[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
try and convince me there's an all around better film composer
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 34
File: the man himself.jpg (785 KB, 1144x1400) Image search: [Google]
the man himself.jpg
785 KB, 1144x1400
try and convince me there's an all around better film composer or give me some composers that are on par with him in terms of incredible film scores.
>>
Ennio Morricone
>>
File: Hans_Zimmer_2010.jpg (317 KB, 1532x1916) Image search: [Google]
Hans_Zimmer_2010.jpg
317 KB, 1532x1916
>>
>>68172330
Thomas Newman
Danny Elfman
Hanz Zimmer
>>
>>68172330
>Expecting me to know composers based on what they look like
>>
>>68172416
It's John Williams you dope
>>
>>68172387
>>68172415

>hans zimmer
>on par with Williams

>>68172416
anyone who's not a pleb knows what HE looks like.
>>
>>68172446
It's a meme to hate Zimmer.
>>
>>68172415
Also John Powell and perhaps Giacchino.
>>
>>68172469
i've hated him since i saw batman begins.
>>
>>68172506
Of course.
>>
>>68172487
Giacchino is working his way up. He's good for a recent guy. another god tier composer is Jerry Goldsmith.
>>
Howard Shore

>im the first to post howard shore

fuckin plebs
>>
Juno reactor
http://youtu.be/hMqenL2A9co
>>
>>68172522
i'm cool with people liking zimmer, but i don't have to like soulless music with no charm or character.
>>
>>68172330
john williams is an absolute genius and it makes me sad that I will never meet him in real life.

He is on par with the likes of fucking mozart.
>>
>>68172537
at least Jerry Goldsmith got mentioned before Shore.
>>
>>68172330
le steal scores from german expressionist films man
>>
>>68172330
>tfw no Junkie
>>
File: scores out the ass.jpg (2 MB, 1371x2067) Image search: [Google]
scores out the ass.jpg
2 MB, 1371x2067
>>68172367
first post is always the best post

based anon
>>
>>68172556
You know that 99% of his stuff is just mixing up and reordering classical pieces of music right? He doesn't have a creative bone in his body, he's more like a DJ than a composer. He's great at composing other people's work in a way that is easily marketable for film.
>>
>>68172579
Any examples, or are you just talking out your ass?
>>
>>68172567
That Batman theme was fucking atrocious.
>>68172544
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pd8HAy9WAYs

Hardly what I'd call his greatest work but it has bags of charm.
>>
>>68172579
Does this ring any bells?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0bcRCCg01I
>>
>>68172579
Thats Hans Zimmer you just described, pleb.
>>
>>68172603
This was for >>68172586

>>68172606
Zimmer is even worse, he just rips off OTHER film composers.
>>
>>68172617
*other FILM
>>
>>68172631
What are you talking about, I used the word film?

Also more, lel:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtRU8cMp0Nk
>>
>>68172655
you used all caps so he corrected it
>>
>>68172670
Zimmer is also a film composer, I meant what I typed.
>>
>>68172603
if that is your proof that Williams just remixes old compositions then you can make that case for literally any composer that came after Mozart.
>>
>>68172603
its just orchestral music. There are some parts which sound close to starwars. but its not copied at all you fucking moron.

Kill yourself you contrarian dickless fuck
>>
>>68172655
because you were trying to get across the idea that zimmer portrayed less skill compared to his contemporaries, and the topic of discussion is discerning artists ripping off one another, therefore we already there are others involved so the emphasis on the word 'other' is not necessary but to emphasize the word 'film' would make sense as its directing our attention to the weaker comparison other than john williams who borrows from greater source material. i agree with you though, hans zimmer is a pleb
>>
>>68172692
Understood!
Also lol at Williams copying shit.
>>
>>68172693
The great composers don't lift entire sections like Williams does, you can't compare him to any great composer, he's not an artist just a technician, he mixes together other people's work.
>>
>>68172705
*we already know there are others
>>
>>68172586
>Any examples, or are you just talking out your ass?

I love John Williams to death but https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RCct_tSQ8WY
>>
File: nigger please.jpg (42 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
nigger please.jpg
42 KB, 1280x720
>>68172698
>he has no ears
>kill yourself
>he's mad
>>
>>68172705
Jesus fuck this genuine autism.

