[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Was Winter Soldier even that Good?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 140
Thread images: 22
File: wintersoldier.jpg (69 KB, 493x720) Image search: [Google]
wintersoldier.jpg
69 KB, 493x720
All I remember was Sam Jackson needlessly faking his death and escaping by cutting pavement or something

Cap jumping 30ft in the air to punch a F35 into an explosion

and a Cap/BW talking to a dead nazi in a 1950s computer


shit was jank, yo
>>
I liked it the first time I watched it.
The second time the movie felt clumsy.

It's good compared to the other Marvel movies.
>>
It's one of those films that gets worse and worse the more you watch it.
>>
What if Cap's shield hit you in the balls?
>>
>>68244173
Baltroc in the Opening fight scene was ace
Him meating Falcon was ace
Fight scenes were fucking Ace
Armin Zola being a real fucking character was awesome they used him perfectly the end Cap vs Bucky fight was amazing
>>
>>68244173

Saw it the first time, it was a 7/10 max. Not sure why everyone likes it, but then again I'd rate IM3 an 8 on entertainment factor alone.
>>
no man-ant was better
>>
it's a good political thriller for our generation
>>
File: Manant.jpg (54 KB, 650x720) Image search: [Google]
Manant.jpg
54 KB, 650x720
>>68244342
>man-ant
>>
File: man spider.jpg (38 KB, 500x334) Image search: [Google]
man spider.jpg
38 KB, 500x334
>>68244342
Man-ant ain't got shit on man spider.
>>
it was fun
>>
File: 1460493684940.png (97 KB, 735x608) Image search: [Google]
1460493684940.png
97 KB, 735x608
>>68244447
>muh fun
>le turn off your brain bro xd
>>
>>68244173
I don't remember any of these things except Sam Jackson faking his death. Come to think of it, that's all I really remember.
>>
The problem is nothing happens for most of the movie. Seriously. It's just them driving around for half the movie.
>>
File: Winter Soldier.webm (3 MB, 1280x533) Image search: [Google]
Winter Soldier.webm
3 MB, 1280x533
The action wasn't CGI'd to shit
>>
>>68244508
It had some of the best fight scenes

Political message that isn't even hidden, which I thought was cool too. "Give up your freedom because of fear".

Also Bucky was cool
>>
>>68244173
marvel movies are if you watch in theaters, then great who cares. catch it on FX like the 30 times they show it on tv. you buy it on dvd/blu ray, it will def collect dust on your shelf, which is really every comic book movie out
>>
The action sequences annoyed me. They were all almost cool but then ruined by absolutely shitty direction .

It's like they planned out a cool elevator fight and then gave a spastic monkey the camera

The comedic bathroom fight in Jack Reacher was better. Based tom told the director how to do it. Keep the distance and don't use as many cuts.

Sam Jackson car chase was cool...then the director just edits it together in the worst possible way.

It's actually not a bad flick overall but could use better directing and shorten it up
>>
>>68244173
Disney pays critics to fool people to believe that it was good.
https://es.scribd.com/doc/308457900/Tweet-List
>>
Everything is good until the third act.
>>
>>68244636
DCuck
>>
File: 1409544794152.webm (3 MB, 1000x419) Image search: [Google]
1409544794152.webm
3 MB, 1000x419
good cinematography
>>
>>68244173
Great for the first half. Hated the part where it goes from interesting to "Nah, don't worry, none of the bad guys are American, they're all secret Hydra agents."
>>
>>68244858
If the shield can cut into that wing shouldn't it also slice his fingers off?
>>
>>68244878
>butthurt DCuck
>>
>>68244858
>Would it have been better if the aircraft was like
>"wtf, did you just throw this giant frisbee at me? I'm supposed to be an aircraft, not a dog."
>>
>>68244902
you forgot the part where he's a superhuman soldier DCuck

>>68244962
nice meme DCuck
>>
>>68244508
>TONY HELP
>>
>>68244962
I want this meme and the one who created it to die.
>>
>>68244858
Fuuuck. Cap is so cool.

