Which is better?
TFA
It had good lead acting
>>64253882
Force Awakens.
Revenge is the second worst in the series.
>>64253882
Tough. Both are good but completely different films.
The Force Awakens is a solidly and competently made sci fi action with all around good characters, scenes, dialogue and music, however it possess very little memorable scenes, for it does not attempt to stand out. It is an overall good but not great movie.
Revenge of the Sith meanwhile, is the best prequel, where there is an enormous amount of conflict, drama and characterization revolving around the transformation of Anakin Skywalker to Darth Vader, as well as the fall of the Republic and transformation into the dreaded evil Empire that we all know. It tries to stand out and does possess some memorable scenes. The movie is overall good, however it is flawed with clunky sometimes cringeworthy dialogue, bad acting, and excessively overused weak cgi.
I would give a very slight edge to ROTS because it has more heart poured into it, but TFA is more solid in terms of how it was made.
>>64253882
3 definitely has better memes, all 7 has yielded so far is TRAITOR and TELATTAKANJIKLUB
maybe if we give it 10 years...
>>64253909
When did acting in a Star Wars film become important?
>>64253882
Revenge of the Sith
Force awakens was good but that was it. There was not a single special or outstanding thing about it, whereas Revenge of the Sith certainly has its low points, but unlike TFA it has some pretty great high points that finally lived up to the potential greatness the prequels had.
In the final battle with Anakin and Obi Wan there was emotion, and there was tension. When Finn and Rey fought Kylo Ren it was a good fight but there was nothing special about it, no stand out moment, and most importantly, no fucking drama. ROTS was not perfect and it has some pretty awful parts but the good outweighs the bad and it certainly makes for a more enjoyable experience than watching TFA's bland effort.
>>64253882
it's irrelevant as neither is a good film.
but Sith is at least worth watching for the ideas and the decent plot arc. TFA is literally not worth bothering with.
>>64253926
>putting TPM above RotS
The Force Awakens, obviously.
>>64253882
reveng of the sith
both are garbage tho
>>64253882
ROTS.
It had more of an impact and serious feeling.
ANH > TESB > RotJ > TFA > RotS > TPM > AotC
>>64254310
FTFY
TESB > ANH > ROTJ > ROTS > TFA> TPM > AOTC
>>64254091
TFA took an old and recycled and unoriginal and shallow idea and made made it effectively, magical, fun, with good acting, dialogue, that's a joy to watch
ROTS took and interesting original and deeply developed idea and made it a a cringe worthy slow droll with awkward scenes, awkward monotone dialogue, had acting, and terrible pacing
>>64254310
this
with rotj and tfa being pretty close imo
>>64254248
>Putting cry baby Annie over Duel of the Fates
Three
>>64254197
Since someone decides not to gerrymander rules for classifying films.
TFA has CUTE
so TFA
Episode 3 had Sheev. Episode 7 had HAHA REMEMBER THAT FROM THE OT, THAT HAPPENED tier jokes.
Episode 3 is better, not even joking
>>64254341
What's Peepee supposed to signify, comfy?
>>64254365
Sorry, all films are not equal. A film series aping Republic Serials is not held to the same acting standard as Schindler's List.
>>64254334
>>64254353
Yeah, the order I gave is my personal opinion. This is the objective ranking.
Best Two:
ANH and TESB
Middle Three:
RotJ, RotS and TFA
Bottom Two:
TPM and AotC
Stick to those tiers in your order and you're totally fine by me.
>>64254399
Just look at Peypey's face. It's obviously:
>good
RotS easily
>>64254494
>millennials
>>64254513
> ROTS 2005
> TFA 2015
>>64254513
>Grandpas
I watched the OT first on casette tape as a child too
>>64254551
Different poster but I think he was getting at the fact that the people who grew up as the prequels came out defend them as the masterpieces.
Gonna go with Sith
Discuss https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=335EHIGg9Xs
>>64254358
>implying Duel of the Fates didn't appear in both AotC and RotS
>>64254584
>>64254607
Yeah. Those 15-25 year olds on this board, think about how TFA felt weird and just plain wrong after growing up with the prequels.
That is how the rest of us felt about the prequels in comparison to the OT.
>>64254372
Natalie Portman is cuter than Daisy
>>64254392
Stop joking, is not even funny.
>>64254584
Who said anything about ROTS being a masterpiece? TFA is OT masturbatory trash. ROTS is flawed, but still a better film on concept alone.
