![RWRtJZu[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/uNem51Q.jpg "RWRtJZu[1].jpg")
This is /v/'s up-to-date GOAT list. What do you faggots think of it? It looks pretty good imo.
>>342773205
Vice city is my favorite game and it has no business being that high on the list
>FFT #4i prefered FFTA
>Persona 4 over NOcturne
>P3 isn't even on the list
>MGS2 so low
>Bayo 2 over 1
>BG 1 over 2
>All those nintendo platformers with no Crash/Spyro/Sly/Jak/Rachet and Clank
Holy shit this list is pure garbage
Each series should only have its best game, maybe two if it's an exceptionally large series like Final Fantasy, Zelda, or Mario. Things like 4 Metal Gears prevent the list from covering other games/series.
>>342773205
nitendrones trying so hard
>>342775291 , here
Also, Twilight Princess over New Vegas and Dark Souls? Fuck off.
If I've never played a final fantasy game which game should I start with?
>>342773205
>No Undertale
>No E.Y.E. Divine Cybermancy
Break your legs, you faggot
>>342775304
Metal Gear Rising is fundamentally different from the rest in the series.
>>342775582
4 for classic FF
7 for Golden PSX age
X or 12 for PS2
none of the 7th gen games
I remember the very first time we voted on this, it was right after Dark Souls came out. It was #1 for months. Now it's not even in the top half, fromdrones are such fucking cancer.
>>342773205
>>p4 over 3, 2
>that many fucking zelda, metal gear, mario games
List is alright, but the ordering sucks. I am happy that my favorite game is on there though
>PW and w101 in top ten
Not even gonna look at the rest
>>342773205
this is your list, not /v/, you
most of it is shit
>>342775863
Generally, the longer a game is out, the easier it is for the flaws to shine through. A lot of people probably just like it was a breathe of fresh air in modern game design at the time. That, and maybe not a lot of them had made it to Lost Izilith.
Please continue to stay fucking salty though, you fucking faggot
>>342773205
Most of these games are not even 10 years old or not that good to be on those spots
Like I know W101 is fun but it doesn't deserve to be ranked that high
>>342773205
>echochamber solipsism taste: the post
>>342773205
>played 18/100
I don't even like most of the ones I've actually played, this list is shit
looks like a bunch of fags made it
I still don't get why people like Morrowind so much. Maybe I didn't play it far enough.
>>342776853
Typically Elder Scrolls games don't get good until you reach about level 20 where you have a good handle on the mechanics and have past the shittier beginning quests for the factions.
>morrowind #1
Dont get me wrong... I fucking love this game. And the landscapes/enemies/plot is fairly unique but without mods this game is an unstable steaming pile of poo.
>>342777136
Any tips for making it less of a slog? I remember disliking how slow the character walked and how it took ages to kill one enemy. Also, any decent graphics mods?
>>342777242
Explore as much as you can and focus only on one or two combat skills. Speechcraft is the most powerful skill.
>>342773205
>Morrowind over SMB3
What?
>>342777340
Thanks, I'll give it another go.
>Morrowind
>Fedora's Mask
>Final Fantasy Tactics
>Warcraft 3
>Phoenix Wright
>DKC2
>Wonderful 101
>all in the top 10
/v/ has pretty shit taste.
>>342775665
>Metal Gear Rising is fundamentally different from the rest in the series.
It's also fundamentally shit.
>>342773205
WHY IS THERE NO QUAKE?
>>342774036
Why would you lie on the internet ?
I " only " liked Vice City and i think it deserves to be so high
>>342777741
>SMB3
>Shit Taste
>>342778057
I didn't list SMB3 because it deserves to be in the top 10.
None of those other games do.
>>342778057
>>342777741
>all in the top 10
Stop Anon.
>>342777741
But those are good games
>>342773205
>Warcraft 3
>Ace Attorney
>Wonderful 101
>fucking Majora's Mask
>in the top ten games of ALL TIME
Stopped reading there
>>342778402
They may be good, but they're not top ten good.
>>342778402
and they're only in the top ten to retards that have played less than 30 games
>Earthbound finally above Mother 3
It's nice to see once in a while.
MGS2 is way too low, though.
>Majora's Mask instead of OOT
>IX instead of VII
>Tactics instead of tactics advance
>Marios lmao
>Visual Novels
>More platformer shit
>Mixed Reviews shit
>alttp instead of plenty of subsequent 2D zeldas that were objectively better
As if I needed any more proof that /v/ is a bunch of hipsters
Doom II that much higher than Doom I? What the fuck?