Also the best line of the movie..
>Before we get started, Does anyone want to get out?
>>
>>68244508
see >>68244858

Look I don't care for the "cgi is bad" meme, it's really not. But believe it or not, that's not Chris Evans.
>>
>>68245032

Don't you ever make a filename like that again.
>>
File: pepe evans.jpg (6 KB, 188x252) Image search: [Google]
pepe evans.jpg
6 KB, 188x252
>>68245147
Make me.
>>
Can't remember. Fell asleep in the theater, that's how shitty it was.
>>
>>68244302

IM3 was actually kind of funny and original. Winter Soldier was just generic as fuck. It wasn't much better than Thor 2 in my opinion
>>
>>68244858
Why is it that his shield can cut through metal but doesn't cut guys in half when he throws it at them?
>>
one thing I really like is the choreography and the action. Surpisingly brutal and has more weight to it, unlike previous Marvel movies.

And I really like how clear the motivation from every characters in here. It's practically a great character-driven movie.
>>
File: 1460582892361.jpg (104 KB, 665x607) Image search: [Google]
1460582892361.jpg
104 KB, 665x607
>>68245201
>DCuck in charge of not being butty-blasted
>>
File: The Good King Harold.jpg (67 KB, 721x960) Image search: [Google]
The Good King Harold.jpg
67 KB, 721x960
>>68245172

Last chance, Anon.
>>
File: 1387212589269.jpg (263 KB, 890x890) Image search: [Google]
1387212589269.jpg
263 KB, 890x890
>>68245201
Why would you even go in the first place then?
>>
>>68244858
hahahaha what the fuck
>>
File: img-thing.jpg (18 KB, 300x300) Image search: [Google]
img-thing.jpg
18 KB, 300x300
>mfw I like DC and Marvel
>mfw I enjoyed BvS and Winter Soldier
>mfw I just want capekino viewers to unite and take over /tv/
>>
File: 1406222649846.jpg (45 KB, 482x750) Image search: [Google]
1406222649846.jpg
45 KB, 482x750
>>68245392
Never happen. Too many Edgelords, Contrarians and austists.
>>
File: hsaog.jpg (36 KB, 549x549) Image search: [Google]
hsaog.jpg
36 KB, 549x549
>>68244173
not gonna lie: i hated it

however, nobody is to blame but /tv/. it was a retarded actioner, and i should have know it, if not by /tv/ parroting how it was "smart spionage movie". hard to believe how naive i was back then.
>>
>>68244858
my favorite action scene of any marvel movie desu
>>
>>68245392
/co/ is more your thing
>>
>>68244173
>shit was jank, yo

Is this Millennial coolspeak?
>>
>>68244902
>>68245211
SHUT UP
>>
No it was fucking garbage and is nigh unwatchable more than once.
>inb4 muh 8 minutes of quality action in a 2.5 hour movie
>>
>>68244173
>Sam Jackson needlessly faking his death
It wasn't needles. It stopped them from coming after him again and finishing the job.
>>
>>68245627
stop samefagging DCuck
>>
don't know why it was so highly praised. bethesda fallout tier writing.
>>
>>68245661
wasn't samefagging kid i fucking dare you to argue for this movie.
>>
File: 1458657890174.gif (637 KB, 200x100) Image search: [Google]
1458657890174.gif
637 KB, 200x100
>>68245627
>>68245687
>>68245694
DCuck pls go back to BLACKED.com
>>
>>68245425
>/tv/ parroting how it was "smart espionage movie"

Yeah, it was a pretty good movie in my opinion, but nowhere near as great as people make it out to be.
>>
>muh NSA Hydra analogy
>>
>>68244858
there are only two movie sins that matter
dont be boring
don't be stupid

this scene might be the dumbest scene in the MCU

that or grown men whispering hail hydra or some shit
>>
>>68244238
The only thing clumsy is Hydra's plan. It needed more subtlety. Like if Project Insight had remote stealth drones that could kill and make it look like accidents or natural causes. Then Hydra could have slowly killed all opposition without anyone even realizing it. Just one tweak and it's perfect.
>>
File: 1460452882956.png (187 KB, 375x317) Image search: [Google]
1460452882956.png
187 KB, 375x317
>>68245767
>>68245790
>being a DCuck
>>
>>68245425
>smart spionage movie
there's literally no espionage
>>
>>68245790
>don't be stupid
That's wrong though, stupid is fine. If you couldn't have stupid, you couldn't have superheroes in the first place.
>>
HYDRA has created a world so chaotic that the people are finally ready...to accept memes
>>
>>68245826
>samefagging this hard

The biggest mistake this movie made was not having enough Cap vs Bucky shit.
>>
>>68244962
KEK
>>
It is literally underage Redditor politics: the movie.

