[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Is HP Lovecraft a racist? if so does than detract from his work?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /pol/ - Politically Incorrect

Thread replies: 126
Thread images: 26
File: cthulhu_by_disse86-d9tq84i.jpg (118 KB, 1063x752) Image search: [Google]
cthulhu_by_disse86-d9tq84i.jpg
118 KB, 1063x752
Thoughts on HP Lovecraft?
>>
>>79154828
He was a racist, yes.
>>
He was a white supremacist who wrote some shitty pamphlets about this.
It should not be a problem for this board.
>>
>>79154828
It is true... all of it
>>
Yes he was a racist but he actually dialed it back as he got older. I haven't read all of his material yet, but there are only a few stories that really explore any racist views (Medusa's Coil, The Rats in the Wall). Mostly he was against immigrants and foreigners.
>>
>>79156296
It should be since they renamed the HP Lovecraft award when that negro bitch won it and cried racism.
>>
He was pretty racist.

But then again he was /r9k/ as fuck so he didn't have a shit.
>>
File: iG9MP.jpg (43 KB, 480x480) Image search: [Google]
iG9MP.jpg
43 KB, 480x480
>>79156184
>>79156296
>>79156588
>>79158841
Raaaaaaycist
>>
>>79154828

Racism in fiction is much easier to swallow because there are much more obvious signs that all races aren't equal.

That being said how anyone can look at a sub-saharan negro and a caucasian or asian person and say "these people are all human and exactly the same isn't that lovely :^)" is beyond me.

Racism is defined as believing there is an inherent differences between people of different races, despite what social marxists will tell you.
>>
>was he racist

yes

>does it detract from his work?

of course not

it didn't detract from James Watson or Henry Fords work either

>>79158841
>married a jew for money
>ran away to new england because he hated the minorities in NYC

he was a cyborg at best
>>
>>79158954
you know, there isn't any kind of proof that Leon actually said it. You're being ignorant when you spread false "infographs"
>>
>>79154828
Yes he was a racist, just like every reasonable American man in the early 20th century.
>>
File: 1465866161664.png (229 KB, 900x900) Image search: [Google]
1465866161664.png
229 KB, 900x900
>>79159287
I can't not think about James Watson and not descend into a black rage. He's the fucking master of genetics and evolutionary biology, if he says that races exist you shut your fucking baboon mouth and better believe that races fucking exist DONT CALL HIM RACIST ITS A FUCKING COLD HARD TRUTH
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
File: lovecraft2.jpg (23 KB, 295x454) Image search: [Google]
lovecraft2.jpg
23 KB, 295x454
When, long ago, the gods created Earth
In Jove's fair image Man was shaped at birth.
The beasts for lesser parts were next designed;
Yet were they too remote from humankind.
To fill the gap, and join the rest to Man,
Th'Olympian host conceiv'd a clever plan.
A beast they wrought, in semi-human figure,
Filled it with vice, and called the thing a Nigger.
>>
>>79159621
Beautiful
A true poet
My new favourite phrase is now
"Well,fill me with vice and call me a nigger!"
>>
>>79158954
Kiss your sister retard
>>
>HP Love craft married a Jewish women.
> wrote about hideous monsters whose mere presence can drive a man insane.
Probably unrelated though
>>
>>79154828
>Is HP Lovecraft a racist? if so does than detract from his work?
Of course he was. hell no, it makes it more interesting.
>>
If you're a Lovecraft fan, you must know of ST Joshi. He's an poo in loo and here are his views:
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/nov/11/hp-lovecraft-biographer-rages-against-ditching-of-author-as-fantasy-prize-emblem
>>
I've read tons of Lovecraft and the only thing that really stuck out to me was when a negro came to someones door.
>>
>>79154828
>mfw the old ones are muslim immigrants
>mfw when the stars are right (i.e. when their numbers are sufficient) they will rise and wreak havoc
>mfw they destroyed the great race of yith and their library (egypt much?)
>mfw followers of their cult are degenerate and insane

it's like hp has foreseen the future
>>
It's pretty obvious that he was racist.

I don't agree with his views, but I do enjoy his work nonetheless.
The way I see it, his extreme xenophobia, fucked-up upbringing, and slew of strange phobias enabled him to be afraid of everything. In turn, this let him write great horror fiction, especially about the unknown and alien, which a large part of the world was to him.
>>
File: bronn-game-of-thrones.jpg (394 KB, 1146x667) Image search: [Google]
bronn-game-of-thrones.jpg
394 KB, 1146x667
>>79154828
>does racism detract from his work
No. It enhances it, really.
>>
File: horrorfromthebeyond.gif (2 MB, 458x330) Image search: [Google]
horrorfromthebeyond.gif
2 MB, 458x330
>>79159745
A pure coïncidence.