>>64254686
Sorry, might've exaggerated. I just mean to say that nostalgia goggles affect 70s children and 90s children alike, that's all.
>>64254666
Funny enough I grew up with the OT. Episode 7 is shitty nostalgia bait
>>64254392
this
memes aside, Palpatine is the best character in the whole saga
7 had practical effects which ultimately looks better than cgi all over the place and may be better paced specially considered as a standalone movie. But it brought nothing new to the star wars universe aside from (until now) underdeveloped unidimensional characters (aside maybe from Ben), "star wars for the le new generation" and more tentacle porn.
3, on the other hand, brought the conclusion to a story that had already been developed two films before. So, even if its somewhat slow, it has more space for moments of its own and to tie some loose ends between prequels and OT.
In short, 7 is better as a standalone film but 3 brought more to the star wars universe
>>64254729
7 is a horrible standalone.
I can't even.
>>64254729
Episode 7 had some really bad practial effects.
The bird, and the portions guy to note.
They looked fucking awful, it was laughable.
>>64253882
TFA is only better than unedited clone wars. If you strip out the garbage romance subplot from TCW then TFA is the worst by far. Abrams can't into cinematography script or action. He's trash.
>>64253882
TFA obviously
>>64254613
>Ironically bad video
>>64254197
having characters that you care about is kinda linchpin of these movies
>>64254780
2/10 keep trying.
ROTS. It's even better than ANH, ROTJ, AOTC, and TPM.
>>64253882
I'll bite, fuck it
TFA. by fucking miles.
>>64254613
holy fuck thats hilarious
>TFA
>worse than prequels
Tfa by far.its on par with rotj
>>64254900
>>64254931
>thinking anyone cares about a non-Star Wars fan's opinion
>>64254866
I didn't say it looked bad overall, but it had some really stand out bad looking effects. I don't think portions guy even moved his fucking mouth.
>>64253882
Revenge of the Sith but both are far from perfect
>>64254720
>"I'm totally like 25 guys, I'm old and I grew up with the OT I swear."
TFA - 7/10
RotS - 6/10
>>64254970
goofy costume aliens arefun
>>64253882
They're equal in quality. Neither are good.
like that one copypasta says, "Episode 7 isn't even a Star Wars movies. It is a Marvel flick masquerading as one."
at least ROTS feels genuine
>>64254613
>If a new hope gets recycled, I'm gonna kill myself just like Kurt Cobain
Uh I got news for you buddy
>>64254999
My first Star Wars move was the original un altered on cassette I was like 4 maybe
>>64255002
TFA - 7.5/10
ROTS -= 7.7/10
>>64254780
>>64254970
>implying that wasn't the purpose
>implying the OT wasn't campy as fuck
lololol look at this kid
>>64254152
i hope you die in a vicious car accident
>>64254947
>Remake of New Hope with derivative, lazy story telling and a Mary Sue MC.
>Better than ROTJ
Kill yourself.
>>64255039
>millennials
>>64255026
Gotta admit it's kinda endearing, but it doesn't stop it from looking like fucking ass.
>>64254637
Suck shit, as if it were a dick
you faggot fuckfairy
ROTS has a god tier ost. TFA didn't have a memorable soundtrack.
>>64255099
stop this meme
TFA had a (mostly) competent plot and dialogue that let the actors breathe a bit of life into the characters.
RotS had better music and some neat action scenes (fuck everything that happened after Obi Wan and Anakin fell into the volcano though)
Overall, I had a better time watching TFA.
>>64255057
>"the prequels were my childhood! haters beware! hating the PT is a le reddit le meme!!"
>>64254965
A true patrician Star Wars fan would appreciate the exquisite piece of art that TFA awakens.
Prequels? Ha, throw it to the pigs.
>>64255039
>feels
This is what you say when you can't justify your shitty counter-culture opinions.
>>64255129
>millennials thinking they can get their way by calling something a meme
>>64255099
It doesn't feel like Star Wars.
The pacing was fucking terrible, the shots were completely different, almost all the humor was based on nostalgia bait, fuck the whole movie is nostalgia bait. That's literally the only reason I can someone liking it so much, nostalgia bait.
>>64255056
>If a new hope gets recycled, I'm gonna kill myself just like Kurt Cobain
>posted december 29th
hehehehe funny, I guess.
>>64254854
Are you arguing for or against TFA? The characters were marvel lite. Nothing memorable.
