ITT /v/ related confessionsWhenever someone says any game has "bad combat", such as Witcher or Morrowind, I instantly dismiss them as a Soulsfag and stop reading their post
Witcher and morrowind do have bad combat you fucking retarded nostalgia fag.
The Souls games literally have the best combat out of any ARPG in history.
I play Dark Souls and considered myself a hardcore gamer when deep down I know the game is more casual than Assassin's Creed
>>324282865
Stop being a delusional fanboy.
>>324282865
Bait but fact is even though Witcher and Morrowind do have bad combat in comparison, combat isn't even the main focus for those games so who gives a shit? If you play any other RPG expecting, or desiring souls combat you're an absolute faggot.
>First person real-time action game
>Using traditional turn-based combat mechanics
Morrowind's combat is fundamentally flawed. It's a combat system designed for interactions that aren't in real-time, shoved into a real-time game. Nothing you visually see happening is representative of what's actually happening in the game.
Most Morrowind fags can agree that the combat is unbalanced and clunky as shit. Strong gameplay mechanics were never a strong suit of Bethesda's. There is a lot of other reasons to like Morrowind and the gameplay has it moments here and there especially at the end game.
The Witcher games are a mixed bag I get what they were going for with the combat and it works and looks nice about 75 percent of the time, but they still just aren't quite there with the execution.
You don't need to mention From combat to know other RPG's aren't living up to their full potential gay op.
>>324282714Scholars of the First Sin was fun and less annoying than DaS, despite the weird movements.
>>324283090
>the gameplay isn't the main focus of these games
Do tell, why should I even play them then?
Daggerfall has better combat than Morrowind 2bh
>>324283257
>gameplay is nothing but combat
Don't be so close-minded.
>>324283257
The problem here is that in your mind gameplay and combat seem to be synonymous.
>>324283257
>playing an RPG
>doesnt like roleplaying
>>324282714
I love playing Farming Simulator
>>324283257
Morrowind and Witcher?
There is none, they have garbage writing, world design, and quest design as well as shitty combat.
I disregard the opinion of anyone saying DS2 or Bloodborne were good titles
>>324282714
Maybe that's because morrowind has shit combat and you shithesda drone can't cope with it
>>324283485
Whats wrong with BB? If you want to be hip you better include DaS1 in that list too.
>>324282714
>dismiss them as soulfag
name an action roll playing gaim that has better combat
this should be good
>>324282714
But you're right.
>>324282714
Gone Home was a good game
I hate any Zelda game
Undertale is literally one of the best games out there
I watch Let's Play videos (Pewdiepie and TheRadBrad)
I liked FNAF
Hitman Absolution was a good game
I liked Skyrim
>>324283597
heres whats wrong with it
>>324283641
Arkham City
>>324283370
>>324283348
The combat is major gameplay element of these games.
It is the aspect of the game that has a definitive fail-state, so the part that requires the most player input. If you're telling me the core mechanics that make a game a game isn't good, then why should I even bother with them?
>>324282714
That's some solid bate mate, I'm pretty fucking irritated
>>324283641
Rune Factory.
>>324283776
He asked for BETTER combat, anon.
dark souls a bes
>>324283257
>combat is the only thing in gameplay
If you're thinking one of those shitty hack&slash like Bloodborne then you're right.
>>324283776
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PxQbuv8I1k
is this a joke?
>>324283090
>thread is about combat
>c-combat isn't even important
Nice back peddling.
Dice-roll combat is fucking garbage.
>>324282714
literally a meme game.
it released when? 2011?
and you still talk about that shit.
>>324282714
You done nothing wrong, OP.
I consider Halo 2 and 3 to be great games, not story wise thoughAll Hitman games are greatI am more than 13 y/o and still post on /v/
>>324283879
haha, good one, I almost laff
>>324284059
Butthurt soulsfag detected
>every game would be better with souls combat
>>324283850
It's a major element in Dark Souls because it literally has nothing else and play like a single player MMORPG.
>>324283661
you sound like a modern game journalist
>>324283686
>Everyone who doesn't like BB is just a booty bothered PC gamerYes I am a PC gamer primarily, yes I too am annoyed that it's an exclusive, but I like souls enough that it actually is a driving force behind the fact that I will at some point get a PS4
>>324284123
seems the guy cannot tell bees from frogs
>>324284194
Jokes on you, I love TW3.
>>324283641
Pokemon
>>324283850
By that definition, something like Gratuitous Space Battles or Endless Space aren't actually games because the combat proper is mostly outside of player hands.
You don't define gameplay as simply whatever part of the game is closest to the fail-state. You can wear a piece of gear in the game that curses you and causes you to instantly die. Did combat happen? No. Is that not a fail state, then?
>>324284224
>everything you do is meaningfull
>on a grand quest in an unknown land
>game is concise and on point with no bullshit like in mmos
its literally the opposite from mmorpgs when it comes to rpgs you massive retard
>"YOU CAN'T SAY THE GAMEPLAY IS SHIT BECAUSE OF JUST THE COMBAT"
>aside from combat game literally just has walking around in an uninteresting world with bland characters and lore
You're all either fanboys or just happy with very fucking little.
Oh great, another Dark Souls/Bloodborne shit posting thread.
Can't you fuck face just go back to your contained general in /vg/?
>>324284276
BB is a bonus for those who dont play on getting a gaming PC. Hence the no games meme. Its only worth getting a PS4 if you plan on making it your primary system. I got a good 100 hours from BB but its time to move on.
>>324282714
this
you have no idea how many times i have done this
>>324284194
That's not wrong though, after playing Souls games I think that many games would benefit from having dodge mechanics.
>>324284194
Morrowind sure would be.
>>324283661
>>324283776
>>324283879
>>324284336
AND NOT A SINGLE REAL ANSWER
FACE IT N00Bz, DARK SOULS IS the BEST RPG OF ALL TIME
go back to your gay wow and its clones you autists
>>324284612
Trying too hard.
