ITT: Make an album better by cutting it down to an EP
Painting With Animal Collective EP
1.Hounds of Bairro
2.Bagels in Kiev
3.Hocus Pocus
4.Vertical
5.Summing the Wretch
6.Recycling
7.Spilling Guts
>no floridada
Whatever
Daft Punk- Human After All EP
1.Human After All
2. Robot Rock
3.Make Love
4. Steam Machine
5. Emotion
>>65838516
I think RAM demands this treatment more than anything else
Lonely Boy
Lookalike
Dimed Out
Sun Salutation
Funny Feeling
Auld Lang Syne
The Fall
Into the Void
>>65839815
Holy shit that'd be a lot better than what we got
>>65838385
>No Floridada
>No Golden Gal
wtf
>>65839924
I don't think either really displays the tone of the album all that accurately, it's pretty clear they were meant to be the singles. Lying in the Grass would be the best choice as far as singles go I think, but even that didn't really seem to fit.
Thinking of making it seamless rather than objective best tracks:
1. Pyramid Song
2. You and Whose Army?
3. I Might be Wrong
4. Knives Out
5. Dollars and Cents
6. Like Spinning Plates
7. Life in a Glasshouse
>>65838516
Take out Robot Rock
Add Prime Time of Your Life
1. Cygnus X-1, Book II
2. La Villa Strangiato
>>65839995
I feel like Packt could add a lot to the vibe of this one, otherwise good stuff
>>65838385
Why would you end with Spilling Guts, nonetheless right after a great closer track? Garbage.
>>65838385
>7 track EP
thats not how it works
strawberry jam was fucking 9 tracks
>>65840107
Spilling Guts is a wonderful song and incorporates xylophone in a way I thought would be fitting after the end of Recycling.
>>65840117
These songs are all much shorter than the songs on SJ
>>65839980
Those songs both have the front-end urgency, and consciousness of human interaction that makes the album stand out from their others. Your list is ridiculous.
>>65838385
>all those panda tracks
no
>>65840078
I guess I was emphasising acoustic over electronic?
>>65840199
they're two of the most ridiculous songs on the album dude, lyrically and sonically
>>65838385
>no on delay
>>65838516
This album is fine as it is, i've recently come to the conclusion that discovery suffers more from filler
>>65840075
>Not liking Circumstances
I can understand The Trees but that's one of my favorite Rush songs, I love when they would pack a 10 min prog song into a 4/5 minute track
>>65840223
Oh I can see that, Like Spinning Plates' live version would work better for that I feel
>>65838580
1. Give Life Back to Music
2. Game of Love
3. Giorgio By Moroder
4. Instant Crush
5. Lose Yourself to Dance
6. Get Lucky
7. Fragments of Time
8. Doin it Right
9. Contact
still an LP though, too many tracks to be an EP
>>65840075
but The Trees man
>>65838385
1. FloriDada
2. Hocus Pocus
3. Vertical
4. Natural Selection
5. Bagels in Kiev
6. On Delay
7. Golden Gal
>>65840321
I agree actually. How fucking amazing would a live, intimate, acoustic session of Amnesiac be?
>>65840332
>Instant Crush
>Lose Yourself to Dance
>Get Lucky
You've kept the three worst songs
>>65838385
>including hounds of bairro, bagels in kiev, hocus pocus, summing the wretch, and spilling guts
it should be
1. On Delay
2. Lying in the Grass
3. Golden Gal
4. Vertical
5. Floridada
6. Recycling
thats a 10/10 EP
>government plates
pillbox hat
anne bonny
two heavens
birds
big house
government plates
whatever i want (fuck who's watching)
>>65840381
Bagels in Kiev is the best song on the album by a long shot
1. Love For Sale
2. Puzzlin' Evidence
3. Wild Wild Life
4. Dream Operator
5. City of Dreams
>>65840376
i know it's cool to hate singles on /mu/, but I genuinly think all three are good songs. I mean i don't even understand how someone could think Get Lucky is the worst song on that album, it's a great pop song
>1. Dogs
>2. Pigs
>3. Sheep
Fuck that intro/outro repetitive acoustic minimalistic garbage ass pigs on the wang nonsense
>>65840444
It's not the worst thing ever but the rest of the songs are much better. Get Lucky also got over played to death. Get Lucky and Lose Yourself to Dance got worn out so fast. I also just never liked Instant Crush.