>>64255154
I guess you are right in that most patrician Star Wars fans are muh nostalgia manchildren that TFA pandered to in the absence of taking any kind of risk or new direction.
TFA is worse than all the original movies (being just a glossy greatest hits compilation of them anyway) and arguably worse than Episode III.
It was an offensively lazy film that did nothing but pander.
>>64255149
I don't even think the prequels OVERALL are above the OT.
ROTS easily.
>>64255180
Maybe.
The Force Awakens is the Rocky Balboa of Star Wars films
It's the exact same shit as the first one, done again but old, but its so charming that you don't care.
VII, though both are rather dull. III is more entertaining thanks to McDiarmid's scenery-chewing, but VII is much more competently assembled. Neither are very good.
>>64255148
>TFA had a competent plot
News to me.
>>64255220
>Nothing memorable.
as opposed to all the memorable characters in the prequels? the whole thing was like watching cardboard talking to cardboard (Sheev aside)
As formulaic as the characters in TFA felt at times, at least they were competently written. Who gave a fuck about Obi Wan, Anakin or Padme at any point in the prequels?
>>64255208
>"waah it doesn't FEEL like thuh OT even though the majority agrees it does :'("
>>64255244
No shit you fucking child.
>>64255289
>It's the exact same shit as the first one, done again but old, but its so charming that you don't care.
That's the entire Rocky Saga.
>>64255330
>lol what memorable characters
>aside from that one memorable character
great job anon
>>64255289
Yeah, come back in a year and tell us that. You're drunk on nostalgia, but I forgive you.
>>64255289
ITS ABOUT HOW HARD
YOU CAN GET HIT, AND KEEP MOVING FORWARD
>>64255312
It was just the plot of A New Hope with a few tweaks. They couldn't have played it any safer.
There's a lot to complain about in TFA, but I feel like you don't know what you're talking about.
>>64255302
>>64255249
>>64255312
>>64255242
>>64255096
>>64255029
>shit minority opinions
>>64255333
It's almost a direct remake, with the same elements, almost nothing original. Of course it's going to feel like Star Wars to you , you nostalgia deluded fuck.
>>64255073
Lighten up, anon.
>>64255330
TFA just came out. The characters will age like milk, I assure you. Especially, Kylo "Let the bodies hit the floor" Ren.
>>64255401
LETS START MAKING SOME HURTING BOMBS
>>64255370
>only actor that carried over to the OT minus shoved in R2 and 3po
IV - 10
V - 10
VI - 8.5
VII - 9
I - 8
II - 7
III - 6
Now these are just my opinions, but the idea of comparing the two films is laughable to me.
>>64255408
Tell me why TFA is better than ROTS
>>64255289
my feelings exactly
>>64255431
>REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE STOP LIKING WHAT I DON'T LIKE!!!1
wew
The Empire Strikes Back > A New Hope > Return of the Jedi >Revenge of the Sith >The Force Awakens > The Phantom Menace > Attack of the Clones
OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED
OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED
OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED
OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED OTHER OPINIONS DISCARDED
>>64253882
TFA > TESB > AotC > RotS > ANH > RotJ > TPM
>>64255289
Balboa at least tackles its ridiculousness head on though and uses it to strengthen the plot.
>>64255487
That was literally you throughout the thread.
I liked the movie, but it's tied for the worst star wars along with episode 2 tbqh
>>64255408
Why is TFA better ROTS?
>>64255499
>Revenge of the Sith >The Force Awakens
Stop this meme and this thread.
>>64255457
IV - 9
V - 9
VI - 8
I - 5
II - 4
III - 6
VII - 7
imo.
>>64255447
Marvel makes inoffensive, marketable characters. Avengers have been around for half a decade now and plebs still eat them up.
TFA was competent. That's pretty much all it took to beat the Prequels.
>>64255499
swap the Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones and I agree 100%
>>64255530
lol
>>64255543
>literally
wew teen wew
>>64255289
Rocky 6 was fucking glorious nostalgia bait though
Star wars is just too precious to fuck with
>>64255554
characters, dialogue and plot
also goofy aliens costumes
Episode 3 hands down. No bullshit super weapon and no gay ass lightsaber and less plot holes than a sieve which is what tfa is
>>64255470
>>64255554
lol if you can't see that for yourself you have garbage minority opinions.
>>64255577
Nice shitposting.
