Top 10 dungeons in WoW according to IGN:
10. Grimrail Depot
9. Zul'Farrak
8. Culling of Stratholme
7. Icecrown Citadel Dungeons
6. The Deadmines
5. Grim Batol
4. Scarlet Monestary
3. Shadow Labyrinth
2. Magisters' Terrace
1. Zul'Gurub
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-AUoF2hVHEo&feature=youtu.be
are they right?
They got number 1 right for sure.
Cata Zul'Gurub was a fucking masterpiece of linear dungeon design. It's a shame 90% of the player base was awful at it.
>>335207212
I like Shadowmoon Burial Grounds better than Grimrail, other then that, I think thats a solid list.
Grimrail was ass
>No Shadwfang Keep
what
>no BRD
>post vanilla dungeons at all
>wow on complete damage control
>h-hey guys do you remember these dungeons? p-please buy the expansion...
>>335207212
>Zul'Gurub
>dungeon
T O P K E K
O
P
K
E
K
>>335209470
>remember that time when Blizzard shat out recycled content? BEST DUNGEON EVER
>>335207212
>Culling of Stratholme
>Grim Batol
>ZG as a dungeon
It's shit.
Shadow Labs is my favorite dungeon. Its fairly long, and the heroic version back in BC was murder if you didnt know what you were doing. Plus the Murmur Fight was dank as fuck
>>335207212
>Grim Batol
>Those shitty icecrown dungeons
Maybe i missed something but both of those felt pretty shitty, they were basically linear and had no interesting gimmicks. It's like they decided they needed some cata and wotlk dungeons in there
OG Deadmines not #1
>>335207212
>grimrail
>grim batol
>mgt
epic
>>335209810
My Nigga
I remember doing this (heroic) when i was like 15 and thinking i was hot shit
>10. Grimrail Depot
WHAT
THE
FUCK
Why is this even on the list? It was the worst dungeon in WoD and possibly the worst dungeon ever, bar Violet Hold.
>>335209936
Grimrail has a cool gimmick atleast and the mini gunner boss is pretty rad
>>335207212
>no scholomance
IGN is fucking shit
>>335209567
Zul'Aman was a literal rehash with little changes.
Zul'Gurub was a complete overhaul, and was a fucking masterpiece.
>>335209932
OG VC wasn't even that good desu
>>335209869
The linearity of Grim Batol was minor compared to retards never understanding what targets to hit with the drakes or grasping simple concepts on the bosses.
>>335209567
What are you even talking about? zul'gurub isn't a dungeon nigga.
>Guild was too shitty for 40 mans
>We just did ZG all the time
>Finally got enough people in guild for MC
>It's just boring tank and spank shit
They really got a lot better at dungeons later. I'm glad ZG was basically my most frequent raid in WoW. Karazhan every week was a pretty good shit-tier guild dungeon too, when BC came out.
Never played past BC.
>>335207212
Zul'Gurub was amazing as a dungeon, it was hard and worked really well, but the Icecrown dungeons sucked dick, they were short and fucking awful, what were they thinking?
>No shadowfang keep
>No original stratholme
>NO FUCKING BLACK ROCK DEPTHS
>>335209994
Grimrail was by far my favorite WoD dungeon. I don't see how you can think it was the worst.
>>335208363
Came here to post this.
No Shadowfang Keep automatically gets this list an invalid/10
>>335207212
>Dungeons
>Zul'Gurub
?
>>335210274
They were all shit senpai
We're gonna bring back Karazhan as a 5-man Dungeon
Where the fuck is Ulduar?
Not sure why MgT and the icecrown dungeons are on there.
Can't speak for deadmines because horde stronk
I think the rest of the list looks alright.
>>335210306
They recycled ZA and ZG and made five mans out of them at one point.
>>335210438
Ulduar wasn't a dungeon you colossal faggot.
