THAT'S IT.
The debate is officially over.
ALIENS > ALIEN
>>69166021
based tomatoes are right as always.
Aliens confirmed for patrician, alien confirmed for pleb garbage. Alienfags absolutely btfo. Kill yourselfs
>>69166021
>not ranking both GOAT for different reasons but equal amounts
>he uses RT
.georgecostanza.jpg
they are both 10/10
>>69166021
More proof Disney buys RT critics.
>Alien>Aliens
>Terminator>Terminator 2
>critic rating 97%, audience 3.9
>critic rating 98%, audience 3.8
NOTHING IS SETTLED.
>>69166279
Nothing wrong here just superior taste
>its a "posters from websites that begin with r prefer the quipfest over the masterpiece" episode
>>69166021
>scientist joint vs. space marines ćinema
The choice was always obvious.
>>69166021
Until Aliens gets as many reviews as Alien, nothing is settled.
There are almost twice as many reviews for Alien and it managed to remain just 1% behind.
It's honestly a better film. Aliens is great though.
RIDLEYFAGS BTFO
Cameron > your opinion
>>69166021
Normies were a mistake.
They're very different animals.
However one thing that surprised me on rewatching both is that in parts Aliens actually looks weirdly cheap.
Like it was filmed on one very crammed soundstage and the budget didn't live up to Cameron's vision.
It's especially apparent before the final showdown when Ripley goes into the elevator.
Alien being a much smaller film, kinda felt more polished and "real".
Alien 10/10
Aliens 7/10
Alien3 8/10
Prometheus 7/10
AR 3/10
AVP 3/10
>not accepting that both are different, but perfect in their own right
Plebs.
>muh space marines
>muh action family
>muh shooty shooty explosions
Aliens is garbage. It killed the franchise before it even became a franchise.
Cock
>>69167413
were you born with half a brain?
>>69167458
This x1000David Fincher did nothing wrong
>>69166387
>>69166686
>>69166807
>>69167413
fucking contrarians
critics agree that Aliens is better
>>69167413
This. AR deserves at least 4/10, and AVP 5/10, but otherwise this.
>>69167472
Cameron fags btfo
Undeniable truth here that Aliensfags are little fucking plebs
>>69167458
>>69167503
I'm a famous director, and I know for a fact that the original Alien is better.
>>69166304
This
>>69167503
HaAHhhahHahHah$-$$-$$hahHhaa
Cameronfags BLoWN tHE FUCK OUT
>muh RT rating
>>69166021
Retrospective Critics are retarded, I hate Rotten Tomatoes for allowing this.
Critics should be aggregated with reviews +- 1 year of Premiere of criticized film.
>>69167413
What in the fuck? I like Alien 3 just fine but it's by NO MEANS better than Aliens. You have to be out of your goddamn mind, you fucking retard. You fucking moron. You goddamn fucking idiot. Fucking hang yourself.
But I respect your opinion.
>>69167638
Not him, but Alien 3 is way better than Aliens. It at least tries to be a horror movie, and to tell some kind of story that isn't just shooty shooty explosions, and to make the alien creature actually threatening again.
>>69167693
Except Aliens isn't a horror movie nor does it try to be one.
>>69167728
It's shit action shit horror and shit scifi. What's the point in not having horror in an r rated alien movie. Fuck off Cameron cuck
Screw newt she's annoying as fuck
>>69166304
3.9 = 78% and the average between critic and audience ratings is 87.5
3.8 = 76% and the average is just 87
so alien technically wins
Where did this "aliens is bad" meme come from? I prefer Alien btw
>>69166021
both a 9/10
I think that's fair
Sci-fi action horror is better than sci-fi suspense horror, I agree.
>>69166021
JIM
I
M
>>69167458
>Aliens is garbage. It killed the franchise before it even became a franchise.
He's right you know
>>69166021
Is Alien 3 Assembly Cut worth watching?
Aliens is such a shit movie that ruins almost every aspect of the previous film.
>>69169520
Absolutely.
>>69169520
It's good if you enjoyed Alien. I've never seen the theatrical version of it though.
>>69169520
>>69169572
Assembly is about Medieval Europe symbolically, one of the first scenes in assembly shows someone with a horse and cart, not exactly futuristic space movie now, huh?
>>69166279
>Alien = Aliens
>Terminator 2 > Terminator
>Predator >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Predator 2
>>69166021
But the people desperately defending BvS told me that critics are plebs who know nothing, so wouldn't Aliens' higher rating prove that it's actually worse?
>>69169659
But they are only plebs, when they disagree with you, silly
Giger>>>>>>>>
>this thread.
Sure feels like DC is here.
>>69166021
having watched all four alien movies a year ago for the first time, I would say that comparing the first two movies is a totally wrong approach
the movies are not even in the same genre if you ask me. alien was more of a "horror" movie with a creepyness factor to it while aliens was mostly an action movie. both are really great movies though
>Alien=xenomorph is a horrible, terrifying organism, an engineer does all she can to survive, watching her coworkers die one by one. The xeno is an ambush predator, stalking its way close, then appearing out nowhere like a fucking horrendous spider, a real predatory animal.
>Aliens:xenomorphs get mowed down left and right, 400+lb creatures scurrying about like insects, not scary at all. Hurr durr muh grrll pwer.
Aliens took a great ideal and dumbed it down for the unwashed masses.
>>69169459
Damn, how can one man be so based?
>>69169644
And Robocop Robocop 2
>>69169644
Terminator 2 is shit loaded with cringey dialogue and a time travel plot that doesn't work.
>>69172074
Hurr durr grrl pwer too.
>>69166021
It's within statistical margin of error, so the debate must rage on <:^)
>>69166021
>The kind of people who rate alienS between 80 and 100 are the same people who don't realize they are different movies.
They are simply confusing the two.
I guarantee you.
>>69166021
2 different genres.
like saying captain america winter soldier
is better then Scream 3
>>69166021
> RT
> Anything but Plebs
The reverse is the patrician choice.
>>69167693
>shooty shooty explosions
I recognize you from every single aliens thread. Saying "shooty shooty explosions" just makes you sound like a fucking mongoloid.
>>69167693
>It at least tries to be a horror movie
It also failed. Trying isn't the same as actually achieving. Stop sucking Fincher's cock, even he hates the movie
>>69171292
>where_do_you_thing_we_are.jpg
>>69169459
I just... I just want to hate him but I can't.
>>69166094
Here is your (you).
>>69169459
Based Jim
>>69167413
awful fucking taste
try
Alien 7/10,
Aliens 8/10
Alien3 4/10
Prometheus 5/10
AR 5/10
AVP 3/10
Alien was a bit of a generic slasher in space, it lacks the depth or complexity to hold your interest, especially on second viewing
Aliens is where the series peaked, but alien 3 killed it
Prometheus had an awful fucking script and nothing going for it except the cgi set design and camer work
Resurrection had a better plot than Prometheus but it feels low budget, rushed, and silly at times
AVP does nothing with its premise, its just all around lazy
Overall the series wasnt that great to begin with, it never lived up to its potential and similar to star wars the world fans build around it is the best part of the whole franchise.
