I think we can all agree with this.
I actually love this list. Undertale, HOTS, and Hotline Miami 2 could be a bit higher though
>Rocket League
Haha, no
Oddly enough I heard good things about CoD.
Black Ops 3 has excellent multi-player and zombies, but the campaign is shit as always. I'd say at least Good tier for that game
>>321121376
I see you're too much of a retard to like anything mainly about story.
>>321122019
>>321122054
every single year they say the same thing about how there were actual improvements to the franchise. dont fall for that shit
>>321121376
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bp55goEW82c
Curious OP, why is Undertale so low?
>>321121376
Sure, I can mostly agree with that.
>>321121376
>halo 5
>anything other than average
It's not shit but it's a terrible halo entry. Also fallout needs to be pushed down a level, it was an extremely dissapointing game across the board.
>>321121376
Undertale is atleast great tier
>>321122395
cause he's one of those people that looks at fanbase instead of game content and screams TUMBLR!!11! at anything he doesn't like.
>MGSV
>God Tier
Here OP, I fixed your post. I took all the cinematic trash and mature gamer sludge and put it in its place.
>>321122596
Halo multiplayer was great. Unless your bad; in that case it's not fun.
>>321122258
This.
Every single fucking year cunts go on about how shit CoD is until it gets released. Then They all say: "oh it's actually not too bad hey, there's been improvements" fuck off, it's irredeemable shit and you all know it, you can pay it and enjoy it, but don't act like it's not effortless cash grab cancer
Halo 5 is average
Bloodborne is great, not god tier
I haven't played a lot of these games, but the ones I have played are in their correct positions. I'd add EO:Untold 2 to Great tier and call it pretty good.
>>321122834
It's ok at best. But it's not halo any more, it may as well be a new IP. Also no split screen our lan takes it to an instant below average rating.
Age of Wonders 3 belongs in at least great tier. Also it came out last year
>>321122827
>xenoblade x
>below average
MOSHI MOSHI, BEITO DESU
>>321123226
>kawaii anime loli dress up simulator where you don't even get the mechs until 12 hours in
>anywhere above or near average
>>321122609
The fact that there are Tumblrinas who actually believe this astounds me.
>>321122395
Because OP hates anything that has a popular following that isnt kataku autistic.
halo 5 belongs in average
undertale may have a cringe fanbase but the game itself was actually good
>>321121376
MGS5 is shit, Undertale on shit teir is you trying to be a fucking idiot. Pillars should be top teir.
>>321121376
>Rise of the Tomb Raider
>Great
>Hotline Miami 2
>Shit
I wish we were all dead
>Shit
>hotline miami
You wet in the brain son?
Actually the only part of this list I disagree with is Undertale. I thought it was great.
>>321121376
I'd argue that Age of Decadence is God Tier in its own regard.
No other RPG has taken dialogue based role playing as far since Torment.
Certainly, AoD is an acquired taste, but it's definitely good. It's one of the few games that actually pushed the boundaries of its genre rather than merely playing it safe.
>People saying Undertale is better than MGSV
>kek
>>321122827
>MH4U
>Below Average
>>321124429
One is a pretentious meme game with no gameplay, and is at 60 dollars, while the other one is only 10 dollars. I'd consider that better.
>>321124653
>handheld
>mature dudebro killing simulator (where you violently kill monsters and rip pieces off of them in a 2dgy6me fashion)
>can't rebind the controls
>can't play it at higher than 240p
>Capcom game
That's pretty much all I need to say.
>>321121376
>ori and the shill forest
>god
nope
>>321122827
>I took all the cinematic trash and mature gamer sludge and put it in its place
>Witcher 3 is Good Tier
>>321124668
Nice b8
>>321124986
It did alot of other things good,and being on the PC it wasn't held back by arbitrary limitations like weak console hardware. Even though it has ports on consoles, it doesn't have to be run with a controller, for instance. Unlike Dark Souls with its poor controls.
if it was less MATURE GAYMER with less cinematics, it'd be GOTY for sure.
not OP
is this more accurate from what was criticized?