Also, I think it was more like some kind of casual racism, exagerated as time goes by, by people who undestand jack shit about his work ans just wanted to make money out of it (I'm looking at you, Derleth you son of a whore).
He had a great scientific mind tho, and was really interested in the progress made in his time si I'm sûre it was justified racism
>>
>>79154828
>Is HP Lovecraft a racist?

>On the Creation of Niggers
When, long ago, the gods created Earth
In Jove's fair image Man was shaped at birth.
The beasts for lesser parts were next designed;
Yet were they too remote from humankind.
To fill the gap, and join the rest to Man,
Th'Olympian host conceiv'd a clever plan.
A beast they wrought, in semi-human figure,
Filled it with vice, and called the thing a Nigger.
>>
>>79154828

His biggest crime is that he was a cat loving retard.
>>
File: 9d642e.jpg (256 KB, 608x720) Image search: [Google]
9d642e.jpg
256 KB, 608x720
>>79160532
>His last notebook is forever lost.
He also wrote a few (2 or 3 I don't recall correctly) letters to Hitler
>>
>implying you can judge people from a century ago by modern standards
>>
>>79154828
he's a pioneer and more or less invented fiction as we know it imo

that said his work fucking sucked. there's only so many times you can read that something is 'more terrible than you can even comprehend' without getting bored of it

it lacks real content for that reason, whenever introducing his own bad guys he's basically giving everyone a do-it-yourself version of horror which is actually lazy and lame as fuck
>>
>>79154828
>Is HP Lovecraft a racist?
yes
>if so does than detract from his work?
his best works are based on racism

also, it's important to note that Lovecraft wasn't merely racist by modern definition. He hated non-whites yes, but he hated literally everyone that wasn't an educated white gentile from a city in England or New England
>>
File: H.P.Lovecraft inspiration.png (143 KB, 680x798) Image search: [Google]
H.P.Lovecraft inspiration.png
143 KB, 680x798
>>79160380

/this.

One of greatest american writers and a close personal favorite.
>>
File: 1452469086585.jpg (221 KB, 766x1024) Image search: [Google]
1452469086585.jpg
221 KB, 766x1024
>>79160879

Sounds like you've read like two or three of his stories then?

The description of the barrel-creatures in The Mountains Of Madness is pretty much perfect, stop parroting what you hear online and actually form your own opinion.
>>
File: saddog.png (134 KB, 398x368) Image search: [Google]
saddog.png
134 KB, 398x368
>>79160848

>being survived by your aunt.
>>
>>79156588
I don't think Rats in the Wall really explored his racism, it just had his cat called Niggerman in it. I'd say something like Horror at Red Hook or The Street were more about exploring his racism, though I'd say they are among his poorer stories
>>
>>79158841
Really makes you think...

How many famous people through the years would have ended up on the 4chinz if it was an option?

Lovecraft of course. Hunter s Thompson? Hemingway? That faggot Oscar wilde? Voltaire?
>>
>>79161181
>azathoth
>HE IS EVIL AND IN SPACE IF HE WAKES U DIE
>nyarlathotep
>HE IS LOKI BUT EVEN BADDER AND HE CAN LOOK LIKE ANYBODY LMAO ALSO SPACE
>cthulu
>I HATE FISH ALSO HE LOOKS LIKE AN OCTOPUS I GUESS BUT HIS REAL FORM IS LITERALLY UNKNOWABLE LMAO

face it lovecraft was basically shitposting
>>
>>79161293
the Shadow Over Innsmouth is pretty racist too. It's one of his longer stories, and it's all about how racemixing will literally cause the apocalypse
>>
File: image.jpg (1 MB, 3583x1917) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
1 MB, 3583x1917
I don't care if he's maybe a racist - he's definitely an incredibly poor

"It was a dark and stormy night. Suddenly a shot rang out!" snoopy tier writer.
>>
>>79154828
He was more than a racist, he was a misanthrope.
>>
>>79161458
Nah m8. I'm not even a lovecraft fan but his concept of the psychic horror presented by mindless and unknowable chaos gods is pretty good stuff.