It's just >muh nsa and the retarded liberal meme that the government shouldn't surveil metadata. It's the reddit delusion of not understanding no one is going to fucking read the content of the inane trite that is your communications, but algorithmic monitoring of metadata will diminish risk of crime and terrorism
>>
>>68246134
>DCuck on suicide watch
>>
>>68246134
I thought it was about an old Nazi-founded secret society trying to take over the world and kill the heroes.
>>
>>68246134
You should pay attention to the big black cock inside Snyder's anus.
>>
>>68244173
Whenever you have to bring in nazis as the villains, you know you have a weak plot.
>>
>>68246548
>nazis
They are a splinter group of the nazis that went rogue.
Hell, they even tried to destroy the nazis too in TFA, one of the objectives of their Tesseract bombs was Berlin, and they killed the one nazi officer that discovered it.
>>
It fell apart in the third act like most Marvel movies do. It is not a great movie for repeat viewings either.
>>
It wasn't, but it had a 90% on rottentomatoes so people pretended to like it.
>>
>>68246602
nazis so extreme even other nazis think they're evil
literally worse than hitler
>>
>>68247967
Nah, they didn't have any nazi ideology apart from sharing Hitler's love for occultism.
>>
>>68246548
Captain America, the character who became famous for punching hitler.
>why is he fighting nazis?
>>
Legit best Marvel movie
>>
Watched it just yesterday. Thought it was really good, way better than that fucking turd iron man 3. Now i gotta catch up on age of ultron
>>
It's biggest strength is Cap who I like because he's the only superhero who acts like a superhero from the MCU. Everyone else is either boring or Quiper McQuiperson.
>>
>>68244375

>tfw someone else knows about the aquabats super show
>>
>>68244173
Don't worry, Wonder Woman will be worse.
>>
>>68246548
>Captain America, WWII hero. Fought Nazis
>Captain America's arch rival is a Nazi General and splinter group of Nazi scientists turned cultists
>His girlfriend has a show dedicated to hunting and fighting said group.

God guys, why is he still fighting nazis. It's not like they're part of Captain America's long history.
>>
>>68244173
that's way more than I remembered anon good for you
>>
>>68244465
>fun isn't a valid praise anymore
>Movies literally cannot be fun anymore
>>
>>68244300
>Armin Zola being a real fucking character

expositionman

then he tries to kill cap with missiles despite being on a anti-missile bunker
>>
>>68244508
The fights actually felt tense, like bucky could kill cap
>>
>>68244508

Was there ever any sunshine like that? I just remember the whole thing being grim, grey, and overcast.
>>
>>68244858
This is how I know the movie's good on some level at least because just watching this had me genuenly engaged instantly
>>
>>68252028

"Any sunshine in this" I meant.
>>
>>68248050
Not saying much, but ya it is.
>>
>>68250840
movies are like waterboarding, this is why people hate fun movies. you know it's a shitty movie when you're laughing out loud.

everyone knows laughing out loud doesn't happen any more, it's just a saying like when in roam.

to be a good movie it has to be boring, slow, symbolic, and all about lighting and camera angles, with raw audio. wide screen but with letter boxes helps too.

less music the better
>>
>>68244173
>Only few quips
>Solid plot
>Actual struggle that is not determined by powerlevels,but by character interaction
>good fight scenes
It's pretty good compared to the other Marvel movies
>>
>>68244173
It was on par with the first Iron Man hence putting the movie in a whole other league above the rest of the MCU garbage that were released up to that point.
>>
>>68252372
This.