>>321125607
The only game there that belongs in God tier is The Witcher. Put everything else about 3 tiers down.
>>321121376
>I think we can all agree
You must be new here. Welcome to /v/.
>>321121376
almost
>>321125607
wonders 3 was released in 2014 i think OP fucked up, only the mac/linux ports were in 2015
What's wrong with Just Cause 3?
>>321121376
you should remove Her Story from the list all together.
it doesn't deserve the publicity.
>>321125764
>Undertale in the trash
>Xenoblade X, Bloodborne, and MGS isn't there with it
I smell bait.
>>321122695
This
>>321125940
>TF2 screenshot
>tumblr filename
that explains it. The Übercu.ck
>Trine 3 the same tier as Her Story
That isn't really fair. As much shit as Trine 3 was, it's still leagues better than that
Splatoon should move up a tier
Undertale, Hotline Miami 2 and Trine 3 should move up a tier
Surprised to see Stella Glow get some love. Good shit.
>>321126136
>calls other keks
>defends games being cinematic experiences
Okay mate.
>>321121376
>Rocket League in God Tier
>King's Quest in Great Tier
>Halo 5 in Great Tier
>Fallout 4 in average tier
>Hotline Miami 2 not in Average Tier
>Undertale not in Average Tier
I'd call it shit but I love it considering that Evolve isn't even mentioned. Literal blunder of the decade 2bh
>>321122827
>Splatoon and XCX below average
>Super Mystery Dungeon that low
Get some taste
>>321124882
>Ori and the Blind Forest
>bad
nope
>>321126304
>bloodborne is a cinematic experience
>MGS5 which has the least cinematics of any MGS game to the point of people actually complaining about it, is a cinematic experience
>XCX, altough mediocre, is a cinematic experience
lil, kek, joj.
>>321126481
whats wrong with king's quest fite me fgt
>>321121376
apart from undertale and life is strange in shit tier (should be in average) its pretty on point.
fuck her story.
>>321123372
>i have to wait <certain_amount_of_length> for <thing>
>this means it's shit
>everything must be handed to me
welcome to the next generation on a grand scale
>>321126494
I do have taste, otherwise those games would be higher.
>>321126632
>bloodborne is a cinematic experience
Every moment you're not fighting something, someone's talking in your ear or giving you boring monologue.
>MGS5 which has the least cinematics of any MGS game
You call 5 hours "least cinematic"? I call that "The David Cage special". Not even The Order 1886 is that cinematic.
>XCX, altough mediocre, is a cinematic experience
Same problem with bloodborne. Nobody ever shuts up.
I thought I was playing video games, not listening to people talk and watching cutscenes.
>>321126859
Shouldn't a game be FUN in the first few hours, instead of boring me with dialogue and exposition and playing dress up? In a game that advertised itself as FFXV but with robots, that's unforgivable. A good game would give you the robots from the get-go and the anime characters wouldn't exist period. Why they felt the need to ruin a good premise by turning it into some hackneyed fusion between Senran Kagura and Naruto fanfiction is beyond me.
>>321126867
>I do have taste, otherwise those games would be higher.
>implying
>>321121376
Neither Undertale nor Hotline Miami 2 deserve that hate.
Also, this shit lists always go to reddit so fuck you.
>>321125607
>moved Bloodborne down but kept TPP
This shit's even worse.
>>321121376
>god tier
All of those belong in the average tier
>great tier
pillars, xeno,skylines, isaac go into the average tier
yakuza and nuclear stay were they are.
Everything else is shit
>average
db, fallout 4, and tales stay
everything else is shit
>shit
undertale and life is strange move up to average
Everything else stays.
>>321126867
>Every moment you're not fighting something, someone's talking in your ear or giving you boring monologue.
what? I.. huh... what?
