Is Cinema Sins the single worst thing in existence?
Yeah. All they do is encourage nitpicking by people who don't understand how movies are made, how stories are written, or even what something as simple as a plot hole is.
>>68234682
>the origin of the creature from It Follows is never explained
>PLOT HOLE!
>this movie sucks.
>>68234592
last time i checked, bronies are still a thing, so no. not by a long shot.
>some set-piece in the background is an object part of an in-joke from another CS video
>sin
>the time travel aspect of Terminator is unrealistic
>SIN
>people are this mad that they can't make money talking about movies like cinemasins
lel
I don't really remember, but I think in the beginning actual flaws were pointed out. Now it just consists of snarky nitpick man trying hard to be funny and clever about stuff that doesn't matter in the slightest.
>this newspaper on screen for 0.02 seconds has something on it
>ding
>>68235139
>It's a "You hate a thing so you must just be jealous of it!" episode
>>68235057
>>68235100
it's almost like cinemasins isn't a literal go to source for all legitimate flaws in movies.
>DC Comics
>>68234930
This man is correct, bronies are worse
>>68234930
Nah, bronies are cringy, but they keep to themselves for the most part. The worst you'll have to endure on an everyday basis is just people with pony avatars.
The current trend of contrarian nitpicking of movies is far more annoying.
I like RedLetterMedia, but I blame them for this plague.
>bitching about every little detail in shit movies
>being an impotent nerd pointing out shit nobody cares about
>not being able to spell in the pithy comments you make
I thought /tv/ would love Cinema Sins.
>>68235225
I miss a world where it wasn't true.
>>68235201
Right, but it's still not funny or clever.
It's kinda funny. Used to actually put effort into the series, but they've ballooned too big for their own good. Now it's just nit pic shit and memes.
Not to mention the spin-offs they've inspired. Cinemasins related or not.BRAND SINS
MUSIC VIDEO SINS
GAMING SINS
>>68235164
IIRC youtube changed their monetization to be based on video length and thats when he went full nitpick with 20 minute videos. Not that it was great before.
>>68235249
RLM isn't really contrarian, though, outside of a few things like Boyhood.
>>68234682
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PnhZXELUmUs
CineFix is like opposite. These guys knows their movies so hardcore I feel ashamed. s-sanpai....
>>68234930
>>68235233
MLP is pure kino
Go back to your Anti-brony Tumblr page
THIS SCENE DOES NOT INCLUDE A LAP DANCE XD
THIS PEN MOVES ON ITSELF BETWEEN CUTS
>>68234682
>All they do is encourage nitpicking by people who don't understand how movies are made,
THIS. I fucking hate this culture that has developed.
>This movie sucks!
>Why?
>point out minor inconsistencies and continuity errors
Fucking dumb
They are now. They used to do horrible movies which was funny.
Now it's like
>Everything wrong with the Godfather in 18mins
>Everything wrong with Back To The Future
>Everything wrong with A Clockwork Orange
It's not even funny. Pointing out mistakes in beloved or critically acclaimed stuff is retarded.
The comments are screaming for actual shit movies for them to destroy, yet never happens anymore.
ITS 2016
BING
The one that always annoyed me was when they sin for putting a country name on screen
>Manchester England. As opposed to Manchester Yemen? BING
This week for instance. Did they do a funny video of a hated movie?
No. They did The Jungle Book. The original Disney movie.
Why? Because the live action one is out and they gotta get that sweet ad revenue.
>>68234592
>>68235522
I wonder what film that was.
>>68235510
Then again so did HISHE and Honest Trailers
>>68234592
its not great and really is a one joke premise.
But the internet is full of unboxing and reaction videos so I'd say there is far worse out there.
I don't hate cinemasins, I hate their little faggoty fanbase that quote the fucking *Ding* noise on YT comments sections, but I guess it's my fault for reading that cancerous shit.
>>68235623
>Honest Trailers
Which is worse than Cinema Sins.