>>324284276
>literally wasting 550$ each year for the latest jewvidia gpu
why do people do this?
why dont you pay a modest amount for your video card and upgrade every 2-3 years?
if it's a game you want money shouldnt be a problem. being an idort is much better
My last Nintendo console was a SNES.
>>324283641
Devil May Cry
>>324284470
all this tells everyone that you and your ilk are pea-brained morons
>>324284659
still waiting for that better combat fuckboy
Witcher 1 made me realize most RPG players, both J and W, suffer from severe stockholm syndrome.
>>324284771
not an ARPG you retard
>>324282714
I wish TES remained a dungeon crawler series
Outside of 06, most 3D Sonics are at least okay
Soul Calibur 2 positioned a stake above the franchise's heart and 3 drove it in.
>>324282885
How is anything more casual than Assasin's Creed? You press R trigger to parkour.
>>324283661
>>Hitman Absolution was a good game
Well, I'm stealing this one for myself, Mr. Shitposter.
Hitman Absolution was an amazing game from a technical standpoint with by far the worst mission design in the franchise. This is proven by the fact that the couple missions that actually play like Hitman games are actually wonderful.
>>324284612
I certainly hope you are underage, because at least that would justify you sounding as if you were.
It's not a matter of which game has a better combat, you fool. One doesn't take the same combat pattern and applies it to every single game in existence. No matter how much you might love it, games need to have different systems or else they stagnate.
Would you want every single game that exists to have Assassin's Creed combat? Because that was hailed as pretty good back in the day too, because 20 games were made out of it.
>>324284686
I do though. The computer I'm using is like 3-4 years old mate.
>>324284059
>back peddling.
It's a doggie dog world, after all.
>>324282714
The combat in morrowind and witcher sucks. Best combat in any ARPG is Dragons Dogma.
>>324282885
>I know the game is more casual than Assassin's Creed
This is some white-guilt level of delusion
>>324282885
>I consider myself a hardcore gamer
>>324285185
Use summons, use spells, use items/buffs/resin. The games become pretty fucking casual.
>>324285161
Shut up.
>>324285068
blah blah blah thats a lot of words for such an empty post
i type deez way cuz /v/ is for idiots so I adapt fucktoy
you are talkin maad shit though
>one doesent take blah blah
except youre implying there is good combat out there, dark souls combat isnt even that great and its still the best, the point is all other rpgs have SHIT TIER combat
your entire genre is shit and dark souls is the redeemer
I like the remastered version of the Cave Story OST more than the original.
>>324282885
>considered myself a hardcore gamer
neck yaself
>>324282714I used cheat engine in dark souls and bumped myself to soul level 131 at the beginning and went on through the game with a large health and stamina. I am in anor londo with stone armor and stone greatsword
>>324285395
Yup. 16 or lower, I hope for your own sake that that's the case.
>>324285358
>I know the game is more casual than Assassin's Creed
This is some white-guilt level of delusion
>>324284457
PS4 is getting some more exclusives this year so it's not too bad but I get where you are coming from.
>>324285537
still waiting for that answer though retard
>>324285358
And yet it's never as easy as AC.
>>324282714
gaming confessions?
>I try extremely hard to see things from other people's point of view. I can understand why CoD players like CoD, why DOTA2 players like DOTA2, but I still utterly fail to grasp what people see in Undertale.
>Similarly, the only conclusion I have been able to come to when people criticize Dark Souls combat is that they just aren't good at it. Every other explanation (It's too slow or it's too complicated) feels like a cop out.
>I thought base game Diablo 3 was fine the first time I played it. It had way less replay value than the previous installment, but it was fine enough.
>I think Perfect Dark is better than GoldenEye
>I think the focus on graphics has been one of the leading causes on the decline in game quality. Too much funding goes to visual development and story/design/complexity suffer for it.
>I own more consoles that I never play than I do ones I actively use.
>I still think Mario 64 is one of the best games I've ever played.
I never played a Zelda game.The only Final Fantasy I ever played and completed was the first one and I enjoyed it.
>>324285068
no mission plays like an 'actual hitman game' because the game is flawed at its very foundation;
disguises are literally worthless and you're spending more time crouching and hiding and treating it like some third-rate splinter-cell game, than doing the things how agent 47 is supposed to work
>>324283090
>literally 80% of your time in W3 is fighting shit, or looking for shit you'll need to fight
>not main focus
>>324285670
You don't even have to do anything, the NPCs/players do all the job for you. How could it be easier?
>>324285658
I already answered you, idiot.
You deluded yourself into thinking the matter is what combat is the best and that said combat should be applied to every game in existence, then hold onto those goalposts with a deathgrip and when pointed to you that having the best combat doesn't necessarily justifies wanting that combat system to be copy-pasted to every game, or that it remains the best outside of the specific parameters of its own game, you fall silent and fall back on shitposting.
If I want to go fast and play with bows, what does Dark Souls offer me? If I want multi-elemental magic, what does Dark Souls offer me? If I want to be a summoner, what does Dark Souls offer me? If I want to be an illusionist, what does Dark Souls offer me?
Slow, lumbering, one-on-one combat in Dark Souls is very satisfying. Slow, lumbering, one-on-one combat is not and will never be the extent to which combat in these games go to.
And no, you ARE pretty clearly either a fanboy or a shitposter
I have beaten every AssCreed that wasn't mobile or handheld release, totaling 13.
1, 2, Brotherhood, Revelations, 3, Black Flag, Rogue, Unity, Syndicate, Liberation HD, Freedom Cry, Chronicles China, and Chronicles India.
I fully intend to purchase Chronicles Russia day 1, and see the movie day 1.