95% of character dialog is optional, you can outright ignore them. the other 5% is skippable by pressing X a couple of times
>You call 5 hours "least cinematic"?
Compared to every other MGS game, yes. You average 3 hours of gameplay for 1 min of cinematics
>Same problem with bloodborne. Nobody ever shuts up.
People talk with you, yes. But that's like saying Dragon'sDogma is the most cinematic RPG out there. I don't think you know what the word means.
And I'm still baffled at your bloodborne BS. The one and only time I remember any dialog while you run aroud is the AWWOOOO boss, which is purposely made to fuck with your head.
>>321128003
>what? I.. huh... what?
>95% of character dialog is optional, you can outright ignore them. the other 5% is skippable by pressing X a couple of times
It's not good game design to ask me to skip large segments of your game. SOME story I can tolerate, for the sake of context, but I shouldn't have to be slamming my finger against the button just to make the latest quest giver close his gabber.
>Compared to every other MGS game, yes
Let's compare that to an actually good video game, like Pacman, or Super Mario World, or Super Metroid.
>10 hours of gameplay for 1 min of cinematics
Sounds much better than what Metal Gear Movie tries to push.
>People talk with you, yes. But that's like saying Dragon'sDogma is the most cinematic RPG out there. I don't think you know what the word means.
It's the same way that Kid Icarus: Uprising is cinematic. I don't want to hear characters talking constantly, and I shouldn't have to constantly be slamming the finger on the button to get past it That's bad game design.
I hold to the fact that no game needs a large story at all, and any game that relies on it in even the slightest is a lesser game because of it. This is of course ignoring the other problems with each game, like the casualization, the horrific graphical presentations, the poor performance, and the lack of variety in gameplay other than "sneak and kill stuff".
>>321121376
Move everything into the shit category.
>Reddit League
>Ori and the SJW forest
>Incomplete Game V
>Crypt of the Casual Dancer
About all I cared to look at.
>>321128913
fucking etrian dungeon
at least the music was good
>>321129083
>that piece of shit got higher review scores than pokemon super mystery dungeon
reviewers have no idea what they are talking about
>>321124231
I found it boring and too easy.
>>321127005
>boring me with story
>advertised itself as a game that hasn't come out
>>321121376
>implying any game but Witcher should be in God Tier
>implying Super Mario Maker shouldn't be in great
Other than that, whatever
>God Tier
Looks okay enough
>Great Tier
Holy nigger fuck that drop in quality what ar eyou even doing
>>321129617
what games deserve great tier, then?
>>321128428
holy shit could it be more obvious that you never touched bloodborne or any souls game ever?
> I shouldn't have to be slamming my finger against the button just to make the latest quest giver close his gabber.
>make the latest quest giver close his gabber.
>quest giver
WEW lad
>SOME story I can tolerate, for the sake of context
But Bloodborne is exactly that. Story is "told" through items descriptions and assumptions/connections you make by looking at the world around you
All character do is tell you their own story, add their own piece of the puzzle, they barely talk about anything larger than their own experience and are always brief about it, they say 3 or 5 lines at any point.
I don't even know why I'm explaining this to you since you didn't play it.
In terms you can comprehend, Bloodborne is like Metroid Prime, where you scan shit and read the context of that object, what it is or what it does, except in bloodborne those little blobs of text are on items.
Stop playing pretend. I'm not even going to adress your other points, I don't know if you are just baiting hard or didn't play any of the games.
>>321129791
Nothing rehashed.
Nothing cinematic
Nothing violent like another killing simulator ala Bloodborne.
Nothing casual.
Nothing weeaboo.
Most of all, it should be user friendly, but not casualized for a child audience. Like it should be a love letter to guys who love getting indepth with a game's deep mechanics, but shouldn't rip out features just to appeal to kids.