>>335210389
Might as well, already pissing in the ashes of all the content that used to be good
>>335208464
Nothing wrong with it, BRD was garbage and no one who played during vanilla liked it. It's wotlk kids who never even played through it for some reason decided to meme it as a good dungeon
Personally I would remove all wotlk dungeons from this list
There nothing good about them
>>335210389
>Karazhan getting back in the spotlight
Honestly I wouldn't be mad if they made a patch breaking the original raid down into some Dungeons.Too bad no new players would like the Chess Encounter because they're too fucking retarded to understand it.
>>335210460
>Not sure why MgT is there
because this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqHTwLU40yU&t=86s
How the fuck is the Culling of Stratholme on this list? that's the most boring fucking dungeon in the game
>>335207212
LOL
HO
LEE
SHIT
>Culling of Stratholme
>Grimrail Depot
>"Icecrown Citadel Dungeons"
>Scarlet Monastary
>Zul'Gurub
This is a travesty.
>>335210274
Because it's a fucking corridor. It's the laziest design you can come up with bar a single room.
>>335210306
They removed it as a raid and remade it into a dungeon during cataclysm.
>>335210618
>complaining that a train is a straight line
>>335210274
Too many vanilla fags can't comprehend gameplay beyond moving out of a puddle
>>335210504
>They recycled ZA and ZG
>ZG
You never was in the original ZG, right?
>>335210636
So the rehashed ZG is apparently the best dungeon to them?
???
>>335210567
you only need 1 person in the group to do chess anyway
>>335210256
The ICC dungeons were challenging and fun.
>>335210710
Too many retail fags don't understand that a dungeon should be more than one tunnel with no turns or options.
>>335210578
>Get to experience Arthas going crazy first hand
>Fight those baller-fucking Infinites
>Bronze Drake drop from heroic
>One of the best looking X-Mog shield drops
>Fighting Mal'ganis beside Arthas
Honestly the only shitty part was the wave stuff before hand.
>no original Scholomance
why do people hate a challenge?
>>335210709
Yes that's right.
>We're too lazy to make a real dungeon
>what can we do?
>I know, let's make a train, it's a single corridor but we'll put a moving background in there and retarded nerds will think it's cool
>>335210567
>implying there's anything to "understand" about "move the pawns in front of the king and queen forward, then just sit in the king the rest of the time"
>>335207212
Oculus should be #1
>>335209567
ZG remake was actually fucking amazing.
The ZA rehash was pathetic though.
>>335210726
ZA was apparently rehashed, but ZG got a whole rework if I remember right, even a bit of an intro questline to run around Northern Stranglethorn seeing what's going on.
>>335210593
there's nothing wrong with SM or ZG (although it prolly doesn't deserve #1)
>>335210578
It was the best dungeon on launch. It was only boring in later patches when you outgear it and have to wait around the whole time.
Appart from Shadowmoon Burial Grounds (that fucking atmosphere and subterranean lake), I can't think of a single post-BC dungeon I like
Shadowfang, Scholomance, Shadow Lab, Shattered Halls, Magister's Terrace were the tits
>>335210898
Only the first boss was good and that was because I could solo it for 10 minutes while everyone else was dead because they're stupid.
>>335210919
>Among all of the raptors in Mandokir's domain, one familiar face stands out. She's grown a little bigger, and she's earned a few scars, but the lashtail hatchling is still here.
>She recognizes you. Her father has finally come back to save her.
>>335210780
Ah blackrock depths, the most enjoyable dungeon in the game
>Zul'Farrak
Zul'Farrak was pretty standard shit honestly
It was nonlinear but in the most boring way and didn't really have events outside of the pyramid thing
But I'm a filthy faggot who likedMaraudon and Sunken Temple
>>335207212
>Grimrail Depot
>Straight line with one interesting boss, the turret faggot
>Grim Batol
>Huge letdown, waste of what was easily one of the most mysterious and interesting locations in WoW
These do not belong.
Everything else I agree with though.
>>335207212
This list is bad and you should feel bad, any list that includes shitty mechanics like pulling everything and aoeing it is terrible.
