Part 3.
You know the drill.
バンプ
![467Magmortar[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/Fa2pboo.png "467Magmortar[1].png")
Requesting Gen 1 Magmortar.
>>25794371
>>25794037
Gen 4 was noteworthy for having a ton of cross-gen evolutions, but the majority of them unfortunately fell into the "let's make them BIGGUR" trap
>>25794037
I really like this redesign for it. It's amazing what getting rid of that stupid mouth can do for a design.
I know Electabuzz has the antennae things but I bet Electivire would look great without those, and maybe keeping the weird wire things.
But how would a Gen VI Pikachu look like, though?
Asking the real questions.
>>25794389
Don't know if I really agree with that. Off of the top of my head the only ones that really fall into that category are Rhyperior, Tangrowth (which I actually think looks pretty good in spite of that), Lickilicky, Gliscor (also looks pretty good in my opinion.) and maybe Mismagius. I don't think they all look great, but I feel like they for the most part did a good job of at least making them obviously related but also distinct from their pre-evolutions.
>>25794389
What's wrong with just making it bigger?
>>25794483
In my opinion, Pokemon that fall into that category:
>Dusknoir
>Probopass
>Mamoswine
>Magmortar
>Electivire
>Tangrowth
>Rhyperior
>Lickilicky
>Magnezone
>Togekiss
Ones that don't:
>Weavile
>Yanmega
>Eeveelutions
>Gliscor
>Porygon-Z
>Gallade
>Froslass
So from my own personal list, the majority of Gen 4's cross-gen evolutions fell into that trap. This is just my own opinion though, and it clearly shows that I'm just not a huge fan of Gen 4.
>>25794583
>Probopass
>Legs and arms become magnetic noses
>Now works like a complete compass
>Enhances the magnetic theme by levitating and uses iron filings as facial hair
>Resembles a complete moai and not an unfinished one
"Just gets bigger" my fucking ass. Not even near Poilwrath tier.
>>25794470
Like it stopped eating for a month. Oh wait.
>>25794703
This guy fucking gets it. Probopass gets too much undeserved hate by people who don't understand the design. Even if the facial hair is weird, when I realized it was based on a complete moai my mind was fucking blown.
>>25794583
I don't think Dusknoir really fits. It has way more changes than something like Tangrowth, Magmortar, or Lickilicky.
>>25794371
>>25794583
>>25794483
>>25794389
There is literally nothing wrong with "it just gets bigger" if the design that gets bigger was already pretty much perfect to begin with.
>>25795284
Perfect example of a good 'it just gets bigger'
>>25795165
That's more of a redesign of what magmortar should have been than a gen 1 version desu.
>>25795324
Roger just end your life
Ahhh yay ee yay ee yaaaaayy
>>25794470
It would have a heart on its tail and/or cosplay as a wrestler
>>25794583
I am not a huge fan of 4 either in fact I think its almost as shit as 2 but you are seriously retarded if you believe electivre, togekiss, magmortor and mamoswine are cases of just gets bigger
Someone request something.
Requesting a gen 4 Meowstic
>>25794037
Requesting gen2 heatmor.
>>25795324
Nah, it's arguably more simple, line wise, than Magmar
>>25795988
Reposting this from the last thread.
>>25794037
please dear god don't do this to my favorite pokemon
>>25796702
And a version with a simplified tail.
Meh
>>25794037
from earlier thread
>>25796848
Negative, ghost rider. Can't even tell wtf is going on
>>25795966
Gen V Dugtrio
>>25795165
holy fuck that's so much better
Hey, if the based Pansear guy is still around, who said they would be willing to do a request for me than here is my request.
If you were willing to do me the solid of a gen 1 Flygon I would have some thoughts on the matter. I have no problems with Flygon's design but if he was going Gen1 I would probably expect him to adapt some more generic dragon-like wings. I imagine the goggles would need to be kept to hold on to the dragonfly origins, and i imagine them staying red is alright. Maybe a larger head proportional to the body and I'm not sure the stark reds would stick around on the body. Possibly replaced by more natural colors. I imagine his feet would probably get toes or more likely toe-like claws. If you were to take on my request I'm sure you have your own thoughts, definitely go with yours first, as you have a great grasp on it. Whether or not you do, keep up the good work guy.
