>
>>142840047
left looks like the most awkward beta male and female. like I believe they're siblings from that
>>
>>142840047

Is this a secret '____ was better back in my day' thread?
>>
Both garbage, Oreimo more so.
>>
>>142840047
Because OreImo was written for otaku and pandered to them.

Koi Kaze managed to explore not just incest but age gap relationships more realistic and it leaves off in an ending that it won't be easy for Koushirou and Nanoka to be together but they will try and Koushirou already set his life to be a bachelor even if Nanoka leaves him for good.
>>
>>142840047
Both are good though. However Koi Kaze is one of the really rare times the age difference was actually a bit creepy, he is almost twice as old and it was overall quite angsty.
>>
>>142843059
>author was a female
It's pretty old trick even on the west.
>>
>>142840047
They are only children and did not actually have sisters, and you're probably the same. The incest fetish shit is just a projection of your childhood loneliness, because very very few people that actually have sisters want to fuck them.
>>
>>142843059
Kodomo no Jikan is also by a woman.
>>
>>142844974
I like reading mother incest porn but that doesn't mean I want to bang my mom.
>>
>>142845069
Yes it does.
>>
File: Sigmund.jpg (876 KB, 1066x1500) Image search: [Google]
Sigmund.jpg
876 KB, 1066x1500
>>142845069
Of course you don't.
>>
>>142845549
Did you finish watching the show, you retard? They feel bad about it because it's a social taboo. It's not portrayed as inherently wrong.
>>
>>142842601
>y 92.84% of anime is cute girls doing cute things
I wished. It's more like 30% harems, 20% action stuff with a shitty contrived but ultimately stereotypical plot, 30% actual cgdct (on its highest proportion, else it's eaten by the two previous types), and 20% miscellaneous.
>>
>>142847946
Nice bump idiot.
>>
File: vlcsnap-2016-06-14-05h39m34s60.png (414 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
vlcsnap-2016-06-14-05h39m34s60.png
414 KB, 1280x720
>quality incest story thread
>no one mentions the pinnacle of incest done right, Yosuga no Sora
>>
Oreimo was a genuinely terrible anime.
>>
>>142849836
It can't be that terrible if pretty much everybody watched both seasons when it was airing. It's a shit adaption but there still are many fun moments.
>>
Koi Kaze was FAR more squicky and realistic, although given the fact that Koushiro is almost 10 years older and literally twice Nanoka's height, that's a given. It feels better when the siblings are closer in age and size, like OreImo or Yosuga no Sora
>>
File: 1465876464505.jpg (303 KB, 1030x1514) Image search: [Google]
1465876464505.jpg
303 KB, 1030x1514
When will you people learn?
>>
File: 1445929788747.png (2 MB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
1445929788747.png
2 MB, 1920x1080
>>142850172
>All incest is amazing
Fixed it for ya
Well, except Father/Daughter, unless it's a widower, or Father/Son or any other gay shit
>>
>>142850172
Sibling Incest is fine.
>>
File: mostSereneDoge.jpg (79 KB, 680x488) Image search: [Google]
mostSereneDoge.jpg
79 KB, 680x488
>>142842884
>Gavelkind succession
Moorsman, I implore thee!
>>
>>142844877
This. A man writing under a female pen name is pretty common.
>>
>>142840047

Well because most just fetishize it, it doesnt mean anything beyond the fetish ... its hard to find someone that wants to deal with the subject in a realistic way.

Also hacks because the Oreimo guy is at it again, same face and same fucking story ...
>>
>>142850780
>...
Are you sure your parents weren't also fantasizing about it?
>>
>>142850780
>...

Eromanga Sensei is NBR, you moron.
>>
because incest is wrong
>>
File: 1463174776746.jpg (256 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1463174776746.jpg
256 KB, 1280x720
>>142850846
>>
>>142850836

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsukasa_Fushimi
>>
>>142850902
What am I suppose to be seeing here?
>>
File: wall of imouto.jpg (289 KB, 675x1043) Image search: [Google]
wall of imouto.jpg
289 KB, 675x1043
So, who's the best?
I would have included Karen and Tsukihi, but I can't think of 1 more imouto for an even 12
>>
>>142850942

The fact its the same author.

