ITT: We make a list of /v/'s top 100 favorite video games of all time
Pic is from the last time we did this, around 3 years ago.
>post a game (preferably one game per post)
>reply to games you want on the list with "approved"
>every game with 14 approvals or more will be a contender for the 100 list
>once we reach 150-200 games, I'll make a poll/thread to vote for your favorites from the list, leaving us with the final ranked 100 list
Games with 14 or more approvals: http://pastebin.com/8m1j4kBX
Posted games with less than 14 approvals: http://pastebin.com/ZeVD5vV7 (Feel free to repost or add approvals to any of these games)
Diablo II
>>321966589
approved
Metal Gear Solid
Fallout
Ace Combat 4
F-Zero GX
Halo 3
Halo 3: ODST
Mirror's Edge
Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario World
Age of Empire 2
Terraria
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
100% ORANGE JUICE
Dark Souls
Ace Combat 04: Shattered Skies
OFF
Shovel Knight
Dead Space
MGSV
Burnout 3
Bioshock
Dota 2
>>321966589
>>321966668
>>321966827
>>321966989
Aproved.
Super Metroid.
Half-Life
Sly 2 Band Of Thieves
Half-Life: Opposing Force
Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate
Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
Halo: Combat Evolved
>>321966989
Approved
>>321966807
Approve Halo 3
Final Fantasy VI
Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney: Trials and Tribulations
Persona 3
>>321966827
>>321966989
approved
Persona 4
Mass Effect 2
>>321966668
Approved
>>321966807
Approve Super Mario Galaxy
Approve Super Mario World
SMT: Strange Journey
Dragons Dogma?
>>321967624
Approved
SMT: Nocturne
The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
>>321967827
Approved
Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic 2: The Sith Lords
>>321967792
Rejected
Castlevania Symphony of the Night
Binding of Isaac: Rebirth
Pokemon Black & White
Pokemon Black 2 & White 2
Pokemon HeartGold & SoulSilver
Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Sky
Pokemon Platinum
>>321967106
>>321967857
Approved
Pokemon Soul Silver
>>321967457
Approved
>>321967857
>>321967901
Approved
Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
>>321966668
Approved
KOTOR
Okami
>>321967060
>>321967294
>>321966807
>>321966989
Approve F-Zero and Mario World
Banjo Tooie
Also putting an approval for Fire Emblem 7
Battlefield 2
>>321966129
Wait, what the fuck? Why is it all BattleToads?
Animal Crossing on gamecube
Portal
Spongebob Squarepants: Battle for Bikini Bottom (This game was fucking amazing)
>>321968034
Approved
Portal 2
Rome Total War
This was clearly not made by /v/
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
Super Mario Bros 3
Mount and Blade Warband
>>321968104
>>321968186
Approved
TF2
>>321968186
Approved
>>321968251
Rejected
Hotline Miami
>>321967457
Approved
>>321968104
>>321968186
Approved
>>321967912
Approved all of them
Divinity Original Sin. We need some good new modern games on the list; cant just be pure nostalgia.
Doom 1 + 2
Super mario world
call of duty 4, modern warfare 2
fallout new vegas
halo 3
The World Ends With You
>>321967868
Approved
>>321966668
approved
>>321968070
approved
>>321968412
Approved
Nominating Alien: Isolation
>>321968302
approved, too fucking good in its heyday
>>321966668
Approved
Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective
>>321968321
approved
>>321967106
Approved
Baldur's Gate 2
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
Chrono Trigger
Fallout 2
NFL 2K5
Path of Exile
>no megaman
There are alot of better games then 2 but this is probably the only one people will actually vote for here.
Okami
>>321966668
approved
Shining Force
>Meme Run is on the approved list
Obviously it was voted on by a samefag.
>>321968747
approved
>>321968614
Approved
gothic 2
>>321966129
>list of 100 games
>no mention of a quake game
>nier is on there
>deus ex #1
turn 360 degrees and walk away
>>321966589
>>321966989
Approved
Skullgirls
>>321968925
You can change that anon!