>>324286000
I considered disguises in Absolution as being a pretty good middle point between how unreliable they were in Hitman 2, and how all-powerful they were in Blood Money. And trust me, I played Blood Money extensively, I know that game in and out, and disguises would never fail outside of extreme circumstances like not being in an area where your disguise should give you access or being two feet from a dead body, no matter what. Disguises that allow you to mostly blind in from a distance and when nobody can see you directly but that still requires you to sneak through some areas sound good to me, a police officer would know that you're not part of his patrol team if he gets close enough to you.
>>324286207
to start off, you put that comma in front of idiot
>you, idiot
you obviously have autism
next is
>You deluded yourself into thinking the matter is what combat is the best and that said combat should be applied to every game in existence
I never implying it should be applied to anything, you mentioned that first and now are shitposting with it
my question was, an action rpg with better combat?
your answer: sonic isnt even animeme
dark souls still has the best combat and with a proper system for magic/bows it would have better combat than 99% of games, not just rpgs
So what other games offer nice summoner/illusionist/magician experiences?
oh thats right, none, because rpgs have shitty combat
>>324282714
>Morrowind
But morrowind does have shit combat, why are you undermining your point?
>>324285369
This whole argument is a damp squid, anyway. Stop putting yourself on a peddle stool.
>>324285501
But why? If you can't play the game just watch a lore let's play.
Or just learn the gimmicks of the combat, it's not a difficult game at all.
>>324282885
Nice false flag
>>324282865
I like your thinking
I hate TLOU even though I never played it, just cause I disliked all Uncharted games I playedI love Mario 64, it's probably ma favorite game of all time. But I never enjoyed any other mario gameI hate fighting games in general, specially SF and SSBI'm to much of coward to be able to play any horror game. So I never played any RE, SH or FEAR
>>324286651
>dark souls still has the best combat and with a proper system for magic/bows it would have better combat than 99% of games, not just rpgs
>Dark Souls would have the best combat for the situations you described if it included great systems for those circumstances that currently do not exist
Well, no shit, aren't you a genius.
And no, I already answered you, idiot, is not gramatically incorrect. You're just grasping at straws here, while STILL ignoring that YOU are the one with a deathgrip on your goalposts despite how irrelevant they are to this discussion, when I have stated multiple times that Dark Souls melee combat is pretty great and I probably couldn't cite a better one. And that by no means mean they should be applied to all games, which is what OP's original statement of "whenever I see someone complaining about combat I disregard them as Soulsfags" implies.
>>324287159
>I hate fighting games in general
Why's that?
>>324287169
no, it implies that hes butthurt about his shitty games having shitty combat so he takes it out on darksouls
not grasping for shit but thanks for being autistic with those huge replies made my day boii
> probably couldn't cite a better one
thats all i needed to hear, why did you even start this comment chain autist?
> And that by no means mean they should be applied to all games
Theres that tacked on autismo juice you put yourself in the discussion gayboiii
anyway tnx 4 answering, I knew theres no rpg with good combat other than dark souls
>>324287159
>I hate TLOU even though I never played it
Like most people here.
sasuga /v/
>>324287443
I guess it's cause I suck, or maybe I don't have anyone to play and get better together.
>>324287159
>I'm to much of coward to be able to play any horror game. So I never played any RE, SH or FEAR
Play RE4.
>>324287623
Is the steam version good? Or should I buy it for some console?
>>324282865
The Souls games are barely RPG, that's why the action isn't complete shit. Though it's still mediocre.
>>324283661
underage detected
please leave
>>324282714
I've never played the Witcher and shitpost about it having bad combat so autists will accuse me of being a Soulsfag, even though I've never played those either.
>>324287621
>>324287443
no ill tell you why, poor fuck probably doesent know it himself
after finishing any tutorial for a fighting game, something becomes obvious
most game mechanics in fighting games are resolved faster than human reaction time, meaning skill means jack shit and its all about whos more autistic with pre memorised combat patterns and stun locking combos
Its a shitty system and it survived for so long because a lot of people get off on paterns in games (as seen in gookclick 2: wings of liberty)
>>324282885
There is nothing more casual than AC, anon.
>hardcore gamer
There is nothing more casual than calling yourself a hardcore gamer, anon.
My interest in video games has seriously waned recently, and suddenly I find myself really interested in Magic cards. My most played game recently is Magic: Origins on steam. Getting into Magic cards has made me exciting for gaming in a way I haven't felt since I was a kid. I have an IRL friend who I used to play 2d fightan with all the time, and now we just play MTG all the time.
>>324288015
>most game mechanics in fighting games are resolved faster than human reaction time, meaning skill means jack shit
How you can tell someone doesn't play fighting games.
>>324287765
Either is fine. The steam and wii versions are probably the best.
>>324287549
>violently defends Dark Souls honor
>oh, and by the way, I'm not a fanboy or anything, it's not like Dark Souls has the best combat out there in the industry :^)
Anyway, yeah, it's been fun, good luck out there.
>>324288194
oh that 2 frame animation sure is blockable
its easier to block/evade a punch in real life than in your shitty games
>>324283686
fucking kek
I love being an Idort
>>324287942
Come on anon, it's time to come clean. Do you even play games at all or do you just enjoy shitposting?
Sometimes I play on easy because I just want to be comfy, stomp on niggers and have fun.
>>324288338
Punches don't come out in 2 frames in street fighter.
>>324288262
>i have to reply with something otherwise i will be completelly btfo
tnx gayboi, I half expected you to actually name a game though, you ruined the fun
>>324282714I've been here for at least 8 years now.
I've seen rules 2 and 3 broken in just about ever single thread in the past 6.
I've seen the mods literally stop giving a shit.
I've applied for janitor the last 3 times applications were up.
I've received nothing in regards to cleaning up this shitpile of a board.
I've only been b& from /v/ for shitting on Nintendo threads.
Not sony threads.
Not xbox threads.
Not PC threads.
Only nintendo threads.
I've witnessed this entire board become run by literal manchildren.
>>324288338
??? Are you talking about jabs? They have no range, try not ramming your face against the enemy. You don't know your shit when it comes to fighting games.
