[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Holy shit JJ is such a hack He explained why R2D2 woke from
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 125
Thread images: 10
Holy shit JJ is such a hack

He explained why R2D2 woke from his slumber. It wasn't due to Rey's presence at all.

http://www.ew.com/article/2015/12/20/jj-abrams-answers-burning-question-about-r2-d2-star-wars-force-awakens

>“BB-8 comes up and says something to him, which is basically, ‘I’ve got this piece of a map, do you happen to have the rest?’” Abrams said. “The idea was, R2 who has been all over the galaxy, is still in his coma, but he hears this. And it triggers something that would ultimately wake him up.”

>The director acknowledges that R2’s sudden “awakening” at the end was designed to be an emotional storytelling utility: “While it may seem, you know, completely lucky and an easy way out, at that point in the movie, when you’ve lost a person, desperately, and somebody you hopefully care about is unconscious, you want someone to return.”

>So for those let wondering: BB-8’s earlier question rattles around inside R2’s dome for a while. Those old astromechs must just take a while to boot up again.

Say it with me

J U S T
>>
HACK
>>
>>63886644
>Having to clarify your movie
>>
>A movie maker used well known story telling methods to get an audience to feel a specific emotion.
Wow, who would have fucking guessed?
>>
>>63887009
Was disappointment one of those emotions?
>>
>>63886644
That's a very disappointing answer IMO. I thought for sure Luke sensed what was going on and woke up R2 with the force so Rey could find him
>>
>>63886644
John Carter was better than TFA
>>
>>63887093
Nope R2 just needed to nap for a little while longer after BB-8 asked him something
>>
>>63887072
*shrug*, I'm just not sure what most of 4chan expects.
It's a JJ Abrams movie, and it played out like a JJ Abrams movie, enjoyable enough but safe.

It's exactly what I've expected for the last 2 years.
>>
I thought maybe Luke did it from afar, allowing himself to be found because he's psychic etc

missed opportunity, JarJar Abrams
>>
>>63887201
>*action*

Kill yourself.
>>
>>63886644
>“The idea was, R2 who has been all over the galaxy, is still in his coma
It's a fucking robot, how is he in a "coma"? Holy shit. This is even stupider than the first impression I got, which is that R2 was sad or something that Luke was gone so he put himself into sleep mode.

Bravo, JewJew.
>>
That's not how droids work, you fucking mong.
>>
File: 1447718599746.gif (418 KB, 300x144) Image search: [Google]
1447718599746.gif
418 KB, 300x144
>>63887246
ok
>>
>>63887273
That's how I thought of it.

I thought he was so sad over Luke being gone that he just didn't feel like doing shit anymore.

Then Rey appears and he senses the skywalker in her and he wakes up to help her find Luke

That would've been better than this shit
>>
>>63886644
>While it may seem, you know, completely lucky and an easy way out,
>may seem

:^)
>>
Rey Skywalker shitters BTFO
>>
>>63886644
JJ is a bigger hack than I thought. Why even answer when you don't have a good explanation?
>>
>>63886644
what
I assumed Luke had done something to R2, as seen in Rey's flashback/vision/whatever
dammit JJ
>>
So in Disney Star Wars, droids that feel sad will go into comas that they can't be woken up from unless they hewr something encouraging?

BRAVO
R
A
V
O
>>
More answers, this one concerning how Maz ended up with luke's lightsaber

>"So Maz has Luke's old lightsaber as you saw... people are apparently thinking about it too much, a few decades ago she was working on Bespin in a little shuttle beneath and the weapon fell on her head. She knew about lightsabers so she found it a curious and intriguing enough find to keep it around; later she learned of its origin when talking to Han"
>>
>>63887554
are you implying droids dont have souls, shitlord?
>>
>>63887554
Droids can get triggered too
>>
>>63887584
how did they let such a mong helm this franchise?
>tfw you realize TFA would have been better if /tv/ wrote it
>>
>>63887584
sauce or I call bullshit
>>
File: 1qfwZyT.jpg (67 KB, 709x765) Image search: [Google]
1qfwZyT.jpg
67 KB, 709x765
>>63887584