If it's shitposting it's top-tier, creative shit posting.
>>
>>79160380
This.

It is easy to argue that his racism (and his general social isolation) enhanced his fiction and that he was great BECAUSE he was able to masterfully abstract and aestheticize the fear and contempt of "the unknown other".
>>
>>79161458
the Outer Gods matter very little in most of his stories, and they're described pretty well in the few where they do matter. The epitome of the "unknowable horror" meme is from At the Mountains of Madness where he says that Shoggoths are indescribable and then immediately describes them in the next sentence
>>
>>79161805
Shoggoths were basically dittos only more terrifying
>>
File: hp_niggerhater2.jpg (119 KB, 680x798) Image search: [Google]
hp_niggerhater2.jpg
119 KB, 680x798
>>79154828
>>
>>79154828
Yes and no respectively.

p.s. the deep ones were metaphorically africans
>>
>>79161138
Holy shit, first time seeing someone post my OC.

Pinch me.
>>
>>79161905

>showgirls were basically ditties only more terrifying?

Unknowably formless blasphemous scaryriffic from the cyclopean depths of unknowable shapeless terror beyond comprehension - you mean?
>>
>>79160067
>https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/nov/11/hp-lovecraft-biographer-rages-against-ditching-of-author-as-fantasy-prize-emblem
>Lovecraft’s racist 1912 poem On the Creation of Niggers. (Its couplets include: “A beast they wrought, in semi-human figure,/ Filled it with vice, and called the thing a Nigger.”)
The guy had issues, I don't think anyone would contest that, but this is pretty funny.
>>
>>79161243
She was a massive psycho too
>>
File: image.jpg (107 KB, 500x666) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
107 KB, 500x666
>>
>>79161458
Check out the "lovecraftian science" blog before parroting nonsense. The guy knew his shit
>>
>>79159621
i love this poem, was just about to post it
>>
>>79162136
WE
WUZ
CLITITHLOOS N SHIIIEET
>>
File: 1465676532911.png (21 KB, 176x232) Image search: [Google]
1465676532911.png
21 KB, 176x232
>>79154828
everybody was racist, what liberals are doing to history and culture is called anachronism - that is the act of appointing traits to a period in which those traits did not belong/exist. It's about as close as you can get to the orwellian "memory hole" without actually entering autodafe territory.
>>
>>79154828
Yes he was, but his fiction? Not overtly, iirc.
>>
>>79158954
That's a WEWUZ-tier pic. Why don't you just kill yourself you fucking nigger?
>>
>>79159967
How does it make it 'more interesting'? For laughs? For "wow, folks were dumb way back then"?
>>
>>79154828
>Is HP Lovecraft a racist?
Yup he didnt like non-whites very much, but didnt he marry a jew or something like that?
>if so does than detract from his work?
not really, if that was the case, we could bascially not read or enjoy anything from the past, what is an acceptable and majority opinion changes from diffrent centuries
>>
>>79160848
Yep; he suffered from an extreme allergic reaction to pencils.
>>
>>79154828
yes he was a racist like pretty much everyone in his time
case closed
>>
>>79160848
The letters "F" and "U"?
>>
>>79154828
By our standards, yes. It doesn't detract from his work the same way Varg Vikernes killing someone (murder or not) does not detract from Burzum.
>>
>>79163426
#OldOnesLivesMatter
#OpenInterdimensionalBordersNow
#NotAllDeepOnes
>>
>>79161138
Holy fucking shit
>>
> implying racism could only detract from his work
>>
>>79154828
No, he grew up in a different time.

Do you think Caesars accomplishments are lessened because he owned slaves?
>>
>>79154828
>1 post by this ID
How can OP make a thread like this and not partake in it?
>>
>>79163552
>>79163589
Made me chuckle a little but it was top easy. Dont get lazy
>>
>>79154828

I also named my cat Nigger Man.

I don't see the problem.
>>
>>79163669
The MI go did nothing wrong
>>
>>79163669
#I'llworshipDagonwithyou
>>
>>79160879
>invented fiction as we know
??
>>
File: 1467095268499.jpg (9 KB, 262x206) Image search: [Google]
1467095268499.jpg
9 KB, 262x206
Yes, pretty much anyone intelligent is openly racist. The unintelligent are racists in denial or hypocrites. Usually both.

The idea that there's a single person on Earth who isn't racist is a liberal sophist's game. Even babies are born racist and will actively shy away or avoid other races than their own.