>>64255561
>>64255457
IV - 7
V - 7
VI - 6
I - 4
II - 3
III - 4
VII - 4
IMO
>>64255559
>everyone who disagrees with me is memeing!!!!
If you can't handle contrary opinions fuck off to Reddit, a hugbox where everyone with dissenting views gets downvoted into oblivion
>>64255606
>gay ass lightsaber
>Ren's lightsaber design makes the most sense out of any in the series
Can't discern the rest really
>>64255451
https://youtu.be/_snO6S64pDg
ROCKY TRAINING MONTAGE RANKINGS
1>4>6>3>2>>>>>>>>>>Tommy gunns bullshit
>>64253882
I must reiterate..... Your mom was the better ride
>>64254900
sup reddit
>>64255626
>>64255626
imo you take things too seriously and probably aren't fun to watch movies with.
>>64255562
Competent doesn't mean memorable or good. This film has no staying power. Everyone was so desperate to get the prequel taste out of their mouth that they would cling to anything with OT overtones. Judging the film by its own merits it's derivative trash of the highest order.
>>64255622
>getting this buttblasted
>even replying
wew
>>64255670
sup reddit
>>64255289
1, Balboa and Creed are genuinely emotional and well-written films.
>>64255611
> liking TFA over ROTS
pleb
>>64255676
Hey, man, my average rating is 5/10. If yours is higher, that's nice, but it's also misrepresentative.
>>64255457
V - 9
IV - 8.5
VI - 8
VII - 7.5
III - 7.5
1 - 6
2 - 4
>>64255684
A New Hope was competent too. Competent movies put asses in seats.
>>64255559
After you're done picking the popcorn out of your teeth you'll eventually see it that way. TFA was a glossy remake and featured disappointingly lazy characters and storytelling. I was so let down. Its big positive was Harrison Ford, who did a great job. I also liked Poe.
>>64255571
Menace was better. At least it had Liam Neeson and the set up with the Trade Federation and Palpy manipulating the senate to start the chain of dominoes was at least pretty intriguing.
Get rid of Jar Jar and cast someone a little less punchable and snot nosed in the role of Anakin and it had the potential to be a very solid entry.
>>64255735
>millennial
pleb
>>64255684
All Star Wars is derivative you pleb. The whole thing is a simple homage to action serials.
You really don't know what you're talking about.
>>64255787
>memeing
Pleb
>>64255829
>People are so desperate to defend TFA that they'll stick up for blatant plagiarism.
What is this world coming to?
>>64255754
I'd say V and IV are both 9's, everything else decent.
>>64255457
>I - 8
>>64255865
>talks about memes
>is a millennial
plab
>>64255935
pleb* whoops
The prequels are infused with a bold vision of artistic profundity that eclipses the likes of generic sci-fi movies of recent times. The streamlining process that has begun to creep into the production of every slightly sci-fi-y tinged movie has created an amorphous blob of mediocrity and blandness. The prequels deliver a basic premise of good vs. evil but do it so by utilizing characters that are endowed with humanity. Aside from the storytelling aspect the prequels stand strong on all fronts, from writing, cinematography and set pieces that truly immerse you into a fantastic world full of wonder and awe. It is infinitely unfortunate that this behemoth of a film project is marred by the majority of the populace's inability to assess the genius and lack of intelligence. One can only hope that in eons to come, evolution will have worked in ways as to ensure and maximize the distribution of the gene that thrives in the intellectual minority of our time so that future generations and civilizations will be able to grasp the grandeur of the prequels and see behind the masquerading illusion that is reddit.
I have about as much respect for The Force Awakens as I do for the dog shit on my shoe.
It is reddit, it is capeshit, it is cheeto dust, it is video games. It's nothing more than memes enjoyed by simplistic pledditors. I have ZERO respect for people who are not free thinkers and blindly enjoy the reddit memes that comprise Cuck Wars: The Search for More Money.
I'm literally screaming, slamming my arms on my desk right now just thinking about it.
>>64254341
Nailed it
>>64255935
>not a millenial
Pleb
>>64255289
>thinking Marvel age Disney is charming
Jesus how low does your IQ have to be to enjoy this shit? If a science fiction movie requires you to turn your brain off to enjoy it then it's a terrible entry in the genre.
>>64255403
no New Hope actually makes sense old ben ramblings aside.
TFA wasted its villains harder than PM wasted Darth Maul
Hux got no screen time
Kylo is a failure
Captain ChromeTits didn't do ANYTHING
I honestly see the movies as almost the same in levels of quality.