>>321122054
how come I see this heaven faggot literally everywhere and he's always being a dick with some wiseass remark? this is probably the 1st time this nolife fuck has said something even semi constructive
>>321130002
>But Bloodborne is exactly that. Story is "told" through items descriptions and assumptions/connections you make by looking at the world around you
The problem is that there's just too much text dumps. It's nothing compared to Metroid Prime, which had a better finesse to it, and wasn't edgy grimdark murderkillan everywhere.
Here's the actual list
>>321130225
that's Reddits list
>>321121376
I have only played one game on that list.
What does that mean?
>>321130219
This guy is the epitome of troll
He hates everything violent and 'edgey' and all story
Your basic Soccer Mom
Ignore him, he posted his bait picture before
>>321122827
>bloodborne in the same category as JUST 3 and undermeme
>>321121376
I disagree with only 2. HoTS should be one tier higher, and Age of Wonders 3 should be one up as wellonce you factor in the dlcs
I ain't played woolly world though. Is it really just ok?
>>321130219
>The problem is that there's just too much text dumps.
There are none.
Zero.
Nada.
Never Ever.
Why are you still pretending you played the game? I don't get it.
The story is so vague and spread out, in fact, that even austists who delve into it for days and look at every nook and cranny to come to their own conclusions don't agree with each other. Even the guy who wrote the official guide can't tell you the plot, only point out to sources/evidence for some context
You couldn't pick a worse example to shit on for being cinematic. Why didn't you pick another token PS4 game to hate? Why not the obvious Order1886 movie? That would've been easier to shitpost about
>>321130818
Yeah, I can see that. I'm just trying to explore his mind. I can't imagine anyone else's working like his. It's a good study case.
>>321130818
You know what's the epitome of a troll? Wanting things in your VIDEO GAME that aren't GAMEPLAY, or don't directly support it.
Do you want the industry to be dominated by the PS4 and clones of Uncharted and TLOU and Gone Home, where the "cinematic experience" is given precedence over gameplay?
>>321130992
>there are none
Father Gascoigne would argue otherwise. But look, we're arguing semantics, let me get to the point: I think a game should not have any story aside from the basics, and I feel that the souls series in general just puts it on a bit too heavy.
Then again, people ITT are arguing that Metal Gear isn't a movie, so I feel like I'm being trolled.
>>321121376
>MGS5 God tier
yeah no, other than that I agree
>>321123372
>12 hours in
Honestly more like 40-60.
That being said, fantastic game.
>>321131289
>Father Gascoigne would argue otherwise.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7J_Vqnthwh4
Woah! You got me. A 40 second long cutscene with literally 2 lines of dialog. This is unacceptable
> I think a game should not have any story aside from the basics, and I feel that the souls series in general just puts it on a bit too heavy.
Good, you are a radical. Go be moronic somewhere else then. Even monster hunter and etrian odyssey must be too story-driven for you, holy shit
>>321121376
>witcher 3
>god tier
game is so good its on sale for 50% off less than 6 months after release. Guess how many times that happened with bethesda games? If you guessed zero, you're right
fuckin shit, unfun game.
>>321131964
name one flaw that isn't "floaty combat"
it won pretty much every Game of the Year award for a reason
>>321131872
You call 40 seconds a "short cutscene"? Wew lad.
>Good, you are a radical
No, I care about video games, not muh feelings and muh emotions. A good video game can get by without erroneous amounts of story. A bad one relies on it like its the lifeblood of the product.
>>321132061
everything about the game is a flaw
the combat being shit is a pretty major flaw in a game thats full of combat
ive honestly never felt so fucking bored in my life. game just sucks.
giant open world full of NOTHING is the biggest flaw. all PoIs are fucking bandits standing around a treasure chest or monster nests.
>>321121376
>MGS5 and Witcher as God Tier
>Mad Max as average tier
>Life is Strange as shit tier
>Black Ops 3 as shit tier
>>321124231
I loved it too. Good lore and plenty of choice so each playthrough is pretty different.
Talking your way through everything is kinda easy though as long as you have the right skills.
