Unpopular opinion coming through:
SGU > Stargate (1994) < SG-1 > SGA
Agreed. SGU was fantastic.
>>71279817
More like factually and universally wrong opinion coming through.
The real ranks are as follows:
Stargate > SG1 > SGA > SGU
>>71279899
SGA is unwatchable I hate that colonel with the whinny voice and long hair. They added too much camp, nobody who enjoyed the movie could watch that shit.
>>71279919
Yep, which shows just how bad Universe is.
>>71279955
No, SGU fixed everything.
>>71279817
I liked the new Independence Day.
>>71279973
SGU fucked everything.
Until roughly halfway through S2, the writers didn't realize nobody wanted space opera. They wanted SG1 with less, whiny characters and more interesting, varied plot lines.
>>71280001
OK.
>>71279817
Stargate : McKay > everythang
>>71280058
Mckays actor should be lynched. Everything, and I mean everything this dog touches turns to utter shit.
>>71280058
>Rooooodney!
>>71279817
If I liked TNG would I like the Stargate shows?
>>71280112
Some episodes sure.
If you like TNG watch SG1
If you like DS9 watch SGU
If you VOY watch SGA
>>71280080
I'm literally triggered right now.
Did you know that the humans sgu meets, their descendents are the ones who created the drone ships?
Did you know that those who decided to renew their contact would have been the ones that don't die from the freezing process?
Did you know that the fucker still won't tell us what the cosmic background radiation signal was all about?
>>71280144
Kill yourself rodney.
>>71280112
It's more or less the same thing, instead of the enterprise it's Stargate Command/SGC in another galaxy/on the most fucking advanced starship that was just abandoned.
>>71280164
>Did you know that the fucker still won't tell us what the cosmic background radiation signal was all about?
It was god telling us he exists. You're welcome.
>>71280080
>Mckays actor should be lynched.
keked when I read this, totally inappropriate
>>71280058
Best episode.
>>71280139
>>71280181
Thanks guys
>>71280269
The groundhog day from SG1 is the best episode.
>>71280311
Well the implication I made by quoting the previous anon was that it was the best Rodney episode.
>>71279817
I liked SGU, the darker and more serious tone was a nice change. However the desire to be BSG in the first season meant the story arcs were too long and too boring to begin with.
Whole episodes on finding food, then water, then power... Fine this stuff needs to happen but as the main plot of an episode where nothing else seems to happen?
The second season was heading in the right direction by lightening up a bit, getting glimpses of what the Lanteans were up to before they turned into lazy gods was fun, it's just a shame they didn't do all this interesting stuff earlier.
>>71280486
I also loved that the ship was literally the pinnacle of Lantean technology, I mean, flying into a star to scoop up some energy like ice cream was pretty fun.
>>71279817
Why do you refuse to rank SGA in line with the movie and Universe? Are you a coward?
>>71280520
Yep, felt as excited as Rush discovering all this shit.
>>71280080
Hey I liked that one movie he did where he killed a guy I think? It was funny damn it.
>>71280520
>Lantean
The Lanteans are just the people living in Atlantis in Pegasus after it left earth, it's not the name of the whole race.
SGU was like being a fan of Farmer Joe's Apples and one day receiving a box from Farmer Joe that contains oranges instead. Because he wants orange audience.
Not that I can't appreciate oranges, but I wanted apples. Farmer Joe lost lots of customers who did not want oranges at all. And people who like oranges never thought to look for them in a crate labelled "Farmer Joe's Apples". And those oranges were not that good, because Joe was growing apples all his career and doesn't quite get the technology. Farmer Joe is a fool.
>>71280659
>you wouldn't download an orange
>>71280486
This
The idea of SGU was pretty good, and had a lot of potential. But they just fucked up the execution of it. It was just starting to find its feet when they axed it. Same thing happened with Dollhouse.
Also, SGU had a "eagles fly frodo to mordor" with the portal stones. Have Daniel Jackson use the portal stones and he and Rush, and hell possibly McKay and/or Carter figure the whole ship out...
