Does it really deserves scores that high with that garbage combat system?
>>319201101
>Caring about this
Hey look its the "witcher is a shitty game" anon-kun again.
Everyone, post here so that hell keep making these threads until he dies.
>>319201101
Wizards, and check my 5
>>319201101
>shitting on a game I never played just to fit in
>>319201101
Hey it's you again
http://sys.4chan.org/derefer?url=https%3A%2F%2Fboards.fireden.net%2Fv%2Fsearch%2Ffilename%2Fb-but%2520that%2520doesnt%2520count%2F
Give it a break man, you're more obsessed with the game then Witcherfags. In fact you're worse.
>>319203181
>not having "virgin" wizard
An opportunity was lost there.
>>319201101
its better than bloodburn
so fuck off
and have butthurt seizure somewhere else
>>319204051
>virgin
>wizard
Anon that's what's called an oxymoron. All those wizards are virgins, having a virgin wizard would be a waste.
>>319203181
Rollin
>>319201101
How many times are you going to make this thread?
>>319201406
>Say that a game needs a great story
>These same people give bethesda games high marks
>>319203181
Come on gender bender!
>>319201101
It wasn't even that bad. Especially when you compare it to other games, like Shadow of Mordor where you can literally turn off your monitor and still win.
>>319204379
Not quite an oxymoron. An oxymoron would be something like having a Father Wizard.
>>319203181
Roll
>>319203181
Rollan for vidya wizard
>>319201101
You mad, FROMfag?
>>319203181
let's DO this
>>319201406
>>319201101
One could ask the same question about Dark Souls.
>>319206170
Umad CDshill?
>>319206542
>not a single Souls game even on the list
"B-best game of all time! IT'S SO HARD GUIS ITS LIKE THE HARDEST GAME EVER! W-why are you leaving? P-please, I don't want to be alone..."
>>319201101
Yes. The combat is weak (thought not TERRIBLE) but it is serviceable enough to get you through the game without too much difficulty. Every other aspect of the game is amazing.
Baby's first Western JRPG. That's the only reason it got graded so high.
Also I highly recommend not using metacritic as it allows reviews from blogging websites and non video game publications like celebrity gossip magazines and news papers.
>>319201101
It's almost as if RPGs rely more on giving a great story and world for the player to invest and immerse themselves in instead of focusing on making pressing buttons fun.
>>319206542
>game has to be popular to be good.
I guess CoD is the best game series of all time?
Besides, Skyrim is known for its mods which really helps extend its life.
>>319203181
Bet
>>319201101
Ilikethe combat system if I'm honest. I went for a pyromaniac build with as many igni buffs and apply burning glyphs as I could and I'm having a blast
>>319201101
Are you the same guy who does nothing but shit on The Witchers combat system since launch?
>>319206542
>2 football manager games
nerds btfo jocks rule /fucks your nerdyhot girlfriend in the back of my mercedes after practice and blow in her puss
>>319207187
>ignores 70% of the pictures information
>brings up an online FPS for some reason
Everytime
>>319203181
Rollan senpai
>>319207630
>Soulsfag mad his Appeal to Skyrim failed
Be honest dude, does that ever work?
>>319201406
Their story checks out.
>>319201924
>>319203409
>>319204279
>>319205412
Witcherfags literally incapable of admitting any fault.
Is that why no one ever discusses the story or Combat? Because they fall incredibly short and all you have left is pushing its Graphics, which were average 6 months later.
Never once seen a single person who says they like Witcher attempt once to discuss the games Story.
And you want to say how great it is.
TW3 presents this medium's defining achievement in narrative and character interaction.
Its gameplay and technical presentation are merely a cherry on top of an already perfect work of art. You guys should be glad you're alive to witness something of this magnitude being released during your lifetime.
>>319201101
>>319201101
>Does it really deserves scores that high with that garbage combat system?
Bloodborne and Dark Souls get high remarks from critics and /v/ so yes
>>319208281
Buzzwords.
Astonishing, the CDPR Shills don't even bother hiding anymore.
I knew they paid for reviews, but still.
>>319208241
Combat was meh, not bad but not great.
Story is great so far.
>>319203181
Hoping Modding will fix the garbage combat system
What do people even have against the combat system?
>>319207740
>failed despite my picture being unrefutable
>implying I like soulshit
>>319208364
After CDPR paid for positive reviews then yeah. It's going to score high.
No review mentions that the combat is baby's first video game easy.
>Two Swords
>Game chooses the correct one for you.
>Dodge and Slash
Or that the game was released completely unstable and that to this day, over a thousand people on the main Witcher sub on Reddit talk about how the game crashes frequently.
And then you have the fact that they used False Advertising to get sales, they should have been sued.
