Who was the better Spider-Man Tobey Maguire or Andrew Garfield?
capeshit board when containment
>>67635391
Garfield by far, but Maguire had the best movie.
>>67635391
Better Spider-man? Andrew
Better Peter? Tobey
>>67635391
Andrew, by far.
Toby on all accounts. Fucking giraffe neck ruined it.
>>67635391
Toby will always be my Spiderman
>>67635410
>>67635512
>>67635571
is this a fucking joke? get the fuck out you underage fucks
Tobey 4 life
neither of them.
skinnyfat vs pencilneck
>>67636893
this
tumblr is leaking
>>67635391
Tobey. People will always remember him as THE Spiderman people will forget right guy as soon as Civil War hits
Tugboat Maguire
>>67635391
Tobey
Garfield was a lasagna eating annoying fatass
>>67635391
Tugboat Tobey looks more like an awkward loser nerd with no friends, so i think he can pool off the role of Peter Parker better, although he looks a little older than Andrew.
Andrew is way too pretty, there's no way he'd ever get bullied at school. If anything, the bullies would rape his boi pussy.
Tobey
Spider Man 2 is the greatest superhero movie ever
>>67635391
TF2 movie: Andrew Garfield as Scout please make this happen
>>67637029
this
reminder that tugboat was part of an illegal poker ring and asked the host woman to bark like a dog for 1k
>>67637029
I miss Raimi so much
I would take SM3 over most of the shit we've been given since then
>>67637088
Did he also ask her to cluck like a chicken?
>>67635391
Tobey.
Garfield is pretty forgettable.
Why is the CGI so bad in all these movies?
>>67637105
I don't get why people hate SM3 so much. I mean yeah it wasn't as good as SM2 but if people's problem was that it was way too convoluted how did they all sit through BvS
>>67635410
>>67635512
>>67635571
>Garfield contrarians
He's a terrible actor and brings nothing to the character. Tobey wasn't a perfect Peter but he's better than Mr. Quip.
The ONLY thing the Amazing movies did right was Spideys costume. That's it.
>>67635391
Tobey was 1000x more believable
>>67637105
Me too. I've given up on superhero movies, they're all the exact same thing now. If you want to get into modern superhero movies just watch Avengers and then you've seen every single one for the past 10 years.
>>67637177
Maybe it was ... different people.
>>67637182
>contrarians
Oh, fuck off with your buzzword nonsense. Maguire was nowhere near enough scrawny to be Parker, nor did he have the right voice or face.
The only negative you can say about Garfield is that he had an annoying lack hat hair.
Don't get me wrong, his movies were shit, and the writing wasn't as good, but performances only?
A Raimi film with Garfield would've been fantastic.
Tobey easily. I liked Garfield's cocky spiderman but Tobey's felt truer to the comics and the TV show.
>>67635391
ayy
>>67637286
Garfield is a pretty boy, he doesnt look like the nerd stereotype at all. Peter was never particularly attractive, and got picked on constantly. Garfield does not fit the character at all, he was cast solely to put teenage girls in seats.
>>67637177
>but if people's problem was that it was way too convoluted how did they all sit through BvS
I haven't.
>>67637384
>Peter was never particularly attractive
You what? Peter was pulling pussy left and right from his high school days.
>>67635391
Tobei was only good at the clumsy spiderman in the beginning that still struggles using its powers. Garfield is only good at the cocky son of a bitch Spiderman.
TUGBOAT
>>67635391
For me Maguire felt "believable" in the role as Peter, being an awkward nerd who slowly has to adjust to his new powers.Maguire was of course helped by the fact that the cast and the movie overall was much better, but Garfield was not believable from the beginning.
>>67637029
oh really?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U59GTK94KnA
>>67637286
Peter was built as fuck in the comics what are you talking about? Unless you're referring to USM which yeah he was scrawny but he was also like what 13?
Peter has always been attractive and sometimes with hair on the long side that curls
Tobey's Peter was what an actual nerd in high school would look/act like (minus looking too old)
Garfield was a terrible actor and portrayed Pete as a cocky asshole
Hey guys
>>67637995
I can't tell if his costume looks stupid or I'm just used to the raimi one.
Tugboat's spidey would never have a shit scfene like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEz_zs67hwY
>>67638044
>moving eyes
>web design is barely visible
>color is muted
>it's CG and the effects aren't even finished yet
It's not just you.
>>67636728
>>67636821
>>67636893
>>67636924
>>67636943
>>67636945
>>67636953
>>67637029
>>67637052
>>67637105
>>67637137
>>67637182
>>67637183
>>67637309
>>67637384
>>67637666
>>67637795
>>67637939
Is this memes? Garfield was better in every way an actor can be. Tugboat's performance is cringe-inducing. He comes off as a cross between Sheldon Cooper and Norman Bates, an awkward, annoying, autist who's a little too into his aunt.Do you guys just identify with him or something?
>>67638176
>is this memes
Go back to R*ddit, stupid faggot. No one likes the guy who replies to every single person in the thread.
Toby is shit when you realize he's supposed to be a teenager. Overall the movies are better though.
>>67638296
>Raimicucks telling anyone to go back to le'ddit
kek
>Implying Tobey's Spidey isn't the best capeshit hero of all time.
>>67636728
>giraffe neck
can't unsee
>>67635512
This, pretty much.
Tobey wasn't like a shit Spiderman tho.
And boy I'd like to fuck Andrew Garfield
Garfield was a better Spider-man but Toby nailed the Peter Parker.
What do you guys think it must feel like to grow up with Amazing Spider Man and Garfield as spiderman? Do kids who saw him also watched Tobey's Spiderman films? If so, which one will they remember the most when they grow up? I guess it would be like Batman in the 90s, just a complete clusterfuck and you could never fully identify with one actor because there were so many
>>67637146
I don't remember the CGI being bad in SM2.
>>67635391
Tobey
Andrew looked better but Tobeu was better directed and so tu rned in the better performance