The point I was making was that Zimmer doesn't even rip of the greats, he just rips off his peers in the film scoring industry.

I really hope English isn't your first or even second or third language.
>>
Philip Glass

Williams is a hack.
>>
>>68172725
This sounds great
>>
>>68172721
Williams makes the best music to fit the tone of what's happening. frankly your case is weak. i still think you might as well say any composer after Mozart steals from him.
>>
>>68172469
The theme of capekino.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ox7S0Nttbh0
>>
>>68172761
>he hasn't heard Dvorak no9
literally how
>>
>>68172744
exactly, so you should've emphasized the word 'film' instead of 'other'. just accept you were wrong mate, or you can keep deflecting
>>
>>68172693
The Star Wars soundtrack was practically composed by Igor Stravinsky.
>>
>>68172761
It's one of my favourite pieces of music ever.

Also not that anon, but I do genuinely like William's work, it's just wrong to compare him to the great composers of the past, scoring a Hollywood film is a completely different craft. He wasn't trying to create new or beautiful music, he was trying to piece together shit often to a tight schedule that had catchy hooks and would fit the tone of various scenes the director had prepared.
>>
>>68172761
It's a favorite
>>
>>68172783
See >>68172692
>>
>>68172821
exactly, so you should've emphasized the word 'film' instead of 'other'. just accept you were wrong mate, or you can keep deflecting
>>
>>68172797
Stravinsky + Holst, yeah.
>>
>>68172797
more ass talking. Williams is god tier.
>>
>>68172770
literal shit. the same noise for like 4 minutes straight, then it gets interesting for like a minute then it's over.
>>
Most conductors are glorified cover band leaders.

If you're a conductor and you don't compose your own work once in a while then you should fucking kill yourself.

Paying $400+ to see the latest cover of Beethoven is the same as paying $60 to see someone cover Nirvana.

Just because you dress yourself up in fancy suits doesn't make it any better.
>>
>>68172873
That's because you're deaf, friendo.
>>
>>68172845
Just out of interest what is your first language?
>>
>>68172896
Good way to look at it.
I hate cover bands I would never pay to see one.
>>
>>68172900
>music is from my favorite movie
>you just don't UNDERSTAND it like i do
>>
>>68172896
its very satisfying watching an entire orchestra ensemble play the fuck out of some classic pieces that they've rehearsed for days on end. dont tell me a nirvana cover band rehearses as much as an orchestra because that would be redundant, nirvana songs aren't hard.
>>
>>68172910
what business is it of yours?
>>
>>68172943
Just wondering if your autism makes more sense in whatever it is as opposed to English, you really seem to be struggling with this one.
>>
>>68172924
That's not my favourite movie.
It's not even close.
Hell it's not even my favourite capeshit movie.
Hell, it's not even my favourite BATMAN movie.
Or my favourite NOLAN movie.
Or ZIMMER movie.

But it isn't the same for 4 minutes straight, that's wrong.
>>
File: weird 1.jpg (61 KB, 443x490) Image search: [Google]
weird 1.jpg
61 KB, 443x490
>>68172959
i was expecting a triggering. was not disappointed.
>>
File: fig,grass_green,mens,ffffff_u2.jpg (45 KB, 556x350) Image search: [Google]
fig,grass_green,mens,ffffff_u2.jpg
45 KB, 556x350
>>68172911
>mfw I'm making close to $1500 a week in a cover band
>>
>>68173011
>playing in a cover band
>having dignity

pick one
>>
>>68173011
Make your own music ya dip!
>>
John Williams fucking nails,the sense of wonder

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u5H0sCdvZ14
>>
>>68172330
williams is the family guy/carlos mencia of composers
>>
>>68172487
Giacchino is amazing. His work on the Medal of Honor franchise is god-tier.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-cNGFZQKSxs
>>
too many americans in this thread. i must make haste
>>
>>68173048
$$$$$$$$$$$
>>
Here is some Joe Hisaishi.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KeX4V90A4D4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=llHR8ujREjk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Dpqy4x5PQk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMYqWpzCo8k
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jTHt0WMNwv8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-vditDfo9sw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZ09YFU2jrg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hstbdf-vOo4

