CHOOSE YOUR CHARACTER!!
Add Porky Minch and that is literally the perfect Smash roster for me.
>>320639456
>corrin
feeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet
>>320639456
I'm so happy you're not Sakurai
>>320639625
I almost did, but felt 2 reps was a good number for a 3 game series
>>320639625
Actually I just realized it has no Jigglypuff. Nigga what the fuck are you doing.
>>320639456
Put chun li too and i'm down to it
>>320639743
Cause this is a better character roster than his?
>>320639792
I'm not following the original 12 rule.
>>320639456
Literally every change you made is retarded to levels beyond my comprehension.
>>320639456
>Paper Mario
>Waluigi
Stopped caring right there, but let me finish
>K. Rool
>Ghirahim
>Lana
>Roy
>Ridley
>Sylux
>guy next to Sylux
>Pokemon Trainer
>Guy next to Lucas
>mother fucking 3 F-Zero characters including edgy blood falcon
>Medusa AND Hades. Pick one.
>Eternal Darkness guy
>all those literally whos on the bottom two rows
>furfag b8 banjo
>Crash
>daisy as an alt
>alt movesets
>>320640085
Care to actual state them? Or just keep shitposting with nothing to back it up?
>>320640123
I don't think a Nintendo crossover game is for you
>>320639941
>more KI characters than kirby
>more dk characters than kirby
>more metroid characters than kirby
>removing jiggs
>no chibi robo
Just add chibi, b.dee or dark matter, and throw jiggs back in and its perfect
>unironically thinking dillon, the samurai guy, sable prince andice climbersdeserve roster spots
>>320639456
Cloud Strife
>>320640123
Who do YOU want in?
>>320640421
Not enough history with Nintendo, Black Mage better reps FF as a whole, and FF games that appeared on Nintendo systems.
Apart from that, I have no problems with Cloud.
>>320640472
I have no set want, but I do want somebody who's inclusion isn't retarded.
>>320640656
>Not enough history with Nintendo
>Tries to shove in Crash fucking Bandicoot
I'd rather have a character that has no history with Nintendo than a character who only appeared in bad games with Nintendo
>Black Mage better reps FF as a whole,
More people recognize Cloud than Black Mage. Even in the Smash Ballot Cloud was getting more votes
>>320640668
I will agree with you on some of those, but how are K Rool, Paper Mario, Ray, Issac, or Sami retarded?
>Batman
What the fuck? Lol?
>>320639456
>no Bayonetta
u wot m8?
>>320640863
Crash was Mario's second rival during the 90's, and regardless if they were meh, he had exclusive Nintendo games. Cloud hasn't.
>>320641065
Sami is stupid because Andy is the main character
>>320641312
Black Shadow
>>320641769
The handheld KH titles, Theathythm, and FF Explorers are better than anything Crash got on a Nintendo system
>>320641781
Aren't they all the MCs?
>there are people on /v/ who hate the idea of Ridley or K Rool, despite the fact they are important to their series, and many people would like them.
"haha BTFO salty xd"fags are the worst part of the Smash fanbase.
>>320639456
This roster is correct because there's Lana in it.
>>320641940
Those games are also not Cloud's games, he was just a cameo, and didn't star in them, unlike Crash who did have staring Nintendo games, regardless of quality.
>9 Zelda characters
>4 FE characters
I can feel your butthurt through my monitor
>>320642182
I love how you're making up rules at random when Sakurai never said anything of the sort.
>>320642549
Well Sakurai didn't make this roster, if he did there would be more FE characters
>>320639456
<Waluigi
>4 DK reps
>Girahim
>Skull Kid
>Lana
>2 Hunters
>the LITERALLY WHO carrot head
>3 F-Zero reps
>4 KI reps
>a skellington Etenral Darkness aka LITERALLY WHO
>half of the last row
Come on
>>320642519
Its funny, cause I made this before Cloud was announced
>>320640196
I'm writing a big ass response, hold on.