>>335211142
my heart broke when they split up mara and ST
>>335210565
>no one who played during vanilla liked it
You mean, nobody SHIT that played during vanilla liked it, because me and everyone I knew liked it. That fucking place is the pinnacle of dungeon designing from Blizzard and we will never have anything like it again. That's part of why WoW is shit now
Vanilla dungeons were generally nonlinear and embraced the classic roots of dungeon delving ala D&D games. You have a dungeon, you enter it, you aren't quite sure what to expect, no one's really telling you where to go, there are some secrets on the way, and you may not finish or even survive the whole thing.
The linearity and loss of scope really detracted as time went on.
>>335211229
What? They were never the same dungeon.
WHY
IS
TIMEWALKING
A
TIMED
EVENT?
WHY CAN'T I JUST QUEUE AND GET SCALED DOWN TO ANY DUNGEON AND HELP NEWBIES DOING THE DUNGEON?
WHY IS THE LATEST PATCH CONTENT THE ONLY RELEVANT CONTENT IN THE GAME?
>>335211185
the first boss has you trick one guy into ramming into the other guy, how is that not cool?
>>335211229
They didn't "split up" Sunken Temple they got rid of the shitty bosses on the upper floor because they added absolutely nothing to it
>>335211303
Let me guess, you get nostalgic remembering how you and your friends got lost in it when you were 12
>>335207212
>no strat
They goofed
>>335211389
blizzards way of making the content last longer sadly
>>335211341
I mean they split mara up into separate dungeons, and they split ST up into separate dungeons
>>335211303
>me and everyone I knew liked it
Literally who
I bet you started in wotlk or end of bc
Vanilla had good dungeons, like scholo, but brd wasn't one of them
>>335208567
>literally make fun of blizzard for shutting down nost in the video
>BLIZZ SHILLS!
?
>>335211506
Oh, that's really shitty. I can kinda understand Mara, but why ST?
>>335211185
>one interesting boss, the turret faggot
The most interesting boss in the dungeon came before the most boring one, and that most boring one was the end boss. They had a neat idea by fighting on a moving train, but they fucked up with the boss order.
>>335211604
apparently they didn't split it up, they just got rid of half of it
>>335211604
Too long and mazelike
Even though it was just the right length and not retarded like BRD
>>335211389
Your concern with timewalking dungeons isn't even that big of a deal since you can literally just get better gear killing mobs in tanaan
>WHY IS THE LATEST PATCH CONTENT THE ONLY RELEVANT CONTENT IN THE GAME?
Too many people bitching they can't see all the content because making older content (even raids from the last patch) relevant would mean getting rid of all the shortcuts to current content and would make people have to run older raids not in LFR
>anything on the list that isnt Vanilla/BC
also
>still playing WoW post Wrath of Ruin the Game King
I miss being young and being able to immerse myself in video games...
>>335211701
When you posted this did you think it would be a good contribution? Do you think your opinion is controversial or special in some way?
>putting WoD dungeons in the top 10
Fucking LOL
Reminder that WoW music has never not been good
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngYzSvC864s&t=6m35s
>>335211821
Yes. Yes.
>>335209810
The second boss is still one of the hardest five man bosses they've ever designed, He was absolute bullshit the first time you tried to do it, even on normal. Hell even the trash mobs were hard in that dungeon.
Tbh Murmur was the easiest part so long as people knew how to move quickly
>>335211857
The fantastic music and art are wasted on shit game, sadly.
>>335211827
WOD dungeons weren't too bad, definitely better than MOP dungeons. After Blizzard's retarded server fiasco and before the content drought WOD was looking very promising.
Rate this superior list
1. Blackrock Depths
2. Deadmines
3. Blackrock Spire
4. Dire Maul
5. Scholo
6. Halls of Reflection
7. Maraudon
8. Razorfen Downs
9. Shadowfang Keep
10.Heroic Steamvault
>>335211701
>not realizing 3.1 was the pinnacle of the game
I think I spotted the nostcuck
>>335207212
THATS ZUL'AMAN
The casual shit version at that
>>335211962
>muh BRD
>mara
>RFD
nah
>>335211701
3.1 > 5.2 > vanilla > BC
>>335211962
>Razorfen Downs
Mah nigga.
>>335211919
was the second boss the fucker that turned into a voidspawn?