He's won the Japanese Oscar eight times.
>>
>>68173042
i didn't realize family guy and carlos mencia were timeless, iconic, and bring shame to most of the later tv shows and comedians.
>>
File: 1460454788751.jpg (44 KB, 720x688) Image search: [Google]
1460454788751.jpg
44 KB, 720x688
>>68173099
>>
>>68173102
>timeless, iconic

You mean in that he steals everything from icons of a previous time?
>>
Hating John Wiliams? That's a whole new level of faggotry
>>
>>68173151
>these 5 notes are pretty similar to this other song from 100 years ago
>THIEVERY
>>
>>68173099
No one cares about this Chinese shit, you wannabe gook.
>>
>>68172556
>He is on par with the likes of fucking mozart.

not even fucking close, lol

only someone who hasn't attempted to properly find out what the fuss over Mozart was for would suggest something like this.

Wagner, Beethoven and Bach are the only composers who come anywhere near Mozart.
>>
>>68173187
It's the same for every single iconic bit of music Williams has ever "made". He's a glorified music producer, not a composer.
>>
>>68173118
>>68173189
Why are Americans still unable to let go of Pearl Harbor?
>>
>>68173186
Nope. That's Lukelust.
>>
>>68173232
I'm a Bong, actually.
>>
>>68172330
Vangelis
>>
>>68173217
give me literally any example of John Williams "stealing" music from someone else and i bet 9 times out of 10 the Williams piece sounds better, whether it's "stolen" or not.
>>
>>68172330
There isn't. He's the best of all time. Unquestionably.
>>
>>68173249
No you're not.
>>
>>68173199
>wagner

lmaoing at ur life right now

>bach
baroque music is so fucking samey. outside of his preludes and fugues he did fuck all.

Try again faggot. I stand by my remark
>>
>>68173255
His Blade Runner score is 10/10 and the chariots of fire them is 10/10 but i'm not familiar with anything else he's done. i'll have to look him up.
>>
>>68173264
I live in Bradley Stoke, in Bristol.
>>
>>68173278
I'm sure you know those too:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94dY-QxjDiE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LM3Y6bHFTjQ&nohtml5=False
>>
>>68173249
>>68173264
Yes, he is. I'm the American.

And to answer your stupid question, it's because we find it funny since Japan literally can't let go of us since Pearl Harbor.

Li'l bitch.
>>
>>68173217
actual musician here. I've listened to the comparative videos playing the parts Williams is meant to have stolen.

the only ones that are really close are the atmospheric parts where he uses similar textures and there isn't much of a chord progression.

his melodies are original enough that he couldn't get successfully sued for them.
>>
>>68172446
Zimmer's not the great most of the time but williams is a senile hack
>>
>>68173297
You're American and that's why you're upset.

>>68173303
Japan has no reason to care about Pearl Harbor.
>>
>>68173199
Beethoven is way better than Mozart brah
>dem symphonies 3,5,7,8,9
>dem late string quartets
>dat Grosse Fugue
>dem piano sonatas
>dem concertos
>DEM DIABELLI VARIATIONS
>DAT MISSA SOLEMNIS
Truly a once-in-a-millenium genius. The best at practically every single form. Nothing else comes close.
Even his less-known stuff blows out the competition:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQy-X8dmogc
>>
>>68173270
I can't tell exactly how you're trying to troll me, sorry.

Unless you're just repeating that you think Williams = Mozart which as I said is fucking laughable.
>>
>>68173324
>the weeb isn't up to date on history, geopolitics, economics, or military affairs since World War II--the era he lives in

Truly, this is stunted growth and autism.
>>
>>68173356
I'm not a weeb, and you're the one who is clueless about history.
>>
File: 1459724031886.png (1 MB, 1024x1024) Image search: [Google]
1459724031886.png
1 MB, 1024x1024
>>68172330
>Junkie XL's Mad Max
>Jan Jorgensen (SP?) - Sicario
>Trent Reznor
>Artist who scored Irreversible
>Vangelis
>T Bone Burnett

Williams hasn't done anything worthy in YEARS. He's the Steven Spielberg of scores.
>>
>>68173309
>actual musician here.

