[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why did you faggots tell me this was good?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 31
File: 43-F11-07-26.jpg (131 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
43-F11-07-26.jpg
131 KB, 800x600
Why did you faggots tell me this was good?
>>
Those arms. Jesus Christ, that should of been your first clue this was shit,anon.
>>
>>134498451
holy shit i never noticed

can't be unseen now
>>
Fate route was hard to get through, holy crap it sucked. Except for Saber
>>
>>134498432
>ehmahgerd they gun hav sex? muh vergin waefu!
>>
File: 1449478058178.jpg (68 KB, 519x519) Image search: [Google]
1449478058178.jpg
68 KB, 519x519
>>134498432
>good
You got baited OP.
>>
>>134498432

Sex is a natural part of human existence and has always been associated with magic. Why are you surprised that it pops up here? You should be more shocked if it didn't.
>>
>>134498477
These people have been watching anime all their life, man. Sex is weird and unnatural to them.
>>
>>134498432
This. I stop reading this shit during the "H-scene" and never touched this shit VN again.
>>
>>134498432
Have you never heard of magical sex rituals?
>>
>>134498432
You fell for the VN actually being good lie, huh?
>>
>>134498508
/a/ is not lying to you when they say that UBW and Heaven's Feel are better, and are the backbone of the VN.

But you should always skip the H scenes. Nasu didn't even write them; he had somebody else do it, and apparently didn't even proofread it. The Fate H scenes are basically just S doujins that found their way into the official release, and they just ruin the characters and the story.
>>
>>134498582
>Nasu didn't even write them
Source?
>>
>>134498432
fatefags are delusional, why would you ever listen to them?
>>
>>134498432
turn off H scenes and its fine, the writing is fucking terrible when it gets down and dirty.
>>
>>134498477
It was certainly the perfect timing to have sex.
>>
>>134498432
Just get your dick out.
>>
>>134498589
i 2nd this, the H scene writing is exactly how i pictured it written by Nasu, terrible and over described.
>>
>>134498432
Oh boy, another Fate thread made just to complain about it.

And people read: shitposters have the audacity to call the actual Fatefags cancer.
>>
>>134498637
This. We should just have a general thread to contain all the shitpost.
>>
Now it all makes sense. I even after i acquired wizard age, i didnt feel any magic flowing through me. That must've been because i was throwing my magic infused semen away instead of recycling the magic energy by drinking the semen.
>>
Why is stuff like sex in Fate a problem, but sex in things like Game of Thrones is seen as mature and gritty?
>>
>>134498432
If you were stupid enough to believe anything written by Kinoko Nasu is good,you have only yourself to blame. It should have been obvious to you that it was bad.
>>
File: 1411762256159.jpg (52 KB, 534x1135) Image search: [Google]
1411762256159.jpg
52 KB, 534x1135
>>134498432
Tantrism is 1500 years old, OP. The basis of life energy being contained in the gonads is older still.
Jizz being magic ain't even close to new.
>>
File: 1415271646431.png (358 KB, 719x720) Image search: [Google]
1415271646431.png
358 KB, 719x720
>>134498716
>HBO
>Type-Moon
One of them is a 5 book spanning series that got an adaptation from a large american production company while the other is a fucking VN written by Nasu and produced by type-moon. How about you take a fucking guess.

Not to mention american based audience vs japanese based audience and the difference in genre taste and ethics.
>>
>>134498716
>sex in things like Game of Thrones is seen as mature and gritty?
Maybe it has something to do with the fact that Game of Thrones characters don't refer to their dicks as "wet weapons".
>>
>>134498686
>instead of recycling the magic energy by drinking the semen.

You more have to just slurp it off your hand and knock it back. "Drinking" implies you're accumulating and storing enough of it to fill a glass, which would likely be unhygenic, and would likely taste even worse than fresh. You want to consume it when it's as fresh as possible, or, preferably, to masturbate less often.

