sp-tier thread but it has to be done:
>soundtrack
>acting
>story
>casting
>rewatching
>personal rating out of 10
bonus: which had the shittier prequels
>>68817571
>soundtrack
LotR
>acting
LotR
>story
SW
>casting
tie
>rewatching
LotR
>bonus: which had the shittier prequels
SW
>soundtrack
LotR
>acting
LotR
>story
LotR
>casting
LotR
>rewatchability
LotR
>soundtrack
LotR/10
>acting
LotR/10
>story
LotR/10
>casting
LotR/10
>rewatching
LotR/10
>>68817571
>>soundtrack
SW
>>acting
Lotr
>>story
SW
>>casting
Lotr
>>rewatching
tie
The Hobbit movies have zero redeeming qualities.
>>68817571
Both are garbage for manchildren.
>>68818125
Wowgreat argument fagtronyou sure convinced me with those hot opinions
I like Star Wars, but c'mon, LotR outdoes it completely on practically every level.
>>68817571
>soundtrack
SW
>acting
SW
>story
SW
>casting
SW
>rewatching
SW
>personal rating out of 10
SW: 9/10
LotR: 6.5/10
The Hobbit movies were infinitely more shittier than the Star Wars prequels.
>>68817571
>soundtrack
lotr
>acting
lotr
>story
lotr
>casting
lotr
>rewatching
lotr
star wars BTFO?
>>68818100
>The Hobbit movies have zero redeeming qualities.
Ian McKellen
Christopher Lee
The music
and quite frankly much more. If you look for it you can see the work of those who tried to make a worthy adaption of it. The final product was not up to them to decide on though. Ian for example apparently walked around with a copy of the book calling the script out on the more bullshit lines on set.
>>68817571
>soundtrack
SW tied with LotR
>acting
LotR
>story
SW slightly ahead of LotR
>casting
SW tied with LotR
>rewatching
SW
Thinking about it now I think both trilogies are equal and I honestly give both 10/10
The hobbit trilogy was shittier than the star wars prequels
Anyone who says the acting in Star Wars is better than LOTR is just flat out retarded.
>>68817571
>soundtrack
LotR
>acting
LotR
>story
LotR
>casting
LotR
>rewatching
LotR
10/10
Both were equally shit
>>68817571
>soundtrack
>acting
>story
>casting
All LOTR
>rewatching
Tie
>personal rating
Not rating, but to me, Star Wars has so much to do with growing up that all the technical superiority of LOTR makes it only better filmmaking, while SW means more.
>bonus
The Hobbit is far shittier. Fight me. But don't actually, because I don't care enough to.