Means literally nothing. I'm an "actual musician" too.
There have been plenty posted in this thread.

Like you said, he changes it enough maybe not to be sued, and that is it. He doesn't just steal instrumentation, but entire themes.
>>
>>68173324
Nope, I'm English and I don't care about Pearl Harbour.
>>
>>68172761
>This is /tv/'s culture
How do you expect not having this board full of plebs?
>>
>>68173328
>Grosse Fugue
writing music while deaf: a cautionary fugue.
>>
>>68173390
Only Americans get this butthurt over Japan.
>>
>>68173364
>no u

No, you are.
>>
File: 1429991228164.jpg (71 KB, 520x678) Image search: [Google]
1429991228164.jpg
71 KB, 520x678
Can any of you plagiarismfags provide a concrete example of a specific WIlliams composition that is based on a specific classical composition? Until you do, you're just talking out your ass.
For example, this here is clear proof that the Metal Gear Solid theme was plagiarized:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9k7DrIWcrdI
>>
>>68173414
That isn't true, everyone laughs at anime.
>>
>>68173403
I'm working on becoming a patrician.
>>
>>68173414
>defending your animoo waifus this hard

no, anon, the entirety of the (healthy-minded) west views all contemporary asian culture as fucking retarded. your men are women and your real women are ours

get chalked fuccboi
>>
>>68173382
Like I said, none of the comparative videos are as damning as "steals themes" implies.
>>
>>68173378
that's a fine comparison considering Williams has been Spielberg's right hand man since the mid 70's. only 2 of his movies weren't scored by Williams.
>>
>>68173404
Symph. 9, the Missa Solemnis and the late string quartets were composed when the man was completely deaf.
>>
>>68173418
Japan attacked Pearl Harbor. They have no reason to be traumatized over it. It's America that's traumatized over it, because they were the ones being attacked.

>>68173424
The vast majority of those are American, and the vast majority of the rest are bandwagoners.

>>68173449
I didn't mention anime or waifus anywhere.

>contemporary asian culture
We're not talking about contemporary Asian culture, we're talking about Japan.

>your men are women and your real women are ours
You're actually confusing Asia and Europe now. That is quite an accomplishment.
>>
>>68173466
Then you didn't actually listen to them.
>>
>>68173419
the Rites of Spring ones (Dune Sea from Star Wars, and the rhythm parts of the Jaws theme after the intro) are the only ones that are really egregious.
>>
>>68173467
Yeah, look, I'm not trying to dimish the man's contributions to cinema over the years. Jurassic Park, Star Wars, Jaws etc will go down as some of the greats. I just think that there's no place for Williams' scores in the modern world. His TFA score was so weak, just like every other part of the film. I'm more disappointed than anything.

Ennio Morricone on the other hand, still is making fantastic work.

Spielberg, in my opinion, made 3 great films; Jaws, Raiders and Jurassic Park.
>>
>>68173522
The whole of Holst's Mars is pretty damming imo
>>
>>68172330
Basil Poledouris
Ennio Morricone
Danny Elfman
John Carpenter
>>
>>68173483
>>68173449
>>68173424
>>68173414
>>68173390
>>68173364
>>68173356
>>68173324
>>68173303
>>68173249
>>68173232
>>68173118

American/OP here. fuck off with this Pearl Harbor shit.
>>
>>68173483
Pearl Harbour led to Japan getting blown the fuck out. Most rational Japs would regret it.
>The vast majority of those are American, and the vast majority of the rest are bandwagoners.
Americans are the biggest user of this site, no shit. The vast majority of the weebs here are Americans, too.
>>
File: asian_male_ideal.jpg (11 KB, 333x500) Image search: [Google]
asian_male_ideal.jpg
11 KB, 333x500
>>68173483
>>
File: typical_asian_man.jpg (93 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
typical_asian_man.jpg
93 KB, 1280x720
>>
>>68173468
yes, I know. I think he got better at compensating for his disability.
>>
>>68173545
This
>>
>>68173548
I didn't start this. I just posted music by a Japanese composer, and then the amerifats lost their minds.