>>320642159
haha BTFO salty xd
>>320642720
Which is better than basing most of the Zelda shit being based on Fanfiction Warriors
>>320639456
This is delusion: the roster and you knew this when you were making it
>>320639456
>Dixie despite having no defining traits other than girl Diddy that hovers
>all these literally whos from Hyrule Warriors and the fuckboi from Skyward Sword
>characters from Prime: Hunters that never got fleshed out
>Samurai Goroh despite having less material to work with than Captain Falcon
>list begins to devolve from this point to more literally whos or pointless shit like an Eternal Darkness rep
>Black Mage instead of Red Mage or someone that would have an excuse to use melee attacks
Many of the other additions were fine but man does this entire thing reek of autism. Keep it to the fucking general on /vg/
>Switching characters back
No,fuck that.
>>320642810
for how big DKC is, DK deserves 4 characters
The Zelda characters also rep different games in the series
Metroid is big enough and has been around long enough to have 4 characters that are actually different characters.
Mike Jones is a retro character, along with the other characters you are too young to know about
F-Zero has also been around for years, and 3 reps isnt too bad, but I could live without Black Shadow
, same with KI, I can do without Medusa or Hades, probably Hades more because Medusa has the history behind her. I put them in mostly because I pictured cool movesets for them
Eternal Darkness was a popular horror game on the GC, and reminds people Nintendo used to be more than Playskool tier designs/games.
>>320643210
>>all these literally whos from Hyrule Warriors and the fuckboi from Skyward Sword
only 1 character from HW
I just used the HW designs because I liked them
>>320643362
Why only 3 kirby reps then
>>320643362
>The Zelda characters also rep different games in the series
WHY do we need a rep per GAME now?
>>320642941
The designs mean nothing, I just happened to use them because I liked the style, literally only 1 character is from HW, Lana, the rest are for main line Zelda titles. and Zelda is Nintendo's second flag ship franchise, it can have 9 characters
Pig Ganon would be cool but they'd have to change Dorf's FS and I have no idea how.
>>320643732
It can't if they're not recurring characters.
That's the point of "reps" they need to be representative of that franchise.
>>320643732
Lana is to much already I like HW in the fan service department but when it tries anything original it botches it horribly
>>320640196
You're OP, isn't it? Jeus.
>Paper Mario
From a spin-off.
>Waluigi
From Spin-offs
>Dixie
Does people seriously want to fill the roster with DK characters just for the sake of it? Dixie is simply Diddy 2, just make it an Alt. Skin or something.
>K.Rool
The so "main antagonist" of the series is dead as fuck and never coming back. It didn't even make it to Smash. Get over it.
>Impa
Irrelevent, but not as much as the next three.
>Ghirahim
Villain of only one game, one that people didn't like that much.
>Skull Kid
No real complaints actually, besides that it only appears in one game overshadowed by Ocarina.
>Lana
From a spin-off.
>>320640123
>Not wanting Banjo
>Not wanting Crash
>Not wanting Peach's Daisy alt to actually be a Daisy alt
You're a faggot
>>320644176
cont. from >>320644176
>Removing Lucina and Corrin
Leaving Marth, Ike, Robin and Roy is a pretty good shortening actually, I don't know if removing Lucina is viable. Consider that a new rep IS comming regardless.
>Ridley
Get over it. 3big
>Those 2 aliens from Metroid I don't recognize
Just no. Metroid is dead, and you expect they'll put THREE more characters from it on Smash? C'mon.
>Wolf
Proven clonest of clones. Shitty design. But this is just my oppinion, there's no real reason to exclude him, so it's okay I guess.
>Removing Jigglypuff
Oh wow, you seriously think they'll remove one of the staple characters of Smash Bros.? Why does everyone hate Jigglypuff so much?
>Pokémon Trainer
You don't understand that characters are no longer going to have multiple movesets, don't you? Wait, no, Zelda and Sheik are separate. Are you high, or something?
>>320644027
>It can't if they're not recurring characters.
Fire Emblem
>That's the point of "reps" they need to be representative of that franchise.
and they do as a whole. The Zelda series has more characters than just Link, Zelda and Ganon, which I chose to add other villains and characters in the series
>>320640196
whoops meant to cont. from >>320644270 in the previous one
also cont. from that one as well
>Greninja
I guess we tought the same about Lucario, and now that it has gotten its Ash-Greninja form it's more relevant now. Shit, I don't know.