>>25795966
Gen 2 Unfezant (and the rest of the line if you want)
>>25794037
Wow that looks amazing. I would love Electrivire if it looked like this.
>>25795165
This is good. Why did they have to get rid of the duck bill?
>>25796879
Why would you post a shit one?
>>25798545
Half a chan doesn't allow for multi-image posting? God, so backwards.
(lol, post filters, get bent)
>>25798594
>>25798604
>>25798619
>>25798604
this lucario looks like its holding in a massive shit desu
>>25798631
>>25798653
>>25798665
>>25798682
>>25798710
>>25798724
>>25798736
>>25798754
>>25798770
>>25798782
>>25798800
>>25798807
And the best for last.
>>25798665
Jesus Christ
>>25797916
Hey man, it's the Druddigon/Pan/Simisear guy. Out of town for the weekend, but I'll work on it when I get home.
>>25798665
Title of the image is top kek
>>25798604
>>25799362
For the keks?
>>25799967
Well done!
You should make a dex in numbered order with updated versions. I'd love to see Caterpie, Metapod, and Butterfree
>>25798682
HEY SOMEBODY DID MY REQUEST FOR ONCE! NICE!
>>25800097
Happened in the old thread, bro...keep up
Requesting gen 1 Larvesta and Volcarona
I'm requesting a gen 1 Swampert
Either one
>Gen 5 Ho-Oh
>Gen 1 Zygarde any %
>Gen 1 Zoroark
>>25800203
>>25800464
>>25800674
...anyone? Anyone!?
read the very bottom if you want to know how to do this
>>25801330
the eyes on baby kangajistan fucked me up real bad
>>25795165
looks fucking retarded
>>25801376
Ignoring the stupid fucking blush; the fuck is going on with its ears? There's some useless edges going on around it that OG Kanga doesn't have.
>>25801386
So youre saying theres no difference?
>>25801386
Eyyy...shit taste, friendo. You can't fix a shit design without completely redoing it, but if you don't think it looks at least a little better, you're smoking something.
>>25798665
I made this once upon a time
>>25794583
>Dusknoir
Looks almost nothing like Dusclops
>Probopass
It gets a hat, a mustache, loses its legs and arms, and gets 3 miniheads
>Mamoswine
No more fur in eyes, mask, different legs, different body shape in general
>Magmortar
Different face, different body, different tail, arm cannons
>Electivire
Different bodyshape, different head, electrical wires, furry
>Rhyperior
Orange plates, fatter, different tail, 2 horns
>Lickilicky
Different head, different patterns, different tail
>Magnezone
Seriously anon what the fuck
>Togekiss
See Magnezone
And yet you list Weavile and Yanmega as not being "it just gets bigger" when they're easily the most applicable. Are you actually blind?
>>25801408
>>25801420
sue me, always thought Magmortar looks fucking badass and 10 times better than your stupid buttface duck, also the edit itself is fucking terrible, look at that down syndrome beak
>>25796073
>Is a feline
Thats literally all they have in common
>>25801434
This guy gets it
>>25798604
>getting rid of the fist spikes
For what reason? That's like one of the few mons where the spikes actually make sense. And its not like gen 1 mons couldn't have random spikes. See Omastar.
>>25801436
>always thought Magmortar looks fucking badass
Stopped reading there
>>25798818
Brilliant
>>25800674
Just a sketch
>>25798594
I want this to be real so bad
>>25800674
It didn't end up very gud :(
>>25801420
It doesn't.
They both look like garbage.
What if Vileplume was introduced in Gen 5?
>>25801509
That looks like shit. Gen I had bipedal shit like Meowth, so it's not like you had to make it a quadruped.
>>25794583
lol
>>25801509
>>25801608
forgot what that guy said
looks great
it doesn't needed to be bipedal
>>25795165
Goddammit Anon I was just starting to like Magmortar now I see this and I just wish this what happened
Especially the tail
>>25794470
how'd I do, anons?
>>25801445
Steel wasn't in Gen 1. It would be pure Fighting type.
requesting gen 4 wobuffet
>>25801436
I only would change the color of the lips and legs. Im not fan of that color tone.