>>321132186
>No I'm not radical
>All videogames ever should follow my doctrine otherwise they are pure shit
ok.
>>321132061
The world is not that compeling for those who weren't already invested in the franchise
Combat is indeed mediocre
Crafting is also nothing special. The potion system improved just a bit though
Gathering is boring overall, it doesn't help if you have OCD either, as you have to pick up every item indivisually, walk up to 15 different plants in a 10 metre radius to pluck each of them up, and having to look at every spot of every room to find the tiniest seperate objects.
Overall story was meh, characters and character progression being the best part about it
Open world design didn't help the game. Too many boring quests, with good ones hidden between them
>>321132195
This. The combat is too damn boring to have fun in that game. Keep in mind, I play DaS.
>>321125764
Good list but I'd bump up just cause 3 since it runs superbly in offline mode and mostly only AMD people have had problems
>>321132814
>All videogames ever should follow my doctrine otherwise they are pure shit
Doctrine? The only thing I ask is that a game not be heavy on the story. Is that so much to ask from this industry where meme games like Undertale and Her Story and Life is Strange and MGS get praise because they caused le fee-fees on tumblr?
>haha this character says memes!
>this girl is like le plant!
>le suicidal time traveling lesbians!
>whopps where is the gameplay
I figured /v/, with their normal hateboner for reddit and tumblr and neogaf and "cinematic movies", would at least sympathize with me here. You guys could at the least understand why I don't want a game that's heavy on story.
>>321132865
it's funny how they tried to emulate the souls style with "weighty" combat and it just feels fucking unresponsive and terrible
hope you like changing spells and using bombs 15 times a fight!! it's super intuitive after all
3 games and they didnt get anything right. Cyberpunk will suck also because CDPR DOESN'T UNDERSTAND FUN.
>>321133060
>mostly only AMD people have had problems
i told people for years every time there was a thread not to buy amd, have just given up at this point. those who want more "bang for the buck" get what they pay for. trash.
>>321122054
>excellent multi-player and zombies
>things that 12-year-olds care about
>>321121376
Wicther III was the same dumbed-down, narrative-heavy western shit everyone gives Bethesda and many other western publishers shit for making.
The gameplay is fucking boring and shallow, you're doing the same shit after hour 50 you were doing in hour 5.
>>321133329
>only 12 year olds play multiplayer games
if you play only single player games deeply into adulthood, it's a sign of a personal problem.
>>321133120
Dude, chill.
>/v/ is one person
You don't like those games, that's fine. I personally enjoy any game that has a great story, soundtrack, set of mechanics, etc. If at least one thing about it is fun it's good. You don't have that opinion, and that's fine. Shut the fuck up sempai
>>321122596
The multiplayer alone is god tier. The single player is average which puts it at great desu senpai.
The Phantom Content is what should be in average tier
>>321133120
>The only thing I ask is that a game not be heavy on the story.
When Souls games are considered heavy in the story, yes, you are a radical. Only shoot'em ups, platformers and MP-only games meet your criteria
You didn't didnt answer about my silly MonHun and EtrianOdyssey comment, but I'm sure even those have too much story for you, Mr.TF2 austistand I hated undertale and its fanbase, as you can see from >>321125764 ,not sure why you used it as an example. For you it's nothing or everything, so scale of gray in-between
>>321133165
Man, I really want to play cyberpunk, but for the love of god I hope they overall the combat system.
Witcher3 was more boring to play than the literal offline MMO that was XCX, and that's saying something. Witcher could've had something similar to dragons dogma, but no.
>>321121376
>Hotline Miami 2 is worse than Rise of the Tomb Raider and Halo 5
Looks like someone couldn't beat the prison level
Do you think people would be less critical of Her Story if it was named something else?
>>321133682
>I personally enjoy any game that has a great story, soundtrack, set of mechanics, etc. If at least one thing about it is fun it's good.