JUST
U
S
T

Disney must be ringing their lawyers to get him to shutup and ruining their chances of selling more comics with all these backstories in them.
>>
>>63887662
>how did they let such a mong helm this franchise
have you seen the prequels?
>>63887662
>>tfw you realize TFA would have been better if /tv/ wrote it
yeah but then the kids wouldn't buy the toys
>>
>>63887662
TFA would've been better if George Lucas wrote it
>>
>>63887554
This is beyond prequel levels of bullshit tbf ham
>>
File: 1418249169243.png (41 KB, 168x180) Image search: [Google]
1418249169243.png
41 KB, 168x180
>>63887584
>people are apparently thinking about it too much
DUDE JUST TURN YOUR BRAIN OFF
L M A O
M
A
O
>>
>>63887554
holy shit even jar jar binks was better than this shit
>>
dont pretend you niggies wouldnt complain no matter which reason he said it was
>>
File: 1449594833025.png (39 KB, 500x502) Image search: [Google]
1449594833025.png
39 KB, 500x502
>>63887584
I don't have a reaction picture to convey my rage adequately

>>63887835
We complain because droids going into a "coma" is in itself fucking retarded
>>
>>63887554
droids have souls, shitlords

#DroidLivesMatter
>>
>>63887835
I won't because it's a fucking stupid plot element to begin with. Literally nothing he could've possibly said would've changed that. He's a hack.
>>
>>63887584
JUST
>>
>>63887894
>We complain because droids going into a "coma" is in itself fucking retarded

R2 switched himself to low power mode when Luke left. It wasn't a coma in a human medical sense.
>>
>>63887584

JUST
>>
>>63887959
>The idea was, R2 who has been all over the galaxy, is still in his coma
>R2
>is
>still
>in
>his
>coma
>>
File: rey-rey.jpg (79 KB, 640x860) Image search: [Google]
rey-rey.jpg
79 KB, 640x860
>>63886644
>>
>>63887835
R2D2 waking up and revealing he had the missing piece all along is fucking stupid, regardless of the reason why he woke up.
>>
>>63887584
>30 years to make the movie
>Can't properly explain plot details in the movie
>>
File: star-wars-rey.jpg.resize.400.jpg (17 KB, 380x380) Image search: [Google]
star-wars-rey.jpg.resize.400.jpg
17 KB, 380x380
>>63888060
Why are her cheeks around the corners of her mouth so puffy?

I find it unusually attractive
>>
File: 1355970235450.jpg (3 KB, 148x152) Image search: [Google]
1355970235450.jpg
3 KB, 148x152
>yfw Disney assassinated JewJew to get him to stfu saying dumb shit about their movie
>>
>>63888102
theyre pushed out because her mouth is so used to slurping down dongs
>>
>>63887584

Is that uh... Is that a real answer? Link?
>>
>>63888102
because Brits talk funny so their mouths get fucked
hers also got fucked by loadsa dicks
>>
>>63887835

It was a retarded plot element.

R2-D2 suddenly waking back up to show the rest of the map was done for the sole purpose to move the plot forward because JJ had no idea how to link together the death planet blowing up to Rey going off to find Luke. The ending of the movie was total shit.

BB-8 and the retarded idea that for whatever reason, the map was complete except for one small section were inconsequential. You could do away with all of that and have R2 just powering back up and revealing the whole map after Rey got done pummeling everyone with her perfect princess powers and nothing would change.
>>
>>63887201

>*shrug*
Kill yourself
>>
>>63888035

I'm going off of what was actually said in the movie. C-3PO literally said, "He switched into low power mode ever since Master Luke disappeared."
>>
>>63886644
But R2 awakening because of Rey makes so much more fucking sense. Hell it even fits in better with the title of the goddamn film.

Fuck you, Jew Jew.
>>
>>63888265
Which is still a bit silly, why couldn't they just hook R2 up to another droid and transfer his data across to check if he had the information they needed?

It's not coma silly though
>>
It was really a nice touch how the stormtrooper armies were literally like nazis during that speech
real subtle
>>
>a robot is in a coma

JJ Abrams confirmed for literally retarded.
>>
>>63888355
Probably too subtle, they should have made it more clear that they are basically space nazis
>>
>everyone ITT confirmed for autism and taking things way too literally just so they can complain about it
>>
>>63888246
But then we wouldn't have the "search for the droid on a desert planet" plot that ANH did.
>>
>>63888269
how would R2 recognize her though?
>>63888358
C3PO specifically said he's on battery saving mode
"coma" is just a turn of phrase
>>
>>63888355
They raised their left arms though. Nazis do a right handed salute, dummy. Totally different.
>>
>>63888246
ren knew r2d2 had it though
he mentions the republic have the map befpre r2d2 wakes from the coma
>>
>>63888421
The Force, obviously. I imagined Luke put some silly Force magic on him to wake up once Rey (or some other worthy person) awoke to their Force powers.