Lovecraft also unleashed some 10/10 platinum banter against niggers.
>>
>>79154828

I don't know if he is racist but he described socialism as the "most advanced system know to man" and women "as pieces of meat lacking any natural capacity to deal with the otherworld"
>>
>>79165334
Cause it's black or acting like a stereotypical nigger?
>>
>>79154828
Just makes it better desu, I never get tired of reading a few paragraphs about how dirty some mustached mexican """"woman"""" is in the middle of a horror story.
>>
>>79154828
Nyarko a best, Hastor a shit.
>>
>faggots try to be edgy and hip and back lovecraft because lmao we're nerds too XD
>find out he, like everyone ever, hated niggers very openly
>UGH PROBLEMATIC
>they forget he exists until it's time to take an award away from him

I wonder if they know or care that Tesla also hated niggers and wops and once said that the only good race were the whites and orientals because they're the only ones who ever get work done.
>>
now that someone made this thread...

is this worth getting? anyone has it?
>>
File: lovecraft2.png (243 KB, 404x507) Image search: [Google]
lovecraft2.png
243 KB, 404x507
>>79154828
He had a cat called Nigger Man. We know he loved his cat. Why would he call his cat a nigger if he hated niggers? Lovecraft was not racist. QED.
>>
File: necronomicon.jpg (8 KB, 259x194) Image search: [Google]
necronomicon.jpg
8 KB, 259x194
>>79167060

Don't know, I've got this.

Read it over 5 times and planning on doing it again this summer
>>
>>79165334
Honestly that's probably one of my favourite stories by him.
>>
>>79167060

looks beautiful AF and I really love books that are beautiful on the inside and the outside.
>>
File: 1463165526470.png (39 KB, 321x322) Image search: [Google]
1463165526470.png
39 KB, 321x322
>>79154828

>Racism is factually incorrect
>>
>>79167060

http://arkhamarchivist.com/free-complete-lovecraft-ebook-nook-kindle/
>>
File: 1280px-RAF_Scampton_022.jpg (285 KB, 1280x1006) Image search: [Google]
1280px-RAF_Scampton_022.jpg
285 KB, 1280x1006
>>79167235
Nigger was a common as fuck name for pets until Americans told us we couldn't use the word anymore.
>>
>>79162637
I don't this pic. The point of Lovecraft was about isolation and how small is the human to the rest of the universe, sure there was monsters and stuff beyond imagination but the main idea was how pointless is our existence in the universe
>>
>>79167342

>ebook

please leave and never come back
>>
>>79167389
Were*
>>
File: nigger cats.jpg (32 KB, 500x589) Image search: [Google]
nigger cats.jpg
32 KB, 500x589
>>79167362
>>
>>79154828
Why would a person being 'racist' effect their ability to tell a good story?

New poll- is OP a faggot? ...the results are in
>>
File: Mosley.jpg (23 KB, 490x313) Image search: [Google]
Mosley.jpg
23 KB, 490x313
>>79156296
he was actually more of a anglo supremacist.
>>
>>79154828
He was a classical thinker who loved victorian culture, not some skinhead poltard cocksucker of Hitler the metis.
>>
wasen't Lovecraft married to a jew?
>>
>>79160107
>forelegs
>>
I read quite a bit of his work after reading Stephen King's Lovecraft-inspired short stories.

Lovecraft's ideas were great but his writing is too dry and restrained for me. His dialogue is also pretty bad.

I like Stephen King's fake Lovecraft more than the real deal.
>>
File: image.jpg (121 KB, 1024x561) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
121 KB, 1024x561
>>79160380
Bronn is literally a white male and not either a eunuch or cucked. He and Sandor need to be killed off or turned into eunuchs along with Euron.
>>
>>79154828
him being a shit author has nothing to do with racism

he couldn't write for shit, other than MUH SPOOKY COSMIC HORROR, IT'S SO SCARY YOU COULDN'T UNDERSTAND IT BUT ITS SCARY BE SCARED

faggot
>>
>>79156350

kraut knows
>>
>>79154828

Yes, no.
>>
>>79156588
>Medusa's Coil

An example of his racism detracting from his work.

>so there's this witch, okay, and she's got this hair with powers or whatever
>...AND SHE'S SECRETLY PART BLACK, HOLY SHIIIIIIIIT
>>
>>79170869
Holy fuck burger, cool it, you made me almost pee myself
>>
>>79166547
>Cause it's black or acting like a stereotypical nigger?