>>68173551
Again: it is Japan that attacked America, not the other way around. Americans are butthurt over Pearl Harbor because they got attacked. The Japanese were the ones who did the attack. So they have no reason to be butthurt over it.

>Americans are the biggest user of this site, no shit.
I didn't say it has anything specifically to do with 4chan.

>>68173558
?
>>
>>68173612
Again: Pearl Harbour led to Japan getting blown the fuck out. Most rational Japs would regret it.
>>
File: fuccboi.jpg (18 KB, 362x400) Image search: [Google]
fuccboi.jpg
18 KB, 362x400
>>
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9lMArVYkqZ8

Daft Punk need to score more films
>>
>>68173545
Conan The Barbarian. GOAT fantasy film, GOAT choral soundtrack.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LckJTjGtz2M
>>
>>68173612
>i didn't start this
>joins the argument anyway

great job derailing my goddamn thread.
>>
>>68173612
>I didn't say it has anything specifically to do with 4chan.
Well at least here you could attempt polls and shit, I doubt you surveyed the world to back up your nonsensical claims.
>>
you yanks need to stop replying to this>>68173612 turd. he's clearly an ausposter who just shits up the whole board at these hours
>>
>>68173624
>regret
Not the same emotion as butthurt.

>>68173627
Did you get lost on your way to /hm/ or something?

>>68173642
Please explain how posting music by a movie composer is derailing in a thread about movie composers.

>>68173647
There's nothing nonsensical about it. Japan makes Americans deeply upset.

>>68173666
Please explain how posting music by a movie composer is shitting up a thread about movie composers.
>>
>>68173674
>can't read, but somehow able to type sentences
>>
>>68173709
There is nothing wrong with my reading ability.
>>
>>68173674
>Not the same emotion as butthurt.
My point is that Japs have as much a reason to be butthurt over the event as Amerifats, because it directly led to countless more deaths (and MANY civilian casualties) on their side.
>>
>>68173674
in this very post none of what you said is related to music by a movie composer in this thread about movie composers m8
>>
File: 7.jpg (19 KB, 409x126) Image search: [Google]
7.jpg
19 KB, 409x126
>>68173716
my findings say otherwise

you didn't start the argument, but you JOINED it instead of not being a part of it.
>>
File: the hackers.jpg (37 KB, 550x434) Image search: [Google]
the hackers.jpg
37 KB, 550x434
>>68172603
holy shit Williams is a fucking hack!!!
The final chords are almost identical to the opening scene in ANH
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x2J5Oifxp7w&index=2&list=PLeigbpMXUkYlKcypDJRIUDuyz2HtGGEk0 1:36
>>
>>68173674
>I'm talking about movie composers!
>Let me reply to all the Americans first though
>OOPS, no room for non-shitpost, better just make it all diarrhea from down undah!
>>
>>68173751
Except, you know, they're not butthurt. You're just projecting your own butthurt onto them.

>>68173764
How is this post not related to movie composers: >>68173099

>>68173765
I didn't join any argument.
>>
>>68173777
>I'm talking about movie composers!
>Let me reply to all the Americans first though
Does time flow backwards where you live?

>OOPS, no room for non-shitpost, better just make it all diarrhea from down undah!
???
>>
>>68172698
drink bleach you deaf plebian piece of shit
>>
>>68173780
>You're just projecting your own butthurt onto them.
But I told you, I'm a Brit from Bristol remember? And then you just put your fingers in your ears and went "LALALALALALA I CAN'T HEAR YOU" because it upsets you that someone who's not American might mock muh precious Japs folded 1000 times.
>>
File: 7.jpg (32 KB, 607x166) Image search: [Google]
7.jpg
32 KB, 607x166
>>68173780
troll exposed.
>>
>>68173780
How is this one>>68173674
or this one>>68173612
or this one>>68173483

walk away, ausposter ;)
>>
>>68173419
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0bcRCCg01I
6:54
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x2J5Oifxp7w&index=2&list=PLeigbpMXUkYlKcypDJRIUDuyz2HtGGEk0
1:36
>>
>>68173829
If you were actually a Brit you wouldn't be this upset.

>>68173830
You don't know what that word means.
>>
>>68173780
>>68173800

That delicious samefag.