>>134498716
Because the general American public is particularly accustomed to being spoon fed a stream of stupid bullshit.
>>
>>134498716
Because GoT isn't anime. Double standards are a thing outside of SJW bitching, you know.
>>
The fight after that has even worse writing.
Full of plot holes, Nasu can't even follow his own rules
>>
>>134498807
>while the other is a fucking VN written by Nasu and produced by type-moon.
That got an adaptation from a large japanese production company.. twice
>>
>>134498809
What's worse, the fat pink mast or the mollusk?
>>
>>134498784
Is this the equivalent of an Egyptian hummer? Someone was definitely compensating for something.
>>
>>134498432
>>134498463
If you read the Fate route at a leisurely pace after finishing the entire VN, it's actually a pretty good route.
>>
>>134498832
And yet is still little compared to things like game of thrones. And the anime adaptation does not have H scenes so in this argument it doesn't have any place. This is Game of thrones sex scenes v fate sex scenes remember.
>>
>>134498716
None of the characters in Game of Thrones compare human genitalia to mollusks.
>>
GRRM is just as bad as Nasu
>Sunset found her squatting in the grass, groaning. Every stool was looser than the one before, and smelled fouler. By the time the moon came up she was shitting brown water. The more she drank, the more she shat, but the more she shat, the thirstier she grew, and her thirst sent her crawling to the stream to suck up more water.
>>
>>134498858
It's the egyptian god Min, who has a staggeringly large erection at all times.
Similar to the greek god Priapus.
>>
>>134498884
If this is a direct copy from one of the books by god GRRM is a dirty fucker.
>>
File: 1432704767146.jpg (236 KB, 691x625) Image search: [Google]
1432704767146.jpg
236 KB, 691x625
>>134498451
>people actually fap to oRingutans and their lanky ass appendages
>somewhere out there, someone actually finds the erotic parts of type moon works erotic

knowing this is actually kind of unsettling
>>
>>134498884
It's sad that this passage has more sense than 99% of the text in FSN.
It's hard to think of blander writing
>>
File: 1430818170485.jpg (83 KB, 309x300) Image search: [Google]
1430818170485.jpg
83 KB, 309x300
>>134498888
My nigga
>>
>this thread
Do people ITT actually compare Fate with shit like GoT? That's like comparing a pebble to the Moon.
>>
>>134498881
>>134498897
Fat pink mast is GRRM's mollusk.
>She was sopping wet when he entered her. “Damn you,” she said. “Damn you damn you damn you.” He sucked her nipples till she cried out half in pain and half in pleasure. Her cunt became the world.

>And suddenly his cock was out, jutting upward from his breeches like a fat pink mast.
>>
File: ShirouxShiki Eroscene.png (54 KB, 972x295) Image search: [Google]
ShirouxShiki Eroscene.png
54 KB, 972x295
>>134498432
The eroscenes are the funniest part.
>>
Shirou is a deeper, better written and more layered character than any of the characters from A Song of Fire and Ice.
>>
>>134498621
That's too bad then, they were written by Takeuchi.
>>
>>134498923
>Her cunt became the world.
Sounds like Nasu tier writing, maybe they should do a Game of Thrones holy grail war collaboration.
>>
>>134498918
Are you one of these retards who think Fate is actually good?
I thought you people accepted that you only liked FSN due to its concept or whatever.
What do you like about it so much? The bland as fuck writing? The horrible pacing?
>>
File: 1437828634670.jpg (60 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
1437828634670.jpg
60 KB, 800x600
BEST ROMANCE MOMENTS: Fate
BEST PACING: UBW
BEST FIGHTS: UBW
BEST EMOTIONAL HIGHS: HF
BEST SHIROU: UBW
BEST ILYA: HF
BEST KOTOMINE: HF
BEST NON-TRUE ENDINGS: HF
>>
>>134498941
>Shirou is a deeper, better written and more layered character
If you really believe it you probably never read a novel in your life.
The only thing Nasu does with Shirou is piles tons and tons of shit upon Shirou but that doesn't make good writing
The concept that encompass Shirou has been far better done in other places with far less time needed
>>
>>134498432
>Poor magi are literally wankers.
>>
The only thing i cant stand about nasu writting shit is his comparisons with other things. Its always "If i was * then she was *, if that was * then this was *. It probably sounds better in japanese but reading the VN and every 2nd panel has comparison dialog really starts to piss me off.
>>
>>134498952
That's fake.
try to find even one source that say this.

Nasu wrote everything in FSN
>>
>>134498952
Why would the writer dump his job to the artist? Fucking Nasu.
>>
>>134499003
>It probably sounds better in japanese
Not really, if anything it sounds more autistic in Japanese

Nasu didn't have much 語彙 in FSN
>>
>>134498809
>>134498881
The whole mollusk stuff and general absurdity in the sex scenes is only something in the translated version.

You have to remember, FSN was translated by a high school kid.
>>
>>134499068
It wasn't about mollusks? What's the actual term used?
>>
File: EMIYA smile.jpg (28 KB, 600x450) Image search: [Google]
EMIYA smile.jpg
28 KB, 600x450
>>134498988
If you really believe this you didn't read F/SN.

I have read 30,000-word essays from learned men simply unpacking the final shot of Archer smiling as he vanishes.

Identity or Self is something we build from childhood. We (in Nasuverse) start with our origin and then surround ourselves with our parents, etc. That is what separates us from "Akasha" and builds up the I that makes us themselves an individual. Surroundings, past, memory, beliefs, love, relationships. Every foundation of self burned down in that fire.
Shirou is a building without foundation. The foundation burned and on top of that, the ideal was put as a bandaid.

