If it wasn't for the shitty bosses, pic related would be the perfect Sonic game and you cant prove me wrong.
Get a load of this!
>>329569346
>needs a casino level
>needs more levelsthose are nitpicking but really it's fatal flaw is that classic sonic gameplay is broken as shit and no physics, literally modern sonic's sliding physics carry more momentum than classic sonic's roll
still a good game tho
is that the one where you can buy Super Sonic from a store?
>>329569346
Seaside Hill is a bad choice for a Heroes stage to pick.
>>329570258
Indeed, but it turned out to be the best modern stage in the game
So many fucking alternate paths
>>329569346
The jumping in this game is terrible. The side missions with the friend characters are a drag. The Sonic Colors levels are pure shit. The final boss is a mess too.
>playing Sonic unironically as an adult
>>329569346
The modern Sonic stages were shit, just like every "HOLD UP/RIGHT TO WIN" Sonic game. Sonic should stick to 2D.
>>329570904
Video games are for children anyway. What's it matter?
>>329570904
>playing any video game unironically as an adult
Come now let's not split hairs
>>329569435
I find this quite funny
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PUP9KXi_3_Q
>>329569346
Classic's physics were anything but, Modern's gameplay is as fucked as ever, and the graphics are too damn busy to tell what the hell you're doing.
You're factually wrong.
>>329569346
If it wasn't for the fact modern sonic was in this game perhaps
>>329569346
Someone post the physics webm
The input lag and jump physics killed it for me.
Hopefully it gets fixed in the sequel that's rumored.
>>329572929
>input lag
SO IT WASN'T JUST ME
SON OF A BITCH, FUCK SONIC TEAM
Perfect is a tall order.
I disagree. It would've still required a better level trope variety and for the Colors stage to have more polish to have better fluidity and more/better wisps.
Classic should've had better physics and most jumps shouldn't have so much monotonous emphasis on pixel perfectness.
>>329573124
No man, wasn't just you. I tried adjusting my TV's settings for hours to find something that worked to no avail.
Why they'd make a Sonic game, a game based on speed and precision, with input lag is beyond me. Colors was pretty perfect to me, though.
>>329569346
3D Sanic stages were shit. Then again 3D Sanic was always shit.
>>329574110
3D sonic stages were probably the best because, like someone else said, the input lag for classic sonic was horrendous.
>>329569346
If it's so perfect then why'd I stop playing it?
Removing the shitty bosses still leaves the shitty side missions, Classic Sonic not playing right/having lazy level design, and Modern Sonic being boost to win until Crisis City.
>>329569346
Meh. Go between playing the actual classic genesis games and then the "classic" generations levels. It plays more like a mario game with some loops than an actual sonic game.
It's alright as far as the 3D segments, but the classic sonic is completely lackluster and they completely failed to understand the distinct gameplay and style of the 2D sonic games.
Unleashed is the perfect sonic game you faggot
>>329569346
Generations fanboy here, it's the best 3D Sonic has ever been but needs improvements:
2D sections and levels have to go. Period.
Missions are obvious padding and need to go as well.
Boost needs to be harder to build up, that's one of the very few things that turd Colors got right. It needs better boost obstacles than pits too.
Levels need to be branched out even more, Gens was a great start.
But none of this will happen, the functional retards in charge of Sonic Team will try and fail again to appeal to people who don't even play games anymore.
>>329575609
>2D sections and levels have to go. Period.
Soo...you want a Generations game with no Classic Sonic?
>9 levels
>dat final boss
>dat classic sonic speed dash
>no bonus stage/secret levels for chaos emeralds
Yep. Sure.
>>329569346
Not with that shitty classic gameplay and the last two modern levels
>>329570053
The Classic Sonic physics are all wrong, but the levels are still really fun to play. It's a rare occurrence where we didn't get what we wanted but the alternative was still just fine.
>>329570904
>that picture
These are the idiots handling put weapons?
>>329575751
Yes. What will it take for Sonic Team to understand people just want fast platforming, not poorly thought out fillers that no one enjoys?
>>329575996
>not poorly thought out fillers that no one enjoys?
...but you want them to keep boost
>>329575996
But 2D platforming is still platforming.
>>329575894
Yeah, the jump floatyness that began with Rush was still there but hell if it wasn't fun.
>>329576251
Epic. Simply epic.
>>329576294
Low quality platforming. Until they fix the physics and introduce momentum to levels clearly designed for it (they won't), there's absolutely no point.
>>329569346
classic sonic plays like ass and ruins the whole experience imo
I really wanted to like it but the physics never sat well with me
is it really so hard to do 2D physics? just make it handle like the genesis games, the physics were the whole reason they were popular
The only shitty boss was the final level.
Besides it has more issues than that. The classic stages all felt off and most of the challenges were tedious.
Generations is the most overrated 3D sonic besides Adventure 2 if you ask me.
only good parts were 3D modern sonic
that's like a quarter of the game
rest is mediocre
>>329569346
>Shitty Modern Gameplay
>Physics and Level Design in the Classic Sections are fucked
Nah
This game isn't that good outside of fanservice
>>329569346
>Boost
>2D
>Shitty voice acting
>No characters besides Sonic, Tails, and Eggman do anything, but they show up anyway
>Double jump
>No original stage design
>Shit physics
There's a lot more wrong with Generations than the bosses.