Also if you for a second think that aint going to incest you have another thing coming, at least this time is obvious as fuck and only its not is if they arent blood related.
>>
>rejects heaps of girls, ruining his friendships so he can be with his sister even though they don't stay together in the end

L O V I N G
E V E R Y
L A U G H
>>
File: 1433635655308.jpg (621 KB, 840x980) Image search: [Google]
1433635655308.jpg
621 KB, 840x980
>>142851056
>Believing they aren't together
>Didn't read the after story where it pretty much states that they're still together
>>
>>142850221
>Father/Daughter is bad
>not including Mother/Son
Sibling incest is the only fine one. yaoi and yuri siblings need not apply
>>
Angel Sanctuary was incest done right.
>>
>>142851080
>pretty much states
Nice joke. Together as siblings at best.
>>
>>142851056
>even though they don't stay together
But they do.
>ruining his friendships
The only real friendship that gets broken is the one with childhood friend, and there's nothing wrong with that.
>>
File: Capture.png (42 KB, 1265x477) Image search: [Google]
Capture.png
42 KB, 1265x477
>>142851104
>Joke
>>
>>142851097
/ss/ with a mom is ok, it's just a mother relieving her poor son's painful erection
>>
>>142851159
It's not as bad, I would rather have a different milf then the related mother though. Stepmother/son is okay but not stepfather/daughter.
>>
>>142851193
Aunt /ss/ then?
>>
File: 09_Page010.jpg (662 KB, 1199x1107) Image search: [Google]
09_Page010.jpg
662 KB, 1199x1107
>>142850221
>father/son not being the best incest
look at this dumbass who doesn't even wanna sick his dads dick.
>>
>>142851356
Congrats, you are literally a faggot
>>
>>142851018
Already been confirmed she is NBR and unless he goes for Reverse NBR then I don't see it happening.
>>
File: 1426571575799.jpg (783 KB, 1277x1044) Image search: [Google]
1426571575799.jpg
783 KB, 1277x1044
>>142851140
>>
File: 1465430057590.jpg (40 KB, 720x708) Image search: [Google]
1465430057590.jpg
40 KB, 720x708
>>142845069
Mothers are great.
>>
>>142840047
It is impossible to do incest wrong.
>>
File: 1458264113185.jpg (451 KB, 1353x857) Image search: [Google]
1458264113185.jpg
451 KB, 1353x857
>>
File: 1463204995506.jpg (475 KB, 850x850) Image search: [Google]
1463204995506.jpg
475 KB, 850x850
>>
File: 1341105557250.png (241 KB, 492x441) Image search: [Google]
1341105557250.png
241 KB, 492x441
>>142856378
>>142854577
>>142851646
>>
Do you think Kyousuke is filling Kirino up every night?
>>
File: 1439314720319.png (442 KB, 585x935) Image search: [Google]
1439314720319.png
442 KB, 585x935
>>142856638
EVERY night
>>
>>142840047
sibling incest >>>>>> mother-son incest > shit > father-daughter incest
>>
File: 1465433132258.jpg (122 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1465433132258.jpg
122 KB, 1280x720
>>142856753
Usually I prefer sibling incest, but there is something incredibly heart warming about Momkoto's reaction to getting pounded and creampied by her son. That and her general softness really made me appreciate her.
>>
>>142856941
Wait, which of the ____Days VN's is this from?
>>
File: 47098503_p0.jpg (478 KB, 693x950) Image search: [Google]
47098503_p0.jpg
478 KB, 693x950
We need more yuri incest.
>>
File: SBD2.jpg (455 KB, 1500x1115) Image search: [Google]
SBD2.jpg
455 KB, 1500x1115
>>142857090
This one, although it's just a RPS side game. Best part is the mom.

http://webmshare.com/play/WNZaD
>>
>>142857226
Goddamn, how many of these are there?