>>64255934
Movie's dope.
>>64255289
>implying creed wasn't re-igniting a series for millenials in the most effective way possible
What the fuck is there to like about RotS? The writing is bad, the acting aside from Obi and Sheev is bad, the action is boring, the set pieces are uninteresting, the plot is laughable.
It's more original than TFA, but its a much worse movie in every regard.
>>64256297
>>64256323
Seems reddit is down again.
>>64256134
but they are villains in all 3 movies you moron
its like complaining that vader got wasted because he failed in ANH
TFA is disney star wars for casuals
>>64253882
3 undeniably
>>64253909
You can't unironically think Ridley was good, she's cute, but sucks shit at acting
Unless you consider Finn to be the lead
>>64254686
>still a better film on concept alone
>a concept is all it takes for a film to be better
hello liberals
The Prequel Trilogy Universe >>>>>>> TFA Universe
The movies are a mess but at least they have neat details and there is some creativity flowing in the world that made them interesting by default.
TFA was a better movie than the bunch, but the world itself is just so bland and just a marvelfied version of episode 4.
>>64256515
TFA is literally SJW the movie.
>>64256353
There was only one villain in ANH that actually does shit and lives to see another day.
TFA supposedly has 3 villains of which we only see one which ends up disgraced, beaten and probably dead (probably the chick storm trooper died too?). Maul was also only given one fighting sequence then gets cut in half.
They are pretty equal and both really good, but TFA edges it out by a hair.
Episode 3 was great. It's strong point is that it is so obviously better than the other prequels and fit in neatly with the OT unlike the others. It's also pretty hard to fuck up the climax of Darth Vader becoming Darth Vader when everyone is looking forward to it. Episode 1 and 2 were just shitty buildups to 3, which is why they sucked so much and why 3 was so good.
Episode 7 was also good. It has the best storytelling and cinematography of any Star Wars film while still staying quintessentially Star Wars. Since it's been so long since 6, they had to introduce fresh characters, which they did well at memes aside, except for Kylo Ren. It had much, much less CGI than the prequels, while still retaining classic Star Wars chestnuts, resulting in a more genuine and authentic Star Wars. All while bringing back all of the main characters fans know and love, resulting in a truly great film. Something about the cinematic experience of TFA puts it above Sith, even though they are both good. Sith doesn't get enough credit, and TFA is only 2% better than it.
>>64255408
>i follow the majority opinions
loving those circlejerks eh?
>>64256583
>Kylo
>probably dead
Are you retarded?
>>64256653
>It's also pretty hard to fuck up the climax of Darth Vader becoming Darth Vader when everyone is looking forward to it.
Did you actually enjoy Anakin being retarded and a child killer
>except for Kylo Ren
fuck off tard
>>64256675
How did they save him in the middle of nowhere in like 10 seconds before the planet exploded?
>>64255781
Harrison was good, your right. Also, Poe was the one new character who felt like a human fucking being.
I wouldn't necessarily have gotten rid of Jar Jar, I'd probably do that whole "he's secretly a sith lord" thing without really revealing it until the end of AotC.
>people seriously debating this
TFA is competently made at the very least. It's not shot like a stageplay, the acting is good, the ground battles are well staged, it has a descent mise-en-scene. Even a mildly serviceable movie is better than the worst of the prequels.
>>64256672
>edgy contrarian opinions
>>64256653
This is some titanic sized bait, holy shit
>>64256653
>except for Kylo Ren.
LITERALLY THE ONLY GOOD CHARACTER IN THE NEW MOVIE YOU FAGGOT
>>64256743
People like you are the worst.
>>64254341
FIXED. DON'T THANK ME.
>>64256760
>opinions i dont agree with are "edgy" and "contrarian"
two of reddits favorite words
you suck at this, redditor.
>>64256799
Hello reddit!
ESB > ANH >> ROTJ >> TFA > ROTS >>TPM >>>>>>>> AOTC
>>64256743
>g-george lucas raped my childhood :D
go away redditor
>>64256799
swap Genndy Clone Wars with TFA
>>64256789
Episode III is one of the worst movies of its caliber. People in my theater were literally laughing during what was supposed to be its emotional climax.