See, this kind of thing confuses me. Like yeah, you can have fun with the story and characters and music, but shouldn't the GAME part of the video game matter a little more? or is it destined to just be in the background so people can have their emotional character drama told through an unskippable 50 minute cutscene?
>>321133786
>Only shoot'em ups, platformers and MP-only games meet your criteria
Also games like Transistor or Shovel knight or good RPGS that are light on story. They don't bore me with hours of cutscenes. They have story, but it's there strictly for context. They also do alot of other things right in their game, so it's not as big a problem, and doesn't clump up into a large issue.
>You didn't didnt answer about my silly MonHun and EtrianOdyssey comment,
I'm neutral about those series. I don't find them very good, gameplay wise or story wise, so they don't really offer anything to me.
>>321134061
>implying that you own an xbone
>implying that have played either of those games and arent just shitposting for the sake of it
>implying that miami 2 isnt a rancid pile of dog shit that disappoints fans of the original in every way imaginable
>>321134123
If it had some gameplay and wasn't just watching youtube-quality videos for 10 minutes, it would be less criticized. If you want to rename it to accurately depict the content, I'd name it:
>meh story
>>321121376
Actually ya... I'm actually OK with this.
>>321122827
>this guy again
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nkb8wosLe38
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGe9Tw1OseM
You really have awful taste.
>>321122827
>all the cinematic trash and mature gamer sludge
>mature dudebro killing simulator
Literally /v/ incarnate.
>>321134281
What's the problem with those videos anon?
>gameplay starts almost immediately after you press the "start" button
>no character feelings or emotional drama or unskippable 50 minute cinematics in the way of the actual gameplay
>not just another mature dudebro first person shooter
>multiple difficulty levels for those who want a challenge
Do they need skeletons and squid lolis making bad puns? Just curious.
>>321134232
>Talks about disappointment
>Defends RotTR and Halo 5
I consider fallout 4 in the "above average" tier.
>>321134235
Is the story actually bad? or is it just bad because it's a story-game?
>God Tier
Kirby and the Rainbow Paintbrush
>not-God Tier
The Rest.
>GOTY
Bloodborne
>Shit compared to GOTY
Everything else
>>321134628
It's below average at best. The writing is so fucking lazy.
>>321134636
It's a glorified, unchanging murder mystery with 2-3 actual useful hints scattered among the junk, and once you complete it, that's it. It's destined for that cold, dark corner in your game library where nothing ever gets touched again.
Switch xenoblade x with mgsv and yeah
>>321134907
>once you complete it, that's it
this is not inherently bad. the idea that all games have to be replayable for 400 hours is some 2000s kid shit.
journey is really only good for one playthrough and it's among the greatest and most memorable games i ever played.
Of course, who doesn't like popping in from time to time to show off your maxed out scarf...
>>321129220
Nah, you just have shit taste.
>>321135126
>this is not inherently bad.
When there's barely any gameplay and you're just shuffling through videos to watch, I'd say that's pretty bad. You can get the entire experience just by watching a youtube video.
>>321135126
A story being interesting enough to revisit is "2000s kid shit"?
>>321121376
I know y'all biased against the CoD games and the whole "hate activision because it releases one yearly" meme, but BO3 has better quality in almost all regards than fallout 4. And that's a fact, not arguing requried
>>321135314
anon, is that what i said?
shadow of the colossus, pretty much only good for one playthrough unless you like challenge shit, another of the greatest games of all time. the list goes on
>>321135513
>Shadow of the Colossus
You can actually PLAY that game though. It's not just watching videos, and the main draw isn't figuring out who the bad guy is, but rather fighting the bad guys in the process.
>>321134578
Look, dude. If you want to bother with 0/10, shit-tier, flash games, be my guest. Might as well give you another reply.
>>321134935
I love Xenoblade X. but that game has too many flaws to ever be considered god tier
From the shit-tier story, to the zero character development, to the awful music, to the fact that the story is carried by 2 characters making the same joke over and over again and none of your other characters ever speak, there is just way too many problems with it
>>321135513
No, but your comment was already absurd. His criticism wasn't that it didn't have "400 hours" of replayability. What he said was that it's a "glorified, unchanging murder mystery" that has absolutely nothing else going for it.