>>68235335
I like their stuff, and I don't think they're contrarians, but as much as I love the Plinkett reviews, they seem to have started this trend where every hack on the internet thought they could be just as witty and interesting simply by nitpicking movies.
It's like all the AVGN ripoffs from ten years ago, only far more cancerous.
>>68235623
HISHE got popular and now only puts out like 3 videos a year.
Suckered everyone in. Got the big money and now abandons their fans.
>>68235678
So the OP is answered with no then?
>>68235488
Really? There are multiple Manchesters in the US.
>>68235623
>I wonder what film that was.
It Follows.
>>68234592
Is water wet?
>>68235734
Yes. But CS is still a close second.
>>68235678
Honest Trailers is ok.
>>68235775
Ah cool
>>68234682
My 14 year old step brother watches their videos and thinks he's a film critic now.
>>68234930
barely
>>68235678
Regardless of whether or not you think they're funny (which neither of them are), Honest Trailers doesn't actively make film discussion worse like Cinema Sins does.
>>68235819
>pandering, easy humor
>back-tracking when they make fun of popular movies as to not upset humorless spergs
No, not really. It's pretty spineless and unfunny.
>>68235913
In a way, it kinda does, in a way opposte to Cinema Sins. They make sure to throw in some kind of reassurance that the movie's still good when they jab at movies they know their fanbase loves. Wouldn't want to make anyone think any movie can have a fault, right?
>>68235705
What I love about the AVGN knockoffs was how ANOTHER genre of critics came out of nowhere and started shitting on guys like DSP and Chris Bores, but those videos became so popular that people started to ripoff those critics as well! Success breeds imitation in all ranges of life.
>>68235920
That really pissed me off about the one for TFA.
>>68235819
Isn't Honest Trailers just a compilation of all the tired jokes the internet made about a movie crammed into a 4 minute video?
>>68235396
It is fucking dumb.
I didn't like The Dark Knight Rises (except for everything involving Bane of course), but every time someone says it sucks because "how did Batman get into a city on lockdown", I die a little inside.
>>68235225
>Detective Comics Comics
This is actually pretty silly though
>>68236058
wait what happened
What is the worst of his schtick?
>something completely innocuous, albeit silly or a little dumb
>HAHAHAHAHA
>>68236258
>>HAHAHAHAHA
I'm gonna stop you right there, because in my head, that sounds like a real human laugh, not the weird, forced thing he does.
>>68236258
>Sinning a movie for mentioning the country a location is in
>The tired lap dance meme
Or the ones where they aren't even sins, just random things he points out. The Watchmen one is particularly bad
>Alternate history meshes with real history
Somehow this is a bad thing
>all these faggots taking CS too seriously
>>68236226
They had two announcers. The normal guy was going on about how awesome it was while the other was talking about how it wasn't original or good. Then at the end they kiss and make up about their favorite things. Basically, they made every effort to cover their ass.
>>68236258
When he sins stuff in movie adaptations that was sticking to the source material. It's unfair to the filmmakers. Watchmen for instance he sins the cutting of scenes between Nite Owl and Silk Spectre fighting muggers and Dr Manhattan being interviewed, even though this was how the scene played out in the comics.
>>68236258
>Reading.
>(Ding.)
>>68237149
The honest trailers guys make other videos, and in those other videos that divided opinion was pretty much their response to the movie. It wasn't faked.
i think he comes to /tv/ and steals all the plotholes that autists keep spamming about
I was watching one of their videos before and they took out a full minute to shill Crunchyroll. I had no idea they were so popular with weeaboos.
I wish i wasn't an unmotivated piece of shit so i could make bank with stupid fucking viral culture
>>68236258
>There are too many accessories in this room
>(hot actress) isn't my girlfriend in this scene!
>X minutes of characters a doing mundane task
>>68235729
Or they realised what they have become and didn't want to continue.
>>68234592
>>68234682
You're not supposed to take it seriously, you morons. I've watched like three of his videos and it's completely obvious. Fuck.
>>68238930
Kill yourself, frogposter.