>>335211941
>MoP dungeons
>Bad
>>335207212
>>335211962
Deadmines is a literal meme dungeon and far from one of the best.
>>335211962
swap heroic steamvault for heroic shadow labs and swap maraudon with SM armoury and i'd agree
>>335211119
Yes, actually. The only truly amazing dungeons that felt like a real dungeon.
>>335210567
I remember soloing chess for the shield on my shaman. My 10 man group came in the next day like "wtf why is chess down" and I just kind stayed silent and equipped the shield a few weeks later.
Good times
>>335212106
>armory
Spotted the warrior. Library and Cathedral are much cooler.
>>335211962
>Maraudon
>Dire Maul
No one actually liked going there.
>>335212123
>a real dungeon
as opposed to what, a fake dungeon?
>>335211701
>Burningbabb still thinks his meme opinions are relevant
>>335211962
>brd
Into trash it goes
>>335212190
i'll give you library but cathedral's pulls were a nightmare
>>335211303
The bar and the lyseum were straight bullshit. Most groups ended at the bar because someone fucked it up and the walk back was ridiculous and the Lyseum mandated a mage or you were not fucking clearing it.
I love the dungeon too because of the sheer volume of content in it along with the amazing loot the last boss dropped but let's not pretend it wasn't badly designed.
>>335211962
Dire Maul is too fucking big and boring.
>>335212206
I l-liked Maraudon
I could actually find groups that would finish it, unlike BRD
>>335211604
They didn't split ST.
They chopped the upper and lower floors off. Now it's just the main room with Hakkar, Eranikus, Morpho and the Zombie Troll guy.
Zul'Farrak will always be my favorite. That moment when you saved that party at the top of the temple, turned the camera around to go down and see like a hundred of mobs down there. Moments like that helped leveling in early WoW feel like a long journey.
Now you can just aoe them all.
What about favorite dungeon music?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eghspESM7v8
>Dungeons should be a time commitment on par with raids
t. nostalgiafags
>>335212206
Maraudon isn't so bad since they split it up.
>>335212345
You wouldn't know good design if it hit you in the face.
>>335212345
>Most groups ended at the bar
I forgot about this, was so fucking frustrating
>>335212067
Truly the worst. Even the music was abysmal.
>>335211604
The basement section was about all they cut out...and desu most groups didn't even do it when it was there.
>>335212463
I don't get this reasoning
it was ALWAYS split up, you'd do one wing and if everyone felt like it you could do another or all three
the only downside is that you had to do ONE of the first two wings to get to the third
in any case it was way better than Blackrock "Whoops your group died at the bar everyone is leaving" Depths
>>335212430
>tfw you'll never fall through the hole in the middle ever again
>>335212565
I always dragged my group into the basement and the avatar of hakkar fight
>>335211962
Slabs should be on there. I don't care what you get rid of but it was the pinnacle of a 5 man dungeon.
>>335212271
>2006
>Thinks he can speak a word about vanilla.
Good one, senpai.
BRD is the only properly wonderous and impressive dungeon WoW ever had.
fuck, I am so dangerously close to resubbing right now.
Why do I keep coming into these threads?
>>335212742
>TIME FOR FUN
>>335212615
The bar is not even far in if you use the key. You have to clear a medium amount of trash and the engineer room.
>>335212615
The best part about BRD is how people still manage to fuck it up, BoA gear or not.
>>335212472
Here you go, you earned it.
>There are people in this thread with taste so shitty they didn't experience pre-nerf Cataclysm Heroics
>>335212743
>BRD is the only properly wonderous and impressive dungeon WoW ever had.
No it's not
At least I can say this as a person who played when it was relevant
Fucking wotlk kid with your epic memes
>>335210578
Probably because it was one of the most important events in Arthas' story. I'm not a fan of the enemy wave type dungeons but the music and being a part of such a great Warcraft 3 mission were cool to experience.
>>335212947
Really loved them. That priest boss in Lost City was a bitch and it seemed like pugs could rarely get through the shadow phase.
>>335212757
>resubbing to wow during the longest fucking content drought in the worst wow expansion to date
don't be a cuck
>>335207212
>no fucking deadmines.