>Ginger guy whose name I knew but forgot
Wasn't he from an american game? It's a golden rule of Smash that non-japo characters are not allowed. Also, literally no one remembered this guy until Smash threads brought him up.
>forcing Samurai and Horny Batman
Same as Metroid, it's a dead series. Don't force characters anyways just because you like the game.
>Medusa and Hades
Every year that passes, KI:U becomes less and less relevant. And considering that Sakurai won't work on the next installment, it's even less likely.
>no Waddle Dee
Good choice.
>Ice Climbers comming back
Yep, logical since they were only cut because of the 3DS.
>Inkling
Makes sense. I'm sure this will be the "Villager of 5mash"
CHOOSE YOUR CHARACTER
>>320640196
cont from >>320644379
>Wonder Red
Wether it's from Nintendo or not, it sold like shit. If Nintendo puts him in is because Nintendo literally had no other new characters.
>That skull
Uhh... what is this?
>Custom Robo
I'm sure this game is pretty unpopular. However I think Sakurai did consider it, didn't he?
>Isaac
Would've made sense back in Brawl because of its popularity back then, but in the end he's technically not Nintendo. They removed him from being an Assist Trophy and didn't come back as a character. He won't be playable.
>Sami
Seriously? Not even Andy? Fucking waifufags.
>Takamaru
Got BTFO not even once but twice. It's just a Nintendo-licenced game that didn't even get outside Japan. C'mon.
>That kid and trap blond
I know nothing about them. Nothing at all. Can't really say anything.
>>320640196
cont from >>320644471
>Dillon
Nintendo's attempt to make a new eShop IP. It sold like shit. We're lucky it even came as an assist trophy. I like his design though.
>Banjo
Yeah, no. People overhype this guy way too much. Sure, it had one good game but whatever. It's not japanese and it barely sold 3 million copies, series-worth. YOU WANT A MICROSOFT REP? LIKE, YOU REEAAALLLY NEED IT? A GAMING ICON? PUT MOTHERFUCKING MASTER CHIEF IN.
>Crash
HAHAHAH oh wow. Just because it sold well in the PlayStation it doesn't make it an icon. It's also a character based off Sonic, how low can that go?
>Simon
Makes sense. I'm still unsure about any of its designs.
>changing Cloud for Black Mage
Just because Black Mage was from the original NES game doens't make him more likely. Final Fantasy is a leading gaming series and Cloud happens to be the most recognizable character. It's just like that. I like its design, though.
>>320644298
>Fire Emblem
Yeah, that was my point. We have too many reps that represent too little of the franchise.
Again, one time characters are not representative of the entire series. That would be like making Wart or Cat Bowser a Mario rep.
>>320644379
>>320644270
You cannot argue 'muh relevancy' as long as a single Kid Icarus or Fire Emblem character is on the roster
>>320644587
>one time characters are not representative of the entire series
they are if that series has different characters in every game
>>320644567
>Banjo had one good game
Anon I found the problem
You have shit taste
Sorry you had to find >>>/out/ this way
>>320640196
cont from >>320644567
>Rayman
My number 1 choice for the ballot. However, realistically speaking, it doesn't compare with the popularity of any of those 3rd Parties you listed, even Banjo is more iconic. However it IS bigger than Bayonetta, so maybe one day.
>Bomberman
Yes.
>Zero Suit is an Alt. Moveset
No, they stopped doing this shit for good.
>forcing Daisy as an Alt.
Hahahah, oh woooow.
Your roster is pretty bad, you had good calls, but minimally. It really is the worst roster wishlist I've ever seen, even worse than the ones including Goku and/or Krystal.
>>320644176
>>320644270
>>320644379
>>320644471
>>320644567
Who do YOU think should be in smash 5?
>>320644601
Kid Icarus sold amazingly in Japan and Fire Emblem saved the 3DS with Animal Crossing.
It wouldn't be a surprise if the next Smash is filled with Isabelle, Tom Nook, K.K., etc.