Because he sleeps 16 hours a day and receives free food and shelter, acts like he earned it, and yet I provide it to him because I can't help myself.

Also he's black.
>>
>>79154828

Everyone was a racist in his day. It doesn't take anything away from his work. For that sci-fi award to drop his name from it really pissed me off.
>>
>>79170539
leave failing to appreciate grandiose prose to a half-illiterate American
>>79168426
and then of course, as always, there's another fucking leaf making a dumb fuck out of himself whenever I want to comment
>>
Yes.
It enhances his work
>tfw no cat named niggerman
>>
>>79167060
>is this worth getting? anyone has it?

I have the same edition but in a different cover.

It includes the uncut versions of his stories (some editions use the magazine printed versions which were edited by publishers). The bad news is that its filled with a fuckload of type-os. Especially "Dreams in the Witch House".

Also, it doesn't include poems and minutia, like "The Fungi from Yuggoth". Overall, though, it's pretty complete and a good bargain.
>>
File: nolivesmatter.jpg (60 KB, 960x573) Image search: [Google]
nolivesmatter.jpg
60 KB, 960x573
>>79170539
[low-imagination pleb detected]

I think US Weekly, People magazine or childrens picture books are more suited for your... tastes.
>>
>>79154828
>>
>>79156588
Oh there's a ton, Cool Air and that one about the monkey God, he literally cannot stop and it's absolutely hilarious how subtle he can be about it at times
>>
>>79159745
she was also ukranian and along with his complaints about the Jews he also constantly bitched about eastern europeans being asiatic subhumans in her presence
>>
>>79154828
Yes

No

Meh
>>
File: image.jpg (112 KB, 1000x628) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
112 KB, 1000x628
>>79171478
How does it compare to the BN version?
>>
Lovecraft could be repetitive, yeah. But I think what people forget is that "weird fiction" and "CoocooCoocoo Mythos" stories don't begin and end with Lovecraft. You weren't really meant to sit down and read Lovecraft's complete works from beginning to end in publication order.

They read best when you intersperse them with works from contemporary weird fiction authors who borrowed and donated concepts and characters. Clark Ashton Smith, Robert Bloch, Robert E. Howard, Fritz Lieber, Frank Belknap Long, etc.

If you stop at just Lovecraft you're kinda only getting the fringe of the material. They all worked together and riffed off one another and their stories were published side by side in the same magazines as part of a bigger picture.
>>
>>79171992
>How does it compare to the BN version?

It's identical to the BnN version (both the hardcover with the dust cover and the one you have in pic). Since the material is public domain, different publishers just reprint the same source files. The ones with all the type-os. Kind of annoying.
>>
>>79159621
Brilliant
>>
>>79172015
>Frank Belknap Long

The Horror from the Hills is fuck trash.

An old one consistently described as looking like an elephant. It's name is Chaugner Fahn, but they refer to it as "Chaugner" like that's his first name. Like if they wanted to be polite, they'd have called him Mr. Fahn.

They beat him by chasing him down in a runabout with an x-ray apparatus, blasting him with energy zaps until he dies.

A lot of the "Lovecraft circle" members were great (Howard and Ashton Smith could write circles around Lovecraft) but some of them were legitimate shit (Derleth Derleth Derleth).
>>
Of course he was a racist. He had to live in Red Hook, Brooklyn for a while.
He was still the most influential horror writer of the last century.
>>
>>79161444

I like HST's eariler work and his devotion to gunz, but he's too much of a namefag - would more than likely be an AMA whore on reddit.
>>
>>79167463
fuck you and your dead trees. Dumb ass paying for shit that is free.
>>
>>79158954
>trying to redefine well-known words so they can't be used against you
Hmmm, that seems really familiar...
>>
>>79154828

If he was I will start reading his stuff.
>>
>>79171202
>Because he sleeps 16 hours a day and receives free food and shelter, acts like he earned it, and yet I provide it to him because I can't help myself.

Cats are house niggers?
>>
>>79173866
It only shows up in a few of his stories, and even then rather as a side note. Of course almost all characters in his stories are white. Or white but degenerate. (Degenerate as in having defective genes.)
>>
>>79154828
He was racist as fuck. Duh.
Fuck no, if anything it adds to it.
Best horror writer in American history. Fuck Poe and if you even consider King then you're a pleb.
>>
>>79167280
>tfw I had a Necronomicon and my mom threw it out because she thought it was satanist or something
Thread replies: 126
Thread images: 26

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.