Feel outnumbered, kiddo?
>>
>>68173833
I'm not Australian, and what point are you trying to make?
>>
>>68173850
He completely rips off the section around 1:30 as well, fuck every bit of Mars ends up somewhere in the Star Wars score.
>>
>>68173857
Arguing with you doesn't mean I'm upset, though.
>>
>>68173867
yes, you are
>>
>>68173865
Posting more than once in a thread is not samefagging, newfriend.

>>68173880
You are upset. One of these posts was yours:
>>68173118
>>68173189
>>
>>68173887
No I'm not.
>>
File: 465752438.0.jpg (116 KB, 1280x854) Image search: [Google]
465752438.0.jpg
116 KB, 1280x854
>>68173872
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b9IV5u9iwuQ
i think this video should close any argument in this thread
>>
>>68173909
Yes, you are
>>
>>68173894
Mine was the Bert and Ernie one, and I posted it because it made me laugh and belittled Hisaishi's "accomplishments".
>Japanese Oscars
lmao.
>>
>>68173945
No I'm not.

>>68173951
You got butthurt just because I mentioned Japan. You were instantly triggered. Because you're American.

>Japanese Oscars
>lmao.
They have awards equivalent to the Oscars. Are you mentally handicapped?
>>
>>68173951
something the weeb ausposter will never understand how lowly the rest of the world thinks of his idealized nippon
>>
>>68173930
Williams sounds better
>>
>>68173977
I'm not a weeb or Australian and this has nothing to do with any "idealized nippon." And just because pathetic amerifats get triggered by Japan doesn't mean everyone else does too.
>>
>>68173968
Yes you are
>>
File: 1460255807544.jpg (9 KB, 262x263) Image search: [Google]
1460255807544.jpg
9 KB, 262x263
>>68173968
>You got butthurt just because I mentioned Japan. You were instantly triggered. Because you're American.
You're reaching.


>>>equivalent
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqDrEVugpSM&nohtml5=False
this is maby his most original score
>>
>>68174002
No I'm not.

>>68174010
No I'm not.

>equivalent
Yes, you retard. They are the same thing.
>>
>>68174001

You reveal your kangaroo bias, Ausposter. America and Britain are literally all that matter and you're not good enough for either. Get you gone, weeabo filth!
>>
>>68174036
I'm not Australian or a weeaboo.

>>68174047
I didn't start this.
>>
>>68174035
>being this flustered
>arguing this long with a bunch of virgins
Jesus christ I wasn't going to take sides but shit, anon lmao
>>
good shit from Jerry Goldsmith

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PP1Ulx-CfI
>>
>>68174059
>being this flustered
Projection.

>arguing this long with a bunch of virgins
You started this argument.
>>
>>68174035
>No I'm not.
Yes you are.

I don't think most people here put much stock in the ACTUAL Oscars, let alone the Jap variant, so I don't really know what "He's won the Japanese Oscar eight times" was meant to prove. I wouldn't praise a Jap Oscar any more than I would praise a fucking BAFTA.
>>
>>68174052
does it matter if you started it? you joined the argument. you're feeding the off topic discussion.

good shit from James Newton Howard

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U06IPcob5bE
>>
>>68173980
>Gustav Mahler
>Igor Stravinsky
>Tchaikovsky
>Holst
you are what is wrong with classical music today my friend
>>
>>68174089
No I'm not.

>I don't think most people here put much stock in the ACTUAL Oscars, let alone the Jap variant, so I don't really know what "He's won the Japanese Oscar eight times" was meant to prove.
You're just butthurt because they're Japanese.

>>68174095
I didn't join any argument.
>>
>>68174052
You are Australian and you are a weeaboo.
>>
More Jerry Goldsmith greatness.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ibb7NtALV58
>>
>>68174110
I'm neither of those things.
>>
File: eye roll.jpg (26 KB, 300x308) Image search: [Google]
eye roll.jpg
26 KB, 300x308
>>68174102
yeah because me thinking John Williams sounds better is detrimental to society.
>>
>>68172330
Yeah JW is pretty much the best composer of the last 50 years. He is a modern mozart when it comes to writing tunes that will be remembered 100s of years from now. He has written some stinkers though. TFA being one of them
>>
>>68174108
>No I'm not
Yes you are.
>You're just butthurt because they're Japanese
I'm saying that citing these awards in general is pointless, hence why pretty much no one else in this thread is doing it to support their answers to the OP.
>>
File: 7.jpg (44 KB, 1186x170) Image search: [Google]
7.jpg
44 KB, 1186x170
>>68174108
i can literally see you arguing with a guy in that very post.
>>
>>68174125
You're both of those things.
>>
>>68174166
No I'm not.