Also is there anywhere I can get translated versions if they're available?
>>
File: 1464031884716.png (823 KB, 720x1280) Image search: [Google]
1464031884716.png
823 KB, 720x1280
>>142857260
>Goddamn, how many of these are there?
Not enough including best girl Momkoto.

>Also is there anywhere I can get translated versions if they're available?
Not as far as I know.
>>
>>142857418
>Not as far as I know

Well fuck
>>
>>142856699
I'm sure he's pounded her so thoroughly into his shape that it's become impossible for any other object that isn't his dick to please her anymore. By now her body is probably physically addicted to his cum and integrated it into its body functions.
>>
File: 1459570715936.jpg (642 KB, 1296x725) Image search: [Google]
1459570715936.jpg
642 KB, 1296x725
>>142858289
I'm sure it works both ways. They've fucked so much that they literally can't be satisfied by anything else
>>
>>142851000
Let's see, Kotori, Illya, Pacifica Casull, Komachi from Yahari

Just go with Komachi but you should include all 12 sisters from Sister Princess too.
>>
>>142857226
Who are girls 1 and 2? Don't remember them.
>>
File: 1365111722659.gif (2 MB, 480x270) Image search: [Google]
1365111722659.gif
2 MB, 480x270
>>142840047

OP has the balls to say the truth. GJ. Typical though, that most of /a/ has shit taste, and that's why so many like 'incest done wrong'.
>>
>>142858708
It can't compare though because of the age gap. Kyousuke and Kirino are close in age while the dude in Koi Kaze is in his 30s with his middile school age sister.
>>
>>142858895
High school. She's almost 18 by the end of it, she's just really tiny.
>>
>>142858402
>implying Kirino won't find a college boyfriend
>>
>>142858895

>older men don't like younger women
(see above ... that's the point! That's why it's a better example)

Also, koi kaze = blood related.
>>
File: 1436370594046.gif (112 KB, 191x201) Image search: [Google]
1436370594046.gif
112 KB, 191x201
>>142859120
>Implying she doesn't already have one
Kyou is in college
>>
>>142859152
Kyousuke and Kirino are blood related.
>>
>>142859160
A sexy gaijin boyfriend who's a model too. Not Kyousuke, of course.
>>
>>142859204
Stop inserting your NTR fetish into loving Incest stories, anon.
>>
File: 1435432204478.jpg (2 MB, 1041x1509) Image search: [Google]
1435432204478.jpg
2 MB, 1041x1509
>>142859152
Didn't think it was possible to be this stupid.
>>
>>142859204
>kyou
>not sexy
>implying he wouldn't make a good model
Faggot.
>>
File: 1451000738977.jpg (53 KB, 638x635) Image search: [Google]
1451000738977.jpg
53 KB, 638x635
>>142859204
We've been over this. They have had so much sex that no one else can satisfy them anymore.
>>
File: 1451099836549.jpg (197 KB, 647x440) Image search: [Google]
1451099836549.jpg
197 KB, 647x440
>>142859204
>implying she could ever give up the pinnacle of manliness
>>
>>142850221
I'm not entirely sure what someone would hate about father/daughter yet at the same time find older brother/little sister so endearing to be honest.
>>
>>142859350
It's not giving up, it's growing bored. Getting with your brother, whom you already know, can only last so much.

Especially if you're a girl like Kirino, with that specific job too.
>>
>>142859361
Father/daughter is the more "normal" (for the lack of a better word) one even, "dad not wanting to let go of his daughter" is a common character trait in every type of fiction ever
though maybe it's not as a common in Japan perhaps, I dunno
>>
File: 13.png (450 KB, 1110x1600) Image search: [Google]
13.png
450 KB, 1110x1600
>>142859361
Because, more often than not, it's rape. And I just can't dig it.
If it's not rape, and it's completely consensual, or better yet, the DAUGHTER tazes and rapes her dad, then I'm slightly more ok with it
>>
>>142843059
Fun fact: most sexual abuse of children is done by women.
>>
>>142859527
Well typically in anime the dad either isn't there or is some sort of villain/obstacle for the protagonist to overcome
>>
File: image.jpg (43 KB, 480x384) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
43 KB, 480x384
>>
File: image.jpg (33 KB, 419x264) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
33 KB, 419x264
>>
File: 1456275050433.png (31 KB, 400x250) Image search: [Google]
1456275050433.png
31 KB, 400x250
>>142859546
>disliking rape
>>
File: image.jpg (166 KB, 1192x675) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
166 KB, 1192x675
>>142840047
It's best when incest doesn't progress beyond teasing and foreplay