Fuck this list.
>>335212947
i did tbc heroics and quit when cata came out :)
>>335212271
>2006
BC Heroics where the pinnacle of dungeons followed by Vanilla ones
never played past WOTLK, so my list, in a rough order. not doing raids because my vanilla guild never got past the two 'easy' bosses in naxx and i didnt raid much in either expansion
5: Shadowfang Keep
4. Dire Maul West
3. Blood Furnace
2. Blackrock Depths
1. Scholomance
WOTLK had no good dungeons except maybe that troll one or the first azjol nerub
>>335212947
Pre nerf cata heroics were smalltime.
Pre nerf BC heroics.....jesus christ that was a mess. I remember the first time I cleared one (Underbog) it was more frustrating than your average Kara run. The damage those bog giants did was absurd.
>>335211962
>Halls of Reflection
Maraudon is still my favorite. While razorfen downs had such a cool setting that i haven't seen replicated in wow. Its like being lost a thicket of death
>>335213121
>you can't go back and do old shit during a drought
don't be a cuck
>>335212852
man no one ever had that fucking key
>>335207212
ZG is a fucking raid
I liked spending an entire Saturday morning to noon BRD run. I've been playing since Vanilla so I don't really understand this wrath baby meme.
>>335213068
>last boss of lost city
>forge guy in grim batol
>rock giant in stonecore
fuck those niggers on heroic. Some retard always screwed it up for us.
>>335213257
http://wow.gamepedia.com/Zul%27Gurub_(instance)
?
?
?
>>335213068
I forgot about the phoenix fight. That was a serious pug killer.
>>335213259
>I liked spending an entire Saturday morning to noon BRD run
Things that never happened
>>335213243
half the 'old shit' is now 'new shit' because blizz loves rehashing
>>335213325
rehashed garbage
>>335213317
THRONGUS GET WHIPPED AGAIN IF HE NO FINISH
>>335213257
Got made into a dungeon, senpai. A really good one at that the first few times you run it.
>>335213317
I remember rolling adruidtank during cata and tanking that rock giant in stonecore was a nice learning experience. It was one of those fights that forced you to git gud at tanking and I'll remember it because of that.
>>335207212
>ICC Dungeons, SLABs or Grim Batol belonging anywhere on that list
Top 10 are as follows
>Scarlet Monastery
>Mount Hyjal
>ZF
>ZG
>AQ20
>Dead Mines
>ZA
>Karazhan
>TK dungeons
>Naxxramas in Pre
>>335213259
>Tfw completing the MC attunement
>>335213230
that was back when you still needed mezzers for heroics, but nobody knew that you needed them
>>335213364
Sure lemme just go into this so-called "raid version".
Oh wait.
>>335213352
If you played Vanilla, yes it did. Stop shitposting.
>>335212206
Maraudon was a shithole of boring ugly rock tunnels, the little city model thing was the only cool thing in the whole dungeon
Dire Maul is baller as fuck though
>>335207212
>Nothing from the best expansion
okay
>>335213470
>not liking Slabs
also these lists were dungeons not raids
BREAK YOURSELVES UPON MY BODY
FEEL THE STRENGTH OF THE URRRR
>>335212967
>At least I can say this as a person who played when it was relevant
Yeah no, you joined in April 2006, you were hitting 60 within a couple months of TBC launch.
>Le wrathbabby meme
Nice try, pseudo-TBCbaby.
>>335213484
Well yeah, we cc'd the shit out of stuff but the giants in that particular dungeon (esp the ones before the black stalker) could not be avoided and they did some Mike Tyson from punchout levels of damage to your tank. I'll never understand why they were tuned like that if they were supposed to be the stepping stone to raiding....still fun as hell though.
>>335213548
You're thinking of Uldaman, Maraudon was the one with Princess
>>335213419
hurp durp let me just stand in front of his shield while it's shooting fire, don't mind me
>>335213449
I feel like soloing the first boss almost every run is what killed any enjoyment I could've gotten from it.