>I'm saying that citing these awards in general is pointless
No, you're just butthurt because they're Japanese.

>>68174180
What about it?

>>68174181
No.
>>
>>68174180
Aussies aren't known for their intelligence. Weebs are characteristically stubborn.

Aussie weebs are trash given human form.
>>
>>68174200
I'm not Australian or a weeb.
>>
>>68174217
Yes, you are.
>>
>>68174198
>No I'm not.
Yes you are.

>No, you're just butthurt because they're Japanese.
Aaaaaaand you're just repeating yourself and ignoring what I say, so this is where I take my triumphant leave :^)
>>
File: 1422918091565.png (68 KB, 217x234) Image search: [Google]
1422918091565.png
68 KB, 217x234
>>68174161
>when it comes to writing tunes
>>
>>68174198
>says he didn't join an argument
>can be seen arguing in the same exact post where he says he isn't arguing.

>>68174200
and you are no better. you're adding to the argument as well.

Randy Edelman's Dragonheart is beauty

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEzy8_67VmU
>>
>>68174161

There was music in TFA?
>>
>>68174236
No I'm not.

>>68174239
No I'm not.

>Aaaaaaand you're just repeating yourself and ignoring what I say, so this is where I take my triumphant leave :^)
Why wouldn't I ignore what you say when you're just lying?

>>68174260
That doesn't mean I joined an argument.
>>
File: gif 15.gif (997 KB, 230x230) Image search: [Google]
gif 15.gif
997 KB, 230x230
>>68174287
>arguing with someone doesn't mean i've joined an argument
>>
Danny Elfman

https://youtu.be/jItz-uNjoZA
>>
>>68174151
>reddit
>>
>>68174299
ok I'm a weeb
happy now?
>>
>>68172387
Yeah, I like that piece... that one... the one he does for every movie, you know which one...
>>
I don't even know the difference between John Williams, Danny Elfman and Hanz Zimmer.

Ennio Morricone is the italian western guy tho.
>>
>>68174299
I didn't join an argument. The argument was started because I referred to the existence of Japan.
>>
>>68174307

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mdDo-LLlmM
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BAoVWQnwmhM&nohtml5=False

Alan Menken
>>
>>68172367
/thread
>>
>>68174347
you don't listen to movie scores then
>>
>>68174336
Yes, thank you, you Aussie piece of shit.
>>
File: mad 8.jpg (7 KB, 259x195) Image search: [Google]
mad 8.jpg
7 KB, 259x195
>>68174348
>i didn't join an argument
>is currently arguing just by saying that
>>
>>68174354
james newton howard is great
>>
>>68173099
Brother's OST is absolutely fucking awesome. Just ike the movie, in fact
>>
>>68174397
Again: I didn't join an argument. The argument was started because I referred to the existence of Japan.
>>
>>68173545
>Danny Elfman
holy fucking shit...
>>
>>68174425
Based Japan.
>>
>Ctrl - F "Thomas Newman"
>One match

The man is severely underappreciated

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNbaRiZJJQo
>>
OP here. well, even though a bunch of this thread was extended by tards arguing about japan, i'm happy that one of my posts has gotten this much attention.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=65As1V0vQDM
>>
>>68174277
This

JW is awesome, but he's clearly too old now. The only memorable partin the whole TFA was three seconds of Imperial March.