That's pretty fucking damning for a story driven game.
>>321135616
i played plenty of games where the gameplay is only good for one go-round too. i get your point but a game not being replayable is not inherently a strike against it
>>321135669
>Look, dude. If you want to bother with 0/10, shit-tier, flash games
>he says as he defends Life is Strange and 10FPSBorne and UnfinishedGearV
Calling the kettle black again, eh Mr. Pot?
Is Yokai Watch really that good?
I mostly hear "it's alright but nothing special".
>>321135830
Kongregate is my GOTYAY too :^)
>>321135845
It looks fantastic, idk. I'd say it's a top 5 rpg this year
>>321135724
>i played plenty of games where the gameplay is only good for one go-round too
If the game has good, well designed gameplay, then it's always worth a replay regardless of genre.
>>321134134
Not the guy you've been arguing with, but it looks like you're just an ADD sperg if you think that Bloodborne is too heavy on the story. The game is pretty much all gameplay.
>>321136027
>If the game has good, well designed gameplay, then it's always worth a replay regardless of genre.
no, this isn't true. I simply don't replay games that aren't multiplayer unless they are very very special. it boils down to the person. i don't reread books or rewatch movies either. i consider reconsuming non-music media to be weird and a waste of time.
>>321135965
The funny thing is that their games have more gameplay than most AAA titles this year, combined.
What was your point again?
>>321122258
funny thought that it has better quality than half of the games considered better than it in this list
>>321136179
Do you have a point? You sound like an annoying freshmen preaching about relativism.
>>321136153
It's not the MOST story-heavy. That goes to MGS. Still, it needed alot of improvement in that area. I guess cinematic isn't the best word for Bloodborne specifically. I'd chalk it up to more lazy gameplay design and not knowing how to implement lore than anything else.
>>321136184
More gameplay, but it's all 0/10. Wew, lad. Sure showed me.
>posting console cover when game has PC version
that's an instaNOPE
>>321136372
>0/10 because it doesn't have teh latest grafix or tits and gore everywhere
Awful shallow thinking if you ask me.
>>321136501
0/10 because the gameplay is shit. Casual, flash "games" aren't good just because of your mech fetish, son.
>>321122923
>>321122258
>>321122019
I got the game 4free since I honestly would not pay for the game...
It is good. Not at that PRICE, but it is really good.
I personally liked the story, zombies is as fun as it has always been. Freerun was a nice addition.
MP is what most people play and the main reason you hear "[mumbling noises] uh there have been some uh...improvements uh [Unintelligible Dialogue followed by excessive drooling]" the fanbase is retarded, but Treyarch do try, it is not soulless rehashed bullshit like Assassin's Creed for example.
Personally if it was $20 I would buy any of the games if they included the DLC and the full package. Kinda ridiculous to charge over $20 for a 2011 Game like Blops or MW3 at this point.
>>321122827
>this autist again
Just stop, man.
>>321134276
>>321121376
Yeah I agree with this.
Shame for Trine 3 really.
Being honest Xenoblade is more deserving of a Goty than MGSV
>>321121376
>Someone actually mentioning Odallus
Why no one ever talks about that game? It is a lot of fun and a great throwback to classic Castlevania
>>321136607
>0/10 because the gameplay is shit.
Why is it "shit" though?
>>321136896
No challenge.
>but muh mechs
>>321122827
>>321137113
>no challenge
So what, you think the game should have various difficulty modes?
>>321122695
To be fair, the game content isn't really that great. Along with a few other games, it deserves to be higher. A tier between average and great. Good seems appropriate. Undertale isn't a bad game but it just isn't difficult at all and there's no real satisfaction because you have to intentionally gimp yourself for there to be any sort of challenge. I still enjoyed it but I genuinely believe that it is just good game as opposed to great, in the context of these tiers. Solid 7.5 out of 10. Carried heavily by soundtrack.