>>335213518
I played
No, it didn't
There was nothing to do there all this time, because half of dungeon was 52 lvl and another 58-60
And stories how you gathered party on 50 and spend full day clearing it are clearly lie and shows that you are pathetic wotlk kid
>>335213579
nostalgiafags did not play mop. they didn't miss out on much
>>335213230
No one in this thread ever had the pleasure doing pre-nerf Durnolde Keep. That shit was some Metal Gear stealthing dungeon because if those dogs spotted you it was instant death.
Me and my leveling group forced ourselves to do all the heroic dungeons while waiting for our friends to get ready for kara, especially since the dungeon loot was better before they buffed Kara drops.
>>335213692
I didn't say an entire day. Are you so perpetually butthurt that you can't even read? Stop lying about playing Vanilla as well you're trying too hard to fit in.
>>335213208
Why is yours month/day/year on BNet site?
Mine is day/month/year despite being Canadian and we use the same date format as you.
>>335213838
No clue also I'm Australian
>>335213829
Cry more, wotlk kid
Grim Batol is just proof that Dwarves are truly the master race
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1fORGYFR0RM
>>335213648
>tell people for several expansions not to eat Shatter
>retards still eat Shatter to this day
I love Stonecore, but I honestly can't recall a time I've ever run it where somebody didn't eat something like it was their job.
>>335213817
I remember that shithole, I did it because the last boss dropped a chestpiece I needed for my enhancement shaman. I cleared it about a dozen times and never did see it until I already had the epic crafted one.
>>335213212
The lich king dungeons added towards the end of WOTLK were all pretty good. Shame there's no reason to do them now and it's impossible to find groups for them.
>>335214019
no fuck you, I needed it for my hunter
>>335213927
>Hey excuse me you can't seem to read
>CRY MORE
You're a confusing person to talk to.
>>335214019
>Friend ran Shadow Labs countless times as a Hunter trying to get Sonic Spear
>I got it on my first run
>And I beat him on a roll for Dragonspine Trophy the first time it dropped
>>335213817
I mainly didn't like that place because of having to follow thrall's slow ass on his horse.
I can't even remember anything that the bosses did.
>>335213470
>>Mount Hyjal
Who /scarletstrat/ here?
>>335214245
The bosses were generic. Epoch just sent waves of dudes at you before attacking. It was fucking nothing
Post your favorite dungeons from every point in WoW's history so far
>Scholomance
>Magister's Terrace
>Drak'tharon Keep
>Grim Batol
>Stormstout Brewery
>Shadowmoon Burial Grounds
>>335210460
>not conning an entire group of lowbies into taking the zeppelin to GG and then swimming to Westfall just so your rogue can get his BiS stuff for PvP and that bad ass banana.
>Ice Crown Citadel dungeons
>Implying Halls of Reflection was anything but a chore
>Implying Pit of Saron wasn't boring besides BURY THEM ALIVE
Forge of Souls is the best one and it's 75% for the music.
Good decisions
>Zul'Farrak
>Magisters Terrace, I can forgive it being one off from it's deserved spot in first
>Scarlet Monastery assuming they mean the first iteration
Bad decisions
>Everything Cataclysm and beyond
>Seriously who decided the bastardized version of a beloved raid should belong in the number one spot
>Deadmines over Shadowfang Keep, Wailing Caverns
>No Maraudon
>No Hellfire Ramparts, the PERFECT introduction into Outland, topped off by the final boss having the illustrious flying mount you would earn at the end of your leveling journey
Headscratching decisions
>Culling of Strath, Durnholde Keep was better mechanical wise if were going for Caverns of Time (especially since both are glorified escort quests) and Strath was bettter, it was a real challenge and made the harrowing chapter of Warcraft history feel properly dark and dangerous, 90% sure it's on here because of the free dragon
That said having to help Arthas slaughter Strathholme in order to keep the timeline in tact from a lore standpoint is fucking incredibly cool
>Shadow Labyrinth, the Auchindoun dungeons all blended together for me
>>335214475
Yea, the bosses were shit. It was more of the experience of going back in time and doing a lore important event. Then going to the Southshore Inn and seeing all those major NPCs.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3jSY5fIeDA
>mfw
>>335213817
Vanilla fag here. git fucking good. Durnolde was easy and fuck. Th dogs did nothing without backup. Which if you were smart a little CC solved that problem when it arose.