>>320644740
actually your entire rant just proves you have terrible taste
>No Snek
>No Dracula
>The literally who's next to ridley
Diddy should just be a Robin, Robin can leave for FE15 protag and Lucina should be Marth's alt
>>320644867
apparently no Nintendo characters, or if they are they are the newest characters.
the guy clearly doesnt like history to go with characters
>>320644992
>>No Dracula
Simon is a better rep for Castlevania, plus Dracula would be a 4th party character since he isnt a video game character
>>320639456
>Removing Jigglypuff
You dumb mutherfucker.
>>320645248
apart from being in the original, what does she offer?
>>320645343
Rest motherfucker
>>320645343
A unique moveset?
>>320639456
My wish
>>320639456
>my main is saddled with Squirtle and Ivysaur
>>320644867
>>320645003
>Inkling
>Toad (not Captain Toad)
>fucking Isabelle, Tom Nook, K.K., whatever
>>320644874
How so? My wishes for Brawl were Olimar, and for Sm4ash were Villager, Mega Man, Pac-Man, Ryu and Little Mac and I've got them ALL. Except for Rayman who I like but realize is not big enough for Smash.
Wouldn't ray just be a Saki clone?
I'd play Isaac if he was in Smash but let's be real Golden Sun isn't really relevant anymore.
>>320645659
dont worry, I didnt put it, but He plays like he does in Sm4sh
the swap gimmick is changed to two options
you can ether pick just 1 pokemon to play, or you can have the swap option active, which would be a down taunt instead of down b
>>320639456
No Jigg, can't dig.
>>320644380
>>320639456
>>320645486
WHAT ABOUT SNEK?
>>320639456
>Zelda and sheik are separated
>Samus and Zero Suit Samus aren't
Why though?
smash's next big-boy heavy akin to DK/bowser/Dedede
i know the game's indulged enough on gen 1 but even normies know and remember this fuck and has been a face of the brand for nearly 20 years
>>320646707
the Zelda is a different Zelda than the one who changes into Sheik
there is only 1 Samus
Smash 5Assist Trophies:
>Inkling
>Brown Genie Waifu
>Shovelware Kight
>Spyro
>Rayman
>Hector
>Chrom
>Daisy
>Black Shadow
>Hades
>Wonder Red
>Dante from the Devil May Cry Series
>King K.Rool
now everyone is happy
>>320645793
>Inkling
>Toad
100% confident they're in Smash 5
a Rhythm Heaven character like 98% confident
for any other newcomer it's a complete toss-up
WHERE IS MY SHOVEL KITE
REEEEEEEE
>>320639456
Wait...OP...
Where...
Where is Chibi Robo?
>>320646734
Snorlax would be a pretty welcome pokemon.
B - Rollout. Like Jigglypuff, but slower and heavier, does not travel as far. Hits really hard.
Up B - Body Slam. Jump high and do a powerful belly flop. Like Dedede's recovery but slightly more horizontal movement.
Side B - Yawn. Hold to charge, then release a cloud of sleepy air forward.
Down B - Minimize. Shrinks Snorlax, raising his jump and speed significantly, while lowering his size and weight considerably. Wears off slowly, so Snorlax gradually inflates back to his regular size.
Final Smash - Giga Impact. Snorlax leaps high and plummets back to the stage like a meteor. When he lands, a powerful shockwave spreads from him and blasts back opponents.
>>320647335
Glad someone finally agrees with me.
>>320647048
OP used HW Sheik and Zelda though,
>>320649272
I think thats just a design choice, plus HW Zelda and Sheik are different people
>>320639456
This roster looks fucking terrible and you should genuinely reassess your fucking life you stupid cumdumpster
>Wolf
>Banjo
>Crash
>Rayman
>Gay Simon Belmont
glad you're not sakurai
>>320650213
>not wanting Crash or Banjo
Im sorry you were dropped on your head as a child
>>320639456
Pretty damn good. Would be perfect for me if:
>Remove
Ghirahim
Skull Kid
Lana
Weavel
Eternal Darkness Skeleton
Mike Jones
>Add
Tingle
Chorus Kids
Jigglypuff
Captain Rainbow
Snake
Bandana Dee