I've never beaten a Final Fantasy game.
I enjoyed The Order: 1886 and Until Dawn.
I think Halo and Gears of War are a lot of fun co-op.
I own a Mac and don't do computer gaming.
>>324282714
So what, you don't think games can have bad combat?
>>324288590
>I own a Mac and don't do computer gaming
>mac
>gaming
Well no shit you retarded faggot hipster
>>324288452
but they do in 99% of 2D fighting games, which is most of the games in the genre
its random as shit, I tried to get into blazblue continuum shit and studied its game mechanics a bit
the conclusion was obvious, all the 15-20 intricate systems that are put together to make its combat happen too fast for human reaction time to matter
its for autists who like patterns (or button mashing casuals)
I don't shitpost
>witcher fags literally think CLICKCLICKCLICKCLICKCLICKCLICKCLICKCLICK is good combat
>>324288474
Well you haven't stopped responding either, fuccboi.
Besides, I don't have extensive experience with action RPGs, turn based RPGs or actual action games like Devil May Cry are more my speed.
>>324288685
Do you think it's 1995 or something?
>>324288804
WHAT THE FUCK MAN
>>324288768
>make its combat happen too fast for human reaction time to matter
Jabs have small range, don't run into your enemy if you don't have anything and you're just going to stand there like an idiot.
I play on PC even though I know PS4 is better. I donate yearly to Sony (serious) because they've been there for me.
>>324282865
that would be dragons dogma
>>324288927
actually turn based games are alright
and dmc is also a good choice
youre still gay though and you probably like dick too
>>324284879
True. I even started liking the combat in Witcher 1 nearing the end of the game, despite knowing it's shit. I like Witcher 1 but I don't think I'll ever bother replaying it.
>>324282865
The Souls games are hardly even RPGs, they're most of all action games.
>>324289110
I only played 2h of DD so far, but I really disagree with you, from what i've seen
>>324289108
Here for (you)
I'm in love with someone who isn't real
>>324289302
roleplaying hasn't been important in rpgs for a long time
>>324289084
>>324288561
you fags must have been discussing a specific game earlier in the comment chain or some shit
anyway
in most fighting games (that would be 2d games) the animations come out of nowhere and are lazily done, the genre is a joke and relies on memorizing patterns enough that you dont have to think about controls to execute them, so maybe 3000 hours in when you develop full blown autism you will be able to enjoy the game
>>324282714
But Souls combat is its worst aspect and it plays like Ninja Gaiden Black with no real jumping game and at 1/100 the speed and 1/1000 the difficulty. I can never fathom why people like it for that its not really hard or fun for that. Just good games for lore , the world and level design besides 2.
BloodBorne vastly improved the gameplay at its core with a speed/recovery boost as well as weapons with movesets that don't suck but its still leagues behind a real action game series in gameplay.
Also i hate when people just shake it off to me as "Its a ARPG not a action game" At its core and mechanically it is one. You pick gear and stats but the gameplay itself is trying to be like a slow one for idiots. I hope DaS3 is alot more like BB.
>>324289371
what class are you using?
>>324289605
Dude with sword and shield. Coming from DaS the lack of dodge is bothering me a lot.
>>324288390
I'm on /v/, of course I don't play games, silly.
>>324289469
The point remains that literally all you do in Souls is run around more or less aimlessly while killing the ever respawning monsters until you run into a boss battle so that you can progress, unlock a shortcut, trigger some objective, etc.
It doesn't actually need the stats. The game wouldn't be much worse if the stats weren't there and the game did character definition through equipment,
>>324289540
>that you dont have to think about controls to execute them
LOL!
>>324289540
>in most fighting games (that would be 2d games) the animations come out of nowhere and are lazily done
>in most fighting games
Let's hear you name a few. I haven't checked out blazblue, so I want to hear what specific "most fighting games", have 2 frame start-up attacks that aren't jabs.Here's a tip, champ. Just accept you're bad at the games.
>>324289802
not the same guy but dude you need to buzz of with that shit
stats are great in dark souls, put some in vitality boom nice chunk of hp added, put some in strenght boom more damage and can wield bigger weapons
Unlike shitty classic rpgs where 200 lvls later your character plays the same, acts the same, but has bigger numbers and 10 more buff spells, 10 more nuke spells, 10 more spells that are sword swings with different anims
>>324288015
Fighting games operating on a level faster than human reactions is the point. You're supposed to be fighting the opponent, not observing what he does and then reacting with an optimal decision. If fighting games worked like that there'd be 0 depth
>Thinking you can react to punches in real life
top kek
>>324282714I genuinely get bothered when a console/handheld exclusive gets ported to PC. Every single game getting porting to Steam nowadays just gives me less of a reason to own a console/handheld and, in turn, makes them less unique. Back in the day consoles, handhelds and PCs had their own unique set of libraries, and that was great. You'd buy a PS2 for games like Metal Gear Solid 3, Shadow of the Colossus, and Final Fantasy X. You'd buy a PC for games like Age of Empires, Diablo, and Half Life 2 (Even if some of those games had console/PC ports they were still significantly better on their original platforms i.e. Half Life 2 and MGS2). But now Steam is making everything homogeneous and that's boring as shit to me. Collecting for consoles/handhelds is one of my favorite aspects of this hobby, and Steam making everything one homogenized, digital only platform is depressing.
>>324289540
>3s
>GG
>Melty Blood
>KOF
>Lazy animations
Top kek you're just a worthless shitter who is objectively wrong. Also SFV has decent animations or actually pretty solid ones. SF4 and BB are the only games i've seen with animation problems. SF4 just primarily jump start animations are really poor and sub consciously this actually leads to making AAing alittle more difficult at first.
>>324290165
I guess being supper rich is not so cool.
>>324290131
>Unlike shitty classic rpgs where 200 lvls later your character plays the same, acts the same, but has bigger numbers and 10 more buff spells, 10 more nuke spells, 10 more spells that are sword swings with different anims
Clearly you haven't played a lot of classic RPGs.