The only dungeon that was anywhere difficulty was Shattering halls and that was ONLY because idiots would rush foward and not let the tank get some thread or pull extra packs.
This is why blizzard keeps pruning skills. Because idiots have no damn clue how to use them.
>>335214694
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMl4dBzEu-w
>>335214554
My friend kept trying to get me to run his twink rogue through deadmines.
We went all the way to westfall but couldn't find the entrance.
He made a 29 twink instead.
>>335207212
>no netherstorm dunegons
Into le trash
>>335207212
>counting ICC when that's 3 dungeons, not 1
>counting all of SM as one dungeon
>saying ZG is a dungeon at all
I clicked the link purely because the Top 10 title for a WoW vid made me think it was crendor and not IGN.
>>335214903
Honestly the only memorable one was Botanica, and I still wouldn't put it on a top ten list either.
>>335214903
All of them were trash. Just because you did your daily heroic Mechanar for easy badges doesn't mean it was that good.
>>335214903
the only thing I remember liking was milhouse
>>335211634
I think my favorite WoD dungeon was Iron Docks. The dialogue in there was actually entertaining and I like the second/last bosses.
>>335210719
dont give a fuck if ZG was good, still rehashed shit.
>Mfw nostalgiafags will never experience Challenge Modes
>>335215064
is Millhouse a meme?
>>335214903
this
>>335214967
Botanica was decent. But that was it. Not a top ten for sure
>>335214903
Fuck the Mechanar. Must have ran that instance 30+ times just to get the druid shoulder pads from the first boss.
>>335215162
cool!
>>335215164
Milhouse manastorm?
Grimrail and ICC are literally in the bottom 10 of anyone who's ever played them.
>>335215162
>hate wod enough to quit after 10 years of play
>feel guilty about not finishing the challenge modes for it first
Kinda want to go back to finish them, but I am sure it's near impossible to get a group for them this late into the expansion.
My favourite was Karazhan. I have no argument to prove it's the best, but it was definitely my favourite.
I used to run it while listening to the Kamelot album Ghost Opera.
The nostalgia.
>>335215314
THIS PEAR
>>335215331
>Kinda want to go back to finish them, but I am sure it's near impossible to get a group for them this late into the expansion.
The only groups doing them now are selling runs.
>>335215076
My favorite part about that instance was
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0xu9lIwwLA
>>335215164
>>335215302
is is millhouse a meme a meme?
>>335215314
I think people like grimrail because it's "different."
In reality it's linear and boring as fuck.
>>335211303
>That fucking place is the pinnacle of dungeon designing
Yeah and even at the time, unless you were there for MC the only reason people gave a shit about it was for Emperor Runs, ignoring 2/3 of the dungeon.
>>335211427
The huge 5 mans were cool the very first time going through since you had no idea wtf was going on. After that it was just bullshit.
>>335215076
That is what I do, Zoggosh.
I think good.
>>335215451
every dungeon after vanilla was linear, grimrail depot had the two great, original bosses and even had interesting trash
>>335207212
i'd probably put vanilla ZG as #1 too
>>335207212
Favorite dungeons from each expansion
>Vanilla
UD Stratholme
>BC
It'd be too easy to say Magister's Terrace so barring that I did really enjoy Shadow Labyrinth
>Wotlk
Gun'drak
>Cata
Halls of Origination (I love egyptian themed stuff)
>MoP
Gate of the Setting Sun
Quit before WoD
I actually really liked Maraudon, it was fucking great, I really liked the old super huge instances that spanned a large range of levels. BRD, Maraudon, Scarlet Monastery, I love that shit.
>>335214853
Lol its a little hidden away, that's for sure.
It was always fun to gank the alliance there trying to kill the defias mages too. Man I really miss playing Vanilla.
Cata ZG was one of the worst fucking dungeons I've ever done
>there are literally people that liked Stratholme
The only way you can justify this is if you somehow got the horse in your first 5 runs.