MH4U deserves to be lower though.
>>321121376
no just no
All you autists not putting Undertale as god tier, it's like you actually want to stay virgins for the rest of your lives.
>>321137745
>MH4U deserves to be lower
Look at this faggot and laugh.
>>321124769
Yes, all you needed to say for everyone to disregard your posts lmao
>>321138010
Are you saying I'm not allowed to be entitled to a game that doesn't have horrible performance and resolution?
>>321137745
>Solid 7.5 out of 10. Carried heavily by soundtrack.
I used to think this, but I don't think the soundtrack can carry it that much, nor can the characters even if you like them. I think it'd be more fair to give it a 5/10, maybe a 5.9. Hard mode really should've been in there and it shouldn't have been blatantly teased despite being unfinished.
:^)
>>321130448
>I don't like it so it's Leddit
:^)
>>321138131
are we not allowed to disregard your posts for being bait?
>>321137373
I think it should have challenging gameplay, instead of mindless, violent, dudebro, robot killing.
>>321137881
go back to your containment board
>>>/vg/126234937
>>321138816
You can disregard them if you don't agree with them, but you can't call them bait and expect it to be true.
>>321138971
>I think it should have challenging gameplay, instead of mindless, violent, dudebro, robot killing.
Confirmed for never playing either game.
>>321139090
>Confirmed for never playing either game.
>says the guy who outright says in his bait images that he doesn't even play at least half of the games
>>321139415
>says the guy who outright says in his bait images that he doesn't even play at least half of the games
I'm gonna need a citation on that.
Whats with all the Hotline Miami 2 hate.
I fucking love it and have 60+ hours in it.
>>321139559
Then post one of them with the autistic criteria on the right.
>>321139772
What criteria? The only goty image I've posted is >>321122827 for reference.
>>321139959
Kek. So you cut it to make it somewhat less baity.
>>321121376
>>321122827
>>321125607
>no Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold
baka desu senpai
>>321135252
You clearly haven't played EMD.
>>321121376
How come you did not like life is strange?
>>321140058
I have an image that details criteria about what I feel makes a game good. Is that what you're talking about? Since we're discussing GOTY nominations in here, I guess it would be relevant.
>>321121376
>I think we can all agree with this.
The answer is always no.
>>321140147
>video games
>>321121376
I'dUndertale in Great Tier
>>321136338
His point is pretty clear, lack of replayability isn't necessarily a bad thing in a coherent game. If you don't like this game and think it doesn't merit one play that's something else entirely.
Honestly in 2015 it's almost better to be able to finish a game and move on, since there's so many more than there were in the 90s and 00s
>>321141708
>His point is pretty clear, lack of replayability isn't necessarily a bad thing in a coherent game
But it needs to have gameplay at the very least. If you're just watching it, then it can't suffer from a lack of replayability. Then again, """games""" like Her Story don't even have playability, so it's hard to be re-playable.
>>321121376
Move every game to shit, and the list is perfect.
>>321136179
>i don't reread books or rewatch movies either.
This says a lot more about how shitty the books and movies you read and watch are.
>>321141102
>>321121376
I'd move some stuff around, like Mario Maker or MGSV or yo-kai's placement, but its a list that acknowledges MH4U as the GOTY that it is
one question, though: what the fuck are helldivers and ori and the blind forest? they look generic and mediocre at best
Etrian odyssey is on sale on the 3ds shop. should I get 4 or mystery dungeon? I've never played any etrian or mystery dungeon.
>>321122054
I'm with you anon
I've actually been playing the campaign a lot, trying to 100% it. It's been a fun challenge.
>>321143757
get 4, etrian mystery dungeon is the most generic and uninteresting dungeon crawler i have ever played
>>321142732
perfect response
>hml2 was bad For what purpose