Also, how is what you wrote even relevant to my post? The point remains that the stats don't do much for gameplay. The game's selling point is the combat system, not the stats distribution. If the game didn't have the stats and you defined your character by picking certain types of equipment, the game wouldn't be much worse.
>>324289763
dodging is an ability that you get later on my recommendation is to pick the magic archer so you can get a taste of everything
>>324290431
So should I restart or can I change my class someway?
>>324290165
Personally, I hate physical goods so I'm perfectly content with the situation. In my opinion we could get rid of handhelds, consoles, etc. and just distribute everything on PC.
The only thing which bothers me is that Steam is such a cancerous facebook-like data miner.
>>324290579
when you get to the capitol you can switch classes at the inn
I've never solo'd every boss in a souls game, I usually summon for the harder ones and still enjoy the games
>>324290143
nah see if you invest the time to be better at fighting in real life you will be, and predicting enemy movement based on their body language is a big factor in evading, but you cant predict shit when 0.3 seconds earlier the enemy was standing perfectly still in their shitty idle animation
>>324290020
>your tip
yeah, no. when I play its always win some, lose some, its still random as shit because you can button mash to win to break your opponents concentration
also the games are shitty because a big part of the meta is always forcing your opponent into an invisible wall on the edge of the screen and stun locking them
some examples are guilty gear, blaz blue, mugen games, most arcade fighters (on those old arcade machines) - even then it was shitty and random since you cant really react to anything
just face it faggots, those COUNTER moments are random and no one in the world can do it intentionally
>>324290615
Why do you care about data miner, why does anyone care? I never got it.
There're 7 billion people in the world, 125 million on steam. No one give a fuck about you in particular. They just use it to get some stats so they can make more money and shit.
The average user on /v/ is younger than 16.
Fact
Dark Souls combat is still shit though
>hitboxes
>KOTOR 2
>trash combat, good/great everything else
>loved by /v/
>The Witcher 3
>Decent combat, good/great everything else
>routinely shat on
>>324282714whenever someone destroys me in CSGO I go through their profile to see if there's something there to make myself feel better about my shit lifeusually there isn't
>>324290131
wouldnt dark souls work well enough with a system like Monster Hunter, the game it most resembles in combat?
I see souls games as action adventure games with rpg elements, like Zelda 2 on NES.
>>324290615
But once you get rid of consoles and handhelds you're just removing everything unique from this hobby. You wouldn't see stuff like the Wii U's gamepad being a central aspect of games if they were all on PC. Not to mention games making use of their specific platforms would just be flat out lost if everything were on PC. For example, the impact of a game like 999, that made full use of the DS hardware, would be significantly lessened if done on any other
I also hate the thought of everything becoming digital only. I like actually owning my games instead of them being owned at Valve's whim.
>>324291145
because the witcher 3 is popular
>>324291165
Now that's just sad.
Why are action games with bad combat like Zelda, GTA or the Witcher popular?
But Witcher does have bad combat
I even loved all three games, and I can admit the combat isn't as good as it could be
>>324291297
>the impact of a game like 999, that made full use of the DS hardware, would be significantly lessened if done on any other
I disagree for 2 reasons
1. I played it on an emulator and loved it
2. Ever17 is made for PC, similar to this and is great
>>324290825
>fighting in real life
What do you know, fighting games are nothing like fighting in real life. Great observation!
>those COUNTER moments are random and no one in the world can do it intentionally
What are frametraps?
> a big part of the meta is always forcing your opponent into an invisible wall on the edge of the screen and stun locking them
That's called "rushdown" not all charcters do that, you silly. Maybe you should have SOME knowledge of what you're talking about before you spout stupid shit.
>yeah, no. when I play its always win some, lose some
Let's run a set. I want to see how "random" it is.
>>324291484
The reason those games are popular isn't because of their combat. Zelda is popular because of it's exploration and formula, GTA is popular because of its open world. The Witcher is popular because it's a fantastic RPG.
Also, what's wrong with the combat in Zelda and GTA?
>>324282865
>ARPG
is that the word for a 3DZelda-like game?
>>324290879
>There're 7 billion people in the world, 125 million on steam. No one give a fuck about you in particular.
How do you know? You might be a 20 year old college student who's not of interest to anyone right now. If you complete your studies however, get involved with tech branches that are of interest to some, or perhaps government or politics, then you do indeed become interesting to many people as a person, and it's not just in your interest to hide certain things.
Not to mention that even as a regular guy you may not want your insurance company to know that you've spent your youth playing lots of games while sitting on your ass. If you run for office, are you certain that you want people to find out about that Hyperdimension Neptunia game on your Steam account? etc.
Also, it's a matter of principle. My data belongs to me. They can pay me for it, but they don't have the right to steal it from me, and at least in Europe, people are waking up about this and within the coming years this business model is going to change. Especially after safe harbour was declared void.
>They just use it to get some stats so they can make more money and shit.
They can make money by selling games. If they want to make more money from peoples' personal data, they should pay people for it or give them the option to opt out.
>>324285818
>base Diablo 3
>fine enough for 60$
Look I see shitty opinions on here every day but this takes the cake.
I don't have any "confessions" because I'm not ashamed of any of my unpopular (or at least polarizing) opinions.