Then they could have made Star Trek in the Stargate universe, with them using the full abilities of the ship to get home
>>71280659
The quality apples I'd come to enjoy in the 90s were no sustained in production. I like oranges just as much as apples, and the apples were rotten so I happily opted for oranges when they became available.
>>71280058
I used to love stargate Atlantis, but now as an adult I think it's unwatchable because Rodney has a meltdown like every episode
>>71280749
Nah, the problem was mostly infrastructure and resource shortage. Expertise was never the problem.
>>71280112
There are two difference. Stargate characters are non-nosense military men and not some kind of philosophers and there's very few rubber forehead aliens.
There's mostly humans, humans who were transported to other planets by aliens, humans infested by mind-controlling alien parasites, humans engineered by mind-contolling alien parasites, aliens that look like humans because they made humans look like them and aliens who look like humans because they were also made by previous aliens.
>>71280886
>no-nosense military men
Someone hasn't seen SGA, it's The Office in space. Watch it if you doubt me, that's a pretty accurate way to describe it.
>>71281094
Agree with you there.
SG1 had alot of humor but just as much drama to level it out.
SGA is packed with quips and humor every episode. Rarely any drama that doesn't feel forced. This is all because of rodney though. Remove him and no more humor, just straight up SG1 on an island.
>>71281141
>SGA
>rarely any drama that not forced
Replicators with an agenda and resources
Todd
>>71281141
>>71281264
>caring about faggy drama
>>71279817
Maximum wrong you retard.
>>71279817
>>71279851
Drink more semen faggot
>>71280164
Jesus that's awful and you think this is good quality? Wtf is wrong with you?
>>71280486
Just go watch BSG
>>71281264
I like when Tayla sung
>>71280787
He's under an ungodly amount of stress, though. They make him do fucking everything and come up with all the ideas.
>>71281843
So he represents whites in society?
SG1 = SGA > Stargate (1994) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> SGU
This is not debatable.
>>71281283
>I was born in 1999
>>71281916
Was Prince your dad?
>>71281912
GO sit in the corner.
>>71281945
I will goa'uld sit in the corner :^)
>>71279817
this god damn mini arc, god damn that was so good.
Novus had so much potential!
>>71279817
Did you know that the Stargate TV series is not originally a Sy-Fy concept?
It actually began on Showtime and aired Friday nights with Odyssey 5 and Jeremiah (reverse Children of Men). Back then Stargate often had nudity in it, these episodes weren't shown on Sci-Fi channel or were edited.
>>71282579
That pilot episode when Apophis stripped Sha're bare was always pleasant to watch. Nothing like some random nudity on TV.
Now the creators have backtracked and said it felt out of place and wasn't part of their original vision, it was a suggestion of the network to make it more adult. Considering that's how it began it's odd that it turned more family friendly in the end.
>>71282905
He stripped a female US airman topless as well.
Do you know how much shit the military keeps getting because of the sexual harassment of their soldiers, sailors etc.
I would love to see the original pilot air today, the shit storm would be lovely.
>>71282948
that's my waifu, but she was never nude because all of SGU was on Sy-Fy, not Showtime.
>>71283043
She was nude in Masters of Horror though
>>71283088
She was indeed.
Do you know how many women are blessed with a body like hers? Not many.
>giant fucking tits
>strong amazonian body
>lovely photogenic face
>former ballet dancer
>It's an SG1 goes through the wormhole and arrives in Canada episode
>>71279817
Last bit of SGU was shaping up to be some GOAT shit.
Wish they hadn't fucked up the first like 24 episodes though and tanked it.
>>71283131
A ballet dancer with tits? That's a fuckin' unicorn right there.
>>71279851
It wasn't even stargate.
>>71283439
Too much teen drama and who the fuck though the lucian alliance was a good idea?
>>71284322
The producers obviously. Those old geezers who know what young people want to watch.
If nothing else the show had a really great set, I loved the dirty but functional aesthetic.