1. Cap 2
2. Iron Man 1
3. Ant-Man
4. Guardians of the Galaxy
5. The Incredible Hulk

6. Cap 1

7. rest of MCU garbage (including the two avengers films)
>>
>>68244465

This wasn't Pacific Rim, which is the only time people ever used "turn your brain off" unironically. One was an absolute disappointing shitfest with bad acting and writing featuring nobodies, and the other one wasn't. If you can't tell which is which, you should be put down like an animal to benefit mankind.
>>
>>68244508

I'm not really a "fan" of either, but this was pretty fucking badass. I know which movie I'll be watching tomorrow. Marvel might have a new viewer.
>>
>>68244534

>Bucky was cool

Bucky without the eyewear, but with the mouth-mask was an absolute fucking legend. He was intimidating as fuck.
>>
>>68252664

I might not agree with the bottom half of your list, but thank you for acknowledging Iron Man 1 as one of the best,as the rest of this board shits on it because it's a meme to hate RDJ. That movie was absolute GOAT Marvel capeshit.
>>
File: image.jpg (33 KB, 440x500) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
33 KB, 440x500
>>68244173
>It's a "snyderlard revisits history in a damage control stupor" thread
oh wew
>>
Just marathoned winter solider
It was alright for a cape film in that it had an actual plot

Scarlet is usually pretty attractive but every close up of black widows face made her look ugly. Maybe they uglied her up for the movie??

the action scenes are kind of shit and the film goes on to long. Overall a B plus.

I didn't get Gary Shandling in the movie. Was it a joke? Why was he in it for 2 scenes and then arrested?

I know Winter Solider is from the comics but its still dumb. Oh Captain that guy you knew from 50 years ago is also a soviet era super agent...for some dumb reason.
Kind of like how Elektra just happens to be daredevils gf from college...its just kind of stupid that only works in comics
>>
>>68254975
>Maybe they uglied her up for the movie??
easily the worst haircut she's had, knocks her down a couple of points
>>
>>68254975
>I didn't get Gary Shandling in the movie
He was a character in the MCU, he pops up in Iron Man 2
>>
>>68244173
>as Winter Soldier even that Good?
Yes, it's the greatest superhero movie ever made.
>>
>>68254975

Scarlett has never looked worse in her life than in Winter Soldier, it probably doesn't help that she was VERY pregnant while they were filming, and at least 50% of the scenes with her in it are CGI and/or her stunt double.

It actually bothered me that so many Chris Evans/Scarlett scenes were filmed at shoulder level in Winter Solider, although it was still a great movie.
>>
>>68254975

You had to watch Iron Man 2 to "respect" Gary Shandling showing up as a "secret bad guy" in a later movie, as it all made sense when tied with his aversion to Tony Stark saving the day.
>>
File: 1388176691466.jpg (20 KB, 336x237) Image search: [Google]
1388176691466.jpg
20 KB, 336x237
People say it was 'so good' because the first was so shit. It was just a low tier spy drama / bourne movie with more retarded action scenes.

> tfw Capeshit is discussed unironically on /tv/

Oh how the mighty have fallen.
>>
>>68244173
>Was Winter Soldier even that Good?
No, it was bland as fuck.
>>
>>68255168

>still not comfortable enough in masculinity to admit enjoying modern superhero blockbusters

It's okay anon, I almost sure your mom still believes you when you say you aren't gay.
>>
>>68244858
>>68244508
>cut
>cut
>cut
>cut>cut>cut>cut>cut>cut
>cut
>cut.
>>
>>68255283

You're right, film editing shouldn't be a thing.
>>
>>68245032
AAAHHHH SAVE ME IRONMAN
>>
>>68255349
>implying
>>
>>68255433

>implying I'm not speaking to a 14 yo perma-virgin

My mistake, friendo! Carry on shitposting.
>>
>>68255558
get mad
>>
>>68244173

Not really, if you put it up against most actual spy thrillers it's awful. It only seems good because it's a slight deviation from the exact same movie Marvel makes every time.
>>
>>68244173
No
It had decent fight choreography by capeshit standards but you couldn't see shit because of the MODERN SLEEK FAST EDITING and camera being IN THE ACTION AND VERY CLOSE SO IT FEELS INTENSE
>>
only good MCU movie so far is ant-man
>>
>>68255580