As Shirou himself states: "There's no such thing. Kiritsugu merely saved me. And you talk about taking something from me, but at that time... I had nothing to give."

The fire burned out his identity.

Seeing Kiritsugu's smiling face, sparked a wish to be happy in him and he, as a machine, longed to replicate that smile.

He is pretty much an "inverted Kirei" in that aspect. The only difference between them is the way they try to attain their happiness.
"Consider it a friendly warning. We are the same, you and I. As we do not have clear wishes, we cannot seek salvation."

That is the reason Kirei is so interested in him in the first place.

Shirou has a complete disregard to his self and his emotional range is incredibly limited. He has complete disregard to societal rules or even sense of morality. His "morality" is only governed by his ideal - "making people feel good would make me feel happy so making them feel bad is wrong". It is further evidenced by the "bye, Shinji" scene as well as by Mind of Steel ending.

He has no interest in societal norms or care for human logic - Shinji mocks him to clean the archery range? Sure, he already wanted to visit the archery range so that's okay for Shirou. No care or understanding on the underlying tone targeting his self or identity.
>>
Is there an FSN audiobook? I wanna listen to the sex scenes narrated by some sophisticated-sounding fella.
>>
>>134499040
Well then hes got the writing ability of a 12 year old. One of the first things we learn as children when it comes to writing stories is to not use comparisons like the ones he uses too much, but yet fate is full of them from start to end.
>>
>>134498898
It's weird, but every now and then there will come along some fag who will claim Takeuchi is not actually a bad artist and actually excels at shading and drawing cloth.
>>
>>134499137
Nice meme
>>
>>134499101
this pretty much
>>
I don' get where all these hyper critical fags are coming from. I'm watch all sorts of anime and hang out in all sorts of anime thread.

When it comes to Fate some people just hold it to a standard I haven't seen many other anime/franchise being hold to.
>>
>>134499101
''It has to be this way'' would a good battle theme song for Kirei vs Shirou
>>
>>134499235
Most of them speedread it because it's popular and get mad when nothing makes sense to them.

Anon earlier today claimed "Shirou randomly masters projection by watching others fighting".

>>134499272
That song would be weirdly appropriate actually. Fate game by Platinum when?
>>
>>134498432
Magic sex rituals are not a VN/anime/manga/japan exclusive. I think FSN is shit but this is not an issue.
>>
>>134499235
Excuses from people who don't like to read. The same happens with manga.
>>
>>134498970
>HF's non true ending better than UBW's

nigga wat. It's depressing as fuck. In UBW Seiba stays and you have awesome threesomes
>>
>>134499101
You read essays from 12 years old autists
Shirou was better done in fucking Utena
Except Utena not only did Shirou better it also tackled tons of other shit
In FSN the only thing Nasu can do with a bit of success is Shirou's development, everything else is subpar as hell
>>
File: Wtf_man.jpg (220 KB, 908x730) Image search: [Google]
Wtf_man.jpg
220 KB, 908x730
>>134498923
>Her cunt became the world.
>And suddenly his cock was out, jutting upward from his breeches like a fat pink mast.

Top-tier writing.
>>
>>134499419
it's a pasta
>>
>>134499419
>it was done better elsewhere so it's bad

baito desu
>>
>>134499235
To be really critical of something, to have actually standards, you have to be able to compare it with stuff.
Let alone other VNs you guys probably never read actual novels either so here you are claiming FSN is the deepest thing ever

People who are hyper critical are retarded too but people like you guys who praise it like it's the greatest thing ever written are at the same level
>>
>>134499419
>Shirou was better done in fucking Utena

Can you explain?
>>
>>134499525
>you are claiming FSN is the deepest thing ever
I keep hearing these from people who shit on Fate but I only hear it from you guys. Maybe it's projection or something. And half the time you people reply to obvious pasta, like cancerous newfags.
>>
>>134499508
It's not bad, it's mediocre mostly because the writing is really bland and powerlevel and the pacing is pure shit
It's longer than LoTR yet the only thing it manages to do with a tiny bit of success is Shirou, that's a big problem
>>
>>134498582
Nasu H scenes are not erotic at all, but they are absolutely hilarious.
>>
>>134499575
Nasufags now blame Takeuchi for the sex scenes.
>>
>>134499563
I think some of these guys take copypastas like this >>134499101 seriously.
>>
>>134499546
How about you go watch Utena and see for yourself?
>>
>>134499609
Regardless of whether it's a pasta that information is all completely true. Have you even read the VN?
>>
>>134499610
Not particularly interested at this point, and while I'm sure that's a grievous sin or whatever, I was just wondering about that statement.
>>
>>134498881
I want to see this now, a whole big production HBO series version of fate just for the H scenes being adapted an narrated by Morgan Freeman.
>>
File: even ranime hates fate.jpg (84 KB, 1057x666) Image search: [Google]
even ranime hates fate.jpg
84 KB, 1057x666
>>134499525
>>
>>134499235
Most of the "hypercritical fags" are just Frodos who bait the overly serious Fatefags. It's hilarious, actually.
>>
>>134499700
So hating Fate is Reddit as fuck. As expected.
>>
>>134499653
>Not particularly interested at this point
Yeah arguing in FSN thread for the nth times again sure is a better use of your time.