>>25795165
That's crazy how this little face change could have improved it
I fucking hate Magmortar for ruining my beloved Magmar, but I kinda like it with this face
>>25801386
>>25801436
Spotted the 10 years old
Requesting Gen 1 version of Escavalier and/or Accelgor
>>25795165
I hate the "babby's first drawing" oval body and legs that thing has. I wish its lower body anatomy was more 'natural' and realistic.
I like the revamp back to duckface though. Good job.
>>25801397
The babby Mega Evolved
I want to see a Gen V Jynx
>>25802316
I do too...although I started accepting it a little bit after I realized Magmar is kind of guilty of the same thing. Granted it looks more natural on Magmar, but it's still a similar idea.
That's the main reason I hate Lickilicky too...too simplistic. Will someone make a Gen I Lickilicky more similar to Lickitung's design?
>ctrl+f Honchkrow
>0 results
Lmao everyone forgets he's a cross gen evo
>>25802566
Probably because he's one of the better, more accepted designs.
>>25802498
I want this bad
>>25802498
Yes please!
>>25802587
Not if you go by the massive amount of shitposting there was about it around 2012
>>25802498
Looks like Marowak.
>>25802562
I agree.
I feel like we need a Lickilicky more like pic related - bigger, fatter and less simplistic.
>>25802838
The hivemind opinion changes over time. See: Gen V, Greninja.
>>25802842
A lot of Gen 1 mons look the same
How would Gen 5 Machamp work?
>everything gen 1 just gets white dragonball z triangle eyes with black pupils
>>25803392
Take away a pair of arms, give it a clown nose, some colored veins, and give it concrete slabs.
![067Machoke[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/fWEKFWj.png "067Machoke[1].png")
>>25803392
With the big lips and extra arms, Machamp could pass for a Gen 4 cross-gen evo.
i'd love to see a gen 6 chikorita
>>25803583
It'd still be shit
>>25803583
Here.
>>25799362
>>25803648
Nightmare fuel
Would you consider this too much for gen 1/2
>>25804308
Gen 2 for sure. Kind of reminds me of tyrogue.
>>25795165
That looks worse. The color contrast makes the official design look better. Here, you just plastred Magmar's tail on it and removed the pink along with removing the Firebreather trainer reference too.
tl;dr you missed the point, like these threads always do.
>>25797916
Awesome
>>25795165
Good!
>>25804308
I like it
>>25802282
spotted the underage who wants to fit in with the genwunners on facebook
>>25804478
Eh, opinion. I like it better.
>>25798604
>>25798818
>>25798594
Fucking nice.
>>25804308
Actually a really cool interpretation
>>25801330
>cherrypicking.jpg
>>25794037
hoooooly
that's terrible
>>25798724
This looks fucking rad.
>>25801330
>slugs are 100% made out of goo
Of course this whole image is mostly filthy bullshit, but that one line put my sides in orbit.
>>25801330
Jellicent's tentacles are must closer to real-life jellyfish tentacles than Tentacruel's. Tentacruel's tentacles look nothing like the real thing.
>>25801602
It's "hat" would be a much more blatant visual gag.
>>25808143
That's a lot of fucking cherries.
>>25808402
of 721 pokemon, it's pretty valid to call it cherrypicking
>>25801330
>Tyrantrum almost passes
FUCK
YOU
THE GOLD IS NOT RANDOM, IT'S ON THE EDGES OF HIS ARMOR PLATES TO MAKE THEM MORE DISTINCT
ITS FUCKING BLENDED, PRECISELY IN THE GEN 1 STYLE YOU DESCRIBED, WITH ROUGH OUTLINES FOR A NATURAL LOOK BECAUSE REPTILES ARE NOT FUCKING MONOCHROME, THEY HAVE MARKINGS, AND THE COLOR MATCHES HIS GOLD CROWN AND COORDINATES BEAUTIFULLY WITH HIS SHADE OF RED
TYRANTRUM IS A MASTERPIECE
FUCK YOU
>>25801330
>overly thin waist
>>25808474
You are retarded. Cherrypicking implies you could list at least as many examples of the contrary, where a newer gen mon is better drawn than his older counterpart. I would love to see you try.
hey guys, what about a gen 6 Palkia and/or Giratina? They would look different but how?
>>25801330
>criticising artstyle instead of design choices
you tried anon
>>25808617
Perfection.
>>25808617
the only bad part of the design i'd say is the flesh teeth on his upper lip but i guess it does fit the beard aesthetic
>>25801330
>filename
then why are gen 1 pokemon infinitely more popular and easy to marke?