I ain't gotta explain shit.
>>
>>63888424
right, and their fanatical shouting leader didn't even have a moustache
my bad
>>
>>63886644
>people will defend this

>if you have any kind of problem with this you're a 'contrarian'
>>
Can someone please explain to me the factions in this movie? The First Order is clear, and calling their enemies the Resistance makes it sound like they're just underground rebels fighting against the oppression of an empire that has already conquered most of the galaxy
But then they also talk about hitting the Republic and Senate with that first attack? How the hell does that work? Where's the Republic in all this?
>>
>>63886644
Nice trip of dubs.
But is anyone really surprised?
The backstory of Nero, the main villain from Star Trek 2009 was that he had a mining ship, and he got so mad at his planet being destroyed, that he went off with his mining vessel, took out a Borg Cube (one of the sickest, most bad ass sons of bitches you find in that universe), salvaged it for tech, used said tech to upgrade his mining vessel into a functional warship, and then went back to his home system.
And he did this, between the time of his planet exploding, and Spock getting there a few minutes too late to stop the supernova.
>>
>>63888656
After episode 6 the empire was shattered. Many people left it, joined the new republic or they ended up not accepting defeat and joining the new first order that was born out of the ashes of the old empire and probably still had access to a whole bunch of its assets and shit

the republic is everyone else who just wants peace and freedom but they're also pussies and don't dare attacking the first order directly so they just secretly give money to some allah ackbar resistance group to fight the fight for them

it's retarded
>>
>nerds getting butt blasted over little details on a movie that has aliens, spaceships and wizards.

No wonder everybody hates Star Wars fags.
>>
I call misunderstanding on this one. In one of the trailers you see Luke do something to R2, which obviously has something to do with a backstory being explained where he gives instructions to R2 or something.
>>
>>63888656
It makes no fucking sense without context. They didn't offer context because they're hacks.

Along with it being a cynical cashgrab that hinges on nostalgia, it's literally a "just turn your brain off dude" movie.

It's an insulting copy and paste to people that didn't like it and a 'soft reboot' to those that did like it.
>>
tfw the first order has like 500000000 soldiers and can build a whole planet sized weapon

the resistance can only afford like 15 x-wings and that's it

lel
>>
>>63888844
JJIDF in full swing I see
>>
>>63887112
Fucking hell, this.
>>
>>63887112
He-hey now.
You make it sound like John Carter wasn't absolutely everything it wanted or needed to be as a space Tarzan adaptation.
>>
Wouldn't it be just as effective to have r2 awake the whole time and Leia say something like "well shit r2 has an incomplete map to Luke. We gotta go get that missing piece."
>>
>>63889072
and TFA was everything it wanted and needed to be as a cash grab
what's your point?
>>
>>63886644
>The director acknowledges that R2’s sudden “awakening” at the end was designed to be an emotional storytelling utility: “While it may seem, you know, completely lucky and an easy way out, at that point in the movie, when you’ve lost a person, desperately, and somebody you hopefully care about is unconscious, you want someone to return.”
I'm sure Mike and every TFA shill will eat it up and praise JJ, but it's nothing but a hackneyed plot convenience to justify Luke's appearance at the end.
>>
File: ingmar bergman.jpg (6 KB, 264x191) Image search: [Google]
ingmar bergman.jpg
6 KB, 264x191
>>63887072
>Was disappointment one of those emotions?
>>
>>63889145
That it's unfair to make it sound like John Carter is barely better than TFA.
It was fun, and it did great as an adaptation of its source material, without massive holes riddling every single thing that happens in it.
>>
Bravo Abrams!
>>
>>63887595
>>63887653
>>63887756
>>63887829
>>63887903
Samefagging doesn't make your post any funnier
>>
>>63889225
then why did TFA make more money? :^)
>>
jar jar abrams strikes again
>>
File: I see.gif (215 KB, 500x209) Image search: [Google]
I see.gif
215 KB, 500x209
>>63889295
>>
>>63889293
fuck off tumblr
>>
>>63887584
This is made up.

In novelization it goes like this:
>Lando gets the lightsaber as one of his Bespin workers found it.
>Lando gives it to Leia.
>Leia and Han hang around Maz so they know each other pretty well.
>After Ben fucks up, Leia gives the lightsaber to Maz, because she can't think of a safer place.
>The end.