Nominate Quake and it may get voted on!
I believe in you!
Approve BattleToads.
Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
The Elder Scrolls IV : Oblivion
>>321968975
this board isn't old enough to have played quake and it likes to repeat this dumb notion that doom is more fun single player than quake, which is stupid as fuck, considering that doom levels cannot be anywhere near as complex as quake ones.
nah, i know you're all too young to know the games, doesn't bother me that much.
but nier on a top anything list. lol.
>i never read a book in my life so this AMAZING PLOT TWIST means this game with 1/10 gameplay is a top game of all time!
Morrowind
Can we approve games already on the shortlist to give them more votes? If so:
>Undertale
>Demon's Souls
>Deus Ex
Also approving:
>>321966589
>>321967710
I'd also like to nominate Assassin's Creed 2 and Steins;Gate.
Jedi accedemy
Jedi outcast
Bastion
>>321968614
Approve
>>321966989
>>321967060
>>321967624
Approved
>>321967912
Approved HG/SS
>>321968803
Approved
>>321969178
Approved Academy
Persona 3 Fes
Golden Sun
Golden Sun: The Lost Age
>>321969109
>Steins gate
this is a list for video games, sorry.
>>321969079
Anon why are you so salty about Nier?
I've personally never played it but I would be more angry about games like Fallout 3 and GTA 4 being on the list
Warcraft 3 The Frozen Throne
>>321969276
Approved both
Golden Sun
Tokyo Jungle
>>321969293
That's why I suggested it senpai
>>321966668
>>321966989
These got 14+, someone add them to the list.
Also: Bloodborne
Ace Attorney Investigations 2, aka, Ace Attorney Investigations: Miles Edgeworth: Prosecutor's Path
>>321969371
Approved
Pikmin 2
the stanley parable
>>321969378
>vn
>game
Why not just read a book then? Oh wait, I forgot you don't actually care about plot just shitty same looking anime girls. Ii
Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door
MegaMan Battle Network 3
I prefer 2 but more people will vote for 3
Mario 64
MegaMan Battle Network 2
MGS2
DragonQuest V
>>321969305
games like fallout 3 and gta4 are universally considered good. Nier is considered trash by everyone in the world except this board, where the special snowflakes who really understand gaming!! come to play
same thing with deadly premonition. some games are just trash and /v/ "adopted" them. Nier has among the worst gameplay and most phoned-in, lazy design i have seen in over 25 years of playing the vidya
Dark Cloud
>>321970076
But Fallout 3 is trash unless it is your first RPG and GTA 4 is trash unless it is your first GTA.
>>321970076
Shit, here I was thinking we were compiling "a list of /v/'s top 100 favorite video games of all time". Someone better let OP know we're not doing that anymore.
>>321969912
Approved
Fallout: New Vegas
(Let's go ahead and spell out the implication that only one post-fallout2 can make this list.)
Dark Cloud 2 (Dark Chronicle in EU/JP)
>>321970076
Fallout 3 is not objectively bad unlike Skyrim, it's just that it's writing and quests are a huge step down from 1 and 2, and New Vegas surpasses it in literally every way
>>321970174
it isn't /v/ it's a vocal minority of people here who stick up for these awful games because it makes them hip and elite.
Bubsy 3D
EYE
Monkey Island 1,2,3
>>321970272
Cool.Nier is actually unironically my favourite game of all time
On that note, I'm approving the Nier nomination on the pastebin
to the moon
Nier
Banjo-kazooie
>>321969978
>>321970005
>>321970008
>>321970042
>>321970185
>>321969848
>>321969707
>>321969459
>>321967912
Approve Pokemon Platinum
>>321969183
>>321968814
>>321968747
>>321968614
Approve all these
Nominate Pokemon Super Mystery Dungeon
Counter-Strike 1.6
>>321966129
Gonna approve Nier and OoT from the pastebin.
>>321967731
approved
Hey OP, last thread had at least 3 Banjo Tooie votes when I left, why hasn't it been added to the list?