>Use memes in defense of own masculinity

Hello, confirmed plebbit manchild!
>>
>>68255641
kek faggot
>>
>>68244300
>>68251202
You know Zola was in the first one, right?
>>
>>68255580

You know this isn't the doctor who general, right? Maybe you should stick to your own inferior kind.
>>
>>68244508
>cameraman having seizures and he is too close
>cuts less than second apart
what a fucking mess
>>
>>68255580

>"Oh shit, someone smarter than me caught me being a total faggot, better meme back in defense! That'll show em!"
>>
If Cap is so great, why did he bailed on Carter?
>>
File: BTFO.jpg (70 KB, 400x400) Image search: [Google]
BTFO.jpg
70 KB, 400x400
>>68255580

Got em!
>>
>Cap/BW talking to a dead nazi in a 1950s computer

Best scene in the movie, though.

>>>68255168

>People say it was 'so good' because the first was so shit.

Also this. It was ok for what it is, but not nearly as great as neckbeards made it out to be.
>>
>>68255580

>>>/r/eddit
>>
>>68255722
The first was good due to them doing a real good job of explain why Steve Rodgers is Captain America and who he is. It also has a great kind of retro feel to it.

Then the third act comes and pew-pew laz0rs and shit which is all kinda "meh" at best.

Fist half to 2/3 is real good though and a strong piece of storytelling for a rather difficult subject. Really this is part of what raises the bar of Marvel movies is they get their characters and do a good job of translating them to a modern audience.
>>
>>68255580

>nothing intelligent to say in response

Boy, you showed him!
>>
>Damn it, Fury, these drones represent fear, not freedom! Power without oversight is tyranny. The cost of freedom is high but it's a price I'm willing to pay. Maybe I'm too old-fashioned to belong in this world of secrets and spies, but....
>lol nevermind Nazis are behind everything imma go punch em!

A complex modern "political thriller", everyone.
>>
>>68255647

Haha, nothing better than upsetting a sperglord! Poor child.you mad?
>>
File: Guardians-of-the-Galaxy-img.1.jpg (455 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
Guardians-of-the-Galaxy-img.1.jpg
455 KB, 1920x1080
I thought Guardians of the Galaxy was a better, if not the best, Marvel movie

>good use of banter and quips
>good chemistry between all characters, no forced romance/friendship/rivalry
>aside from Thanos, isn't bound by the shitty continuity story of the MCU
>no hamfisted political agenda where the government is evil
>beautiful set design, good uses of CGI, not too many action scenes with bad editing
>>
>>68255283

>that post when underage retards on /tv/ don't understand even the simplest aspect of film-making

Kill yourself, when?
>>
>>68255994
>manipulative insincere emotional moments
>garbage action
>trash sense of humor
i cant even sit through that pos a 2nd time, i would rather watch iron man 3 on loop
>>
>>68255918
How did Hydra being behind it negate the message? Fury still was the one wanting the build them, Hydra just wanted to use them for different reasons.
>>
>>68255647

>oh shit, they noticed I'm a 100% virgin manchild from leddit, better use kek for the first time ever to throw them off
>>
>>68256063
>muh spoonfed origin story
>muh explosions and pew pew
>muh one liners
>>
>>68256069
>2 people debating
>"How does me being a Nazi negate my political message?"
>>
>>68255068
Oh
I saw iron man 2 I guess I just forgot. Easily could have cut him out of the film but I guess it was a cute Easter egg for people who remembered
>>
>>68255618
This
The action scenes were cool
But poorly edited
Should have hired someone who knew what they were doing for those scenes
>>
>>68256222
Fury was a Nazi?

Captain America opposed the idea of such a weapon system because it could be abused. The next day, it gets abused because Hydra infiltrated the government and SHIELD.

It didn't have to be Hydra, it could have just be some president who decides to preemptively kill all Asians or something.
Thread replies: 140
Thread images: 22

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.