As this is in the novel, which was based on the script, I'd guess this is the canon answer to how the lightsaber got into Maz's possession.
>>
>>63886644
Inspired by modem noise
>>
>>63889676
JJ said the novel isn't canon
>>
>>63889676
>give the saber to some random ayy lmao because it's a good friend
>>
>>63889676
okay so now tell me how the light saber called to Rey
>>
>>63886644

For fuck's sake Abrams. You could've at least have had the scene where Luke touches R2 to be the reason as to why R2 stayed in low power mode until Rey showed up.
>>
>>63889775
According to the novelization Maz was literally running her pirate safe-haven for a 1000 years.
>>
>>63887093
Can't I just pretend that's what really happened. If enough people say it as if it were true then maybe Disney well reconsider.
>>
>>63889676

Then why didn't Han know why she had it?
>>
In 15 years from now we'll have to have a whole new trilogy to explain away and repair the damage JJ has done to the brand. It's happening all over again.
>>
>>63889676
That's gay as fuck son. Vader collected the hand and saber and it was later stolen by a dark Jedi after the fall of the Empire.

Then he cloned the hand and Luuke Skywalker BT JJ the FO
>>
>>63889870
So what

Why even give it out, did someone try to steal it? Were the rebelsistance not good friends enough?
>>
>>63889676
>because she can't think of a safer place.

Can't think being the operative phrase. Why even treat the saber as something that needs hiding. What kind of lightsaber related OCD faggot wrote this shit?
>>
>>63890056
15 years? kek
star wars and star trek are the new capeshit, they'll be rebooted every 5 years
>>
>>63888102
her jaw is oversize due to the large amount of Neanderthal DNA in the British genome
>>
>>63889104
Nah, cause that would have involved them coming up with their own plot instead of just copy and pasting the ready made story they had.
>>
>>63887001
Agreed. Ridley Scott is a fucking hack.
>>
>>63890006
Probably Leia didn't tell him.

>>63890161
>Why even give it out, did someone try to steal it? Were the rebelsistance not good friends enough?
Kylo worshipped the lightsaber and "wanted" it. So they took away a shiny toy from their freaky child.
>>
>>63889159
For people that liked it, none of the convenient plot points or inconsistencies or plagiarism will deter from their enjoyment of the film.

For people that didn't like it, shit like this is just more reason not to like it.

Jay from RLM for example, disliked Jurassic World for the very same reasons he praised or excused parts of TFA.
>>
Cool. Now I know from JJ's interviews both why R2 woke up, AND that the First Order are akin to Nazis who ran off to South America. Think any other plot points will be made clear in the next few days?
>>
>>63889810
Probably possessed by the spirits of all those younglings.
>>
>>63889676
>giving your brother's lightsaber to some bar owner because why the fuck not?
>>
>>63889825
>/tv/ comes up with better excuses for the shit writing than JJ ever could
>>
>>63890756

I bet we'll find out who Snoke is and it will be something equally retarded.

"Oh he was just Palpatine's best buddy and also super strong in the force. He just wasn't mentioned ever before because Palpatine kept it a secret. There."
>>
>>63890955
it's Darth Plagueis
>>
>>63890756
maybe he'll explain why Han happened to be scanning for the Millenium Falcon at the exact time Rey flew away in it, that would be a good trick.
>>
It's not exactly any worse than any of the other star wars writing.
>>
>>63890756
>modern movies now get 'patched' with with explanations in sequels to justify inconsistent writing and characterisation
>>
>>63891029
>Falcon sits around disused for 20 years
>durr how do you think we found you? everyone can track it at any time
>>
>>63890955
inb4 ssssnok is a failed clone of Luke, Luuuuuuuke
>>
>>63887201
>*shrugs*
The cringe is real
>>
>>63886644
I prefer my headcanon that Luke felt Han's death and woke R2 up
>>
>>63891061
haha I retroactively dismiss things I loved as a child too, aren't we both cool mature adults? XD
>>
>>63887584
Please dear god tell me this is from the onion
>>
>>63886644
no poetry or it rhymes just a hack.
>>
>>63891196
This is honestly what I assumed. I thought it was obvious. It's really strange they didn't fuckin mean this:

Luke feels Han's death from afar, meditates on it for a couple hours or whatever then decides to give R2 the green light from through the Force.
>>
>>63887201
>safe
watch out for this shill word it's used used by mouse faggots.
>>
>>63891196
JJ has the force, most convenient plot device in history, at his disposal and he doesn't use it properly.
>>
>>63890287
>What kind of lightsaber related OCD faggot wrote this shit?

someone paid a salary to patch holes in other screenwriters shitty plotting
>>
>>63886644
why didn't R2 just wake up when orangebot originally showed up?
>>
>>63891237
epic shitposting my friend, you should win some kind of award
Thread replies: 125
Thread images: 10

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.