PC is better than consoles, because it's nice having all my games on one convenient system. I don't value playing on the original console. Puritans need to fuck off. If I can play a game on my PC, even if it's on emulator, I don't care, as long as it's a good experience. If it runs poorly I'll play it on console, but other than that, 99% of the games I play are playable on PC. So that makes it better. What else would you base your gaming experience off of, other than what system allows you to play the most and best games? This idea that all the games are on consoles is fucking ridiculous. Gen 7 had no good games on consoles, and gen 8, the only good console is the Wii U. And it's selling like shit. So that shows what piss poor taste console drones have. You niggers bought up the PS4 and didn't buy the Wii U - Thus, showing Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft, and any other company that may create a game console, that having more and better games than the competition will not make you successful. You need the netflix. You need the little internet browser, because who doesn't wanna use a non-optimized, non-personalized browser to watch youtube videos or whatever? You need the non-vidya. You need the gimmicks. That's what will make your console successful. Not games. Not having more and better games. But having more SHIT that appeals to millennials. Gen 8 is the most damaging generation to gaming as a hobby ever. Enjoy no more games on consoles in the future. Luckily fewer people are buying consoles and more people are switching to PC so. Even with the PS4's "success" it's much less than what we've seen of consoles in the past.
>Whenever someone criticizes games with mediocre combat, I dismiss their opinion because they may or may not like a game with good combat
The worst part is that you aren't the only idiot who thinks like this. I've seen a good number of people trying to move to goalposts about Souls games whenever they see their favorite games being criticized. Stop being so damn defensive about things you like, The Witcher 3 is a fantastic game, but the combat could really have some improvements, it's dull and pretty generic. As for Morrowind, the combat in that game aged like nigger cum.
Fable 2 was the best fable and is one of my favorite games of all time
Dragon age 2 had really bad gameplay, but it's literally the only game in the series that doesn't have shitty boring characters and an unoriginal plot.
If the game lets me, I'll always make a shota in the character creator. otherwise, I'll play as a woman.
>>324291718
3D combat always sucks so it's only possible to mitigate the damage. Zelda uses lock-on, other games handle it differently but at the end of the day it's never as good as 2D. 3D is suited to racing, exploration and FPS or flying shooters.
>>324291765
Yes. Its a nouvelle /v/ buzzword.
I actually enjoy walking simulators.
>>324291626
>1. I played it on an emulator and loved it
You played on a device that emulated the DS, dual screens included. If the DS hadn't have existed 999 wouldn't have been designed around its hardware.
>2. Ever17 is made for PC, similar to this and is great
Like I said above, 999 was a game that was designed purposefully around the DS and its strengths. If the game was originally made to be a PC game, like Ever17, it would've have to been redesigned and the game wouldn't have been as memorable of unique.
>>324291941
Souls combat is really overrated though. There are lots of things that could need improvement.
>>324292084
it stands for action RPG dumbass and it was around before /v/
>>324291642
so youre just gonna sit there and pretend fighting games arent all about the following things:
patterns, repetition, memorizing patterns, repetition, patterns, repetition until you "gid gud"
and pretend youre skilled because you can totally wreck all your friends
because you grinded that shit until it turned into muscle memory and thats just so skillfull, what an intricate combat system
also
>lets see how random it is
no consistency at all, people who button mash with basic controls can sometimes even kill people who played for 100 hours, sure im playing for the first time but its not like your experience will save you when I spam shit
>>324291786
That's actually a good explanation, I was expectin something like "muh fredom",
Your point on your own info being used against u in the future is kinda scary.
>>324292228
Name them.
Let us tell you how you're wrong on all of them.
>>324292228
when it comes to rpgs, no, its not overrated
>>324292228
There's nothing that really NEEDS changed. I don't see the point in holding it up to some other games' standards, I think it's perfect for what it is. Can you name a combat system that does everything it does but better?
>>324292398
see: bloodborne's combat
>>324292448
It's an action game, not an RPG.
>>324292279
>people who button mash with basic controls can sometimes even kill people who played for 100 hours
Top kek
All right then? Fightcade is free, let's run a set of thirdstrike friend.
>It's not like your experience will save you when I spam shit
Holy shit, are you just a comedian? Learning how to counter moves is basics.
>>324288338
Blocking starts on frame 1 if your in neutral, you could put a bit more effort in your shitpost.
>>324285358
>spells, items, buffs, resin
what's the problem?
>summons
handicap for bads
oh I see the problem
you need to git gud
>>324291941
I think its more about criticizing the game for the combat when its not even the primary focus like in Souls where its the only focus.
>>324292279
Name one competitive game that isn't either a test of pattern memorization or of physical skill
Now name any kind of competitive game that minimizes the need to memorize patterns better than fightan
Protip: you can't
>>324292228
I do think that Dark Souls is the ARPG with the best combat out there though. It isn't perfect by any stretch of imagination and it could sure use some improvements. However, I feel like some people on /v/ are trying way too hard to criticize it these days just because the game is overly praised.
Also, I was mainly pointing out how retarded it is to dismiss someone opining just because you assume that they like something.
>>324292398
Souls combat is best against singular, humanoid enemies. It really falls apart against multiple enemies though and the gigantic monstrous enemies weren't really handled that well either, since their hitboxes tend to be rather icky and the camera is often pretty bad. The lock-on is lacking accuracy due to the fact that it doesn't indicate to you what you're targeting before lock. The fact that the game needs this sort of lock-on mechanic at all is a good indicator that the input mechanics aren't fully working. A good game shouldn't rely on computerised input but put the player fully in charge. Not to mention that distance weapons weren't handled that well either.
>>324292873
Pretty much every time someone says "this game has bad content" its usually followed by saying the game would be better if it was more like Dark Souls, you will see soon enough Redditor.
>>324292532
shit, then I guess the entire genre can burn in hell
witcher, wow, zu online, TERA, black desert, shit, any rpg, theyre all shit
IS THERE A SINGLE RPG WITH GOOD GAMEPLAY THAT DOESENT JUST SERVE AS A FACEBOOK TIER SOCIAL CONTACT EMULATOR
>>324292828
>like in Souls where its the only focus.
Not really. Primary focus in Souls games is atmosphere and It has many elements that come together to make a good combat, I say that the game would be pretty meh if combat was the only focus.
>>324292873
It's hardly even an RPG. Why do people call it an RPG again? You distribute stats in GTA: San Andreas too, does that make it an action RPG?
You run around and kill monsters and if the stats weren't there and you could equip anything, the game would largely be the same.