On top of that sibling relationships are best when they include casual nudity around each other and the occasional lewd contact.

else it could get weird and awkward in the future.

Alas, that's my opinion.
>>
>>142851356
What's the source?
>>
>>142859280
>>142858402
I'm sure her body is so accustomed to his sperm that her womb already made preparations to perfectly conceive Kyousuke's child once they decide to have one. It'll be amazing how easy it'll be for them to have children once they start to breed like rabbits because they're so synched up. They are literally made for each other and to have lots and lots of superior inbred children.
>>
File: 1434671708544.jpg (833 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
1434671708544.jpg
833 KB, 1920x1080
>>142862003
The first generation will be fine, as long as their kids don't decide to emulate their parents. It probably wouldn't be a problem, Kyou and Kiririn only got attracted to each other because they were seperated for a while, so as adults they would probably encourage their kids to be close so they don't go through the same shit. They also kept an eye out for potential Manami's so their hard work doesn't get ruined
>>
>>142859459
I doubt that there is anything more exciting than illegally conceiving your brother's child. I can only imagine how her heart must race when she isn't on any birth control and he cums inside.
>>
File: 1428001490606.gif (2 MB, 350x300) Image search: [Google]
1428001490606.gif
2 MB, 350x300
>>142861428
>Liking rape
>>
>>142840047
>112 replies
>nobody can say why Oreimo is done wrong
Every time, and why you guys keep replying to a bait thread? Polite sage.
>>
>>142863338
It's a poorly disguised incest thread, not all that surprising
>>
>>142863338
>can't explain what's wrong
Because there's nothing actually wrong.
>>
>>142843059
>The thing that the author was a female surprised me out though.
Most books that graphically describe those things are written by women.
>>
>>142845069
Probably means your mom didn't love you enough in your childhood.
>>
File: imouto paradise 2.jpg (298 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
imouto paradise 2.jpg
298 KB, 1280x720
>>142862095
>not wanting to inbreed with your inbred imouto

What sort of faggotry is this?
>>
>>142842884
Doing incest to keep money in the family honestly seems more Jewish than the alternative.
>>
>>142863762
No matter how much I love my imouto, if we're siblings born of incest, I wouldn't want to inflict any kind of deformities on our children. I can still cum inside, just get snipped. Maybe we can adopt
>>
>>142863835
How likely would it be to have a completely healthy child when you impregnate your imouto and your parents are siblings? Is there even a chance to have an almost or actually completely healthy child?
>>
>>142864220
It's significantly higher than first gen incest. First gen incest has about as large of a risk for deformities as having a child with a 30 or so year old woman does, but when the following generations start doing it, thats when shit starts getting fucky
>>
>>142861592
>doesn't progress beyond teasing and foreplay