But no review even mentions those and you honestly expect people to believe it deserves the scores it gets
>>319201101
muh combat system
It was fine, stop being an entitled crybaby
>>319208420
The discuss the story, saying its great and nothing else, means its bad. Because no one wants to talk about it. Beyond, "its good" and then moving on. Was there no quests where you felt really attached to a character, were there no parts where you were laughing?
This is just further evidence that Witcher 3 is a mediocre game. Because when 1 and 2 were released people discussed the games story and characters, no one does that for 3. And in 3 you have to choose which Waifu you want, and /v/ is all about Waifufagging, so why do you expect me to believe that this is the one game that /v/ doesn't have Waifus in?
>>319203181
wiz
>>319208947
>It was fine, stop being an entitled crybaby
Literally every videogame ever, I guess it's time to pack it in, no reason to discuss any Videogames anymore.
>People think BloodBorne's combat is superior than Witcher 3's combat system
Shit gameplay means a game is shit
Massive ass blast ITT
Reason no one wants to talk about it is because it's need discussed so many times it doesn't need to any more
The game got GOTY and deservedly so.
It had great story and good combat.
Cry more faggots
>>319208241
>Is that why no one ever discusses the story or Combat?
90% of the threads are about story or combat, idiot.
>>319208802
All right you dense fuck, listen here with your "they should be sued" bullshit. The only case that may help would be Spice Girls Ltd v Aprilla World Service, which established that where the representor makes a statement he believes to be true, he owes a positive duty to correct that statement should it be proved false. This could arguably be extended to gameplay trailers, but would rely on them not including the work in progress tag in any shape or form, as a statement of future intention does not constitute a misrepresentation (Edginton v Fitzmaurice). So, assuming that a) the court would allow the expansion of the Spice Hirls rule and b) they do not include the disclaimer, we move onto the reasons the defense would fucking shred this argument.
The Spice Girls rule can easily be satisfied by a subsequent trailer being released with worse graphics. That would inform you of the misrepresentation before the contract is complete (date of sale) and therefore avoid any liability for misrepresentation. If you try to bring a case under the Fair Trading Act or the Consumer Guarentees Act, it's likely that would fail as well due to the same reason as CD corrected their representation with later material. Finally, it's likely a court would accept policy as a reason to find in favour of CD as it is standard practice to just show off what stage your software is at, and finding in favour of the Plaintiff would open Software Development firms to an unreasonable amount of liabilty. Now could you fuck off with that "they should be sued" meme?Note this is not intended as legal advice and should not be relied on as such
>>319201101
the movement system is even more worse than the combat. alternate movement option didn't fix it. it's way too clunky and unresponsive. it made me hate this game.
not to talk about that fucking dumbass horse
>>319209315
In literally everyday
>>319201101
If you think the combat in The Witcher 3 is garbage, you were playing on an easy difficulty.
>>319204623
They're being objective when works.
/v/ no longer cares about gameplay in games
they only care about graphics and whether they were downgraded or not, whether or not the devs are SJWs or the game panders to Tumblr, and if the game is a console exclusive
>>319210787
Except a developer directly stated in an interview that not only would the graphics not be downgraded, but would actually be improved from the last footage shown, this was in an official interview in 2014.
Not a single time during that instance to release did they under any circumstance attempt to inform players that they did in fact lower the graphics.
Only upon release did they acknowledge they reduced the graphics and their defense was
>It was unrealistic to expect those Graphical standards
If I promote a new Ferrari and then say, in an interview the car will be better, faster, more efficient. Then on release it provably is not. That is 100% false advertising.
Because they never made a single attempt to correct that statement in a years time. CDPR literally committed False Advertising.
>>319209148
I haven't finished the game yet, I'm actually playing it now. That's way I said "so far"
>>319213980
False Advertising is not something you commit. You commit a misrepresentation with regards to contract. What you speak of is actually perfectly covered by Dimmock v Hallett, which states that advertising hyperbole is something that is not intended to be relied upon. That is legally considered a puff, and does not become a term in the contract like a true representation of the product. My point still stands if the later footage was "downgraded" as then CD would have done everything in their power short of emailing every single person who preordered their game (which would be economically unfeasible), which will have discharged their Spice Girls obligation and negate claims against them. Look up the judgment in Carlill v Carabolic Smoke Ball Co if you need some further information on what constitutes a puff or not.
>>319209148
I felt attached to the Baron and Vesemir.
>>319209148
fucking hell man stop projecting.
>>319210787
>>319214978
Thank you for fighting shitposting, lawfag.
I will remember your service with tenderness in my heart.
>>319215474
You cannot deny how good the Baron quest was
People had valid motivations to do things, the crones weren't just LE BIG EVIL THATS WANTS TO KILL EVERYONE, they helped people out in their own twisted ways
Really liked it, I don't think any quest in witcher 3 comes close to it
>>319214978
Puff is different than saying something as fact.