The problem with the FSN fanbase is that they are stuck in a loop and do nothing to get out.
FSN every days
>>
>>134499563
>>134499609

Lies. I've literally seen dedicated fans declare Fate being the masterstroke of Nasu's writing that utterly changed their lives (it's hardly even his best work).
>>
>>134499857
Damn nigger you're projecting harder than Shirou.

Just asked a question, how did I know though that it'd probably get someone up on their high horse?
>>
>>134499873
DDD? My nigga
>>
>>134499873
>Not accepting Fate as a true masterpiece
>Not living your life true to Shirou's ideals

Shaking my head to be honest, familia.
>>
>>134499880
>My nigga
Kill yourself.
>>
>>134499873
No you were baited.
>>
>>134499889
You first.
>>
>>134498463
>japan forces king arthur to suck japanese dick
>>
>>134499891
Nah. I've actually lurked around where people actively discussed with each other about the series and its writing. I love TM but jesus the Fate fans tend to reach another level of ridiculousness when it comes to circlejerks. You literally get statements like the one I mentioned every now and then. Shit's so prevalent it practically became a meme for Fate shitposters hence all the pasta being thrown around.
>>
>>134499941
>Not understanding that it's a statement on Japan's burning, but repressed desire to dominate, and conquer once again

Shirou represents Japanese society, Saber represents the imperial west. Shirou wants to be a man of action, but Saber holds him back and tells him he's too weak. Shirou making her suck his dick is a deep social commentary that I'm not surprised flew right over your head.
>>
>>134499969
It's turning into the next Evageeks.
>>
>>134500015
Damn I didn't think about it this way before. The whole thing about Saber being a foreign ruler that submits to Shirou's perception of gender roles as a homely Japanese person (akin to a housewife) actually fits with the dynamic of the domineering imperialism of the West vs the well-meaning civilian life of the East (a theme that goes as far back as the victimization of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and the resulting generation that came after).
>>
>>134500040
More or less.
>>
File: academia.png (108 KB, 900x287) Image search: [Google]
academia.png
108 KB, 900x287
>ITT
>>
>>134500279
Type Moon's been on this site longer than Reddit's existed.
>>
>>134500383
There's a reason why you people were kicked out of /jp/.
>>
>>134498432
>Reading Jackpatch
You fucked up.
>>
>>134500452
There are at least three Type Moon threads up on /jp/ right now.
>>
>>134499235
I agree. You rarely ever see things on /a/ analyzed to the same extent FSN is.
>>
>>134500500
Empty threads. Not even the otaku want to see this shit.
>>
>>134499758
Reddit loves Fate. The only place you'll find a large group of people that really hate Fate is Neogaf where they only like F/Z.
>>
>>134500635
>Empty threads

Yeah, that's /jp/ in general. Except for the month old 200 post threads for people to post "healthy" girls.
>>
>>134498637
Nice cancerous use of spoiler tags you fatefag cancer.
>>
>>134500452
I thought /jp/ was created to contain the cancerous VNfags?
>>
>>134500838
Why do you choose to actively browse Reddit?
>>
>>134500857
It was created to contain Touhou and other non anime related things like idol shit. /VG/ was pretty much made for vn's because of KS among other reasons.
>>
>>134500905
Don't change the subject. Loving Fate is Reddit as fuck.
>>
>>134500949
And loving TM is 4chan as fuck. You count how many TM banners are up on this site?

You choose though to care about and browse Reddit for it.
>>
>>134500452
Translation is reason.
>>
>>134500838
>Rin with her hair down is the best and most gorgeous Rin :)
Absolute cringe
>>
>>134501040
Rin fans are trash, who knew.
>>
>>134498807
More like one is from a shitty book made by literally fat fedora neckbeard
>>
>>134500984
>identifying a company with an image board
>acting like you were around for the old /b/, the perfect age for chuuni stuff
>not knowing that only /a/ cared about fate
>forgetting that everyone migrated to beast's lair after mirror moon translated the games
>the banners!
>>
>>134500838
>Rin
>Archer
>Saber