>>64256807
>le reddit meme
>le fedora meme
>le prequels were good meme
wew crymoar EU fanboy wew
>>64256817
>the prequels were good
This meme has gone on for too long tbqh
George Lucas
>spaced out the series so it would maintain its hype factor in the public eye
>gave birth to LucasArts, producing great vidya
>introduced great non-film spin offs in the EU like Heir to the Empire
>films have poetry while consistently introducing new stuff so it wouldn't be aping of the OT
Disney
>marvelized the series, producing annual movies until franchise fatigue sets in
>killed LucasArts, outsources vidya to EA if not cheap mobileshit
>rendered the EU non-canon yet copies from it for the new movies
>films lack poetry and rather copies the OT in every possible way
>>64256653
this
sith only gets credit because it's an easy continuation into a new hope. TFA had to start a whole new universe/trilogy and still rekt all the prequels and empire strikes back, the clear worst of the OT
>>64255499
I can dig it. RotS is a lot of fun, much more so than ANH.
The prequels were much better written, they had actual characters and story, not a bunch of memes and one-liners that lack any emotion or coherence. Luke is a cliched everyboy "hero" that goes through an absurdly rapid transformation between the fifth and the sixth episodes. Anakin's emotional instability and his exposure as a psychopath are gripping; and his doomed relationship with Padme is touching. In the "original trilogy" Han, Leia, Darth Vader and Obi Wan are complete meme characters, nothing about them is remotely believable or human. And why doesn't anyone care about deaths in those movies? Leia's planet destruction, Luke's stepparents' death, all of the blown up rebels--the list could go on--all the deaths are forgotten moments later.
As for direction, the movies from the "original trilogy" were mostly incoherent, badly edited and full of logical problems. The prequel trilogy is a work of a "vulgar auteur".
I feel neutral about the series overall, and honestly don't care about trolling or contrarianism. Here are my sincere rankings:
1. "Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones"
2. "Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace"
3. "Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith"
4. "Star Wars"
5. "The Empire Strikes Back"
6. "Return of the Jedi"
7.
8. "The Force Awakens"
Episode 7 isn't even a Star Wars movies. It is a Marvel flick masquerading as one.
TFA is just ANH with like 10 new major plot holes added, improved CGI, a nigger C3PO, a ball shaped R2, an even girlish Luke bad actres, a goofy looking Vader and a dozen other characters no one cares about.
What is itnotto like?
>>64253882
Revenge of the Sith
>god-tier soundtrack
>saw it when I was a little kid, so nostalgia helps me overlook all the movie's flaws
Kylo Ren is the coolest character in the SW universe
Prove me wronf
>>64256965
You honestly thought the prequels were all better than any of the originals?
.....wow.
>>64257046
he's gay
Is this thread b8 or what?
I can't tell if you're actually serious that III is any good or possibly better than any of the movies in this tired series.
>>64256965
>the prequels [...] had actual characters [...]
Worst bait ever
>>64253882
The Force Awakens.
>>64253882
Poster-wise I honestly can't believe they didn't go with painted posters.
>>64253882
Episode 3
>believable character development
>ends well
To be honest, it should have ended with Vader breathing in his first breath.
>>64257056
it's pasta
>>64257360
>>believable character development
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHA
>>64257360
>believable character development
>>64253882
V ≥ IV > VI >>> III > I >>> II ≈ VII
>do the math
>>64254970
The portions guy was completely CG though.
>>64257634
1 < 2 < 3 < 6 < 7 < 5 < 4
>>64257667
It was Simon Pegg in a costume. I think that only the face was CG.
>>64256515
you're a confused mate
>>64257360
Padme: I don't wanna live
*dies*
>>64256927
>TFA had to start a whole new universe
>better than empire
holy shit, look at this retard
>>64254686
Shakespeare only wrote remakes. It doesn't fucking matter that the plot is a rehash, what matters is how well the film itself is made.
>>64257245
am I the only one that thinks the lightsabers looked better in this film compared to TFA?
Revenge of the Sith is better by fucking miles.
TFA is just a shitty version of ANH.
>>64254421
this.
>>64257960
Yes, you're the only one. The lightsabers in TFA actually emit light that reflect off the actors and environments
>>64258066
take a look at the dooku picture are tell me there isn't a red/blue light being emitted on his face
Prequels are not canon anymore, thank god.
>>64258066
They started to fix it by episode III, but even then the light they emit is inconsistent. You can tell that they aren't using objects with a real lighting source, unlike pic related. Look how red Kylo's arm is, and how blue Finn's face is.