They even directly stated they downgraded the graphics in a measurable way.
It would be puff, if they said it was the best looking game on the market.
What they did was have an agent of the company in an interview make a statement not just that their game would not only not be downgraded, which was a lie, and proven to be so. But that it would improved upon.
And you are a moron who needs to leave, because they don't need to make a mass email, they could have released a tweet saying that they had to downgrade the graphics. Unless you want to say a tweet was infeasible.
If you are a lawyer you need to be disbarred. But I doubt that because you are literally too stupid to understand.
>>319215993
He's literally a CDPR employee who's paid to do this. Do you honestly believe that a lawyer just happened to be in a thread with Copy Pasted Law Information on hand.
>>319210787
>>319214978
Is 100% provably a shill, CDPR hires people to deflect the discussion.
>>319216553
>BOO HOO IT'S A SHILL
>has nothing to refute it
>provably
Ok retard please "provably" show us it's a CDPR marketer and not just someone a lot smarter or knowledgeable about law compared to you.
>>319216553
M80 I'm not even a lawyer, just a second year Bachelor of Laws student.Drawing all this from my Contract Law cheat sheet
>>319216214
You haven't citied a single fucking case in your arguments, just made a bunch of unsubstantiated claims and then called me an idiot for using proper legal arguments. A puff is defined as an statement made for advertising purposes that the reasonable person would not believe. The reasonable person, being familiar with standard practice of games development would know that statement is a puff as it's unrealistic to say the least.
Also, yes a tweet would have fulfilled their obligations but so did the video. The fact remains, you could take them to court but you'd lose, badly to boot. There's just no legal or policy reason that a Judge should impose liability in this circumstance, particually when the gameplay and other aspects of the game remained the same, or at least very similar (enhanced gore notwithstanding). If the finished game had been totally different from that, like an FPS or some shit then you'd have a better chance but as it stands you wouldn't have a legal leg to stand on.
>>319216553
>Shitposter butthurt about getting BTFO
You should be used to it by now. What ever happened to W3 NEVER EVER winning GOTY?
>>319203181
Rolling!
>Still being cut nerds
>>319217794
I'm saving all your posts for the next time he makes a thread. Because he will. He's a huge autistic faggot.
>>319218468
Not worth it if I'm honest. If it becomes a copypasta then it's basically pointless because he'll just say hurr durr copy paste shilleven though he already says that.
>>319210787
>>319214978
>>319217794
Thank you based anon. This faggot admits to spending time on /vg/ and reddit, and uses Skyrim as an example of a great RPG. He's pure cancer but no matter how hard he gets BTFO he always comes back.
>>319218950
He can't, because all he does is copy paste >>319203717 has the link for proof. Same memes every day, he always claims Skyrim's sales and userbase as proof it's better, and he's the one who always shit up Witcher threads, or if there isn't any, he makes his own.
>>319207187
TW3 would get mods if those talentless hacks put some effort into the mod tools.
>>319203181
The people who criticize the combat need to play more and try a sign based build. The enemies also get more interesting later in the game. The first time I fought a gargoyle outside was fucking terrifying, and I don't fucking see how you are supposed to fight that fucker without quen.
2015 is the year reviewers finally realized gameplay is irrelevant.
This threads still going on, oh well least it's slow.
>>319201101
the story was garbage too
2>1>3
>>319203181
I wanna be a wizard.
>>319203181
give me the powah
>>319219683
Except they have mods faggot. https://youtube.com/watch?v=PPMVQiDv62c
>>319221323
I didn't say it doesn't have, i'm saying the mod tools are complete shit.
>>319201101
Almost all RPGs have garbage combat system, so yes.
When compared shit shooting, vats and that joke of battle system from Bloodborne, yes it deserves.When compared to MGSV i'd take that instead, thought
>>319221825
You can just say BB was too hard for you.
>>319222050
How is it hard, you self heal just by counter hiting everything the game is all a joke.
>>319222243
You're not gonna heal everything even if you land every hit in the 2 second recovery window.
Still doesn't make the game as easy as having Quen.
>>319221825
BB has good combat but it's limited by 30fps. Still better than Witcher's combat.
>>319216553
dude srly you need help, come on talk to us tell us whats happening to you. whats wrong, you are too obsessed with TW3, are you deflecting something? we are here for you and we love you anon
>>319223346
thanks aniki
>>319203181
roll
>>319201101
Yes, the core mechanics of an RPG isn't is combat. If it was an action RPG or some hybrid I would agree, but the rest of the shit in the Witcher 3 makes up for it.
Why are we talking about combat? Characters can't even walk/run properly. Riding on the horse is a sure thing not to win any race.
>>319208241
Witcher was never about combat, ever played 1 and 2? Faggot.