Top laff. Not even Reddit likes Sakura.
>>
>>134501181
>everyone is me!
>>
>>134501181
Yeah man, only /a/ has threads about Fate. Let's ignore the ones on /jp/, /v/, /vg/, and fuck, probably elsewhere. And all the fans migrated to Beast's Lair? Yeah, that's why there's always like, three plus threads on /a/ constantly.
>>
>>134498988
I'm a Fate scholar who studied the Visual Novel for over 7 years and I still get amazed every single time I read it. Emiya Shirou is a deconstruction of the Superhero archetype while Kirei is a deconstruction of the Supervillain archetype. You have to read the original Japanese text of the Visual Novel to understand how truly amazing these characters are. Not even Yang Wenli and Reinhard for the masterpiece that is LotGH manages to make me question my ideals in life.
>>
>>134501256
>imply it's reddit to hate fate
>imply it's 4chan to love tm because banners lol
>mention early days of 4chan, when moot loved the tsukihime anime
>forget that mirror moon translating fate/stay night made the series available to english speaking fans
>forget that aniplex's fate/zero anime made the series incredibly popular

Quit trying to waste my time.
>>
>>134499091
Scallops
>>
>>134501359
I don't even know the point you're trying to make anymore other than trying to create a vague timeline of TM events for this site.
>>
File: 1448615926937.jpg (34 KB, 200x378) Image search: [Google]
1448615926937.jpg
34 KB, 200x378
>>134501347
Sounds about right.
>>
>>134500271
Bill Waterson was some sort of prophet.
>>
>>134498716
In one of them sex is just something that happens, in the other a king of Europe acts like a shy Japanese virgin while a 8 foot tall killing machine is trying to track her down. You tell me which one people are going to roll their eyes towards.
>>
>>134501347
>I'm a Fate scholar
I'm not sure if i can take you serious after reading that
>>
>>134501446
What? UBW is a beautiful exercise in the emotional craft of storytelling. It isn't a story about mythological heroes going at war. It's a story about the importance of what heroes represent, and fighting for those ideals. Tightly plotted, thematically consistent, emotionally affecting, and incredibly layered. There's so much meat on Fate/stay night it may be impossible to digest all of it.

But hey, it's your choice to stay in the pleb abyss.
>>
>>134500984
>You count how many TM banners are up on this site?

Can't tell if trolling or not. The TM banners were only there because moot had no idea what it was before the /a/ and /jp/ split.
>>
File: 14085861301981.jpg (272 KB, 1005x923) Image search: [Google]
14085861301981.jpg
272 KB, 1005x923
>>134501522
Uh huh. The point being made is that TM is deeply ingrained into this site and its culture.
>>
>>134501513
You should join ANN's review team and get paid for your expert analysis of Type-Moon's classics
>>
>>134498884
>tfw Wyman Manderly feeds his guests Frey Pies
>>
>>134501658
You give the ANN review team too much credit. They've proven time and time again that TM is above their understanding.

You don't get a reviewer who only knows about cape flips and Tyler Perry movies to talk about the intricacies of Kubrick and Welles.
>>
>>134501642
You could say the same thing about gamefaqs and animesuki, and also, reddit.
>>
>>134501736
Is that you, Nick Creamer?
>>
File: 1430886355733.png (293 KB, 1096x357) Image search: [Google]
1430886355733.png
293 KB, 1096x357
>>134501408
Not the first time I've heard him called that
>>
>>134501750
The entire community surrounding TM in the west is based off 4chan and its response to it. All the major shit has originated from here.
>>
>>134501798
Leave the advanced discussion of subtext and symbolism to those of us who have done the requisite study to understand Fate/stay night - there are a number of intelligent responses that completely cripple your amateur analysis of Nasu's work.

All you can do is post reaction images. Really shows your abilities to understand grand complex concepts. Such a shame you can't experience the story that is Fate/stay night.
>>
>>134501962
why did pariah abandon us?
>>
File: 1414900102157.png (9 KB, 100x100) Image search: [Google]
1414900102157.png
9 KB, 100x100
The last form of Japanese literature I took seriously was the book of five rings.

If you just relax and enjoy it for what it is the amount of fun you'll have playing stuff like Fate goes through the roof
>>
>>134502035
>just turn your brain off bro!