>>329576596
>Generations is the most overrated 3D sonic besides Adventure 2 if you ask me.
You mean Colors.
>>329569346
>3D segments
>Modern Sonic is in it
There proved you wrong. Wow that was hard
>>329576741
Colors is probably #3 on that list.
If you think Generations is good (the classic segments in particular), play it after a session on Sonic 2 or 3.
The entire thing is just off.
series hasn't been good since S3&K
don't mention Advance or Rush, they're just ok
>>329569346
Too bad that.
1.- It's too short and the side missions are a bit shitty
2.-The final battle and the music for it are TRASH.
>No Crush 40 theme
Even the fucking storybook games had that.
It has a handful of good modern sonic stages
Green Hill, Speed highway, Rooftop run. The others suck ass and are to short, theres to much 2D, to much platforming, or they end right when they get good, like city escape, chemical plant, or crisis city.
Classic sonic is a good 2D platformer but not the same as original sonic. Frankly Id rather take the werehog as it at least offers tricky 3D platforming, a rarity in the modern sonic games. I dont really like a lot of the music either, and planet wisp, egg dragoon, and time eater is a TERRIBLE way to end off the game. Also really? 9 levels to celebrate 20 years? With stages and game length shorter than Unleashed? But the challenge missions have good diversity and are fun bonus acts.
Despite all this its a good game because whats good is really good, but most of it is to 2D heavy or theres to much platforming and not enough speed. Unleashed will never be toppled as the best sonic game.
>>329569346
Too many city levels.
>>329580219
Its not their fault that city levels are some of the best in sonic history
>>329569346
No, I can't prove you wrong. If you had the most fun with it compared to other Sonic games you played, then it is indeed your perfect Sonic game. I've never played it so I can't refute any claims.
>>329569346
No, too few levels and shitty 2d physics.
Yeah it's great fun, but levels still are too few and the physics are still shitty.
I will never understand why casino night is the only dlc.
>>329581146
Leave the roster open for a future generations game
>>329581248
Which, if it isn't announced in a month, will probably never see the light.
>>329581457
Its not a bad idea actually but its way to soon, those shouldnt be out every 5 years. But for the 30th anniversary...? I dont see why not, they could reuse a bunch of assets and make more levels faster if they sitll have the data for them that is
>>329581802
There won't be a Sega in 5 years if they keep doing the same mistakes every time.
>>329582081
Ah you must be one of those guys who said the PS4 will never exist either
Best of luck to you and have a good day
>>329576837
That list is getting long. Which is the most underrated? None?Shadow?
>>329583049
Unleashed
>>329576596
I'd say that the Death Egg Boss is too easy and simple, and the Egg Phoenix or whatever they called it wasn't well designed even if it was fun sometimes.
>>329585106
Egg dragoon?
>>329585940
That's probably it, it was a mixture of several bosses so I have trouble recalling the name.
>>329569346
>mandatory friend missions to advance
>3 out of the 9 modern stages can literally be beat by holding forward and boosting
>spindash is ridiculously OP
>only good boss was shadow (but it was GOAT and should have been made into a 2 player mode)
>shields are 1 time use rather than being recurring items
>casino DLC was just Microsoft pinball
>super sonic in modern is just boost to win literally
>super sonic in classic is just invincibility with no animations
>sonic 4 for super music
>skateboard power up is in one level and does literally nothing
The only way this game is over a 6.5/10 is the modded PC version. Base version was extremely underwhelming.
>>329586265
Has to be that if it wasnt the egg death robo. That was the only other egg boss in the game i think. Most fans agree the original fight was better, no thanks to the amazing cinematics and intensity of the scene itself
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o2LEBFz_pzI
Fight starts at 1:40
>>329586568
Is one mission of a one minute platforming session really so painful for nu gamers? How can anyone hate the side missions when theyre all just interesting takes and cut outs of the main stages? And are short as fuck? People find anything to shit on it sure seems like
>>329587225
>skateboard only mission
>slow as fuck floating platform angel island mission
>instadeath side mission
>rogue side mission
>VECTOR SIDE MISSION
These are literally pulling out teeth to play and are not fun period. Why do they have to be mandatory? Why couldn't they just. I don't know, make new stages or something? Even the more normal time trial or tails assist side missions are just a waste of time when you've already played the game or just want to get to the next area.
The only good side mission is the 100% custom one on wisp planet that actually has a little challenge to them.
>>329588589
Didn't you only have to do one mission from each level? You didn't have to do the Vector side mission, or the skateboard only mission, or the floating platform Angel Island mission. You could pick and choose.
>>329588704
3 per "era", 9 in total you had to play. Which means odds are you had to play one of those painful missions.
>>329588589
The classic city escape skateboard one? that is one of the coolest ones in the game. The rouge one has some good 3D sections to
And you literally have to pick one from each level, classic or modern, to do, 9 missions total
if you cant find 9 missions that are fun out of 90 then im sorry its not the games fault, its yours for being to picky or sucking ass. There are some duds obviously but theyre not all garbage. In fact a majority of them are pretty good and nice side missions