>1: Untitled
>2: Untitled
>3: Untitled
>4: Untitled
>5: Untitled
>>65840475
Yeah those two were definitely overplayed to death, but idk I still enjoy them
>>65840533
>picking only the worst songs
>>65840444
I think those were good inclusions, if anything I'd remove GLBTM, game of love, and fragments of time, and that would just be to get it down to EP length
1. Universally Speaking
2. Dosed
3. Don't Forget Me
4. Zephyr Song
5. Throw Away Your Television
6. Tear
7. Venice Queen
1. It's No Game pt. 1
2. Up the Hill Backwards
2. Ashes to Ashes
3. Fashion
4. Teenage Wildlife
6. It's No Game pt. 2
Very hard to chose between Scream Like a Baby and Up the Hill Backwards, but pretty easy otherwise
>>65840567
I was actually thinking about removing GLBTM when making it, Fragments of Time is one my favorites on there though
>>65840660
But Kingdom Come is so good though
>>65840685
yeah, pretty good too, but I had to cut it to make it an EP
1. Ultralight Beam
2. Famous
3. Feedback
4. Low Lights
5. Waves
6. Real Friends
7. Wolves
8. 30 Hours
9. No More Parties in LA
10. Fade
11. Saint Pablo
Cut almost half the album and it's still 11 tracks lmao
top 3 Kanye right here
You can count on me
Last Night at the Jetty
Scheherazade
Drone
Alsatian Darn
>>65840939
no way that would be an EP, only Sufjan can get away with that shit
>>65841004
Yeah i know, i cut out half the album and it's still not even close to being an EP, i just don't know what else to cut at this point
>>65838580
No
>>65839997
Prine time is daft's worst track, literally just fart noises, explain to me why Robot Rock is bad either then "lazy sampling" because that doesn't make it a bad song.
>>65840245
Nightvision is the only song that might be filler
>>65840391
Replace two heavens with this is violence now and you're good
>>65841191
that song is so bad
>>65841260
Why?
>>65841155
>Retorting with "fart noises"
Average daft punk fan
>>65841265
it's obnoxious and goofy as fuck. i only like about four tracks on the album though so i may be biased.
>>65840391
>Cutting down government plates
pleb
>>65840958
>Scheherazade
>Drone
nah
>>65841155
Prime Time of Your Life is one of Daft Punk's best tracks
>>65840332
I'd rework the album like this
1. Give Life Back to Music
2. Game of Love
3. Giorgo by Moroder
4. Horizon
5. Touch
6. Beyond
7. Motherboard
8. Fragments of Time
9. Doin' it Right
10. Contact
The King of Carrot Flowers, Pt. 1
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
Two-Headed Boy
Holland, 1945
Ghost
Two-Headed Boy Pt. Two
>>65841280
But it does sound like fart noises, it sounds like wet and goopey farts and shits on a hot day. Also although most songs on HAA does this, it goes nowhere and barley hss any sort of progression.
>>65841422
Add pt 2/3
>>65841438
Do you think things "are just noise" too?
No Church In The Wild
Niggas In Paris
Otis
Gotta Have It
Murder To Excellence
>>65840958
I have no clue why his albums have so much filler now
Mr Noah
Boys Latin
Butcher Baker Candlestick Maker
PrÃncipe Real
Tropic of Cancer
>>65841362
What's wrong with those songs?
>>65841471
What do you mean? If your referring to noise music then no.
>>65841422
gross
1) Perfect situation
2) The Damage in your Heart
3) Hold Me
4) Pardon Me
5) The Other Way
6) Haunt You Every Day
Passable Pinkerton-lite
>>65842849
Maybe a passable green lite at the most
>>65841601
>butcher baker
My nigga, such an underrated track
>>65841422
>cut out Communist Daughter, Oh Comely, and untitled
ewwww
Niggas on the Moon
1. Up My Sleeves
2. Billy Not Really
3. Black Quarterback
4. Say Hey Kid
5. Big Dipper