You're as bad as the shitposters.
>>
>>134502015
Fate is so taut and perfectly layered that it makes my head spin. It clearly wasn't trying to please everyone, though, as evidenced by the plebs on here. It has a real vision and real ambitions. If you want a simple narrative and paint-by-numbers filmmaking, go watch your shoot-em-up cop films and capeshit. Fate appeals to the few of us who enjoy challenging complexity. Nasu knows that the public is aware of mythology; that's precisely why he references it (and probably 50+ other stories). This is called an homage, and the masters use homage to keep a "conversation with history" going. He includes well-worn tropes and plot points to lure you into a far grander story. The very best artists do this. They leave breadcrumbs in their stories that work as subtext and establishing a film in cinematic history. The fact that you can't see this says a lot about your general lack of expertise in the subject of cinema. There's pretty much unanimous consensus among scholars that Fate is a masterpiece...
>>
>>134501828
Keep telling yourself that. TM used to be our sole newfag magnet.
>>
>>134502167
>shoot-em-up
That movie's actually kinda fun.
>>
>>134498432
HF is the only good part
>>
>>134502114
I didn't say that but when you're watching anything with an anime theme you kind of have to lower your expectations a bit
>>
>>134502167
I wish TM wasn't a dead horse so we could talk about some new or exciting story they are working on
>>
>>134502114
You are the shitposter.
>>
>>134502235
We need Mahoyo translated, Extra CCC translated, Tsukihime remake out (and adapted), and a HF adaptation that isn't shit.
>>
>>134502167
>There's pretty much unanimous consensus among scholars that Fate is a masterpiece...
I know you're just trolling but that kind of goes out the window watching a revived genderbent King arthur sucking off a japanese teenager
>>
>>134502194
Of course someone of your caliber would say so. The Fate universe is simply too grand a creation for some to come to terms with. Maybe one day you'll grow up enough to "get" it. I've seen it about 15 times and I'm still learning. Fate grounds its storytelling in solid plotting instead of messianic symbolism: which is actually harder to pull off and requires more craftsmanship but doesn't impress the pretentious teenagers who think Evangelion is Art. I guess some art dilettantes get their kicks critiquing the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel, so why not attack Fate too?
>>
>>134502299
Well, at least CCC translation is running again. Maybe I'll even play it before next decade.
>>
>>134502345
Do you people really wait for translations? Like, you actively sit and wait?
>>
>>134502309
I feel it's very insulting to Fate that people write it off just for the non-canon porn. I mean yeah Fate had a few H-scenes, but before that it's an incredibly character driven story, and I'd say Realta Nua exceeds the original. And in regards to Saber, I feel dismissing her is like skipping the crown jewel of characterization in the franchise.
>>
>>134502309
But that reveals the mass complexities behind society and is a carefully constructed criticism of gender roles and norms writing society. It shows that issue's and struggles surpass time and space and dealing with those realities is what is seen.
>>
>>134502373
As opposed to what, learning Japanese?
>>
>>134502432
You could do that. Learn about Japan's culture and the language they speak. It's a much better time investment than looking at this shitty site.
>>
>>134502373
I wonder how one can actively sit. What do you mean? No, I don't check translation status every hour, but I do wait for it.
>>
>>134502553
I came here to laugh at you.
>>
>>134501221
Considering Sakura haters behave like they came straight from r/MRA, that's no surprise.
>>
File: nasu prose.jpg (1 MB, 2350x3174) Image search: [Google]
nasu prose.jpg
1 MB, 2350x3174
Obligatory.
>>
File: UBW-critical-anal.png (374 KB, 639x480) Image search: [Google]
UBW-critical-anal.png
374 KB, 639x480
>>134501513
>>
>>134501040
you shit this kind of shit on /a/ all the time faggot, probably even more so
>>
>>134502808
That's HF, ya jackass.
>>
>>134498716
Nne word: mollusks
>>
File: 1342231892242.png (428 KB, 1325x765) Image search: [Google]
1342231892242.png
428 KB, 1325x765
>>134502805
>>
>>134502834
Same Fate, different route.
>>
File: cajolery1.png (1 MB, 1003x755) Image search: [Google]
cajolery1.png
1 MB, 1003x755
>Threesome Stay Night will never be animated
why live?

all shiposting aside though, this sex scene wasn't horrible at least when compared to the others
>>
If I start doing high jumps, will I get numerous bitches later in my life?
>>
>>134498451
>should of
please please kill yourself
>>
>>134502943
Depends, are you a sword?
>>
>>134502928
I wish FHA got animated so we could potentially get Rider/Sakura/Shirou threesome. Fans who can't accept Fate's eroge roots and keep recommending RN are the deluded ones for obviously missing out.
>>
>>134502965
I can wear a costume and keep making sword analogies. Does that count?
>>
>>134503004
Dye your hair and you're all set.
>>
>>134502943
You might.

>>>/fit/
>>
>>134503032
>/fit/
>getting bitches
But they are all gay.
>>
>>134502983
>EOP fandom
>>
File: Fate.stay.night.full.1239292.jpg (142 KB, 792x671) Image search: [Google]
Fate.stay.night.full.1239292.jpg
142 KB, 792x671
>>134503084
Embrace it.
>>
>>134503154
>EOP
What?
>>
>>134503193
Bitches love it when you're gay. It's a whole new level of playing hard to get, both literally and figuratively. That even why you have fujoshi.
>>
>>134503274
That's it, now you're getting it!
>>
>>134502730
Looks like the perpetually triggered Sakurafags are up.
>>
>>134503669
Need a trip so we can filter you
>>
>>134503669
It's true, though. The shit they say often sounds like it's straight out of /r9k/ or /pol/, such as "used goods". They're cringeworthy as fuck even to people who don't care about Sakura one way or another.
>>
>>134503890
At least they use it against a bad character though.
>>
>>134503890
Bitching about used goods and sluts is nothing new on /a/, though. And do you people know so much about reddit?
>>
>>134498471
But it's not just sex. You, the viewer, bear witness, so it's voyeurism.
>>
>tfw cookingpriest changed his username