But Monogatari implies that rrr and Karen fucked
>>
File: imouto paradise 2.jpg (354 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
imouto paradise 2.jpg
354 KB, 1280x720
>>142864333
But third generation incest produced Cleopatra. You want your children to have strong inbred genes like Cleopatra don't you?
>>
>>142864455
I wouldn't risk it
>>
>>142862095
What if Daisuke and Yoshino were siblings too?
>>
File: 024.jpg (537 KB, 1201x1718) Image search: [Google]
024.jpg
537 KB, 1201x1718
>>142865088
Then I hope they tell Kiririn and Kyou before anything happens
>>
>>142865218
I hope they never ever use any protection and make as many inbred babies as possible.
>>
>>142865251
Not if there is a higher than normal risk of genetic deformities. They wouldn't inflict that kind of pain on an innocent baby
>>
>>142866329
I'm pretty sure all it takes is a quick moment filled with lust and passion and I doubt that Kyousuke could resist cumming inside his delicious sister, assuming that she wouldn't leglock him in the first place.
>>
File: 1433576947913.jpg (221 KB, 700x800) Image search: [Google]
1433576947913.jpg
221 KB, 700x800
Why do you fags make them out to be so lewd?
>>
File: 1458271830235.jpg (280 KB, 1200x1600) Image search: [Google]
1458271830235.jpg
280 KB, 1200x1600
>>142867327
You're saying that like it's a bad thing
>>
For the same reason they do incest at the first place: Most Japs are single children and the concept of have a sibling is completely alien to them.
>>
File: 1437423532504.jpg (397 KB, 1000x1000) Image search: [Google]
1437423532504.jpg
397 KB, 1000x1000
>>142867352
What a lewd pair. Look, his mere touch instantly opens the floodgates, even when she is asleep
>>
>>142867327
Because they wrongfully sexualize Kirino and love to self-insert into Kyousuke.
>>
File: 1366446371376.jpg (473 KB, 827x1200) Image search: [Google]
1366446371376.jpg
473 KB, 827x1200
>/a/ is a bunch of retarded redneck inbreeds who want to fuck their sister
I knew you was the same guys than /pol/. Btw incest is a desease and cat is best
>>
>>142868182
>calling kirinofags rednecks
>I knew you was
Oh, the irony.
>>
>>142868350
What's wrong, bongistanman, can't stand real english? Go back to mexico.
>>
File: 1434830242999.jpg (162 KB, 480x315) Image search: [Google]
1434830242999.jpg
162 KB, 480x315
>>142868182
>Can't spell disease
>Thinks Neko is best
Man, downs really hit you hard, huh
>>
>>142868535
猫は最高。Go fuck your sister, sisterfucker. English is shit language anyway
>>
>>142868535
Also
>guys than /pol/
>inbreeds
But let's not pick on the actual redneck.
Neko is second best, though.
>>
>>142845474
Nobody in psychology thinks Freud is worth a damn
>>
File: 1433632083515.png (107 KB, 341x358) Image search: [Google]
1433632083515.png
107 KB, 341x358
>>142868636
That's really not that difficult. She wins second by default, most of the other girls are either garbage (Ayase, Manami) or literal whos in the anime.
Except Saori, she's a strange phenomenon
Neko isn't like Nao, who takes second because she's a total fucking bro
>>
>>142868677
I can see at least two dicks in that pic, though.
>>
>>142868737
But Neko also gets it as a bro, at least in the anime.
And Ayase still gets to be better than that other whore.
>>
>>142840047
>Koi Kaze fags still think their shit is good
LOL!
>>
>>142844974
>have four sisters
>wanted to bang all of them
your move
>>
What does Kirino smell like, /a/?
>>
File: 1442536225338.jpg (78 KB, 302x242) Image search: [Google]
1442536225338.jpg
78 KB, 302x242
>>142870396
During the day? Perfume and strawberries
During the night? Sweat and pure sex
>>
>>142870396
rotting shit
you are now thinking of kirino smelling like shit
you can never erase this mental image
>>
>>142869712
I don't like Koi Kaze, but it's probably the most realistic portrayal of an incestuous relationship between siblings in all of anime
>>
>Just finished Tuskimonogatari
>That bath scene
>The toothbrush scene from the earlier seasons

Karen and Tsukihi need Koyomi Dick.
>>
File: let's be honest.jpg (24 KB, 611x476) Image search: [Google]
let's be honest.jpg
24 KB, 611x476
There's only one good incest and you all know it
>>
>>142840047
Oreimo is a better love story than Koi kaze.
>>
>>142873736
>this is what idiots actually believe
>>
File: 1441650124577.png (279 KB, 593x540) Image search: [Google]
1441650124577.png
279 KB, 593x540
>>142874187
Thread replies: 156
Thread images: 50

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.