>>25809459
Nostalgia
Take away nostalgia, and the amount of actually marketable Gen 1 Pokemon is about the same as any other gen
>>25795165
I dunno but imagina how cool mega magmortar might be
>>25809430
>flesh teeth
They're not flesh, they're stone.
Requesting Gen IV or V Jigglypuff.
>>25809675
Wait is this edited?
>>25809570
Stay mad faggot.
Your gen V shitmon bro will never get the marketing you wrongly think it deserves.
>>25809675
that would be a cute, punk rocker jigglypuff
I want everyone to know my actual favorite pokemon is Lickilicky.
So go ahead kids.
TRY to impress me.
>>25809711
Do you think they'd leave such a lewd face in the game?
>>25794483
>Mismagius
Nope, not even close to being just a bigger version of Misdreavous. One is a clump of hair with a pearly necklace and no body and the other is a tall, elegant floaty wizard. I can't even see why you would possibly say it's just a bigger version of Misdreavous unless you don't know what that expression means.
>>25809711
Yes. The real one doesn't have the eye sparkles, drool or blush
>>25794583
What the hell is wrong with you? You're another example of someone who has no clue what "it just gets bigger is".
With the exception of Tangrowth and Lickilicky, ALL of those you said fell into that category aren't even close to being just bigger versions of their prevos. They are new, distinct designs. Tell me what exactly your thought process was for saying Dusknoir and Electivire were just bigger versions of Dusclops and Electabuzz, please.
Also, Weavile is probably one of the dumbest evolutions in term of design. Literally just adding a retarded headfan to Sneasel's head is so lazy.
>>25809832
Ewww
>>25809732
It's a fact that Lucario is more recognizable than any Gen 1 Pokemon that isn't Pikachu, the starters, Jigglypuff, or Mewtwo.
>>25802005
I tried.
Also, edited with MS Paint.
>>25809120
Either she's Gen-1'd himself or that Meowstic is a reverse-trap.
Kinda hard to decide if I should like that or not...
Gen 6 Nidoking
>>25798682
Well it's actually an improvement.
>>25794371
>>25810537
Looks sick desu
>>25810537
that look great
>>25810537
>no buster arms
SOILED IT
>>25808374
This. Always annoys me when I see that.
>>25810537
now this is something i can get behind, looks more like a mega magmar though
>>25810537
You brought back the duck mouth but not the head-ass. Why?
>>25810537
it's looks so much better than magmar or magmortar
I want to train this right now
>>25810332
It looks cool actually.
Gen 1 Torterra (Turtwig is fine too)
>>25810537
I came buckets.
>>25810537
Looks sick -- but on the other hand, I didn't think it was supposed to be Magmortar. I know many Gen I Pokemon just look like bigger versions of their prevos, but this one really really does.
That's not to take away from a great piece of work. Touché.
>>25810537
could you please have a deviantart or anything like that and draw a lot of pokemon in gen 1 style?
>>25810757
Torterra looks something that could be gen 1, it's not that complicated compared to something like Venusaur
>>25810537
Now that looks fucking great.
>>25809732
Stay stuck in the past sucking Gen 1's cock you pathetic shithead
I never did anything like this before.
Is this any good?
>>25810856
Nah, its head shape and the border on its shell are very gen 4. Gen 1 Torterra would be a much different creature.
>>25811289
That looks really cool anon!
>>25810537
The fact that I will never be able to train this pains me on a physical, mental, and spiritual level.
>>25811289
Actually sweet.
Angrier than I'd expect for a basic but still cool. You definitely got the fur right
>>25810757
>>25813455
fucking kek
>>25810757
Torterra was one of the best things to come from Gen 4 desu
>>25810537
>>25796848
It's a need anon. Don't even try. They just need to axe rhyperior all together and start over
>>25811289
Needs more of a muzzle.
>>25810537
It's everything I ever dreamed. I'mgenuinely mad this isn't the official version now.
>>25810550
>>25810564
>>25810537
>>25810677
>>25810816
>>25810878
>>25813950
It's not a Magmortar redesign it's a fucking Mega Magmar.
>>25802498
That's so cool.
>>25808617
Tyrantrum really is a fucking masterpiece im with you anon. I wish he was better he's so fucking cool.