http://myanimelist.net/profile/Fai
>>
>>134503958
It's nothing new, but it's an old tired meme that's stale as fuck by now. Anyone still using it just looks like a huge tryhard trying to fit in with what they read on ED/KYM.
>>
>>134504013
Is that true? I always thought you were meant to self-insert during those segments but if it's meant to represent a sense of voyeurism as a third party, I think that actually adds a certain dimension with regards to the unsettling nature of the sex scenes.
>>
>>134498432
It's all titillation and fanservice. What'd you expect from an eroge aka *adult* visual novels? Not teens fucking or ancient kings and evil witches getting off on raping king arthur?
>>
>>134504015
doesn't have the same ring as cooking priest
>>
File: mPpxGNw.png (44 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
mPpxGNw.png
44 KB, 800x600
>>134504163
>>
>>134498432
Next time play Bible Black
>>
File: 1408158750451.png (488 KB, 1750x1200) Image search: [Google]
1408158750451.png
488 KB, 1750x1200
>>134502299
>>134502345
Best Sakura soon
>>
>>134504043
>I don't like it, so it's old and tired

Go back to bed worm-anon.
>>
>>134504204
It should be a woman's joy to be held down and be violated. So why do you refuse? It is not like you are a virgin. Are you scared to become mine?

It was Caster that dressed her in this white costume.
It is not arousing with her armor, and most of all, the armor does not suit her.
Caster should take time training her, since she is a lovely toy.
Then she should make her into a virgin that drowns in pleasure.


The writer seems to have a thing for Saber being fucked over by everybody
>>
File: notto disu shitto agen.jpg (156 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
notto disu shitto agen.jpg
156 KB, 1920x1080
>>134504204
>bait/stay night
>>
>>134498432
The only way to get into Fate is to never play the games, unless you want to fap, if that's not the case just stick to the anime which is better if you want real plot.
>>
>>134504736
Fuck off secondary. This guy gets it.
>>
>>134504435
>I don't like it, so it's "worm-anon"
Go back to bed, newfag.
>>
>>134498716
The more she drank, the more she shat.
>>
File: what the rin is cooking.jpg (32 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
what the rin is cooking.jpg
32 KB, 1280x720
>>134505312
The shit it stank, but the ass was fat.
>>
>>134504015
Fitting for the secondary circlejerk thread.
>>
>>134498432

Wait until you hit the jack hammering.
>>
>>134498884
He's got a thing for matter-of-factly describing the kind of mundane stuff most writers would choose to gloss over, dance around, or ignoring. It's the same with the sex scenes, he doesn't want to just fade to black or describe it poetically. Instead of saying a character is down with a bad stomach, he frankly states that the character is suffering from diarrhea and then details how awful the experience is. I think that's what most people are charmed by, because most of the really mainstream fantasy classics will almost have you think it's all grand adventuring and dragon-slaying all day long. I figure it's kinda like if you compared Terry Gilliam's Jabberwocky against The Desolation of Smaug. I'm personally not a big fan of ASoIaF, but I think the appeal of the book series is sort of like how I've described it.
>>
File: 1446002674066.png (312 KB, 866x631) Image search: [Google]
1446002674066.png
312 KB, 866x631
>actually thinking F/SN was good

Babby's First VN was overrated on this board due to the anime adaptations. Don't think for a second that this franchise has anything worth giving. All the routes are jumbled up cluster fuck messes and one is filled entirely with cooking filler.
>>
>>134505967
>one is filled entirely with cooking filler.
Fate was pretty bad, yeah.
>>
>>134506046
Fate and Heaven's Feel.
>>
I finished the Fate route a few years ago and didn't enjoy it that much. I've heard people say that it isn't representative of Nasu's writing. Are UBW and HF any better?
>>
File: notcanon.jpg (44 KB, 200x125) Image search: [Google]
notcanon.jpg
44 KB, 200x125
>>
>>134506484
UBW is way better, I was already enjoying it more than Fate by the end of the 3rd day.
HF is pretty boring as well, but it has its moments.
>>
File: notcanon2.jpg (48 KB, 400x250) Image search: [Google]
notcanon2.jpg
48 KB, 400x250
>>
>>134506878
>canon: what I like
>non canon: what I don't like