>>321970076
>shitpost about Nier
>people nominate it in response
Clever guy
Earthbound
>>321968919
approved
>>321970289
approved
Mother 3
>>321970856
Approved.
>>321970756
Old list I presume.
Morrowind
>>321971158
Well I dop hope OP updates the pastebin before making a new thread each time
>>321971058
approved
darksiders
>>321971058
It's already in op's list.
>>321970289
Approved
Pikmin1
>>321969520
wew Pikmin 2 lads
>over 200 posts
>no one mentions Terranigma
Are you guys serious? I don't understand. It's easily in the top 5 video games of all time for me. The best RPG and the one that managed to actually make you cry.
Great story, great world, everything is good in this game.
What the fuck guys. This is a crime.
Digimon World
Didn't plan on making a new thread until I counted all the approvals from the last thread but this will work
>>321970185
>>321970040
>>321969912
My fault, I just posted my top 3 games immediately without going to OP's links. These three are already approved.
Adding an approval to Devil May Cry 3 on the pastebin
>>321967827
>>321968034
>>321968321
Approved
>>321971569
this box art interests me but i have never heard of it tell me more
>>321971569
Approved. There's no need to bitch tho.
Silent Hill 2
Ys: Oath in Felghana
>>321967294
>>321967792
Approved
>>321966129
Goldeneye 007
WWE Smackdowm! Here Comes the Pain
>having a top 100 list without the best wrestling game
Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair
Dark Souls
Deadly Premonition
Deus Ex: Human Revolution
Earthbound
Fire Emblem Awakening
Hitman Blood Money
Last Window
Nier
Persona 3 Portable
Persona 4 Golden
Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney: Trials and Tribulations
Pokemon Blue
Pokemon Soul Silver
Silent Hill 2
Super Smash Bros Wii U
The Wolf Among Us
>>321971740
It's a SNES RPG by Quintet and published by Enix. Same guys made Illusion of Gaia, Soul Blazer and ActRaiser.
It was never officially released in the NA region so many people don't know it.
Story is a bit complicated, but basically it's a story about light vs dark, god vs devil and you (from the under world) go above to Earth's surface to bring life to it. So you bring plants and water, animals and eventually humans to the planet. There's much more to it but it's just great, I really recommend giving it a try. It also has very enjoyable gameplay.
>>321970856
>>321970495
Approved
>>321966129
Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Sky
Crash Team Racing
Fantasy Life
>>321966129
no fallout 2 in top 10....
mgs3
OP link your new thread when you make it
>>321972031
Im sure spurging all of your shitty opinions in one post like this makes it more difficult for him to tally it up than it needs to be.
>>321971569
Approved, Adding Illusion of Gaia even though no one will vote for it.
>>321970289
Approved
Hotline Miami 1
Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory
>>321972738
approved
>>321971827
Approved.
How in the fuck has no one else approved this.
Sly Cooper
>>321971569
>>321971981
>>321970856
>>321969707
>>321968747
>>321967857
>>321967593
Approved
La-Mulana
>>321966807
Approved Halo 3 and ODST
>>321966989
>>321967149
>>321967857
>>321968186
>>321970005
>>321970334
>>321970495
>>321970856
>>321971058
>>321972902
Approved
>>321972031
Approved Deus Ex: HR
Where the Secret of Mana love guys? Where is it?
>>321969520
approved
Rayman 2: The Great Escape
>>321973207
What about Secret of Evermore?
COD: Black Ops
Zombies was amazing.
I feel like this isn't a super efficient way to form a list. Is this more efficient than everyone just posting their top five games, then doing ctrl+f to tally up the most popular games, then go from there?
The Wind Waker
Thief 2
>>321973351
approve
>>321966129
Approving Ghost Trick and The World Ends With You.
>>321973340
Oops, didn't actually finish post. But this way allows people to spam votes and piggyback on the hivemind opinion of others instead of actually posting unbiased favorites.
Also,
>>321973247
>>321973386
Approved
>>321966129
Gonna throw one in for Bloodborne.