They should have go with Giacchinno. He's not a genious but gets the job done.
>>
File: happy 25.jpg (15 KB, 213x180) Image search: [Google]
happy 25.jpg
15 KB, 213x180
>>68174425
>is arguing
>but didn't join an argument
>>
>>68174482
Are you retarded? Joining implies something that was already on-going, when in fact there wasn't anything on-going. The argument STARTED when I mentioned Japan. I therefore did not JOIN it.
>>
>>68174516
What part of being anonymous do you not get? Why the fuck are you defending yourself? The guy you're talking to will literally never meet you nor will he ever know who you are

Jesus christ
>>
>>68174530
>Why the fuck are you defending yourself?
Why the fuck are you attacking me?
>>
>>68174482
that's like seeing a bunch of guys start shooting each other, picking up a gun and shooting someone shortly afterwards, and then saying you didn't join the gunfight. you're arguing. that means you joined an argument, you Australian weeb,
>>
>>68174579
I'm not Australian or a weeb, and I didn't join an argument.
>>
>>68174556
why the fuck are you arguing in a thread about movie composers?

some John Barry

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EuaDf0L11E4
>>
>>68174611
Why the fuck do you flip out when someone mentions a Japanese composer in a thread about movie composers?
>>
File: dafuq 17.jpg (7 KB, 223x225) Image search: [Google]
dafuq 17.jpg
7 KB, 223x225
>>68174604
>is arguing
>didn't join an argument

that's like being a toddler who knocks a plate off the table while your mom is looking directly at you, then denying that you did it.
>>
>>68174652
I didn't join an argument and I already explained to you why that is, but evidently you are too stupid to understand.
>>
>>68174643
when did i do that? this is OP you're talking to just so you know. i never went off because someone mentioned a Japanese composer. i'm going off because it led to a bunch of idiots arguing about Pearl harbor and weeaboos.
>>
>>68174720
This started because amerifats lost their minds when I mentioned Japan.
>>
>>68174673
>is arguing
>but didn't join an argument

the toddler and the plate.
>>
>>68174747
See >>68174516
>>
>>68174746
and you talked back to them, meaning you joined the argument.
>>
>>68174775
I have every right to defend myself. That doesn't mean I'm "joining an argument."
>>
>>68174769
>an argument starts after mentioning Japan
>responds to the arguers (joins the argument)
>but didn't join an argument
>>
Nah, my top 3 faves are John Williams, Ennio Morricone and James Horner.

My guilty pleasures are Zimmer, Badelt and Jablonsky.
>>
>>68174832
See >>68174516
>>
>>68174788
yes it does. someone attacks, you defend, making you a part of the fight whether you want to be a part of it or not.
>>
>>68174835
Jablonsky has done some good stuff, honestly.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WMls20yX148
>>
>>68174870
See >>68174516
>>
>>68174849
are you telling me you have not once responded to any of the people arguing about your post?
>>
>>68174924
I never said or implied any such thing. What is your point?
>>
>>68173300
James Horner made the last of the mohicans you pleb. The OST for Alexander by Vangelis was great though.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kUzkEPW5IGA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=duvcwBApmyM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SIpjLWQCSY8
>>
>>68174936
have you or have you not responded to any of the people arguing about your post? it's an easy yes or no. i realize we're anonymous here so i might have mistaken you for some other fucker who was arguing when you might not have.
>>
>>68173545
>Basil Poledouris
>I have only heard the Klendathu drop from Starship troopers and the opening OST for the hunt for red october
>>
>>68174967
Again, I never said or implied I haven't. What is your point?
>>
>>68172387
The music from Sherlock is god tier
>>
>>68174988
if your answer is no, then you haven't been arguing. if someone argues and you respond, then you've joined the argument. if you don't respond, you never joined the argument. if you have responded, you have joined the argument.
>>
John Williams is based. I believe that his music should have played more in TFA because some pieces were really good.
>>
>>68174988
come on, bro. it's not that hard.
>>
>>68175026
See >>68174516

>>68175045
What are you talking about?
>>
>>68175049
yes or no? did you respond to any arguers or not?
>>
>>68175085
See >>68174988
>>
this must be mentioned

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ac4xamCIgY
>>
>>68175095
so you did respond to arguers, meaning you argued. a simple yes would have sufficed.
>>
>>68175127
I never said I didn't argue. What is your point?
>>
>>68175198
What does what I said have to do with that highlighted text?
>>
>>68175227
Or actually here is a better question: why are so fucking invested in this that you actually take screenshots and highlight text in them?
>>
>>68175227
the hell are you responding to there?
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 34

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.