>>324293069
combat not content*
>>324293071
It depends on what you mean by "good gameplay".
There are plenty of good RPGs out there, but they're not necessarily action games like Souls.
I enjoy combat in most crpgs but hate morrowind's
I've dropped every final fantasy game I've ever tried
I sometimes play dota 2 and league of legends
>>324293140
Its literally the only gameplay focus aside from walking.
>>324293227
People don't know what makes a game an RPG, so they call anything vaguely resembling one an RPG.
>>324293227
You can create your own character, customize your build and play however you want in GTA?Dark Souls is considered a RPG because it has a big focus on immersion, atmosphere and also has a open-ended gameplay.
>>324283641
Dragons dogma
Souls game really are the most fun I've ever had from a combat system. I get that it's got flaws, but so few other games give you such a wide variety of weapons, each handling in a unique way. Like, with most ARPGs you'll have a couple of varieties of sword categories (usually just shortswords and greatswords) and everything within handles the exact same; you'll be slashing with rapiers and stabbing with scimitars the exact same way you would with an arming sword. But not with souls. Rapiers are actually based around stabs, scimitars slashes. Polearms have damage sweetspots on the blades. Spears can be used from behind shields. Shit like that.
>>324292514
Chalice dungeons are the worst inclusion in souls' history.
The inclusion of gun parries still suffers in execution and the changes to pvp are downright retarded.
The weapons are limited to a single system of gun in one hand and melee in the other. It's a limiting system that never expanded in depth even after the dlc release.
Magic is all over the place and arcane doesn't become interesting unlike the end of ng.
Which ng+ is utterly pointless past one novelty playthrough. No changes to the environment, no new items, and no significant changes to boss fights.
The speed of the game is never matched by difficult enemies. 3/4 of the enemies are pathetically weak to r1 spam and the remaining 1/4 feature retarded amounts of super armor with easily avoided attacks. Only one enemy is remotely challenging and it possesses a shitbox attack that would make ds2 proud.
>>324293071
TWEWY
>>324293047
/thread
>>324293434
That's a retarded and shallow view. Yes, you spend most of your time on combat, but the same is true for the vast majority of games that aren't glorified movies.
>>324293375
>dota 2 and league of legends
>and
>>324293553
As much as I love DD, no. It doesn't have better combat.
>>324293336
by good gameplay i mean the interaction with the game world should not feel like it needs to be labeled made in china
that means people go trough each other, everything is homing, enemies could have 5X less HP and the game would be better, 90% of encounters are trivial (A STRONG PLUS FOR DARK SOULS) since other rpgs are easy as shit when it comes to basic enemies, some originality would be nice.
Basically every rpg I have encountered EVER plays like a failed turn based game and would probably be better as a turn based game, honestly a good rpg would be the biggest surprise ever, if you could name me one?
>>324293691
Compared to other RPGs Dark Souls has a lot less to offer, even a Souls fan has to admit that. Thats why they like it, because they want to always be in action.
So complaining Morrowind isn't like an action movie at all times is pretty retarded.
>>324293510
>Dark Souls is considered a RPG because it has a big focus on immersion, atmosphere and also has a open-ended gameplay.
San Andreas has all of that too.
The point remains however that Dark Souls mostly focusses on action based combat. In San Andreas you get to fly aircraft, does that mean it's a flight simulator? No, of course not, because the flying-aircraft part is a tiny bit of the whole package and most of the time you do other things.
In Dark Souls you mostly run around and slay monsters in action-based combat. That's what you do 99.9% of the time.
At its very heart it's an action game.
I prefer the Untold series over the mainline Etrian Series.
I consider BB to be the most complete Souls game.
I think the Halo series has good lore and EU(until 4)
I play LoL over DOTA2 because LoL is simpler.
>>324282714
Beat DaS in 2 days, missed on a bunch of side content I eventually went back to but didn't die more than 3 times to a boss. Game's easy, and the trial and error of exploration is not "difficulty", soulsfags hold on to that for dear life afraid that they lose their status of having played a (lol) hard game
This week I tried DaS2 and almost puked at how relatively worse it is. Movement/combat is slow and clunky, fast weapon degradation adds literally nothing but being a nuisance, the lore is spit in your face instead of subtlety, surprise gangbangs more frequent as a way to try to make the game harder. Not to mention was on pc so the controls are absolute dogshit, FromSoft somehow fucked up their port even harder than DaS1 with the exception of optimization.
Got hopes for DS3 as Miyazaki's on the helm again tho
>>324293731
I have friends that play dota 2 and I have friends that play league. I don't play either enough to get seriously competitive in them and we just fuck around in unranked stuff
>>324283686
*typical_pconly_player.jpg
>>324293553
is that available for PC I have would like to try it but i got turned off by people saying
IM HITTIN IT FOR 10 MIN AND ITS NOT DED
was it just a case of getting an enemy into a certain state or climbing it to deal more damage like in shadow of the collosus?
>>324293990
>if its not on PC, it doesnt exist to me
>>324284686
I get a console because I sit at work on a computer 8 hours a day.
The last thing I want to do is sit infront of a computer on my time off.
>>324294024
It just got a pc release. Costs like $40
>>324293227
The term RPG in regards to vidya secretly stands for Raising Parameters Game far more often than it does role-playing.
>>324293673
twewhat?
>>324294124
You can connect a TV and gamepad to your PC and put in in your living room.
>>324283597
Not him, but I didn't care for BB.
You are kind of stuck with one play style when going through BB. The counter-attacking, stealth build with high risk, high reward gameplay.
If that is your preferred style from the souls game, it is fantastic experience and one of the best in the series. Unfortunately, it was my least preferred style of gameplay.
I liked being a slow bastard with crazy high defense and fuck huge weapons. I liked playing a glass cannon mage fucking up the battle area with magic. I liked playing an archer picking off foes from afar. On the whole though, I didn't like playing a parrying quick foot character, so BB didn't feel as fun to me.