>Dragons Dogma
>MGR Revengeance
>on this list at all
Haha come on now
How many people were polled, twelve? No any kind of decent margin of /v/ thinks fucking Morrowind is the best game of all time.
>>342779428
This
The guy who made the lists is todd
>Deus Ex not #1
That's how I know you got this list from reddit.
>>342779641
You spelled God Hand wrong
>>342775452
Yeah this is a shitty list, who fucking approved this?
The old one from 2012 I think.
>>342779852
I'll never understand how this one doesn't have Cave Story.
>>342779852
>gta 4 above RDR
>>342779852
better
/v/ has awful taste these days
>>342779852
Top 10 is better, but still bad.
>>342780062
Because the other platformers and run and guns on the list are better?
>>342779852
Wait what wheres Vice City ? It wasnt top 100 in 2012 and now its nearly top 10 in 2016 ?
>>342780239
/v/ had a huge hard on for Cave Story back then. This was slightly before indie games turned big
>>342780190
>these good games are bad
I want you dead
>>342773205
>doom 2 over doom 1
>stalker anywhere near this list
>no DaS2 but DeS and DaS1 are both there
>no bioshock 2
>what the actual fuck is Yggdra union?
>>342780418
>>no DaS2 but DeS and DaS1 are both there
nothing wrong with that
>>342780418
>doesn't like stalker
>DaS2
>bioshock 2
confirmed pleb
>>342773205
I've never played Morrowind.
Should I go for that over Skyrim remastered?
>>342779852
Just looking at the top ten this looks so much better.
>old list- balance of western and eastern games of different genres
>new list- mostly eastern and just filled with turn based rpgs and action adventure games
>>342780239
Cave story is one of the closest examples of a perfect game, very few like smb3 and doom are as high quality. How ut didn't make that list is bizarre.
>>342780524
I can't say anything about DeS because I've never played it myself but DaS is fucking overrated as fuck, and made 3 arguably the worst out of the series because all 3 is, is pandering to 1 in every fucking way possible and removing all the good shit from 2.
>>342780692
Stalker is too slow. Bioshock 2 is way better gameplay wise and didn't even try a final boss because they knew it'd just suck even more ass than 1, plus it's good throughout, and doesn't just drop off 3/4s in.
>>342780734
Playneither.
>>342773205
>Wonderful 101
>9th
Was it really that good?
>>342773205
>morrowind
>number one
>>342779852
What the fuck went wrong?
>>342780878
I don't think you can really compare Stalker to Bioshock
>>342781104
I'm not, my bad. I was saying that about bioshock 1, should have separated them more.
>>342773205
>morrowind
typically games in the first place should have gameplay as the reason they are in first, not lore. Final Fantasy Tictacs or Warcraft 3 should be in the first spot. Morrowind and Fedora's Tip shouldn't even grace the top 50.
>>342779852
Fixed.
Muramasa, Odin Sphere and P4 should be there somewhere.
>>342781337
>dorf fort is /v/core
top kek, I bet the vast majority of /v/ couldn't even make it 2 minutes into the game before going "shit grafix wtf how do I play I don't get it, why isn't this like Overwatch or LoL?".
>>342775452
All 3D Zelda games have better gameplay than Dark Souls
>slow combat that lacks the control and precision of Zelda combat
>good
>>342781080
/v/ started obsessing about things like politics, other websites, and gender instead of video games. And while OP's list has very obviously an embarassingly low sample size to the point I'm not sure why he bothered compiling the votes, it is at the very least 1) OC and 2) directly about video games. Something that can save the board.
>>342781337
>>342780239
But that's not true at all
>>342780806
Please never put Cave Story in the same league as Doom or SMB, ever again. It's a great game, but it's far from perfect. The gunplay isn't as good as people say it is, let alone the platforming.
>>342781583
see >>342781563
this isn't 2007 anymore.
>4. Final Fantasy Tactics
>9. The Wonderful 101
>13. Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver
>21. Bayonetta 2
>25. The Witcher 3
>37. Dragon's Dogma
>49. SMT: Persona 4
>50. Fire Emblem
>62. Dark Souls
>80. Nier
Why don't we create a poll? Because the site that was used to make this shit glitched every two seconds and allowed multiple votes from the same IP. Also I'd like to remind you that Bad Rats was in the first top 10 for a couple of hours and Nintendrones raided the whole poll.