My comment didn't once mention whether or not I enjoyed Cinema Sins or whether I thought they were funny or even if I took them seriously, my comment was about how they encourage their retarded fanbase to nitpick and act like that's legitimate discussion.
Learn to read, you fucking mongoloid.
>>68238845
lol you're cute
>>68235347
Tumblr is so pro-pony it hurts. The hell are you on about?
DING LOL OLO
I
N
G
THATS A SIN LOL
SUBTRACT A SIN BECAUSE I LIEK IT
Yeah complete cancer
/tv/ doesn't like people who criticize movies unless it's someone from /tv/
>>68235337
Cinefix is one of the few good movie channels on Youtube.
Their "What's the difference" videos are really interesting.
>>68234592
>something actually integral to the plot, but made them think
SIN!
>>68234877
Shit like CS turns normies into wannabe film critics too. I had a friend argue with me about Mad Max not being good because "them not explaining how the apocalypse happened is a huge plot hole".
>monsters university
>video starts
>"Uh, they look weird, but they never explain race"
>BING
>IMMEDIATELY go watch something else
That wasn't funny. I'm not saying it was offensive, it was just not funny. It wasn't a serious criticism, because it was fucking dumb. Can you at least make it halfway through before ya do filler? I know ya have to fill, but c'mon.
Are you faggots seriously butthurt over CS? Moar sins does not equal a bad movie, they've made that painfully clear. It's fucking comedy.
>>68234592
He used to be okay when he was a condensed MST3K throwing snarks at a movie for 3 minutes or so, when he became ''serious'' and started making 20+ minute videos it all went to shit
>>68243482
> It wasn't a serious criticism
It's not meant to be. Are you autistic?
>>68234682
>all they do is encourage nitpicking by people who don't understand how movies are made.
Youjust described /tv/
>>68237210
>It's a it's the same as the source material so it's good faggot
>>68243878
It clearly wasn't trying to be funny
>it's a musical film based on fairy tales
>sins for singing
>sins for fairy tale stuff
ffffffffffffffffff
>CinemaSins
http://youtu.be/NTvBQE6cvVg
>>68243878
I never said it was
>>68234592
They've basically put the idea that cinema is not a visual medium in kids heads. So yes.
It's not meant to be serious criticism.
>>68234592
I literally went to go watch a CS vid about Pixels just because of this thread.
Are you a shill?
>>68234592
Do people not know everything they make is a joke? It's not "real" nitpicking
>>68244451
You can tell it is when he doesn't like the movie
Eg
Mad Max
>Not real crit
Pixels
>Real
Roger Rabbit
>Not real
Transformers
>Real
Star Wars 3
>Real
Man of Steel
>Real
>>68238930
That was the same bullshit excuse Jon Stewart used.
>Here's my actual opinions
>Oh you think they're retarded? Well I don't have to actually defend them because it's just comedy, man! Lighten up!
>>68243010
They literally show and tell how the apocalypse happened in the first moments of the movie!
>>68244231
holy fuck what a pleb, no wonder it got such score with this being the average movie audience
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xKItdQEPW8
>>68244620
I mean yeah but some of the Cinema Sins jokes are completely and blatently nitpicking for the sake of nitpicking
>ITS JUST A PRANK BRO
>>68244231
>people think Stan Lee created Captain America
It triggers me.
>>68234930
I can see how a bleeding heart jew loving liberal would hate MLP.
It beautifully displays all the core tenants of white nationalism and supremacy and it's refreshing to see that in this day and age.
Like, for instance, the episode where Rarity is captured by a malevolent race of dogs pretty much showcases the state of whites in the western world, and teaches us to be cautious about multiculturalism
My Little Pony:Friendship is Magic should be required viewing for any serious white nationalist. It's a shame so many jews want to take it down and constantly berate it.
I realize CS is supposed to be humor and not actual criticism.Aside from the actual fact that they are not funny at all.But videos like >>68244231 just show what a smug pleb he really is, thinking he's a master movie fan.
![CS[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/atwdGQo.png "CS[1].png")