Fixed.
>>
>>134506878
KnK and Tsukihime can't both happen in the same universe, how come they are both canon?
>>
>>134498432
>>>/jp/
>>
>>134507877
>>>/out/
>>
>>134507541
It means that what happens in them is an accurate representation of the Nasuverse, like the different routes of one VN. Other stuff is fanfiction based on that universe.
>>
>>134506484
Not really. Nasu tries to tackle complex themes but gives you generic animu shit anyway.
>>
>>134506878
Technically, the only true Type-Moon works are:

>Tsukihime & PLUS-DISC
>Kagetsu Tohya
>Fate/stay night, Fate/hollow ataraxia
>Mahoutsukai no Yoru

Everything else is a spin off.
>>
>>134507970
Extra doesn't conflict with the rules of the Nasuverse, so by your own logic it is canon.
>>
>>134508026
Fate/Zero was published by TM and Extra was developped by them too.
>>
>>134508086
>Extra doesn't conflict with the rules of the Nasuverse
Yes it does
>>
>>134508169
anon, you can't just say it does or it doesn't without telling us how or why
>>
>>134508086
I didn't make the other image I wouldn't be able to tell you how he came up with that. I was simply explaining why both Tsukihime and KnK are both canon.

Personally I would say everything Nasu wrote is canon(Which would include Extra). As much as I love Kaleid, It might as well be fanfiction if we were to go into the nitty-gritty.
>>
>>134508195
Does it matter if it is canon or not?
>>
>>134508240
One of the reasons people like the Nasuverse is because of the world building. Differentiating between canon and non-canon is just useful because fans wanna know what to care about and what not to care about.

If you read the script for DtB season 3 and at the end you saw "disclaimer this is fanfiction OC do not steal" you might think you'd have wasted your time because you're a fan of DtB not NarutoLove113's literary work.

I love the spin-offs just as much as I like the main franchise though. Kaleid and CP are just as good. So it depends what you mean by matter.
>>
>>134498432
Ignore the smut, or play the Relata Nua version. I think the original version is better, but shit man, Nasu can't write smut worth a damn.

>>134498451
Early Type Moon art a shit. Storytelling is good tho.
>>
>>134508195
Stuff like Apocrypha and Strange Fake are also canon because they are Nasu approved. Kaleid, not so much since the author admits it's fanfiction.

Everything that remains consistent within the Nasuverse rules and branches off from a certain point in a primary work can be said to be canon. Only stuff like Fate Tiger Coliseum, CP and FUC which is so inconsistent with Nasuverse rules it might as well be something else aren't canon.
>>
fate/zero > fate/stay night
>>
>>134509314
don't trigger the eroge defense force
>>
>>134509314
Fate/Prototype > Fate/Hollow Ataraxia > Fate/Zero
>>
>>134509314
Fate/mollusk > Fate/EDGE
>>
>>134509462
My nigga
>>
>>134504447
>It should be a woman's joy to be held down and be violated.

Haddock vomit.jpg
>>
>>134498716
It's awful in both.
>>
>>134504447
>It should be a woman's joy to be held down and be violated. So why do you refuse? It is not like you are a virgin. Are you scared to become mine?
Is this from Sakura's secret H-scene with Shinji?
>>
>>134498923
You forgot the Myrish swamp.
>>
>>134510134
Gilgamesh says it to Saber in the F/a/te route senpai
>>
>>134510168
Saber isn't a virgin??
>>
clannad > steins;gate > fate/stay night
>>
>>134510288
Excalibur was too much for Saber to handle so uses Shirou's sperm to replenish her mana.
>>
File: 1448582233110.png (245 KB, 500x289) Image search: [Google]
1448582233110.png
245 KB, 500x289
>my friends kept trying to make me watch/read it
thank god I listened to my guts
>>
>>134510339
Baby level
>>
>>134510342
Eroge logic
>>
File: 1337106245491.png (2 MB, 1051x4140) Image search: [Google]
1337106245491.png
2 MB, 1051x4140
>>
>>134498432
Well, this is a VN releases during 2004, if I'm not mistaken, and there was little hope this type of media would sell without said scenes.
You can also see it as a form of imprinting clichés concerning the harem elements of this story, i.e., a way to get Shirou involved in some sort of sex antics.
If you're not into Shirou's ideology, it is also pretty difficult to enjoy FSN since there's no choice regarding which character POV the player/reader would want to go through the story with.
>>
>>134510339
Didn't really like S;G. Was too much of a YU-NO rip off with more modern otaku pandering. Still better than garbage like Muv Luv or butcher's stuff.
>>
>>134498884
You are right.This sounds like a sex scene in FSN.
>>
>>134510288
None of the heroines are, outside of Realta Nua.
>>
>>134510342
Clannad seemed to move in a slow pace, and the character didn't seem appealing to me. I felt like the plot tries way too hard to make the viewer cry, I don't even dislike melodrama completely, but it must be executed at the right time and circumstances.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 31

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.