>>25816591
Kek
>>25815903
Thirded. My favorite fossil
>>25810537
Should've kept the arm cannons
>>25810537
>has less detail than its prevo
Thats gen 1 all right.
Also I would complain that it looks too close to Magmar but gen 1 was all about that "just gets bigger" syndrome.
>>25816591
I dun geddit
>>25818129
Pikachu gets skinnier as the mascot; if clefairy were the mascot so would he
>>25818129
clefairy was originally meant to be the pokemon mascot
>>25817377
>>25815903
>>25808617
fourthed my nigs
>>25817959
Amen
What have I done
>>25797916
>>25799310
Hey if you wanted some ideas I have been fucking around on MSpaint, because I don't have the skills you have, but just in case you were curious.
>>25813455
>>25818980
>>25819344
Yeah man lets see it
>>25820642
Keep in mind they aren't any attempts at making something look good, just ideas. A slightly bigger head and or adjusted antenna sizes might be something to look in to as well.
>>25818980
what am I looking at
>>25801438
I think he may be the same anon who dicks up the fakemon threads
>>25809832
You know what?He's one of my favourites too.
>>25820864
Nice. Would have to be part Bug though.
>>25801330
>cartoony heart shaped nose
It's a fucking human skull though
>>25809832
Please someone do this.
>>25821079
That Vullaby looks like it just took a massive fucking shit.
>>25798818
>real wings and real legs
finally something i could use without vomiting
Someone do Gen 2 Braviary, please
>>25821271
>>25794703
This!
>>25794746
>Probopass gets too much undeserved hate by people who don't understand the design
And fucking this!
>>25794583
>Probopass, Magnezone and Togekiss in "Pokemon that fall into that" category
> Not Weavile
Are you serious?
>>25820864
what gen is the jigglypuff?
>>25820915
Because its insectile features were tottally taken into accouny before
>>25821984
I'd assume V
>>25801602
The hat would be a fedora
>>25809832
>>25809832
300 years in GNU+Linux paint
>>25823067
>>25823141
Nope. Needs a complete redesign.
>>25810537
And the /mortar/ part in its design is?
>>25825193
That Venusaur is pretty based.
>>25810537
impressive
>>25794583
>porygon-Z
Porygon-Z doesn't change whatsoever. It literally just flips the head upside down and twists the limbs.
>>25794037
What if no unnecessary evolutions was introduced during 2nd or 4th gen? Seriously, even number gens suck.
Requesting a shuckle for every generation, not a troll a post this is a legit request
>>25801330
>all these people in these threads/on the internet in general
>"if ____ was made in gen 1"
>hurrr itd be simplr! itd hav 1 colour n hav no shapes n nothin!!!!
Fucking thank you. Gen 1 pokemon are NOT simpler, they're way more detailed.
>>25794583
With the exception of Tangrowth, you're way off base with that. Like, what the fuck are you talking about? Magneton goes from three attached magnemites into one solid fucking UFO that looks nothing like any of the other two stages. Mamoswine goes from a lump of fur into something that actually resembles an animal. Togekiss loses its entire neck and arms. Dusknoir might as well be a different pokemon entirely. Meanwhile, Porgyon-Z doesn't even get bigger. It just twists its limbs. They don't even change. It's the same pokemon.
>>25825898
seconding
>>25810537
It's like Magmar as a DBZ villain. I love it.
>>25818136
Man, that OG Pikachu looks way cuter than the Subway diet Pikachu we've got now. Look at that lil chubby bastard.
>>25798724
holy shit this is awesome
>>25826588
>Later gen Exeggcute
>Remove all detail, make the eyes completely round circles, and add some random stripes and pointless clashing colors.
>>25813455
My sides, you did good anon
>>25826690
An Easter egg version of Exeggcute? That's be pretty cool
>>25801577
You used unofficial art as base to begin with
>>25809859
At least they respected the eyes. I give them credit for that.
But, what the fuck is that mouth. Also, was it designed by a borafag that likes Stewie from Family Guy?
>>25825906
This guys gets it. While the color pallette might be slightly simpler (to accommodate for the earlier hardware), body shapes and add ons are much more detailed and realistic in shape.
>>25809859
>>25826858
Mismagius is my favorite 4th gen.