Revenge of the Sith
>Better, more original, story
>Better casting
>Better world Building
>Better fights
>Better antagonists
>Clones and Droids
The Force Awakens
>Better CGI
>Better Sound
>Kylo
Sith wins.
>>64254613
>78 views
fuck off
>>64258236
reply to>>64258110
>>64258244
>Better casting
>Better fights
>Better antagonists
>Clones and Droids as a pro
>>64258244
>>Better casting
>>Better fights
Why would you say this when you know it's wrong?
>>64258244
>TFA
>Better CGI
LOL
Should have said Practical Effects as a plus.
>>64254341
I don't get what each thing is supposed to symbolize, qualitywise.
>>64256583
>>64256134
Kylo Hux and even Chrometits survive. I don't fucking know how she survived, but I guess her action figure did well in focus groups.
I will admit that it would have been cool if Tarkin could have survived the death star somehow. Or maybe it would have been dumb but I want more Tarkin.
>>64258297
>>64258309
Say what you want about the prequels, but they had god tier casting. Way better than TFA by miles. Also yes, it has better antagonists. You have to by a delusional man baby to say otherwise.
>>64257360
>>believable character development
>>64258522
I mean, Sheev is a legitimately good character, and Christopher Lee is fucking Christopher Lee. Anakin talks and acts like Elliot Rodger.
>>64258522
>Lee
>Hayden
>Hersh
>good casting
literally TWO good casting choices in THREE MOVIES
>>64258623
Faggot please, if the prequels did anything right it was casting choices. Pretty much every casting choice was great, even Hayden.
>>64258683
Lee was absolute trash, Mace was a fucking joke, Hayden was bad, Portman was a joke (though the least bad of the bad ones)
the only good choices mentioned over and over are Sheev and Obi for a reason
>>64258683
The only thing the prequels did of note regarding acting is to get terrible performances out of exceptionally talented people
>>64258683
confirmed for not knowing what acting is.
>>64258522
Visually, yes. Acting wise? Hayden and Natalie aren't suited for conventional roles like go. Take a look at their other movies and their more stellar performances are with characters that are much more grounded in the real world (They can't be blamed though since they were casted in the early portion of their careers). Samuel L. Jackson suffers a similar problem; he performs best when he's completely losing his shit but was casted as a wise man.
Lee could have been feeling but was wasted in playing a shoe-horned villain (we didn't even know what he was casted to play as considering his character is such a piece of wood).
Ian McDiarmid and Ewan McGregor are the only two casting choices that are absolutely on point.
>>64258909
*Allegedly* Hayden could do a more convincing Anakin, but Lucas Lucased and took the emotion out of it.
>>64258968
Yeah, I remember hearing this and also remember watching a video about Lucas telling Hayden to change his acting for the role. Wish I could find it.
>>64258968
I've heard about that and I wouldn't be surprised either. If Anakin started as more of a charismatic wisecracker than a whiner, the movies would have worked a lot better.
VI > V > I > II > VII > IV > III
>>64253882
If I could only watch one for the rest of my life it would be III.
>>64258968
sheev awakens his cock in anakin's sandpipe to farm his moisture and pump him full of midichlorians
>>64259037
STOP
>>64254721
Yes, and he still couldn't make Episode III watchable.
Truth is TFA was borderline trash. It was a remake of the original but with the intent of appealing to progressive America consisting of muh-strong-independent-women, muh-moral black guy, muh evil white supremacists.
Basically a transgendered Luke and a black Solo.
>>64253882
TFA and anyone who says otherwise is a fucking retard.
>>64256653
Was Vaders character so important he deserved a whole prequel dedicated to him?
>>64256922
>the picture
I know it's bait but I gulped it.
>>64259872
What do you think, he's hands down the most popular Star Wars character
TFA but by a small margin
>>64254152
I'll give you 1/2 portion for that meme
>>64254152
daily reminder 7 took traitor from 3
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ESOrF_u1hg
>>64253882
TFA DESU
>>64260312
The way Ian McDiarmid sang "unlimited" is glorious.
Does TFA have Battle of the Heroes?
https://youtu.be/tIl7-rDOuTM
>>64260668
yea this guy is such a based actor that lucas wanted him to play sheev 16 years after doing so in rotj
it's too bad jj didnt let andy serkis show off his character some more, he's forced to play 2nd to kylo
Let's start seeing some numbers
http://strawpoll.me/6401336