>>324294124
>not having your PC connected to your main TV/couch setup
>>324294139
The world ends with you.
>>324293886
What is with Morrowind faggots having such shitastic opinions?
I mean first they're trying to shill their game as the best ever made, then they're sitting here trying to deny how shit their game is.
Literally garbage combat, art design, story, and rpg mechanics.
But it's shilled to no tomorrow
>>324284194
Witcher 3 sure as hell would
>>324294269
Best summary of BB I have even seen on this board.
>>324293829
Yes it does. DD at least doesn't boil down to timing your dodges and circle strafing.
>>324293830
>rpgs are easy as shit when it comes to basic enemies
It's not like Dark Souls was particularly difficult either. I've had trouble with a few bosses, but most of the basic gameplay is fairly straightforward.
Also, RPGs - and that does not include Dark Souls here - are a genre which by definition is not about difficulty, since the player is "playing" a role rather than "being" that role. In an RPG, the player makes the decisions, but they are executed by the player's character, and if the player's character happens to be bad at what the player wanted him to do, then he may likely fail at doing so, even if the player happens to be very good at that very thing. Dark Souls heavily relies on player input, if a player is bad at flipping around and hitting monsters at the right moment, then he's likely going to fail at playing the game. A one-armed, blind kid is going to have a hard time playing Dark Souls, yet he could perfectly play Fallout or Baldur's Gate by making use of the auto-pause functionality - or the original D&D for that matter.
>>324293886
>lot less to offer
what about all those hidden areas that you had to think real hard how to get to and the fact that exploring the world in dark souls is about 7 times more thrilling than in other rpgs?
I suppose youre going to back that up and name me an rpg that has more to offer huh?
some thrilling immersive experience no doubt?
possibly not with piss easy crabs as a starter "enemy" and a world that isnt empty valleys populated with the same mob like someone pulled an editor out of their ass, selected place mob, and spammed left click?
>>324294124
That's literally the most pleb of reasons to prefer consoles over pc.
>>324294346
shiieeeet, with me? gonna check it out
>>324286526
Are you genuinely enjoying everything the series has to offer or is it just a habit you have ?
>>324294024
You can climb on enemies to damage their weakpoints, however most people are complaining about fighting shit they are underleveled for.
>>324282714
Congratulations OP, you triggered the Soulsfags.
>>324294642
You dont like RPGs or roleplaying thats fine, try Zelda and Metroid, sound perfect for you.
>>324294518
quit samefagging that post only explores 1/100th of Bloodborne's numerous problems. It's literally babby's first post
>>324293927
>San Andreas has all of that too.
No, it doesn't. GTA games are linear as it gets.
Who was the idiot who said that RPGs need to have focus on story and dialogues?Because that's exactly what you're saying. The biggest difference between Dark Souls and games like GTA or Zelda is that these games give you the impression of being open-ended but are extremely on rails, while in Souls games you actually have freedom of what do in relation to the gameplay, your character and world of the game.
>>324294874
Aww jealous of (You)s? Here have one on the house.
>>324294808
>>324294637
Shit are you guys implying that there is meaningful interaction with characters and a good story in other rpgs?
BECAUSE
i have read every fucking piece of dialogue in every rpg i fucking tried and it was always, ALWAYS, pointless bullshit that didnt matter
my decisions didnt matter, the things npcs talked about didnt matter
the other rpgs are just as bad with their role playing as dark souls, except they pretend they arent AND have shitty gampeplay to top it off
>>324294914
>No, it doesn't. GTA games are linear as it gets.
You're locked out of certain areas until you do a certain thing. GTA operates the same way. Until you've done a certain amount of missions you're locked out from parts of the world map.
>Who was the idiot who said that RPGs need to have focus on story and dialogues?
They certainly don't focus on beating up monsters in action-based combat, because that's what action games do. Is Devil May Cry an RPG too?
I only browse /v/ to shitpost in the porn threads. I mainly try to GETs.
>>324294914
RPGs as a whole were founded because some wargaming nerd wanted to make a wargame that was smaller in focus, where the players could create characters with their own personalities and stories and roleplay them.
>>324295260
>i have read every fucking piece of dialogue in every rpg i fucking tried and it was always, ALWAYS, pointless bullshit that didnt matter
I very much doubt that you've played a lot of RPGs.
>the other rpgs
Dark Souls is not an RPG.
>just as bad with their role playing as dark souls, except they pretend they arent AND have shitty gampeplay to top it off
Except for the part where they're actual RPGs. What you want is not an RPG but an action game.
>>324282714
GG OP.
>>324295489
>RPGs have to be bioware dialogue-fests
role playing games on computers were about building characters for combat since the very beginning; tabletop-style character roleplaying was introduced later.
>>324295387
It's not just that. The focus was cooperative storytelling and non-combat player-world interaction.
In Dark Souls you barely interact with the world beyond hitting things.
And keep in mind: I'm not even saying that it's a bad game, however, as an RPG it's lacking.
>>324293886
Dark Souls has great lore. A lot of hidden areas. Tons of different builds to try. Rare yet meaningful interactions with NPCs. Enemies, especially bosses, have terrific designs. Great world-building. A lot of little things that add to your immersion(such as the lack of music, NPCs or the way that the enemies behave)and are lacking in other games.
Better question would be, what Morrowind has to offer aside from endless texts and a boring combat?In my opinion a good game should be able to convey the majority of its feelings through gameplay and while Dark Souls manages to do it, Morrowind fails miserable. Morrowind tries to convey what it wants through huge amounts of texts, which is boring and could be managed in a book.
>>324294637
In Dark Souls I had a harder time against common enemies in areas in which they can ambush you than against bosses.
The archers of anor londo, or the crystal dudes + the channelers in the library of Seath.
The hardest boss for me was Bed of Chaos, and it isnt a real boss, it is a stage hazard.