>>335215412
Yea, that's what I figured. When I did the MoP ones on my alt during the SoO it was so fucking hard to find people who weren't sellers and had enough skill to get through them. Now with that addon that made cross-realm LFG dead I'm sure it's impossible without holding some sort of forum recruitment drive.
The raid was shit but I actually had a ton of fun with the Trial of the whatever the 5-man dungeon was called from the Argent Tournament.
>Medieval ass honorable lancing on the field of battle
>Grinded out the Sunreaver Dragonhawk so I was the king of that shit
>Boss devoted to making fun of Paladins
>Paletress, Lolladin, and Black Knight all a ton of fun even if you hate going full Lancelot
>Little bullshit inbetween boss encounters
>Scarlet Monastery higher than VC
Fucking DROPPED.
>>335215162
I would find CMs more fun if they were just brutally hard instead of a semi-hard speedrun
>>335211962
No one liked the Coilfang dungeons
>>335207212
>no Scholo
>no MoP dungeons
Shit list.
>>335215724
I YIELD
I SUBMIT
May I run away now?
>>335207212
>No Utgarde Keep
I RETURN! A SECOND CHANCE TO
CARVE
YOUR
S K U L L S !
K
U
L
L
S
!
>>335215659
I must have run undead side 500 times to get my deathcharger, and then my friend got it on his first and only run.
I think I used to like strat, but I definitely don't anymore.
>video obviously made by alliance player because it puts VC on the list and ignores SFK
>>335213243
Yeah but you can do that when Legion comes out so that you at least have new shit to do when you finish the old shit. What's the point of resubbing now, to sit on your ass until August when you finish the old stuff?
Aaahhh fuck you guys.
I've been trying so hard not to resubscribe lately.
>>335215971
>No! I can do... better! I can...
>>335215659
I liked it as a priest because I got to shackle things!
Also, the original challenge mode dungeon. That 45m strat was imposing without raid gear.
I was a big fan of strat overall, I think I always joined a run for it when I saw it advertised. The Righteous Orbs didn't hurt either.
Now that I think about it, Cata ZG was indeed a pretty good instance. Not sure if it's the best, but it's pretty good.
>>335213419
This boss was basically Cata's dedicated retard check even after the nerf.
>>335216157
Ey, grats mon!
Top 3 Raids
Ulduar
Karazhan
Throne of Thunder
Top 3 Dungeons
Deadmines (old)
Zul'Gurub
Stratholme (old)
>>335215659
I didn't care about the mount because I was undead so I never had a problem with it. Also seeing the aftermath of one of the coolest Warcraft 3 missions was fantastic.
>>335216157
It gets an asterisk in my eyes since it got a double dose of attention, polish and design since it was a really important raid in Vanilla and then a big story piece of Cata's plot. Most dungeons just get a small pass and it's out the door.
>>335216189
>Cata's dedicated retard check
>Not this guy
BOSS CHO'GALL NOT GONNA BE HAPPY ABOUT DIS
>>335216150
I cant even remember....what did saving the argent dawn lady get you again? I know it was important and I always did it but I can't remember what the difference was.
best instance in WoD was the one with the boat and the cannons.
Best raid trailer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JmndxoF74qQ
>>335216312
Plus I had max archaeology and I loved showing people the boss most didn't even know was there.
>>335216417
you posted the wrong one friendo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_OKqik-G9x4
>>335216229
Debates about the best raids are harder because most people never got a chance to do thearguablybest raids while they were current.
>>335215994
Basically this. I loved Strat before I was running it over and over for a horse that wouldn't drop.
>>335216376
It was part of the questline to upgrade your dungeon gear set. Also I think it gave some rep.
>>335207212
>No BRD
>The intricate, awe-inspiring epitome of the dungeon experience
It really felt like a huge ominous city of evil with so many optional areas it felt massive. The friendly tavern area made it extra special.
Actually slogging through that with a rag tag group of adventurers was amazing.
Shit list
>>335216376
Got you some pots and finished a quest if you were doing the 0.5 questline. Don't think there was any extra loot.