>>342773205
No xenogears or legend of mana, the "current" list less than shit. Good try anon
>>342781454
>>342779852
These are fucking great. Add The Witcher 3 in top 50.
looks like shit, some of those games aren't even critically acclaimed
>>342781862
>critically acclaimed
Where the fuck do you think you are?
>42. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
>62. Dark Souls
Literally two most beloved games on /v/, we all know that this poll is fake and gay. We should try again, using a different website.
>>342781862
>games have to be critically acclaimed to be considered good
http://pastebin.com/u/JJJKopf
>>342781696
However I would say Cave Story is better than Mega Man 2 which is on the list.
>>342781971
>>342782152
Just report and ignore please, unless you like threads getting derailed by obvious flamers.
>>342781971
in a place where people use goty awards as arguments
>>342780380
>Dark Souls
>Half-Life 2
>Team Fortress 2
>good games
>>342781040
it's definitely one of the top 6 wii u games:
>W101
>Pikmin 3
>Bayo 2
>Splatoon
>Dong Freeze / SM3DW
>>342782292
>Dark Souls
>bad game
Worst meme since daily dose
>>342782161
>life is strange
I didn't even have to scroll and I knew it was full of shit.
>>342782471
Dark Souls is babby's first "hard" game.
I cant believe Civilization IV cant make it to a top 100 list
>>342782452
well it's definitely not in the top 9 games of all time. If it was Wii U would be worth buying.
>>342782548
That's because 4x games are awful.
>>342782514
Does that make other aspects of it bad? No.
>>342773205
this is so obviously a nintendrone list
who even talks about wonderful 101 anymore?
>morrowind and majoras mask 1 and 2
Kek didn't even read past that. Its literally a Reddit or gamefaqs approved top 100 list.
>>342773205
>leddit filename
Kill yourself OP
>>342776402
>buzzwords that the poster loosely understands
the post
>>342782827
Well it was raided by reddit and the website allowed multiple votes from the same IP.
>>342777836
you fundamentally have shit tastes mate
>>342773205
Holy shit, that's worse than the old one and that one was years out of date.
>>342782873
>knowing that a mismatched jumble of letters as a filename is from reddit
>>342780878
>overated
nice empty criticism
>>342783124
It's common knowledge if you aren't a newfag.
>>342783269
Or if you go to fucking reddit.
>>342782514
marketing to normies doesn't mean it isn't still a good game
>>342779852
Swap HL with HL2 and replace TF2 with BB and that list pretty much still holds up.
>>342783124
>i-it's not from reddit i swear!
>>342783418
>Bubble Bobble
My nigga
>>342783421
Great argument pal.
>>342773205
Morrowind is number one with Majora's Mask at number two?
What kinda shit list is this?
>>342783375
Over the years you learn where all filenames originate from since anons keep bitching about it.
You will too.
>>342773205
megaman legends is not on the list there for it is shit
>>342783572
list on a website that allows multiple votes from the same ip
>>342783682
Yea.
>>342783572
majoras mask is just the normal wee wee pee poo loz stuff but with annoying time mechanics?
>>342783682
>>342783803
I've played MML why do you guys like it so much? It's pretty bad for a TPS.
>>342773205
>Phoenix Wright
Most disappointing shit /v/ has ever hyped up.
It seems universally loved here but I also fell for the shilling of Neptunia.
Weebs just have shit taste.
>all that rpg
/v/ really is gay and friendless
>>342773205
>morrowind
>majoras mask
>final fantasy 9
What the fuck. Decent games but nowhere near top ten. Disregard this shit.
>>342774036
It's alright but a few things are confusing.
Diablo 2 listed over Lord of Destruction.
Warcraft 3 TFT being so high up especially when starcraft broodwar was superior as an MP game and a campaign .
KOTOR1 being listed instead of KOTOR2
>wii u game in the top 10
>final fantasy
>elder scrolls
>fallout 2 but no fallout 1 which is the best game in the series
>no planescape: torment
this is as degenerate as it gets
>>342773205
SMB 2 > SMB 3
Fire Emblem & Witcher 3 shouldn't be above Dark Souls.
>>342783682
On a similar note
>no Megaman Battle Network
>>342773205
cuckrina of time fags on suicide watch
